Sympatric speciation in threespine stickleback: Why not?

International Journal of Ecology

Volumn , Issue , 2011, Pages

  Bolnick, Daniel I ^a  

^a HOWARD HUGHES MEDICAL INSTITUTE   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

GASTEROSTEUS; GASTEROSTEUS ACULEATUS;

EID: 81555203165     PISSN: 16879708     EISSN: 16879716     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1155/2011/942847     Document Type: Review

References (132)

1. Coyne J. A., Orr H. A., Speciation 2004 Sunderland, Mass, USA Sinauer Associates
2. Mayr E., Evolution and the Diversity of Life 1976 Cambridge, Mass, USA Belknap Press
3. Barluenga M., Stlting K. N., Salzburger W., Muschick M., Meyer A., Sympatric speciation in Nicaraguan crater lake cichlid fish Nature 2006 439 7077 719 723 (Pubitemid 43237617)
4. Ryan P. G., Bloomer P., Moloney C. L., Grant T. J., Delport W., Ecological speciation in South Atlantic island finches Science 2007 315 5817 1420 1423 (Pubitemid 46399552)
5. Savolainen V., Anstett M. C., Lexer C., Hutton I., Clarkson J. J., Norup M. V., Powell M. P., Springate D., Salamin N., Baker W. J., Sympatric speciation in palms on an oceanic island Nature 2006 441 7090 210 213
6. Schliewen U. K., Tautz D., Paabo S., Sympatric speciation suggested by monophyly of crater lake cichlids Nature 1994 368 6472 629 632
7. Barraclough T. G., Vogler A. P., Detecting the geographical pattern of speciation from species-level phylogenies American Naturalist 2000 155 4 419 434 (Pubitemid 30258043)
8. Brger R., Schneider K. A., Willensdorfer M., The conditions for speciation through intraspecific competition Evolution 2006 60 11 2185 2206 (Pubitemid 44925463)
9. Dieckmann U., Doebeli M., On the origin of species by sympatric speciation Nature 1999 400 6742 354 357 (Pubitemid 29355104)
10. Dieckmann U., Doebeli M., Metz J. A. J., Tautz D., Adaptive Speciation 2004 New York, NY, USA Cambridge University Press
11. Gavrilets S., Perspective: models of speciationwhat have we learned in 40 years? Evolution 2003 57 10 2197 2215 (Pubitemid 37388014)
12. Gavrilets S., Vose A., Case studies and mathematical models of ecological speciation. 2. Palms on an oceanic island Molecular Ecology 2007 16 14 2910 2921 (Pubitemid 47035460)
13. Gavrilets S., Vose A., Barluenga M., Salzburger W., Meyer A., Case studies and mathematical models of ecological speciation. 1. Cichlids in a crater lake Molecular Ecology 2007 16 14 2893 2909 (Pubitemid 47035461)
14. Hendry A. P., Bolnick D. I., Berner D., Peichel C. L., Forth and back on the speciation continuum: explorations with stickleback Journal of Fish Biology 2009 75 8 2000 2036
15. Abrams P. A., Matsuda H., Harada Y., Evolutionarily unstable fitness maxima and stable fitness minima of continuous traits Evolutionary Ecology 1993 7 5 465 487 (Pubitemid 24414429)
16. Brger R., Gimelfarb A., The effects of intraspecific competition and stabilizing selection on a polygenic trait Genetics 2004 167 3 1425 1443 (Pubitemid 39045647)
17. Doebeli M., A quantitative genetic competition model for sympatric speciation Journal of Evolutionary Biology 1996 9 6 893 909
18. Rosenzweig M. L., Competitive speciation Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 1978 10 3 275 289
19. Brger R., Schneider K. A., Intraspecific competitive divergence and convergence under assortative mating American Naturalist 2006 167 2 190 205 (Pubitemid 43271173)
20. Felsenstein J., Skepticism towards Santa Rosalia, or why are there so few kinds of animals Evolution 1981 35 124 138
21. Gavrilets S., Fitness Landscapes and the Origin of Species 2004 Princeton, NJ, USA Princeton University Press
22. Arajo M., Bolnick D. I., Diet as a primary target for natural selection in the threespine stickleback. Evolutionary Ecology Research. In press
23. Snowberg L. K., Bolnick D. I., Assortative mating by diet in a phenotypically unimodal but ecologically variable population of stickleback American Naturalist 2008 172 5 733 739
