The tragedy of the uncommons: Reframing workforce diversity

Human Relations

Volumn 66, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 271-294

  Jonsen, Karsten ^a   Tatli, Ahu ^b   Özbilgin, Mustafa F ^c,d   Bell, Myrtle P ^e  

^a IMD   (Switzerland)

^b QUEEN MARY UNIVERSITY OF LONDON   (United Kingdom)

^c BRUNEL UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^d UNIVERSITÉ PARIS DAUPHINE   (France)

^e UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT ARLINGTON   (United States)

Author keywords

coercion; collectivism; individualism; social dilemma; tragedy of commons; voluntarism; workforce diversity

Indexed keywords

EID: 84873852308     PISSN: 00187267     EISSN: 1741282X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0018726712466575     Document Type: Article

References (135)

1. Acker J.Inequality regimes: Gender, class, and race in organizations.Gender & Society. 2006;20 (4): 441-464.
2. Agocs C,Burr C.Employment equity, affirmative action and managing diversity: Assessing the differences.International Journal of Manpower. 1996;17 (4/5): 30-45.
3. Banerjee SB.Corporate social responsibility: The good, the bad and the ugly.Critical Sociology. 2008;34 (1): 51-79.
4. Barclay P.Trustworthiness and competitive altruism can also solve the 'tragedy of the commons'.Evolution and Human Behavior. 2004;25 (4): 209-220.
5. Barry B,Bateman TS.A social trap analysis of the management of diversity.Academy of Management Review. 1996;21 (3): 757-790.
6. Bell MPDiversity in Organizations. 2012) Diversity in Organizations, 2nd edn. Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning.Mason, OH: South-Western Cengage Learning; 2012:.
7. Bertrand M,Mullainathan S.Are Emily and Greg more employable than Lakisha and Jamal? A field experiment on labor market discrimination.American Economic Review. 2004;94 (4): 991-1011.
8. Berry DP,Bell MP.'Expatriates': Gender, race and class distinctions in international management.Gender, Work & Organization. 2012;19 (1): 10-28.
9. New Issues and Paradigms in Research and Social Dilemmas. Biel AEek DGärling TGustafsson M, ed. New York: Springer; 2008:.
10. Blockson LC.Multisector approaches to societal issues management.Business and Society. 2003;42 (3): 381-390.
11. Bourdieu PHandbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. Richardson JG, ed. New York/London: Greenwood; 1986:241-258.
12. Campbell JL.Why would corporations behave in socially responsible ways? An institutional theory of corporate social responsibility.Academy of Management Review. 2007;32 (3): 946-967.
13. Castilla EJ.Gender, race, and meritocracy in organizational careers.American Journal of Sociology. 2008;113 (6): 1479-1526.
14. The Bottom Line: Corporate Performance and Women's Representation on Boards. New York: Catalyst Inc; 2007:.
15. Chrobot-Mason D,Ruderman MN,Weber TJ,Ernst C.The challenge of leading on unstable ground: Triggers that activate social identity faultlines.Human Relations. 2009;62 (11): 1763-1794.
16. Cox TH.The multicultural organization.Academy of Management Executive. 1991;5 (2): 34-47.
17. Creyer EH,Ross WT.The influence of firm behaviour on purchase intention: Do consumers really care about business ethics?.Journal of Consumer Marketing. 1997;14 (6): 421-432.
18. The Bureaucratic Phenomenon. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press; 1964:.
19. Dawes RM.Social dilemmas.Annual Review of Psychology. 1980;31 (1): 169-193.
20. Dawes RM,Messick DM.Social dilemmas.International Journal of Psychology. 2000;35 (2): 111-116.
21. De Cremer D,Van Dijk E.Perceived criticality and contributions in public good dilemmas: A matter of feeling responsible to all?.Group Processes & Intergroup Relations. 2002;5 (4): 319-332.
22. De Cremer D,Van Knippenberg D,Van Dijk E,Van Leeuwen E.Coorporating if one's goal are collective-based.Journal of Applied Psychology. 2008;38 (6): 1562-1579.
23. Demuijnck G.Non-discrimination in human resources management as a moral obligation.Journal of Business Ethics. 2009;88 (1): 83-101.
