Law, legitimacy and the rationing of healthcare: A contextual and comparative perspective

Law, Legitimacy and the Rationing of Healthcare: A Contextual and Comparative Perspective

Volumn 9780521857734, Issue , 2007, Pages 1-252

  Syrett, Keith ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84929858621     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book    
DOI: 10.1017/CBO9780511495380     Document Type: Book

References (494)

1. B. Salter, The Politics of Change in the Health Service (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1998) at 17.
2. R. Klein, ‘Self-Inventing Institutions: Institutional Design and the UK Welfare State’ in R. Goodin (ed.), The Theory of Institutional Design (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1996) at 243.
3. N. Daniels, ‘Accountability for Reasonableness in Private and Public Health Insurance’ in A. Coulter and C. Ham (eds.), The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing (Buckingham: Open University Press, 2000) at 89.
4. M. Piccart-Gebhart, M. Proctor, B. Leyland-Jones et al., ‘Trastuzumab after Adjuvant Chemotherapy in HER2-positive Breast Cancer’ (2005) 353 New England Journal of Medicine, 1659
5. E. Romond, E. Perez, J. Bryant et al., ‘Trastuzumab Plus Adjuvant Chemotherapy for Operable HER2-Positive Breast Cancer’ (2005) 353 New England Journal of Medicine, 1673
6. R. Dent and M. Clemons, ‘Adjuvant Trastuzumab for Breast Cancer: We Need to Ensure that Equity Exists for Access to Effective and Expensive Treatments’ (2005) 331 British Medical Journal. 1035.
7. A. Barrett, T. Roques, M. Small et al., ‘How Much Will Herceptin Cost?’ (2006) 333 British Medical Journal, 1118.
8. A. d’Argue, quoted in ‘Woman Waits for Herceptin Ruling’, BBC News Online, 2 November 2005, available at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/manchester/4398588.stm (accessed 8 January 2005)
9. A.M. Rogers, quoted in ‘Doctors “Prescribing Herceptin”’, BBC News Online, 3 February 2006, available at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4677538.stm (accessed 8 January 2007)
10. K. Syrett, ‘A Technocratic Fix to the “Legitimacy Problem”? The Blair Government and Health Care Rationing in the United Kingdom’ (2003) 28 Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 715.
11. M. Rodwin, ‘The Politics of Evidence-Based Medicine’ (2001) 26 Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 439.
12. B. Clark, quoted in ‘Dying Nurse Sues NHS for Denying Her Cancer Drug’, The Observer, 18 September 2005.
13. Y. Amin (solicitor), quoted in ‘My Fight for Life’, ThisisWiltshire.co.uk, 19 December 2005, available at www.thisiswiltshire.co.uk/display.var.663185.0.my_fight_for_life.php (accessed 8 January 2007).
14. A. Bradley and K. Ewing, Constitutional and Administrative Law (London: Longman, 14th edn, 2006) at 9–10.
15. C. Newdick, Who Should We Treat? (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2nd edn, 2004)
16. A. Grubb, ‘Problems of Medical Law’, in S. Deakin, A. Johnston and B. Markesinis, Markesinis and Deakin’s Tort Law (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 5th edn, 2003) at 263
17. C. Ham and G. Robert (eds.), Reasonable Rationing (Buckingham: Open University Press, 2003).
18. W. Edgar, ‘Rationing in Health Care – a New Zealand Perspective on an International Dilemma’ (2001) 81 Schweizerische Ärztezeitung, 190 at 193.
19. I. Kennedy and A. Grubb, Medical Law (London: Butterworths, 3rd edn., 2000) at 6.
20. J. Mann, S. Gruskin, M. Grodin et al. (eds.), Health and Human Rights: a Reader (New York: Routledge, 1999).
21. J. Morone, ‘The Bias of American Politics – Rationing Health Care in a Weak State’ (1992) 140 University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 1923 at 1933.
22. J. Bryant, ‘Health Priority Dilemmas in Developing Countries’, in Coulter and Ham (eds.), The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing at 64
23. G. Mooney and V. Wiseman, ‘Burden of Disease and Priority-Setting’ (2000) 9 Health Economics, 369 at 371.
24. K. Khan, ‘Public Health Priorities and the Social Determinants of Ill Health’, in Coulter and Ham (eds.), The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing at 80.
25. D. Dolowitz and D. Marsh, ‘Who Learns What from Whom: a Review of the Policy Transfer Literature’ (1996) 44 Political Studies, 343 at 344.
26. H. Leichter, A Comparative Approach to Policy Analysis: Healthcare Policy in Four Nations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979) at 272.
27. K. Jacobs and P. Barnett, ‘Policy Transfer and Policy Learning: a Study of the 1991 New Zealand Health Services Taskforce’ (2000) 13 Governance, 185
28. C. Ham, ‘Priority-setting in Health Care: Learning from International Experience’ (1997) 42 Health Policy, 49
29. C. Ham and A. Coulter, ‘Explicit and Implicit Rationing: Taking Responsibility and Avoiding Blame for Health Care Choices’ (2001) 6 Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 163.
30. P. Ubel, Pricing Life: Why It’s Time for Health Care Rationing (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 2000) at 16.
31. Oxford English Dictionary (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2nd edn, 1989).
32. R. Klein, P. Day and S. Redmayne, Managing Scarcity (Buckingham: Open University Press, 1996) at 7.
33. A. Maynard, ‘Rationing Health Care: an Exploration’ (1999) 49 Health Policy, 5.
34. M. Loughlin, ‘Rationing, Barbarity and the Economist’s Perspective’ (1996) 4 Health Care Analysis, 146 at 148.
35. P. Ubel and S. Goold, ‘“Rationing” Health Care: Not All Definitions Are Created Equal’ (1998) 158 Archives of Internal Medicine, 209 at 214.
36. H. Aaron and W. Schwartz, ‘Rationing Health Care: the Choice Before Us’ (1990) 247 Science, 418.
37. L. Locock, ‘The Changing Nature of Rationing in the National Health Service’ (2000) 78 Public Administration, 90 at 92.
38. M. Hall, ‘The Problems with Rule-Based Rationing’ (1994) 19 Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 315.
39. C. Havighurst, ‘Prospective Self-denial – Can Consumers Contract Today to Accept Health Care Rationing Tomorrow?’ (1992) 140 University of Pennsylvania Law Review; 1755 at 1759.
40. U. Reinhardt, ‘Rationing Health Care: What It Is, What It Is Not and Why We Cannot Avoid It’ in S. Altman and U. Reinhardt (eds.), Strategic Choices for a Changing Health Care System (Chicago: Health Administration Press, 1996).
41. R. Evans, ‘Health Care Technology and the Inevitability of Resource Allocation and Rationing Decisions’ (1983) 249 Journal of the American Medical Association, 2208.