24. Bolnick D. I., On L. L., Predictable patterns of disruptive selection in stickleback in postglacial lakes American Naturalist 2008 172 1 1 11 (Pubitemid 351920307)
25. Gavrilets S., Adaptive speciationit is not that easy: a reply to Doebeli et al Evolution 2005 59 3 696 699 (Pubitemid 40441336)
26. Bolnick D. I., Svanbck R., Fordyce J. A., Yang L. H., Davis J. M., Hulsey C. D., Forister M. L., The ecology of individuals: Incidence and implications of individual specialization American Naturalist 2003 161 1 1 28 (Pubitemid 36144810)
27. Smith T. B., Sklason S., Evolutionary significance of resource polymorphisms in fishes, amphibians, and birds Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 1996 27 111 133
28. raujo M. A., Layman C., Bolnick D. I., The ecological causes of individual specialization Ecology Letters 2011 14 948 958
29. Butlin R. K., The variability of mating signals and preferences in the brown planthopper, Nilaparvata lugens (Homoptera: Delphacidae) Journal of Insect Behavior 1993 6 2 125 140
30. Lande R., Arnold S. J., The measurement of selection on correlated characters Evolution 1983 37 1210 1226
31. Kingsolver J. G., Hoekstra H. E., Hoekstra J. M., Berrigan D., Vignieri S. N., Hill C. E., Hoang A., Gibert P., Beerli P., The strength of phenotypic selection in natural populations American Naturalist 2001 157 3 245 261 (Pubitemid 32214660)
32. Wilson D. S., Turelli M., Stable underdominance and the evolutionary invasion of empty niches American Naturalist 1986 127 6 835 850 (Pubitemid 17252094)
33. Jiang Y., Bolnick D. I., Kirkpatrick M., Widespread positive assortative mating within animal populations. In revision
34. Puebla O., Bermingham E., Guichard F., Whiteman E., Colour pattern as a single trait driving speciation in Hypoplectrus coral reef fishes? Proceedings of the Royal Society B 2007 274 1615 1265 1271 (Pubitemid 47056699)
35. Reynolds R. G., Fitzpatrick B. M., Assortative mating in poison-dart frogs based on an ecologically important trait Evolution 2007 61 9 2253 2259 (Pubitemid 47340756)
36. Hendry A. P., Huber S. K., De Len L. F., Herrel A., Podos J., Disruptive selection in a bimodal population of Darwin's finches Proceedings of the Royal Society B 2008 276 1657 753 759
37. Huber S. K., De Leon L. F., Hendry A. P., Bermingham E., Podos J., Reproductive isolation between sympatric morphs in a bimodal population of Darwin's finches Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B 2007 274 1709 1714 (Pubitemid 47356121)
38. Schluter D., McPhail J. D., Ecological character displacement and speciation in sticklebacks American Naturalist 1992 140 1 85 108
39. Robinson B. W., Wilson D. S., Character release and displacement in fishes: a neglected literature American Naturalist 1994 144 4 596 627
40. Smith T. B., Bill size polymorphism and intraspecific niche utilization in an African finch Nature 1987 329 6141 717 719
41. Arajo M. S., Guimaraes J. P. R., Svanbck R., Pinheiro A., dos Reis S. F., Bolnick D. I., Network analysis reveals contrasting effects of intraspecific competition on individual vs. population diets Ecology 2008 89 7 1981 1993
42. Price T., Diet variation in a population of Darwin's finches Ecology 1987 68 4 1015 1028
43. Doebeli M., Dieckmann U., Evolutionary branching and sympatric speciation caused by different types of ecological interactions American Naturalist 2000 156 4 S77 S101
44. Wootton R. J., The effect of size of food ration on egg production in the female three-spined stickleback, Gasterosteus aculeatus L Journal of Fish Biology 1973 5 1 89 96
45. Wootton R. J., Effect of food limitation during the breeding season on the size, body components and egg production of female sticklebacks (Gasterosteus aculeatus) Journal of Animal Ecology 1977 46 823 834
