Briefing and debriefing during simulation-based training and beyond: Content, structure, attitude and setting

Best Practice and Research: Clinical Anaesthesiology

Volumn 29, Issue 1, 2015, Pages 87-96

  Kolbe, Michaela ^a,b   Grande, Bastian ^a   Spahn, Donat R ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL ZURICH   (Switzerland)

^b ETH ZURICH   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

communication; debriefing; learning; patient simulation; safety

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; ATTITUDE; CLINICAL PRACTICE; FEEDBACK SYSTEM; HUMAN; INFORMATION; INFORMATION PROCESSING; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; LEARNING; PRIORITY JOURNAL; SIMULATION; SIMULATION BASED TRAINING; TEAMWORK; TRAINING; ANESTHESIOLOGY; EDUCATION; PATIENT CARE; SIMULATION TRAINING;

ANESTHESIOLOGY; COMMUNICATION; HUMANS; PATIENT CARE TEAM; SIMULATION TRAINING;

EID: 84927952209     PISSN: 15216896     EISSN: 1532169X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.bpa.2015.01.002     Document Type: Review

References (82)

1. J.W. Rudolph, R. Simon, and P. Rivard et al. Debriefing with good judgement: combining rigorous feedback with genuine inquiry Anesthesiol Clin 25 2007 361 376
2. R.E. Butler LOFT: full-mission simulation as crew resource management training E.L. Wiener, B.G. Kanki, R.L. Helmreich, Cockpit resource management 1993 Academic Press San Diego, CA 231 259
3. R.M. Fanning, and D.M. Gaba The role of debriefing in simulation-based learning Simul Healthc 2 2007 115 125
4. D. Raemer, M. Anderson, and A. Cheng et al. Research regarding debriefing as part of the learning process Simul Healthc 6 2011 S52 S57
5. Kihlgren P, Spanager L, Dieckmann P. Investigating novice doctors' reflections in debriefings after simulation scenarios. Medl Teach. 1-7 online first. doi: 10.3109/0142159X.2014.956054
6. E. Salas, C. Klein, and H. King et al. Debriefing medical teams: 12 evidence-based best practices and tips Jt Comm J Qual Patient Saf 34 2008 518 527
7. M. Brett-Fleegler, J.W. Rudolph, and W.J. Eppich et al. Debriefing assessment for simulation in healthcare. Development and psychometric properties Simul Healthc 7 2012 288 294
8. C. Argyris Double-loop learning, teaching, and research Acad Management Learn Education 1 2002 206 218
9. A. Cheng, W. Eppich, and V. Grant et al. Debriefing for technology-enhanced simulation: a systematic review and meta-analysis Med Education 48 2014 657 666
10. A.Y. Kolb, and D.A. Kolb Learning styles and learning spaces: enhancing experiential learning in higher education Acad Management Learn Education 4 2005 193 212
11. M.A. Rosen, E. Salas, and K.A. Wilson et al. Measuring team performance in simulation-based training: adopting best practices for healthcare Simul Healthc 3 2008 33 41
12. J.J. Zigmont, L.J. Kappus, and S.N. Sudikoff Theoretical foundations of learning through simulation Semin Perinatol 35 2011 47 51
13. P. Dieckmann, S.M. Friis, and A. Lippert et al. Goals, success factors, and barriers for simulation-based learning: a qualitative interview study in health care Simul Gaming 43 2012 May 14 627 647
14. D.R. Vashdi, P.A. Bamberger, and M. Erez Can surgical teams ever learn? the role of coordination, complexity, and transitivity in action team learning Acad Manage J 56 2013 945 971
15. M. Kolbe, M. Weiss, and G. Grote et al. TeamGAINS: a tool for structured debriefings for simulation-based team trainings BMJ Qual Saf 22 2013 541 553
16. E.R. Eddy, S.I. Tannenbaum, and J.E. Mathieu Helping teams to help themselves: comparing two team-led debriefing methods Pers Psychol 66 2013 975 1008