42. D. Hadorn and C. Brook, ‘The Health Care Resources Allocation Debate: Defining Our Terms’ (1991) 266 Journal of the American Medical Association, 3328 at 3331.
43. L. Fleck, ‘Just Health Care Rationing – a Democratic Decision-Making Approach’ (1992) 140 University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 1597 at 1605.
44. L. Brown, ‘The National Politics of Oregon’s Rationing Plan’ (1991) 10 Health Affairs, 28 at 30.
45. C. Dougherty, ‘Setting Health Care Priorities: Oregon’s Next Steps’ (1991) 21 Hastings Center Report, Supplement: 1 at 3.
46. R. Klein, ‘Priorities and Rationing: Pragmatism or Principles?’ (1995) 311 British Medical Journal, 761.
47. D. Mechanic, ‘Cost Containment and the Quality of Medical Care: Rationing Strategies In an Area of Constrained Resources’ (1985) 63 Millbank Quarterly, 453 at 457.
48. R. Klein, P. Day and S. Redmayne, ‘Rationing in theNHS: theDance of the Seven Veils – in Reverse’ (1995) 51 British Medical Bulletin 769 at 770.
49. C. Ham and A. Coulter, ‘Explicit and Implicit Rationing: Taking Responsibility and Avoiding Blame for Health Care Choices’ (2001) 6 Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 163.
50. A. Coulter and C. Ham (eds.), The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing (Buckingham: Open University Press, 2000) at 2
51. S. McIver and C. Ham, ‘Five Cases, Four Actors and a Moral: Lessons from Studies of Contested Treatment Decisions’ (2000) 3 Health Expectations, 114.
52. P. Mullen, ‘Is It Necessary to Ration Health Care?’ (1998) 18 Public Money and Management, 52.
53. D. Hunter, Desperately Seeking Solutions (London: Longman, 1997) at 25.
54. E. Tragakes and M. Vienonen, Key Issues in Rationing and Priority-setting for Health Care Services (Copenhagen: WHO, 1998) at 2–3.
55. R. Maxwell, ‘Why Rationing is on the Agenda’ (1995) 51 British Medical Bulletin, 761.
56. C. Bryson and B. New, ‘Health Care Rationing: a Cut Too Far?’, in R. Jowell, J. Curtice, A. Park et al., British Social Attitudes: the Seventeenth Report (London: Sage, 2000) at 21.
57. C. Ham and A. Coulter, ‘Conclusion – Where Are We Now?’, in Coulter and Ham (eds.), The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing at 233.
58. R. Klein, The New Politics of the NHS (London: Prentice Hall, 4th edn, 2001) at 66–7.
59. R. Klein, ‘Puzzling Out Priorities’ (1998) 317 British Medical Journal, 959.
60. A. Milburn, ‘Modern Services, Modern Choices: Tackling the Lottery of Health Care’, speech to NICE Conference, 8 December 1999, available at www.nice.org.uk/oldsite/conf/sos_speech.htm (accessed 8 January 2007).
61. The NHS Plan (London: HMSO, 2000)
62. M. Rawlins, ‘In Pursuit of Quality: the National Institute for Clinical Excellence’ (1999) 353 Lancet 1079 at 1082.
63. M. Rawlins, ‘Building a Reputation’, Primary Care: NHS Magazine (September 2004).
64. E. Powell, A New Look at Medicine and Politics (London: Pitman Medical, 1966) at 38.
65. G. Matthew, ‘Measuring Need and Evaluating Services’ in G. McLachan (ed.), Portfolio for Health (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1971) at 27.
66. A. Culyer, ‘Need: the Idea Won’t Do – but we still need it’ (1995) 40 Social Science and Medicine, 727.
67. A. Williams, ‘Need as a Demand Concept (with Special Reference to Health)’ in A. Culyer and A. Maynard (eds.) Being Reasonable about the Economics of Health (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 1997) at 180.
68. R. Cookson and P. Dolan, ‘Principles of Justice in Health Care Rationing’ (2000) 26 Journal of Medical Ethics, 323.
69. J. McKie and J. Richardson, ‘The Rule of Rescue’ (2003) 56 Social Science and Medicine, 2407.
70. World Health Organization, The World Health Report 2005 (Copenhagen: WHO, 2005) at 196.
71. World Health Organization, The World Health Report 2002 (Copenhagen: WHO, 2002) at 208.
72. OECD Health Data 2005 (Paris: OECD, 2005).
73. Department of Health, Chief Executive’s Report to the NHS: December 2005 (London: Department of Health, 2005) at 16.
74. J. Appleby and A. Harrison, Spending on Health Care – How Much Is Enough? (London: King’s Fund, 2006) at 64.
75. C. Newdick, Who Should We Treat? (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1st edn, 1995) at 41–3.
76. NHS Management Executive, Priorities and Planning Guidance for the NHS for 1992–93 (London: Department of Health, 1991)
77. NHS Management Executive, Priorities and Planning Guidance for the NHS for 1994–95 (London: Department of Health, 1993).
78. S. Straus, W. Richardson, P. Glasziou et al., Evidence-Based Medicine: How to Practice and Teach EBM (Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 3rd edn, 2005).
79. Audit Commission, Managing the Financial Implications of NICE Guidance (Wetherby: Audit Commission, 2005)
80. R. Cookson, D. McDaid and A. Maynard, ‘Wrong SIGN, NICE Mess: is Guidance Distorting Allocation of Resources?’ (2001) 323 British Medical Journal, 743
81. Health Committee, National Institute for Clinical Excellence, Second Report, HC 515-I (2001–02).
82. M. McKee and A. Clarke, ‘Guidelines, Enthusiasms, Uncertainty and the Limits to Purchasing’ (1995) 310 British Medical Journal, 101.
83. D. King and A. Maynard, ‘Public Opinion and Rationing in the United Kingdom’ (1999) 50 Health Policy, 39 at 40.
84. D. Hunter, ‘Rationing Health Care: the Political Perspective’ (1995) 51 British Medical Bulletin, 876 at 877.
85. OECD Health Database 2005 (Paris: OECD, 2005).
86. OECD, Projecting OECD Health and Long-term Care Expenditures: What are the Main drivers? (Paris: OECD (ECO/WKP(2006)5), 2006) at 7.
87. D. Wanless, Securing Our Future Health: Taking a Long-term View (London: HM Treasury, 2002)
88. D. Wanless, Securing Our Future Health: Taking a Long-term View: Interim Report (London: HM Treasury, 2001)
89. OECD, OECD Factbook 2005 (Paris: OECD, 2005) at 190–3.
90. J-P. Cotis, ‘Population Ageing: Facing the Challenge’ (2003) 239 OECD Observer (Paris: OECD, 2003)
91. P. Zweifel, S. Felder and M. Meiers, ‘Ageing of Population and Health Care Expenditure: a Red Herring?’ (1999) 8 Health Economics, 485.
