The Influence of Social Information on Children's Statistical and Causal Inferences

Advances in Child Development and Behavior

Volumn 43, Issue , 2012, Pages 321-350

  Sobel, David M ^a   Kirkham, Natasha Z ^b  

^a BROWN UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF LONDON   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Causal learning; Natural pedagogy; Social inferences; Statistical learning

Indexed keywords

EID: 84866751752     PISSN: 00652407     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book Series    
DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-12-397919-3.00012-5     Document Type: Chapter

References (128)

1. Allan L.G. A note on measurement of contingency between two binary variables in judgment tasks. Bulletin of the Psychonomic Society 1980, 15:147-149.
2. Beck S.R., Robinson E.J., Carroll D.J., Apperly I.A. Children's thinking about counterfactuals and future hypotheticals as possibilities. Child Development 2006, 77:413-426.
3. Biederman I. Recognition-by-components: a theory of human image understanding. Psychological Review 1987, 94:115-147.
4. Bonawitz, E., Denison, S., Chen, A., Gopnik, G., & Griffiths, T. L. (2011). A simple sequential algorithm for approximating Bayesian inference. Proceedings of the thirty-third cognitive science society.
5. Bonawitz E.B., Shafto P., Gweon H., Goodman N.D., Spelke E., Schulz L.E. The double-edged sword of pedagogy: teaching limits children's spontaneous exploration and discovery. Cognition 2011, 120:322-330.
6. Brugger A., Lariviere L.A., Mumme D.L., Bushnell E.W. Doing the right thing: infants' selection of actions to imitate from observed event sequences. Child Development 2007, 78:806-824.
7. Bruner J.S. The act of discovery. Harvard Educational Review 1961, 31:21-32.
8. Bruner J.S. Acts of meaning 1990, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
9. Bullock M., Gelman R., Baillargeon R. The development of causal reasoning. The developmental psychology of time 1982, 209-254. Academic Press, New York. W.J. Friedman (Ed.).
10. Butterfield J., Jenkins O.C., Sobel D.M., Schwertfuger J. Modeling aspects of theory of mind with Markov Random Fields. International Journal of Social Robotics 2009, 1:41-51.
11. Butterworth G. Joint visual attention in infancy. Theories of infant development 2004, 317-354. Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford. G. Bremner, A. Slater (Eds.).
12. Carpenter M., Nagell K., Tomasello M. Social cognition, joint attention, and communicative competence from 9- to 15-months of age. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 1998, 63.
13. Coady C.A.J. Testimony: A philosophical study 1992, Oxford University Press, New York.
14. Cohen L.B., Amsel G. Precursors to infants' perception of the causality of a simple event. Infant Behavior and Development 1998, 21:713-732.
15. Cohen L.B., Oakes L.M. How infants perceive simple causality. Developmental Psychology 1993, 29:421-433.
16. Cook C., Goodman N., Schulz L.E. Where science starts: spontaneous experiments in preschoolers' exploratory play. Cognition 2011, 120:341-349.
17. Csibra G., Gergely G. Social learning and social cogniton: the case for pedagogy. Processes of change in brain and cognitive development. Attention and performance 2006, vol. XXI:249-274. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Y. Munakata, M.H. Johnson (Eds.).
18. Csibra G., Gergely G. Natural pedagogy. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2009, 13:148-153.
19. Davies C.M. Development of the probability concept in children. Child Development 1965, 36:779-788.
20. Denison, S., Reed, C., &, Xu, F. (in press). The emergence of probabilistic reasoning in very young infants: evidence from 4.5- and 6-month-olds. Developmental Psychology.
21. Eaves B., Shafto P. Unifying pedagogical reasoning and epistemic trust. Advances in Child Development and Behavior 2012, F. Xu, T. Kushnir (Eds.).
22. Eisbach A.O. Children's developing awareness of the diversity in people's trains of thought. Child Development 2004, 75:1694-1707.
23. Elsner B., Aschersleben G. Do I get what you get? Learning about the effects of self-performed and observed actions in infancy. Consciousness and Cognition 2003, 12:732-751.