17. P. Pronovost Teamwork matters E. Salas, S.I. Tannenbaum, D. Cohen, Developing and enhancing teamwork in organizations: evidence-based best practices and guidelines 2013 Jossey-Bass San Francisco, CA 11 12
18. A.A. Gawande, M.J. Zinner, and D.M. Studdert et al. Analysis of errors reported by surgeons at three teaching hospitals Surgery 133 2003 614 621
19. J.E. Mathieu, and T.L. Rapp Laying the foundation for successful team performance trajectories: the roles of team charters and performance strategies J Appl Psychol 94 2009 90 103
20. M.A. West Effective teamwork. Practical lessons from organizational research 2nd ed. 2004 BPS Blackwell Oxford
21. J.R. Hackman, and C.G. Morris Group tasks, group interaction process, and group performance effectiveness: a review and proposed integration L. Berkowitz, Adv Exp Soc Psychol. 1975 Academic Press New York 45 99
22. S.I. Tannenbaum, and S. Goldhaber-Fiebert Medical team debriefs: Simple, powerful, underutilized E. Salas, K. Frush, Improving patient safety through teamwork and team training 2013 Oxford University Press New York 249 256
23. M. Ahmed, N. Sevdalis, and J. Paige et al. Identifying best practice guidelines for debriefing in surgery: a tri-continental study Am J Surg 203 2012 523 529
24. M. Ahmed, S. Arora, and S. Russ et al. Operation debrief: a SHARP improvement in performance feedback in the operating room Ann Surg 258 2013 958 963
25. J.W. Rudolph, E.G. Foldy, and T. Robinson et al. Helping without harming. The instructor's feedback dilemma in debriefing-a case study Simul Healthc 8 2013 304 316
26. J.W. Rudolph, R. Simon, and R.L. Dufresne et al. There's no such thing as "nonjudgmental" debriefing: a theory and method for debriefing with good judgment Simul Healthc 1 2006 49 55
27. C. Argyris Making the undiscussable and its undiscussability discussable Public Adm Rev 1980;May/June 205 213
28. D.T. Gilbert, and P.S. Malone The correspondence bias Psychol Bull 117 1995 21 38
29. R.K. Dismukes, D.M. Gaba, and S.K. Howard So many roads: facilitated debriefing in healthcare Simul Healthc 1 2006 23 25
30. M. Kolbe, and J.W. Rudolph Snapshots of the road to reflective practice: what advanced simulation instructors think during a master class Simul Healthc 7 2012 519
31. N.P. Repenning, and J.D. Sterman Capability traps and self-confirming attribution errors in the dynamics of process improvement Adm Sci Q 47 2002 265 295
32. E.H. Schein Humbly inquiry. The gentle art of asking instead of telling 2013 Berrett-Koehler San Francisco, CA
33. J.S. Carroll, J.W. Rudolph, and S. Hatakenaka Learning from experience in high-hazard organizations Res Organ Behav 24 2002 87 137
34. R.D. Minehart, J. Rudolph, and M.C.M. Pian-Smith et al. Improving faculty feedback to resident trainees during a simulated case: a randomized, controlled trial of an educational intervention Anesthesiology 120 2014 160 171
35. J.R.J. Larson, P.G. Foster-Fishman, and T.M. Franz Leadership style and the discussion of shared and unshared information in decision-making groups Pers Soc Psychol Bull 24 1998 482 495
36. J.R. Mesmer-Magnus, and L.A. DeChurch Information sharing and team performance: a meta-analysis J Appl Psychol 94 2009 535 546
37. J.R.K. Kelly, and J. Steven Group decision making: the effects of initial preferences and time pressure Pers Soc Psychol Bull 25 1999 1342 1354
38. T. Greitemeyer, and S. Schulz-Hardt Preference-consistent evaluation of information in the hidden profile paradigm: beyond group-level explanations for the dominance of shared information in group decisions J Pers Soc Psychol 84 2003 322 339
39. A.C. Edmondson Speaking up in the operating room: how team leaders promote learning in interdisciplinary action teams J Management Stud 40 2003 1419 1452
