Peer versus expert feedback: An investigation of the quality of peer feedback among secondary school students

Computers and Education

Volumn 71, Issue , 2014, Pages 133-152

  Hovardas, Tasos ^a   Tsivitanidou, Olia E ^a   Zacharia, Zacharias C ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CYPRUS   (Cyprus)

Author keywords

Expert feedback; Peer feedback; Reciprocal peer assessment; Secondary school science; Web portfolios

Indexed keywords

EXPERT FEEDBACK; PEER ASSESSMENT; PEER FEEDBACK; SECONDARY SCHOOLS; WEB-PORTFOLIOS;

CARBON DIOXIDE; DECISION MAKING; PERSONNEL TRAINING; SCAFFOLDS; SURVEYS; TEACHING;

STUDENTS;

EID: 84887113804     PISSN: 03601315     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.compedu.2013.09.019     Document Type: Article

References (67)

1. R. Azevedo, and A.F. Hadwin Scaffolding self-regulated learning and metacognition-Implications for the design of computer-based scaffolds Instructional Science 33 5 2005 367 379 (Pubitemid 41455843)
2. R. Ballantyne, K. Hughes, and A. Mylonas Developing procedures for implementing peer assessment in large classes using an action research process Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education 27 5 2002 427 441
3. R.L. Bangert-Drowns, C.L.C. Kulick, J.A. Kulick, and M.T. Morgan The instructional effect of feedback in test-like events Review of Educational Research 61 1991 213 238
4. S.A. Barab, K.E. Hay, M.G. Barnett, and K. Squire Constructing virtual worlds: tracing the historical development of learner practices/understandings Cognition and Instruction 19 1 2001 47 94 (Pubitemid 33582611)
5. B. Bell, and B. Cowie The characteristics of formative assessment in science education Science Education 85 2001 536 553
6. M. Birenbaum Assessment 2000: towards a pluralistic approach to assessment M. Birenbaum, F. Dochy, Alternatives in assessment of achievements, learning processes and prior knowledge 1996 Kluwer Boston, MA 3 29
7. P. Black, and C. Harrison Feedback in questioning and marking: the science teacher's role in formative assessment School Science Review 82 301 2001 55 61
8. P. Black, and D. William Assessment and classroom learning Assessment in Education 5 1 1998 7 74
9. P. Black, and D. William The formative purpose: assessment must first promote learning Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of Education 103 2004 20 50 10.1111/j.1744-7984.2004.tb00047.x
10. S. Bloxham, and A. West Understanding the rules of the game: marking peer assessment as a medium for developing students' conceptions of assessment Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education 29 6 2004 721 733
11. C. Brindley, and S. Scoffield Peer assessment in undergraduate programmes Teaching in Higher Education 3 1 1998 79 89
12. C.M. Cestone, R.E. Levine, and D.R. Lane Peer assessment and evaluation in team-based learning New Directions for Teaching and Learning 116 2008 69 78
13. N.-S. Chen, C.-W. Wie, K.-T. Wu, and L. Uden Effects of high level prompts and peer assessment on online learners' reflection levels Computers and Education 52 2009 283 291
14. K. Cho, T.R. Chung, W.R. King, and C.D. Schunn Peer-based computer-supported knowledge refinement: an empirical investigation Communications of the ACM 51 2008 83 88 (Pubitemid 351357120)
15. K. Cho, and C. MacArthur Student revision with peer and expert reviewing Learning and Instruction 20 4 2010 328 338
16. K. Cho, and C.D. Schunn Scaffolded writing and reviewing in the discipline Computers and Education 48 2007 409 426
17. K. Cho, C.D. Schunn, and W. Wilson Validity and reliability of scaffolded peer assessment of writing from instructor and student perspectives Journal of Educational Psychology 98 2006 891 901 (Pubitemid 44747846)
18. L. Crane, and M. Winterbottom Plants and photosynthesis: peer assessment to help students learn Journal of Biological Education 42 2008 150 156
19. P. Davies Peer assessment: judging the quality of students' work by comments rather than marks Innovations in Education and Teaching International 43 2006 69 82 (Pubitemid 43256492)
20. F. Dochy, M. Segers, and D. Sluijsmans The use of self-, peer and co-assessment in higher education: a review Studies in Higher Education 24 1999 331 350
21. N. Falchikov Peer feedback marking: developing peer assessment Innovations in Education and Training International 32 1995 175 187
