Needle-tissue interaction forces - A survey of experimental data

Medical Engineering and Physics

Volumn 34, Issue 6, 2012, Pages 665-680

  van Gerwen, Dennis J ^a   Dankelman, Jenny ^a   van den Dobbelsteen, John J ^a  

^a DELFT UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Cutting; Friction; Insertion; Puncture; Resistance

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL ENVIRONMENTS; EXPERIMENTAL DATA; FORCE DATA; INSERTION; NEEDLE-INSERTION; NEEDLE-TISSUE INTERACTION; PEAK FORCE; PUNCTURE; PUNCTURE FORCE;

CUTTING; ELECTRIC RESISTANCE; FRICTION; TISSUE;

NEEDLES;

BIOARTIFICIAL ORGAN; BIOMECHANICS; COMPUTER AIDED DESIGN; EQUIPMENT DESIGN; EX VIVO STUDY; EXPERIMENTAL STUDY; FORCE; FREEZE THAWING; HUMAN; HYDRATION; INJECTION; INJECTION SITE; LOADING TEST; LUBRICATION; MEDICAL INSTRUMENTATION; NEEDLE; NONHUMAN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; REVIEW; TISSUE CHARACTERIZATION; TISSUE INJURY; TISSUE INTERACTION;

ANIMALS; HUMANS; MECHANICAL PROCESSES; NEEDLES; ROTATION; TIME FACTORS;

EID: 84863328306     PISSN: 13504533     EISSN: 18734030     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.medengphy.2012.04.007     Document Type: Review

References (107)

