Metabolomics and systems biology: Making sense of the soup

Current Opinion in Microbiology

Volumn 7, Issue 3, 2004, Pages 296-307

  Kell, Douglas B ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Fourier transform infrared (spectrometry); FTIR; gas chromatography time of flight (mass spectrometry); gas chromatography mass spectrometry; GC MS; GC TOF; LC MS; liquid chromatography mass spectrometry; MCA; metabolic control analysis

Indexed keywords

MEVINOLIN;

ALGORITHM; ANALYTIC METHOD; ASPERGILLUS TERREUS; BIOLOGY; CHEMICAL ANALYSIS; DRUG BINDING; DRUG METABOLISM; GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY; INFRARED SPECTROSCOPY; LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY; MASS SPECTROMETRY; MEMBRANE RECONSTITUTION; METABOLIC ACTIVATION; METABOLIC REGULATION; NONHUMAN; NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE; PROTEIN MICROARRAY; PROTON NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE; REVIEW; STOICHIOMETRY; SYSTEM ANALYSIS; TECHNIQUE;

ALGORITHMS; BACTERIA; CHEMISTRY, ANALYTICAL; ENERGY METABOLISM; FUNGI; GENOMICS; HUMANS; MODELS, BIOLOGICAL; PLANTS; SYSTEMS THEORY;

ASPERGILLUS; ASPERGILLUS TERREUS;

EID: 2942676743     PISSN: 13695274     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.mib.2004.04.012     Document Type: Review

References (157)

1. Lazebnik Y. Can a biologist fix a radio? - or, what I learned while studying apoptosis. Cancer Cell. 2:2002;179-182 A wonderful and amusing piece extolling the virtues of a top-down and quantitative approach to understanding complex biological networks. The radio engineer succeeds because s/he has a wiring diagram, not merely a list of isolated components that may be present but without any knowledge of their values and what they interact with.
2. Kell D.B., Oliver S.G. Here is the evidence, now what is the hypothesis? The complementary roles of inductive and hypothesis-driven science in the post-genomic era. Bioessays. 26:2004;99-105
3. Kell D.B. Genotype:phenotype mapping: genes as computer programs. Trends Genet. 18:2002;555-559 Genetic programming methods can provide a straightforward link between the genotype and for example metabolomic phenotype of an organism, which maybe useful in both genetic and other nonlinear mappings. The strategy could clearly be used to determine important connectivities in nonlinear metabolic networks.
4. Sweetlove L.J., Last R.L., Fernie A.R. Predictive metabolic engineering: a goal for systems biology. Plant Physiol. 132:2003;420-425
5. King R.D., Whelan K.E., Jones F.M., Reiser P.G.K., Bryant C.H., Muggleton S.H., Kell D.B., Oliver S.G. Functional genomic hypothesis generation and experimentation by a robot scientist. Nature. 427:2004;247-252 The authors implemented an entirely closed loop system of automated experimentation in which a computer containing background knowledge proposed the 'best' (most discriminating) experiment, performed it and evaluated it seriatim before performing the next cycle, without human intervention. The method was applied to the identification of mutants in aromatic amino acid biosynthesis in baker's yeast, using growth and nutrient feeding experiments. The strategy could be applied to many areas of post-genomic biology and elsewhere.
6. Mendes P. Emerging bioinformatics for the metabolome. Brief Bioinform. 3:2002;134-145 Metabolome data differ from transcriptome and proteome data and have special bioinformatics needs, which are reviewed here. Special emphasis is placed on the important issue of data visualisation.
7. Sumner L.W., Mendes P., Dixon R.A. Plant metabolomics: large-scale phytochemistry in the functional genomics era. Phytochemistry. 62:2003;817-836 A first-class and easy-to-read review of the technology and science of metabolomics, concentrating on plants, and including a helpful discussion of database issues.
8. Fiehn O. Metabolomics: the link between genotypes and phenotypes. Plant Mol Biol. 48:2002;155-171 A very nice review, including a detailed discussion of the differences between metabolomics, metabolic profiling and metabolic fingerprinting and methods for performing them. GC-MS remains the most common and 'gold standard' method, but other methods are being introduced.
9. Harrigan GG, Goodacre R (Ed): Metabolic profiling: its role in biomarker discovery and gene function analysis Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers; 2003.
10. Nicholson J.K., Connelly J., Lindon J.C., Holmes E. Metabonomics: a platform for studying drug toxicity and gene function. Nat Rev Drug Discov. 1:2002;153-161 A review of metabonomics (metabolomics) with specific reference to its use in assessing mechanisms of toxicity from the metabolic profiles in urine. A particularly useful feature of this review is the helpful figure relating specific markers in the profiles to the major target sites.
11. Watkins S.M., German J.B. Metabolomics and biochemical profiling in drug discovery and development. Curr Opin Mol Ther. 4:2002;224-228
12. Fiehn O., Weckwerth W. Deciphering metabolic networks. Eur J Biochem. 270:2003;579-588 A review that aims to concentrate on methods aimed at exploiting metabolomic measurements for deciphering metabolic networks, but also covering many of the existing or emerging methods for measuring the metabolome itself.
13. Weckwerth W. Metabolomics in systems biology. Annu Rev Plant Biol. 54:2003;669-689 A review of metabolomics concentrating on its contribution to the emerging field of systems biology.
14. Lindon J.C., Holmes E., Nicholson J.K. So what's the deal with metabonomics? Metabonomics measures the fingerprint of biochemical perturbations caused by disease, drugs, and toxins. Anal Chem. 75:2003;384A-391A A review of the 'metabonomics' agenda, concentrating on high-resolution NMR and pattern recognition, although somewhat misrepresenting the origins and usage of the term 'metabolomics'. Stress is laid on the use of automation in making such methods rapid and robust, which means the cost-per-sample can be low even when using rather expensive equipment.
