Mandatory Calorie Disclosure: A Comprehensive Analysis of Its Effect on Consumers and Retailers

Journal of Retailing

Volumn 94, Issue 1, 2018, Pages 89-101

  Zlatevska, Natalina ^a   Neumann, Nico ^b   Dubelaar, Chris ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY SYDNEY   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE   (Australia)

^c DEAKIN UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

Author keywords

Calorie labels; Mandatory disclosure; Meta analysis

Indexed keywords

EID: 85033411617     PISSN: 00224359     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jretai.2017.09.007     Document Type: Article

References (82)

1. *Aaron, Jacqueline I., Evans, Rhian E., Mela, David J., Paradoxical Effect of a Nutrition Labelling Scheme in a Student Cafeteria. Nutrition Research 15:9 (1995), 1251–1261.
2. *Bassett, Mary T., Dumanovsky, Tamara, Huang, Christina, Silver, Lynn D., Young, Candace, Nonas, Cathy, Matte, Thomas D., Chideya, Sekai, Frieden, Thomas R., Purchasing Behavior and Calorie Information at Fast-food Chains in New York City, 2007. American Journal of Public Health 98:8 (2008), 1457–1459.
3. Binks, Martin, The Role of the Food Industry in Obesity Prevention. Current Obesity Reports 5:2 (2016), 201–207.
4. *Bleich, Sara N., Wolfson, Julia A., Jarlenski, Marian P., Calorie Changes in Chain Restaurant Menu Items: Implications for Obesity and Evaluations of Menu Labeling. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 48:1 (2015), 70–75.
5. *Bleich, Sara N., Wolfson, Julia A., Jarlenski, Marian P., Block, Jason P., Restaurants with Calories Displayed on Menus Had Lower Calorie Counts Compared to Restaurants without Such Labels. Health Affairs 34:11 (2015), 1877–1884.
6. *Bleich, Sara N., Wolfson, Julia A., Jarlenski, Marian P., Calorie Changes in Large Chain Restaurants: Declines in New Menu Items but Room for Improvement. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 50:1 (2016), e1–e8.
7. *Bollinger, Bryan, Leslie, Phillip, Sorensen, Alan, Calorie Posting in Chain Restaurants. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 3:1 (2011), 91–128.
8. Bond, Charles F. Jr., Wiitala, Wyndy L., Richard, F. Dan, Meta-analysis of Raw Mean Differences. Psychological Methods, 8(4), 2003, 406.
9. Burton, Scot, Cook, Laurel Aynne, Howlett, Elizabeth, Newman, Christopher L., Broken Halos and Shattered Horns: Overcoming the Biasing Effects of Prior Expectations Through Objective Information Disclosure. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science 43:2 (2015), 240–256.
10. Burton, Scot, Creyer, Elizabeth H., Kees, Jeremy, Huggins, Kyle, Attacking the Obesity Epidemic: The Potential Health Benefits of Providing Nutrition Information in Restaurants. American Journal of Public Health 96:9 (2006), 1669–1675.
11. Burton, Scot, Kees, Jeremy, Flies in the Ointment? Addressing Potential Impediments to Population-based Health Benefits of Restaurant Menu Labeling Initiatives. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 31:2 (2012), 232–239.
12. Chandon, Pierre, Wansink, Brian, The Biasing Health Halos of Fast-food Restaurant Health Claims: Lower Calorie Estimates and Higher Side-dish Consumption Intentions. Journal of Consumer Research 34:3 (2007), 301–314.
13. Clarke, Tainya C., Ward, Brian W., Freeman, Gulnur, Schiller, Jeannine S., Early Release of Selected Estimates Based on Data from the January-September 2015 National Health Interview Survey. 2016, National Centre for Health Statistics.
