The impact of prosthesispatient mismatch on long-term survival after aortic valve replacement: A systematic review and meta-analysis of 34 observational studies comprising 27 186 patients with 133 141 patient-years

European Heart Journal

Volumn 33, Issue 12, 2012, Pages 1518-1529

  Head, Stuart J ^a   Mokhles, Mostafa M ^a   Osnabrugge, Ruben L J ^a   Pibarot, Philippe ^b   MacK, Michael J ^c   Takkenberg, Johanna J M ^a   Bogers, Ad J J C ^a   Kappetein, Arie Pieter ^a  

^a ERASMUS MEDICAL CENTER   (Netherlands)

^b LAVAL UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^c Heart Hospital Baylor   (United States)

Author keywords

Aortic valve replacement; Meta analysis; Prosthesispatient mismatch; Survival

Indexed keywords

AORTA VALVE REPLACEMENT; BIOCOMPATIBILITY; CARDIOVASCULAR MORTALITY; FOLLOW UP; GENETIC HETEROGENEITY; HEALTH HAZARD; HEART VALVE BIOPROSTHESIS; HUMAN; LONG TERM SURVIVAL; META ANALYSIS; OBSERVATIONAL STUDY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROSTHESIS FAILURE; PROSTHESIS PATIENT MISMATCH; REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; AGED; AORTA VALVE STENOSIS; BODY SURFACE; FEMALE; HEART VALVE PROSTHESIS; HEART VALVE REPLACEMENT; MALE; MORTALITY; PROSTHESIS; SURVIVAL; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

AGED; AORTIC VALVE STENOSIS; BODY SURFACE AREA; FEMALE; HEART VALVE PROSTHESIS; HEART VALVE PROSTHESIS IMPLANTATION; HUMANS; MALE; PROSTHESIS DESIGN; PROSTHESIS FAILURE; SURVIVAL ANALYSIS; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84863579774     PISSN: 0195668X     EISSN: 15229645     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/eurheartj/ehs003     Document Type: Review

References (69)