1. Abolhassani N., Patel R., Moallem M. Needle insertion into soft tissue: a survey. Med Eng Phys 2007, 29:413-431.
2. Misra S., Ramesh K.T., Okamura A.M. Modeling of tool-tissue interactions for computer-based surgical simulation - a literature review. Presence-Teleop Virt Environ 2008, 17(5):463-491.
3. Cowan N.J., Goldberg K., Chirikjian G.S., Fichtinger G., Alterovitz R., Reed K.B., et al. Robotic needle steering: design, modeling, planning, and image guidance. Surgical Robotics: Systems Applications and Visions 2011, vol. 3:557-582. Springer. J. Rosen, B. Hannaford, R.M. Satava (Eds.).
4. Trejos A., Patel R., Naish M. Force sensing and its application in minimally invasive surgery and therapy: a survey. P I Mech Eng C-J Mech 2010, 224:1435-1454.
5. Frick T., Marucci D., Cartmill J., Martin C., Walsh W. Resistance forces acting on suture needles. J Biomech 2001, 34:1335-1340.
6. Jensen W., Yoshida K., Hofmann U.G. In vivo implant mechanics of single-shaft microelectrodes in peripheral nervous tissue. IEEE EMBS conference on neural engineering 2007, 1-4.
7. Kobayashi Y., Onishi A., Hoshi T., Kawamura K. Modeling of conditions where a puncture occurs during needle insertion considering probability distribution. IEEE/RSJ international conference on intelligent robots and systems 2008, 1433-1440.
8. Mahvash M., Dupont P.E. Mechanics of dynamic needle insertion into a biological material. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 2010, 57(4):934-943.
9. Okamura A.M., Simone C., O'Leary M.D. Force modeling for needle insertion into soft tissue. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 2004, 51(10):1707-1716.
10. Passerotti C.C., Begg N., Penna F.J., Passerotti A.M.A., Leite K.R., Antunes A.A., et al. Safety profile of trocar and insufflation needle access systems in laparoscopic surgery. J Am Coll Surg 2009, 209(2):222-232.
11. Podder T., Clark D., Sherman J., Fuller D., Messing E., Rubens D., et al. In vivo motion and force measurement of surgical needle intervention during prostate brachytherapy. Med Phys 2006, 33(8):2915-2922.
12. Podder T.K., Sherman J., Messing E.M., Rubens D.J., Fuller D., Strang J.G., et al. Needle insertion force estimation model using procedure-specific and patient-specific criteria. 28th Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2006, 555-558.
13. Stellman JT. Development, production, and characterization of plastic hypodermic needles. Master's thesis. Georgia Institute of Technology; 2009.
14. Suzuki T., Tanaka A., Fukuyama H., Nishiyama J., Kanazawa M., Oda M., et al. Differences in penetration force of intravenous catheters - effect of grinding methods on inner needles of intravenous catheters. Tokai J Exp Clin Med 2004, 29(4):175-181.
15. Westbrook J.L., Uncles D.R., Sitzman B.T., Carrie L.E.S. Comparison of the force required for dural puncture with different spinal needles and subsequent leakage of cerebrospinal fluid. Anesth Analg 1994, 79:769-772.
16. Yan K., Podder T., Li L., Joseph J., Rubens D.R., Messing E.M., et al. A real-time prostate cancer detection technique using needle insertion force and patient-specific criteria during percutaneous intervention. Med Phys 2009, 36(7):3356-3362.
17. Crouch J.R., Schneider C.M., Wainer J., Okamura A.M. A velocity-dependent model for needle insertion in soft tissue. Lecture notes in computer science 2005, 624-632. Springer Berlin/Heidelberg, Berlin.
18. Gossot D., Validire P., Matsumoto S., Tokumura H., Shimomura K., Flowers J., et al. Development of an ultrasonically activated trocar system. Surg Endosc 2002, 16:210-214.
19. Hing J.T., Brooks A.D., Desai J.P. Reality-based needle insertion simulation for haptic feedback in prostate brachytherapy. IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, ICRA 2006 2006, 619-624.
20. Hing J.T., Brooks A.D., Desai J.P. A biplanar fluoroscopic approach for the measurement, modeling, and simulation of needle and soft-tissue interaction. Med Image Anal 2007, 11:62-78.