14. Davis-Chervin, Doryn, Rogers, Todd, Clark, Mia, Influencing Food Selection with Point-of-Choice Nutrition Information. Journal of Nutrition Education 17:1 (1985), 18–22.
15. *DerSimonian, Rebecca, Laird, Nan, Meta-analysis in Clinical Trials. Controlled Clinical Trials 7:3 (1986), 177–188.
16. Dobbs, Richard, Sawers, Corinne, Thompson, Fraser, Manyika, James, Woetzel, Jonathan, Child, Peter, McKenna, Sorcha, Spatharou, Angela, Overcoming Obesity: An Initial Economic Analysis. 2014, McKinsey Global Institute (November), p. 120.
17. *Dodds, Pennie, Wolfenden, Luke, Chapman, Kathy, Wellard, Lyndal, Hughes, Clare, Wiggers, John, The Effect of Energy and Traffic Light Labelling on Parent and Child Fast Food Selection: a Randomised Controlled Trial. Appetite 73 (2014), 23–30.
18. Downs, Julie S., Wisdom, Jessica, Loewenstein, George, Helping Consumers Use Nutrition Information: Effects of Format and Presentation. American Journal of Health Economics 1:3 (2015), 326–344.
19. Driskell, Mary-Margaret, Dyment, Sharon, Mauriello, Leanne, Castle, Patricia, Sherman, Karen, Relationships Among Multiple Behaviors for Childhood and Adolescent Obesity Prevention. Preventive Medicine 46:3 (2008), 209–215.
20. *Dumanovsky, Tamara, Huang, Christina Y., Nonas, Cathy A., Matte, Thomas D., Bassett, Mary T., Silver, Lynn D., Changes in Energy Content of Lunchtime Purchases from Fast Food Restaurants after Introduction of Calorie Labelling: Cross Sectional Customer Surveys. BMJ, 343, 2011, d4464.
21. *Elbel, Brian, Gyamfi, Joyce, Kersh, Rogan, Child and Adolescent Fast-food Choice and the Influence of Calorie Labeling: A Natural Experiment. International Journal of Obesity 35:4 (2011), 493–500.
22. *Elbel, Brian, Mijanovich, Tod, Dixon, L. Beth, Abrams, Courtney, Weitzman, Beth, Kersh, Rogan, Auchincloss, Amy H., Ogedegbe, Gbenga, Calorie Labeling, Fast Food Purchasing and Restaurant Visits. Obesity 21:11 (2013), 2172–2179.
23. ERS Food Expenditure Series, Economic Research Services (US). 2016 https://www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-expenditures.aspx.
24. FDA, Food Labeling: Nutrition Labeling of Standard Menu Items in Restaurants and Similar Retail Food Establishments Final Regulatory Impact Analysis FDA–2011–F–0172. 2014 https://www.fda.gov/downloads/Food/IngredientsPackagingLabeling/LabelingNutrition/UCM423985.pdf.
25. Fernandes, Ana C., Oliveira, Renata C., Proença, Rossana P.C., Curioni, Cintia C., Rodrigues, Vanessa M., Fiates, Giovanna MR, Influence of Menu Labeling on Food Choices in Real-life Settings: A Systematic Review. Nutrition Reviews 74:8 (2016), 534–548.
26. *Finkelstein, Eric A., Strombotne, Kiersten L., Chan, Nadine L., Krieger, James, Mandatory Menu Labeling in One Fast-food Chain in King County, Washington. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 40:2 (2011), 122–127.
27. Fotouhinia-Yepes, Maryam, Menu Calorie Labelling in a Fine Dining Restaurant: Will it Make a Difference?. Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality and Tourism 14:3 (2013), 281–293.
28. Freedman, Marjorie R., Connors, Rachel, Point-of-purchase Nutrition Information Influences Food-purchasing Behaviors of College Students: A Pilot Study. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 111:5 (2011), S42–S46.
29. *Girz, Laura, Polivy, Janet, Herman, C. Peter, Lee, Helen, The effects of calorie information on food selection and intake. International Journal of Obesity 36:10 (2012), 1340–1345.
30. *Hammond, David, Goodman, Samantha, Hanning, Rhona, Daniel, Samantha, A Randomized Trial of Calorie Labeling on Menus. Preventive Medicine 57:6 (2013), 860–866.