1. Rahimtoola SH. The problem of valve prosthesis-patient mismatch. Circulation 1978;58:20-24. (Pubitemid 8376654)
2. Dumesnil JG, Honos GN, Lemieux M, Beauchemin J. Validation and applications of indexed aortic prosthetic valve areas calculated by Doppler echocardiography. J Am Coll Cardiol 1990;16:637-643. (Pubitemid 20296128)
3. Dumesnil JG, Yoganathan AP. Valve prosthesis hemodynamics and the problem of high transprosthetic pressure gradients. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 1992;6:S34-S37.
4. Pibarot P, Dumesnil JG, Lemieux M, Cartier P, Metras J, Durand LG. Impact of prosthesis-patient mismatch on hemodynamic and symptomatic status, morbidity and mortality after aortic valve replacement with a bioprosthetic heart valve. J Heart Valve Dis 1998;7:211-218. (Pubitemid 28168500)
5. Flameng W, Herregods MC, Vercalsteren M, Herijgers P, Bogaerts K, Meuris B. Prosthesis-patient mismatch predicts structural valve degeneration in bioprosthetic heart valves. Circulation 2010;121:2123-2129.
6. Pibarot P, Dumesnil JG. Prosthesis-patient mismatch: definition, clinical impact, and prevention. Heart 2006;92:1022-1029. (Pubitemid 44125207)
7. Blais C, Dumesnil JG, Baillot R, Simard S, Doyle D, Pibarot P. Impact of valve prosthesis-patient mismatch on short-term mortality after aortic valve replacement. Circulation 2003;108:983-988. (Pubitemid 37048229)
8. Ruel M, Rubens FD, Masters RG, Pipe AL, Bedard P, Hendry PJ, Lam BK, Burwash IG, Goldstein WG, Brais MP, Keon WJ, Mesana TG. Late incidence and predictors of persistent or recurrent heart failure in patients with aortic prosthetic valves. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2004;127:149-159. (Pubitemid 38160478)
9. Tasca G, Mhagna Z, Perotti S, Centurini PB, Sabatini T, Amaducci A, Brunelli F, Cirillo M, Dalla Tomba M, Quaini E, Troise G, Pibarot P. Impact of prosthesispatient mismatch on cardiac events and midterm mortality after aortic valve replacement in patients with pure aortic stenosis. Circulation 2006;113:570-576.
10. Urso S, Sadaba R, Vives M, Trujillo J, Beltrame S, Soriano B, Piqueras L, Aldamiz-Echevarria G. Patient-prosthesis mismatch in elderly patients undergoing aortic valve replacement: impact on quality of life and survival. J Heart Valve Dis 2009;18:248-255.
11. Walther T, Rastan A, Falk V, Lehmann S, Garbade J, Funkat AK, Mohr FW, Gummert JF. Patient prosthesis mismatch affects short- and long-term outcomes after aortic valve replacement. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2006;30:15-19. (Pubitemid 44183638)
12. Blackstone EH, Cosgrove DM, Jamieson WR, Birkmeyer NJ, Lemmer JH Jr, Miller DC, Butchart EG, Rizzoli G, Yacoub M, Chai A. Prosthesis size and longterm survival after aortic valve replacement. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2003;126: 783-796. (Pubitemid 37151965)
13. Pibarot P, Dumesnil JG. Hemodynamic and clinical impact of prosthesis-patient mismatch in the aortic valve position and its prevention. J Am Coll Cardiol 2000; 36:1131-1141.
14. Stroup DF, Berlin JA, Morton SC, Olkin I, Williamson GD, Rennie D, Moher D, Becker BJ, Sipe TA, Thacker SB. Meta-analysis of observational studies in epidemiology: a proposal for reporting. Meta-analysis Of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) group. JAMA 2000;283:2008-2012. (Pubitemid 30214957)
15. Pocock SJ, Clayton TC, Altman DG. Survival plots of time-to-event outcomes in clinical trials: good practice and pitfalls. Lancet 2002;359:1686-1689. (Pubitemid 34518535)
16. Karrison TG. Use of Irwin's restricted mean as an index for comparing survival in different treatment groups-interpretation and power considerations. Control Clin Trials 1997;18:151-167. (Pubitemid 27225892)
17. Williamson PR, Smith CT, Hutton JL, Marson AG. Aggregate data meta-analysis with time-to-event outcomes. Stat Med 2002;21:3337-3351. (Pubitemid 35314654)
18. Parmar MK, Torri V, Stewart L. Extracting summary statistics to perform meta-analyses of the published literature for survival endpoints. Stat Med 1998; 17:2815-2834. (Pubitemid 28562978)
