Response to Intervention for Reading Difficulties in the Primary Grades: Some Answers and Lingering Questions

Journal of Learning Disabilities

Volumn 45, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 232-243

  Denton, Carolyn A ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS   (United States)

Author keywords

instruction; learning disabilities; reading difficulties; reading intervention; response to intervention

Indexed keywords

CHILD; DYSLEXIA; EDUCATION; HUMAN; METHODOLOGY; READING; REVIEW; TEACHING;

CHILD; DYSLEXIA; EDUCATION, SPECIAL; EDUCATIONAL MEASUREMENT; HUMANS; READING; TEACHING;

EID: 84860149926     PISSN: 00222194     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0022219412442155     Document Type: Review

References (82)

1. Alliance for Excellent Education. (2002). Every child a graduate: A framework for an excellent education for all middle and high school students. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved from http://www.all4ed.org/files/archive/publications/EveryChildAGraduate/every.pdf.
2. Al Otaiba S.,Fuchs D.Characteristics of children who are unresponsive to early literacy intervention: A review of the literature.Remedial and Special Education. 2002;23:300-316.
3. Al Otaiba S.,Kosanovich-Grek M. L.,Torgesen J. K.,Hassler L.,Wahl M.Reviewing core kindergarten and first-grade reading programs in light of No Child Left Behind: An exploratory study.Reading & Writing Quarterly: Overcoming Learning Difficulties. 2005;21 (4): 377-400.
4. Al Otaiba S.,Schatschneider C.,Silverman E.Tutor-assisted intensive learning strategies in kindergarten: How much is enough?.Exceptionality. 2005;13 (4): 195-208.
5. Al Otaiba S.,Torgesen J.Handbook of response to intervention. Jimerson S. R.Burns M. K.VanDerHeyden A. M., ed. New York, NY: Springer; 2007:212-222.
6. AugustD.ShanahanT. (2006). Executive summary. In AugustD.ShanahanT. (Eds.), Developing literacy in second-language learners: A report of the National Literacy Panel on Language-Minority Children and Youth. Retrieved from http://www.cal.org/projects/archive/natlitpanel.html.
7. Barth A. E.,Stuebing K. K.,Anthony J. L.,Denton C. A.,Mathes P. G.,Fletcher J. M.,Francis D. J.Agreement among response to intervention criteria for identifying responder status.Learning and Individual Differences. 2008;18:296-307.
8. Benner G. J.,Nelson J. R.,Ralston N. C.,Mooney P.A meta-analysis of the effects of reading instruction on the reading skills of students with or at risk of behavioral disorders.Behavioral Disorders. 2010;25 (2): 86-102.
9. Berkeley S.,Bender W. N.,Peaster L. G.,Saunders L.Implementation of response to intervention: A snapshot of progress.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2009;42:85-95.
10. Berninger V. W.,Abbott R. D.,Vermeulen K.,Ogier S.,Brooksher R.,Zook D.,Lemos Z.Comparison of faster and slower responders to early intervention in reading: Differentiating features of their language profiles.Learning Disability Quarterly. 2002;25:59-76.
11. Blachman B. A.,Schatschneider C.,Fletcher J. M.,Francis D. J.,Clonan S.,Shaywitz B.,Shaywitz S.Effects of intensive reading remediation for second and third graders.Journal of Educational Psychology. 2004;96:444-461.
12. Cavanaugh C. L.,Kim A.-H.,Wanzek J.,Vaughn S.Kindergarten reading interventions for at-risk students: Twenty years of research.Learning Disabilities: A Contemporary Journal. 2004;2 (1): 9-21.
13. Center on Crime, Communities, and Culture. (1997). Education as crime prevention(Occasional Paper Series No. 2). Retrieved from http://www.prisonpolicy.org/scans/research_brief__2.pdf.
14. Chard D. J.,Vaughn S.,Tyler B. J.A synthesis of research on effective interventions for building reading fluency with elementary students with learning disabilities.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2002;35 (5): 386-406.
15. Cirino P.,Vaughn S.,Linan-Thompson S.,Cardenas-Hagan E.,Fletcher J.,Francis D.One-year follow-up outcomes of Spanish and English interventions for English language learners at risk for reading problems.American Educational Research Journal. 2009;46 (3): 744-781.
16. Compton D. L.,Fuchs D.,Fuchs L. S.,Bouton B.,Gilbert J. K.,Barquero L. A.,Crouch R. C.Selecting at-risk first-grade readers for early intervention: Eliminating false positives and exploring the promise of a two-stage gated screening process.Journal of Educational Psychology. 2010;102:327-340.
17. Connor C. M.,Piasta S. B.,Fishman B.,Glasney S.,Schatschneider C.,Crowe E.Individualizing student instruction precisely: Effects of child by instruction interactions on first graders' literacy development.Child Development. 2009;80 (1): 77-100.