92. J. Fries, ‘The Compression of Morbidity’ (2005) 83 Milbank Quarterly, 801.
93. E. Grunenberg, ‘The Failure of Success’ (1977) 55 Millbank Memorial Fund Quarterly, 3.
94. E. Schneider and J. Brody, ‘Ageing, Natural Death and the Compression of Morbidity: Another View’ (1983) 309 New England Journal of Medicine, 854.
95. J. Newhouse, ‘Medical Care Expenditure: a Cross-National Survey’ (1977) 12 Journal of Human Resources, 115.
96. T. Getzen, ‘Health Care is an Individual Necessity and a National Luxury: Applying Multilevel Decision Models to the Analysis of Health Care Expenditures’ (2000) Journal of Health Economics, 259 at 268.
97. A. Culyer, Health Care Expenditures in Canada: Myth and Reality; Past and Future (Toronto: Canadian Tax Federation (Paper No. 82), 1988) at 20.
98. A. Blomqvist and R. Carter, ‘Is Health Care Really a Luxury?’ (1997) 16 Journal of Health Economics, 207 at 208.
99. L. Di Matteo, ‘The Macro Determinants of Health Expenditure in the United States and Canada: Assessing the Impact of Income, Age Distribution and Time’ (2005) 71 Health Policy, 23 at 24.
100. D. Parkin, A. McGuire and B. Yule, ‘Aggregate Health Care Expenditures and National Income: Is Health Care a Luxury Good?’ (1987) 6 Journal of Health Economics, 109 at 109–12.
101. A. Sen, ‘Is Health Care a Luxury? New Evidence from OECD Data’ (2005) 5 International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics, 147.
102. L. Di Matteo and R. Di Matteo, ‘Evidence on the determinants of Canadian provincial government health expenditures: 1965–1991’ (1998) 17 Journal of Health Economics, 211.
103. V. Fuchs, ‘Economics, Values and Health Care Reform’ (1996) 86 American Economic Review, 1 at 8.
104. J. Newhouse, ‘Medical Care Costs: How Much Welfare Loss?’ (1992) 6 Journal of Economic Perspectives, 3.
105. A. Okunade and V. Murthy, ‘Technology as a “Major Driver” of Health Care Costs: a Cointegration Analysis of the Newhouse Conjecture’ (2002) 21 Journal of Health Economics, 147.
106. OECD, Competition and Regulation Issues in the Pharmaceutical Industry (Paris: OECD, 2001 (DAFFE/CLP (2000) 29)) at 25.
107. D. Cutler and M. McClellan, ‘Is Technological Change in Medicine Worth It?’ (2001) 20 Health Affairs, 11 at 14.
108. A. Harrison, J. Dixon, B. New and K. Judge, ‘Funding the NHS: can the NHS Cope in Future?’ (1997) 314 British Medical Journal, 139 at 140.
109. WHO, Definition, Diagnosis and Classification of Diabetes Mellitus and its Complications: Report of a WHO Consultation (WHO: Geneva, 1999 (WHO/NCD/NCS 99.2)).
110. D. Wanless, Securing Good Health for the Population: Population Health Trends (London: HM Treasury, 2002).
111. B. Weisbrod and C. LaMay, ‘Mixed Signals: Public Policy and the Future of Health Care R & D’ (1999) 18 Health Affairs, 112 at 116.
112. E. Jonsson, ‘Development of Health Technology Assessment in Europe: a Personal Perspective’ (2002) 18 International Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care, 171.
113. C. Farrell, R. Levenson and D. Snape, The Patient’s Charter: Past and Future (London: King’s Fund, 1998)
114. G. Scally and L. Donaldson, ‘Clinical Governance and the Drive for Quality Improvement in the New NHS in England’ (1998) 317 British Medical Journal, 61 at 62.
115. Department of Health, National Service Frameworks (London: The Stationery Office, 1998 (HSC 1998/074)).
116. D. Mechanic, ‘Changing Medical Organisation and the Erosion of Trust’ (1996) Milbank Quarterly, 171
117. H. Davies, ‘Falling Public Trust in Health Services: Implications for Accountability’ (1999) 4 Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 193
118. O. O’Neil, A Question of Trust (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002).
119. J. Neuberger, ‘The Educated Patient: New Challenges for the Medical Profession’ (2000) 247 Journal of Internal Medicine, 6.
120. C. Emmerson, C. Frayne and A. Goodman, Pressures in UK Healthcare: Challenges for the NHS (London: Institute for Fiscal Studies, 2000) at 57.
121. A. Maynard, K. Bloor and N. Freemantle, ‘Challenges for the National Institute for Clinical Excellence’ (2004) 329 British Medical Journal, 229.
122. R. Klein, P. Day and S. Redmayne, Managing Scarcity (Buckingham: Open University Press, 2000) at 11–12.
123. A. Culyer, ‘Equity – Some Theory and its Policy Implications’ (2001) 27 Journal of Medical Ethics, 275 at 278.
124. R. Cookson and P. Dolan, ‘Public Views on Health Care Rationing: a Group Discussion Study’ (1999) 49 Health Policy, 63 at 70–71.
125. B. New and J. LeGrand, Rationing in the NHS: Principles and Pragmatism (London: King’s Fund, 1996) at 23.
126. D. Mechanic, ‘Dilemmas in Rationing Health Care Services: the Case for Implicit Rationing’ (1995) 310 British Medical Journal, 1655 at 1658.
127. S. Frankel and R. West, ‘What Is to Be Done?’ in S. Frankel and R. West, Rationing and Rationality in the National Health Service: the Persistence of Waiting Lists (Basingstoke: Macmillan, 1993) at 125.
128. L. Locock, ‘The Changing Nature of Rationing in the National Health Service’ (2000) 78 Public Administration, 90 at 93.
129. Canadian Nurses Association, Ethics in Practice (C.N.A.: Ottawa, 2000 (September)) at 2.
130. Department of Health, The NHS Cancer Plan: a Plan for Investment, a Plan for Reform (London: Department of Health, 2000).
131. R. Klein, ‘Dimensions of Rationing: Who Should Do What?’ (1993) 307 British Medical Journal, 309.
132. B. New, ‘The Rationing Agenda in the NHS’ in B. New (ed.), Rationing – Talk and Action in Health Care (London: BMJ, 1997) at 19–20.
133. A. Bowling, ‘Health Care Rationing: the Public’s Debate’ (1996) 312 British Medical Journal, 670 at 673
134. J. Kneeshaw, ‘What does the Public think about Rationing? A review of the evidence’, in New (ed.), ibid. at 72
135. C. Bryson and B. New, ‘Health Care Rationing: A Cut Too Far?’ in R. Jowell, J. Curtice, A. Park et al., British Social Attitudes: the Seventeenth Report (London: Sage, 2000) at 42.