15. Nicholson J.K., Wilson I.D. Understanding 'global' systems biology: Metabonomics and the continuum of metabolism. Nat Rev Drug Discov. 2:2003;668-676 A review that stresses the relationship between diet, the gut microflora, and the host's genome, metabolome and disease. It includes a figure illustrating 'metabolic space' with over 5000 samples and provides a clear statement of the authors' distinction between the metabolome and the 'metabonome', the latter of which is said to relate to the metabolic responses to pathophysiological stimuli or genetic modification.
16. Goodacre R, Vaidyanathan S, Dunn WB, Harrigan GG, Kell DB: Metabolomics by numbers: acquiring and understanding global metabolite data. Trends Biotechnol. 2004: in press.
17. Marshall A.G., Hendrickson C.L. Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance detection: principles and experimental configurations. Int J Mass Spectrom. 215:2002;59-75
18. Aharoni A., Ric de Vos C.H., Verhoeven H.A., Maliepaard C.A., Kruppa G., Bino R., Goodenowe D.B. Nontargeted metabolome analysis by use of Fourier Transform Ion Cyclotron Mass Spectrometry. OMICS. 6:2002;217-234 An FTICR instrument was used to separate metabolites following electrospray or chemical ionisation solely on the basis of their accurate masses, and to identify nine specific metabolites that changed following transfection with a specific MYB transcription factor.
19. Fiehn O., Kopka J., Dormann P., Altmann T., Trethewey R.N., Willmitzer L. Metabolite profiling for plant functional genomics. Nat Biotechnol. 18:2000;1157-1161
20. Guttman A., Varoglu M., Khandurina J. Multidimensional separations in the pharmaceutical arena. Drug Discov Today. 9:2004;136-144 One way to improve separations, and hence improve the effective dynamic range, is to use multidimensional methods in which a first dimension effects a partial separation and imperfectly separated peaks are then resolved in a second dimension. This review gives a very useful overview of existing methods and trends.
21. Lu X., Cai J.L., Kong H.W., Wu M., Hua R.X., Zhao M.Y., Liu J.F., Xu G.W. Analysis of cigarette smoke condensates by comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography/time-of-flight mass spectrometry. 1 acidic fraction. Anal Chem. 75:2003;4441-4451
22. Blumberg L.M. Comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography: metrics, potentials, limits. J Chromatogr A. 985:2003;29-38
23. Niessen W.M. Progress in liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry instrumentation and its impact on high-throughput screening. J Chromatogr A. 1000:2003;413-436
24. Tolstikov V.V., Fiehn O. Analysis of highly polar compounds of plant origin: combination of hydrophilic interaction chromatography and electrospray ion trap mass spectrometry. Anal Biochem. 301:2002;298-307
25. Tolstikov V.V., Lommen A., Nakanishi K., Tanaka N., Fiehn O. Monolithic silica-based capillary reversed-phase liquid chromatography/electrospray mass spectrometry for plant metabolomics. Anal Chem. 75:2003;6737-6740 Monolithic C18 silica allows the use of long columns that give much better separation and, together with peak alignment and deconvolution software, reveal qualitatively many more peaks in the polar metabolome than had previously been construed.
26. Soga T., Ohashi Y., Ueno Y., Naraoka H., Tomita M., Nishioka T. Quantitative metabolome analysis using capillary electrophoresis mass spectrometry. J Proteome Res. 2:2003;488-494 A substantial improvement on this group's previous work combining capillary electrophoresis and low-resolution mass spectrometry. The method (which uses three columns for cationic, anionic and nucleotide/CoA metabolites) was validated with 352 metabolite standards. It was suggested that one can discriminate 1692 metabolites from Bacillus subtilis extracts (of which 150 were identified and 83 assigned), a number rather greater than that assessed from genomics. Attractions of the method include its quantitative nature and speed (20 min).
27. Kristal B.S., Vigneau-Callahan K.E., Matson W.R. Simultaneous analysis of the majority of low-molecular-weight, redox-active compounds from mitochondria. Anal Biochem. 263:1998;18-25
28. Goodacre R., Vaidyanathan S., Bianchi G., Kell D.B. Metabolic profiling using direct infusion electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry for the characterisation of olive oils. Analyst. 127:2002;1457-1462
29. Castrillo J.I., Hayes A., Mohammed S., Gaskell S.J., Oliver S.G. An optimized protocol for metabolome analysis in yeast using direct infusion electrospray mass spectrometry. Phytochemistry. 62:2003;929-937
30. Allen J.K., Davey H.M., Broadhurst D., Heald J.K., Rowland J.J., Oliver S.G., Kell D.B. High-throughput characterisation of yeast mutants for functional genomics using metabolic footprinting. Nat Biotechnol. 21:2003;692-696 Ignoring the widely proclaimed potential 'ion suppression effects', the authors showed that rapid and reproducible low-resolution (i.e. unit) mass spectra could be obtained from yeast supernatants grown in a suitable medium. Numerical processing of the data, including the use of genetic programming, allowed them to use such 'metabolic footprinting' data to discriminate S. cerevisiae strains lacking just a single gene.
31. Wei J., Burlak J.M., Siuzdak G. Desorption-ionization mass spectrometry on porous silicon. Nature. 399:1999;243-246
32. Go E.P., Prenni J.E., Wei J., Jones A., Hall S.C., Witkowska H.E., Shen Z., Siuzdak G. Desorption/ionization on silicon time-of-flight/time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Anal Chem. 75:2003;2504-2506 The matrix-less desorption ionisation on silicon method can be applied with advantage to metabolomics, and a tandem (dual time-of-flight) mass spectrometer allows rapid identification of the metabolites in question.