18. Council for Exceptional Children, Division on Developmental Disabilities. (2007). Position on response to intervention (RtI): The unique role of special education and special educators. Retrieved from http://www.cec.sped.org.
19. Coyne M. D.,Kame'enui E. J.,Simmons D. C.,Harn B. A.Beginning reading intervention as inoculation or insulin: First-grade reading performance of strong responders to kindergarten intervention.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2004;37 (2): 90-104.
20. Crosson A. C.,Lesaux N. K.Revisiting assumptions about the relationship of fluent reading to comprehension: Spanish-speakers' text-reading fluency in English.Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal. 2010;23:475-494.
21. Daniel S. S.,Walsh A. K.,Goldston D. B.,Arnold E. M.,Reboussin B. A.,Wood F. B.Suicidality, school dropout, and reading problems among adolescents.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2006;39:507-514.
22. DavisN.FanQ.ComptonD. L.FuchsD.FuchsL. S.CuttingL. E.GoreJ. C.AndersonA. W. (2010, October). Influences of neural pathway integrity on children's response to reading instruction. Frontiers in Systems Neuroscience, 4, 1-11. Retrieved from www.frontiersin.org.
23. Denton C. A.,Cirino P. T.,Barth A. E.,Romain M.,Vaughn S.,Wexler J.,Fletcher J. M.An experimental study of scheduling and duration of "tier 2" first grade reading intervention.Journal on Research on Educational Effectiveness. 2011;4:208-230.
24. Denton C. A.,Fletcher J. M.,Anthony J. L.,Francis D. J.An evaluation of intensive intervention for students with persistent reading difficulties.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2006;39:447-466.
25. Denton C. A.,Mathes P. G.Preventing and remediating reading difficulties: Bringing science to scale. Foorman B. R., ed. Timonium, MD: York Press; 2003:229-251.
26. Denton C. A.,Nimon K.,Mathes P. G.,Swanson E. A.,Kethley C.,Kurz T.,Shih M.The effectiveness of a supplemental early reading intervention scaled up in multiple schools.Exceptional Children. 2010;76:394-416.
27. Ehri L. C.The voice of evidence in reading research. McCardle P.Chhabra V., ed. Baltimore, MD: Brookes; 2004:153-186.
28. Ehri L. C.,Nunes S. R.,Stahl S. A.,Willows D. M.Systematic phonics instruction helps students learn to read: Evidence from the National Reading Panel's meta-analysis.Review of Educational Research. 2001;71 (3): 393-447.
29. Elbaum B.,Vaughn S.,Hughes M. T.,Moody S. W.How effective are one-to-one tutoring programs in reading for elementary students at risk for reading failure? A meta-analysis of the intervention research.Journal of Educational Psychology. 2000;92 (4): 605-619.
30. Fletcher J. M.,Lyon G. R.,Fuchs L. S.,Barnes M. A.Learning disabilities: From identification to intervention. New York, NY: Guilford; 2007:.
31. Fletcher J. M.,Stuebing K. K.,Barth A. E.,Denton C. A.,Cirino P. T.,Francis D. J.,Vaughn S.Cognitive correlates of inadequate response to reading intervention.School Psychology Review. 2011;40:3-22.
32. Foorman B. R.,Francis D. J.,Fletcher J. M.,Mehta P.,Schatschneider C.The role of instruction in learning to read: Preventing reading failure in at-risk children.Journal of Educational Psychology. 1998;90 (1): 37-55.
33. Foorman B. R.,Torgesen J. K.Critical elements of classroom and small-group instruction promote reading success in all children.Learning Disabilities Research & Practice. 2001;16 (4): 202-211.
34. Francis D. J.,Santi K. L.,Barr C.,Fletcher J. M.,Varisco A.,Foorman B. R.Form effects on the estimation of students' oral reading fluency using DIBELS.Journal of School Psychology. 2008;46:315-342.
35. Francis D. J.,Shaywitz S. E.,Stuebing K. K.,Shaywitz B. A.,Fletcher J. M.Developmental lag versus deficit models of reading disability: A longitudinal, individual growth curve analysis.Journal of Educational Psychology. 1996;88 (1): 3-17.
36. Fuchs D.,Compton D. L.,Fuchs L. S.,Bryant J.,Davis G. N.Making "secondary intervention" work in a three-tier responsiveness-to-intervention model: Findings from the first-grade longitudinal reading study of the national research center on learning disabilities.Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal. 2008;21 (4): 413-436.
37. Fuchs D.,Deshler D. K.What we need to know about responsiveness to intervention (and shouldn't be afraid to ask).Learning Disabilities Research & Practice. 2007;20:129-136.
38. Fuchs L. S.Assessing intervention responsiveness: Conceptual and technical issues.Learning Disabilities Research & Practice. 2003;18 (3): 172-186.