21. Kobayashi Y., Sato T., Fujie M.G. Modeling of friction force based on relative velocity between liver tissue and needle for needle insertion simulation. 31st Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2009, 5274-5278.
22. Matsumiya K., Momoi Y., Kobayashi E., Sugano N., Yonenobu K., Inada H., et al. Analysis of forces during robotic needle insertion to human vertebra. Lecture notes in computer science, vol. 2878 2003, 271-278. Springer, Berlin.
23. Mayer G, Knappertz V, Kinast P, Needles: a comparison study. Tech. Rep., European Medical Device Technology; 2009.
24. Mueller F. Biomechanical test report on hsw fine-ject needles. Tech. Rep.; Henke-Sass Wolf GmbH; 2011.
25. Okuno D., Togawa T., Saito H., Tsuchiya K. Development of an automatic blood sampling system: control of the puncturing needle by measuring forces. 20th Annu. Int. Conf. of the IEEE Eng. in medicine and biology soc 1998, 1811-1812.
26. Podder T.K., Sherman J., Fuller D., Messing E.M., Rubens D.J., Strang J.G., et al. In-vivo measurement of surgical needle intervention parameters: a pilot study. 28th Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2006, 3652-3655.
27. Podder T.K., Sherman J., Li L., Joseph J., Rubens D.R., Messing E.M., et al. Mechanical properties of human prostate tissue in the context of surgical needle insertion. Int J Comp Assist Radiol Surg 2007, 2:S82-S133.
28. Saito H., Togawa T. Detection of needle puncture to blood vessel using puncture force measurement. Med Biol Eng Comput 2005, 43:240-244.
29. Tran D., Hor K.w., Kamani A.A., Lessoway V.A., Rohling R.N. Instrumentation of the loss-of-resistance technique for epidural needle insertion. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 2009, 56(3):820-827.
30. Wittek A., Dutta-Roy T., Taylor Z., Horton A., Washio T., Chinzei K., et al. Subject-specific non-linear biomechanical model of needle insertion into brain. Comput Meth Biomech Biomed Eng 2008, 11(2):135-146.
31. Abolhassani N., Patel R., Moallem M. Experimental study of robotic needle insertion in soft tissue. Int Congr Ser 2004, 1268:797-802.
32. Abolhassani N., Patel R., Moallem M. Trajectory generation for robotic needle insertion in soft tissue. 26th Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2004, 2730-2733.
33. Abolhassani N., Patel R., Moallem M. Control of soft tissue deformation during robotic needle insertion. Minim Invasiv Ther 2006, 15(3):165-176.
34. Abolhassani N., Patel R., Ayazi F. Minimization of needle deflection in robot-assisted percutaneous therapy. Int J Med Robot Comp 2007, 3:140-148.
35. Asadian A., Kermani M.R., Patel R.V. A compact dynamic force model for needle-tissue interaction. 32nd Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2010, 2292-2295.
36. Asadian A., Patel R.V., Kermani M.R. A distributed model for needle-tissue friction in percutaneous interventions. IEEE International conference on robotics and automation 2011, 1896-1901. IEEE, Shanghai, China.
37. Azar T., Hayward V. Estimation of the fracture toughness of soft tissue from needle insertion. Lecture Notes in Computer Science 2008, vol. 5104:166-175. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. F. Bello, E. Edwards (Eds.).
38. Badaan S., Petrisor D., Kim C., Mozer P., Mazilu D., Gruionu L., et al. Does needle rotation improve lesion targeting. Int J Med Robotics Comput Assist Surg 2011, 7:138-147.
39. Bzostek A, Kumar R, Diaz L, Svrivastava M, Anderson JH, Taylor RH. Force vs deformation in soft tissue puncture. MICCAI 1999, http://dx.doi.org/10.1.1.37.6345.
40. Choy Y.B., Cao H., Tungjitkusolmun S., Tsai J.Z., Haemmerich D., Vorperian V.R., et al. Mechanical compliance of the endocardium. J Biomech 2002, 35:1671-1676.
41. DiMaio S.P., Salcudean S.E. Needle insertion modelling and simulation. IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, ICRA 2002 2002, 2098-2105.
42. DiMaio S.P., Salcudean S.E. Needle insertion modeling and simulation. IEEE Trans Robotic Autom 2003, 19(5):864-875.
