Surface chemistry of porous silicon and implications for drug encapsulation and delivery applications

Advances in Colloid and Interface Science

Volumn 175, Issue , 2012, Pages 25-38

  Jarvis, Karyn L ^a   Barnes, Timothy J ^a   Prestidge, Clive A ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA   (Australia)

Author keywords

Drug delivery; Drug loading; Porous silicon; Surface chemistry; Surface modification

Indexed keywords

CHARACTERIZATION TECHNIQUES; CONTROLLED RELEASE PROPERTIES; CRYSTALLINITIES; DISSOLUTION RATES; DRUG DELIVERY APPLICATIONS; DRUG ENCAPSULATION; DRUG LOADING; DRUG RELEASE; HIGH LOADINGS; LOADING LEVEL; POORLY SOLUBLE DRUGS; POTENTIAL DRUG; PROTEIN THERAPEUTICS; THERMAL CARBONIZATION; TIME OF FLIGHT SECONDARY ION MASS SPECTROMETRY;

DISSOLUTION; DRUG DELIVERY; DRUG INTERACTIONS; DRUG PRODUCTS; ENCAPSULATION; HYDROSILYLATION; PHOTOELECTRONS; POROUS SILICON; SECONDARY ION MASS SPECTROMETRY; SURFACE CHEMISTRY; SURFACE TREATMENT; X RAY PHOTOELECTRON SPECTROSCOPY;

LOADING;

SILICON;

CHEMISTRY; DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEM; DRUG FORMULATION; POROSITY; REVIEW; SURFACE PROPERTY;

DRUG COMPOUNDING; DRUG DELIVERY SYSTEMS; POROSITY; SILICON; SURFACE PROPERTIES;

EID: 84860756318     PISSN: 00018686     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cis.2012.03.006     Document Type: Review

References (174)