136. C. Heginbotham, ‘Health Care Priority-Setting: a Survey of Doctors, Managers and the General Public’, in R. Smith (ed.), Rationing in Action (London: BMJ, 1993) at 147
137. D. Hunter, Desperately Seeking Solutions (London: Longman, 1997) at 27.
138. J. Abelson, J. Lomas, J. Eyles et al., ‘Does the Community Want Devolved Authority? Results of Deliberative Polling in Ontario’ (1995) 153 Canadian Medical Association Journal, 403.
139. J. Lomas, ‘Reluctant Rationers: Public Input into Health Care Priorities’ (1997) 2 Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 103 at 107.
140. D. Mechanic, Future Issues in Health Care: Social Policy and the Rationing of Medical Services (New York: Free Press, 1979)
141. R. Maxwell, Rationing Health Care (London: Churchill Livingstone), 1995
142. A. Coulter and C. Ham (eds.), The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing (Buckingham: Open University Press, 2000)
143. C. Ham and A. Coulter, ‘Explicit and Implicit Rationing: Taking Responsibility and Avoiding Blame for Health Care Choices’ (2001) 6 Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 163.
144. J. Coast, ‘The Rationing Debate: Rationing Within the NHS Should Be Explicit: The Case Against’ (1997) 314 British Medical Journal, 1118.
145. E. Tragakes and M. Vienonen, Key Issues in Rationing and Priority-setting for Health Care Services (Copenhagen: WHO, 1998) at 4.
146. V. Schmidt, ‘Models of Health Care Rationing’ (2004) 52 Current Sociology, 969 at 972.
147. H. Aaron and B. Schwartz, The Painful Prescription: Rationing Hospital Care (Washington DC: Brookings Institution, 1984) at 100–102.
148. A. Campbell, G. Gillett and G. Jones, Medical Ethics (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 4th edn, 2005) at 277.
149. D. Callahan, ‘Ethics and Priority-Setting in Oregon’ (1991) 10 Health Affairs, 78 at 85.
150. M. McKee and A. Clarke, ‘Guidelines, Enthusiasms, Uncertainty and the Limits to Purchasing’ (1995) 310 British Medical Journal, 101.
151. M. Gold, ‘Is Honesty Always the Best Policy? Ethical Aspects of Truth Telling’ (2004) 34 Internal Medicine Journal, 578.
152. L. Doyal, ‘The Rationing Debate: Rationing Within the NHS Should Be Explicit: The Case For’ (1997) 314 British Medical Journal 1114 at 1118
153. D. Longley, Public Law and Health Service Accountability (Buckingham: Open University Press, 1993) at 7–8.
154. A. Maynard, ‘Rationing Health Care’ (1996) 313 British Medical Journal, 1499.
155. K. Obermann and D. Buck, ‘The Health Care Rationing Debate: More Clarity by Separating the Issues?’ (2001) 2 Health Economics in Prevention and Care, 113 at 115
156. C. Ham, ‘Priority-Setting in Healthcare: Learning from International Experience’ (1997) 42 Health Policy, 49
157. C. Ham and G. Robert (eds.), Reasonable Rationing (Buckingham: Open University Press, 2003)
158. C. Ham, ‘Health Care Rationing’ (1995) 310 British Medical Journal, 1483.
159. Oregon Health Services Commission, The 1991 Prioritization of Health Services (Salem: Oregon Health Services Commission, 1991, No. 8746).
160. P. Ubel, Pricing Life: Why It’s Time for Health Care Rationing (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 2000) 1 at 8–9
161. F. Honigsbaum, J. Calltorp, C. Ham et al., Priority-Setting Processes for Healthcare (Oxford: Radcliffe Medical Press, 1995)
162. J. Blumstein, ‘The Oregon Experiment: the Role of Cost-Benefit Analysis in the Allocation of Medicaid Funds’ (1997) 45 Social Science and Medicine, 545.
163. J. Dixon and H. Welch, ‘Priority-Setting: lessons from Oregon’ (1991) 337 Lancet, 891 at 892.
164. National Advisory Committee on Core Health and Disability Services, Third Report: Core Services for 1995/96 (Wellington: Core Services Committee, 1994)
165. Ministry of Welfare, Health and Cultural Affairs, Choices in Health Care. A Report by the Government Committee on Choices in Health Care, The Netherlands (Rijswijk: Ministry of Welfare, Health and Cultural Affairs, 1992).
166. J. Cumming, ‘Defining Core Services: New Zealand Experiences’ (1997) 2 Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 31 at 32.
167. M. Field and K. Lohr (eds.), Clinical Practice Guidelines: from Development to Use (Institute of Medicine, Washington, DC: National Academy Press, 1992) at 2.
168. S. Woolf, R. Grol, A. Hutchinson et al., ‘Potential Benefits, Limitations and Harms of Clinical Guidelines’ (1999) 318 British Medical Journal, 527 at 527.
169. O. Norheim, ‘Clinical Guidelines: Healthcare Rationing and Accountability for Reasonableness’, in J. Tingle and C. Foster (eds.), Clinical Guidelines: Law, Policy and Practice (London: Cavendish, 2002) at 162
170. J. Grimshaw and A. Hutchinson, ‘Clinical Practice Guidelines – Do They Enhance Value for Money in Healthcare?’ (1995) 51 British Medical Bulletin, 927.
171. D. Eddy, ‘Clinical Decision-making: from Theory to Practice. Guidelines for Policy Statements: the Explicit Approach’ (1990) 263 Journal of the American Medical Association, 2239 at 2243.
172. ‘Rationing in Health Care – a New Zealand Perspective on an International Dilemma’ (2001) 81 Schweizerische Arztezeitung, 190 at 191.
173. C. Feek, W. McKean, L. Henneveld et al., ‘Experience with Rationing Health Care in New Zealand’ (1999) 318 British Medical Journal, 1346.
174. S. Harrison, ‘New Labour, Modernisation and the Medical Labour Process’ (2002) 31 Journal of Social Policy, 465, 469
175. D. Sackett, ‘Evidence-Based Medicine: What It Is and What It Isn’t’ (1996) 312 British Medical Journal, 71.
176. J. Schwartz, G. Vanscoy and T. Lee, Healthcare Economics: The New Tool for Clinical Decision Making (Center for Continuing Education in Health Sciences: University of Pittsburgh, 1995).
177. S. Harrison and G. Wistow, ‘The Purchaser/Provider Split in English Health Care: Towards Explicit Rationing?’ (1992) Policy and Politics, 123
178. N. Freemantle, I. Watt and J. Mason, ‘Developments in the Purchasing Process in the NHS: towards an Explicit Politics of Rationing? (1993) 71 Public Administration, 535 at 536.
179. K. Barker, ‘NHS Contracts, Restitution and the Internal Market’ (1993) 56 Modern Law Review, 832.
180. Department of Health, The New NHS: Modern, Dependable (London: HMSO, 1997)
181. H. Davies, ‘Understanding Organizational Culture in Reforming the National Health Service’ (2002) 95 Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 140.
