Experimental design methods for bioengineering applications

Critical Reviews in Biotechnology

Volumn 36, Issue 2, 2016, Pages 368-388

  Gündoʇdu, Tuʇba Keskin ^a   Deniz, ̄rem ^a   Çalişkan, Gülizar ^a   Şahin, Erdem Sefa ^a   Azbar, Nuri ^a  

^a EGE UNIVERSITY   (Turkey)

Author keywords

Bioprocess; Box Behnken design; Central composite design; Full factorial design; Placket Burrman design; Taguchi design

Indexed keywords

STATISTICS;

BIOPROCESSES; BOX-BEHNKEN DESIGN; CENTRAL COMPOSITE DESIGNS; FULL FACTORIAL DESIGN; TAGUCHI DESIGN;

DESIGN;

BIOENGINEERING; BIOPROCESS; BOX BEHNKEN DESIGN; CENTRAL COMPOSITE DESIGN; EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN; FACTORIAL DESIGN; HUMAN; NONHUMAN; PLACKETT BURMAN DESIGN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RESPONSE SURFACE METHOD; REVIEW; TAGUCHI DESIGN; METHODOLOGY; STATISTICAL MODEL;

BIOENGINEERING; MODELS, STATISTICAL; RESEARCH DESIGN;

EID: 84954496587     PISSN: 07388551     EISSN: 15497801     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3109/07388551.2014.973014     Document Type: Review

References (105)