1. A. Uhlir Bell Labs Tech J 35 1956 333
2. S.N. Sharma, R.K. Sharma, G. Bhagavannarayana, S.B. Samanta, K.N. Sood, and S.T. Lakshmikumar Mater Lett 60 2006 1166
3. F.A. Harraz, T. Sakka, and Y.H. Ogata Electrochim Acta 47 2002 1249
4. L.T. Canham Appl Phys Lett 57 1990 1046
5. A.G. Cullis, L.T. Canham, and P.D.J. Calcott J Appl Phys 82 1997 909
6. O. Bisi, S. Ossicini, and L. Pavesi Surf Sci Rep 38 2000 1
7. O. Worsfold, N.H. Voelcker, and T. Nishiya Langmuir 22 2006 7078
8. J.L. Coffer, M.A. Whitehead, D.K. Nagesha, P. Mukherjee, G. Akkaraju, and M. Totolici Phys Status Solidi A 202 2005 1451
9. A.V. Sapelkin, S.C. Bayliss, B. Unal, and A. Charalambou Biomaterials 27 2006 842
10. J. Salonen, L. Laitinen, A.M. Kaukonen, J. Tuura, M. Bjorkqvist, and T. Heikkila J Control Release 108 2005 362
11. C.A. Prestidge, T.J. Barnes, C.-H. Lau, C. Barnett, A. Loni, and L. Canham Expert Opin Drug Deliv 4 2007 101
12. L. Vaccari, D. Canton, N. Zaffaroni, R. Villa, M. Tormen, and E. di Fabrizio Microelectron Eng 83 2006 1598
13. E.J. Anglin, M.P. Schwartz, V.P. Ng, L.A. Perelman, and M.J. Sailor Langmuir 20 2004 11264
14. F. Wang, H. Hui, T.J. Barnes, C. Barnett, and C.A. Prestidge Mol Pharm 7 2010 227
15. A.B. Foraker, R.J. Walczak, M.H. Cohen, T.A. Boiarski, C.F. Grove, and P.W. Swaan Pharm Res 20 2003 110
16. E.C. Wu, J.S. Andrew, A. Buyanin, J.M. Kinsella, and M.J. Sailor Chem Commun (Camb) 47 2011 5699
17. I.N. Lees, H. Lin, C.A. Canaria, C. Gurtner, M.J. Sailor, and G.M. Miskelly Langmuir 19 2003 9812
18. T. Limnell, J. Riikonen, J. Salonen, A.M. Kaukonen, L. Laitinen, and J. Hirvonen Int J Pharm 343 2007 141
19. L.A. Perelman, C. Pacholski, Y.Y. Li, M.S. VanNieuwenhze, and M.J. Sailor Nanomedicine (London) 3 2008 31
20. J. Salonen, V.P. Lehto, and E. Laine Appl Phys Lett 70 1997 637
21. A.E. Pap, K. Kordas, G. Toth, J. Levoska, A. Uusimaki, and J. Vahakangas Appl Phys Lett 86 2005 041501
22. R. Herino, A. Perio, K. Barla, and G. Bomchil Mater Lett 2 1984 519
23. X.Y. Hou, G. Shi, W. Wang, F.L. Zhang, P.H. Hao, and D.M. Huang Appl Phys Lett 62 1993 1097
24. J.M. Buriak Adv Mater 11 1999 265
25. J.M. Buriak, and M.J. Allen J Am Chem Soc 120 1998 1339
26. J.M. Buriak, M.P. Stewart, T.W. Geders, M.J. Allen, H.C. Choi, and J. Smith J Am Chem Soc 121 1999 11491
27. J. Salonen, V.P. Lehto, M. Björkqvist, E. Laine, and L. Niinistö Phys Status Solidi A 182 2000 123
28. J. Salonen, M. Bjorkqvist, E. Laine, and L. Niinisto Appl Surf Sci 225 2004 389
29. M.P. Stewart, and J.M. Buriak Adv Mater 12 2000 859
30. M.J. Sailor, and E.J. Lee Adv Mater 9 1997 783
31. J.H. Song, and M.J. Sailor Comment Inorg Chem 21 1999 69
32. J. Salonen, and V.-P. Lehto Chem Eng J 137 2008 162 (Amsterdam, Neth.)
33. E.J. Anglin, L. Cheng, W.R. Freeman, and M.J. Sailor Adv Drug Deliv Rev 60 2008 1266
34. J. Salonen, A.M. Kaukonen, J. Hirvonen, and V.-P. Lehto J Pharm Sci 97 2008 632
35. H.A. Santos, L.M. Bimbo, V.-P. Lehto, A.J. Airaksinen, J. Salonen, and J. Hirvonen Curr Drug Discov Technol 8 2011 228
36. A. Halimaoui L.T. Canham, Properties of porous silicon 1997 INSPEC, The institution of Electrical Engineers Chapter 1.2
