'Unionising' the new spaces of the new economy? Alternative labour organising in India's IT Enabled Services-Business Process Outsourcing industry

Geoforum

Volumn 41, Issue 3, 2010, Pages 364-376

  James, Al ^a   Vira, Bhaskar ^b  

^a QUEEN MARY UNIVERSITY OF LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Business Process Outsourcing (BPO); Call centres; Global South; India; Information Technology Enabled Services (ITES); Labour organising; New economy

Indexed keywords

CALL CENTER; EMPIRICAL ANALYSIS; EMPLOYMENT; INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY; LABOR DIVISION; NUMERICAL MODEL; OCCUPATION; OUTSOURCING; TRADE UNION; WORKPLACE;

INDIA;

EID: 77649339463     PISSN: 00167185     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.geoforum.2009.11.003     Document Type: Article

References (113)

1. Anant, B., Kuruvilla, B., Menon, M., 2005. When the Wind Blows: An Overview of Business Process Outsourcing in India. Young Professionals Collective and Focus India, Mumbai. Available from: .
2. Anderson J., Hamilton P., and Wills J. Space and organising. In: McGrath-Champ S., Herod A., and Rainnie A. (Eds). Handbook of Employment and Society: Working Space (2009), Edward Elgar, London
3. In: Bagchi A.K. (Ed). New Technology and the Workers' Response: Microelectronics, Labour and Society (1995), Sage Publications, New Delhi
4. Bain, P., 2003. Unions and Call Centres: The UK Experience. USW Canada. Available from: .
5. Bain P., and Taylor P. Ringing the changes? Union recognition and organisation in call centres in the UK financial sector. Industrial Relations Journal 33 3 (2002) 246-261
6. Batt R., and Moynihan L. The viability of alternative call centre production models. Human Resource Management Journal 12 4 (2002) 14-34
7. Batt, R., Doellgast, V., Kwon, H., Nopany, M., Nopany, P., da Costa, A., 2005. The Indian Call Centre Industry: National Benchmarking Report Strategy, HR Practices, and Performance (A Report of the Global Call Centre Industry Project). Cornell University, School of Industrial and Labor Relations, Center for Advanced Human Resource Studies, Ithaca, NY.
8. Belt V. A female ghetto? Women's careers in call centres. Human Resource Management Journal 12 (2002) 51-66
9. Benner C. Win the lottery or organize: traditional and non-traditional labor organizing in Silicon Valley. Berkeley Planning Journal 12 (1999) 50-71
10. Benner C. Computers in the wild: guilds and next-generation unionism in the information revolution. In: Blok A., and Downey G. (Eds). Uncovering Labour in Information Revolutions, 1750-2000 (2003), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 181-204
11. Benner, C., 2007. International outsourcing and new forms of eWork: an economic boom for Africa? In: Paper Presented to the Second Global Conference on Economic Geography, 25-28 June, Beijing, 2007.
12. Benner, C., Dean, A., 2000. Labor in the new economy: lessons from organizing in Silicon Valley. In: Carre, F., Ferber, M., Golden, L., Herzenberg, S., (Eds.), Nonstandard Work Arrangements and the Changing Labor Markets: Dimensions, Causes and Institutional Responses, Industrial Relations Research Association, Annual Research Volume, 2000.
13. Benner C., Leete L., and Pastor M. Staircases or Treadmills? Labor Market Intermediaries and Economic Opportunity in a Changing Economy (2007), Russell Sage Foundation, New York
14. Bhattacherjee, D., 1999. Organized Labour and Economic Liberalisation: India Past, Present and Future. Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta (Labour and Society Programme Discussion Papers DP/105/1999).
15. Bhattacherjee D. The evolution of Indian industrial relations: a comparative perspective. Industrial Relations Journal 32 3 (2003) 244-263
16. In: Bronfenbrenner K., Freidman S., Hurd R., Oswald R.A., and Seeber R.L. (Eds). Organizing to Win: New Research on Union Strategies (1998), ILR Press, Ithaca, NY
17. Budhwar P.S. HRM in business process outsourcing firms operating in India. In: Budhwar P.S., and Bhatnagar J. (Eds). The Changing Face of People Management in India (2009), Routledge, Oxford 135-158
18. Budhwar P., Varma A., Singh V., and Dhar R. HRM systems of Indian call centres: an exploratory study. International Journal of Human Resource Management 17 5 (2006) 881-897
19. Budhwar P., Malhotra N., and Singh V. Work processes and emerging problems in Indian call centres. In: Thite M., and Russell B. (Eds). The Next Available Operator: Managing Human Resources in Indian Business Process Outsourcing Industry (2009), Sage, New Delhi 59-82