24. Estes K.G., Evans J.L., Alibali M.W., Saffran J.R. Can infants map meaning to newly segmented words? Statistical segmentation and word learning. Psychological Science 2007, 18:254-260.
25. Farroni T., Massaccesi S., Pividori D., Simion F., Johnson M.H. Gaze-following in newborns. Infancy 2004, 5:39-60.
26. Fawcett C., Markson L. Children reason about shared preferences. Developmental Psychology 2010, 46:299-309.
27. Fireman G., Kose G., Solomon M.J. Self-observation and learning: the effect of watching oneself on problem solving performance. Cognitive Development 2003, 18:339-354.
28. Fischbein E. The intuitive sources of probabilistic thinking in children 1975, Reidel, Boston, MA.
29. Fiser J., Aslin R.N. Statistical learning of new visual feature combinations by infants. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of The United States of America 2002, 99:15822-15826.
30. Flavell J.H., Green F.L., Flavell E.R. Young children's knowledge about thinking. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 1995, 60. (1, Series No. 243).
31. Flom R., Pick A.D. Gaze-following: its development and significance. Gaze following: Its development and significance 2007, 95-111. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. R. Flom, K. Lee, D. Muir (Eds.).
32. Gergely G., Bekkering H., Kiraly I. Rational imitation in preverbal infants. Nature 2002, 415:755-756.
33. Gliga T., Csibra G. One-year-old infants appreciate the referential nature of deictic gestures and words. Psychological Science 2009, 20:347-353.
34. Gopnik A., Astington J.W. Children's understanding of representational change and its relation to the understanding of false belief and the appearance-reality distinction. Child Development 1988, 59:26-37.
35. Gopnik A., Slaughter V. Young children's understanding of changes in their mental states. Child Development 1991, 62:98-110.
36. Gopnik A., Sobel D.M., Schulz L.E., Glymour C. Causal learning mechanisms in very young children: two, three, and four-year-olds infer causal relations from patterns of variation and covariation. Developmental Psychology 2001, 37:620-629.
37. Gredebäck, G., Melinder, A., & Daum, M. (in press). The development and neural basis of pointing comprehension. Social Neuroscience.
38. Griffiths T.L., Sobel D.M., Tenenbaum J.B., Gopnik A. Bayes and blickets: effects of knowledge on causal induction in children and adults. Cognitive Science 2011, 35:1407-1455.
39. Gweon H., Tenenbaum J.B., Schulz L.E. Infants consider both the sample and the sampling process in inductive generalization. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2010, 107:9066-9071.
40. Haith M.M. Future-oriented processes in infancy: the case of visual expectations. Visual perception and cognition in infancy 1993, 235-264. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. C. Granrud (Ed.).
41. Harris P.L., Koenig M.A. Trust in testimony: how children learn about science and religion. Child Development 2006, 77:505-524.
42. Herbert J., Gross J., Hayne H. Age-related changes in deferred imitation between 6 and 9 months of age. Infant Behavior and Development 2006, 29:136-139.
43. Hoemann H.W., Ross B.M. Children's understanding of probability concepts. Review of child development research 1971, Vol. 6:600-668. University of Chicago Press, Chicago. W.W. Hartup (Ed.).
44. Hoemann H.W., Ross B.M. Children's concepts of chance and probability. Children's logical and mathematical cognition 1982, 93-121. Springer, New York. C.J. Brainerd (Ed.).
45. Holyoak K.J., Cheng P.W. Causal learning and inference as a rational process: the new synthesis. Annual Review of Psychology 2011, 62:135-163.
46. Hood B.M., Willen J.D., Driver J. Adult's eyes trigger shifts of visual attention in human infants. Psychological Science 1998, 9:131-134.
47. Jaswal V.K., Neely L.A. Adults don't always know best: preschoolers use past reliability over age when learning new words. Psychological Science 2006, 17:757-758.
48. Johnson S.C., Slaughter V., Carey S. Whose gaze will infants follow? The elicitation of gaze-following in 12-month-olds. Developmental Science 1998, 1:233-238.