24. Devinney TM.Is the socially responsible corporation a myth? The good, the bad, and the ugly of corporate social responsibility.Academy of Management Perspectives. 2009;23 (2): 44-56.
25. Dickens L.Gender, race and employment equality in Britain: Inadequate strategies and the role of industrial relations actors.Industrial Relations Journal. 1997;28 (4): 282-291.
26. Dickens L.Re-regulation for gender equality: From 'either/or' to 'both'.Industrial Relations Journal. 2006;37 (4): 299-309.
27. DiTomaso N,Hooijberg R.Diversity and the demands of leadership.Leadership Quarterly. 1996;7 (2): 163-187.
28. DiTomaso N,Post C,Parks-Yancy R.Workforce diversity and inequality: Power, status, and numbers.The Annual Review of Sociology. 2007;33:473-501.
29. Dobbs MF.Managing diversity: Lessons from the private sector.Public Personnel Management. 1996;25 (3): 351-367.
30. Donaldson T.Making stakeholder theory whole.Academy of Management Review 2. 1999;4 (2): 237-241.
31. Edmondson A.Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams.Administrative Science Quarterly. 1999;44 (2): 350-383.
32. Elkington JCannibals with Forks: The Triple Bottom Line of 21st Century Business. Stony Creek, CT: New Society Publishers; 1998:.
33. Ellickson RCSocial Norms. Hechter MOpp K-D, ed. New York: Russell Sage Foundation; 2001:35-75.
34. Elvira MM,Zatzick CD.Who's displaced first? The role of race in layoff decisions.Industrial Relations: A Journal of Economy and Society. 2002;41 (2): 329-361.
35. Embrick DG.The diversity ideology in the business world: A new oppression for a new age.Critical Sociology. 2011;37 (5): 541-556.
36. ForsanderA (2004) Labour market integration in the Nordic welfare state. Does work make you into a real Finn?Working paper presented at the 13th Nordic Migration Conference, Aalborg, 18-20 November 2004. CEREN, University of Helsinki. Available at: http://www.amid.dk/ocs/viewpaper.php?id=140&cf=1 (accessed 23 August 2011).
37. Frank R,Cook PJThe Winner-Take-All Society: Why the Few at the Top Get So Much More Than the Rest of Us. New York: Penguin; 1995:.
38. Freeman REStrategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Boston, MA: Pittman; 1984:.
39. French PA.Integrity, intentions and corporations.American Business Law Journal. 1996;34 (2): 141-155.
40. Gioia DA.Practicability, paradigms and problems in stakeholder theorizing.Academy of Management Review. 1999;24 (2): 228-232.
41. Gladwin TN,Kennelly JJ,Krause T.Shifting paradigms for sustainable development: Implications for management theory and research.Academy of Management Review. 1995;20 (4): 874-907.
42. Glenn NDThe Family in the New Millennium. Loveless ASHolman TB, ed. Westport, CT: Praeger; 2007:81-85.
43. Greene AM,Kirton GDiversity Management in the UK: Organizational and Stakeholder Experiences. London: Routledge; 2009:.
44. Habermas JThe Postnational Constellation. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 2001:.
45. Hardin G.The tragedy of the commons.Science. 1968;162 (3859): 1243-1248.
46. Hardin RCollective Action. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press; 1982:.
47. Healy G,Kirton G,Özbilgin M,Oikelome F.Competing rationalities in the diversity project of the UK judiciary: The politics of assessment centres.Human Relations. 2010;63 (6): 807-834.
48. Henry P,Sears D.The symbolic racism 2000 scale.Political Psychology. 2002;23 (2): 253-283.
49. Janssens M,Zanoni P.Many diversities for many services: Theorizing diversity (management) in service companies.Human Relations. 2005;58 (3): 311-340.
50. Jayne MEA,Dipboye RL.Leveraging diversity to improve business performance: Research findings and recommendations for organizations.Human Resource Management. 2004;43 (4): 409-424.
51. Jensen MBreaking the Code of Change. Beer MNohria N, ed. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press; 2000:.
52. Jewson N,Mason D.The theory and practice of equal opportunities policies: Liberal and radical approaches.Sociological Review. 1986;34 (2): 307-334.
53. Jones TM.Instrumental stakeholder theory: A synthesis of ethics and economics.Academy of Management Review. 1995;20 (2): 404-437.