33. Go E.P., Shen Z., Harris K., Siuzdak G. Quantitative analysis with desorption/ionization on silicon mass spectrometry using electrospray deposition. Anal Chem. 75:2003;5475-5479
34. 12 fewer experiments. A genetic programming analysis of the data was used to identify a major and novel reason for the improvement.
35. Viant M. Improved methods for the acquisition and interpretation of NMR metabolomic data. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 310:2003;943-948
36. Griffin J.L. Metabonomics: NMR spectroscopy and pattern recognition analysis of body fluids and tissues for characterisation of xenobiotic toxicity and disease diagnosis. Curr Opin Chem Biol. 7:2003;648-654
37. Grivet J-P., Delort A-M., Portais J-C. NMR and microbiology: from physiology to metabolomics. Biochimie. 85:2003;823-840
38. Moolenaar S.H., Engelke U.F., Wevers R.A. Proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy of body fluids in the field of inborn errors of metabolism. Ann Clin Biochem. 40:2003;16-24
39. Wang Y., Bollard M.E., Keun H., Antti H., Beckonert O., Ebbels T.M., Lindon J.C., Holmes E., Tang H., Nicholson J.K. Spectral editing and pattern recognition methods applied to high-resolution magic-angle spinning 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy of liver tissues. Anal Biochem. 323:2003;26-32
40. Lindon J.C., Nicholson J.K., Holmes E., Antti H., Bollard M.E., Keun H., Beckonert O., Ebbels T.M., Reily M.D., Robertson D., et al. Contemporary issues in toxicology the role of metabonomics in toxicology and its evaluation by the COMET project. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol. 187:2003;137-146
41. Nishikawa Y., Dmochowska B., Madaj J., Xue J., Guo Z., Satake M., Reddy D.V., Rinaldi P.L., Monnier V.M. Vitamin C metabolomic mapping in experimental diabetes with 6-deoxy-6-fluoro-ascorbic acid and high resolution 19F-nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Metabolism. 52:2003;760-770
42. Lindon J.C., Nicholson J.K., Wilson I.D. Directly coupled HPLC-NMR and HPLC-NMR-MS in pharmaceutical research and development. Journal of Chromatogr. 748:2000;233-258
43. Lindon J.C. HPLC-NMR-MS: past, present and future. Drug Discov Today. 8:2003;1021-1022
44. Albert K: On-line LC-NMR and related techniques. New York: Wiley; 2002.
45. Oliver S.G., Winson M.K., Kell D.B., Baganz F. Systematic functional analysis of the yeast genome. Trends Biotechnol. 16:1998;373-378
46. -1. The 'top' rule obtained made clear that the main biochemical indicator of spoilage was proteolysis.
47. Winson M.K., Goodacre R., Timmins É.M., Jones A., Alsberg B.K., Woodward A.M., Rowland J.J., Kell D.B. Diffuse reflectance absorbance spectroscopy taking in chemometrics (DRASTIC). A hyperspectral FT-IR-based approach to rapid screening for metabolite overproduction. Anal Chim Acta. 348:1997;273-282
48. Mouille G., Robin S., Lecomte M., Pagant S., Hofte H. Classification and identification of Arabidopsis cell wall mutants using Fourier-Transform InfraRed (FT-IR) microspectroscopy. Plant J. 35:2003;393-404
49. Kell DB, Mendes P: Snapshots of systems: metabolic control analysis and biotechnology in the post-genomic era. In Technological and Medical Implications of Metabolic Control Analysis. Edited by Cornish-Bowden A., Cárdenas ML: Kluwer Academic Publishers; 2000:3-25 (and see http://dbk.ch.umist.ac.uk/ WhitePapers/mcabio.htm)
50. Cascante M., Boros L.G., Comin-Anduix B., de Atauri P., Centelles J.J., Lee P.W. Metabolic control analysis in drug discovery and disease. Nat Biotechnol. 20:2002;243-249
51. Urbanczyk-Wochniak E, Luedemann A, Kopka J, Selbig J, Roessner-Tunali U, Willmitzer L, Fernie AR: Parallel analysis of transcript and metabolic profiles: a new approach in systems biology. EMBO Rep 2003.
52. Fehr M., Lalonde S., Lager I., Wolff M.W., Frommer W.B. In vivo imaging of the dynamics of glucose uptake in the cytosol of COS-7 cells by fluorescent nanosensors. J Biol Chem. 278:2003;19127-19133 The authors used a glucose-binding system engineered with two GFP variants, whose ability to perform fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) was a function of the glucose concentration. This allowed optical imaging of the glucose concentration. A striking finding for metabolomics was that in COS-7 cells, cytoplasmic glucose concentrations can vary over at least two orders of magnitude.
53. Jonsson P, Gullberg J, Nordström A, Kusano M, Kowalczyk M, Sjöström M, Moritz T: A strategy for identifying differences in large series of metabolomic samples analyzed by GC/MS. Anal Chem 2004:in press.
54. Duran A.L., Yang J., Wang L., Sumner L.W. Metabolomics spectral formatting, alignment and conversion tools (MSFACTs). Bioinformatics. 19:2003;2283-2293 MSFACTs contains two tools. RTAlign takes peak lists and aligns them, somewhat like image registration does in 2D gel analysis, and RICExtract takes raw 'hyphenated' (e.g. GC-MS) data in ASCII form and reconstructs an aligned series of chromatograms based on retention times with values for the 'peaks' that can subsequently be identified. It is available via http://www.noble.org/PlantBio/MS/MSFACTs/MSFACTs.html.