49. Johnson S.P., Amso D., Slemmer J.A. Development of object concepts in infancy: evidence for early learning in an eye tracking paradigm. Poceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of The United States of America 2003, 100:10568-10573.
50. Jones M., Love B.C. Bayesian fundamentalism or enlightenment? On the explanatory status and theoretical contributions of Bayesian models of cognition. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2011, 34:169-231.
51. Kingstone A., Smilek D., Ristic J., Friesen C.K., Eastwood J.D. Attention, researchers! It is time to take a look at the real world. Current Directions in Psychological Science 2003, 12:176-180.
52. Kinzler K.D., Corriveau K.H., Harris P.L. Children's selective trust in native accented speakers. Developmental Science 2011, 14:106-111.
53. Kirkham N.Z., Slemmer J.A., Johnson S.P. Visual statistical learning in infancy. Cognition 2002, 83:B35-B42.
54. Kirkham N.Z., Slemmer J.A., Richardson D.C., Johnson S.P. Location, location, location: development of spatiotemporal sequence learning in infancy. Child Development 2007, 78:1559-1571.
55. Koenig M.A., Harris P.L. Preschoolers mistrust ignorant and inaccurate speakers. Child Development 2005, 76:1261-1277.
56. Koenig M.A., Jaswal V.K. Characterizing children's expectations about expertise and incompetence: halo or pitchfork effects. Child Development 2011, 82:1634-1647.
57. Kosugi D., Ishida H., Fujita K. 10-month-old infants' inference of invisible agent: distinction in causality between object motion and human action. Japanese Psychological Research 2003, 45:15-24.
58. Kuhn D., Ho V. Self-directed activity and cognitive development. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology 1980, 1:119-133.
59. Kushnir T., Gopnik A. Young children infer causal strength from probabilities and interventions. Psychological Science 2005, 16:678-683.
60. Kushnir T., Gopnik A. Conditional probability versus spatial contiguity in causal learning: preschoolers use new contingency evidence to overcome prior spatial assumptions. Developmental Psychology 2007, 44:186-196.
61. Kushnir T., Wellman H.M., Gelman S.A The role of preschoolers' social understanding in evaluating the informativeness of causal interventions. Cognition 2008, 107:1084-1092.
62. Kushnir T., Xu F., Wellman H.M. Young children use statistical sampling to infer the preferences of other people. Psychological Science 2010, 21:1134-1140.
63. Kuzmak S.D., Gelman R. Young children's understanding of random phenomena. Child Development 1986, 57:559-566.
64. Lagnado D., Sloman S.A. The advantage of timely intervention. Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning Memory and Cognition 2004, 30:856-876.
65. Madole K.L., Cohen L.B. The role of object parts in infants' attention to form-function correlations. Developmental Psychology 1995, 31:637-648.
66. Mareschal D., Quinn P.C., French R.M. Asymmetric interference in 3- to 4-month-olds' sequential category learning. Cognitive Science 2002, 26:377-389.
67. Marr D. Vision: A computational investigation into the human representation and processing of visual information 1982, W.H. Freeman, San Francisco.
68. McClelland J.L., Thompson R.M. Using domain-general principles to explain children's causal reasoning abilities. Developmental Science 2007, 10:333-356.
69. Meltzoff A.N. Infant imitation and memory: nine-month-olds in immediate and deferred tests. Child Development 1988, 59:217-225.
70. Muentener P., Carey S. Infants' causal representations of state change events. Cognitive Psychology 2010, 61:63-86.
71. Nielsen M. Copying actions and copying outcomes: social learning through the second year. Developmental Psychology 2006, 42:555-565.
72. Oakes L.M. Development of infants' use of continuity cues in their perception of causality. Developmental Psychology 1994, 30:869-879.
73. Oakes L.M., Cohen L.B. Infant perception of a causal event. Cognitive Development 1990, 5:193-207.
74. Pasquini E.S., Corriveau K., Koenig M.A., Harris P.L. Preschoolers monitor the relative accuracy of informants. Developmental Psychology 2007, 43:1216-1222.
75. Perner J. Discrepant results in experimental studies of young children's understanding of probability. Child Development 1979, 50:1121-1127.