54. Jones TM,Wicks AC.Convergent stakeholder theory.Academy of Management Review. 1999;24 (2): 206-221.
55. Jonsen K, et alAdvances in International Management: The Past, Present and Future of International Business and Management. Devinney TPedersen TTihanyi L, ed. New York: Emerald; 2010:43-69.
56. Jonsen K,Maznevski ML,Schneider SC.Diversity and its not so diverse literature: An international perspective.International Journal of Cross Cultural Management. 2011a;10 (1): 35-62.
57. Jonsen K,Schneider SC,Maznevski MLDiversity in the Workplace: Multi-disciplinary and International Perspectives. Gröschl S, ed. London: Gower; 2011b:.
58. Joshi A,Roh H.Considering context in team diversity research: A meta-analytic review.Academy of Management Proceedings. 2008;:1-6.
59. Kalev A,Dobbin F,Kelly E.Best practices or best guesses? Assessing the efficacy of corporate affirmative action and diversity policies.American Sociological Review. 2006;71 (4): 589-617.
60. Kelly E,Dobbin F.How affirmative action became diversity management: Employer response to anti-discrimination law, 1961 to 1996.American Behavioural Scientist. 1998;41 (7): 960-984.
61. Kerr NLSocial Dilemmas: Psychological Perspectives. Schroeder D, ed. New York: Praeger; 1992:.
62. Kersten A.Diversity management, dialogue, dialects and diversion.Journal of Organisational Change Management. 2000;13:235-248.
63. Kirton G,Greene.The costs and opportunities of doing diversity work in mainstream organisations.Human Resource Management Journal. 2009;19 (2): 159-175.
64. Knyght PR,Kakabadse NK,Kouzmin A,Kakabadse A.Chronic limitations of neo-liberal capitalism and oligopolistic markets: An urgent case for socialized capital.Society and Business Review. 2011;6 (1): 7-26.
65. Kollock P.Social dilemmas: The anatomy of cooperation.Annual Review of Sociology. 1998;24 (1): 183-214.
66. KrysanMFaisonN (2012) Racial attitudes in America: A brief summary of the updated data. Institute of Government Public Affairs, University of Illinois. Available at: http://igpa.uillinois.edu/programs/racial-attitudes/brief (accessed 11 August 2012).
67. Korten DWhen Corporations Rule the World. West Hartford: Kumarian Press; 1995:.
68. Kumar R,Lamb WB,Wokutch R.The end of South African sanctions, institutional ownership, and the stock price performance of boycotted firms: Evidence on the impact of social/ethical investing.Business & Society. 2002;41 (2): 133-165.
69. Lamb WB,Kumar R,Wokutch RE.Corporate social performance and the road to redemption: Insights from the South Africa sanctions.Organizational Analysis. 2005;13 (1): 1-14.
70. Latané B.The psychology of social impact.American Psychologist. 1981;36 (4): 343-356.
71. Lindblom CPolitics and Markets: The World's Political Economic Systems. New York: Basic Books; 1977:.
72. Litvin DCasting the Other: The Production and Maintenance of Inequalities in Work Organizations. Czarniawska BHopfl H, ed. London: Routledge; 2002:.
73. Litvin DHandbook of Workplace Diversity. Konrad APrasad PPringle J, ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE; 2006:75-94.
74. Lorbiecki A,Jack G.Critical turns in the evolution of diversity management.British Journal of Management. 2000;11 (3): 17-31.
75. Maak T,Pless N.Business leaders as citizens of the world. Advancing humanism on a global scale.Journal of Business Ethics. 2009;88 (3): 537-550.
76. Mackey A,Mackey TB,Barney JB.Corporate social responsibility and firm performance: Investor preferences and corporate strategies.Academy of Management Review. 2007;32 (3): 817-835.
77. Mannix E,Neale MA.What differences make a difference?.Psychological Science in the Public Interest. 2005;6 (2): 31-55.
78. Margolis JD,Walsh JP.Misery loves companies rethinking social initiatives by business.Administrative Science Quarterly. 2003;48 (2): 268-305.
79. Martin J,Meyerson DNew Approaches in Management and Organization. Barry DHansen H, ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE; 2008:552-553.