55. Johnson K.J., Wright B.W., Jarman K.H., Synovec R.E. High-speed peak matching algorithm for retention time alignment of gas chromatographic data for chemometric analysis. J Chromatogr A. 996:2003;141-155
56. Wasim M., Hassan M.S., Brereton R.G. Evaluation of chemometric methods for determining the number and position of components in high-performance liquid chromatography detected by diode array detector and on-flow 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Analyst. 128:2003;1082-1090 Comparison of a series of chemometric methods for deconvoluting peaks in methods such as LC-NMR and LC-DAD (diode array detection).
57. Feigenbaum E.A., Buchanan B.G. DENDRAL and META-DENDRAL: Roots of knowledge systems and expert system applications. Artif Intell. 59:1993;223-240
58. Lindsay R.K., Buchanan B.G., Feigenbaum E.A., Lederberg J. DENDRAL - a Case study of the first expert system for scientific hypothesis formation. Artif Intell. 61:1993;209-261
59. Buchanan B.G., Feigenbaum E.A. DENDRAL and META-DENDRAL: their application dimensions. Artif Intell. 11:1978;5-24
60. Steinbeck C. SENECA: A platform-independent, distributed, and parallel system for computer-assisted structure elucidation in organic chemistry. J Chem Inf Comput Sci. 41:2001;1500-1507
61. Meiler J., Sanli E., Junker J., Meusinger R., Lindel T., Will M., Maier W., Kock M. Validation of structural proposals by substructure analysis and 13C NMR chemical shift prediction. J Chem Inf Comput Sci. 42:2002;241-248
62. Meiler J., Will M. Genius: a genetic algorithm for automated structure elucidation from 13C NMR spectra. J Am Chem Soc. 124:2002;1868-1870 A continuation of earlier work from the same group [61] in which a genetic algorithm generates candidate chemical structures (the empirical formula is assumed known from high-resolution mass spectrometry), a neural network is trained to predict chemical shifts, and further candidate structures are evolved predominantly from those whose calculated spectra best match those observed.
63. Fontana P., Pretsch E. Automatic spectra interpretation, structure generation, and ranking. J Chem Inf Comput Sci. 42:2002;614-619
64. Elyashberg M.E., Blinov K.A., Williams A.J., Martirosian E.R., Molodtsov S.G. Application of a new expert system for the structure elucidation of natural products from their 1D and 2D NMR data. J Nat Prod. 65:2002;693-703
65. Hardy N, Fuell H: Databases, data modeling and schemas: database development in metabolomics. In Metabolic profiling: its role in biomarker discovery and gene function analysis. Edited by Harrigan GG, Goodacre R: Kluwer Academic Publishers; 2003:277-291.
66. Brazma A., Hingamp P., Quackenbush J., Sherlock G., Spellman P., Stoeckert C., Aach J., Ansorge W., Ball C.A., Causton H.C., et al. Minimum information about a microarray experiment (MIAME)-toward standards for microarray data. Nat Genet. 29:2001;365-371
67. Brazma A., Sarkans U., Robinson A., Vilo J., Vingron M., Hoheisel J., Fellenberg K. Microarray data representation, annotation and storage. Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol. 77:2002;113-139
68. Taylor C.F., Paton N.W., Garwood K.L., Kirby P.D., Stead D.A., Yin Z., Deutsch E.W., Selway L., Walker J., Riba-Garcia I., et al. A systematic approach to modelling capturing and disseminating proteomics experimental data. Nat Biotechnol. 21:2003;247-254 The first proposal for a data model for proteomics data, described as a UML (unified modelling language) model, together with XML (extensible markup language) and SQL (structured query language) implementations, as well as a description of a suitable proteome repository (PEDRo).
69. Orchard S., Hermjakob H., Apweiler R. The proteomics standards initiative. Proteomics. 3:2003;1374-1376
70. Mendes P., Kell D.B. On the analysis of the inverse problem of metabolic pathways using artificial neural networks. Biosystems. 38:1996;15-28
71. Mendes P., Kell D.B. Non-linear optimization of biochemical pathways: applications to metabolic engineering and parameter estimation. Bioinformatics. 14:1998;869-883
72. Hucka M., Finney A., Sauro H.M., Bolouri H., Doyle J.C., Kitano H., Arkin A.P., Bornstein B.J., Bray D., Cornish-Bowden A., et al. The systems biology markup language (SBML): a medium for representation and exchange of biochemical network models. Bioinformatics. 19:2003;524-531 Systems biology markup language (SBML) provides a medium for exchanging metabolic models and their metadata regardless of the (SBML-compliant) simulator that was used to produce and run the model.
73. Tomita M., Hashimoto K., Takahashi K., Shimizu T.S., Matsuzaki Y., Miyoshi F., Saito K., Tanida S., Yugi K., Venter J.C., et al. E-CELL: software environment for whole-cell simulation. Bioinformatics. 15:1999;72-84
74. Takahashi K., Ishikawa N., Sadamoto Y., Sasamoto H., Ohta S., Shiozawa A., Miyoshi F., Naito Y., Nakayama Y., Tomita M. E-cell 2: Multi-platform E-Cell simulation system. Bioinformatics. 19:2003;1727-1729 A multi-platform (Windows 98/NT/2000/XP/ Linux) update of the e-cell simulation system for modelling metabolic networks.
75. Klamt S., Stelling J., Ginkel M., Gilles E.D. FluxAnalyzer: exploring structure, pathways, and flux distributions in metabolic networks on interactive flux maps. Bioinformatics. 19:2003;261-269 The FluxAnalyzer is a software tool in MATLAB, which inter alia allows users to perform metabolic flux analysis, flux optimisation, detection of topological features and pathway analysis by elementary flux modes or extreme pathways. Licenses are free to academic users.