46. Wootton R. J., Effects of food and density on the reproductive biology of the threespine stickleback with a hypothesis on population limitation in sticklebacks Behaviour 1985 93 101 111
47. Ingram T., Stutz W. E., Bolnick D. I., Does intraspecific size variation in a predator affect its diet diversity and top-down control of prey? PLOS One 2011 6
48. Bolnick D. I., Can intraspecific competition drive disruptive selection? An experimental test in natural populations of sticklebacks Evolution 2004 58 3 608 618 (Pubitemid 38449135)
49. Vamosi S. M., Hatfield T., Schluter D., A test of ecological selection against young-of-the-year hybrids of sympatric sticklebacks Journal of Fish Biology 2000 57 1 109 121
50. Rundle H. D., Vamosi S. M., Schluter D., Experimental test of predation's effect on divergent selection during character displacement in sticklebacks Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2003 100 25 14943 14948 (Pubitemid 37517996)
51. Schluter D., Experimental evidence that competition promotes divergence in adaptive radiation Science 1994 266 5186 798 801 (Pubitemid 24359287)
52. Schluter D., Frequency dependent natural selection during character displacement in sticklebacks Evolution 2003 57 5 1142 1150 (Pubitemid 36726568)
53. Snowberg L., Hendrix K. A., Bolnick D. I., Individual diet specialization is widespread across lacustrine threespine stickleback. In preparation
54. Bolnick D. I., Paull J., Diet similarity declines with morphological distance between conspecific individuals Evolutionary Ecology Research 2009 11 1217 1233
55. Snowberg L., Hendrix K. A., Bolnick D. I., Variable variation: patterns of intraspecific niche variation across lake populations of threespine stickleback. In press
56. Svanbck R., Bolnick D. I., Intraspecific competition drives increased resource use diversity within a natural population Proceedings of the Royal Society 2007 274 1611 839 844 (Pubitemid 47056764)
57. Bolnick D. I., Caldera E. J., Matthews B., Evidence for asymmetric migration load in a pair of ecologically divergent stickleback populations Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 2008 94 2 273 287 (Pubitemid 351776863)
58. Matthews B., Marchinko K. B., Bolnick D. I., Mazumder A., Specialization of trophic position and habitat use by sticklebacks in an adaptive radiation Ecology 2010 91 4 1025 1034
59. Robinson B. W., Trade offs in habitat-specific foraging efficiency and the nascent adaptive divergence of sticklebacks in lakes Behaviour 2000 137 7-8 865 888
60. Berner D., Kaeuffer R., Grandchamp A.-C., Raeymaekers J. A. M., Rasanen K., Hendry A. P., Quantitative genetic inheritance of morphological divergence in a lake-stream stickleback ecotype pair: implications for reproductive isolation Journal of Evolutionary Biology 2011 24 9 1975 1983
61. Day T., Pritchard J., Schluter D., A comparison of two sticklebacks Evolution 1994 48 5 1723 1734 (Pubitemid 26446762)
62. Hermida M., Fernndez C., Amaro R., San Miguel E., Heritability and evolvability of meristic characters in a natural population of Gasterosteus aculeatus Canadian Journal of Zoology 2002 80 3 532 541 (Pubitemid 34519716)
63. Peichel C. L., Nereng K. S., Ohgi K. A., Cole B. L. E., Colosimo P. F., Buerklet C. A., Schluter D., Kingsley D. M., The genetic architecture of divergence between threespine stickleback species Nature 2001 414 6866 901 905 (Pubitemid 34024739)
64. Vamosi S. M., The presence of other fish species affects speciation in threespine sticklebacks Evolutionary Ecology Research 2003 5 5 717 730 (Pubitemid 38681669)
65. Bolnick D. I., Ingram T., Stutz W. E., Snowberg L. K., Lau O. L., Pauli J. S., Ecological release from interspecific competition leads to decoupled changes in population and individual niche width Proceedings of the Royal Society B 2010 277 1689 1789 1797
66. Boughman J. W., Divergent sexual selection enhances reproductive isolation in sticklebacks Nature 2001 411 6840 944 948 (Pubitemid 32601489)
