The competition fetish in higher education: Shamans, mind snares and consequences

European Educational Research Journal

Volumn 17, Issue 5, 2018, Pages 605-620

  Naidoo, Rajani ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BATH   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Competition; excellence contests; fetish; neoliberal higher education; ranking; world class

Indexed keywords

EID: 85049613929     PISSN: None     EISSN: 14749041     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1474904118784839     Document Type: Article

References (109)

1. Abbott A, (2017) Efforts to save leading Hungarian university hit hurdle. Nature 550(442) (18 October). Available at: https://www.nature.com/news/efforts-to-save-leading-hungarian-university-hit-hurdle-1.22855 (accessed 12 February 2018)
2. Adriansen HK, Madsen LM, Jensen S, (eds) (2015) Higher Education and Capacity Building in Africa: The Geography and Power of Knowledge under Changing Conditions. Abingdon: Routledge
3. Ahmed S, (2004) Affective economies. Social Text 22(2): 117–139
4. Ainley P, (2004) The new ‘market-state’ and education. Journal of Education Policy 19(4): 497–514
5. Alvesson M, Gabriel Y, Paulsen R, (2017) Return to Meaning: A Social Science with Something to Say. Oxford: Oxford University Press
6. Ball SJ, (2018) Corporate elites and the reform of public education. Educational Review 70(3): 383–384
7. Barley SR, (2007) Corporations, democracy, and the public good. Journal of Management Inquiry 16(3): 201–215
8. Bayliss K, Fine B, Van Waeyenberge E, (2011) The Political Economy of Development: The World Bank, Neoliberalism and Development Research. London: Pluto Press
9. Berlant LG, (2011) Cruel Optimism. Durham, NC and London: Duke University Press
10. Bok D, (2003) Universities in the Marketplace: The Commercialization of Higher Education. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
11. Bourdieu P, (1998a) The State Nobility: Elite Schools in the Field of Power. Cambridge: Polity Press
12. Bourdieu P, (1998b) The essence of neoliberalism: Utopia of endless exploitation. Le Monde Diplomatique (translated by Shapiro JJ,). Available at http://www.homme-moderne.org/societe/socio/bourdieu/varia/essneoUK.html. (accessed 12 February 2018)
13. Bourdieu P, (1988) Homo Academicus. Cambridge: Polity Press
14. Bourdieu P, (1986) The forms of capital. In: Richardson ER, (ed.) Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education. New York: Greenwood Press
15. Bowles S, (2016) The Moral Economy: Why Good Incentives are no Substitute for Good Citizens. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press
16. Brennan J, Naidoo R, Franco M, (2017) From academic profession to higher education workforce: Academic careers in the UK. In: Machado-Taylor M, Soares VM, Teichler U, (eds) Challenges and Options: The Academic Profession in Europe. Dordrecht: Springer, pp 231–252
17. Brøgger K, (2016) The rule of mimetic desire in higher education: Governing through naming, shaming and faming. British Journal of Sociology of Education 37(1): 72–91
18. Brown P, Lauder H, Ashton D, (2010) The Global Auction: The Broken Promises of Education, Jobs and Rewards. New York: Oxford University Press
19. Brown P, Lauder H, Sung J, (2015) Higher Education, corporate talent and the stratification of knowledge work in the global labour market. In: Van Zanten A, Ball SJ, Darchy-Koechlin B, (eds) World Yearbook of Education 2015 – Elites, Privilege and Excellence: The National and Global Redefinition of Educational Advantage. New York: Routledge
20. Brown R, (ed) (2010) Higher Education and the Market. New York: Routledge
21. Brown W, (2015) Undoing the Demos: Neoliberalism’s Stealth Revolution. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
22. Cantwell B, Kauppinen I, (eds) (2014) Academic Capitalism in the Age of Globalization. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press
23. Cardoso M, Steiner-Khamsi G, (2017) The making of comparability: Education indicator research from Jullien de Paris to the 2030 sustainable development goals. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education 47(3): 388–405
24. Cerny PG, (2010) The competition state today: From raison d’État to raison du Monde. Policy Studies 31(1): 5–21
25. Collini S, (2012) What Are Universities For? London: Penguin
26. Collins R, (1998) The Sociology of Philosophies: A Global Theory of Intellectual Change. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
27. Curran T, Hill AP, (2017) Perfectionism is increasing over time: A meta-analysis of birth cohort differences from 1989 to 2016. Psychological Bulletin. Advance online publication. Advance online publication http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/bul0000138
28. Dale R, (2016) The under-recognition of the significance of social class conceptions of education in Piketty’s Capital. British Journal of Sociology of Education 37(6): 836–847