37. J. Salonen, M. Bjorkqvist, E. Laine, and L. Niinisto Phys Status Solidi A 182 2000 249
38. E. Vazsonyi, E. Szilagyi, P. Petrik, Z.E. Horvath, T. Lohner, and M. Fried Thin Solid Films 388 2001 295
39. O.K. Andersen, T. Frello, and E. Veje J Appl Phys 78 1995 6189
40. S. Boughaba, and K. Wang Thin Solid Films 497 2006 83
41. M. Saadoun, N. Mliki, H. Kaabi, K. Daoudi, B. Bessais, and H. Ezzaouia Thin Solid Films 405 2002 29
42. R.E. Hummel, and C. Sung-Sik Appl Phys Lett 61 1992 1965
43. A. Halimaoui J.C. Vial, J. Derrien, Porous silicon science and technology 1995 Spinger-Verlag Chapter 3
44. P. Allongue, V. Kieling, and H. Gerischer Electrochim Acta 40 1995 1353
45. D.J. Blackwood, and Y. Zhang Electrochim Acta 48 2003 623
46. V. Lehmann, and U. Gosele Appl Phys Lett 58 1991 856
47. R.L. Smith, and S.D. Collins J Appl Phys 71 1992 R1
48. W. Theiss Surf Sci Rep 29 1997 91
49. J. Jakubowicz Superlattice Microstruct 41 2007 205
50. P. Allongue L.T. Canham, Properties of porous silicon 1997 INSPEC, The Institution of Electrical Engineers Chapter 1.1
51. N.E. Chayen, E. Saridakis, R. El-Bahar, and Y. Nemirovsky J Mol Biol 312 2001 591
52. J.T.C. Wojtyk, K.A. Morin, R. Boukherroub, and D.D.M. Wayner Langmuir 18 2002 6081
53. L.T. Canham L.T. Canham, Properties of porous silicon 1997 INSPEC, The Institution of Electrical Engineers Chapter 2.1
54. M. Hajji, M. Khardani, N. Khedher, H. Rahmouni, B. BessaIs, and H. Ezzaouia Thin Solid Films 511-512 2006 235
55. S. Setzu, and G. Lerondel J Appl Phys 84 1998 3129
56. R. Herino L.T. Canham, Properties of porous silicon 1997 INSPEC, The Institution of Electrical Engineers Chapter 2.2
57. G. Bomchil, R. Herino, K. Barla, and J. Pfister Electrochem Soc 130 1983 1611
58. R. Herino, G. Bomchil, K. Barla, and C. Bertrand J Electrochem Soc 134 1987 1994
59. L.A. Balagurov, B.A. Loginov, E.A. Petrova, A. Sapelkin, B. Unal, and D.G. Yarkin Electrochim Acta 51 2006 2938
60. P. Kumar, and P. Huber J Nanomater 2007 2007 4
61. T.I. Gorbanyuk, A.A. Evtukh, V.G. Litovchenko, V.S. Solnsev, and E.M. Pakhlov Thin Solid Films 495 2006 134
62. D.B. Mawhinney, J.A. Glass, and J.T. Yates J Phys Chem B 101 1997 1202
63. A. Nakajima, T. Itakura, S. Watanabe, and N. Nakayama Appl Phys Lett 61 1992 46
64. R. Kumar, and Y. Kitoh Appl Phys Lett 63 1993 3032
65. V. Lysenko, J. Vitiello, B. Remaki, D. Barbier, and V. Skryshevsky Appl Surf Sci 230 2004 425
66. N. Errien, L. Vellutini, G. Louarn, and G. Froyer Appl Surf Sci 253 2007 7265
67. R. Zanoni, G. Righini, G. Mattogno, L. Schirone, G. Sotgiu, and F. Rallo J Lumin 80 1998 159
68. T.V. Torchinskaya, N.E. Korsunskaya, L.Y. Khomenkova, B.R. Dhumaev, and S.M. Prokes Thin Solid Films 381 2001 88
69. K. Murakoshi, and K. Uosaki Appl Phys Lett 62 1993 1676
70. S. Gardelis, and B. Hamilton J Appl Phys 76 1994 5327
71. N.H. Zoubir, and M. Vergnat Appl Phys Lett 65 1994 82
72. J. Harper, and M.J. Sailor Langmuir 13 1997 4652
73. A. Takazawa, T. Tamura, and M. Yamada J Appl Phys 75 1994 2489
74. E.P. Domashevskaya, V.M. Kashkarov, E.Y. Manukovskii, A.V. Shchukarev, and V.A. Terekhov J Electron Spectrosc Relat Phenom 88-91 1998 969