1. Adnani A, Basri M, Malek EA, et al. (2010). Optimization of lipasecatalyzed synthesis of xylitol ester by Taguchi robust design method. Ind Crops Prod, 31, 350-6.
2. Ahmadi M, Vahabzadeh F, Bonakdarpour B, et al. (2005). Application of the central composite design and response surface methodology to the advanced treatment of olive oil processing wastewater using Fenton's peroxidation. J Hazard Mater, 123, 187-95.
3. Akgun I, Erkucuk A, Pilavtepe M, Yesil-Celiktas O. (2011). Optimization of total alkannin yields of Alkanna tinctoria by using sub-and supercritical carbon dioxide extraction. J Supercrit Fluids, 57, 31-7.
4. Antony J. (1997). Experiments in quality. J Manuf Eng, 76, 272-5.
5. Bajpai S, Gupta S, Dey A, et al. (2012). Application of Central Composite Design approach for removal of chromium (VI). from aqueous solution using weakly anionic resin: modeling, optimization, and study of interactive variables. J Hazard Mater, 227, 436-44.
6. Bankar SB, Singhal RS. (2010). Optimization of poly-lysine production by Streptomyces noursei NRRL 5126. Bioresource Technol, 101, 8370-5.
7. Basak B, Bhunia B, Dutta S, Dey A. (2013). Enhanced biodegradation of 4-chlorophenol by Candida tropicalis PHB5 via optimization of physicochemical parameters using Taguchi orthogonal array approach. Int Biodeter Biodegrad, 78, 17-23.
8. Biswas R, Sahai V, Mishra S, Bisaria VS. (2010). Bioprocess strategies for enhanced production of xylanase by Melanocarpus albomyces IITD3A on agro-residual extract. J Biosci Bioeng, 110, 702-8.
9. Boey PL, Maniam GP, Hamid SA, Ali DMH. (2011). Utilization of waste cockle shell (Anadara granosa). in biodiesel production from palm olein: optimization using response surface methodology. Fuel, 90, 2353-8.
10. Briggs B. (2011). Three quarter Plackett-Burman designs for estimating all main effects and two-factor interactions. Richmond (VA): Virginia Commonwealth University.
11. Chavalparit O, Ongwandee M. (2009). Optimizing electrocoagulation process for the treatment of biodiesel wastewater using response surface methodology. J Environ Sci, 21, 1491-6.
12. Chen Q, He G, Ali MAM. (2002). Optimization of medium composition for the production of elastase by Bacillus sp. EL31410 with response surface methodology. Enzyme Microb Technol, 30, 667-72.
13. Chen Q, Ni J. (2012). Ammonium removal by Agrobacterium sp. LAD9 capable of heterotrophic nitrification-aerobic denitrification. J Biosci Bioeng, 113, 619-23.
14. Cheng YS, Zheng Y, Yu CW, et al. (2010). Evaluation of high solids alkaline pretreatment of rice straw. Appl Biochem Biotechnol, 162, 1768-84.
15. Choorit W, Saikeur A, Chodok P, et al. (2011). Production of biomass and extracellular 5-aminolevulinic acid by Rhodopseudomonas palustris KG31 under light and dark conditions using volatile fatty acid. J Biosci Bioeng, 111, 658-64.
16. Chowdhurya A, Chakrabortyb R, Mitraa D, Biswasa D. (2014). Optimization of the production parameters of octyl ester biolubricant using Taguchi's design method and physico-chemical characterization of the product. Ind Crops Prod, 52, 783-9.
17. Coban I, Sargin S, Celiktas MS, Yesil-Celiktas O. (2012). Bioethanol production from raffinate phase of supercritical CO2 extracted Stevia rebaudiana leaves. Bioresource Technol, 120, 52-9.
18. Correa FA, Sutili FK, Miranda LSM, et al. (2012). Epoxidation of oleic acid catalyzed by PSCI-Amano lipase optimized by experimental design. J Mol Catal B Enzymatic, 81, 7-11.
19. da Cunha MA, Converti A, Santos JC, et al. (2009). PVA-hydrogel entrapped Candida guilliermondii for xylitol production from sugarcane hemicellulose hydrolysate. Appl Biochem Biotechnol, 157, 527-37.
20. Da Rós PC, de Castro HF, Carvalho AK, et al. (2012). Microwaveassisted enzymatic synthesis of beef tallow biodiesel. J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol, 39, 529-36.
21. Dagnino E, Chamorro E, Romano S, et al. (2013). Optimization of the acid pretreatment of rice hulls to obtain fermentable sugars for bioethanol production. Ind Crops Prod, 42, 363-8.
22. Das A, Paul T, Halder SK, et al. (2012). Production of cellulolytic enzymes by Aspergillus fumigatus ABK9 in wheat bran-rice straw mixed substrate and use of cocktail enzymes for deinking of waste office paper pulp. Bioresource Technol, 128, 290-6.