19. Liberati A, Altman DG, Tetzlaff J, Mulrow C, Gotzsche PC, Ioannidis JP, Clarke M, Devereaux PJ, Kleijnen J, Moher D. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. Ann Intern Med 2009;151:W65-W94.
20. Tierney JF, Stewart LA, Ghersi D, Burdett S, Sydes MR. Practical methods for incorporating summary time-to-event data into meta-analysis. Trials 2007;8:16.
21. Egger M, Davey Smith G, Schneider M, Minder C. Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ 1997;315:629-634. (Pubitemid 27387172)
22. Rao V, Jamieson WR, Ivanov J, Armstrong S, David TE. Prosthesis-patient mismatch affects survival after aortic valve replacement. Circulation 2000;102:III5-III9.
23. Frapier JM, Rouviere P, Razcka F, Aymard T, Albat B, Chaptal PA. Influence of patient-prosthesis mismatch on long-term results after aortic valve replacement with a stented bioprosthesis. J Heart Valve Dis 2002;11:543-551. (Pubitemid 34814522)
24. Hanayama N, Christakis GT, Mallidi HR, Joyner CD, Fremes SE, Morgan CD, Mitoff PR, Goldman BS. Patient prosthesis mismatch is rare after aortic valve replacement: valve size may be irrelevant. Ann Thorac Surg 2002;73:1822-1829. (Pubitemid 34596724)
25. Milano AD, De Carlo M, Mecozzi G, D'Alfonso A, Scioti G, Nardi C, Bortolotti U. Clinical outcome in patients with 19-mm and 21-mm St. Jude aortic prostheses: comparison at long-term follow-up. Ann Thorac Surg 2002;73:37-43.
26. Penta de Peppo A, Zeitani J, Nardi P, Iaci G, Polisca P, De Paulis R, Chiariello L. Small functional size after mechanical aortic valve replacement: no risk in young to middle-age patients. Ann Thorac Surg 2005;79:1915-1920. (Pubitemid 40804163)
27. Tasca G, Brunelli F, Cirillo M, DallaTomba M, Mhagna Z, Troise G, Quaini E. Impact of valve prosthesis-patient mismatch on left ventricular mass regression following aortic valve replacement. Ann Thorac Surg 2005;79:505-510. (Pubitemid 40186547)
28. Flameng W, Meuris B, Herijgers P, Herregods MC. Prosthesis-patient mismatch is not clinically relevant in aortic valve replacement using the Carpentier-Edwards Perimount valve. Ann Thorac Surg 2006;82:530-536. (Pubitemid 44088650)
29. Howell NJ, Keogh BE, Barnet V, Bonser RS, Graham TR, Rooney SJ, Wilson IC, Pagano D. Patient-prosthesis mismatch does not affect survival following aortic valve replacement. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2006;30:10-14. (Pubitemid 43850318)
30. Mohty D, Malouf JF, Girard SE, Schaff HV, Grill DE, Enriquez-Sarano ME, Miller FA Jr. Impact of prosthesis-patient mismatch on long-term survival in patients with small St Jude Medical mechanical prostheses in the aortic position. Circulation 2006;113:420-426. (Pubitemid 43803204)
31. Moon MR, Pasque MK, Munfakh NA, Melby SJ, Lawton JS, Moazami N, Codd JE, Crabtree TD, Barner HB, Damiano RJ Jr. Prosthesis-patient mismatch after aortic valve replacement: impact of age and body size on late survival. Ann Thorac Surg 2006;81:481-488.
32. Garcia Fuster R, Estevez V, Rodriguez I, Canovas S, Gil O, Hornero F, Mart?́nes-León J. Prosthesis-patient mismatch with latest generation supra-annular prostheses. The beginning of the end? Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg 2007;6: 462-469. (Pubitemid 47403937)
33. Kato Y, Suehiro S, Shibata T, Sasaki Y, Hirai H. Impact of valve prosthesis-patient mismatch on long-term survival and left ventricular mass regression after aortic valve replacement for aortic stenosis. J Card Surg 2007;22:314-319. (Pubitemid 47174332)
34. Monin JL, Monchi M, Kirsch ME, Petit-Eisenmann H, Baleynaud S, Chauvel C, Metz D, Adams C, Quere JP, Gueret P, Tribouilloy C. Low-gradient aortic stenosis: impact of prosthesis-patient mismatch on survival. Eur Heart J 2007;28: 2620-2626. (Pubitemid 350071524)
35. Nozohoor S, Nilsson J, Luhrs C, Roijer A, Sjogren J. The influence of patientprosthesis mismatch on in-hospital complications and early mortality after aortic valve replacement. J Heart Valve Dis 2007;16:475-482. (Pubitemid 47527395)