182. Department of Health, A First-Class Service: Quality in the New NHS (London: HMSO, 1998)
183. Cabinet Office, Modernising Government, (London: HMSO, 1999, Cm 4310)
184. NICE, A Guide to NICE (London: NICE, 2005)
185. NICE, Legal Context of NICE Guidance (London: NICE, 2004)
186. I. Kennedy and A. Grubb, Medical Law (London: Butterworths, 3rd edn, 2000)
187. Department of Health, Directions to Primary Care Trusts and NHS Trusts in England concerning Arrangements for the Funding of Technology Appraisal Guidance from the National Institute for Clinical Excellence (1 July 2003)
188. Welsh Assembly, Directions to Local Health Boards and NHS Trusts in Wales (23 October 2003).
189. R. Klein, ‘Setting Priorities: What is Holding Us Back – Inadequate Information or Inadequate Institutions?’ in Coulter and Ham (eds.), The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing at 25.
190. L. Jacobs, T. Marmor and J. Oberlander, ‘The Oregon Health Plan and the Political Paradox of Rationing; what advocates and critics have claimed and what Oregon did’ (1999) 24 Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 161 at 177.
191. G. Calabresi and P. Bobbit, Tragic Choices: the Conflicts Society Confronts in the Allocation of Tragically Scarce Resources (New York: W.W. Norton & Co, 1978) at 17.
192. B. Chapman (1979) 29 University of Toronto Law Journal, 182.
193. B. Bloom, ‘Rationing Health Care: Tragic Choices’ (1986) 8 Transactions and Studies of the College of Physicians of Philadelphia, 27
194. D. Weigert, ‘Tragic Choices: State Discretion over Organ Transplant Funding for Medicaid Recipients’ (1994) 89 Northwestern University Law Review, 268
195. R. James and D. Longley, ‘Judicial Review and Tragic Choices: ex parte B’ [1995] Public Law, 367
196. C. Ham and S. Pickard, Tragic Choices in Health Care: the case of Child B (London: King’s Fund, 1998)
197. G. Rutecki and S. Kilner, ‘Dialysis as a Resource Allocation Paradigm: Confronting Tragic Choices Once Again?’ (1999) 12 Seminars in Dialysis, 43.
198. B. Barry, ‘Tragic Choices’ (1984) 94 Ethics, 303 at 304.
199. H. Lasswell, Politics: Who Gets What, When and How (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1936).
200. C. Gwin (1978) 93 Political Science Quarterly, 506.
201. J. Rawls, ‘Social Unity and the Primary Goods’ in A. Sen and B. Williams (eds.), Utilitarianism and Beyond (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982) at 168.
202. J. Rawls, A Theory of Justice (Oxford: Oxford University Press, revised edn, 1999) at 54.
203. K. Arrow, ‘Some Ordinalist-Utilitarian Notes on Rawls’ Theory of Justice’ (1973) 20 Journal of Philosophy, 251, 254.
204. N. Daniels, Just Health Care (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985) at 43.
205. J. Ruger, ‘Health and Social Justice’ (2004) 364 Lancet, 1075.
206. N. Daniels, ‘Justice, Health and Healthcare’ (2001) 1 American Journal of Bioethics, 2.
207. R. Woolfolk and J. Doris, ‘Rationing Mental Health Care: Parity, Disparity and Justice’ (2002) 16 Bioethics, 469 at 471–2.
208. N. Daniels, Am I My Parent’s Keeper? An Essay on Justice Between the Old and the Young (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988)
209. C. Bryson and B. New, ‘Health Care Rationing: a Cut Too Far?’ in R. Jowell, J. Curtice, A. Park et al., British Social Attitudes: the Seventeenth Report (London: Sage, 2000) at 27, 34
210. J. Kneeshaw, ‘What Does the Public Think About Rationing? A Review of the Evidence’ in B. New (ed.), Rationing – Talk and Action in Health Care (London: BMJ, 1997) at 69.
211. A. Buchanan, ‘The Right to a Decent Minimum of Health Care’ (1984) 13 Philosophy and Public Affairs, 55 at 63.
212. N. Daniels, ‘Fair Equality of Opportunity and Decent Minimums: a Reply to Buchanan’ (1985) 14 Philosophy and Public Affairs, 106.
213. A. Culyer and A. Wagstaff, ‘Equity in Health and Healthcare’ (1993) 12 Journal of Health Economics, 431
214. E. van Doorslaer, A. Wagstaff and F. Rutten, Equity in the Finance and Delivery of Health Care: an International Perspective (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993)
215. A. Culyer, ‘Equity – Some Theory and its Policy Implications’ (2001) Journal of Medical Ethics, 275 at 278
216. A. Sen, ‘Why Health Equity?’ (2002) 11 Health Economics, 659.
217. T. Beauchamp and J. Childress, Principles of Biomedical Ethics Oxford: Oxford University Press, 3rd edn, 2001
218. R. Gillon, ‘Preface: Medical Ethics and the Four Principles’ in Gillon (ed.), Principles of Health Care Ethics (Chichester: John Wiley & Sons, 1994) at xxv
219. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, Social Value Judgements: Principles for the Development of NICE Guidance London: NICE, 2005
220. J. Butler, The Ethics of Health Care Rationing (London: Cassell, 1999)
221. R. Cookson and P. Dolan, ‘Principles of Justice in Health Care Rationing’ (2000) 26 Journal of Medical Ethics, 323.
222. P. Ubel, Pricing Life: Why It’s Time for Health Care Rationing (Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 2000) at 68.
223. M. Gold, J. Siegel, L. Russell, M. Weinstein (eds.), Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996).
224. E. Nord, Cost-Value Analysis in Health Care: Making Sense out of QALYs (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999).
225. J. Harris, ‘QALYfying the Value of Life’ (1987) 13 Journal of Medical Ethics, 117.
226. D. Hadorn, ‘Setting Health Care Priorities in Oregon: Cost-Effectiveness meets the Rule of Rescue’ (1991) 265 Journal of the American Medical Association, 2218.
227. E. Nord, ‘The Trade-Off Between Severity of Illness and Treatment Effect in Cost-value Analysis of Health Care’ (1993) 24 Health Policy, 45
228. R. Cookson and P. Dolan, ‘Public Views on Health Care Rationing: a Group Discussion Study’ (1999) 49 Health Policy, 63 at 71.
229. A. Campbell, G. Gillett and G. Jones, Medical Ethics (Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 4th edn, 2005) at 260.
230. J. Harris, The Value of Life (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1985) at 91–4
231. A. Williams, ‘Intergenerational Equity: an Exploration of the “Fair Innings” Argument’ (1997) 6 Health Economics, 117.
232. J. Grimley Evans, ‘Rationing Health Care by Age – the Case Against’ in New (ed.), Rationing – Talk and Action in Health Care at 116.