23. Das Mohapatra P, Maity C, Rao R, et al. (2009). Tannase production by Bacillus licheniformis KBR6: optimization of submerged culture conditions by Taguchi DOE methodology. Food Res Int, 424, 430-5.
24. de Araújo Viana D, de Albuquerque Lima C, Neves RP, et al. (2010). Production and stability of protease from Candida buinensis. Appl Biochem Biotechnol, 162, 830-42.
25. Domingues LCG, Teodoro JC, Hokka CO, et al. (2010). Optimisation of the glycerol-to-ornithine molar ratio in the feed medium for the continuous production of clavulanic acid by Streptomyces clavuligerus. Biochem Eng J, 53, 7-11.
26. Donzelli BGG, Siebert KJ, Harman GE. (2005). Response surface modeling of factors influencing the production of chitinolytic and b-1, 3-glucanolytic enzymes in Trichoderma atroviride strain P1. Enzyme Microb Technol, 37, 82-92.
27. Erkucuk A, Akgun I, Yesil-Celiktas O. (2009). Supercritical CO2 extraction of glycosides from Stevia rebaudiana leaves: identification and optimization. J Supercrit Fluids, 51, 29-35.
28. Fakhfakh-Zouari N, Haddar A, Hmidet N, et al. (2010). Application of statistical experimental design for optimization of keratinases production by Bacillus pumilus A1 grown on chicken feather and some biochemical properties. Process Biochem, 45, 617-26.
29. Ferreira HS, Matos GD, David JM, et al. (2007). Box-Behnken design: an alternative for the optimization of analytical methods, S.L.C. Ferreira, R.E. Bruns. Anal Chim Acta, 597, 179-86.
30. Fisher RA. (1935). The design of experiments. Oxford, England: Oliver & Boyd. 251 p.
31. Fontes GC, Amaral F, Filomena P, et al. (2010). Factorial design to optimize biosurfactant production by Yarrowia lipolytica. J Biomed Biotechnol, 2010, 1-8.
32. Gao H, Liu M, Liu J, et al. (2009). Medium optimization for the production of avermectin B1a by Streptomyces avermitilis 14-12A using response surface methodology. Bioresource Technol, 100, 4012-16.
33. Gharibzahedi SMT, Razavi SH, Mousavi SM, Moayedi V. (2012). High efficiency canthaxanthin production by a novel mutant isolated from Dietzia natronolimnaea HS-1 using central composite design analysis. Ind Crops Prod, 40, 345-54.
34. Ghosh D, Sobro IF, Hallenbeck PC. (2012). Optimization of the hydrogen yield from single-stage photofermentation of glucose by Rhodobacter capsulatus JP91 using response surface methodology. Bioresource Technol, 123, 199-206.
35. Gonzalez-Mira E, Egea M, Souto E, et al. (2010). Optimizing flurbiprofen-loaded NLC by central composite factorial design for ocular delivery. Nanotechnology, 22, 045101.
36. Haddar A, Driss D, Frikha F, et al. (2012). Alkaline xylanases from Bacillus mojavensis A21: production and generation of xylooligosaccharides. Int J Biol Macromol, 51, 647-56.
37. Hao J, Wang F, Wang X, et al. (2012). Development and optimization of baicalin-loaded solid lipid nanoparticles prepared by coacervation method using central composite design. Eur J Pharm Sci, 47, 497-505.
38. Harun R, Danquah MK. (2011). Influence of acid pre-treatment on microalgal biomass for bioethanol production. Process Biochem, 46, 304-9.
39. Heck JX, Flores SH, Hertz PF, Ayub MAZ. (2005). Optimization of cellulase-free xylanase activity produced by Bacillus coagulans BL69 in solid-state cultivation. Process Biochem, 40, 107-12.
40. Hendry D, Venkitasamy C, Wilkinson N, Jacoby W. (2011). Exploration of the effect of process variables on the production of high-value fuel gas from glucose via supercritical water gasification. Bioresource Technol, 102, 3480-7.
41. Herculano PN, Porto TS, Moreira KA, et al. (2011). Cellulase production by Aspergillus japonicus URM5620 using waste from castor bean (Ricinus communis L.). under solid-state fermentation. Appl Biochem Biotechnol, 165, 1057-67.
42. Hollebeeck S, Borlon F, Schneider YJ, et al. (2012). Development of a standardized human in vitro digestion protocol based on macronutrient digestion using response surface methodology. Food Chem, 138, 1936-44.
43. Hong CW. (2012). Using the Taguchi method for effective market segmentation. Expert Syst Appl, 39, 5451-9.