75. D.Q. Yang, M. Meunier, and E. Sacher J Appl Phys 99 2006
76. H. Munder J.C. Vial, J. Derrien, Porous silicon science and technology 1995 Springer-Verlag Chapter 16
77. H. Munder, M.G. Berger, S. Frohnhoff, M. Thonissen, H. Luth, and M. Jeske J Lumin 57 1993 223
78. V.A. Terekhov, V.M. Kashkarov, Manukovskii, A.V. Schukarev, and E.P. Domashevskaya J Electron Spectrosc Relat Phenom 114-116 2001 895
79. F. Leisenberger, R. Duschek, R. Czaputa, F.P. Netzer, G. Beamson, and J.A.D. Matthew Appl Surf Sci 108 1997 273
80. I.M. Kempson, T.J. Barnes, and C.A. Prestidge J Am Soc Mass Spectrom 21 2010 254
81. K.L. Jarvis, T.J. Barnes, and C.A. Prestidge Langmuir 26 2010 14316
82. T.J. Barnes, I.M. Kempson, and C.A. Prestidge Int J Pharm 417 2011 61 69
83. C.A. Prestidge, T.J. Barnes, A. Mierczynska-Vasilev, I. Kempson, F. Peddie, and C. Barnett Phys Status Solidi A 205 2008 311
84. A. Benninghoven, F.G. Rudenauer, and H.W. Werner P.J. Elving, J.D. Winefordner, 1987 John Wiley & Sons Chapter 5
85. Jarvis KL, PhD Thesis, 2010, University of South Australia, Adelaide.
86. J. Salonen, V.P. Lehto, and E. Laine Appl Surf Sci 120 1997 191
87. R.B. Bjorklund, S. Zangooie, and H. Arwin Langmuir 13 1997 1440
88. J.E. Bateman, R.D. Eagling, B.R. Horrocks, A. Houlton, and D.R. Worrall Chem Commun (Camb) 2275 1997
89. Y.H. Ogata, T. Tsuboi, T. Sakka, and S. Naito J Porous Mater 7 2000 63
90. K.L. Jarvis, T.J. Barnes, and C.A. Prestidge Langmuir 24 2008 14222
91. Y. Ogata, H. Niki, T. Sakka, and M. Iwasaki J Electrochem Soc 142 1995 1595
92. G. Mattei, V. Valentini, and V.A. Yakovlev Surf Sci 502-503 2002 58
93. H. Chen, X. Hou, G. Li, F. Zhang, M. Yu, and X. Wang J Appl Phys 79 1996 3282
94. J.-Y. Park, and J.-H. Lee Mater Chem Phys 82 2003 134
95. J. Salonen, E. Laine, and L. Niinisto J Appl Phys 91 2002 456
96. M. Bjorkqvist, J. Salonen, and E. Laine Appl Surf Sci 222 2004 269
97. M. Bjorkqvist, J. Salonen, J. Paski, and E. Laine Sens Actuators A 112 2004 244
98. J. Salonen, M. Bjorkqvist, and J. Paski Sens Actuators A 116 2004 438
99. J. Paski, M. Björkqvist, J. Salonen, and V-P. Lehto Phys Status Solidi C 2 2005 3379
100. M. Björkqvist, J. Paski, J. Salonen, and V.P. Lehto Phys Status Solidi A 202 2005 1653
101. J. Salonen, J. Tuura, M. Bjorkqvist, and V.P. Lehto Sens Actuators B 114 2006 423
102. M. Bjorkqvist, J. Paski, J. Salonen, and V.-P. Lehto IEEE Sensors J 6 2006 542
103. V. Torres-Costa, J. Salonen, V.P. Lehto, R.J. Martín-Palma, and J.M. Martínez-Duart Microporous Mesoporous Mater 111 2008 636
104. V. Torres-Costa, R.J. Martin-Palma, J.M. Martinez-Duart, J. Salonen, and V.P. Lehto J Appl Phys 103 2008 083124
105. F. Geobaldo, P. Rivolo, P. Ugliengo, and E. Garrone Sens Actuators B 100 2004 29
106. S.P. Low, K.A. Williams, L.T. Canham, and N.H. Voelcker Biomaterials 27 2006 4538
107. J. Salonen, E. Laine, and L. Niinistö Phys Status Solidi A 197 2003 246
108. J.E. Bateman, R.D. Eagling, D.R. Worrall, B.R. Horrocks, and A. Houlton Angew Chem Int Ed 37 1998 2683
109. H.J. Fan, M.H. Kuok, S.C. Ng, H.S. Lim, N.N. Liu, and R. Boukherroub J Appl Phys 94 2003 1243
110. R. Boukherroub, S. Morin, D.D.M. Wayner, and D.J. Lockwood Phys Status Solidi A 182 2000 117