76. Piaget J., Inhelder B. The origins of the idea of chance in children 1975, (L. Leake, Jr., P. Burrell, & H. Fischbein, Trans.), Norton, New York, (Original work published in 1951).
77. Poulin-Dubois D., Demke T.L., Olineck K.M. The inquisitive eye: infants' implicit understanding that looking leads to knowing. Gaze-following: Its development and significance 2007, 263-281. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. R. Flom, K. Lee, D. Muir (Eds.).
78. Rakison D.H., Butterworth G.E. Infants' use of object parts in early categorization. Developmental Psychology 1998, 34:49-62.
79. Reid T. An inquiry into the human mind 1764/1970, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
80. Repacholi B.M., Gopnik A. Early reasoning about desires: evidence from 14- and 18-month-olds. Developmental Psychology 1997, 33:12-21.
81. Rozenblit L.R., Keil F.C. The misunderstood limits of folk science: an illusion of explanatory depth. Cognitive Science 2002, 26:521-562.
82. Saffran J.R., Aslin R.N., Newport E.L. Statistical learning by 8-month-old infants. Science 1996, 274:1926-1928.
83. Saxe R., Tenenbaum J.B., Carey S. Secret agents: inferences about hidden causes by 10- and 12-month-old infants. Psychological Science 2005, 16(12):995-1001.
84. Senju A., Csibra G. Gaze following in human infants depends on communicative signals. Current Biology 2008, 18:668-671.
85. Schlottman A. Children's probability intuitions: understanding the expected value of complex gambles. Child Development 2001, 72:103-122.
86. Schulz L.E., Bonawitz E.B. Serious fun: preschoolers play more when evidence is confounded. Developmental Psychology 2007, 43:1045-1050.
87. Schulz L.E., Gopnik A. Causal learning across domains. Developmental Psychology 2004, 40:162-176.
88. Schulz L.E., Gopnik A., Glymour C. Preschool children learn causal structure from conditional independence. Developmental Science 2007, 10:322-332.
89. Schulz L.E., Sommerville J.A. God does not play dice: causal determinism and preschoolers' causal inferences. Child Development 2006, 77:427-442.
90. Schwier C., van Maanen C., Carpenter M., Tomasello M. Rational imitation in 12-month-old infants. Infancy 2006, 10:303-311.
91. Schyns P.G., Rodet L. Categorization creates functional features. Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning Memory and Cognition 1997, 23:681-696.
92. Shafto P., Eaves B.S., Navarro D.J., Perfors A. Epistemic trust: Modeling children's reasoning about others' knowledge and intent. Developmental Science 2012, 15:436-447.
93. Shanks D.R. Is human learning rational?. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 1995, 48A:257-279.
94. Shultz T.R. Rules of causal attribution. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 1982, 47(1):1-51.
95. Sobel D.M., Buchanan D.W. Bridging the gap: causality at a distance in children's categorization and inferences about internal properties. Cognitive Development 2009, 24:274-283.
96. Sobel D.M., Buchanan D.W., Butterfield J., Jenkins O.C. Interactions between causal models, theories, and social cognitive development. Neural Networks 2010, 8(9):1060-1071.
97. Sobel D.M., Corriveau K.H. Children monitor individuals' expertise for word learning. Child Development 2010, 81:669-679.
98. Sobel D.M., Kirkham N.Z. Blickets and babies: the development of causal reasoning in toddlers and infants. Developmental Psychology 2006, 42:1103-1115.
99. Sobel D.M., Kirkham N.Z. Bayes nets and blickets: infants' developing representations of causal knowledge. Developmental Science 2007, 10:298-306.
100. Sobel D.M., Kirkham N.Z. Interactions between causal and statistical learning. Causal learning: Psychology, philosophy, and computation 2007, 139-153. Oxford University Press, New York. A. Gopnik, L.E. Schulz (Eds.).
101. Sobel D.M., Kushnir T. The importance of decision demands in causal learning from interventions. Memory & Cognition 2006, 34:411-419.
102. Sobel D.M., Munro S.A. Domain generality and specificity in children's causal inferences about ambiguous data. Developmental Psychology 2009, 45:511-524.
