Directed evolution: The 'rational' basis for 'irrational' design

Current Opinion in Structural Biology

Volumn 10, Issue 4, 2000, Pages 421-427

  Tobin, Matthew B ^a   Gustafsson, Claes ^a   Huisman, Gjalt W ^a  

^a MAXYGEN INC   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ENZYME; PROTEIN;

DNA SEQUENCE; ENZYME STRUCTURE; EVOLUTION; GENETIC ENGINEERING; MUTAGENESIS; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROTEIN STRUCTURE; REVIEW; STRUCTURE ACTIVITY RELATION;

EID: 0033928844     PISSN: 0959440X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S0959-440X(00)00109-3     Document Type: Review

References (57)

1. Miyazaki K., Arnold F.H. Exploring nonnatural evolutionary pathways by saturation mutagenesis: rapid improvement of protein function. J Mol Evol. 49:1999;716-720. Extremely high mutation rates were applied to subtilisin to determine whether it enables better evolution of function for directed evolution than more conventional (and less severe) mutagenesis. It does, as rare amino acid changes that require multiple base substitutions in a single codon are accessed by saturation mutagenesis, allowing the exploration of broader sequence space. This works towards a 'codon-based' mutagenesis approach.
2. Zaccolo M., Gherardi E. The effect of high-frequency random mutagenesis on in vitro protein evolution: a study on TEM-1 beta-lactamase. J Mol Biol. 285:1999;775-783. Hypermutation resulted in the isolation of enzymes with exceptionally higher activity. The use of triphosphate nucleotide analogs afforded good control over mutational load.
3. Arnold F.H. Design by directed evolution. Accounts Chem Res. 31:1998;125-131.
4. Giver L., Arnold F.H. Combinatorial protein design by in vitro recombination. Curr Opin Chem Biol. 2:1998;335-338.
5. Harayama S. Artificial evolution by DNA shuffling. Trends Biotechnol. 16:1998;76-82.
6. Minshull J., Stemmer W.P. Protein evolution by molecular breeding. Curr Opin Chem Biol. 3:1999;284-290.
7. Steipe B. Evolutionary approaches to protein engineering. Curr Top Microbiol Immunol. 243:1999;55-86. This review affords a reasonably thorough treatment of the field, including a discussion of the myriad techniques that fall under the guise of 'directed evolution'. It also includes a discussion of screening methods and accentuates the general caveat to all evolutionary experiments: you get what you screen for.
8. Arnold F.H., Volkov A.A. Directed evolution of biocatalysts. Curr Opin Chem Biol. 3:1999;54-59. A good review describing the use of directed evolution to improve key properties of biocatalysts.
9. Bornscheuer U.T. Directed evolution of enzymes. Agnew Chem Int Ed Engl. 37:1998;3105-3108.
10. Kuchner O., Arnold F.H. Directed evolution of enzyme catalysts. Trends Biotechnol. 15:1997;523-530.
11. Marrs B., Delagrave S., Murphy D. Novel approaches for discovering industrial enzymes. Curr Opin Microbiol. 2:1999;241-245.
12. Encell L.P., Landis D.M., Loeb L.A. Improving enzymes for cancer gene therapy. Nat Biotechnol. 17:1999;143-147.
13. Stemmer W.P.C., Soong N.W. Molecular breeding of viruses for targeting and other clinical properties. Tumour Target. 4:1999;59-62.
14. Patten P.A., Howard R.J., Stemmer W.P. Applications of DNA shuffling to pharmaceuticals and vaccines. Curr Opin Biotechnol. 8:1997;724-733.
15. Stemmer W.P. Rapid evolution of a protein in vitro by DNA shuffling. Nature. 370:1994;389-391.
16. Stemmer W.P. DNA shuffling by random fragmentation and reassembly: in vitro recombination for molecular evolution. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 91:1994;10 747-10 751.
17. Chang C.C., Chen T.T., Cox B.W., Dawes G.N., Stemmer W.P., Punnonen J., Patten P.A. Evolution of a cytokine using DNA family shuffling. Nat Biotechnol. 17:1999;793-797. The authors describe the evolution of an interferon-α with broadened specificity by family shuffling of over 20 human genes. Using a modest number of assays, shuffled variants that are more active than the native cytokine were identified. Very different, yet highly active solutions to functional problems were obtained. Many higher activity solutions appear to exist in the virtual genome (i.e. sequence space), making the high premium on the human genomic sequence seem somewhat over-rated.
18. Zhang J.H., Dawes G., Stemmer W.P. Directed evolution of a fucosidase from a galactosidase by DNA shuffling and screening. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 94:1997;4504-4509.
19. Crameri A., Whitehorn E.A., Tate E., Stemmer W.P. Improved green fluorescent protein by molecular evolution using DNA shuffling. Nat Biotechnol. 14:1996;315-319.
20. Crameri A., Dawes G., Rodriguez E. Jr., Silver S., Stemmer W.P. Molecular evolution of an arsenate detoxification pathway by DNA shuffling. Nat Biotechnol. 15:1997;436-438.
21. Crameri A., Raillard S.A., Bermudez E., Stemmer W.P. DNA shuffling of a family of genes from diverse species accelerates directed evolution. Nature. 391:1998;288-291.