36. Tao K, Sakata R, Iguro Y, Ueno M, Tanaka Y, Otsuji Y, Tei C. Impact of valve prosthesis-patient mismatch on intermediate-term outcome and regression of left ventricular mass following aortic valve replacement with mechanical prosthesis. J Card Surg 2007;22:486-492. (Pubitemid 350178876)
37. Florath I, Albert A, Rosendahl U, Ennker IC, Ennker J. Impact of valve prosthesispatient mismatch estimated by echocardiographic-determined effective orifice area on long-term outcome after aortic valve replacement. Am Heart J 2008; 155:1135-1142. (Pubitemid 351721024)
38. Kato Y, Tsutsumi Y, Kawai T, Goto T, Takahashi Y, Ohashi H. Aortic valve replacement for aortic stenosis in the elderly: influence of prosthesis-patient mismatch on late survival and left ventricular mass regression. Gen Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2008;56:397-403.
39. Kohsaka S, Mohan S, Virani S, Lee VV, Contreras A, Reul GJ, Coulter SA. Prosthesis-patient mismatch affects long-term survival after mechanical valve replacement. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2008;135:1076-1080. (Pubitemid 351609035)
40. Mascherbauer J, Rosenhek R, Fuchs C, Pernicka E, Klaar U, Scholten C, Heger M, Wollenek G, Maurer G, Baumgartner H. Moderate patient-prosthesis mismatch after valve replacement for severe aortic stenosis has no impact on short-term and long-term mortality. Heart 2008;94:1639-1645.
41. Ryomoto M, Mitsuno M, Yamamura M, Tanaka H, Kobayashi Y, Fukui S, Tsujiya N, Kajiyama T, Miyamoto Y. Patient-prosthesis mismatch after aortic valve replacement in the elderly. Gen Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2008;56:330-334. (Pubitemid 351952067)
42. Tsutsumi K, Nagumo M, Nishikawa K, Takahashi R. Effect of prosthesis-patient mismatch on survival after aortic valve replacement using mechanical prostheses in patients with aortic stenosis. Gen Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2008;56:577-583.
43. Vicchio M, Della Corte A, De Santo LS, De Feo M, Caianiello G, Scardone M, Cotrufo M. Prosthesis-patient mismatch in the elderly: survival, ventricular mass regression, and quality of life. Ann Thorac Surg 2008;86:1791-1797.
44. Mannacio VA, De Amicis V, Di Tommaso L, Iorio F, Vosa C. Influence of prosthesis-patient mismatch on exercise-induced arrhythmias: a further aspect after aortic valve replacement. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2009;138:632-638.
45. Mohty D, Dumesnil JG, Echahidi N, Mathieu P, Dagenais F, Voisine P, Pibarot P. Impact of prosthesis-patient mismatch on long-term survival after aortic valve replacement: influence of age, obesity, and left ventricular dysfunction. J Am Coll Cardiol 2009;53:39-47.
46. Moon MR, Lawton JS, Moazami N, Munfakh NA, Pasque MK, Damiano RJ Jr. POINT: Prosthesis-patient mismatch does not affect survival for patients greater than 70 years of age undergoing bioprosthetic aortic valve replacement. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2009;137:278-283.
47. Mrowczynski W, Lutter G, Attmann T, Hoffmann G, Quaden R, Cremer J, Bö ning A. Does patient-prosthesis mismatch influence the results of combined aortic valve replacement and coronary bypass grafting?. Kardiol Pol 2009;67: 865-873.
48. Bleiziffer S, Ali A, Hettich IM, Akdere D, Laubender RP, Ruzicka D, Boehm J, Lange R, Eichinger W. Impact of the indexed effective orifice area on mid-term cardiac-related mortality after aortic valve replacement. Heart 2010;96:865-871.
49. Jamieson WR, Ye J, Higgins J, Cheung A, Fradet GJ, Skarsgard P, Germann E, Chan F, Lichtenstein SV. Effect of prosthesis-patient mismatch on long-term survival with aortic valve replacement: assessment to 15 years. Ann Thorac Surg 2010; 89:51-59.
50. Sakamoto Y, Yoshitake M, Naganuma H, Kawada N, Kinouchi K, Hashimoto K. Reconsideration of patient-prosthesis mismatch definition from the valve indexed effective orifice area. Ann Thorac Surg 2010;89:1951-1955.
51. Bakhtiary F, Schiemann M, Dzemali O, Dogan S, Schachinger V, Ackermann H, Moritz A, Kleine P. Impact of patient-prosthesis mismatch and aortic valve design on coronary flow reserve after aortic valve replacement. J Am Coll Cardiol 2007;49:790-796. (Pubitemid 46240712)