233. N. Daniels and J. Sabin, Setting Limits Fairly (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002) at 33.
234. G. van der Wilt, ‘Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Health Care Services and Concepts of Distributive Justice’ (1994) 2 Health Care Analysis, 296 at 301.
235. J. Williams and M. Yeo, ‘The Ethics of Decentralising Health Care Priority-Setting in Canada’ in A. Coulter and C. Ham (eds.), The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing (Buckingham: Open University Press, 2000) at 126.
236. S. Holm, ‘Goodbye to the Simple Solutions’ (1998) 317 British Medical Journal, 1000 at 1001.
237. Swedish Parliamentary Priorities Commission, Priorities in Health Care: Ethics, Economy, Implementation (Stockholm: Ministry of Health and Social Affairs, 1995) at 5.
238. J. Calltorp, ‘Priority-Setting in Health Policy in Sweden and a Comparison with Norway’ (1999) 50 Health Policy, 1.
239. A. Williams, ‘Tydligare Definitioner Och Bättre Fakta Krävs’ (‘Clearer Definitions and Better Facts are Required’) (1996) 93 Läkartidningen, 3376
240. P-E. Liss, ‘Hard Choices in Public Health: the Allocation of Scarce Resources’ (2003) 31 Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 30.
241. P-E. Liss, ‘The Significance of the Goal of Health Care for the Setting of Priorities’ (2003) 11 Health Care Analysis, 161.
242. N. Daniels, ‘Accountability for Reasonableness’ (2000) 321 British Medical Journal, 1300 at 1301.
243. C. Ham, ‘Tragic Choices in Health Care: Lessons from the Child B case’ (1999) 319 British Medical Journal, 1258.
244. K. Syrett, ‘A Technocratic Fix to the “Legitimacy Problem”? The Blair Government and Health Care Rationing in the United Kingdom’ (2003) 28 Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 439.
245. J. Habermas (trans. T. McCarthy), Legitimation Crisis (Boston: Beacon Press, 1975).
246. B. New and J. LeGrand, Rationing in the NHS: Principles and Pragmatism (London: King’s Fund, 1996) at 8–9.
247. J. Lomas, ‘Reluctant Rationers’: Public Input into Health Care Priorities’ (1997) 2 Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 103.
248. J. Freedman, Crisis and Legitimacy: the Administrative Process and American Government (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1978) at 10.
249. M. Weber, The Theory of Social and Economic Organisation (New York: Free Press, 1964) at 130–32.
250. J. Black, ‘Proceduralizing Regulation Part I’ (2000) 20 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 597 and ‘Part II’ (2001) 21 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 33.
251. R. Klein ‘Setting Priorities: What is Holding Us Back – Inadequate Information or Inadequate Institutions?’ in Coulter and Ham (eds.), The Global Challenge of Health Care Rationing at 21.
252. J. Thibaut and L. Walker, Procedural Justice (Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum, 1975)
253. T. Tyler, ‘Governing amid Diversity: the Effect of Fair Decision-Making Procedures on the Legitimacy of Government’ (1994) 28 Law and Society Review, 809
254. J. Rawls, ‘The Idea of an Overlapping Consensus’ (1987) 7 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 1
255. N. Daniels and J. Sabin, ‘The Ethics of Accountability in Managed Care Reform’ (1998) 17 Health Affairs, 50 at 57.
256. A. Hasman and S. Holm, ‘Accountability for Reasonableness: Opening the Black Box of Process’ (2005) 13 Health Care Analysis, 261.
257. M. Waymack, ‘Daniels on Justice and Healthcare: Laudable Goals – Questionable Method’ (2001) 1 American Journal of Bioethics, 28.
258. S. Gorovitz, ‘Justice in Healthcare and Dimpled Chads’ (2001) 1 American Journal of Bioethics, 29 at 29–30.
259. D. Martin, M. Giacomini and P. Singer, ‘Fairness, Accountability for Reasonableness and the Views of Priority-Setting Decision-Makers’ (2002) 61 Health Policy, 279.
260. P. Singer, D. Martin, M. Giacomini et al., ‘Priority-Setting for New Technologies in Medicine: a Qualitative Case Study’ (2000) 321 British Medical Journal, 1316.
261. N. Daniels and J. Sabin, ‘Last Chance Therapies and Managed Care: Pluralism, Fair Procedures and Legitimacy’ (1998) 28 Hastings Center Report, 27.
262. D. Martin, D. Hollenberg, S, MacRae et al., ‘Priority-setting in a Hospital Drug Formulary: a Qualitative Case Study and Evaluation’ (2003) 66 Health Policy, 295.
263. C. Mitton, M. McMahon, S. Morgan et al., ‘Centralized Drug Processes: Are They Fair?’ (2006) 63 Social Science sharmeela and Medicine, 200.
264. D. Martin, P. Singer and M. Bernstein, ‘Access to Intensive Care Unit Beds for Neurosurgery Patients: a Qualitative Case Study’ (2003) 74 Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 1299.
265. O. Norheim, ‘Healthcare Rationing – Are Additional Criteria Needed for Assessing Evidence Based Clinical Practice Guidelines?’ (1999) 319 British Medical Journal, 1426.
266. C. Ham and G. Robert (eds.), Reasonable Rationing (Buckingham: Open University Press, 2003).
267. N. Daniels, J. Bryant, R. Castano et al., ‘Benchmarks of Fairness for Health Care Reform: a Policy Tool for Developing Countries’ (2000) 78 Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 740.
268. O. Wright, ‘NICE Man with a Reason to Smile’, The Times, 2 December 2003
269. J. McMillan, M. Sheehan, D. Austin et al., ‘Ethics and Opportunity Costs: Have NICE Grasped the Ethics of Priority-Setting?’ (2006) 32 Journal of Medical Ethics, 126.
270. C. Ham and A. Coulter, ‘Explicit and Implicit Rationing: Taking Responsibility and Avoiding Blame for Health Care Choices’ (2001) 6 Journal of Health Services Research and Policy, 163
271. F. Schauer, ‘Giving Reasons’ (1995) 47 Stanford Law Review, 633 at 658.
272. A. Gutmann and D. Thompson, Democracy and Disagreement (Cambridge, Mass: Belknap Press, 1996) at 94.
273. P. Craig, ‘The Common Law, Reasons and Administrative Justice’ (1994) 53 Cambridge Law Journal, 282 at 283.
274. D. Galligan, Due Process and Fair Procedures (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1996) at 433.
275. T. Prosser, ‘Towards a Critical Public Law’ (1982) 9 Journal of Law and Society, 1 at 11.
276. S. Benhabib (ed.), Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Boundaries of the Political (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1996)
277. J. Bohman, Public Deliberation: Pluralism, Complexity and Democracy (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1996)
278. J. Bohman and W. Rehg (eds.), Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics (1997)
279. J. Elster (ed.), Deliberative Democracy (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1997)
280. J. Dryzek, Deliberative Democracy and Beyond: Liberals, Critics, Contestations (Oxford: OUP, 2000).
281. Between Facts and Norms: Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy (Cambridge: Polity, 1996).
282. J. Parkinson, ‘Why Deliberate? The Encounter between Deliberation and New Public Managers’ (2004) 82 Public Administration, 377 at 379.