31. Harnack, Lisa J., French, Simone A., Effect of Point-of-purchase Calorie Labeling on Restaurant and Cafeteria Food Choices: A Review of the Literature. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 5(1), 2008, 51.
32. Hill, James O., Wyatt, Holly R., Reed, George W., Peters, John C., Obesity and the environment: where do we go from here?. Science 299:5608 (2003), 853–855.
33. *Hoefkens, Christine, Lachat, Carl, Kolsteren, Patrick, Van Camp, John, Verbeke, Wim, Posting Point-of-purchase Nutrition Information in University Canteens Does Not Influence Meal Choice and Nutrient Intake. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 94:2 (2011), 562–570.
34. Holden, Stephen, Zlatevska, Natalina, Dubelaar, Chris, Whether Smaller Plates Reduce Consumption Depends on Who's Serving and Who's Looking: A Meta-Analysis. The Journal of the Association of Consumer Research 1:1 (2016), 134–146.
35. *Holmes, Ashley S., Serrano, Elena L., Machin, Jane E., Duetsch, Thomas, Davis, George C., Effect of Different Children's Menu Labeling Designs on Family Purchases. Appetite 62 (2013), 198–202.
36. Hwang, Johye, Lorenzen, Carol L., Effective Nutrition Labeling of Restaurant Menu and Pricing of Healthy Menu. Journal of Foodservice 19:5 (2008), 270–276.
37. *James, Ashlei, Adams-Huet, Beverley, Shah, Meena, Menu Labels Displaying the Kilocalorie Content or the Exercise Equivalent: Effects on Energy Ordered and Consumed in Young Adults. American Journal of Health Promotion 29:5 (2015), 294–302.
38. Janakiraman, Narayan, Syrdal, Holly A., Freling, Ryan, The Effect of Return Policy Leniency on Consumer Purchase and Return Decisions: A Meta-analytic Review. Journal of Retailing 92:2 (2016), 226–235.
39. *Krieger, James W., Chan, Nadine L., Saelens, Brian E., Ta, Myduc L., Solet, David, Fleming, David W., Menu Labeling Regulations and Calories Purchased at Chain Restaurants. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 44:6 (2013), 595–604.
40. Larson, Nicole, Story, Mary, A Review of Environmental Influences on Food Choices. Annals of Behavioral Medicine 38 (2009), 56–73.
41. Lazareva, Yulia, Can Nutrition Menu Labelling Positively Influence Consumer Food Choices? A Review of the Literature. Surrey Undergraduate Research Journal, 1(1), 2015.
42. *Lee, Morgan S., Thompson, Joel Kevin, Exploring Enhanced Menu Labels’ Influence on Fast Food Selections and Exercise-related Attitudes, Perceptions, and Intentions. Appetite 105 (2016), 416–422.
43. Levin, Sarah, Pilot Study of a Cafeteria Program Relying Primarily on Symbols to Promote Healthy Choices. Journal of Nutrition Education 28:5 (1996), 282–285.
44. Littlewood, Jodie Anne, Lourenço, Sofia, Iversen, Cecilie Lauberg, Hansen, Gitte Laub, Menu Labelling is Effective in Reducing Energy Ordered and Consumed: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Recent Studies. Public Health Nutrition 19:12 (2016), 2106–2121.
45. *Liu, Peggy J., Roberto, Christina A., Liu, Linda J., Brownell, Kelly D., A Test of Different Menu Labeling Presentations. Appetite 59:3 (2012), 770–777.
46. Long, Michael W., Tobias, Deirdre K., Cradock, Angie L., Batchelder, Holly, Gortmaker, Steven L., Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of the Impact of Restaurant Menu Calorie Labeling. American Journal of Public Health(May), 2015.
47. Mayer, Joni A., Brown, Timothy P., Heins, Joan M., Bishop, Donald B., A Multi-component Intervention for Modifying Food Selections in a Worksite Cafeteria. Journal of Nutrition Education 19:6 (1987), 277–280.