20. Carnoy M. Sustaining the New Economy: Work Family and Community in the Information Age (2002), Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
21. Castree N., Coe N.M., Ward K., and Samers M. Spaces of Work: Global Capitalism and Geographies of Labour (2004), Sage, London
22. Cobble D.S. Organizing the postindustrial work force. Lessons from the history of waitress unionism. Industrial and Labor Relations Review 44 3 (1991) 419-436
23. Cobble D.S. The prospects for unionism in a service society. In: Macdonald C.L., and Sirianni C. (Eds). Working in the Service Society (1996), Temple University Press, Philadelphia 333-358
24. Coe N., Kelly P., and Yeung H.W. Economic Geography: A Contemporary Introduction (2007), Blackwell, Oxford
25. Cohen L., and El-Sawad A. Lived experiences of offshoring: an examination of UK and Indian financial service employees' accounts of themselves and one another. Human Relations 60 8 (2007) 1235-1262
26. Cohen L., El-Sawad A., and Arnold J. Outsourcing careers: to what extent do western theories of career fit Indian contexts?. In: Thite M., and Russell B. (Eds). The Next Available Operator: Managing Human Resources in the Indian Business Process Outsourcing Industry (2009), Sage, London 186-215
27. Contact Babel. The UK Contact Centre Operational Review 2008 (2008), Contact Babel, Durham
28. Cumbers A., Nativel C., and Routledge P. Labour agency and union positionalities in global production networks. Journal of Economic Geography 8 (2008) 369-387
29. d'Cruz P., and Noronha E. Being professional: organizational control in Indian call centres. Social Science Computer Review 24 3 (2006) 342-361
30. Deery S., and Kinnie N. Call centres and beyond: a thematic evaluation. Human Resource Management Journal 12 4 (2002) 3-13
31. Diamond W., and Freeman R.B. Will unionism prosper in cyber-space? The promise of the internet for employee organization. British Journal of Industrial Relations 35 4 (2002) 515-546
32. Evetts J. The sociological analysis of professionalism: occupational change in the modern world. International Sociology 189 (2003) 395-415
33. Freeman R.B., and Rogers J. Open source unionism: beyond exclusive collective bargaining. Working USA: The Journal of Labor and Society 5 4 (2002) 3-4
34. Frenkel S.J., Tam M., Korczynski M., and Shire K. On the Front Line: Organisation of Work in the Information Economy (1999), Cornell University Press, Ithaca
35. Glucksmann M. Call configurations: varieties of call centre and divisions of labour. Work, Employment and Society 18 4 (2004) 795-811
36. Hay Group/Manpower India, 2006. The Indian ITES/BPO Industry: Human Resource Trends. Discussion Document 18 May 2006. Hay Group/Manpower India, Delhi.
37. Herod A. Labour organizing in the new economy: examples from the USA and beyond. In: Daniels P.W., Leyshon A., Bradshaw M., and Beaverstock J. (Eds). Geographies of the New Economy: Critical Reflections (2007), Routledge, London 132-150
38. Herod A., Rainnie A., and McGrath-Champ S. Working space: why incorporating the geographical is central to theorizing work and employment practices. Work, Employment and Society 21 2 (2007) 247-264
39. Hossfeld K.J. Why aren't high-tech workers organized? Lessons in gender, race, and nationality from Silicon Valley. In: Cornford D. (Ed). Working People of California (1995), University of California Press, Berkeley/Los Angeles 405-432
40. Houlihan M. Tensions and variations in call centre management strategies. Human Resource Management Journal 12 4 (2002) 67-85
41. Hunter I. The Indian Offshore Advantage: How Offshoring is Changing the Face of HR (2006), Gower, Aldershot
42. Hurd, R.W., 2000. Professional workers, unions and association: affinities and antipathies. Paper Prepared for the Albert Shanker Institute Seminar on Unions Organizing Professionals, Washington, DC, June 2000.
43. Hyman R. The future of employee representation. British Journal of Industrial Relations 37 1 (1997) 309-336
44. Hyman R. An Emerging Agenda for Trade Unions? Discussion Paper DP/98/1999 Published by the Labour and Society Programme (1999), ILO, Geneva
45. IDS. Pay and Conditions in Call Centres (1997), Incomes Data Services, London
46. IDS. Pay and Conditions in Call Centres (2002), Incomes Data Services, London
47. International Labor Organisation, 1992. World Employment Report. ILO, Delhi.
48. RS I. Call Centres 2001: Reward and Retention Strategies (2001), Industrial Relations Services, London
49. Kayser F. Defending Social Justice and Workers' Rights in a Globalised World (2004), Friedrich Ebert Stiftung Foundation, Jakarta