76. Doniger SW, Salomonis N, Dahlquist KD, Vranizan K, Lawlor SC, Conklin BR: MAPPFinder: using Gene Ontology and GenMAPP to create a global gene-expression profile from microarray data. Genome Biol 2003, http://genomebiology.com/2003/4/ 1/R7.
77. Weckwerth W., Fiehn O. Can we discover novel pathways using metabolomic analysis? Curr Opin Biotechnol. 13:2002;156-160
78. Noble D. The future: putting Humpty-Dumpty together again. Biochem Soc Trans. 31:2003;156-158
79. Moles C.G., Mendes P., Banga J.R. Parameter estimation in biochemical pathways: a comparison of global optimization methods. Genome Res. 13:2003;2467-2474 Parameter estimation of metabolic networks is recognised explicitly as an ill-conditioned inverse problem. A case study concerning the estimation of 36 parameters of a three-step, nonlinear biochemical dynamic model is used as a benchmark model. Of a series of algorithms, one based on an evolutionary computing method was the most robust and successful for this dataset.
80. Mendes P., Sha W., Ye K. Artificial gene networks for objective comparison of analysis algorithms. Bioinformatics. 19(Suppl 2):2003;II122-II129 Arguably the biggest problem with developing algorithms for solving the inverse problem of metabolic and genetic networks is that we do not know what the correct answer is! The obvious way round this is to simulate the time-dependent behaviour of networks of known properties (with added noise) so as to determine which algorithms do best at reconstructing the generating networks successfully. This is what is done here using an artificial gene network generator. Various models are available at http://www.vbi.vt.edu/∼mendes/AGN.
81. Barabási A-L., Oltvai Z.N. Network biology: understanding the cell's functional organization. Nat Rev Genet. 5:2004;101-113 A superb review of current knowledge about the general properties of networks, including a substantial focus on metabolic networks. The scale-free nature of metabolic networks probably has an evolutionary basis, in that the growth of networks, and especially hubs, occurs by accretion, with more 'linked' nodes being more likely to acquire new partners. The network motifs seen in metabolic networks, especially triangles, differ greatly from those seen in electrical circuits for example, where squares are common. A must-read paper for network biologists.
82. Wixon J., Kell D.B. The Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes - KEGG -. http://www.genome.ad.jp/kegg Yeast. 17:2000;48-55
83. Karp P.D., Kummenacker M., Paley S., Wagg J. Integrated pathway-genome databases and their role in drug discovery. Trends Biotechnol. 17:1999;275-281
84. Karp P.D., Riley M., Saier M., Paulsen I.T., Collado-Vides J., Paley S.M., Pellegrini-Toole A., Bonavides C., Gama-Castro S. The EcoCyc Database. Nucleic Acids Res. 30:2002;56-58
85. Reed JL, Vo TD, Schilling CH, Palsson BØ: An expanded genome-scale model of Escherichia coli K12 (iJR904 GSM/GPR). Genome Biol 2003, 4:R54 (open access at http://genomebiology.com/2003/2004/2009/R2054).
86. •].
87. Förster J., Famili I., Fu P., Palsson B.Ø., Nielsen J. Genome-scale reconstruction of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae metabolic network. Genome Res. 13:2003;244-253 The author's combine genomic, biochemical and physiological knowledge to reconstruct a metabolic network for the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, leading to a network containing 1155 biochemical reactions and 584 metabolites. Very useful supplementary information is available at http://www.cpb.dtu.dk/models/yeastmodel.html.
88. Nobeli I., Ponstingl H., Krissinel E.B., Thornton J.M. A structure-based anatomy of the E. coli metabolome. J Mol Biol. 334:2003;697-719 A very interesting paper in which the authors seek to catalogue the metabolome of E. coli from a physico-chemical point of view. The numbers of known 'basal' metabolites are in the hundreds, with a large and effectively continuous spread of physical properties (knowledge of which is useful for designing metabolomics analysis strategies), and most are of fairly low molecular weight (Figure 3). A small family of substructures can be used to build up this metabolome, and a certain level of clustering of metabolites according to physico-chemical properties is then possible.
89. Bono H., Nikaido I., Kasukawa T. RIKEN GER Group, GSLMembers, Hayashizaki Y, Okazaki Y: Comprehensive analysis of the mouse metabolome based on the transcriptome. Genome Res. 13:2003;1345-1349
90. Renesto P., Crapoulet N., Ogata H., La Scola B., Vestris G., Claverie J.M., Raoult D. Genome-based design of a cell-free culture medium for Tropheryma whipplei. Lancet. 362:2003;447-449
91. Ravasz E., Somera A.L., Mongru D.A., Oltvai Z.N., Barabási A.L. Hierarchical organization of modularity in metabolic networks. Science. 297:2002;1551-1555 The metabolic network of 43 organsisms is analysed, with a focus on E. coli. Metabolic networks are scale-free networks, and consist of modular building blocks organised hierarchically, with the degree of clustering following a power law. In E. coli, networks can also be clustered on the basis of the biochemical type or function of the molecules involved.
92. Alm E., Arkin A.P. Biological networks. Curr Opin Struct Biol. 13:2003;193-202 A useful review of the emerging recognition that biological systems are best viewed as networks and not lists of parts, concentrating on techniques, structures and modules/motifs.