283. J. Steele, ‘Participation and Deliberation in Environmental Law: Exploring a Problem-solving Approach’ (2001) 21 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 415.
284. J. Parkinson, ‘Legitimacy Problems in Deliberative Democracy’ (2003) 51 Political Studies, 180 at 181.
285. N. Daniels, ‘Enabling democratic deliberation: how managed care organizations ought to make decisions about coverage for new technologies’, in S. Macedo (ed.), Deliberative Politics: Essays on Democracy and Disagreement (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999) at 198.
286. J. Rawls, Political Liberalism (New York: Columbia University Press, 1993) at xix.
287. E. Hauptmann, ‘Deliberation = Legitimacy = Democracy’ (1999) 27 Political Theory, 857.
288. D. Weinstock (1997) 91 American Political Science Review, 724.
289. A. Gutmann and D. Thompson, ‘Deliberative Democracy Beyond Process’ (2002) 10 Journal of Political Philosophy, 153.
290. J. Newman, M. Barnes, H. Sullivan et al., ‘Public Participation and Collaborative Governance’ (2004) 33 Journal of Social Policy, 203.
291. L. Pratchett, ‘New Fashions in Public Participation: Towards Greater Democracy?’ (1999) 52 Parliamentary Affairs, 617
292. J. Abelson, P-G. Forest, J. Eyles et al., ‘Deliberations about deliberative methods: issues in the design and evaluation of public participation processes’ (2003) 57 Social Science and Medicine, 239 at 242–3.
293. J. Lenaghan, ‘Involving the Public in Rationing Decisions. The Experience of Citizens’ juries’ (1999) 49 Health Policy, 45.
294. J. Abelson and F-P. Gauvin, Engaging Citizens: One Route to Health Care Accountability (Ottawa: Canadian Policy Research Network, 2004).
295. G. Mooney and S. Blackwell, ‘Whose Health Service Is It Anyway? Community Values in Healthcare’ (2004) 180 Medical Journal of Australia, 76.
296. D. Fox and H. Leichter, ‘Rationing Care in Oregon: the New Accountability’ (1991) 10 Health Affairs, 7 at 21.
297. R. Klein, P. Day and S. Redmayne, Managing Scarcity (Buckingham: Open University Press, 1996) at 113.
298. L. Jacobs, T. Marmor and J. Oberlander, ‘The Oregon Health Plan and the Political Paradox of Rationing: What Advocates and Critics Have Claimed and What Oregon Did’ (1999) 24 Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 16 at 173.
299. M. Rawlins and A. Culyer, ‘National Institute for Clinical Excellence and its Value Judgments’ (2004) 329 British Medical Journal, 224 at 225.
300. M. Rawlins, ‘Pharmacopolitics and Deliberative Democracy’ (2005) 5 Clinical Medicine, 471.
301. C. Davies, M. Wetherell, E. Barnett et al., Opening the Box: Evaluating the Citizens’ Council of NICE (Milton Keynes: Open University, 2005).
302. Canadian Bar Association Task Force on Health Care, What’s Law Got To Do With It? Health Care Reform in Canada (Ottawa: Canadian Bar Association, 1994).
303. D. Hunter, ‘Rationing Health Care: the Political Perspective’ (1995) 51 British Medical Bulletin, 876 at 881.
304. M. Hall, Making Medical Spending Decisions (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997) at 73.
305. D. Mechanic, Future Issues in Health Care: Social Policy and the Rationing of Medical Services (New York: Free Press, 1979) at 118.
306. C. Burgoyne, ‘Distributive Justice and Rationing in the NHS: Framing Effects in Press Coverage of a Controversial Decision’ (1997) 7 Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology, 119 at 129.
307. W. Hutton, New Life for Health (London: Vintage, 2000) at 31, 60–62.
308. B. New, ‘The Rationing Agenda in the NHS’ (1996) 312 British Medical Journal, 1593 at 1597.
309. Y. Amin, quoted in ‘Woman Loses Herceptin Court Bid’, BBC News Online, 15 February 2006, available at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4715430.stm (accessed 8 January 2007).
310. C. Ham and S. McIver, Contested Decisions (London: King’s Fund, 2000)
311. ‘High Court Ruling in Breast Cancer Victim’s Fight for Life’, Irwin Mitchell Press Release, 21 February 2006, available at www.irwinmitchell.com/PressOffice/PressReleases (accessed 8 January 2007).
312. ‘Court to Rule in Herceptin Battle’, BBC News Online, 11 April 2006, available at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4900674.stm (accessed 8 January 2007);
313. ‘Q & A: Herceptin Ruling a Victory for Patient Power’, Times Online (12 April 2006), available at www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,8122-2131111,00.html (accessed 8 January 2007).
314. C. Harlow and R. Rawlings, Law and Administration (London: Butterworths, 2nd edn, 1997)
315. A. Dicey, Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution (London: Macmillan, 10th edn, 1959).
316. H. Wade and C. Forsyth, Administrative Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 9th edn, 2004) at 5.
317. M. Loughlin, ‘The Functionalist Style in Public Law’ (2005) 55 University of Toronto Law Journal, 361.
318. D. Woodhouse, In Pursuit of Good Administration: Ministers, Civil Servants and Judges (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1997)
319. H. Laski, ‘Judicial Review of Social Policy in England’ (1926) 39 Harvard Law Review, 832.
320. Treasury Solicitor’s Department, The Judge over Your Shoulder (London: The Stationery Office, 4th edn, 2006)
321. M. Loughlin, Public Law and Political Theory (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1992) at 181.
322. H. Woolf, J. Jowell and A. Le Sueur, De Smith, Woolf and Jowell’s, Principles of Judicial Review (London: Sweet and Maxwell, 1999)
323. D. O’Sullivan, ‘The allocation of scarce resources and the right to life under the European Convention on Human Rights’ [1998] Public Law, 389 at 389
324. J. Jowell, ‘Of Vires and Vacuums: The Constitutional Context of Judicial Review’ [1999] Public Law, 448 at 454.
325. C. Finn, ‘The Justiciability of Administrative Decisions: a Redundant Concept?’ [2002] Federal Law Review, 9 at 9.
326. M. Pieterse, ‘Coming to Terms with Judicial Enforcement of Socio-Economic Rights’ (2004) South African Journal on Human Rights, 383 at 390–96
327. L. Fuller, ‘The Forms and Limits of Adjudication’ (1978) 92 Harvard Law Review, 353 at 395.
328. J. Allison, ‘The Procedural Reason for Judicial Restraint’ [1994] Public Law, 452 at 457.
329. C. Ngwena, ‘Access to Antiretroviral Therapy to Prevent Mother-to-Child Transmission of HIV as a Socio-Economic Right: an Application of Section 27 of the Constitution’ (2003) 18 SA Publiekreg/Public Law, 83 at 87.