43. Healey AE, Evans JC, Murphy MG, Powell S, How TV, Groves D, et al. In vivo force during arterial interventional radiology needle puncture procedures. In: Westwood J, editor. St Heal T, vol. 13. IOS Press; 2005, p. 178-84.
44. Heverly M., Dupont P. Trajectory optimization for dynamic needle insertion. IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, ICRA 2005 2005, 1658-1663. Barcelona, Spain.
45. Hiemenz Holton L.L. Force models for needle insertion created from measured needle puncture data. St heal T 2001, 180-186. IOS Press. J. Westwood (Ed.).
46. Howard M.A., Abkes B.A., Ollendieck M.C., Noh M.D., Ritter R.C., Gillies G.T. Measurement of the force required to move a neurosurgical probe through in vivo human brain tissue. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 1999, 46(7):891-894.
47. Kataoka H., Washio T., Chinzei K., Mizuhara K., Simone C., Okamura A.M. Measurement of the tip and friction force acting on a needle during penetration. Lecture notes in computer science, vol. 2488 2002, 216-223. Springer Berlin /Heidelberg, Berlin.
48. Kobayashi Y., Onishi A., Watanabe H., Hoshi T., Kawamura K., Hashizume M., et al. Development of an integrated needle insertion system with image guidance and deformation simulation. Comput Med Imag Grap 2010, 34:9-18.
49. Kong X., Wu C. Measurement and prediction of insertion force for the mosquito fascicle penetrating into human skin. J Bionic Eng 2009, 6(2):143-152.
50. Lagerburg V., Moerland M.A., Konings M.K., van de Vosse R.E., WLagendijk J.J., Battermann J.J. Development of a tapping device: a new needle insertion method for prostate brachytherapy. Phys Med Biol 2006, 51:891-902.
51. Langevin H.M., Churchill D.L., Fox J.R., Badger G.J., Garra B.S., Krag M.H. Biomechanical response to acupuncture needling in humans. J Appl Physiol 2001, 91:2471-2478.
52. Lechner T.J., van Wijk M.G., Maas A.J., van Dorsten F.R., Drost R.A. Langenberg C.J., et al. Clinical results with the acoustic puncture assist device, a new acoustic device to identify the epidural space. Anesth Analg 2003, 96:1183-1187.
53. Lechner T., van Wijk M., Maas A., van Dorsten F. Thoracic epidural puncture guided by an acoustic signal: clinical results. Eur J Anaesth 2004, 21:694-699.
54. Lewis M.C., Lafferty J.P., Sacks M.S., Pallares V.S., TerRiet M. How much work is required to puncture dura with tuohy needles?. Brit J Anaesth 2000, 85(2):238-241.
55. Mahvash M., Dupont P.E. Fast needle insertion to minimize tissue deformation and damage. IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, ICRA 2009 2009, 3097-3102.
56. Maurin B., Barbe L., Bayle B., Zanne P., Gangloff J., De Mathelin M., et al. In vivo study of forces during needle insertions. Medical robotics, navigation and visualisation scientific workshop 2004, 415-422.
57. Meltsner M., Ferrier N., Thomadsen B. Observations on rotating needle insertions using a brachytherapy robot. Phys Med Biol 2007, 52:6027-6037.
58. Misra S., Reed K.B., Douglas A.S., Ramesh K.T., Okamura A.M. Needle-tissue interaction forces for bevel-tip steerable needles. IEEE/RAS-EMBS international conference on biomedical robotics and biomechatronics 2008, 224-231.
59. Misra S., Reed K., Schafer B., Ramesh K., Okamura A. Mechanics of flexible needles robotically steered through soft tissue. Int J Robot Res 2010, 29(13):1640-1660.
60. Naemura K. Comparative phantom study on epidural anesthesia needle. 28th Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2006, 4995-4998.
61. Naemura K., Uchino Y., Saito H. Effect of the needle tip height on the puncture force in a simplified epidural anesthesia simulator. 29th Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2007, 3504-3507.
62. Naemura K., Sakai A., Hayashi T., Saito H. Epidural insertion simulator of higher insertion resistance and drop rate after puncture. 30th Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2008, 3249-3252.
63. Nguyen C.T., Vu-Khanh T., Dolez P.I., Lara J. Puncture of elastomer membranes by medical needles. Part I: mechanisms. Int J Fract 2009, 155:75-81.