93. Wagner A., Fell D.A. The small world inside large metabolic networks. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 268:2001;1803-1810
94. Schuster S., Dandekar T., Fell D.A. Detection of elementary flux modes in biochemical networks: a promising tool for pathway analysis and metabolic engineering. Trends Biotechnol. 17:1999;53-60
95. Klamt S., Stelling J. Two approaches for metabolic pathway analysis? Trends Biotechnol. 21:2003;64-69
96. Schuster S., Hilgetag C., Woods J.H., Fell D.A. Reaction routes in biochemical reaction systems: Algebraic properties, validated calculation procedure and example from nucleotide metabolism. J Math Biol. 45:2002;153-181 Provides a formal definition of elementary modes in a metabolic network, and provides and proves an algorithm that can generate all the elementary flux modes of an arbitrary network containing reversible or irreversible reactions or both.
97. Stelling J., Klamt S., Bettenbrock K., Schuster S., Gilles E.D. Metabolic network structure determines key aspects of functionality and regulation. Nature. 420:2002;190-193 As well as their formal use, elementary modes show that even in the absence of quantitative parameters the essential structure of a metabolic network alone contains otherwise hidden constraints that can provide very useful predictions on matters such as flexibility (robustness), functionality, regulation and even cell viability.
98. Papin J.A., Price N.D., Wiback S.J., Fell D.A., Palsson B.Ø. Metabolic pathways in the post-genome era. Trends Biochem Sci. 28:2003;250-258 Metabolic pathways are really networks, which can be analysed formally via a variety of mathematically exact methods. This paper provides a useful, systematic and readable account of them, including elementary modes and extreme pathways.
99. Burgard AP, Nikolaev EV, Schilling CH, Maranas CD: Flux coupling analysis of genome-scale metabolic network reconstructions. Genome Res. 2004:1-12.
100. Almaas E., Kovács B., Vicsek T., Oltvai Z.N., Barabási A-L. Global organization of metabolic fluxes in the bacterium Escherichia coli. Nature. 427:2004;839-843 A global analysis of metabolic fluxes in E. coli shows that while most metabolic reactions have small fluxes, the overall metabolic activity is dominated by a comparatively small subset of reactions with very high fluxes. The organism responds to changes in growth conditions largely by reorganising the rates of selected fluxes within this high-flux backbone. This may have significant implications for metabolic engineering and the 'design' of high-yielding strains.
101. •].
102. Schilling C.H., Edwards J.S., Palsson B.Ø. Toward metabolic phenomics: Analysis of genomic data using flux balances. Biotechnol Prog. 15:1999;288-295
103. Kauffman K.J., Prakash P., Edwards J.S. Advances in flux balance analysis. Curr Opin Biotechnol. 14:2003;491-496 A very helpful review summarising the historical and present development of flux-balancing methods for analysing complex metabolic systems.
104. Westerhoff H.V., Hellingwerf K.J., van Dam K. Thermodynamic efficiency of microbial growth is low but optimal for maximal growth rate. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 80:1983;305-309
105. ••], these authors were able to predict the growth yield, P/2e- ratio, maintenance energy yield and metabolite secretion in S. cerevisiae, which also allowed them to propose transcriptome levels. The in silico results were consistent with the phenotypes observed ∼75% of the time.
106. Förster J., Famili I., Palsson B.Ø., Nielsen J. Large-scale evaluation of in silico deletions in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. OMICS. 7:2003;193-202
107. Mahadevan R., Schilling C.H. The effects of alternate optimal solutions in constraint-based genome-scale metabolic models. Metab Eng. 5:2003;264-276 Sometimes the constraint-based modelling strategy can lead to quite different flux distributions with equally fast growth rates. This paper shows that these depend substantially on the network characteristics. Clearly an iterative interplay between calculations and experiment is necessary here.
108. Ibarra R.U., Edwards J.S., Palsson B.Ø. Escherichia coli K12 undergoes adaptive evolution to achieve in silico predicted optimal growth. Nature. 420:2003;186-189 In continuous cultures, there is a selective pressure to evolve to ever-greater growth rates. The question then arises as to how organisms might manage this from a metabolic network point of view. This excellent article shows that E. coli evolved experimentally in 700 generations (40 days) from using a sub-optimal network to one consistent with that predicted by the in silico constraint-based prediction.
109. Segrè D., Vitkup D., Church G.M. Analysis of optimality in natural and perturbed metabolic networks. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 99:2002;15112-15117
110. Burgard A.P., Pharkya P., Maranas C.D. OptKnock: A bilevel programming framework for identifying gene knockout strategies for microbial strain optimization. Biotechnol Bioeng. 84:2003;647-657 A variant of flux balance analysis (MOMA - method of minimisation of metabolic adjustment), which recognises that knockout or other strains that are not growing at their maximum growth rate may not have evolved optimal fluxes but such strains may have metabolic fluxes which have minimal redistribution with respect to the flux configuration of the wild type, a suggestion borne out by data.
111. Milo R., Shen-Orr S., Itzkovitz S., Kashtan N., Chklovskii D., Alon U. Network motifs: simple building blocks of complex networks. Science. 298:2002;824-827 An analysis of different types of networks shows that metabolic networks and food web networks share related but distinct motifs, and that those observed regularly in nature occur far more often than would be expected for random networks. A 'feed-forward loop' has the useful property of being activated only if the input is persistent.
112. Shen-Orr S.S., Milo R., Mangan S., Alon U. Network motifs in the transcriptional regulation network of Escherichia coli. Nat Genet. 31:2002;64-68 In E. coli, three motifs are particularly prevalent: the feed-forward loop, the 'single-input module', and the 'densely overlapping regulon'. Each of these motifs has a specific type of behaviour and can be argued to have a particular function in gene expression networks.
113. Savageau M: Biochemical systems analysis: a study of function and design in molecular biology. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley; 1976.