67. Hatfield T., Schluter D., A test for sexual selection on hybrids of two sympatric sticklebacks Evolution 1996 50 6 2429 2434
68. McKinnon J. S., Mori S., Blackman B. K., David L., Kingsley D. M., Jamieson L., Chou J., Schluter D., Evidence for ecology's role in speciation Nature 2004 429 6989 294 298 (Pubitemid 38691086)
69. Rundle H. D., Schluter D., Reinforcement of stickleback mate preferences: sympatry breeds contempt Evolution 1998 52 1 200 208 (Pubitemid 28195159)
70. Vamosi S. M., Schluter D., Sexual selection against hybrids between sympatric stickleback species: evidence from a field experiment Evolution 1999 53 3 874 879 (Pubitemid 29332420)
71. Eizaguirre C., Lenz T. L., Sommerfeld R. D., Harrod C., Kalbe M., Milinski M., Parasite diversity, patterns of MHC II variation and olfactory based mate choice in diverging three-spined stickleback ecotypes Evolutionary Ecology 2010 25 3 605 622
72. Vines T. H., Schluter D., Strong assortative mating between allopatric sticklebacks as a by-product of adaptation to different environments Proceedings of the Royal Society 2006 273 1589 911 916 (Pubitemid 46768418)
73. Raeymaekers J. A. M., Boisjoly M., Delaire L., Berner D., Rsnen K., Hendry A. P., Testing for mating isolation between ecotypes: laboratory experiments with lake, stream and hybrid stickleback Journal of Evolutionary Biology 2010 23 12 2694 2708
74. Snowberg L. K., Bolnick D. I., Disentangling spatial segregation and assortative mating in threespine stickleback. Unpublished manuscript
75. Ward A. J. W., Hart P. J. B., Krause J., The effects of habitat- and diet-based cues on association preferences in three-spined sticklebacks Behavioral Ecology 2004 15 6 925 929 (Pubitemid 39471200)
76. Snowberg L., Bolnick D. I., Diet-dependent mate preferences in threespine stickleback. Unpublished manuscript
77. Milinski M., The function of mate choice in sticklebacks: optimizing Mhc genetics Journal of Fish Biology 2003 63 supplement A 1 16 (Pubitemid 38592455)
78. Bell M. A., Foster S. A., The Evolutionary Biology of the Threespine Stickleback 1994 New York, NY, USA Oxford University Press
79. Gow J. L., Rogers S. M., Jackson M., Schluter D., Ecological predictions lead to the discovery of a benthic-limnetic sympatric species pair of threespine stickleback in Little Quarry Lake, British Columbia Canadian Journal of Zoology 2008 86 6 564 571 (Pubitemid 351947198)
80. McKinnon J. S., Rundle H. D., Speciation in nature: the threespine stickleback model systems Trends in Ecology and Evolution 2002 17 10 480 488 (Pubitemid 35249998)
81. Gow J. L., Peichel C. L., Taylor E. B., Ecological selection against hybrids in natural populations of sympatric threespine sticklebacks Journal of Evolutionary Biology 2007 20 6 2173 2180 (Pubitemid 47621915)
82. Taylor E. B., Boughman J. W., Groenenboom M., Sniatynski M., Schluter D., Gow J. L., Speciation in reverse: morphological and genetic evidence of the collapse of a three-spined stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) species pair Molecular Ecology 2006 15 2 343 355
83. Behm J. E., Ives A. R., Boughman J. W., Breakdown in postmating isolation and the collapse of a species pair through hybridization American Naturalist 2010 175 1 11 26
84. Cresko W. A., Baker J. A., Two morphotypes of lacustrine threespine stickleback, Gasterosteus aculeatus, in Benka Lake, Alaska Environmental Biology of Fishes 1996 45 4 343 350
85. Kristjnsson B. K., Sklason S., Noakes D. L. G., Morphological segregation of Icelandic threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus L) Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 2002 76 2 247 257
86. Kristjnsson B. K., Sklason S., Noakes D. L. G., Rapid divergence in a recently isolated population of threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus L.) Evolutionary Ecology Research 2002 4 5 659 672 (Pubitemid 135694231)
