Systems Theory and Thinking as a Foundational Theory in Human Resource Development-A Myth or Reality?

Human Resource Development Review

Volumn 12, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 53-85

  Yawson, Robert M ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA   (United States)

Author keywords

complexity theory; curricula; epistemology; learning; systems dynamics; systems thinking

Indexed keywords

EID: 84873684894     PISSN: 15344843     EISSN: 15526712     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1534484312461634     Document Type: Review

References (127)

1. Bowling Green, OH: Academy of Human Resource Development; 2007:.
2. Standards for HRD graduate program excellence. Saint Paul, MN: Academic Standards Committee of the Academy of Human Resource Development (AHRD); 2008:.
3. AHRD. (2009). Academic programs in HRD. St. Paul, MN: Program Excellence Network (PEN), Academy of Human Resource Development (AHRD). Retrieved from http://www.ahrd.org/displaycommon.cfm?an=1&subarticlenbr=10.
4. Ardichvili A.Can there be a domain-specific knowledge base in HRD? Reflections on the Lille symposium.Human Resource Development International. 2008;11:539-544.
5. Bánáthy B. H.Designing social systems in a changing world (contemporary systems thinking). New York, NY: Kluwer Academic (Springer); 1996:.
6. Bánáthy B. H.Guided evolution of society: A systems view (contemporary systems thinking). New York, NY: Kluwer Academic (Springer); 2000:.
7. Bierema L. L.,Eraut M.Workplace-focused learning: Perspective on continuing professional education and human resource development.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2004;6 (1): 52-68.
8. BoazA.AshbyD.YoungK. (2002). Systematic reviews: What have they got to offer evidence based policy and practice?London, UK: Evidence Based Policy and Practice. Retrieved from http://kcl.ac.uk/content/1/c6/03/45/85/wp2.pdf.
9. Brookfield S.Developing criteria for formal theory building in adult education.Adult Education Quarterly. 1992;42 (2): 79-93.
10. Callahan J. L.Constructing a manuscript: Distinguishing integrative literature reviews and conceptual and theory articles.Human Resource Development Review. 2010;9:300-304.
11. Chalofsky N.A unifying definition for the human resource development profession.Human Resource Development Quarterly. 1992;3:175-182.
12. Checkland P.,Scholes J.Soft Systems methodology in action. Chichester, UK: Wiley; 1990:.
13. CookD. J.MulrowC. D.HaynesR. B. (1997). Systematic reviews: Synthesis of best evidence for clinical decisions. Annals of Internal Medicine, 126, 376-380. Retrieved from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9054282.
14. Systematic reviews: CRD's guidance for undertaking reviews in health care. University of York, Layerthorpe, York, UK: York Publishing Services; 2009:.
15. Daley B. J.,Jeris L.Boundary spanning.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2004;6 (1): 5-8.
16. Davies P.The relevance of systematic reviews to educational policy and practice.Oxford Review of Education. 2000;26:365-378.
17. Davies P.Developing educational leadership. Anderson L.Bennett N., ed. London, UK: SAGE; 2003:25-36.
18. Ditto W.,Munakata T.Principles and applications of chaotic systems.Communications of the ACM. 1995;38 (11): 96-102.
19. Dixon-Woods M.Systematic reviews 1: ESRC methods festival. Oxford, UK: EPPI-Centre, Social Science Research Unit, Institute of Education, University of London; 2006:26.
20. Dixon-Woods M.,Agarwal S.,Jones D.,Young B.,Sutton A.Synthesizing qualitative and quantitative evidence: A review of possible methods.Journal of Health Services Research Policy. 2005;10 (1): 45-53.
21. Engel P. G. H.The social organization of innovation. A focus on stakeholder interaction. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: KIT Press; 1997:.
22. EPPI-centre methods for conducting systematic reviews. Evidence for Policy and Practice. London, UK: EPPI-Centre, Social Science Research Unit, Institute of Education, University of London; 2010:27.