52. Pibarot P, Honos GN, Durand LG, Dumesnil JG. The effect of prosthesis-patient mismatch on aortic bioprosthetic valve hemodynamic performance and patient clinical status. Can J Cardiol 1996;12:379-387. (Pubitemid 26140488)
53. Vincentelli A, Susen S, Le Tourneau T, Six I, Fabre O, Juthier F, Bauters A, Decoene C, Goudemand J, Prat A, Jude B. Acquired von Willebrand syndrome in aortic stenosis. N Engl J Med 2003;349:343-349. (Pubitemid 36886240)
54. Yoshida K, Tobe S, Kawata M, Yamaguchi M. Acquired and reversible von Willebrand disease with high shear stress aortic valve stenosis. Ann Thorac Surg 2006;81: 490-494. (Pubitemid 43120541)
55. Unger P, Magne J, Vanden Eynden F, Plein D, Van Camp G, Pasquet A, Cosyns B, Dedobbeleer C, Lancellotti P. Impact of prosthesis-patient mismatch on mitral regurgitation after aortic valve replacement. Heart 2010;96:1627-1632.
56. Bleiziffer S, Eichinger WB, Hettich I, Guenzinger R, Ruzicka D, Bauernschmitt R, Lange R. Prediction of valve prosthesis-patient mismatch prior to aortic valve replacement: which is the best method?. Heart 2007;93:615-620. (Pubitemid 46707117)
57. Castro LJ, Arcidi JM Jr, Fisher AL, Gaudiani VA. Routine enlargement of the small aortic root: a preventive strategy to minimize mismatch. Ann Thorac Surg 2002;74: 31-36; discussion 36. (Pubitemid 34742000)
58. Pibarot P, Dumesnil JG. Prosthetic heart valves: selection of the optimal prosthesis and long-term management. Circulation 2009;119:1034-1048.
59. Kulik A, Al-Saigh M, Chan V, Masters RG, Bedard P, Lam BK, Rubens FD, Hendry PJ, Mesana TG, Ruel M. Enlargement of the small aortic root during aortic valve replacement: is there a benefit?. Ann Thorac Surg 2008;85:94-100. (Pubitemid 350284578)
60. Peterson MD, Borger MA, Feindel CM, David TE. Aortic annular enlargement during aortic valve replacement: improving results with time. Ann Thorac Surg 2007;83:2044-2049. (Pubitemid 46805079)
61. Clavel MA, Webb JG, Pibarot P, Altwegg L, Dumont E, Thompson C, De Larochellière R, Doyle D, Masson JB, Bergeron S, Bertrand OF, Rodés-Cabau J. Comparison of the hemodynamic performance of percutaneous and surgical bioprostheses for the treatment of severe aortic stenosis. J Am Coll Cardiol 2009;53: 1883-1891.
62. Jilaihawi H, Chin D, Spyt T, Jeilan M, Vasa-Nicotera M, Bence J, Logtens E, Kovac J. Prosthesis-patient mismatch after transcatheter aortic valve implantation with the Medtronic-Corevalve bioprosthesis. Eur Heart J 2010;31:857-864.
63. Sherif MA, Abdel-Wahab M, Awad O, Geist V, El-Shahed G, Semmler R, Tawfik M, Khattab AA, Richardt D, Richardt G, Tö lg R. Early hemodynamic and neurohormonal response after transcatheter aortic valve implantation. Am Heart J 2010;160:862-869.
64. Kulik A, Burwash IG, Kapila V, Mesana TG, Ruel M. Long-term outcomes after valve replacement for low-gradient aortic stenosis: impact of prosthesis-patient mismatch. Circulation 2006;114:I553-I558. (Pubitemid 44297207)
65. Ruel M, Al-Faleh H, Kulik A, Chan KL, Mesana TG, Burwash IG. Prosthesis-patient mismatch after aortic valve replacement predominantly affects patients with preexisting left ventricular dysfunction: effect on survival, freedom from heart failure, and left ventricular mass regression. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2006;131: 1036-1044.
66. Cohen RG, Bourne ET. Industry-generated charts for the selection of stented aortic valve prostheses: clinical tool or marketing ploy? Ann Thorac Surg 2011; 91:1001-1002.
67. Pibarot P, Dumesnil JG. Prevention of valve prosthesis-patient mismatch before aortic valve replacement: does it matter and is it feasible? Heart 2007;93:549-551. (Pubitemid 46707103)
68. Akins CW, Miller DC, Turina MI, Kouchoukos NT, Blackstone EH, Grunkemeier GL, Takkenberg JJ, David TE, Butchart EG, Adams DH, Shahian DM, Hagl S, Mayer JE, Lytle BW. Guidelines for reporting mortality and morbidity after cardiac valve interventions. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg 2008;33: 523-528.
69. Egger M, Davey Smith G, Altman D. Systematic Reviews in Health Care: Meta-analysis in Context. London: BMJ Publishing Group; 2001.