103. Sobel D.M., Sommerville J.A. Rationales in children's causal learning from others' actions. Cognitive Development 2009, 24:70-79.
104. Sobel D.M., Sommerville J.A. The importance of discovery in children's causal learning from interventions. Frontiers in Developmental Psychology 2010, 1:176-183.
105. Sobel D.M., Sommerville J.A., Travers L.V., Blumenthal E.J., Stoddard E. Preschoolers' use of others' beliefs to make causal inferences from probabilistic data. Journal of Cognition and Development 2009, 10:262-284.
106. Sobel D.M., Tenenbaum J.B., Gopnik A. Children's causal inferences from indirect evidence: backwards blocking and Bayesian reasoning in preschoolers. Cognitive Science 2004, 28:303-333.
107. Sobel D.M., Yoachim C.M., Gopnik A., Meltzoff A.N., Blumenthal E.J. The blicket within: preschoolers' inferences about insides and causes. Journal of Cognition and Development 2007, 8:159-182.
108. Sommerville J.A., Woodward A.L. Pulling out the intentional structure of action: the relation between action processing and action production in infancy. Cognition 2005, 95:1-30.
109. Sommerville J.A., Woodward A.L., Needham A. Action experience alters 3-month-old infants' perception of others' actions. Cognition 2005, 96:B1-B11.
110. Sophian C., Huber A. Early developments in children's causal judgments. Child Development 1984, 55:512-526.
111. Steyvers M., Tenenbaum J.B., Wagenmakers E.J., Blum B. Inferring causal networks from observations and interventions. Cognitive Science 2003, 27:453-489.
112. Striano T., Reid V.M. Social cognition in the first year. Trends in Cognitive Science 2006, 10:471-476.
113. Teglas E., Vul E., Girotto V., Gonzalez M., Tenenbaum J.B., Bonatti L.L. Pure reasoning in 12-month-old infants as probabilistic inference. Science 2011, 332:1054-1059.
114. Tenenbaum, J. B., & Griffiths, T. L. (2003). Theory-based causal inference. Proceedings of the 14th annual conference on the advances in neural information processing systems, Vancouver, CA.
115. Thiessen E.D. Domain general constraints on statistical learning. Child Development 2011, 82:462-470.
116. Tomasello M., Carpenter M., Liszkowski U. A new look at infant pointing. Child Development 2007, 78:705-722.
117. Varga, K., Frick, J.E., Stansky, L., Beck, H., Dengler, M.J., & Bright, M.A. (2009). I saw the sign: the development of directional understanding. In Poster presented at the meeting of the society for research in child development, Denver, CO.
118. Vecera S.R., Johnson M.H. Gaze detection and the cortical processing of faces: evidence from infants and adults. Visual Cognition 1995, 2:59-87.
119. Vygotsky L.S. Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes 1978, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
120. Weber M. Basic concepts in sociology 1962/1925, Citadel Press, New York.
121. Wellman H.M., Cross D., Watson J.K. A meta-analysis of theory of mind: the truth about false belief. Child Development 2001, 72:655-684.
122. Wellman H.M., Woolley J.D. From simple desires to ordinary beliefs: the early development of everyday psychology. Cognition 1990, 35:245-275.
123. Wu R., Kirkham N.Z. No two cues are alike: depth of learning during infancy is dependent on what orients attention. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 2010, 107:118-136.
124. Wu R., Gopnik A., Richardson D.C., Kirkham N.Z. Infants learn about objects from statistics and people. Developmental Psychology 2011, 47:1220-1229.
125. Xu F., Denison S. Statistical inference and sensitivity to sampling in 11-month-old infants. Cognition 2009, 112:97-104.
126. Xu F., Garcia V. Intuitive statistics by 8-month-old infants. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2008, 105:5012-5015.
127. Yang, D.J., Bushnell, E.W., Buchanan, D.W., & Sobel, D.M. Infants' use of contextual cues in imitation and generalization of effective causal actions. Manuscript submitted for publication, Brown University.
128. Younger B.A., Cohen L.B. Developmental changes in infants' perception of correlations among attributes. Child Development 1986, 57:803-815.