80. MasciandaroDPansiniRVQuintynM (2011) The economic crisis: Did financial supervision matter?IMF Working Paper WP/11/261. Available at: http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2011/wp11261.pdf (accessed 2 May 2012).
81. Matten D,Crane A.Corporate citizenship: Toward an extended theoretical conceptualization.Academy of Management Review. 2005;30 (1): 166-179.
82. Matten D,Crane A,Chapple W.Behind the mask: Revealing the true face of corporate citizenship.Journal of Business Ethics. 2003;45 (1-2): 109-20.
83. McCarthy JM,Van Iddekinge CH,Campion MA.Are highly structured job interviews resistant to demographic similarity effects?.Personnel Psychology. 2010;63 (2): 325-359.
84. Messick DM,Brewer MBReview of Personality and Social Psychology. Wheeler LShaver P, ed. Beverly Hills, CA: SAGE; 1983:11-44.
85. Milinski M,Semmann D,Krambeck H-J.Reputation helps solve the 'tragedy of the commons'.Nature. 2002;415 (6870): 424-426.
86. Nkomo S.The emperor has no clothes: Rewriting 'race in organizations'.Academy of Management Review. 1992;17 (3): 487-513.
87. Noon M.The fatal flaws of diversity and the business case for ethnic minorities.Work, Employment and Society. 2007;21 (4): 773-783.
88. Nowak M,Sigmund K.The dynamics of indirect responsibility.Journal of Theoretical Biology. 1998;194 (4): 561-574.
89. Ohmae KThe Borderless World: Power and Strategy in the Interlinked Economy. New York: Harper Business; 1990:.
90. O'Leary BJ,Weathington BL.Beyond the business case for diversity in organizations.Employee Responsibilities & Rights Journal. 2006;18 (4): 1-10.
91. Orenstein PWorkplace, Women's Place: An Anthology. 2002) Shortchanging girls: Gender socialization in schools. In: DubeckPDunnD (eds) Workplace, Women's Place: An Anthology, 2nd edn. Los Angeles, CA: Roxbury Publishers, 38-46.Dubeck PDunn D, ed. Los Angeles, CA: Roxbury Publishers; 2002:38-46.
92. Özbilgin M,Tatli AGlobal Diversity Management: An Evidence Based Approach. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan; 2008:.
93. Özbilgin M,Tatli A.Mapping out the field of equality and diversity: Rise of individualism and voluntarism.Human Relations. 2011;64 (9): 1229-1258.
94. Özbilgin MF,Vassilopoulou JReport to the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD). London:; 2010:.
95. Pearce JL.Less epistemology; more government and social status.Human Relations. 2001a;54 (1): 85-89.
96. Pearce JLOrganization and Management in the Embrace of Government. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 2001b:.
97. Pfeffer J.Building sustainable organizations: The human factor.Academy of Management Perspectives. 2010;24 (1): 34-45.
98. Pies I,Hielscher S,Beckham M.Moral commitments and the societal role of business: An ordonomic approach to corporate citizenship.Business Ethics Quarterly. 2009;3 (3): 375-401.
99. Platt J.Social traps.American Psychologist. 1973;28 (8): 641-651.
100. Porter M,Kramer MR.Creating shared value.Harvard Business Review. 2011;:.
101. Putnam RDMaking Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 1993:.
102. Richard O.Racial diversity, business strategy, and firm performance: A resource-based view.Academy of Management Journal. 2000;43 (2): 164-177.
103. Ring PS,Bigley GA,D'Aunno T,Khanna T.Perspectives on how governments matter.Academy of Management Review. 2005;30 (2): 308-320.
104. Roberson Q.Disentangling the meanings of diversity and inclusion in organizations.Group and Organization Management. 2006;31 (2): 212-236.
105. SakouiA (2011) Sovereigns turn to pre-crisis financial wizardry. Financial Times. Available at: http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/53b445a0-4045-11e0-9140-00144feabdc0.html#axzz1u6udGDXP (accessed 2 May 2012).
106. Scherer AG,Palazzo G.The new political role of business in a globalized world: A review of a new perspective on CSR and its implications for the firm, governance, and democracy.Journal of Management Studies. 2011;48 (4): 899-931.
107. Scherer AG,Palazzo G,Baumann D.Global rules and private actors. Towards a new role of the TNC in global governance.Business Ethics Quarterly. 2006;16 (4): 502-532.
