The learning effects of computer simulations in science education

Computers and Education

Volumn 58, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 136-153

  Rutten, Nico ^a   Van Joolingen, Wouter R ^a   Van Der Veen, Jan T ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TWENTE   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Interactive learning environments; Secondary education; Simulations

Indexed keywords

EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH; INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT; INTERACTIVE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT; LEARNING EFFECTS; LEARNING PROCESS; SCIENCE EDUCATION; SIMULATIONS; TRADITIONAL INSTRUCTION;

COMPUTATIONAL METHODS; CURRICULA;

COMPUTER SIMULATION;

EID: 80052544535     PISSN: 03601315     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.compedu.2011.07.017     Document Type: Article

References (76)

1. S. Ainsworth, and N. VanLabeke Multiple forms of dynamic representation Learning and Instruction 14 3 2004 241 255 (Pubitemid 39216287)
2. J.P. Akpan Issues associated with inserting computer simulations into biology instruction: a review of the literature Electronic Journal of Science Education 5 3 2001 Retrieved from: http://ejse.southwestern.edu/article/ viewArticle/7656/5423
3. L. Alfieri, P.J. Brooks, N.J. Aldrich, and H.R. Tenenbaum Does discovery-based instruction enhance learning? Journal of Educational Psychology 103 1 2011 1 18
4. K.B. Baltzis, and K.D. Koukias using laboratory experiments and circuit simulation IT tools in an undergraduate course in analog electronics Journal of Science Education and Technology 18 6 2009 546 555
5. S.A. Barab, B. Scott, S. Siyahhan, R. Goldstone, and A. Ingram-Goble Transformational play as a curricular scaffold: using videogames to support science education Journal of Science Education and Technology 18 4 2009 305 320
6. R.L. Bell, and K.C. Trundle The use of a computer simulation to promote scientific conceptions of moon phases Journal of Research in Science Teaching 45 3 2008 346 372 (Pubitemid 351456613)
7. T. Bell, D. Urhahne, S. Schanze, and R. Ploetzner Collaborative inquiry learning: models, tools, and challenges International Journal of Science Education 32 3 2010 349 377
8. D. Birchfield, and C. Megowan-Romanowicz Earth science learning in SMALLab: a design experiment for mixed reality International Journal of Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning 4 4 2009 403 421
9. C. Blake, and E. Scanlon Reconsidering simulations in science education at a distance: features of effective use Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 23 6 2007 491 502
10. K.E. Chang, Y.L. Chen, H.Y. Lin, and Y.T. Sung Effects of learning support in simulation-based physics learning Computers & Education 51 4 2008 1486 1498
11. D. Clark, and D. Jorde Helping students revise disruptive experientially supported ideas about thermodynamics: computer visualizations and tactile models Journal of Research in Science Teaching 41 1 2004 1 23
12. B. Dalgarno, A.G. Bishop, W. Adlong, and D.R. Bedgood Effectiveness of a virtual laboratory as a preparatory resource for distance education chemistry students Computers & Education 53 3 2009 853 865
13. T. de Jong, and W.R. van Joolingen Scientific discovery learning with computer simulations of conceptual domains Review of Educational Research 68 2 1998 179 201
14. P. Dillenbourg Integrating technologies into educational ecosystems Distance Education 29 2 2008 127 140
15. Y.J. Dori, and J. Belcher How does technology-enabled active learning affect undergraduate students' understanding of electromagnetism concepts? Journal of the Learning Sciences 14 2 2005 243 279
16. M.J. Duran, S. Gallardo, S.L. Toral, R. Martinez-Torres, and F.J. Barrero A learning methodology using Matlab/Simulink for undergraduate electrical engineering courses attending to learner satisfaction outcomes International Journal of Technology and Design Education 17 1 2007 55 73 (Pubitemid 46405857)
17. Education Resources Information Center. (2011). Retrieved 14.04.11.: http://www.eric.ed.gov
18. N.D. Finkelstein, W.K. Adams, C.J. Keller, P.B. Kohl, K.K. Perkins, and N.S. Podolefsky When learning about the real world is better done virtually: a study of substituting computer simulations for laboratory equipment Physical Review Special Topics-Physics Education Research 1 10103 2005 1 8
19. N.D. Finkelstein, W.K. Adams, C.J. Keller, K.K. Perkins, and C.E. Wieman High-tech tools for teaching physics: the physics education technology project Physics Education 2 3 2006 110 120
20. Z. Fund The effects of scaffolded computerized science problem-solving on achievement outcomes: a comparative study of support programs Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 23 5 2007 410 424
21. E. Gazit, Y. Yair, and D. Chen Emerging conceptual understanding of complex astronomical phenomena by using a virtual solar system Journal of Science Education and Technology 14 5 2005 459 470 (Pubitemid 43305749)