39. Fuchs L. S.,Deno S. L.,Mirkin P. K.The effects of frequent curriculum-based measurement and evaluation on pedagogy, student achievement, and student awareness of learning.American Educational Research Journal. 1984;21:449-460.
40. Fuchs L. S.,Fuchs D.,Hosp M. D.,Jenkins J.Oral reading fluency as an indicator of reading competence: A theoretical, empirical, and historical analysis.Scientific Studies of Reading. 2001;5:239-259.
41. GerstenR.ComptonD.ConnorC. M.DiminoJ.SantoroL.Linan-ThompsonS.TillyW. D. (2008). Assisting students struggling with reading: Response to intervention and multi-tier intervention for reading in the primary grades. A practice guide (NCEE 2009-4045). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Evaluation and Regional Assistance, Institute of Education Sciences. Retrieved from http://ies.ed.gov/ncee/wwc/publications/practiceguides/.
42. Grek M. L.,Mathes P. G.,Torgesen J. K.Reading in the classroom: Systems for the observation of teaching and learning. Vaughn S.Briggs K. L., ed. Baltimore, MD: Brookes; 2003:267-296.
43. Gresham F. M.Handbook of response to intervention. Jimerson S. R.Burns M. K.VanDerHeyden A. M., ed. New York, NY: Springer; 2007:10-24.
44. Hatcher P. J.,Hulme C.,Miles J. N. V.,Carroll J. M.,Hatcher J.,Gibbs S.,Snowling M. J.Efficacy of small group reading intervention for beginning readers with reading-delay: A randomised controlled trial.Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry. 2006;47:820-827.
45. Iversen S.,Tunmer W. E.,Chapman J. W.The effects of varying group size on the reading recovery approach to preventative early intervention.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2005;38 (5): 456-472.
46. Jenkins J. R.,Hudson R. F.,Johnson E. S.Screening for at-risk readers in a response to intervention framework.School Psychology Review. 2007;36:582-600.
47. Exceptional Children. Jitendra A. K.Edwards L. J.Sacks G.Jacobson L. A., ed. 2004:299-322.
48. Juel C.A longitudinal study of 54 children from first through fourth grades.Journal of Educational Psychology. 1988;80 (4): 437-447.
49. Kamps D.,Abbott M.,Greenwood C.,Wills H.,Veerkamp M.,Kaufman J.Effects of small-group reading instruction and curriculum differences for students most at risk in kindergarten: Two-year results for secondary- and tertiary-level interventions.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2008;41:101-114.
50. Kovaleski J. F.,Black L.The promise of response to intervention: Evaluating current science and practice. Glover T. A.Vaughn S., ed. New York, NY: Guilford; 2010:23-56.
51. Kratochwill T. K.,Clements M. A.,Kalymon K. M.Handbook of response to intervention. Jimerson S. R.Burns M. K.VanDerHeyden A. M., ed. New York, NY: Springer; 2007:25-52.
52. Mathes P. G.,Denton C. A.,Fletcher J. M.,Anthony J. L.,Francis D. J.,Schatschneider C.An evaluation of two reading interventions derived from diverse models.Reading Research Quarterly. 2005;40:148-183.
53. McMaster K. L.,Fuchs D.,Fuchs L. S.,Compton D. L.Responding to nonresponders: An experimental field trial of identification and intervention methods.Exceptional Children. 2005;71 (4): 445-464.
54. Teaching children to read: Evidence-based assessment of the scientific research literature on reading and its implications for reading instruction. Bethesda, MD: National Reading Panel, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development; 2000:.
55. Nelson R. J.,Benner G. J.,Gonzalez J.Learner characteristics that influence the treatment effectiveness of early literacy interventions: A meta-analytic review.Learning Disabilities Research & Practice. 2003;18:255-267.
56. O'Connor R. E.,Harty K. R.,Fulmer D.Tiers of intervention in kindergarten through third grade.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2005;38:532-538.
57. OliverR. M.ReschlyD. J. (2007). Effective classroom management: Teacher preparation and professional development. Washington, DC: National Comprehensive Center for Teacher Quality. Retrieved from http://www.tqsource.org/topics/effectiveClassroomManagement.pdf.
58. Pollard-Durodola S. D.,Mathes P. G.,Vaughn S.,Cardenas-Hagan E.,Linan-Thompson S.The role of oracy in developing comprehension in Spanish-speaking English language learners.Topics in Language Disorders. 2006;26:365-384.
59. Schatschneider C.,Wagner R. K.,Crawford E. C.The importance of measuring growth in response to intervention models: Testing a core assumption.Learning and Individual Differences. 2008;18 (3): 308-315.