87. McPhail J. D., Ecology and evolution of sympatric sticklebacks (Gasterosteus): origin of the species pairs Canadian Journal of Zoology 1993 71 3 515 523
88. Taylor E. B., McPhail J. D., Evolutionary history of an adaptive radiation in species pairs of threespine sticklebacks (Gasterosteus): insights from mitochondrial DNA Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 1999 66 3 271 291 (Pubitemid 29157981)
89. Rundle H. D., Nagel L., Boughman J. W., Schluter D., Natural selection and parallel speciation in sympatric sticklebacks Science 2000 287 5451 306 308 (Pubitemid 30046757)
90. Mathews W. H., Fyles J. G., Nasmith H. W., Postglacial crustal movements in southwestern British Columbia and adjacent Washington State Canadian Journal of Earth Science 1970 7 690 702
91. Taylor E. B., McPhail J. D., Historical contingency and ecological determinism interact to prime speciation in sticklebacks, Gasterosteus Proceedings of the Royal Society B 2000 267 1460 2375 2384 (Pubitemid 32001478)
92. Kassen R., Schluter D., McPhail J. D., Evolutionary history of threespine sticklebacks (Gasterosteus spp.) in British Columbia: insights from a physiological clock Canadian Journal of Zoology 1995 73 2154 2158
93. Hutchinson I., James T. S., Clague J. J., Barrie J. V., Conway K. W., Reconstruction of late Quaternary sea-level change in southwestern British Columbia from sediments in isolation basins Boreas 2004 33 3 183 194 (Pubitemid 39080991)
94. Bolnick D. I., Waiting for sympatric speciation Evolution 2004 58 4 895 899 (Pubitemid 38583877)
95. Doebeli M., Blok H. J., Leimar O., Dieckmann U., Multimodal pattern formation in phenotype distributions of sexual populations Proceedings of the Royal Society B 2007 274 1608 347 357 (Pubitemid 47055458)
96. Gavrilets S., The Maynard Smith model of sympatric speciation Journal of Theoretical Biology 2006 239 2 172 182
97. Bolnick D. I., Fitzpatrick B. M., Sympatric speciation: models and empirical evidence Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 2007 38 459 487
98. Matessi C., Gimelfarb A., Gavrilets S., Long term buildup of reproductive isolation promoted by disruptive selection: how far does it go? Selection 2001 2 41 64
99. Polechov J., Barton N. H., Speciation through competition: a critical review Evolution 2005 59 6 1194 1210 (Pubitemid 40870416)
100. Siepielski A. M., Dibattista J. D., Carlson S. M., It's about time: the temporal dynamics of phenotypic selection in the wild Ecology Letters 2009 12 11 1261 1276
101. Siepielski A. M., Di Battista J. D., Evans J. A., Carlson S. M., Differences in the temporal dynamics of phenotypic selection among fitness components in the wild Proceedings of The Royal Society B 2011 278 1572 1580
102. Wootton R. J., Smith C., A long-term study of a short-lived fish: the demography of Gasterosteus aculeatus Behaviour 2000 137 7-8 981 997
103. Svanbck R., Persson L., Population density fluctuations change the selection gradient in eurasian perch American Naturalist 2009 173 4 507 516
104. Reimchen T. E., Nosil P., Ecological causes of sex-biased parasitism in threespine stickleback Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 2001 73 1 51 63 (Pubitemid 32602367)
105. Reimchen T. E., Nosil P., Temporal variation in divergent selection on spine number in threespine stickleback Evolution 2002 56 12 2472 2483 (Pubitemid 36108562)
106. Reimchen T. E., Nosil P., Variable predation regimes predict the evolution of sexual dimorphism in a population of threespine stickleback Evolution 2004 58 6 1274 1281 (Pubitemid 38826280)
107. Reimchen T. E., Nosil P., Replicated ecological landscapes and the evolution of morphological diversity among Gasterosteus populations from an archipelago on the west coast of Canada Canadian Journal of Zoology 2006 84 5 643 654 (Pubitemid 44213485)