22. H. Gelbart, G. Brill, and A. Yarden The impact of a web-based research simulation in bioinformatics on students' understanding of genetics Research in Science Education 39 5 2009 725 751
23. N.J. Gibbons, C. Evans, A. Payne, K. Shah, and D.K. Griffin Computer simulations improve university instructional laboratories Cell Biology Education 3 4 2004 263 269 (Pubitemid 40412634)
24. M.L. Gick, and K.J. Holyoak Analogical problem solving Cognitive Psychology 12 3 1980 306 355
25. M.L. Gick, and K.J. Holyoak Schema induction and analogical transfer Cognitive Psychology 15 1 1983 1 38
26. R.L. Goldstone, and J.Y. Son The transfer of scientific principles using concrete and idealized simulations Journal of the Learning Sciences 14 1 2005 69 110 (Pubitemid 40167019)
27. J. Gonzalez-Cruz, R. Rodriguez-Sotres, and M. Rodriguez-Penagos On the convenience of using a computer simulation to teach enzyme kinetics to undergraduate students with biological chemistry-related curricula Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Education 31 2 2003 93 101 (Pubitemid 44132695)
28. T.N. Höffler, and D. Leutner Instructional animation versus static pictures: a meta-analysis Learning and Instruction 17 6 2007 722 738
29. ISI Web of Knowledge. (2011). Retrieved 18.03.11.: http://www. isiknowledge.com
30. A. Jimoyiannis, and V. Komis Computer simulations in physics teaching and learning: a case study on students' understanding of trajectory motion Computers & Education 36 2 2001 183 204 (Pubitemid 33673517)
31. L. Kester, P. Kirschner, and J. van Merrienboer Information presentation and troubleshooting in electrical circuits International Journal of Science Education 26 2 2004 239 256 Research Report (Pubitemid 38237496)
32. D.J. Ketelhut, and B.C. Nelson Designing for real-world scientific inquiry in virtual environments Educational Research 52 2 2010 151 167
33. D.J. Ketelhut, B.C. Nelson, J. Clarke, and C. Dede A multi-user virtual environment for building and assessing higher order inquiry skills in science British Journal of Educational Technology 41 1 2010 56 68
34. J.K. Kiboss, M. Ndirangu, and E.W. Wekesa Effectiveness of a computer-mediated simulations program in school biology on pupils' learning outcomes in cell theory Journal of Science Education and Technology 13 2 2004 207 213
35. P.A. Kirschner, J. Sweller, and R.E. Clark Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: an analysis of the failure of constructivist, discovery, problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching Educational Psychologist 41 2 2006 75 86 (Pubitemid 43837408)
36. M.J. Laakso, N. Myller, and A. Korhonen Comparing learning performance of students using algorithm visualizations collaboratively on different engagement levels Educational Technology & Society 12 2 2009 267 282
37. A.W. Lazonder, P. Wilhelm, and E. van Lieburg Unraveling the influence of domain knowledge during simulation-based inquiry learning Instructional Science 37 5 2009 437 451
38. H. Lee Instructional design of web-based Simulations for learners with different levels of spatial ability Instructional Science 35 6 2007 467 479
39. M. Limniou, N. Papadopoulos, A. Giannakoudakis, D. Roberts, and O. Otto The integration of a viscosity simulator in a chemistry laboratory Chemistry Education Research and Practice 8 2 2007 220 231
40. M. Limniou, N. Papadopoulos, and C. Whitehead Integration of simulation into pre-laboratory chemical course: computer cluster versus WebCT Computers & Education 52 1 2009 45 52
41. R. Lindgren, and D. Schwartz Spatial Learning and computer simulations in science International Journal of Science Education 31 3 2009 419 438
42. S. Manlove, A.W. Lazonder, and T. de Jong Regulative support for collaborative scientific inquiry learning Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 22 2 2006 87 98 (Pubitemid 44058600)
43. S. Manlove, A.W. Lazonder, and T. de Jong Collaborative versus individual use of regulative software scaffolds during scientific inquiry learning Interactive Learning Environments 17 2 2009 105 117
44. P. Martinez-Jimenez, A. Pontes-Pedrajas, J. Polo, and M.S. Climent-Bellido Learning in chemistry with virtual laboratories Journal of Chemical Education 80 3 2003 346 352
45. S.B. McKagan, W. Handley, K.K. Perkins, and C.E. Wieman A research-based curriculum for teaching the photoelectric effect American Journal of Physics 77 1 2009 87 94
46. E. Meir, J. Perry, D. Stal, S. Maruca, and E. Klopfer How effective are simulated molecular-level experiments for teaching diffusion and osmosis? Cell Biology Education 4 3 2005 235 248 (Pubitemid 41247906)
47. R. Mitnik, M. Recabarren, M. Nussbaum, and A. Soto Collaborative robotic instruction: A graph teaching experience Computers & Education 53 2 2009 330 342