22. Christians F.C., Scapozza L., Crameri A., Folkers G., Stemmer W.P. Directed evolution of thymidine kinase for AZT phosphorylation using DNA family shuffling. Nat Biotechnol. 17:1999;259-264. The breeding of two herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase genes resulted in the creation of two novel chimaeric enzymes with increased affinity for AZT and decreased affinity for thymidine. The two progeny contained different solutions to the change in binding, inherited from different parents.
23. Ness J.E., Welch M., Giver L., Bueno M., Cherry J.R., Borchert T.V., Stemmer W.P., Minshull J. DNA shuffling of subgenomic sequences of subtilisin. Nat Biotechnol. 17:1999;893-896. An important paper on multiple levels. The authors describe the simultaneous evolution of multiple properties of an enzyme. The paper also contains interesting data illustrating that the 'best parent' (in desired activity) is not necessarily the 'closest parent' (in sequence identity) to the best-evolved progeny. This provides a caveat to those inclined to employ extremely rational constraints on the choice of identification of 'best' parent genes. It also shows that family shuffling enables a screening scenario in which a relatively small number of progeny need to be screened to find desirable improvements in activity.
24. Hansson L.O., Bolton-Grob R., Massoud T., Mannervik B. Evolution of differential substrate specificities in Mu class glutathione transferases probed by DNA shuffling. J Mol Biol. 287:1999;265-276.
25. Kikuchi M., Ohnishi K., Harayama S. Novel family shuffling methods for the in vitro evolution of enzymes. Gene. 236:1999;159-167. One way to improve the ability to shuffle dissimilar parental genes is to use restriction endonuclease cleavage to fragment the DNA.
26. Kikuchi M., Ohnishi K., Harayama S. An effective family shuffling method using single-stranded DNA. Gene. 243:2000;133-137.
27. Ostermeier M., Nixon A.E., Benkovic S.J. Incremental truncation as a strategy in the engineering of novel biocatalysts. Bioorg Med Chem. 7:1999;2139-2144.
28. Ostermeier M., Nixon A.E., Shim J.H., Benkovic S.J. Combinatorial protein engineering by incremental truncation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 96:1999;3562-3567.
29. Ostermeier M., Shim J.H., Benkovic S.J. A combinatorial approach to hybrid enzymes independent of DNA homology. Nat Biotechnol. 17:1999;1205-1209. This paper describes iterative truncation for the creation of hybrid enzymes ('ITCHY'). Two genes are progressively truncated, followed by ligation, to make recombined, single-crossover chimaeras. This enables the formation of hybrids from two essentially nonhomologous sequences. ITCHY generates a large amount of diversity from the two parents; however, a large amount of this sequence space is nonfunctional.
30. Valenzuela C.Y. Non random DNA evolution. Biol Res. 30:1997;117-123.
31. Dorit R.L., Schoenbach L., Gilbert W. How big is the universe of exons? Science. 250:1990;1377-1382.
32. Chothia C. Proteins. One thousand families for the molecular biologist. Nature. 357:1992;543-544.
33. Gonnet G.H., Cohen M.A., Benner S.A. Exhaustive matching of the entire protein sequence database. Science. 256:1992;1443-1445.
34. Lawrence J.G., Roth J.R. Selfish operons: horizontal transfer may drive the evolution of gene clusters. Genetics. 143:1996;1843-1860.
35. Cane D.E., Walsh C.T., Khosla C. Harnessing the biosynthetic code: combinations, permutations, and mutations. Science. 282:1998;63-68.
36. Konz D., Marahiel M.A. How do peptide synthetases generate structural diversity? Chem Biol. 6:1999;R39-R48.
37. McDaniel R., Thamchaipenet A., Gustafsson C., Fu H., Betlach M., Ashley G. Multiple genetic modifications of the erythromycin polyketide synthase to produce a library of novel 'unnatural' natural products. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 96:1999;1846-1851.
38. Altamirano M.M., Blackburn J.M., Aguayo C., Fersht A.R. Directed evolution of a new catalytic activity using the alpha/beta-barrel scaffold. Nature. 403:2000;617-622. The authors describe the conversion of an indole-3-glycerol-phosphate synthase (IGPS) to a phosphoribosylanthranilate isomerase (PRAI) using a combined structure-based and directed evolution approach. The IGPS α/β barrel was modified by the incorporation of the basic design of the loop system of PRAI. PRAI activity was evolved. The evolved PRAI enzyme obtained a different solution to that encoded by natural PRAI and lost all IGPS activity. This is an important demonstration that evolution occurs in modules and that structural criteria may be useful in choosing parental genes for directed evolution of new functions.
39. Doi N., Yanagawa H. Design of generic biosensors based on green fluorescent proteins with allosteric sites by directed evolution. FEBS Lett. 453:1999;305-307.