60. Simmons D. C.,Coyne M. D.,Kwok O.,McDonagh S.,Harn B. A.,Kame'enui E. J.Indexing response to intervention: A longitudinal study of reading risk from kindergarten through third grade.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2008;41:158-173.
61. Simos P. G.,Fletcher J. M.,Sarkari S.,Billingsley-Marshall R.,Denton C. A.,Papanicolaou A. C.Intensive instruction affects brain magnetic activity associated with oral word reading in children with persistent reading difficulties.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2007;40 (1): 37-48.
62. Preventing reading difficulties in young children. Snow C. E.Burns M. S.Griffin P., ed. Washington, DC: National Academies Press; 1998:.
63. Spectrum K12 School Solutions. (2009). Response to intervention (RTI) adoption survey 2009. Retrieved from http://www.spectrumk12.com.
64. Stanovich K.Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy.Reading Research Quarterly. 1986;21:360-407.
65. Stecker P. M.,Fuchs L. S.,Fuchs D.Using curriculum-based measurement to improve student achievement: Review of research.Psychology in the Schools. 2005;42:795-820.
66. Stein M.,Johnson B.,Gutlohn L.Analyzing beginning reading programs: The relationship between decoding instruction and text.Remedial and Special Education. 1999;20:275-287.
67. Swanson H. L.Reading research for students with LD: A meta-analysis of intervention outcomes.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 1999;32 (6): 504-532.
68. Torgesen J. K.The voice of evidence in reading research. McCardle P.Chhabra V., ed. Baltimore, MD: Brookes; 2004:355-382.
69. Torgesen J. K.,Alexander A. W.,Wagner R. K.,Rashotte C. A.,Voeller K. K. S.,Conway T.Intensive remedial instruction for children with severe reading disabilities: Immediate and long-term outcomes from two instructional approaches.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2001;34 (1): 33 78-58.
70. Torgesen J. K.,Burgess S. R.Word recognition in beginning literacy. Metsala J. L.Ehri L. C., ed. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 1998:161-188.
71. Vadasy P. F.,Sanders E. A.,Peyton J. A.Paraeducator-supplemented instruction in structural analysis with text reading practice for second and third graders at risk for reading problems.Remedial and Special Education. 2006;27:365-378.
72. Vadasy P. F.,Sanders E. A.,Peyton J. A.,Jenkins J. R.Timing and intensity of tutoring: A closer look at the conditions for effective early literacy tutoring.Learning Disabilities Research & Practice. 2002;17 (4): 227-241.
73. Vadasy P. F.,Sanders E. A.,Tudor S.Effectiveness of paraeducator-supplemented individual instruction: Beyond basic decoding skills.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2007;40:508-525.
74. Vanderwood M. L.,Nam J.Handbook of response to intervention. Jimerson S. R.Burns M. K.VanDerHeyden A. M., ed. New York, NY: Springer; 2007:408-417.
75. Vaughn S.,Cirino P. T.,Linan-Thompson S.,Mathes P. G.,Carlson C. D.,Hagan E. C.,Francis D. J.Effectiveness of a Spanish intervention and an English intervention for English language learners at risk for reading problems.American Educational Research Journal. 2006;43:449-487.
76. Vaughn S.,Denton C. A.,Fletcher J. M.Why intensive interventions are necessary for students with severe reading difficulties.Psychology in the Schools. 2010;47 (5): 432-444.
77. Vaughn S.,Linan-Thompson S.,Hickman P.Response to instruction as a means of identifying students with reading/learning disabilities.Exceptional Children. 2003;69 (4): 391-409.
78. Vaughn S.,Linan-Thompson S.,Kouzekanani K.,Bryant D. P.,Dickson S.,Blozis S. A.Reading instruction grouping for students with reading difficulties.Remedial and Special Education. 2003;24:301-315.
79. Vaughn S.,Wanzek J.,Murray C. S.,Scammacca N.,Linan-Thompson S.,Woodruff A. L.Response to early reading intervention examining higher and lower responders.Exceptional Children. 2009;75 (2): 165-183.
80. Vellutino F. R.,Scanlon D. M.,Small S.,Fanuele D. P.Response to intervention as a vehicle for distinguishing between children with and without reading disabilities: Evidence for the role of kindergarten and first-grade interventions.Journal of Learning Disabilities. 2006;39 (2): 157-169.
81. Wanzek J.,Vaughn S.Research-based implications from extensive early reading interventions.School Psychology Review. 2007;36 (4): 541-561.
82. Wanzek J.,Wexler J.,Vaughn S.,Ciullo S.Reading interventions for struggling readers in the upper elementary grades: A synthesis of 20 years of research.Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal. 2010;23:889-912.