23. Garavan T. N.,Heraty N.,Barnicle B.Human resource development literature: Current issues, priorities and dilemmas.Journal of European Industrial Training. 1999;23:169-179.
24. Gasteen M.Research and evidence division systematic review program. Systematic review program. London, UK: DFID; 2010:1-3.
25. Goodwin G. M.,Geddes J. R.Introduction to systematic reviews.Journal of psychopharmacology. 2004;18:249-250.
26. Grieves J.Organizational change: Themes and issues. 2010). Organizational change: Themes and issues (1st ed.). New York, NY: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-921488-4.New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2010:.
27. Harden A.,Thomas J.Methodological issues in combining diverse study types in systematic reviews.International Journal of Social Research Methodology. 2005;8:257-271.
28. Hartshorn G. R.Systems theory applied to human resource development. Gradous D. B., ed. Alexandria, VA: American Society for Training and Development; 1989:83-90.
29. Hemingway P.,Brereton N.What is a systematic review? Evidence-based medicine. 2009). What is a systematic review? Evidence-based medicine (2nd ed., pp. 1-8). Sheffield, UK: Hayward Medical Communications.Sheffield, UK: Hayward Medical Communications; 2009:1-8.
30. HeylighenF. (2000). Cybernetics and systems theory. In, HeylighenF.JoslynC.TurchinV. (Eds.), Principia cybernetica web. Brussels, Belgium: Principia Cybernetica. Retrieved from http://cleamc11.vub.ac.be/cybsysth.html.
31. HeylighenF.JoslynC.TurchinV. (Eds.). (2000). Principia cybernetica web. Brussels, Belgium: Principia Cybernetica. Retrieved from http://cleamc11.vub.ac.be/cybsysth.html.
32. Hickman G. R.Leading change in multiple contexts: Concepts and practices in organizational, community, political, social, and global change settings. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE; 2010:.
33. HigginsJ. P. T.GreenS. (Eds.). (2009). Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Version 5.0.2. The Cochrane Collaboration. Retrieved from: www.cochrane-handbook.org.
34. Holton E. F.Performance domains and their boundaries.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 1999;1:26-46.
35. Houchin K.,MacLean D.Complexity theory and strategic change: an empirically informed critique.British Journal of Management. 2005;16 (2): 149-166.
36. Iles P.,Yolles M.HRD in a complex world, studies in human resource development. Lee M., ed. Oxford, UK: Routledge; 2003:25-41.
37. Jacobs R.Systems theory applied to human resource development, theory to practice monograph. Gradous D., ed. Alexandria, VA: ASTD Press; 1989:27-60.
38. Jayanti E. B.Through a different lens: A survey of linear epistemological assumptions underlying HRD models.Human Resource Development Review. 2011;10 (1): 101-114.
39. Kuchinke K. P.Why HRD is not an academic discipline.Human Resource Development International. 2001;4:291-294.
40. Kuchinke K. P.Institutional and curricular characteristics of leading graduate HRD programs in the U.S.Human Resource Development Quarterly. 2002;13 (2): 127-144.
41. Kuchinke K. P.Theorizing and practicing HRD: Extending the dialogue over the roles of scholarship and practice in the field.Human Resource Development International. 2004;7:535-539.
42. Kuchinke K. P.Birds of a feather? The critique of the North American Business School and its implications for educating HRD practitioners.Human Resource Development Review. 2007;6 (2): 111-126.
43. Lee M. M.HRD in a complex world. Lee M. M., ed. London, UK: Routledge; 2003:7-24.
44. Levy D.Chaos theory and strategy: Theory, application, and managerial implications.Strategic Management Journal. 1994;15:167-178.
45. McGuire D.,Cseh M.The development of the field of HRD: A Delphi study.Journal of European Industrial Training. 2006;30:653-667.
46. McKelvey B.Avoiding complexity catastrophe in coevolutionary pockets: Strategies for rugged landscapes.Organization Science. 1999;10:294-321.
47. McLagan P. A.Systems theory applied to human resource development. Gradous D. B., ed. Alexandria, VA: American Society for Training and Development; 1989:65-86.
48. McLean G. N.Get out the drill, glue and more legs.Human Resource Development International. 1999;2 (1): 6-7.