22. N. Falchikov, and J. Goldfinch Student peer assessment in higher education: a meta-analysis comparing peer and teacher marks Review of Educational Research 70 2000 287 322 (Pubitemid 33282484)
23. S. Fallows, and B. Chandramohan Multiple approaches to assessment: reflections on use of tutor, peer and self-assessment Teaching in Higher Education 6 2 2001 229 246
24. S. Gielen, E. Peeters, F. Dochy, P. Onghena, and K. Struyven Improving the effectiveness of peer feedback for learning Learning and Instruction 20 2010 304 315
25. A.C. Graesser, M. Jeon, and D. Dufty Agent technologies designed to facilitate interactive knowledge construction Discourse Processes 45 4-5 2008 298 322
26. J.C. Hafner, and P.M. Hafner Quantitative analysis of the rubric as an assessment tool: an empirical study of student peer-group rating International Journal of Science Education 25 2003 1509 1528 (Pubitemid 37519479)
27. S.J. Hanrahan, and G. Isaacs Assessing self- and peer-assessment: the students' views Higher Education Research and Development 20 2001 53 70 (Pubitemid 33260248)
28. W. Harlen Holding up a mirror to classroom practice Primary Science Review 100 2007 29 31
29. C. Harrison, and W. Harlen Children's self- and peer-assessment W. Harlen, Ase guide to primary science education 2006 Association for Science Education Hatfield 183 190
30. H.U. Hoppe Integrating learning processes across boundaries of media, time and group scale Research and Practice in Technology Enhanced Learning 2 2007 31 49
31. T. de Jong, W. Van Joolingen, A. Giemza, I. Girault, U. Hoppe, and J. Kindermann Learning by creating and exchanging objects: the SCY experience British Journal of Educational Technology 41 6 2010 909 921
32. T. de Jong, A. Weinberger, W. Van Joolingen, A. Giemza, I. Girault, and U. Hoppe Using scenarios to design complex technology-enhanced learning environments Education, Technology, Research & Development 60 2012 883 901
33. M.S. Kocakülah Development and application of a rubric for evaluating students' performance on Newton's laws of motion Journal of Science Education and Technology 19 2010 146 164
34. I. Kollar, and F. Fischer Peer assessment as collaborative learning: a cognitive perspective Learning and Instruction 20 2010 344 348
35. E. Kyza, G. Michael, and C. Constantinou The rationale, design, and implementation of a web-based inquiry learning environment C. Constantinou, Z.C. Zacharia, M. Papaevripidou, Contemporary perspectives on new technologies in science and education, proceedings of the eighth international conference on computer based learning in science 2007 E-media Crete, Greece 531 539
36. C. Lindsay, and S. Clarke Enhancing primary science through self- and paired-assessment Primary Science Review 68 2001 15 18
37. S.S.J. Lin, E.Z.F. Liu, and S.M. Yuan Web-based peer assessment: feedback for students with various thinking styles Journal of Computer Assisted Learning 17 2001 420 432
38. E.Z. Liu, S.S. Lin, C.H. Chiu, and S.M. Yuan Web-based peer review: the learner as both adapter and reviewer IEEE Transactions on Education 44 3 2001 246 251 (Pubitemid 32945776)
39. D. Magin, and P. Helmore Peer and teacher assessments of oral presentation skills: how reliable are they? Studies in Higher Education 26 3 2001 287 298 (Pubitemid 33342782)
40. L. McDowell The impact of innovative assessment on student learning Innovations in Education and Teaching International 32 4 1995 302 313 (Pubitemid 126023608)
41. P. Orsmond, S. Merry, and K. Reiling The importance of marking criteria in the use of peer-assessment Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education 21 3 1996 239 250 (Pubitemid 127110616)
42. P. Orsmond, S. Merry, and K. Reiling The use of student derived marking criteria in peer and self-assessment Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education 25 2000 23 38
43. T.M. Paulus The effect of peer and teacher feedback on student writing Journal of Second Language Writing 8 1993 265 289
44. J.W. Pellegrino, N. Chudowsky, and R. Glaser Knowing what students know: The science and design of educational assessment 2001 National Academic Press Washington, DC