40. Cherry J.R., Lamsa M.H., Schneider P., Vind J., Svendsen A., Jones A., Pedersen A.H. Directed evolution of a fungal peroxidase. Nat Biotechnol. 17:1999;379-384. A demonstration that 'rational' and 'irrational' approaches may be combined to perform directed evolution. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to alter residues deemed important through structural analysis; this was followed by the randomization and combination of beneficial mutations, by the introduction of random mutations by error-prone PCR and by recombination of mutations by in vivo shuffling using the homologous recombination system of the host.
41. Arnold F.H., Giver L., Gershenson A., Zhao H., Miyazaki K. Directed evolution of mesophilic enzymes into their thermophilic counterparts. Ann NY Acad Sci. 870:1999;400-403.
42. Giver L., Gershenson A., Freskgard P.O., Arnold F.H. Directed evolution of a thermostable esterase. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 95:1998;12 809-12 813.
43. Hoseki J., Yano T., Koyama Y., Kuramitsu S., Kagamiyama H. Directed evolution of thermostable kanamycin-resistance gene: a convenient selection marker for Thermus thermophilus. J Biochem (Tokyo). 126:1999;951-956. Increased thermostability was largely conferred by the accumulation of multiple mutations on the protein surface, obtained by DNA shuffling and antibiotic selection. The best progeny retained full activity, had a 20° increase in thermostability and contained 19 amino acid substitutions.
44. Matsumura I., Wallingford J.B., Surana N.K., Vize P.D., Ellington A.D. Directed evolution of the surface chemistry of the reporter enzyme beta- glucuronidase. Nat Biotechnol. 17:1999;696-701.
45. Matsumura I., Ellington A.D. In vitro evolution of thermostable p53 variants. Protein Sci. 8:1999;731-740.
46. Merz A., Yee M., Szadkowski H., Pappenberger G., Crameri A., Stemmer W.P., Yanofsky C., Kirschner K. Improving the catalytic activity of a thermophilic enzyme at low temperatures. Biochemistry. 39:2000;880-889. A parent enzyme, indole glycerol phosphate synthase from Sulfolobus solfataricus, displayed poor activity at low temperatures, apparently because of structural rigidity. DNA shuffling for improved activity at low temperature can create an enzyme with improved turnover under those conditions.
47. Spiller B., Gershenson A., Arnold F.H., Stevens R.C. A structural view of evolutionary divergence. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 96:1999;12 305-12 310. Crystallographic analyses of variants of p-nitrobenzyl esterases generated in a directed evolution experiment demonstrate the cooperative interplay among networks of mutations. This illustrates how directed evolution can access function via structural changes that result from unpredictable combinations of mutations.
48. Taguchi S., Ozaki A., Nonaka T., Mitsui Y., Momose H. A cold-adapted protease engineered by experimental evolution system. J Biochem (Tokyo). 126:1999;689-693.
49. Van den Burg B., de Kreij A., Van der Veek P., Mansfeld J., Venema G. Characterization of a novel stable biocatalyst obtained by protein engineering. Biotechnol Appl Biochem. 30:1999;35-40.
50. Zhao H., Arnold F.H. Directed evolution converts subtilisin E into a functional equivalent of thermitase. Protein Eng. 12:1999;47-53.
51. Oue S., Okamoto A., Yano T., Kagamiyama H. Redesigning the substrate specificity of an enzyme by cumulative effects of the mutations of non-active site residues. J Biol Chem. 274:1999;2344-2349. An impressive demonstration of the power of DNA shuffling, here used to change the substrate specificity of an aspartate aminotransferase to valine. Crystallographic analysis revealed cumulative and dispersed mutations, distant from the active site, that exert higher order structural changes affecting substrate and cofactor binding. The increase in catalytic efficiency for the valine was two-million-fold that of the parent enzyme.
52. Jaeger K.E., Reetz M.T. Microbial lipases form versatile tools for biotechnology. Trends Biotechnol. 16:1998;396-403.
53. Schulze B., Wubbolts M.G. Biocatalysis for industrial production of fine chemicals. Curr Opin Biotechnol. 10:1999;609-615.
54. Bornscheuer U.T., Altenbuchner J., Meyer H.H. Directed evolution of an esterase for the stereoselective resolution of a key intermediate in the synthesis of epothilones. Biotechnol Bioeng. 58:1998;554-559.
55. Henke E., Bornscheuer U.T. Directed evolution of an esterase from Pseudomonas fluorescens. Random mutagenesis by error-prone PCR or a mutator strain and identification of mutants showing enhanced enantioselectivity by a resorufin-based fluorescence assay. Biol Chem. 380:1999;1029-1033.
56. Reetz M.T., Zonta A., Schimossek K., Liebeton K., Jaeger K-E. Creation of enantioselective biocatalysts for organic chemistry by in vitro evolution. Agnew Chem Int Ed Engl. 36:1997;2830-2832.
57. Joo H., Lin Z., Arnold F.H. Laboratory evolution of peroxide-mediated cytochrome P450 hydroxylation. Nature. 399:1999;670-673. One of the major problems associated with the ex situ use of enzymes requiring cofactors is cofactor regeneration. This paper describes the evolution of P450 monooxygenases that hydroxylate naphthalene in the absence of cofactors by using a 'peroxide shunt' pathway (i.e. hydrogen peroxide as the source of oxygen).