Mentoring beginning teachers: What we know and what we don't

Teaching and Teacher Education

Volumn 25, Issue 1, 2009, Pages 207-216

  Hobson, Andrew J ^a   Ashby, Patricia ^a   Malderez, Angi ^b   Tomlinson, Peter D ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NOTTINGHAM   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Beginning teachers; Early professional development; Literature review; Mentoring

Indexed keywords

EID: 57649105492     PISSN: 0742051X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.tate.2008.09.001     Document Type: Article

References (129)

1. Abell S.K., Dillon D.R., Hopkins C.J., McInerney W.D., and O'Brien D.G. "Somebody to count on": mentor/intern relationships in a beginning teacher internship program. Teaching and Teacher Education 11 2 (1995) 173-188
2. Adey K. First impressions do count: mentoring student teachers. Teacher Development 1 1 (1997) 123-133
3. Anderson J.R. Cognitive psychology and its implications. 6th ed. (2006), Worth Publishers, New York
4. Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Mentoring to improve schools (1999), ASDC, Alexandria, VA
5. Beck C., and Kosnick C. Associate teachers in pre-service education: clarifying and enhancing their role. Journal of Education for Teaching 26 3 (2000) 207-224
6. Bodoczky C., and Malderez A. The INSET Impact of a Mentoring Course. In: Hayes D. (Ed) (1997), Prentice Hall., Hemel Hempstead
7. Brown J.S., Collins A., and Duguid P. Situated cognition and the culture of learning. Educational Researcher 18 1 (1989) 32-42
8. Bryman A. Social research methods. 3rd ed. (2008), Oxford University Press, New York
9. Bullough Jr. R.V. Being and becoming a mentor: school-based teacher educators and teacher educator identity. Teaching and Teacher Education 21 (2005) 143-155
10. Bullough Jr. R.V., and Draper R.J. Mentoring and the emotions. Journal of Education for Teaching: International Research and Pedagogy 30 3 (2004) 271-288
11. Burn K. Learning to teach: the value of collaborative teaching. In: McIntyre D. (Ed). Teacher education research in a new context: The Oxford internship scheme (1997), Paul Chapman Publishing, London 145-161
12. Carroll D. Learning through interactive talk: a school-based mentor teacher study group as a context for professional learning. Teaching and Teacher Education 21 (2005) 457-473
13. Carter M., and Francis R. Mentoring and beginning teachers' workplace learning. Asia-Pacific Journal of Teacher Education 29 3 (2001) 249-262
14. Clarke A., and Jarvis-Selinger S. What the teaching perspectives of cooperating teachers tell us about their advisory practices. Teaching and Teacher Education 21 (2005) 65-78
15. Colley H. A "rough guide" to the history of mentoring from a Marxist feminist perspective. Journal of Education for Teaching 28 3 (2002) 257-273
16. Collison J., and Edwards A. How teachers support student learning. In: Reid I., Constable H., and Griffiths R. (Eds). Teacher education reform: The research evidence (1994), Paul Chapman, London
17. Cornu R.L. Peer mentoring: engaging pre-service teachers in mentoring one another. Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 13 3 (2005) 355-366
18. Crasborn F., Hennisson P., Brouwer N., Korthagen F., and Bergen T. Promoting versatility in mentor teachers' use of supervisory skills. Teaching and Teacher Education 24 (2008) 499-514
19. Davies M.A., Brady M., Rodger E., and Wall P. Mentors and school-based partnership: ingredients for professional growth. Action in Teacher Education 21 1 (1999) 85-96
20. Department for Education. Initial teacher training (secondary phase) (circular 9/92) (1992), DFE, London
21. Department for Education. The initial training of primary school teachers: New criteria for course approval, circular 14/93 (1993), DFE, London
22. Department for Education and Skills. The induction support programme for newly qualified teachers (DfES/0458/2003) (2003), Department for Education and Skills, London
23. Dewey J. How we think: A restatement of the relation of reflective thinking in the educative process (1933), Henry Regnery, Chicago, IL
24. Dingwall R. Accounts, interviews and observations. In: Miller G., and Dingwall R. (Eds). Context and method in qualitative research (1997), SAGE, London 51-65
25. Doyle W. Classroom knowledge as a foundation for teaching. Teachers College Record 91 (1990) 347-360
26. Dunne E., and Bennett N. Mentoring processes in school-based training. British Educational Research Journal 23 (1997) 225-238
27. Edwards A. Guests bearing gifts: the position of student teachers in primary classrooms. British Educational Research Journal 23 1 (1997) 27-37