108. Scherer AG,Palazzo G,Matten D.Introduction to the special issue: Globalization as a challenge for business responsibilities.Business Ethics Quarterly. 2009;19 (3): 327-347.
109. Schneider SK,Northcraft GB.Three social dilemmas of workforce diversity in organizations: A social identity perspective.Human Relations. 1999;52 (11): 1445-1467.
110. Seierstad C,Healy G.Women's equality in the Scandinavian academy - a distant dream?.Work, Employment and Society. 2012;26 (2): 296-313.
111. Sen S,Bhattacharya CB.Does doing good always lead to doing better? Consumer reactions to corporate social responsibility.Journal of Marketing. 2001;38 (2): 225-243.
112. Skinner BFContingencies of Reinforcement: A Theoretical Analysis. New York: Appleton; 1969:.
113. Stahl G,Maznevski ML,Voigt A,Jonsen K.Unravelling the diversity-performance link in multicultural teams: Meta-analysis of studies on the impact of cultural diversity in teams.Journal of International Business Studies. 2010;41 (4): 690-709.
114. Tatli A.A multi-layered exploration of the diversity management field: Diversity discourses, practices and practitioners in the UK.British Journal of Management. 2011;22 (2): 238-253.
115. Tatli A,Özbilgin M.Understanding diversity managers' role in organizational change: Towards a conceptual framework.Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences. 2009;26:244-258.
116. Tatli A,Özbilgin M.An emic approach to intersectional study of diversity at work: A Bourdieuan framing.International Journal of Management Reviews. 2012;13 (2): 177-198.
117. Taylor DM,Taylor GM.The collapse and transformation of our world.Journal of Futures Studies. 2007;11 (3): 29-46.
118. Schumpeter. The eclipse of the public company. 2010;:51.
119. Tullock GThe Social Dilemma: The Economics of War and Revolution. Blacksburg, VA: University Publications - Center for Study of Public Choice; 1974:.
120. Van Dijk E,De Cremer DSocial Psychology and Economics. De Cremer DZeelenberg MMurnighan JK, ed. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 2006:141-154.
121. Van Dijk E,Kwaadsteniet EW,De Cremer D.Tacit coordination in social dilemmas: The importance of having a common understanding.Journal of Personality & Social Psychology. 2009;96 (3): 665-678.
122. Vroom VHWork and Motivation. New York: Wiley; 1964:.
123. Wacquant L.Territorial stigmatization in the age of advanced marginality.Thesis Eleven. 2007;91:66-77.
124. Wacquant L.Ordering insecurity: Social polarization and the punitive upsurge.Radical Philosophy Review. 2008;11 (1): 9-27.
125. Wade-Benzoni K,Tenbrunsel A,Bazerman M.Egocentric interpretations of fairness in asymmetric, environmental social dilemmas: Explaining harvesting behavior and the role of communication.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. 1996;67 (2): 111-126.
126. Watson W,Kumar K,Michaelson LK.Cultural diversity's impact on interaction process and performance: Comparing homogeneous and diverse task groups.Academy of Management Journal. 1993;36 (3): 590-602.
127. Weick KE.Small wins: Redefining the scale of social problems.American Psychologist. 1984;39 (1): 40-49.
128. Wettstein F.Beyond voluntariness, beyond CSR: Making a case for human rights and justice.Business and Society Review. 2009;114 (1): 125-152.
129. Whitehead ANEssays in Science and Philosophy. London: Ridler & Co; 1948:.
130. Wrench J.Diversity management can be bad for you.Race & Class. 2005;46 (3): 73-84.
131. Wu J.The impact of corporate supplier programs on corporate purchasers' intention to purchase from women-owned enterprises.Business & Society. 2010;49 (2): 359-380.
132. Yamagishi T.The provision of a sanctioning system as a public good.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 1986;51 (1): 110-116.
133. Young B.Disciplinary neoliberalism in the European Union and gender politics.New Political Economy. 2000;5 (1): 77-99.
134. Zanoni P.Diversity in the lean automobile factory: Doing class through gender, disability and age.Organization. 2011;18 (1): 105-127.
135. Zuran MWhose World Order? Uneven Globalization and the End of the Cold War. Holm HHSorensen G, ed. Boulder, CO: Westview; 1995:173-264.