50. Kelly P.F. Spaces of labour control: comparative perspectives from Southeast Asia. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 27 (2002) 395-411
51. Kinnie N., Purcell J., and Hutchinson S. Managing the employment relationship in telephone call centres. In: Purcell K. (Ed). Changing Boundaries in Employment (2000), Bristol Academic Press, Bristol
52. Korcyzynski M. Human Resources Management in Service Work (2002), Palgrave, Basingstoke
53. Martin R.L. Making sense of the new economy? Realities, myths and geographies. In: Daniels P.W., Leyshon A., Bradshaw M., and Beaverstock J. (Eds). Geographies of the New Economy: Critical Reflections (2007), Routledge, London 15-48
54. Mattingly, D.J., 2005. Indian Call Centers: The Outsourcing of 'Good' Jobs for Women. Centre for Global Justice, 2005 Conference Papers. Available from: .
55. McMillin D. Outsourcing identities: call centres and cultural transformations in India. Economic and Political Weekly 21 (2006) 235-241
56. In: Milkman R., and Voss K. (Eds). Rebuilding Labor: Organizing and Organizers in the New Union Movement (2004), ILR Press, Ithaca, NY
57. Millward N., Bryson A., and Forth J. All Change at Work? British Employment Relations 1980-1998, as Portrayed by the Workplace Industrial Relations Survey Series (2000), Routledge, London
58. Mirchandani, K., 2003. Making Americans: Transnational Call Centre Work in India. Paper Presented to the Third Critical Management Studies Conference. University of Lancaster. Available from: .
59. Mirchandani K. Practices of global capital: gaps, cracks and ironies in transnational call centres in India. Global Networks 4 4 (2004) 355-373
60. Morgan-Williams H. Newcastle Journal 15 (1998) 15
61. Murphy J.T. Economic geographies of the Global South: missed opportunities and promising intersections with development studies. Geography Compass 2/3 (2008) 851-873
62. NASSCOM, 2006. Knowledge Professionals in India. Available from: .
63. NASSCOM, 2007. Strategic Review 2007. NASSCOM, New Delhi.
64. NASSCOM-Everest. Nasscom-Everest Indian BPO Study: Roadmap 2012 - Capitalising on the Expanding BPO Landscape (2008), NASSCOM, New Delhi
65. NASSCOM-McKinsey. Extending India's Leadership of the Global IT and BPO Industries (2005), NASSCOM-McKinsey, New Delhi
66. Nayyar D. India's unfinished journey: transforming growth into development. Modern Asian Studies 40 3 (2006) 797-832
67. Noronha E., and D'Cruz P. Organising call centre agents: emerging issues. Economic and Political Weekly 27 (2006) 2115-2121
68. Noronha E., and D'Cruz P. Engaging the professional: organising call centre agents in India. Industrial Relations Journal 40 3 (2009) 215-234
69. Ofreneo R., Ng C., and Marasigan-Pasumbal L. Voice for the voice workers: addressing the IR concerns in the call center/BPO industry of Asia. Indian Journal of Industrial Relations 42 (2007) 534-557
70. Perrons D., Fagan C., McDowell L., Ray K., and Ward K. Work, life and time in the new economy. In: Perrons D., Fagan C., McDowell L., Ray K., and Ward K. (Eds). Gender Divisions and Working Time in the New Economy: Changing Patterns of Work, Care and Public Policy in Europe and North America (2006), Edward Elgar, Cheltenham 1-16
71. Poster W.P. Who's on the line? Indian call centre agents pose as Americans for US-outsourced firms. Industrial Relations 46 2 (2007) 271-304
72. Pradhan, J.P., Abraham, V., 2005. Social and cultural impact of outsourcing: emerging issues from Indian call centres. Harvard Asia Quarterly IX (3).
73. Reich R. The Future of Success: Work and Life in the New Economy (2000), Heinemann, London
74. Remesh P. Cyber coolies in BPO: insecurities and vulnerabilities of non-standard work. Economic and Political Weekly 39 (2004) 492-497
75. Remesh B.P. Labour in Business Process Outsourcing: A Case Study of Call Centre Agents (2005), VV Giri National Labour Institute, Noida
76. Richardson R., Belt V., and Marshall N. Taking calls to Newcastle: the regional implications of the growth in call centres. Regional Studies 34 4 (2000) 357-369
77. Roychowdhury S. Public sector restructuring and democracy: the state, labour and trade unions in India. The Journal of Development Studies 39 3 (2003) 29-50
78. Russell B. Call centres: a decade of research. International Journal of Management Reviews 10 3 (2008) 195-219
79. Russell B., and Thite M. The next division of labour: work skills in Australian and Indian call centres. Work, Employment and Society 22 4 (2008) 615-634
80. Sandhu A. Why unions fail in organising India's BPO-ITES industry. Economic and Political Weekly 14 (2006) 4319-4322