44. Horchani H, Chaabouni M, Gargouri Y, Sayari A. (2010). Solvent-free lipase-catalyzed synthesis of long-chain starch esters using microwave heating: optimization by response surface methodology. Carbohydr Polym, 79, 466-74.
45. Huguet L, Carteret C, Gantzer C. (2012). A comparison of different concentration methods for the detection of viruses present in bottled waters and those adsorbed to water bottle surfaces. J Virol Methods, 181, 18-24.
46. Isleten-Hosoglu M, Gultepe I, Elibol M. (2012). Optimization of carbon and nitrogen sources for biomass and lipid production by Chlorella saccharophila under heterotrophic conditions and development of Nile red fluorescence based method for quantification of its neutral lipid content. Biochem Eng J, 61, 11-19.
47. Jin X, Zhang Y, Xiao L, Zhao Z. (2008). Optimization of extended zeroorder release gliclazide tablets using D-optimal mixture design. Yakugaku Zasshi, 128, 1475-83.
48. John PW. (1996). Nesting Plackett-Burman designs. Stat Prob Lett, 27, 221-3.
49. Ju H-Y, Kuo C-H, Too J-R, et al. (2012). A green peptide synthesis-using a magnetic biocatalyst in a stirred-tank bioreactor. Biocatal Agric Biotechnol, 1, 20-4.
50. Kammoun R, Naili B, Bejar S. (2008). Application of a statistical design to the optimization of parameters and culture medium for a-amylase production by Aspergillus oryzae CBS 819.72 grown on gruel (wheat grinding by-product). Bioresource Technol, 99, 5602-9.
51. Larentis AL, Argondizzo APC, Esteves GS, et al. (2011). Cloning and optimization of induction conditions for mature PsaA (pneumococcal surface adhesin A). expression in Escherichia coli and recombinant protein stability during long-term storage. Protein Expr Purif, 78, 38-47.
52. Lawson J. (2010). Design and analysis of experiments with SAS. UK: Chapman & Hall/CRC Taylor & Francis Group.
53. Lee H, Yunus R, Juan J, Taufiq-Yap Y. (2011). Process optimization design for jatropha-based biodiesel production using response surface methodology. Fuel Process Technol, 92, 2420-8.
54. Li W, Rasmussen HT. (2003). Strategy for developing and optimizing liquid chromatography methods in pharmaceutical development using computer-assisted screening and Plackett-Burman experimental design. J Chromatogr A, 1016, 165-80.
55. Lim M, Ye H, Panoskaltsis N, et al. (2007). Intelligent bioprocessing for haemotopoietic cell cultures using monitoring and design of experiments. Biotechnol Adv, 25, 353-68.
56. Majumder A, Singh A, Goyal A. (2009). Application of response surface methodology for glucan production from Leuconostoc dextranicum and its structural characterization. Carbohydr Polym, 75, 150-6.
57. Marques DV, Torres BR, Porto ALF, et al. (2009). Comparison of oxygen mass transfer coefficient in simple and extractive fermentation systems. Biochem Eng J, 47, 122-6.
58. Martnez-Cardeñas JA, Norma M, Salcedo-Hernández R, et al. (2012). Effects of physical culture parameters on bacteriocin production by Mexican strains of Bacillus thuringiensis after cellular induction. J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol, 39, 183-9.
59. Mendes LF, Vale LA, Martins AP, et al. (2012). Influence of temperature, light and nutrients on the growth rates of the macroalga Gracilaria domingensis in synthetic seawater using experimental design. J Appl Phycol, 24, 1419-26.
60. Mohan SV, Raghavulu SV, Mohanakrishna G, et al. (2009). Optimization and evaluation of fermentative hydrogen production and wastewater treatment processes using data enveloping analysis (DEA). and Taguchi design of experimental (DOE). methodology. Int J Hydrogen Energy, 34, 216-26.
61. Mohan SV, Venkateswar-Reddy M. (2012). Optimization of critical factors to enhance polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA). synthesis by mixed culture using Taguchi design of experimental methodology. Bioresource Technol, 128, 409-16.
62. Mona S, Kaushik A, Kaushik C. (2011). Biosorption of chromium (VI). by spent cyanobacterial biomass from a hydrogen fermentor using Box-Behnken model. Int Biodeter Biodegrad, 65, 656-63.
63. Montgomery DC. (2008). Design and analysis of experiments, 7th ed. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated.