40. J.R. Detert, and A. Edmondson Implicit voice theories: taken-for-granted rules of self-censorship at work Acad Manage J 54 2011 461 488
41. A.C. Edmondson Teaming: how organizations learn, innovate, and compete in the knowledge economy 2012 Jossey-Bass San Francisco, CA
42. J.W. Rudolph, D.B. Raemer, and R. Simon Establishing a safe container for learning in simulation: the role of the pre-simulation briefing Simul Healthc. 9 6 2014 339 349
43. J.W. Rudolph, F.B. Simon, and D.B. Raemer et al. Debriefing as formative assessment: closing performance gaps in medical education Acad Emerg Med 15 2008 1010 1016
44. A. Cheng, D.L. Rodgers, and E. van der Jagt et al. Evolution of the pediatric advanced life support course: enhanced learning with a new debriefing tool and web-based module for pediatric advanced life support instructors Crit Care Med 13 2012 589 595
45. M. Kolbe, G. Grote, and M.J. Waller et al. Monitoring and talking to the room: autochthonous coordination patterns in team interaction and performance J Appl Psychol 99 2014 1254 1267
46. Grande B, Weiss M, Biro P, et al. Ist Reden wichtig? Technisches versus kombiniert technisches/nicht-technisches Atemwegstraining in der Anästhesie und Intensivmedizin. Anästhesiologie & Intensivmedizin. [in press].
47. S. Arora, M. Ahmed, and J. Paige et al. Objective structured assessment of debriefing (OSAD): bringing science to the art of debriefing in surgery Ann Surg 256 2012 982 988
48. R. Simon, D.B. Raemer, and J.W. Rudolph Debriefing assessment for simulation in healthcare (DASH) Rater's handbook 2010 The Center For Medical Simulation Boston, MA
49. A.J. Ross, J.E. Anderson, and N. Kodate et al. Simulation training for improving the quality of care for older people: an independent evaluation of an innovative programme for inter-professional education BMJ Qual Saf 22 2013 June 1 495 505
50. K.A. Ericsson Deliberate practice and acquisition of expert performance: a general overview Acad Emerg Med 15 2008 Nov 988 994
51. L.K. McDonnell, K.K. Jobe, and R.K. Dismukes Facilitating LOS debriefings. A training manual 1997 National Aeronautics and Space Administration: NASA Technical Memorandum 112192
52. R. Gardner Introduction to debriefing Semin Perinatol 37 2013 166 174
53. W. Liu, S. Tangirala, and R. Ramanujam The relational antecedents of voice targeted at different leaders J Appl Psychol 98 2013 841 851 2014-06-13
54. I.M. Nembhard, and A.C. Edmondson Making it safe: the effects of leader inclusiveness and professional status on psychological safety and improvement efforts in health care teams J Organ Behav 27 2006 941 966
55. S.E. Husebø, P. Dieckmann, and H. Rystedt et al. The relationship between facilitators' questions and the level of reflection in postsimulation debriefing Simul Healthc 8 2013 135 142
56. G.L. Savoldelli, V.N. Naik, and J. Park et al. Value of debriefing during simulated crisis management: oral versus video-assisted oral feedback Anesthesiology 105 2006 279 285
57. W.C. Kriz A systemic-constructivist approach to the facilitation and debriefing of simulations and games Simul Gaming 41 2010 663 680
58. P. Dieckmann, T. Manser, and T. Wehner et al. Reality and fiction cues in medical patient simulation: an interview study with anesthesiologists J Cognitive Eng Decis Mak 1 2007 148 168
59. P. Dieckmann, S. Molin Friis, and A. Lippert et al. The art and science of debriefing in simulation: Ideal and practice Med Teach 31 2009 e287 e294
60. M.A. Marks, J.E. Mathieu, and S.J. Zaccaro A temporally based framework and taxonomy of team processes Acad Manage Rev 26 2001 356 376