29. David M, (2016) Fabricated world class: Global university league tables, status differentiation and myths of global competition. British Journal of Sociology of Education 37(1): 169–189
30. Davies W, (2016) The Limits of Neoliberalism: Authority, Sovereignty and the Logic of Competition. London: Sage
31. Deem R, (2004) The knowledge worker, the manager-academic and the contemporary UK university: New and old forms of public management? Financial Accountability and Management 20(2): 107–128
32. Deem R, Mok KH, Lucas L, (2008) Transforming higher education in whose image? Exploring the concept of the ‘world-class’ university in Europe and Asia. Higher Education Policy 21(1): 83–97
33. Decuypere C, Simons M, (2016) Continuing attachments in academic work in neoliberal times: on the academic mode of existence. Critical Studies in Education (published online: October): 1–19. Available at https://doi.org/10.1080/17508487.2016.1240095 (accessed 10 February 2018)
34. Dequech D, (2007) Neoclassical, mainstream, orthodox, and heterodox economics. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics 30(2): 279–302
35. Enders J, (2015) The academic arms race: International rankings and global competition for world-class universities. In: Pettigrew AW, Cornuel E, Hommel U, (eds) The Institutional Development of Business Schools. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 155–175
36. Enders J, Naidoo R, (2018) Audit-market intermediaries: Doing institutional work in British research intensive universities. Studies in Higher Education (E-publication in advance of hard-copy, 12 February) DOI: 10.1080/03075079.2018.1436536
37. Enders J, Westerheijden DF, (2011). The Bologna process: From the national to the regional to the global, and back. In: King R, Marginson S, Naidoo R, (eds) Handbook on Globalization and Higher Education: Cheltenham and Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar, pp. 469–484
38. Espeland WN, Sauder M, (2016) Engines of Anxiety: Academic Rankings, Reputation and Accountability. New York: Russell Sage Foundation
39. Etzkowitz H, Leydesdorff L, (2000) The dynamics of innovation: From national systems and Mode 2 to a Triple Helix of university–industry–government relations. Research Policy 29(2): 109–123
40. Findlow S, Hayes A, (2016) Transnational academic capitalism in the Arab Gulf: Balancing global and local, and public and private, capitals. British Journal of Sociology of Education 37(1): 110–128
41. Flaherty C, (2017) Iowa bill would force ‘partisan balance’ in hiring. Inside Higher Ed 21 (February): 201. Available at https://www.insidehighered.com/quicktakes/2017/02/21/iowa-bill-would-force-partisan-balance-hiring(accessed 08 February 2018)
42. Freud S, (1950) [1927] Fetishism. In: Strachey J, (ed.) Collected Papers, Miscellaneous Papers, 1988–1938, Volume 5. London: Hogarth Press
43. Freud S, Strachey J, (1962) Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality (translated and edited by Strachey J,). London: Hogarth Press
44. Forstenzer J, (2016) The teaching excellence framework: What’s the purpose? Sheffield: Sir Bernard Crick Centre, University of Sheffield. Available at: http://www.crickcentre.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/TEF-Whats-the-Purpose-booklet-Josh-Forstenzer.pdf. (accessed 13 February 2018)
45. Gamman L, Makinen M, (1994) Female Fetishism. London: Lawrence and Wishart
46. Gourlay L, Stevenson J, (2017) Teaching excellence in higher education: Critical perspectives. Teaching in Higher Education 22 (4): 391–395
47. Halloy A, (2015) Pierre Smith’s mind traps: The origin and ramifications of a theory of ritual efficacy. Anthropological Theory 15(3): 358–374
48. Hartman E, (2008) Bologna goes global: A new imperialism in the making? Globalisation, Societies and Education 6(3): 207–220
49. Hazelkorn E, (2015) Rankings and the Reshaping of Higher Education: The Battle for World-class Excellence. Dordrecht: Springer
50. Henderson J, (2008) China and the future of the developing world: The coming global-Asian era and its consequences. Research paper No. 2008.58. United Nations University World Institute for Development Economics Research (UNU-WIDER). Available at: https://www.wider.unu.edu/publication/china-and-future-developing-world (accessed 08 June 2018)
51. Hodgson GM, Knudsen T, (2006) Dismantling Lamarckism: Why descriptions of socio-economic evolution as Lamarckian are misleading. Journal of Evolutionary Economics 16(4): 343–366
52. Holmwood J, Balon J, (2018) Neo-liberalism, populism and the demise of the public university. In: Nerlich B, Hartley S, Raman S, Smith A, (eds) Science and the Politics of Openness: Here be Monsters. Manchester: Manchester University Press
53. Huang F, (2015) Building the world-class research universities: A case study of China. Higher Education 70(2): 203–215
54. James D, (2017) Professional identity, learning cultures and educational quality: Some lessons from further education. Wales Journal of Education 19(1): 107–124