64. Mousavi S, Yaghmaei S, Jafari A, et al. (2007). Optimization of ferrous biooxidation rate in a packed bed bioreactor using Taguchi approach. Chem Eng Process Process Intens, 46, 935-40.
65. Muthukumar M, Sargunamani D, Selvakumar N, Venkata Rao J. (2004). Optimisation of ozone treatment for colour and COD removal of acid dye effluent using central composite design experiment. Dyes Pigments, 63, 127-34.
66. Nalakath AH, Veiga MC, Kennes C. (2012). Biological conversion of carbon monoxide to ethanol: Effect of pH, gas pressure, reducing agent and yeast extract. Bioresource Technol, 114, 518-22.
67. Narang S, Sahai V, Bisaria VS. (2001). Optimization of xylanase production by Melanocarpus albomyces IIS68 in solid state fermentation using response surface methodology. J Biosci Bioeng, 91, 425-7.
68. Niklas J, Priesnitz C, Rose T, et al. (2012). Primary metabolism in the new human cell line AGE1 HN at various substrate levels: increased metabolic efficiency and a1-antitrypsin production at reduced pyruvate load. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 93, 1637-50.
69. Palvannan T, Sathishkumar P. (2010). Production of laccase from Pleurotus florida NCIM 1243 using Plackett-Burman design and response surface methodology. J Basic Microbiol, 50, 325-35.
70. Prakash G, Srivastava AK. (2005). Statistical media optimization for cell growth and azadirachtin production in Azadirachta indica (A. Juss). suspension cultures. Process Biochem, 40, 3795-800.
71. Prasad KK, Mohan SV, Rao RS, et al. (2005). Laccase production by Pleurotus ostreatus 1804: optimization of submerged culture conditions by Taguchi DOE methodology. Biochem Eng J, 24, 17-26.
72. Qu W, Ma H, Pan Z, et al. (2010). Preparation and antihypertensive activity of peptides from Porphyra yezoensis. Food Chem, 123, 14-20.
73. Radmann E, Reinehr C, Costa J. (2007). Optimization of the repeated batch cultivation of microalga Spirulina platensis in open raceway ponds. Aquaculture, 265, 118-26.
74. Rahnama F, Vasheghani-Farahani E, Yazdian F, Shojaosadati SA. (2012). PHB production by Methylocystis hirsuta from natural gas in a bubble column and a vertical loop bioreactor. Biochem Eng J, 65, 51-6.
75. Rao RS, Kumar CG, Prakasham RS, Hobbs PJ. (2008). The Taguchi methodology as a statistical tool for biotechnological applications: a critical appraisal. Biotechnol J, 3, 510-23.
76. Ray S, Reaume SJ, Lalman JA. (2010). Developing a statistical model to predict hydrogen production by a mixed anaerobic mesophilic culture. Int J Hydrogen Energy, 35, 5332-42.
77. Roy S, Ghosh S, Das D. (2012). Improvement of hydrogen production with thermophilic mixed culture from rice spent wash of distillery industry. Int J Hydrogen Energy, 37, 15867-74.
78. Ruiz HA, Silva DP, Ruzene DS, et al. (2011). Bioethanol production from hydrothermal pretreated wheat straw by a flocculating Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain-effect of process conditions. Fuel, 95, 528-36.
79. Santis-Navarro A, Gea T, Barrena R, Sánchez A. (2011). Production of lipases by solid state fermentation using vegetable oil-refining wastes. Bioresource Technol, 102, 21, 10080-4.
80. Sathya G, Naidu N, Panda T. (1998). Application of response surface methodology to evaluate some aspects on stability of pectolytic enzymes from Aspergillus niger. Biochem Eng J, 2, 71-7.
81. Sharma RK, Arora DS. (2010). Production of lignocellulolytic enzymes and enhancement of in vitro digestibility during solid state fermentation of wheat straw by Phlebia floridensis. Bioresource Technol, 101, 9248-53.
82. Shen CF, Kamen A. (2012). Hyperosmotic pressure on HEK 293 cells during the growth phase, but not the production phase, improves adenovirus production. J Biotechnol, 157, 228-36.
83. Sifour M, Zaghloul TI, Saeed HM, et al. (2010). Enhanced production of lipase by the thermophilic Geobacillus stearothermophilus strain-5 using statistical experimental designs. N Biotechnol, 27, 330-6.
84. Silva EM, Da Silva JS, Pena RS, Rogez H. (2011). A combined approach to optimize the drying process of flavonoid-rich leaves (Inga edulis). using experimental design and mathematical modelling. Food Bioprod Process, 89, 39-46.