28. Edwards A. Mentoring student teachers in primary schools: assisting student teachers to become learners. European Journal of Teacher Education 21 1 (1998) 47-62
29. Edwards A., and Collison J. Mentoring and developing practice in primary schools (1996), Oxford University Press, Buckingham
30. Elbaz F. Teacher thinking: A study of practical knowledge (1983), Nichols, New York
31. Evans L., and Abbott I. Developing as mentors in school-based teacher training. Teacher Development 1 1 (1997) 135-148
32. Evertson C., and Smithey M. Mentoring effects on protégés' classroom practice: an experimental field study. Journal of Educational Research 93 5 (2000) 294-304
33. Feiman Nemser S. Teacher preparation: structural and conceptual alternatives. In: Houston W.R. (Ed). Handbook of research on teacher education (1990), Macmillan, New York 212-233
34. Feiman Nemser S. Helping novices learn to teach: lessons from an exemplary support teacher. Journal of Teacher Education 52 1 (2001) 17-30
35. Feiman Nemser, S., McDiarmid G. W., Melnick, S. L., & Parker, M. (1989). Changing beginning teachers' conceptions: a description of an introductory teacher education course (research report no. 89-1). Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI: The National Center for Research on Teacher Education. Available at Accessed 15.04.08
36. Feiman Nemser S., and Parker M.B. Mentoring in context: A comparison of two U.S. programs for beginning teachers (1992), Michigan State University, National Centre for Research on Teacher Learning (NCRTL), Michigan, MI. Available at Accessed 15.04.08
37. Feiman Nemser S., Parker M.B., and Zeichner K. Are mentor teachers teacher educators?. In: McIntyre D., Hagger H., and Wilkin M. (Eds). Mentoring: Perspectives on school-based teacher education (1993), Kogan Page, London 147-165
38. Fenstermacher G.D. Philosophy of research on teaching: three aspects. In: Wittrock M.C. (Ed). Handbook of research on teaching. 3rd ed. (1986), Macmillan, New York 37-49
39. Fenstermacher G.D. The place of practical arguments in the education of teachers. In: Richardson V. (Ed). Teacher change and the staff development process: A case in reading instruction (1994), Teachers College Press, NY 23-42
40. Foster R. School-based initial teacher training in England and France: trainee teachers' perspectives compared. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 7 2 (1999) 131-143
41. Franke A., and Dahlgren L.O. Conceptions of mentoring: an empirical study of conceptions of mentoring during the school-based teacher education. Teaching and Teacher Education 12 6 (1996) 627-641
42. Gaede O.F. Reality shock: a problem among first year teachers. The Clearing House 51 8 (1978) 405-409
43. Gay B., and Stephenson J. The mentoring dilemma: guidance and/or direction?. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 6 1 (1998) 43-54
44. Goodlad J. Teachers for our nation's schools (1990), Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA
45. Gough D., and Elbourne D. Systematic research synthesis to inform policy, practice and democratic debate. Social Policy and Society 1 3 (2002) 225-236
46. Graham B. Conditions for successful field experiences: perceptions of cooperating teachers. Teaching and Teacher Education 22 (2006) 1118-1129
47. Graham P. Tensions in the mentor teacher-student teacher relationship: creating productive sites for learning within a high school English teacher education program'. Teaching and Teacher Education 13 5 (1997) 513-527
48. Greeno J.G., Collins A.M., and Resnick L. Cognition and learning. In: Berliner D.C., and Calfee R.C. (Eds). Handbook of educational psychology (1996), Simon & Schuster Macmillan, New York 15-46
49. Grimmett P.P., and MacKinnon A.M. Craft knowledge and the education of teachers. In: Grant G. (Ed). Review of research in education Vol. 18 (1992), American Educational Research Association, Washington, DC 385-456
50. Hagger H., and McIntyre D. Learning teaching from teachers: Realising the potential of school-based teacher education (2006), Open University Press, Maidenhead
51. Hammersley M. The relationship between qualitative and quantitative research: paradigm loyalty versus methodological eclecticism'. In: Richardson J.T.E. (Ed). Handbook of qualitative research methods for psychology and the social sciences (1996), British Psychological Society, Leicester 159-174
52. Hardy C.A. Perceptions of physical education beginning teachers' first year of teaching: are we doing enough to prevent early attrition?. Teacher Development 3 1 (1999) 109-127
53. Harrison J., Dymoke S., and Pell T. Mentoring beginning teachers in secondary schools: an analysis of practice. Teaching and Teacher Education 22 (2006) 1055-1067