111. R. Boukherroub, S. Morin, D.D.M. Wayner, F. Bensebaa, G.I. Sproule, and J.M. Baribeau Chem Mater 13 2001 2002
112. S.A. Alekseev, V. Lysenko, V.N. Zaitsev, and D. Barbier J Phys Chem C 111 2007 15217
113. L. Tay, N.L. Rowell, D.J. Lockwood, and R. Boukherroub J Vac Sci Technol A 24 2006 747
114. B. Gelloz, H. Sano, R. Boukherroub, D.D.M. Wayner, D.J. Lockwood, and N. Koshida Phys Status Solidi C 2 2005 3273
115. R. Boukherroub, D.D.M. Wayner, G.I. Sproule, D.J. Lockwood, and L.T. Canham Nano Lett 1 2001 713
116. D. Dattilo, L. Armelao, M. Maggini, G. Fois, and G. Mistura Langmuir 22 2006 8764
117. D. Dattilo, L. Armelao, G. Fois, G. Mistura, and M. Maggini Langmuir 23 2007 12945
118. B. Gelloz, H. Sano, R. Boukherroub, D.D.M. Wayner, D.J. Lockwood, and N. Koshida Appl Phys Lett 83 2003 2342
119. R. Boukherroub, D.D.M. Wayner, and D.J. Lockwood Appl Phys Lett 81 2002 601
120. M. Björkqvist, J. Salonen, E. Laine, and L. Niinistö Phys Status Solidi A 197 2003 374
121. M.P. Stewart, and J.M. Buriak Angew Chem Int Ed 37 1998 3257
122. M.P. Stewart, E.G. Robins, T.W. Geders, M.J. Allen, H. Cheul Choi, and J.M. Buriak Phys Status Solidi A 182 2000 109
123. L. Britcher, T.J. Barnes, H.J. Griesser, and C.A. Prestidge Langmuir 24 2008 7625
124. V. Vrkoslav, I. Jelinek, T. Trojan, J. Jindrich, and J. Dian Phys B 38 2007 200
125. S. Ciampi, T. Bocking, K.A. Kilian, J.B. Harper, and J.J. Gooding Langmuir 24 2008 5888
126. B. Guan, S. Ciampi, G. Le Saux, K. Gaus, P.J. Reece, and J.J. Gooding Langmuir 27 2010 328 334
127. A. Saghatelian, J. Buriak, V.S.Y. Lin, and M. Reza Ghadiri Tetrahedron 57 2001 5131
128. J.M. Holland, M.P. Stewart, M.J. Allen, and J.M. Buriak J Solid State Chem 147 1999 251
129. E. Romano, and D. Narducci Surf Sci 601 2007 2836
130. J.M. Buriak, and M.J. Allen J Lumin 80 1998 29
131. L.T. Canham, C.L. Reeves, J.P. Newey, M.R. Houlton, T.I. Cox, and J.M. Buriak Adv Mater 11 1999 1505 (Weinheim, Ger.)
132. C. Gurtner, A.W. Wun, and M.J. Sailor Angew Chem Int Ed 38 1999 1966
133. S.C. Bayliss, L.D. Buckberry, P.J. Harris, and M. Tobin J Porous Mater 7 2000 191
134. A.H. Mayne, S.C. Bayliss, P. Barr, M. Tobin, and L.D. Buckberry Phys Status Solidi A 182 2000 505
135. S.C. Bayliss, L.D. Buckberry, I. Fletcher, and M.J. Tobin Sens Actuators A 74 1999 139
136. Y.L. Khung, G. Barritt, and N.H. Voelcker Exp Cell Res 314 2008 789
137. S.C. Bayliss, R. Heald, D.I. Fletcher, and L.D. Buckberry Adv Mater 11 1999 318 (Weinheim, Ger.)
138. V. Chin, B.E. Collins, M.J. Sailor, and S.N. Bhatia Adv Mater 13 2001 1877 (Weinheim, Ger.)
139. S.D. Alvarez, A.M. Derfus, M.P. Schwartz, S.N. Bhatia, and M.J. Sailor Biomaterials 30 2009 26
140. L. Pramatarova, E. Pecheva, D. Dimova-Malinovska, R. Pramatarova, U. Bismayer, and T. Petrov Vacuum 76 2004 135
141. A. Rosengren, L. Wallman, M. Bengtsson, T. Laurell, N. Danielsen, and L.M. Bjursten Phys Status Solidi A 182 2000 527
142. A. Rosengren, L. Wallman, N. Danielsen, T. Laurell, and L.M. Bjursten IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 49 2002 392