49. Mehta M. D. Paper presented at the International Workshop on Science, Technology and Society: Lessons and Challenges; 2002National University of Singapore, Singapore; 2002.
50. Morgan P.The idea and practice of systems thinking and their relevance for capacity development. Maastricht, The Netherlands: European Centre for Development Policy Management; 2005:.
51. Making systematic reviews work for international development research. Briefing Paper 1: Researching livelihoods and services affected by conflict. London, UK: Overseas Development Institute (ODI); 2012:4.
52. Ossimitz G.Development of systemic thinking. München, Germany: Profil; 2000:.
53. Passmore D. L.Human resource development research handbook. Swanson R. A.Holton E. F., ed. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler; 1997:114-137.
54. Petticrew M.Systematic reviews from astronomy to zoology: Myths and misconceptions.BMJ (Clinical research ed.). 2001;322:98-101.
55. Petticrew M.,Roberts H.Systematic reviews in the social sciences: A practical guide. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing; 2006:.
56. Pope C.,Mays N.,Popay J.Synthesizing qualitative and quantitative health evidence: A guide to methods. Maidenhead, UK: Open University Press; 2007:.
57. Porter L.,Schoeneck D.,Frey P.,Hicks D. M.,Libaers D. P.Mining the Internet for competitive technical intelligence.Competitive Intelligence Magazine. 2007;10 (5): 24-28.
58. Raelin J. A.Toward an epistemology of practice.The Academy of Management Learning and Education. 2007;6:495-519.
59. RichardsonG. P. (2012). GPR home page. Albany, NY: Courses. Retrieved from http://www.albany.edu/~gpr/Courses.html.
60. Richmond B.Systems thinking: Critical thinking skills for the 1990s and beyond.System Dynamics Review. 1993;9 (2): 113-133.
61. Roth G. L.CPE and HRD: Research and practice within systems and across boundaries.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2004;6 (1): 9-19.
62. Ruona W. E. A.Foundations of human resource development. 2008). Systems theory as a foundation for human resource development. In SwansonR. A.HoltonE. F.III, Foundations of human resource development (2nd Ed, pp. 128-136). San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers.Swanson R. A.Holton E. F., ed. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers; 2008:128-136.
63. Schneider M.,Somers M.Organizations as complex adaptive systems: Implications of complexity theory for leadership research.The Leadership Quarterly. 2006;17:351-365.
64. Senge P.,Smith B.,Kruschwitz N.,Laur J.,Schley S.The necessary revolution. New York, NY: Crown Publishing Group; 2010:.
65. Short D. C.Closing the gap between research and practice in HRD.Human Resource Development Quarterly. 2006;17:343-350.
66. Short D. C.,Keefer J.,Stone S. J.The link between research and practice: Experiences of HRD and other professions.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2009;11:420-437.
67. Sterman J.Business dynamics-Systems thinking and modeling for a complex world. Boston, MA: Irwin McGraw-Hill; 2000:.
68. Sterman J. D.System dynamics modeling: Tools for learning in a complex world.California management review. 2001;43 (1): 8-25.
69. Straussfogel D.,von Schilling C.Systems theory International encyclopedia of human geography. 2009). Systems theory. In KitchinR.ThriftN. (Eds.), International encyclopedia of human geography (1st ed., Vol. 1, pp. 151-158). Oxford, UK: Elsevier.Kitchin R.Thrift N., ed. Oxford, UK: Elsevier; 2009:151-158.
70. Swanson R. A.HRD Theory: Real or imagined?.Human Resource Development International. 1999a;2 (1): 2-5.
71. Swanson R. A.The foundations of performance improvement and implications for practice.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 1999b;1:1-25.
72. Swanson R. A.Human resource development and its underlying theory.Human Resource Development International. 2001;4 (3): 299-312.
73. Swanson R. A.Foundations of human resource development. 2008). Foundations of human resource development (2nd ed, pp. 18-19 & 108-109). San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers.San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers; 2008:18 108-19 109.