54. Hart A.W., and Murphy M.J. New teachers react to redesigned teacher work. American Journal of Education 98 3 (1990) 224-250
55. Hascher T., Cocard Y., and Moser P. Forget about theory - practice is all? Student teachers' learning in practicum. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice 10 6 (2004) 623-637
56. Hobson A.J. Student teachers' perceptions of school-based mentoring in initial teacher training (ITT). Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 10 1 (2002) 5-20
57. Hobson A.J., Malderez A., Tracey L., Giannakaki M.S., Kerr K., Pell R.G., Chambers G.N., Tomlinson P.D., and Roper T. Becoming a teacher: Student teachers' experiences of initial teacher training in England (2006), Department for Education and Skills (DfES), Nottingham
58. Hobson, A. J., Malderez, A., Tracey, L., Homer, M., Mitchell, N., Biddulph, M., Giannakaki, M. S., Rose, A., Pell, R. G., Roper, T., Chambers, G. N., & Tomlinson, P. D. (2007). Newly qualified teachers' experiences of their first year of teaching: Findings from phase III of the becoming a teacher project. Nottingham: Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF).
59. Hobson A.J., Malderez A., Tracey L., Giannakaki M.S., Pell R.G., and Tomlinson P.D. Student teachers' experiences of initial teacher preparation in England: core themes and variation. Research Papers in Education 23 4 (2008) 407-433
60. Heilbronn R., Jones C., Bubb S., and Totterdell M. School-based induction tutors - a challenging role. School Leadership and Management 22 4 (2002) 371-388
61. Ingersoll R., and Kralik J. The impact of mentoring on teacher retention: What the research says (2004), Education Commission of the States, Denver, CO. Available at Accessed 15.04.08
62. Jacobi M. Mentoring and undergraduate academic success: a literature review. Review of Educational Research 61 4 (1991) 505-532
63. Johnson S. Finders and keepers (2004), Wiley, San Francisco, CA
64. Johnson, S., Berg, J., & Donaldson, M. (2005). Who stays in teaching and why; a review of the literature on teacher retention. The Project on the Next Generation of Teachers: Harvard Graduate School of Education.
65. Jonson K. Being an effective mentor (2002), Corwin, Thousand Oaks, CA
66. Korthagen F.A.J., Kessels J., Koster B., Lagerwerf B., and Wubbels T. Linking practice and theory: The pedagogy of realistic teacher education (2001), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ
67. Lave J., and Wenger E. Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation (1991), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA
68. Lee J.C., and Feng S. Mentoring support and the professional development of beginning teachers: a Chinese perspective. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 15 3 (2007) 243-263
69. Leinhardt G. Capturing craft knowledge in teaching. Educational Researcher 19 2 (1990) 18-25
70. Leinhardt G., Young K.M., and Merriman J. Integrating professional knowledge: the theory of practice and the practice of theory. Learning and Instruction 5 (1995) 401-408
71. Lindgren U. Experiences of beginning teachers in a school-based mentoring programme Sweden. Educational Studies 31 3 (2005) 251-263
72. Little J.W. The mentor phenomenon and the social organization of teaching. In: Cazden C.B. (Ed). Review of research in education Vol. 16 (1990), American Educational Research Association, Washington, DC 297-351
73. Long J. The dark side of mentoring. Australian Educational Researcher 24 2 (1997) 115-133
74. Lopez-Real F., and Kwan T. Mentors' perceptions of their own professional development during mentoring. Journal of Education for Teaching 31 1 (2005) 15-24
75. Maguire M. Bullying and the post-graduate secondary school trainee: an English case study. Journal of Education for Teaching 27 1 (2001) 95-109
76. Malderez A., Hobson A.J., Tracey L., and Kerr K. Becoming a student teacher: core features of the experience. European Journal of Teacher Education 30 3 (2007) 225-248
77. Marable M., and Raimondi S. Teachers' perceptions of what was most (and least) supportive during their first year of teaching. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 15 1 (2007) 25-37
78. Martin M., and Rippon J. Teacher induction: personal intelligence and the mentoring relationship. Journal of In-Service Education 29 1 (2003) 141-162
79. Maynard T. Learning to teach or learning to manage mentors? Experiences of school-based teacher training. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 8 1 (2000) 17-30
80. McIntyre D. Teacher education research in a new context: The Oxford internship scheme (1997), Paul Chapman Publishing, London