108. Johansson J., Ripa J., Will sympatric speciation fail due to stochastic competitive exclusion? American Naturalist 2006 168 4 572 578 (Pubitemid 44582863)
109. Johansson J., Ripa J., Kucklnder N., The risk of competitive exclusion during evolutionary branching: effects of resource variability, correlation and autocorrelation Theoretical Population Biology 2010 77 2 95 104
110. Svanbck R., Pineda-Krch M., Doebeli M., Fluctuating population dynamics promotes the evolution of phenotypic plasticity American Naturalist 2009 174 2 176 189
111. Ackermann M., Doebeli M., Evolution of niche width and adaptive diversification Evolution 2004 58 12 2599 2612 (Pubitemid 40078409)
112. Roughgarden J., Evolution of niche width American Naturalist 1972 106 683 718
113. Slatkin M., Frequency- and density-dependent selection on a quantitative character Genetics 1979 93 3 755 771 (Pubitemid 10121926)
114. Rueffler C., Van Dooren T. J. M., Leimar O., Abrams P. A., Disruptive selection and then what? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 2006 21 5 238 245 (Pubitemid 43669032)
115. Bolnick D. I., Doebeli M., Sexual dimorphism and adaptive speciation: two sides of the same ecological coin Evolution 2003 57 11 2433 2449 (Pubitemid 37502549)
116. Berner D., Stutz W. E., Bolnick D. I., Diversification in phenotypic (co)variances among lacustrine populations of threespine stickleback Evolution 2010 64 2265 2277
117. Shine R., Ecological causes for the evolution of sexual dimorphism: a review of the evidence Quarterly Review of Biology 1989 64 4 419 461 (Pubitemid 20426746)
118. Van Dooren T. J. M., Durinx M., Demon I., Sexual dimorphism or evolutionary branching? Evolutionary Ecology Research 2004 6 6 857 871 (Pubitemid 39283041)
119. Cooper I., Gilman R. T., Boughman J. W., Sexual dimorphism and speciation on two ecological coins: patterns from nature and theoretical predictions Evolution 2011 65 9 2553 2571
120. Kitano J., Mori S., Peichel C. L., Sexual dimorphism in the external morphology of the threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) Copeia 2007 2 336 349 (Pubitemid 47164604)
121. Leinonen T., Cano J. M., Merila J., Genetic basis of seual dimorphism in the threespine stickleback Gasterosteus aculeatus Heredity 2011 106 218 227
122. Thibert-Plante X., Hendry A., The consequences of phenotypic plasticity for ecological speciation Journal of Evolutionary Biology 2011 24 326 342
123. Stephens D. W., Krebs J. R., Foraging Theory 1986 Princeton, NJ, USA Princeton University Press
124. Werner E. E., Optimal foraging and the size selection of prey by the bluegill sunfish (Lepomis macrochirus) Ecology 1974 55 1042 1052
125. Svanbck R., Bolnick D. I., Intraspecific competition affects the strength of individual specialization: an optimal diet theory method Evolutionary Ecology Research 2005 7 7 993 1012 (Pubitemid 41677383)
126. Dres M., Mallet J., Host races in plant-feeding insects and their importance in sympatric speciation Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 2002 357 471 472
127. Doebeli M., Dieckmann U., Metz J. A. J., Tautz D., What we have also learned: adaptive speciation is theoretically plausible Evolution 2005 59 3 691 695 (Pubitemid 40441335)
128. Box G. E. P., Draper N. R., Empirical Model Building and Response Surfaces 1987 Boston, Mass, USA John Wiley Sons
129. Dieckmann U., Doebeli M., Metz J. A. J., Tautz D., Adaptive Speciation 2004 New York, NY, USA Cambridge University Press
130. Lande R., Models of speciation by sexual selection on polygenic traits Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 1981 78 6 3721 3725 (Pubitemid 11060449)
131. Hall D. W., Kirkpatrick M., West B., Runaway sexual selection when female preferences are directly selected Evolution 2000 54 6 1862 1869 (Pubitemid 32113818)
132. R Development Core Team, R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing 2007 Vienna, Austria