55. Jessop B, Fairclough N, Wodak R, (2008) The Knowledge-based Economy and Higher Education in Europe. Rotterdam: Sense
56. Kehm BM, (2013) To be or not to be? The impacts of the excellence initiative on the German system of higher education. In: Shin JC, Kehm BM, (eds) Institutionalization of World-Class University in Global Competition. Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 81–97
57. Klees SJ, Samoff J, Stromquist NP, (eds) (2012) The World Bank and Education: Critiques and Alternatives (Volume 14). Dordrecht: Springer Science & Business Media
58. Krucken G, (2017) Competition in higher education: A research agenda. International Centre for Higher Education Management seminar series, School of Management, University of Bath, Bath, UK, 22 February 2017
59. Littler J, (2013) Meritocracy as plutocracy: The marketising of ‘equality’ under neoliberalism. New Formations 80(80): 52–72
60. Locke WD, Verbik L, Richardson JTE, King R, (2008) Counting what is measured or measuring what counts? League tables and the impact on higher education institutions in England, Appendix A. Research Methodologies Circular 2008/14. Bristol: Higher Education Funding Council for England
61. Luke A, (2011) Generalizing across borders: Policy and the limits of educational science. Educational Researcher 40(8): 367–377
62. Ma W, (2013) The global research and the ‘world-class’ universities. In: Shin JC, Kehm BM, (eds) Institutionalization of World-Class University in Global Competition. Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 33–44
63. Macilwain C, (2009) The RAE: An assessment too far? Cell 139(4): 643–646
64. Marginson S, (2017) World-class universities and the global common good. University World News Issue 483 (17 November)
65. Marginson S, (2016) The worldwide trend to high participation higher education: Dynamics of social stratification in inclusive systems. Higher Education 72(4): 413–434
66. Marginson S, (2011) The Confucian model of higher education in East Asia and Singapore. In: Marginson S, Kaur S, Sawir E, (eds) Higher Education in the Asia-Pacific: Strategic Responses to Globalization. Springer, Dordrecht, pp. 53–75
67. Marginson S, (1997) Markets in Education. Sydney: Allen and Unwin
68. Mangez E, Lienard G, (2015) The field of power and the relative autonomy of social fields: The case of Belgium. In: Hilgers M, Mangez E, (eds) Bourdieu’s Theory of Social Fields: Concept and Applications. London and New York: Routledge
69. Marx K, (1965) [1867] Capital: A Critical Analysis of Capitalist Production. Engels F, (ed.), translated from the 3rd German edition by Moore S and Aveling A, Volume 1. Moscow: Progress Publishing
70. McNay I, (2008) The crisis in higher education: The views of academic professionals on policy, leadership, values and operational practices. Higher Education Review 40(2): 47–69
71. Mok KH, (2005) Globalization and educational restructuring: University merging and changing governance in China. Higher Education 50(1): 57–88
72. Molesworth M, Nixon E, Scullion R, (2009) Having, being and higher education: The marketisation of the university and the transformation of the student into consumer. Teaching in Higher Education 14(3): 277–287
73. Monbiot G, (2013) Captive State: The Corporate Takeover of Britain. London: Pan Macmillan
74. Mowery DC, Nelson RR, Sampat BN, Ziedonis AA, (2004) The Ivory Tower and Industrial Innovation: University–Industry Technology Transfer Before and After the Bayh–Dole Act. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
75. Naidoo R, (2008) L’État et le marché dans la réforme de l’enseignement supérieur au Royaume-Uni [The competitive state and the mobilised market: higher education policy reform in the United Kingdom] (1980–2007). Critique Internationale 39(2): 47–65
76. Naidoo R, (2017) Leading collaboration to solve global challenges (Leadership Insights Series). London: Leadership Foundation for Higher Education. Available at: file:///C:/Users/edsrn/Downloads/6846_lfhe_insights_-_liut_series_-_leading_collaboration_to_solve_global_challenges_16_6_17%20(5).pdf (accessed 12 February 2018)
77. Naidoo R, (2014) Transnational higher education: Global wellbeing or imperialism? Keynote Presentation, United Kingdom Forum for International Education Conference, UCL Institute of Education, London, UK, 24 October 2014. Unpublished conference paper
78. Naidoo R, (2011) Rethinking development: Higher education and the new imperialism. In: King R, Marginson S, Naidoo R, (eds) A Handbook on Globalization and Higher Education. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, pp. 40–58
79. Naidoo R, Pringle J, (2014) Branding business schools: Academic struggles with the management of reputation. In: Pettigrew AM, Cornuel E, Hommel U, (eds) The Institutional Development of Business Schools. Oxford: Oxford University Press
80. Naidoo R, Shankar A, Veer E, (2011) The consumerist turn in higher education: Policy aspirations and outcomes. Journal of Marketing Management 27(11–12): 1142–1162