48. Moorman, Christine, Ferraro, Rosellina, Huber, Joel, Unintended Nutrition Consequences: Firm Responses to the Nutrition Labeling and Education Act. Marketing Science 31:5 (2012), 717–737.
49. *Morley, Belinda, Scully, Maree, Martin, Jane, Niven, Philippa, Dixon, Helen, Wakefield, Melanie, What Types of Nutrition Menu Labelling Lead Consumers to Select Less Energy-dense Fast Food? An Experimental Study. Appetite 67 (2013), 8–15.
50. *Namba, Alexa, Auchincloss, Amy, Leonberg, Beth L., Wootan, Margo G., Peer Reviewed: Exploratory Analysis of Fast-Food Chain Restaurant Menus Before and After Implementation of Local Calorie-Labeling Policies, 2005–2011. Preventing Chronic Disease, 10, 2013, E101.
51. National Restaurant Association (2017), http://www.restaurant.org/News-Research/Research/Facts-at-a-Glance.
52. Neumann, Nico, Böckenholt, Ulf, A Meta-analysis of Loss Aversion in Product Choice. Journal of Retailing 90:2 (2014), 182–197.
53. Neumann, Nico, Böckenholt, Ulf, Sinha, Ashish, A Meta-analysis of Extremeness Aversion. Journal of Consumer Psychology 26:2 (2016), 193–212.
54. *Platkin, Charles, Yeh, Ming-Chin, Hirsch, Kimberly, Wiewel, Ellen Weiss, Lin, Chang-Yun, Tung, Ho-Jui, Castellanos, Victoria H., The Effect of Menu Labeling with Calories and Exercise Equivalents on Food Selection and Consumption. BMC Obesity, 1(1), 2014, 21.
55. Powell, Lisa M., Nguyen, Binh T., Han, Euna, Energy Intake from Restaurants: Demographics and Socioeconomics, 2003–2008. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 43:5 (2012), 498–504.
56. *Pulos, Elizabeth, Leng, Kirsten, Evaluation of a Voluntary Menu-labeling Program in Full-service Restaurants. American Journal of Public Health 100:6 (2010), 1035–1039.
57. *Rainville, Alice Jo, Choi, Kyunghee, Ragg, D. Mark, King, Amber, Carr, Deborah H., Nutrition Information at the Point of Selection in High Schools Does Not Affect Purchases. Journal of Child Nutrition and Management, 34(2), 2010.
58. *Reale, Sophie, Flint, Stuart W., Menu Labelling and Food Choice in Obese Adults: a Feasibility Study. BMC Obesity, 3(1), 2016, 17.
59. Roberto, Christina A., Schwartz, Marlene B., Brownell, Kelly D., Rationale and Evidence for Menu-labeling Legislation. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 37:6 (2009), 546–551.
60. *Roberto, Christina A., Larsen, Peter D., Agnew, Henry, Baik, Jenny, Brownell, Kelly D., Evaluating the Impact of Menu Labeling on Food Choices and Intake. American Journal of Public Health 100:2 (2010), 312–318.
61. Rosenthal, Robert, DiMatteo, M. Robin, Meta-analysis: Recent Developments in Quantitative Methods for Literature Reviews. Annual Review of Psychology 52:1 (2001), 59–82.
62. *Schwartz, Janet, Riis, Jason, Elbel, Brian, Ariely, Dan, Inviting Consumers to Downsize Fast-food Portions Significantly Reduces Calorie Consumption. Health Affairs 31:2 (2012), 399–407.
63. *Seenivasan, Satheesh, Thomas, Dominic, Negative Consequences of Nutrition Information Disclosure on Consumption Behavior in Quick-casual Restaurants. Journal of Economic Psychology 55 (2016), 51–60.
64. Sharma, Shilpa, Wagle, Ashwini, Sucher, Kathryn, Bugwadia, Nancy, Impact of Point of Selection Nutrition Information on Meal Choices at a Table-service Restaurant. Journal of Foodservice Business Research 14:2 (2011), 146–161.
65. Sinclair, Susan E., Cooper, Marcia, Mansfield, Elizabeth D., The Influence of Menu Labeling on Calories Selected or Consumed: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics 114:9 (2014), 1375–1388.