61. C.J.G. Gersick Marking time: predictable transitions in task groups Acad Manage J 32 1989 274 309
62. A. Gurtner, F. Tschan, and N.-K. Semmer et al. Getting groups to develop good strategies: effects of reflexivity interventions on team process, team performance, and shared mental models Organ Behav Hum Decis Process 102 2007 127 142
63. K.A. Smith-Jentsch, J.A. Cannon-Bowers, and S. Tannenbaum et al. Guided team self-correction: Impacts on team mental models, processes, and effectiveness Small Group Res 39 2008 303 329
64. R.K. Dismukes, L.K. McDonnell, and K.K. Jobe et al. What is facilitation and why use it R.K. Dismukes, G.M. Smith, Facilitation and debriefing in aviation training and operations 2000 Ashgate Aldershot, UK 1 12
65. S. Ellis, and I. Davidi After-event reviews: drawing lessons from successful and failed experience J Appl Psychol 90 2005 857 871
66. D. McLain Smith The elephant in the room. How relationships make or break the success of leaders and organizations 2011 Jossey-Bass San Francisco, CA
67. P. Dieckmann, D.M. Gaba, and M. Rall Deepening the theoretical foundations of patient simulation as social practice Simul Healthc 2 2007 183 193
68. S. Minuchin, M.P. Nichols, and W.-Y. Lee Assessing families and couples: from symptom to system 2007 Pearson Boston
69. M. Palazzoli Selvini, L. Boscolo, and G. Cecchin et al. Hypothesizing-Circularity-Neutrality: three guidelines for the conductor of the session Fam Process 19 1980 3 12
70. M. Diorinou, and E. Tseliou Studying circular questioning "in situ": discourse analysis of a first systemic family therapy session J Marital Fam Ther 40 2014 106 121
71. K. Tomm Interventive interviewing: Part 1. Strategizing as a forth guideline for the therapist Fam Process 26 1987 3 13
72. C. Fleuridas, T.S. Nelson, and D.M. Rosenthal The evolution of circular questions: training family therapists J Marital Fam Ther 12 1986 113 127
73. K. Tomm Interventive interviewing: Part 11. Reflexive questioning as a means to enable self-healing Fam Process 26 1987 167 183
74. L. Ross, D. Greene, and P. House The "false consensus effect": an egocentric bias in social perception and attribution processes J Exp Social Psychol 5// 13 1977 279 301
75. R. Kegan, and L.L. Lahey How the way we talk can change the way we work 2001 Jossey-Bass San Francisco
76. S.I. Tannenbaum, and C.P. Cerasoli Do team and individual debriefs enhance performance? A meta-analysis Hum Factors 55 2013 February 1 231 245
77. S.C. Papaspyros, K.C. Javangula, and R.K. Prasad Adluri et al. Briefing and debriefing in the cardiac operating room. Analysis of impact on theatre team attitude and patient safety Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 10 2010 January 1 43 47
78. S. Ellis, R. Mendel, and M. Aloni-Zohar The effect of accuracy of performance evaluation on learning from experience: the moderating role of After-Event Reviews JÂ Appl Soc Psychol 39 2009 541 563
79. S. Ellis, Y. Ganzach, and E. Castle et al. The effect of filmed versus personal after-event reviews on task performance: the mediating and moderating role of self-efficacy J Appl Psychol 95 2010 122 131
80. D.S. DeRue, J.D. Nahrgang, and J.R. Hollenbeck et al. AÂ quasi-experimental study of after-event reviews and leadership development J Appl Psychol 97 2012 997 1015
81. A.J. Villado, and W. Arthur Jr. The comparative effect of subjective and objective after-action reviews on team performance on a complex task J Appl Psychol 98 2013 514 528
82. R. Welter-Enderlin Deine Liebe ist nicht meine Liebe. Partnerprobleme und Lösungsmodelle aus systemischer Sicht 2005 Junfermann Verlag Paderborn