81. Naidoo R, (2018) World class systems rather than world class universities. University World News 20 April 2018 Issue No:502 Available at: http://www.universityworldnews.com/article.php?story=20180417162622337 (accessed 19 June 2018)
82. Neary M, (2014) Student as producer: Research-engaged teaching frames university-wide curriculum development. CUR Quarterly 35(2): 28–34
83. Olssen M, (2016) Neoliberal competition in higher education today: Research, accountability and impact. British Journal of Sociology of Education 37(1):129–148
84. Ordorika I, Lloyd M, (2015) International rankings and the contest for university hegemony. Journal of Education Policy 30(3): 385–405
85. Ostrom E, (2015) Governing the Commons. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
86. Parraguez-Sanchez L, (2016) The Chilean student movement – A family matter: The intimate and conflicting construction of revolution in a post-dictatorial country. PhD Thesis, Loyola University of Chicago, Paper 1963. Available at: http://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss/1963 (accessed 12 February 2018)
87. Pels P, (1998) The spirit of matter: On fetish, rarity, fact, and fancy. In: Spyer P, (ed.) Border Fetishisms: Material Objects in the Unstable Spaces. London: Psychology Press, pp. 91–121
88. Pettersson D, Prøitz TS, Forsberg E, (2017) From role models to nations in need of advice: Norway and Sweden under the OECD’s magnifying glass. Journal of Education Policy 32(6): 721–744
89. Pietz W, (1987) The problem of the fetish II: The origin of the fetish. RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics 13(1): 23–45
90. Pietz W, (1985) The problem of the fetish I. RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics 9(1): 5–17
91. Pietz W, Apter E, (eds) (1993) Fetishism as Cultural Discourse. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press
92. Pusser B, (2001) The contemporary politics of access policy: California after Proposition 209. In: Heller DE, (ed.) The States and Public Higher Education Policy: Affordability, Access, and Accountability. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press, pp. 121–152
93. Restrepo J, Naidoo R, (2017) Colombia: How universities can help to build lasting peace. The Conversation (14 November). Available at https://theconversation.com/colombia-how-universities-can-help-to-build-lasting-peace-85343 (accessed 12 February 2018)
94. Robertson SL, (2008) Europe/Asia’s regionalism, higher education and the production of world order. Policy Futures in Education 6(6): 718–729
95. Robertson SL, Kedzierski M, (2016) On the move: Globalising higher education in Europe and beyond. The Language Learning Journal 44(3): 276–291
96. Shahjahan RA, Morgan C, (2016) Global competition, coloniality, and the geopolitics of knowledge in higher education. British Journal of Sociology of Education 37(1): 92–109
97. Slaughter S, Leslie LL, (1997) Academic Capitalism: Politics, Policies, and the Entrepreneurial University. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press
98. Smith P, (1982) Aspects of the organization of rites. In: Izard M, Smith P, (eds) Between Belief and Transgression: Structuralist Essays in Religion, History and Myth (Leavitt J, transl.). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
99. Stack M, (2016) Global University Rankings and the Mediatization of Higher Education. Dordrecht: Springer
100. Swartz D, (2017) The inter-generational challenges of South African higher education today. Keynote (unpublished presented at The contribution of business schools and higher education to inclusive development conference 19 April 2017 University of Stellenbosch)
101. Tanaka M, (2011) Fetishism: A double denial. ZINBUN 2009/2010 42: 131–146. Available at: https://repository.kulib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2433/139381/1/42_131.pdf(accessed 19 June 2018)
102. Valimaa J, (2005) Globalization in the concept of Nordic higher education (globalization and higher education). RIHE International Publication, Series 9: 93–113
103. Watermeyer R, (2016) Impact in the REF: Issues and obstacles. Studies in Higher Education 41(2): 199–214
104. Wedlin L, (2011) Going global: Rankings as rhetorical devices to construct an international field of management education. Management Learning 42(2): 199–218
105. Wetherell M, (2012) Affect and Emotion: A New Social Science Understanding. London: Sage Publications
106. Williams R, (1958) Culture and Society. London: Hogarth Press
107. Winn J, (2015) The co-operative university: Labour, property and pedagogy. Power and Education 7(1): 39–55
108. Wright S, Greenwood DJ, (2017) Universities run for, by, and with the faculty, students and staff: Alternatives to the neoliberal destruction of higher education. Learning and Teaching 10(1): 42–65
109. Wright S, Greenwood D, Boden R, (2011) Report on a field visit to Mondragón University: A cooperative experience/experiment. Learning and Teaching 4(3, Winter): 38–56