81. McIntyre D., and Hagger H. Mentors in schools: Developing the profession of teaching (1996), David Fulton, London
82. Medgyes, P., & Malderez, A. (1996). Changing perspectives in teacher education. Oxford: Heinemann.
83. Mitchell H.J. Group mentoring: does it work?. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 7 2 (1999) 113-120
84. Moor H., Halsey K., Jones M., Martin K., Stott A., Brown C., and Harland J. Professional development for teachers early in their careers: An evaluation of the early professional development pilot scheme (2005), Department for Education and Skills, Nottingham
85. Munby H., Russell T., and Martin A.K. Teachers' knowledge and how it develops. In: Richardson V. (Ed). Handbook of research on teaching. 4th ed. (2001), American Educational Research Association, Washington, DC 877-904
86. Murray M., and Owen M.A. Beyond the myths and magic of mentoring: How to facilitate an effective mentoring programme (1991), Jossey Bass, San Francisco, CA
87. Oakley A. Research evidence, knowledge management and educational practice: early lessons from a systematic approach. London Review of Education 1 1 (2003) 21-33
88. Oberski I., Ford K., Higgins S., and Fisher P. The importance of relationships in teacher education. Journal of Education for Teaching 25 2 (1999) 135-150
89. Orland L. Reading a mentoring situation: one aspect of learning to mentor. Teaching and Teacher Education 17 (2001) 75-88
90. Rajuan M., Douwe B., and Verloop N. The role of the cooperating teacher: bridging the gap between the expectations of cooperating teachers and student teachers. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 15 3 (2007) 223-242
91. Rippon J.H., and Martin M. What makes a good induction supporter?. Teaching and Teacher Education 22 (2006) 84-99
92. Robinson I., and Robinson J. Learning to live with inconsistency in student entitlement and partnership provision. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 7 (1999) 223-239
93. Roehrig A.D., Bohn C.M., Turner J.E., and Pressley M. Mentoring beginning primary teachers for exemplary teaching practices. Teaching and Teacher Education 24 (2008) 684-702
94. Rogoff B. Observing sociocultural activity on three planes: participatory appropriation, guided participation and apprenticeship. In: Wertsch J.V., Del Rio P., and Alvarez A. (Eds). Sociocultural studies of mind (1995), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA 139-164
95. Roth W.-M., and Tobin K. At the elbow of another: Learning to teach by coteaching (2002), Peter Lang Publishing, New York
96. Schmidt M. Mentoring and being mentored: the story of a novice music teacher's success. Teaching and Teacher Education 24 (2008) 635-648
97. Schön D. The reflective practitioner (1983), Basic Books, New York
98. Schön D. Educating the reflective practitioner (1987), Jossey Bass, San Francisco, CA
99. Simpson T., Hastings W., and Hill B. "I knew that she was watching me": the professional benefits of mentoring. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice 13 5 (2007) 481-498
100. Slavin R.E. Best-evidence synthesis: an alternative to meta-analytic and traditional reviews. Educational Researcher 15 9 (1986) 5-11
101. Slavin R.E. Evidence-based education policies: transforming educational practices and research. Educational Researcher 31 7 (2002) 15-21
102. Smith K., and Maclay M. Curates eggs? Secondary trainee teachers' experience of the Graduate Teacher Programme and the Postgraduate Certificate in Education. Journal of Education for Teaching 33 1 (2007) 35-54
103. Smith T., and Ingersoll R. What are the effects of induction and mentoring on beginning teacher turnover?. American Educational Research Journal 41 3 (2004) 681-714
104. Stanulis R.N., and Weaver D. Teacher as mentor, teacher as learner. The Teacher Educator. 34 2 (1998) 134-143
105. Su J.Z.X. Sources of influence in preservice teacher socialization. Journal of Education for Teaching 18 3 (1992) 239-258
106. Sugrue C. Student teachers' lay theories: Implications for professional development. In: Goodson I.F., and Hargreaves A. (Eds). Teachers' professional lives (1996), Falmer Press, Washington, DC 154-177
107. Sundli L. Mentoring - a new mantra for education?. Teaching and Teacher Education 23 (2007) 201-214
108. Tashakkori A., and Teddlie C. Mixed methodology: Combining qualitative and quantitative approaches (1998), SAGE, Thousand Oaks, CA
109. Tauer S.M. The mentor-protégé relationship and its impact on the experienced teacher. Teaching and Teacher Education 14 2 (1998) 205-218