114. Wall M.E., Hlavacek W.S., Savageau M.A. Design of gene circuits: Lessons from bacteria. Nat Rev Genet. 5:2004;34-42 A convenient and clearly expressed review of the behaviour of different genetic networks, concentrating on their quantitative stability, robustness and responsiveness, with emphasis on the role of different transcription factors. The 'optimal' designs - usually but not exclusively those found or exploited by evolution - differ for different kinds of gain (amplification) and whether the system is based on induction or repression.
115. Wolf D.M., Arkin A.P. Motifs, modules and games in bacteria. Curr Opin Microbiol. 6:2003;125-134 A very useful survey of various network motifs and modules and their 'functions' (i.e. behaviour) as switches, oscillators, filters, amplifiers and other activities typical of electrical circuits.
116. Mangan S., Alon U. Structure and function of the feed-forward loop network motif. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 100:2003;11980-11985 Feed-forward network loop motifs come in eight types; four are 'incoherent' ones that act as 'sign-sensitive accelerators', i.e. they speed up the response time of their target genes to a stimulus when it is changed in one direction but not the other. The other four are sign-sensitive delays.
117. Guet C.C., Elowitz M.B., Hsing W., Leibler S. Combinatorial synthesis of genetic networks. Science. 296:2002;1466-1470
118. Pilpel Y., Sudarsanam P., Church G.M. Identifying regulatory networks by combinatorial analysis of promoter elements. Nat Genet. 29:2001;153-159
119. Hofmeyr J.H., Cornish-Bowden A. Co-response analysis: a new experimental strategy for metabolic control analysis. J Theor Biol. 182:1996;371-380
120. Raamsdonk L.M., Teusink B., Broadhurst D., Zhang N., Hayes A., Walsh M., Berden J.A., Brindle K.M., Kell D.B., Rowland J.J., et al. A functional genomics strategy that uses metabolome data to reveal the phenotype of silent mutations. Nat Biotechnol. 19:2001;45-50
121. Kose F., Weckwerth W., Linke T., Fiehn O. Visualizing plant metabolomic correlation networks using clique-metabolite matrices. Bioinformatics. 17:2001;1198-1208
122. Steuer R., Kurths J., Fiehn O., Weckwerth W. Observing and interpreting correlations in metabolomic networks. Bioinformatics. 19:2003;1019-1026 The authors used a simple Pearson correlation between pairs of metabolites and proposed that these reflected the enzymatic arrangement of the system via the Jacobian of the system. However, although some correlations make sense, an example from a simulation of glycolysis is used to show that these correlations may reflect only poorly the actual pathway(s) that generated them.
123. Taylor J., King R.D., Altmann T., Fiehn O. Application of metabolomics to plant genotype discrimination using statistics and machine learning. Bioinformatics. 18(Suppl 2):2002;S241-S248 Machine learning methods using metabolomics data as the inputs can be used to discriminate plant ecotypes. Deconvolution allows the major metabolites involved to be pinpointed.
124. Kaderbhai N.N., Broadhurst D.I., Ellis D.I., Goodacre R., Kell D.B. Functional genomics via metabolic footprinting: Monitoring metabolite secretion by Escherichia coli tryptophan metabolism mutants using FT-IR and direct injection electrospray mass spectrometry. Comp Funct Genomics. 4:2003;376-391
125. Kell D.B., Darby R.M., Draper J. Genomic computing: explanatory analysis of plant expression profiling data using machine learning. Plant Physiol. 126:2001;943-951
126. Kell DB: Defence against the flood: a solution to the data mining and predictive modelling challenges of today. Bioinformatics World (part of Scientific Computing News) 2002, Issue 1:16-18 http://www.abergc.com/biwpp16- 18_as_publ.pdf.
127. Kell D.B. Metabolomics and machine learning: explanatory analysis of complex metabolome data using genetic programming to produce simple, robust rules. Mol Biol Rep. 29:2002;237-241
128. Goodacre R, Kell DB: Evolutionary computation for the interpretation of metabolome data. In Metabolic profiling: its role in biomarker discovery and gene function analysis. Edited by Harrigan GG, Goodacre R: Kluwer Academic Publishers; 2003:239-256.
129. Goodacre R. Explanatory analysis of spectroscopic data using machine learning of simple, interpretable rules. Vib Spectrosc. 32:2003;33-45 A useful review (albeit in a journal unlikely to be seen routinely by microbiologists) of the use of infrared and Raman spectroscopies in metabolomics and of evolutionary computing methods for analysing the data obtained.
130. Koza JR, Keane MA, Streeter MJ, Mydlowec W, Yu J, Lanza G: Genetic programming: routine human-competitive machine intelligence. New York: Kluwer; 2003.
131. Visser D., Heijnen J.J. Dynamic simulation and metabolic re-design of a branched pathway using lin-log kinetics. Metab Eng. 5:2003;164-176 Describes the use of lin-log kinetics for approximating metabolic networks over a much wider range of validity than usually available in metabolic control analysis (of which this strategy is an extension). Given the present difficulty of measuring kinetic rate equations on a genomic scale, this strategy should be valuable for modellers generally.
132. Raju G.K., Cooney C.L. Active learning from process data. AIChE J. 44:1998;2199-2211
133. Bryant CH, Muggleton SH, Oliver SG, Kell DB, Reiser P, King RD: Combining inductive logic programming, active learning and robotics to discover the function of genes. Electronic Transactions on Artificial Intelligence 2001, 5:1-36 (http://www.ep.liu.se/ej/etai/2001/2001/).
134. Vance W., Arkin A., Ross J. Determination of causal connectivities of species in reaction networks. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 99:2002;5816-5821 The propagation of changes through a network is largely determined by the connectivities and their kinetic constants. The former can be used to predict the latter, and the result may be used to propose strategies for the perturbations that are likely to be most informative.