74. Taleb N.The black swan. New York, NY: Random House; 2007:.
75. Tetenbaum T. J.Shifting paradigms: From Newton to chaos.Organizational Dynamics. 1998;26 (4): 21-32.
76. Thomas J.,Brunton J.,Graziosi S.EPPI-Reviewer 4.0: Software for research synthesis. EPPI-Centre Software. London, UK: Social Science Research Unit, Institute of Education; 2010:.
77. Thomas J.,Harden A.Developing educational leadership. Anderson L.Bennett N., ed. London, UK: SAGE; 2003:39-53.
78. Thomas J.,Harden A.Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews.BMC Medical Research Methodology. 2008;8:45.
79. Torraco R. J.Human resource development research handbook. Swanson R.Holton E., ed. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler; 1997:114-137.
80. Torraco R. J.Writing integrative literature reviews: Guidelines and examples.Human Resource Development Review. 2005;4:356-367.
81. Tranfield D.,Denyer D.,Smart P.Towards a methodology for developing evidence-informed management knowledge by means of systematic review.British Journal of Management. 2003;14:207-222.
82. Vakili K.,Izadi E. F.,Moteabbed S. Proceedings of the 51st annual meeting of the ISSS; 2007Tokyo, Japan; 2007.
83. van der Knaap L. M.,Leeuw F. L.,Bogaerts S.,Nijssen L. T. J.Combining Campbell standards and the realist evaluation approach: The best of two worlds?.American Journal of Evaluation. 2008;29 (1): 48-57.
84. Williams G. P.Chaos theory tamed. Washington, DC: John Henry Press; 1997:.
85. Witten I. H.Adaptive text mining: Inferring structure from sequences.Journal of Discrete Algorithms. 2004;2 (2): 137-159.
86. Wright R. W.,Brand R. A.,Dunn W.,Spindler K. P.How to write a systematic review.Clinical orthopaedics and related research. 2007;455:23-29.
87. Yawson R. M.The future of innovation. Huizingh K. R. EConn S.Torkkeli M.Bitran I., ed. Vienna, Austria: Wiley Higher Education; 2009:.
88. Yawson R. M.,Kuzma J.Systems mapping of consumer acceptance of agrifood nanotechnology.Journal of Consumer Policy. 2010;33:299-322.
89. Yorks L.,Nicolaides A.Complexity and emergent communicative learning: An opportunity for HRD scholarship.Human Resource Development Review. 2006;5 (2): 143-147.
90. Ardichvili A.Can there be a domain-specific knowledge base in HRD? Reflections on the Lille symposium.Human Resource Development International. 2008;11:539-544.
91. Brooks K.,Nafukho F. M.Human resource development, social capital, emotional intelligence: Any link to productivity?.Journal of European Industrial Training. 2006;30 (2): 117-128.
92. Callahan J. L.,De Dávila T. D.An impressionistic framework for theorizing about human resource development.Human Resource Development Review. 2004;3 (1): 75-95.
93. Chalofsky N.The seminal foundation of the discipline of HRD: People, learning, and organizations.Human Resource Development Quarterly. 2007;18:431-442.
94. Chenhall E. C.,Chermack T. J.Models, definitions, and outcome variables of action learning: A synthesis with implications for HRD.Journal of European Industrial Training. 2010;34:588-608.
95. Chermack T. J.,Lynham S. A.Definitions and outcome variables of scenario planning.Human Resource Development Review. 2002;1:366-383.
96. Collin A.Conceptualising the family-friendly career: The contribution of career theories and a systems approach.British Journal of Guidance & Counselling. 2006;34:295-307.
97. Dijk M. S. V.Career development within HRD: Foundation or fad?. Proceedings of the Academy of Human Resource Development Conference, USA; 2004Austin, TX; 2004. 771.
98. Egan T. M.,Upton M. G.,Lynham S. A.Career development: Load-bearing wall or window dressing? Exploring definitions, theories, and prospects for HRD-related theory building.Human Resource Development Review. 2006;5:442-477.
99. Garavan T. N.,Heraty N.,Barnicle B.Human resource development literature: Current issues, priorities and dilemmas.Journal of European Industrial Training. 1999;23:169-179.
100. Systems theory applied to human resource development. Gradous D. B., ed. Alexandria, VA: American Society for Training and Development; 1989:.