110. Teaching and Higher Education Act. (1998). (c.30). London: HMSO.
111. Tharp R.G., and Gallimore R. Rousing minds to life: Teaching, learning and schooling in social context (1988), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA
112. Tomlinson, P. D. (1995). Understanding mentoring: Reflective strategies for school-based teacher preparation. Buckingham: Oxford University Press.
113. Tomlinson, P. D. (1998). Teacher education and psychologies of skill. In D. Shorrocks-Taylor (Ed.), Directions in educational psychology. London: Whurr Publishers.
114. Tracey, L., Homer, M., Mitchell, N., Malderez, A., Hobson, A. J., Ashby, P., & Pell, G. (2008). Teachers' experiences of their second year in post: Findings from phase IV of the becoming a teacher project. Nottingham: DCSF.
115. Tsui A.B.M. Understanding expertise in teaching: Case studies of ESL teachers (2003), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, MA
116. Valencic Zuljan M., and Vogrinc J. A mentor's aid in developing the competences of teacher trainees. Educational Studies 33 4 (2007) 373-384
117. Veenman S. Perceived problems of beginning teachers. Review of Educational Research 54 2 (1984) 143-178
118. Veenman S., Denessen E., Gerrits J., and Kenter J. Evaluation of a coaching programme for cooperating teachers. Educational Studies 3 (2001) 317-340
119. Wang J., and Odell S.J. Mentored learning to teach according to standards-based reform: a critical review. Review of Educational Research 72 3 (2002) 481-546
120. Wertsch J.V. A sociocultural approach to socially shared cognition. In: Resnick L.B., Levine J.M., and Teasley S.D. (Eds). Perspectives on socially shared cognition (1991), American Psychological Association, Washington, DC
121. Whisnant, E., Elliott, K., & Pynchon, S. (2005). A review of literature on beginning teacher induction. Prepared for the Center for Strengthening the Teaching Profession, July 2005.
122. Wildman T.M., Magliaro S.G., Niles R.A., and Niles J.A. Teacher mentoring: an analysis of roles, activities, and conditions. Journal of Teacher Education 43 (1992) 205-213
123. Wilkin, M. (1999). The role of higher education in initial teacher education. Universities Council for the Education of Teachers (UCET), Occasional Paper No. 12. London: UCET.
124. Williams A., and Prestage S. The induction tutor: mentor, manager or both?. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 1 (2002) 35-45
125. Wright N., and Bottery M. Perceptions of professionalism by the mentors of student teachers. Journal of Education for Teaching 23 3 (1997) 235-252
126. Wubbels T. Taking account of student teachers' preconceptions. Teaching and Teacher Education 8 2 (1992) 137-149
127. In: Yeomans R., and Sampson J. (Eds). Mentorship in the primary school (1994), Falmer Press, London
128. Yusko B., and Feiman Nemser S. Embracing contraries: combining assistance and assessment in new teacher induction. Teachers College Record 110 7 (2008) 1-12
129. Zeichner K.M. Conceptions of reflective practice in teaching and teacher education. In: Harvard G., and Hodkinson P. (Eds). Action and reflection in teacher education (1994), Ablex, Norwood, NJ 15-34