135. Kholodenko B.N., Kiyatkin A., Bruggeman F.J., Sontag E., Westerhoff H.V., Hoek J.B. Untangling the wires: a strategy to trace functional interactions in signaling and gene networks. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 99:2002;12841-12846 This paper describes a method (with roots in metabolic control analysis) based on a mathematical derivation that demonstrates how the topology and strength of network connections can be retrieved from experimentally measured network responses to successive perturbations of all modules.
136. de la Fuente A., Brazhnik P., Mendes P. Linking the genes: inferring quantitative gene networks from microarray data. Trends Genet. 18:2002;395-398 A comparatively straightforward method for identifying not only the genes involved in regulatory networks but the strength of these relationships.
137. Ross J. New approaches to the deduction of complex reaction mechanisms. Acc Chem Res. 36:2003;839-847 A useful review, highlighting the canonical metric construction method, and others based on genetic algorithms, for constraining the possible chemical reaction (or metabolic) networks consistent with a particular time series of metabolome data. Glycolysis is used as a specific example.
138. Gardner T.S., di Bernardo D., Lorenz D., Collins J.J. Inferring genetic networks and identifying compound mode of action via expression profiling. Science. 301:2003;102-105 Systematic transcriptional perturbations were used to identify regulatory interactions in a nine-gene sub-network of the E. coli SOS system. The model permitted the major transcriptional targets of mitomycin C to be identified.
139. von Bertalanffy L: General System Theory. New York: George Braziller; 1969.
140. Iberall AS: Toward a general science of viable systems: McGraw-Hill; 1972.
141. Maddox J.S. Towards more measurement in biology. Nature. 368:1994;95
142. Ideker T., Galitski T., Hood L. A new approach to decoding life: systems biology. Annu Rev Genomics Hum Genet. 2:2001;343-372
143. Kitano H. Computational systems biology. Nature. 420:2002;206-210
144. Zhu H., Klemic J.F., Chang S., Bertone P., Casamayor A., Klemic K.G., Smith D., Gerstein M., Reed M.A., Snyder M. Analysis of yeast protein kinases using protein chips. Nat Genet. 26:2000;283-289
145. Zhu H., Bilgin M., Bangham R., Hall D., Casamayor A., Bertone P., Lan N., Jansen R., Bidlingmaier S., Houfek T., et al. Global analysis of protein activities using proteome chips. Science. 293:2001;2101-2105
146. Ouyang Z., Takáts Z., Blake T.A., Gologan B., Guymon A.J., Wiseman J.M., Oliver J.C., Davisson V.J., Cooks R.G. Preparing protein microarrays by soft-landing of mass-selected ions. Science. 301:2003;1351-1354
147. Biomarkers Definitions Working Group: Biomarkers and surrogate endpoints: preferred definitions and conceptual framework. Clin Pharmacol Ther 2001, 69:89-95.
148. Rashed M.S. Clinical applications of tandem mass spectrometry: ten years of diagnosis and screening for inherited metabolic diseases. J Chromatogr B Biomed Sci Appl. 758:2001;27-48
149. van der Greef J, Davidov EJ, Verheij E, Vogels J, van der Heijden R, Adourian AS, Marple EW, Naylor S: The role of metabolomics in systems biology: a new vision for drug discovery and development. In Metabolic profiling: its role in biomarker discovery and gene function analysis. Edited by Harrigan GG, Goodacre R: Kluwer; 2003:171-198.
150. 1H -NMR of blood samples and discriminant partial least squares analysis to discriminate patients with various forms of coronary heart disease. The method consequently shows great promise for providing a replacement for angiography. However, the numbers of samples were rather low, especially when prevalence is taken into account, and the ongoing larger study will be of great interest.
151. 1H NMR-based metabonomic study of urine and plasma samples obtained from healthy human subjects J Pharm Biomed Anal. 33:2003;1103-1115
152. Solanky KS, Bailey NJC, Beckwith-Hall BM, Davis A, Bingham S, Holmes E, Nicholson JK, Cassidy A: Application of biofluid 1H nuclear magnetic resonance-based metabonomic techniques for the analysis of the biochemical effects of dietary isflavones on human plasma profile. Anal. Biochem 2003, 323.
153. Aranibar N., Singh B.K., Stockton G.W., Ott K-H. Automated mode-of-action detection by metabolic profiling. Biochem Biophys Res Commun. 286:2001;150-155
154. Ott K.-H., Aranibar N., Singh B., Stockton G.W. Metabonomics classifies pathways affected by bioactive compounds. Artificial neural network classification of NMR spectra of plant extracts. Phytochemistry. 62:2003;971-985 NMR spectra of extracts of plants treated with compounds with different modes of action were used as the inputs to trained artificial neural networks. As possibly expected from the discrimination of single-gene knockouts, other substances could then be classified according to their mode of action with significant success.
155. Shi Y., Evans J.E., Rock K.L. Molecular identification of a danger signal that alerts the immune system to dying cells. Nature. 425:2003;516-521 The authors purified a molecule from dying cells that had strong adjuvant activity in antigenic stimulation. The molecule turned out to be uric acid. Eliminating uric acid in vivo inhibited the immune response to antigens associated with injured cells, but not to antigens presented by activated dendritic cells.
156. Askenazi M., Driggers E.M., Holtzman D.A., Norman T.C., Iverson S., Zimmer D.P., Boers M.E., Blomquist P.R., Martinez E.J., Monreal A.W., et al. Integrating transcriptional and metabolite profiles to direct the engineering of lovastatin-producing fungal strains. Nat Biotechnol. 21:2003;150-156
157. Holms H. Flux analysis and control of the central metabolic pathways in Escherichia coli. FEMS Microbiol Rev. 19:1996;85-116