101. Harris L.A theory of intellectual capital.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2000;2 (1): 22-37.
102. Iles P.,Yolles M.HRD in a complex world, studies in human resource development. Lee M., ed. Oxford, UK: Routledge; 2003:25-41.
103. Kuchinke K. P.Theorizing and practicing HRD: Extending the dialogue over the roles of scholarship and practice in the field.Human Resource Development International. 2004;7:535-539.
104. Kuchinke K. P.Why HRD is not an academic discipline.Human Resource Development International. 2001;4:291-294.
105. Lee M.CRM conference on critique and inclusivity: Opening the agenda. Gilson C. H. J.Grugulis I.Willmott H., ed. Lancaster, UK:; 2003:1-20.
106. Lynham S.Theory building in the human resource development profession.Human Resource Development Quarterly. 2000;11:159-178.
107. Lynham S.,Chermack T. J.,Noggle M.Selecting organization development theory from an HRD perspective.Human Resource Development Review. 2004;3:151-172.
108. McGuire D.,Cseh M.The development of the field of HRD: A Delphi study.Journal of European Industrial Training. 2006;30:653-667.
109. McLean G. N.HRD: A three-legged stool, an octopus, or a centipede?.Human Resource Development International. 1998;1:375-377.
110. Roth G. L.CPE and HRD: Research and practice within systems and across boundaries.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2004;6 (1): 9-19.
111. Ruona W. E. A.Foundations of human resource development. 2009). Systems theory as a foundation for human resource development. In SwansonR. A.HoltonE. F.III (Eds.), Foundations of human resource development (2nd ed., pp. 128-136). San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers.Swanson R. A.Holton E. F., ed. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers; 2009:128-136.
112. Sambrook S.A "critical" time for HRD?.Journal of European Industrial Training. 2004;28:611-624.
113. Swanson R.Human resource development: Performance is the key.Human Resource Development Quarterly. 1995;6:207-214.
114. Swanson R. A.HRD theory, real or imagined?.Human Resource Development International. 1999;2 (1): 2-5.
115. Swanson R. A.Theory and other irrelevant matters.Human Resource Development International. 2000;3:273-277.
116. Swanson R. A.Human resource development and its underlying theory.Human Resource Development International. 2001;4:299-312.
117. Swanson R. A.Colloquium Presentation at The University of Texas at Tyler. Tyler: The University of Texas at Tyler; 2004:.
118. Swanson R. A.Theory framework for applied disciplines: Boundaries, contributing, core, useful, novel, and irrelevant components.Human Resource Development Review. 2007;6:321-339.
119. Swanson R. A.Economic foundation of human resource development: Advancing the theory and practice of the discipline.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2008;10:763-769.
120. Upton M. G.,Egan T. M.Three approaches to multilevel theory building.Human Resource Development Review. 2010;9:333-356.
121. Wang G. G.,Holton E. F.Neoclassical and institutional economics as foundations for human resource development theory.Human Resource Development Review. 2005;4 (1): 86-108.
122. Wang G. G,Wang J.Human resource development evaluation: Emerging market, barriers, and theory building.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2005;7 (1): 22-36.
123. Wang G. G.,Dou Z.,Li N.A systems approach to measuring return on investment for HRD interventions.Human Resource Development Quarterly. 2002;13:203-224.
124. Weinberger L. A.Commonly held theories of human resource development.Human Resource Development International. 1998;1 (1): 75-93.
125. Yang B.Can adult learning theory provide a foundation for human resource development?.Advances in Developing Human Resources. 2004;6 (2): 129-145.
126. Yoon S.,Kuchinke K. P.Systems theory and technology. Lenses to analyze an organization.Performance improvement. 2005;44 (4): 15-20.
127. Yorks L.,Nicolaides A.Complexity and emergent communicative learning: An opportunity for HRD scholarship.Human Resource Development Review. 2006;5 (2): 143-147.