64. O'Leary M.D., Simone C., Washio T., Yoshinaka K., Okamura A.M. Robotic needle insertion: effects of friction and needle geometry. IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, ICRA 2003 2003, 1774-1780.
65. Podder T.K., Clark D.P., Fuller D., Sherman J., Ng W.S., Liao L., et al. IEEE Eng Med Biol. 2005, 5766-5770.
66. Podder T.K., Sherman J., Clark D.P., Messing E.M., Rubens D.J., Strang J.G., et al. Evaluation of robotic needle insertion in conjunction with in vivo manual insertion in the operating room. IEEE International workshop on robots and human interactive communication 2005, 66-72.
67. Reed K.B., Okamura A.M., Cowan N.J. Controlling a robotically steered needle in the presence of torsional friction. IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, ICRA 2009 2009, 3476-3481.
68. Roy J., Roesthuis Youri R.J., van Veen A.J., Misra S. Mechanics of needle-tissue interaction. IEEE/RSJ international conference on intelligent robots and systems 2011, 2557-2563. IEEE, San Francisco, CA, USA.
69. Saito H., Togawa T. Detection of puncturing blood vessel wall for automatic blood sampling. The first joint BMES/EMBS conference serving humanity, advancing technology 1999, 866.
70. Schneider C.M., Crouch J.R., Okamura A.M. Modeling and measuring the dynamic 3d effects of needle insertion in soft tissue. Tech. Rep. 04-1, The Johns Hopkins University, 2004.
71. Shergold O.A., Fleck N.A. Experimental investigation into the deep penetration of soft solids by sharp and blunt punches, with application to the piercing of skin. J Biomech Eng 2005, 127(5):838-848.
72. Simone C. Modeling of needle insertion forces for percutaneous therapies. Master's thesis, The Johns Hopkins University; 2002.
73. Simone C., Okamura A.M. Modeling of needle insertion forces for robot-assisted percutaneous therapy. IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, ICRA 2002 2002, 2085-2091.
74. Abolhassani N., Patel R. Deflection of a flexible needle during insertion into soft tissue. 28th Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2006, 3858-3861.
75. Barbe L., Bayle B., de Mathelin M., Gangi A. Online robust model estimation and haptic clues detection during in vivo needle insertions. IEEE international conference on biomedical robotics and biomechatronics 2006, 341.
76. Brett P.N., Parker T., Harrison A.J., Thomas T.A., Carr A. Simulation of resistance forces acting on surgical needles. P I Mech Eng H 1997, 211:335-347.
77. Brett P.N., Harrison A.J., Thomas T.A. Schemes for the identification of tissue types and boundaries at the tool point for surgical needles. IEEE Trans Inf Technol Biomed 2000, 4(1):30-36.
78. Brouwer I., Ustin J., Bentley L., Sherman A., Dhruv N., Tendick F. Measuring in vivo animal soft tissue properties for haptic modeling in surgical simulation. St heal T 2001, 69-74. IOS Press. J. Westwood (Ed.).
79. Dehghan E., Wen X., Zahiri-Azar R., Marchal M., Salcudean S.E. Modeling of needle-tissue interaction using ultrasound-based motion estimation. Lecture notes computer science; vol. 4791 2007, 709-716. Springer Berlin /Heidelberg.
80. Dehghan E., Wen X., Zahiri-Azar R., Marchal M., Salcudean S.E. Parameter identification for a needle-tissue interaction model. 29th annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2007, 190-193.
81. Dehghan E., Salcudean S.E. Needle insertion study using ultrasound-based 2d motion tracking. Lecture notes computer science; vol. 5242. 2008, 660-667. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. D. Metaxas (Ed.).
82. DiMaio S.P., Salcudean S.E. Simulated interactive needle insertion. 10th IEEE symposium On haptic interfaces for virtual environments and teleoperator systems 2002, 344.
83. DiMaio S.P., Salcudean S.E. Interactive simulation of needle insertion models. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 2005, 52(7):1167-1179.
84. Elagha A.A., Kim A.H., Kocaturk O., Lederman R.J. Blunt atrial transseptal puncture using excimer laser in swine. Catheter Cardio Inte 2007, 70:585-590.