81. Sarkar S. Individualism-collectivism as predictors of BPO employee attitudes toward union membership in India. Asia Pacific Journal of Management 23 (2007) 283-298
82. Savage L., and Wills J. New geographies of trade unionism. Geoforum 35 (2004) 5-7
83. Schmid J.M. Open-source unionism: new workers, new strategies. Academe 90 1 (2002) 24-27
84. Singh P., and Pandey A. Women in call centres. Economic and Political Weekly 12 (2005) 684-688
85. Sinha, P., 2004. Dilemma of Organising IT Workers: the Case of India. Paper Presented to the Australian Labour Market Research Workshop, 6-7 December, University of Western Australia, Perth, 2004.
86. Taylor P., and Bain P. An assembly line in the head: work and employee relations in the call centre. Industrial Relations Journal 30 2 (1999) 101-117
87. Taylor P., and Bain P. Call center organizing in adversity: from excell to vertex. In: Gall G. (Ed). Union Organizing: Campaigning for Trade Union Recognition (2003), Routledge, London 153-172
88. Taylor P., and Bain P. India calling to the far away towns: the call centre labour process and globalization. Work, Employment and Society 19 2 (2005) 261-282
89. Taylor P., and Bain P. Reflections on the call centre - a reply to Gucksmann. Work, Employment and Society 21 2 (2007) 349-362
90. Taylor P., and Bain P. United by a common language? Trade union responses in the UK and India to call centre offshoring. Antipode 40 1 (2008) 131-154
91. Taylor P., Mulvey G., Hyman J., and Bain P. Work organisation, control and the experience of work in call centres. Work, Employment and Society 16 1 (2002) 133-150
92. Taylor P., Noronha E., Scholarios D., and D'Cruz P. Employee voice and collective formation in the Indian ITES-BPO industry. Economic and Political Weekly 31 (2008) 37-46
93. Taylor P., Noronha E., Scholarios D., and D'Cruz P. Indian call centres and business process outsourcing: a study in union formation. New Technology, Work and Employment 24 1 (2009) 19-42
94. The Economic Times, 2007. Outsourcing Industry Faces Health Problems. The Economic Times, 26 December.
95. The Economic Times, 2008a. Don't Just Blame Odd Hours for BPO Attrition. The Economic Times, 10 June.
96. The Economic Times, 2008b. IT-BPO Union Flays Nasscom Stand on Layoffs. The Economic Times, 7 December.
97. The Hindu, 2005. Safety Issues in BPO Sector to the Fore. The Hindu, 17 December.
98. The Hindustan Times. Many BPO youth begin their walk back to school. Hindustan Times 17 (2007)
99. The Hindustan Times, 2008. Desi Techies Turn to Trade Unions to Save Jobs. The Hindustan Times, 12 November.
100. The Times of India, 2005a. Call Centre Guys Lack Self-Esteem. The Times of India, October 25.
101. The Times of India, 2005b. Narayana Murthy Speaks for BPO Staff. The Times of India, 19 December.
102. Thite M., and Russell B. India and business process outsourcing. In: Burgess J., and Connell J. (Eds). Globalization and Work in Asia: Contemporary Issues and Trends (2007), Chandos Publishing, Oxford 67-92
103. In: Tillman R.M., and Cummings M.S. (Eds). The Transformation of US Unions: Voices, Visions and Strategies from the Grassroots (1999), Lynne Rienner Publishers, Boulder, CO
104. UNI, 2006. UNI's Offshoring Charter. Union Network International, Nyon. Available from: .
105. Unni J., and Raveendran G. Growth of Employment (1993-94 to 2004-05): illusion of inclusiveness. Economic and Political Weekly 20 (2007)
106. UPI, 2005. Trade Unionism Hits India's BPO. United Press International, November 8. Available from: .
107. Van Jaarsveld D.D. Collective representation among high-tech workers at Microsoft and beyond: lessons from WashTech/CWA. Industrial Relations 43 2 (2004) 364-385
108. Venkataratnam C.S. Impact of new economic policies on the role of trade unions. Indian Journal of Industrial Relations 29 1 (1993) 56-77
109. Venkataratnam C.S. Globalization and Labour-Management Relations: Dynamics of Change (2001), Sage Publications, New Delhi
110. Washtech (Washington Alliance of Technology Workers). Disparities within the Digital World: Realities of the New Economy: A Report on Wages and Working Conditions in the Seattle-area IT Sector (2002), Washtech/CWA, Seattle, WA
111. Wills J. Community unionism and trade union renewal in the UK: moving beyond the fragments at last?. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 26 4 (2001) 465-483
112. Wills J. Subcontracted employment and its challenge to labor. Labor Studies Journal 34 4 (2009) 441-460
113. World Bank, 2009. World Development Report 2009: Reshaping Economic Geography. The World Bank, Washington, DC.