143. S.H.C. Anderson, H. Elliott, D.J. Wallis, L.T. Canham, and J.J. Powell Phys Status Solidi A 197 2003 331
144. E. Pastor, E. Matveeva, V. Parkhutik, J. Curiel-Esparza, and M.C. Millan Phys Status Solidi C 4 2007 2136
145. E.A. Tutov, M.N. Pavlenko, I.V. Protasova, and V.M. Kashkarov Tech Phys Lett 28 2002 729
146. M.J. Sweetman, F.J. Harding, S.D. Graney, and N.H. Voelcker Appl Surf Sci 257 2011 6768
147. B. Godin, J. Gu, R.E. Serda, R. Bhavane, E. Tasciotti, and C. Chiappini J Biomed Mater Res A 94A 2010 1236
148. S.P. Low, N.H. Voelcker, L.T. Canham, and K.A. Williams Biomaterials 30 2009 2873
149. Gu.L. Park J-h, G. Von Maltzahn, E. Ruoslahti, S.N. Bhatia, and M.J. Sailor Nat Mater 8 2009 331
150. L.M. Bimbo, E. Mäkilä, T. Laaksonen, V.-P. Lehto, J. Salonen, and J. Hirvonen Biomaterials 32 2011 2625
151. L. Cheng, E. Anglin, F. Cunin, D. Kim, M.J. Sailor, and I. Falkenstein Br J Ophthalmol 92 2008 705
152. S. Zangooie, R. Bjorklund, and H. Arwin J Electrochem Soc 144 1997 4027
153. L.D. Stefano, I. Rea, P. Giardina, A. Armenante, and I. Rendina Adv Mater 20 2008 1529 (Weinheim, Ger.)
154. P. Gupta, A.C. Dillon, A.S. Bracker, and S.M. George Surf Sci 245 1991 360
155. J. Binner, and Y. Zhang J Mater Sci Lett 20 2001 123
156. E. Tasciotti, X. Liu, R. Bhavane, K. Plant, A.D. Leonard, and B.K. Price Nat Nanotechnol 3 2008 151
157. E.C. Wu, J. Park, J. Park, E. Segal, F. Cunin, and M.J. Sailor ACS Nano 2 2008 2401
158. E.C. Wu, J.S. Andrew, L. Cheng, W.R. Freeman, L. Pearson, and M.J. Sailor Biomaterials 32 2011 1957
159. S. Rajaraman, and H.T. Henderson Sens Actuators B 105 2005 443
160. J. Jing, F.E.H. Tay, J. Miao, and C. Iliescu J Micromech Microeng 16 2006 958
161. J. Jing, F.E.H. Tay, and J. Miao J Phys Conf Ser 34 2006 1127
162. A.M. Kaukonen, L. Laitinen, J. Salonen, J. Tuura, T. Heikkila, and T. Limnell Eur J Pharm Biopharm 66 2007 348
163. C.A. Prestidge, T.J. Barnes, A. Mierczynska-Vasilev, W. Skinner, F. Peddie, and C. Barnett Phys Status Solidi A 204 2007 3361
164. P. Kinnari, E. Mäkilä, T. Heikkilä, J. Salonen, J. Hirvonen, and H.A. Santos Int J Pharm 414 2011 148
165. M. Kilpeläinen, J. Mönkäre, M.A. Vlasova, J. Riikonen, V.-P. Lehto, and J. Salonen Eur J Pharm Biopharm 77 2011 20
166. M. Kilpeläinen, J. Riikonen, M.A. Vlasova, A. Huotari, V.P. Lehto, and J. Salonen J Control Release 137 2009 166
167. R.B. Vasani, S.J.P. McInnes, M.A. Cole, A.M.M. Jani, A.V. Ellis, and N.H. Voelcker Langmuir 27 2011 7843
168. A.P. Mann, T. Tanaka, A. Somasunderam, X. Liu, D.G. Gorenstein, and M. Ferrari Adv Mater 23 2011 H278 (Weinheim, Ger.)
169. J. Salonen, J. Paski, K. Vaha-Heikkila, T. Heikkila, M. Bjorkqvist, and V.P. Lehto Phys Status Solidi A 202 2005 1629
170. V.P. Lehto, K. Vaehae-Heikkilae, J. Paski, and J. Salonen J Therm Anal Calorim 80 2005 393
171. J. Riikonen, E. Mäkilä, J. Salonen, and V.-P. Lehto Langmuir 25 2009 6137
172. X. Li, J. St. John, J.L. Coffer, Y. Chen, R.F. Pinizzotto, and J. Newey Biomed Microdevices 2 2000 265
173. J.S. Park, J.M. Kinsella, D.D. Jandial, S.B. Howell, and M.J. Sailor Small 7 2011 2061
174. M. Kovalainen, J. Mönkäre, E. Mäkilä, J. Salonen, V.-P. Lehto, and K.-H. Herzig Pharm Res 29 2012 837