85. Silva JPA, Mussatto SI, Roberto IC. (2010). The influence of initial xylose concentration, agitation, and aeration on ethanol production by Pichia stipitis from rice straw hemicellulosic hydrolysate. Appl Biochem Biotechnol, 162, 1306-15.
86. Singh A, Bishnoi NR. (2012). Enzymatic hydrolysis optimization of microwave alkali pretreated wheat straw and ethanol production by yeast. Bioresource Technol, 108, 94-101.
87. Singh A, Bishnoi NR. (2013). Ethanol production from pretreated wheat straw hydrolyzate by Saccharomyces cerevisiae via sequential statistical optimization. Ind Crops Products, 41, 221-6.
88. Song Z, Yang G, Han X, et al. (2012). Optimization of the alkaline pretreatment of rice straw for enhanced methane yield. BioMed Res Int, 2013, 968692.
89. Tari C, Ustok FI, Harsa S. (2010). Production of food grade b-galactosidase from artisanal yogurt strains. Food Biotechnol, 24, 78-94.
90. Tarley CRT, Silveira G, dos Santos WNL, et al. (2009). Chemometric tools in electroanalytical chemistry: methods for optimization based on factorial design and response surface methodology. Microchem J, 92, 58-67.
91. Teng Y, Xu Y. (2008). Culture condition improvement for whole-cell lipase production in submerged fermentation by Rhizopus chinensis using statistical method. Bioresource Technol, 99, 3900-7.
92. Vatanara A, Rouholamini Najafabadi A, Gilani K, et al. (2007). A Plackett-Burman design for screening of the operation variables in the formation of salbutamol sulphate particles by supercritical antisolvent. J Supercrit Fluids, 40, 111-16.
93. Venkata-Dasu V, Panda T, Chidambaram M. (2003). Determination of significant parameters for improved griseofulvin production in a batch bioreactor by Taguchi's method. Process Biochem, 38, 877-80.
94. Vicente G, Coteron A, Martinez M, Aracil J. (1998). Application of the factorial design of experiments and response surface methodology to optimize biodiesel production. Ind Crops Prod, 8, 29-35.
95. Wang J, Wan W. (2009). Experimental design methods for fermentative hydrogen production: a review. Int J Hydrogen Energy, 34, 235-44.
96. Wang J, Wan W. (2011). Combined effects of temperature and pH on biohydrogen production by anaerobic digested sludge. Biomass Bioenergy, 35, 3896-901.
97. Wang KS, Chen JH, Huang YH, Huang SL. (2012). Integrated Taguchi method and response surface methodology to confirm hydrogen production by anaerobic fermentation of cow manure. Int J Hydrogen Energy, 38, 45-53.
98. Xu TJ, Ting YP. (2004). Optimisation on bioleaching of incinerator fly ash by Aspergillus niger-use of central composite design. Enzyme Microb Technol, 35, 444-54.
99. Yatsyshyn VY, Fedorovych DV, Sibirny AA. (2010). Medium optimization for production of flavin mononucleotide by the recombinant strain of the yeast Candida famata using statistical designs. Biochem Eng J, 49, 52-60.
100. Yin X, You Q, Jiang Z. (2011). Optimization of enzyme assisted extraction of polysaccharides from Tricholoma matsutake by response surface methodology. Carbohydr Polym, 86, 1358-64.
101. Yücel Y. (2012). Optimization of biocatalytic biodiesel production from pomace oil using response surface methodology. Fuel Process Technol, 99, 97-102.
102. Zain WS, Illias RM, Salleh MM, et al. (2007). Production of cyclodextrin glucanotransferase from alkalophilic Bacillus sp TS1-1: optimization of carbon and nitrogen concentration in the feed medium using central composite design. Biochem Eng J, 33, 26-33.
103. Zeng X, Small DP, Wan W. (2011). Statistical optimization of culture conditions for bacterial cellulose production by Acetobacter xylinum BPR 2001 from maple syrup. Carbohydr Polym, 85, 506-13.
104. Zhang C, Fan D, Shang La, et al. (2010). Optimization of fermentation process for human-like collagen production of recombinant Escherichia coli using response surface methodology. Chin J Chem Eng, 18, 137-42.
105. Zolgharneina J, Asanjrania N, Bagtasha M, Azimib G. (2014). Multiresponse optimization using Taguchi design and principle component analysis for removing binary mixture of alizarin red and alizarin yellow from aqueous solution by nano g-alumina. Spectrochim Acta A Mol Biomol Spectrosc, 126, 291-300.