48. R. Moreno, and R.E. Mayer Personalized messages that promote science learning in virtual environments Journal of Educational Psychology 96 1 2004 165 173 (Pubitemid 38397495)
49. A. Pallant, and R. Tinker Reasoning with atomic-scale molecular dynamic models Journal of Science Education and Technology 13 1 2004 51 66
50. M. Papastergiou Digital game-based learning in high school computer science education: impact on educational effectiveness and student motivation Computers & Education 52 1 2009 1 12
51. W.J. Pelgrum Obstacles to the integration of ICT in education: results from a worldwide educational assessment Computers & Education 37 2 2001 163 178 (Pubitemid 33675470)
52. Physics Education Technology website. (2011). Retrieved 14.04.11.: http://phet.colorado.edu.
53. R. Ploetzner, S. Lippitsch, M. Galmbacher, D. Heuer, and S. Scherrer Students' difficulties in learning from dynamic visualisations and how they may be overcome Computers in Human Behavior 25 1 2009 56 65
54. W. Riess, and C. Mischo Promoting systems thinking through biology lessons International Journal of Science Education 32 6 2010 705 725
55. N. Saab, W.R. van Joolingen, and B. van Hout-Wolters Supporting communication in a collaborative discovery learning environment: the effect of instruction Instructional Science 35 1 2007 73 98
56. Scopus. (2011). Retrieved 14.04.11.: http://www.scopus.com.
57. R.S. Shieh, W.J. Chang, and J. Tang The impact of implementing technology-enabled active learning (TEAL) in university physics in Taiwan Asia-Pacific Education Researcher 19 3 2010 401 415
58. L. Stern, N. Barnea, and S. Shauli The effect of a computerized simulation on middle school students' understanding of the kinetic molecular theory Journal of Science Education and Technology 17 4 2008 305 315
59. D. Tall The transition to formal thinking in mathematic Mathematics Education Research Journal 20 2 2008 5 24
60. Thalheimer, W., & Cook, S. (2002). How to calculate effect sizes from published research articles: a simplified methodology. Retrieved 08.06.10: http://work-learning.com/effect-sizes.htm.
61. R.F. Tinker, and Q. Xie Applying computational science to education: the molecular workbench paradigm Computing in Science & Engineering 10 5 2008 24 27
62. L. Trey, and S. Khan How science students can learn about unobservable phenomena using computer-based analogies Computers & Education 51 2 2008 519 529 (Pubitemid 351697614)
63. J. Trindade, C. Fiolhais, and L. Almeida Science learning in virtual environments: a descriptive study British Journal of Educational Technology 33 4 2002 471 488
64. K.C. Trundle, and R.L. Bell The use of a computer simulation to promote conceptual change: a quasi-experimental study Computers & Education 54 4 2010 1078 1088
65. J.J.A. van Berkum, and T. de Jong Instructional environments for simulations Education & Computing 6 1991 305 358
66. J. van der Meij, and T. de Jong Supporting students' learning with multiple representations in a dynamic simulation-based learning environment Learning and Instruction 16 3 2006 199 212
67. W.R. van Joolingen, and T. de Jong Characteristics of simulations for instructional settings Education & Computing 6 3-4 1991 241 262
68. K. Veermans, W. van Joolingen, and T. de Jong Use of heuristics to facilitate scientific discovery learning in a simulation learning environment in a physics domain International Journal of Science Education 28 4 2006 341 361 (Pubitemid 43090569)
69. B. White, A. Kahriman, L. Luberice, and F. Idleh Evaluation of software for introducing protein structure: visualization and simulation Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Education 38 5 2010 284 289
70. C.E. Wieman, and K.K. Perkins Transforming physics education Physics Today 58 11 2005 26 41
71. C.E. Wieman, and K.K. Perkins A powerful tool for teaching science Nature Physics 2 5 2006 290 292 (Pubitemid 43787218)
72. T.M. Winberg, and C.A.R. Berg Students' cognitive focus during a chemistry laboratory exercise: effects of a computer-simulated prelab Journal of Research in Science Teaching 44 8 2007 1108 1133 (Pubitemid 47573897)
73. M. Windschitl, and T. Andre Using computer simulations to enhance conceptual change: the roles of constructivist instruction and student epistemological beliefs Journal of Research in Science Teaching 35 2 1998 145 160 (Pubitemid 128459009)
74. H.K. Wu, and Y.L. Huang Ninth-grade student engagement in teacher-centered and student-centered technology-enhanced learning environments Science Education 91 5 2007 727 749
75. Z.C. Zacharia Comparing and combining real and virtual experimentation: an effort to enhance students' conceptual understanding of electric circuits Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 23 2 2007 120 132
76. J.W. Zhang, Q. Chen, Y.Q. Sun, and D.J. Reid Triple scheme of learning support design for scientific discovery learning based on computer simulation: experimental research Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 20 4 2004 269 282 (Pubitemid 39057703)