66. Sterne, Jonathan A.C., Egger, Matthias, Funnel Plots for Detecting Bias in Meta-analysis: Guidelines on Choice of Axis. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 54:10 (2001), 1046–1055.
67. Swartz, Jonas J., Braxton, Danielle, Viera, Anthony J., Calorie Menu Labeling on Quick-service Restaurant Menus: An Updated Systematic Review of the Literature. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 8(1), 2011, 135.
68. *Tandon, Pooja S., Zhou, Chuan, Chan, Nadine L., Lozano, Paula, Couch, Sarah C., Glanz, Karen, Krieger, James, Saelens, Brian E., The Impact of Menu Labeling on Fast-food Purchases for Children and Parents. American Journal of Preventive Medicine 41:4 (2011), 434–438.
69. *Temple, Jennifer L., Johnson, Karena, Recupero, Kelly, Suders, Heather, Nutrition Labels Decrease Energy Intake in Adults Consuming Lunch in the Laboratory. Journal of the American Dietetic Association 111:5 (2011), S52–S55.
70. *Temple, Jennifer L., Johnson, Karena M., Archer, Kelli, LaCarte, Allison, Yi, Christina, Epstein, Leonard H., Influence of Simplified Nutrition Labeling and Taxation on Laboratory Energy Intake in Adults. Appetite 57:1 (2011), 184–192.
71. Thompson, Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0. 2002.
72. *Vanderlee, Lana, Hammond, David, Does Nutrition Information on Menus Impact Food Choice? Comparisons Across Two Hospital Cafeterias. Public Health Nutrition 17:6 (2014), 1393–1402.
73. VanEpps, Eric M., Downs, Julie S., Loewenstein, George, Calorie Label Formats: Using Numeric and Traffic Light Calorie Labels to Reduce Lunch Calories. Journal of Public Policy and Marketing 35:1 (2016), 26–36.
74. VanEpps, Eric M., Roberto, Christina A., Park, Sara, Economos, Christina D., Bleich, Sara N., Restaurant Menu Labeling Policy: Review of Evidence and Controversies. Current Obesity Reports, 5(1), 2016, 72.
75. Viechtbauer, Wolfgang, Conducting Meta-Analyses in R with the Metafor Package. Journal of Statistical Software 36:3 (2010), 1–48.
76. Vyth, Ellis L., Steenhuis, Ingrid H.M., Roodenburg, Annet J.C., Brug, Johannes, Seidell, Jacob C., Front-of-pack Nutrition Label Stimulates Healthier Product Development: A Quantitative Analysis. International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity, 7(1), 2010, 65.
77. Wansink, Brian, Healthy Profits: An Interdisciplinary Retail Framework that Increases the Sales of Healthy Foods. Journal of Retailing 93:1 (2017), 65–78.
78. Webb, Karen L., Solomon, Loel S., Sanders, Jan, Akiyama, Carol, Crawford, Patricia B., Menu Labeling Responsive to Consumer Concerns and Shows Promise for Changing Patron Purchases. Journal of Hunger and Environmental Nutrition 6:2 (2011), 166–178.
79. *Yamamoto, Julienne A., Yamamoto, Joelle B., Yamamoto, Brennan E., Yamamoto, Loren G., Adolescent Fast Food and Restaurant Ordering Behavior with and without Calorie and Fat Content Menu Information. Journal of Adolescent Health 37:5 (2005), 397–402.
80. Yusuf, Salim, Wittes, Janet, Probstfield, Jeffrey, Tyroler, Herman A., Analysis and Interpretation of Treatment Effects in Subgroups of Patients in Randomized Clinical Trials. JAMA 266:1 (1991), 93–98.
81. Zlatevska, Natalina, Chris, Dubelaar, Stephen, Holden, Sizing up the Effect of Portion Size on Consumption: A Meta-Analytic Review. Journal of Marketing 78:3 (2014), 140–154.
82. WHO, Obesity and Overweight, Fact Sheet N°311. 2016 available at: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs311/en.