45. F.J. Prins, D.M.A. Sluijsmans, P.A. Kirschner, and J.-W. Strijbos Formative peer assessment in a CSCL environment: a case study Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education 30 2005 417 444 (Pubitemid 40639783)
46. P. Race Practical pointers on peer assessment S. Brown, Peer assessment in practice 1998 SEDA publications Birmingham 113 122
47. D.L. Richer The effects of two feedback systems on first year college students' writing proficiency Dissertation Abstracts International 53 1992 2722
48. A.H. Schoenfeld Teaching mathematical thinking and problem solving L.B. Resnick, B.L. Klopfer, Towards the thinking curriculum: Current cognitive research 1989 ASCD Washington DC 83 103
49. M. Searby, and T. Ewers An evaluation of the use of peer assessment in higher education: a case study in the School of Music, Kingston University Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education 22 1997 371 383
50. D.M.A. Sluijsmans Student involvement in assessment, the training of peer-assessment skills 2002 Interuniversity Centre for Educational Research
51. D.M.A. Sluijsmans, S. Brand-Gruwel, J.J.G. Van Merriënboer, and R.L. Martens Training teachers in peer-assessment skills: effects on performance and perceptions Innovations in Education and Teaching International 41 2004 60 78
52. N.B. Songer, and M.A. Ruiz-Primo Assessment and science education: our essential new priority? Journal of Research in Science Teaching 49 6 2012 683 690
53. J.W. Strijbos, and D.M. Sluijsmans Unraveling peer assessment: methodological, functional and conceptual developments Learning and Instruction 20 2010 265 269
54. K. Topping Peer assessment between students in colleges and universities Review of Educational Research 68 1998 249 276 (Pubitemid 128376780)
55. K.J. Topping Self and peer assessment in school and university: reliability, validity and utility M. Segers, F. Dochy, E. Cascaller, Optimising new modes of assessment: In search of qualities and standards 2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers The Netherlands 55 87
56. K. Topping Peer assessment Theory Into Practice 48 2009 20 27
57. K. Topping, F.F. Smith, I. Swanson, and A. Elliot Formative peer assessment of academic writing between postgraduate students Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education 25 2000 149 169
58. C.-C. Tsai, and J.C. Liang The development of science activities via on-line peer assessment: the role of scientific epistemological views Instructional Science 37 2009 293 310
59. C.-C. Tsai, S.S.J. Lin, and S.-M. Yuan Developing science activities through a networked peer assessment system Computers & Education 38 2002 241 252
60. C.-C. Tsai, E.Z.F. Liu, S.S.J. Lin, and S.M. Yuan A networked peer assessment system based on a Vee heuristic Innovations in Education and Teaching International 38 2001 220 230 (Pubitemid 33397738)
61. S.-C. Tseng, and C.-C. Tsai On-line peer assessment and the role of the peer feedback: a study of high school computer course Computers & Education 49 2007 1161 1174 (Pubitemid 47284638)
62. O. Tsivitanidou, Z.C. Zacharia, and A. Hovardas High school students' unmediated potential to assess peers: unstructured and reciprocal peer assessment of web-portfolios in a science course Learning and Instruction 21 2011 506 519
63. O.E. Tsivitanidou, Z.C. Zacharia, T. Hovardas, and A. Nicolaou Peer assessment among secondary school students: introducing a peer feedback tool in the context of a computer supported inquiry learning environment in science Journal of Computers in Mathematics and Science Teaching 31 2012 433 465
64. N.A.E. Van Gennip, M.S.R. Segers, and H.H. Tillema Peer assessment as a collaborative learning activity: the role of interpersonal variables and conceptions Learning and Instruction 20 2010 280 290
65. E. Van Steendam, G. Rijlaarsdam, L. Sercu, and H. Van den Bergh The effect of instruction type and dyadic or individual emulation of higher-order peer feedback in EFL Learning and Instruction 20 2010 316 327
66. M. Van Zundert, D.M.A. Sluijsmans, and J.J.G. Van Merriënboer Effective peer assessment processes: research findings and future directions Learning and Instruction 20 2010 270 279
67. Y. Xiao, and R. Lucking The impact of two types of peer assessment on students' performance and satisfaction within a Wiki environment Internet and Higher Education 11 2008 186 193