85. Fazal I., Karsiti M.D. Needle insertion forces for haptic feedback device. IEEE symposium on industrial electronics and applications 2009, 20-22.
86. Hiemenz L., Litsky A., Schmalbrock P. Puncture mechanics for the insertion of an epidural needle. 21st annual meeting of the American society of biomechanics 1997, SC, Clemson.
87. Hiemenz L., Stredney D., Schmalbrock P. Development of the force feedback model for an epidural needle insertion simulator. St heal T 1998, 272-277. IOS Press. J. Westwood, H. Hoffman (Eds.).
88. Hungr N., Troccaz J., Zemiti N., Tripodi N. Design of an ultrasound-guided robotic brachytherapy needle-insertion system. 31st Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2009, 250-253.
89. Kataoka H., Noda S., Yokota H., Takagi S., Himeno R., Okazawa S. Simulations of needle insertion by using a eulerian hydrocode fem and the experimental validations. Lecture notes in computer science, vol. 5242 2008, 560-568. Springer, Berlin.
90. Kobayashi Y., Onishi A., Hoshi T., Kawamura K., Hashizume M., Fujie M.G. Development and validation of a viscoelastic and nonlinear liver model for needle insertion. Int J Comp Assist Radiol Surg 2009, 4(1):53-63.
91. Kobayashi Y., Suzuki M., Konishi K., Hashizume M., Fujie M.G. Development of a novel approach, palpation based needle insertion, for breast cancer treatment. IEEE international conference on robotics and biomimetics 2009, 505-511.
92. Kobayashi Y., Akinori O., Watanabe H., Hoshi T., Kawamura K., Fujie M.G. Developing a planning method for straight needle insertion using probability-based condition where a puncture occurs. IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, ICRA 2009 2009, 3482-3489.
93. Kobayashi Y., Suzuki M., Kato A., Konishi K., Hashizume M., Fujie M.G. A robotic palpation-based needle insertion method for diagnostic biopsy and treatment of breast cancer. IEEE/RSJ international conference on intelligent robots and systems 2009, 5534-5539.
94. Kokes R., Lister K., Gullapalli R., Zhang B., MacMillan A., Richard H., et al. Towards a teleoperated needle driver robot with haptic feedback for RFA of breast tumors under continuous MRI. Med Image Anal 2009, 13:445-455.
95. Lendvay T.S., Hsieh F.J., Hannaford B., Rosen J. The Biomechanics of Percutaneous Needle Insertion 2008, St Heal T, Newport Beach, CA.
96. Misra S., Reed K.B., Ramesh K.T., Okamura A.M. Observations of needle-tissue interactions. 31st Annual international conference of the IEEE EMBS 2009, 262-265.
97. Nguyen C.T., Vu-Khanh T., Dolez P.I., Lara J. Puncture of elastomer membranes by medical needles. part ii: Mechanics. Int J Fract 2009, 155:83-91.
98. Tse Z.T.H., Elhawary H., Rea M., Young I., Davis B.L., Lamperth M. A haptic unit designed for magnetic-resonance-guided biopsy. P I Mech Eng H 2009, 223:159-172.
99. Vidal F.P., John N.W., Healey A.E., Gould D.A. Simulation of ultrasound guided needle puncture using patient specific data with 3d textures and volume haptics. Comput Anim Virtual Worlds 2008, 19:111-127.
100. Wiksell H., Ekstrand V., Wadstrom C., Auer G. A new semi-automated instrument to improve the fine needle aspiration procedure during breast lesion cell sampling. Phys Med 2009, 25:128-132.
101. Xie Y., Sun D., Liu C., Cheng S.H., Liu Y.H. A force control based cell injection approach in a bio-robotics system. IEEE international conference on robotics and automation, ICRA 2009 2009, 3443-3448.
102. Xu W., Frank T.G., Cuschieri A. Development of a shape memory alloy multiple-point injector for chemotherapy. P I Mech Eng H 2005, 219:213-217.
103. Zivanovic A., Davies B.L. A robotic system for blood sampling. IEEE Trans inf Technol Biomed 2000, 4(1):8-14.
104. Selvadurai A. Deflections of a rubber membrane. J Mech Phys Solids 2006, 54:1093-1119.
105. Mahvash M., Hayward V. Haptic rendering of cutting: a fracture mechanics approach. Haptics-e 2001, 2(3):1-12.
106. Lawrie R.A., Ledward D.A. Lawrie's meat science 2006, Woodhead Publishing Limited, Cambridge. 2nd ed.
107. Warriss P.D. Meat science: an introductory text 2010, CABI, Oxfordshire. 2nd ed.