330. A. Bickel, The Least Dangerous Branch: the Supreme Court at the Bar of Politics (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1986) at 16.
331. H. Laswell, Politics: Who Gets What When and How (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1936).
332. J. Rivers, ‘Proportionality and Variable Intensity of Review’ (2006) 65 Cambridge Law Journal, 174 at 192;
333. Lord Lester and D. Pannick (eds.), Human Rights Law and Practice (London: Butterworths, 2nd edn, 2004)
334. Lord Irvine of Lairg, ‘Judges and Decision-Makers: the Theory and Practice of Wednesbury Review’ [1996] Public Law, 59
335. R. Baggott, J. Allsop and K. Jones, Speaking for Patients and Carers: Health Consumer Groups and the Policy Process (London: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004).
336. C. Harlow and R. Rawlings, Pressure Through Law (London: Routledge, 1992).
337. C. Menkel-Meadow, ‘The Lawyer’s Role(s) in Deliberative Democracy’ (2005) 5 Nevada Law Journal, 347 at 352.
338. D. Longley, Public Law and Health Service Accountability (Buckingham: Open University Press, 1993) at 82.
339. Oxford English Dictionary (Oxford: OUP, 2nd edn, 1989).
340. J. Ketchen, ‘Revisiting Fuller’s Critique of Hart – Managerial Control and the Pathology of Legal Systems: the Hart-Weber Nexus’ (2003) 53 University of Toronto Law Journal, 1 at 18.
341. J. Habermas, ‘Law and Morality’ in S. McMurrin (ed.) The Tanner Lectures on Human Values, Volume 8 (Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 1988)
342. R. Baldwin and C. McCrudden, Regulation and Public Law (London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1987)
343. W. Connolly (ed.), Legitimacy and the State (Oxford: Blackwell, 1984)
344. R. Barker, Political Legitimacy and the State (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1990).
345. J. Habermas, Communication and the Evolution of Society (Cambridge: Polity, 1979) at 178.
346. J. Schaar, ‘Legitimacy in the Modern State’ in Connolly (ed.), Legitimacy and the State at 108–9.
347. P. McAuslan and J. McEldowney (eds.), Law, Legitimacy and the Constitution (London: Sweet and Maxwell, 1985) at 2, 12
348. R. Baldwin, Rules and Government (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995) at 42.
349. M. Weber, Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology, vol. 1 (G. Roth and C. Wittich (eds.)) (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1978) at 215
350. T. Franck, Fairness in International Law and Institutions (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995) at 26.
351. D. Beetham, The Legitimation of Power (London: Macmillan, 1991) at 11.
352. P. Berger and T. Luckmann, The Social Construction of Reality (London: Penguin, 1991) at 111
353. T. Poole, ‘Legitimacy, Rights and Judicial Review’ (2005) 25 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 697 at 714.
354. L. Fuller, The Morality of Law (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1969)
355. T. Allan, Constitutional Justice: a Liberal Theory of the Rule of Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001) at 73.
356. C. Ansell, ‘Legitimacy: Political’ in N. Smelser and P. Bates (eds.), International Encyclopaedia of the Behavioural and Social Sciences (Oxford: Elsevier, 2001) at 8704.
357. D. Georgiev, ‘Politics or Rule of Law: Deconstruction and Legitimacy in International Law’ (1993) 4 European Journal of International Law, 1 at 13.
358. P. McAuslan and J. McEldowney, ‘Legitimacy and the Constitution: the Dissonance between Theory and Practice’, in McAuslan and McEldowney (eds.), Law, Legitimacy at 2.
359. A. Hutchinson and P. Monahan (eds.), The Rule of Law: Ideal or Ideology? (Toronto: Carswell, 1987)
360. B. Tamahana, On the Rule of Law: History, Politics, Theory (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004).
361. I. Harden and N. Lewis, The Noble Lie: The Rule of Law and the British Constitution (London: Hutchinson, 1986) at 5.
362. T. Prosser, ‘Democratisation, Accountability and Institutional Design: Reflections on Public Law’, in McAuslan and McEldowney (eds.), Law, Legitimacy at 172–3
363. P. Nonet and P. Selznick, Law and Society in Transition: Towards Responsive Law (New York: Harper Torchbooks, 1978) at 106–7.
364. G. Teubner, ‘Substantive and Reflexive Elements in Modern Law’ (1983) 17 Law and Society Review, 239 at 251.
365. T. Prosser, ‘Towards a Critical Public Law’ (1982) 9 Journal of Law and Society, 1 at 9.
366. D. Longley, Public Law and Health Service Accountability (Buckingham: Open University Press, 1993) at xi.
367. K. Syrett, ‘NICE Work? Rationing, Review and the “Legitimacy Problem” in the New NHS’ (2002) 10 Medical Law Review, 1 at 18–24.
368. C. Stewart, ‘Tragic Choices and the Role of Administrative Law’ (2000) 321 British Medical Journal, 105 at 107.
369. N. Daniels and J. Sabin, Setting Limits Fairly (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002) at 49.
370. P. Craig, ‘The Common Law, Reasons and Administrative Justice’ (1994) 53 Cambridge Law Journal, 282 at 283
371. D. Galligan, Due Process and Fair Procedures (Oxford: Clarendon Press 1996) at 431–4.
372. J. Dryzek, ‘Legitimacy and Economy in Deliberative Society’ (2001) 29 Political Theory, 651 at 655
373. J. Bohman, ‘The Coming of Age of Deliberative Democracy’ (1998) 6 Journal of Political Philosophy, 400 at 401.
374. R. Talisse, ‘Deliberativist responses to activist challenges: a continuation of Young’s dialectic’ (2005) 31 Philosophy and Social Criticism, 423 at 437.
375. J. Mansbridge, Beyond Adversarial Democracy (New York: Basic Books, 1980).
376. M. Cooke, ‘Five Arguments for Deliberative Democracy’ (2000) 48 Political Studies, 947 at 948–49.
377. A. Lynch, ‘Dissent: the Rewards and Risks of Judicial Disagreement in the High Court of Australia’ [2003] Melbourne University Law Review, 724 at 731.
378. C. Sunstein, ‘Foreword: Leaving Things Undecided’ (1996) 110 Harvard Law Review, 6 at 19
379. C. Sunstein, Legal Reasoning and Political Conflict (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996).
380. O. Fiss, ‘Foreword: The Forms of Justice’ (1979) 93 Harvard Law Review, 1 at 10
381. A. Gutmann and D. Thompson, Democracy and Disagreement (Cambridge, Mass: Belknap Press, 1996) at 46–7.
382. J. Rawls, ‘The Idea of Public Reason Revisited’ (1997) 94 University of Chicago Law Review, 765.
383. J. Rawls, Political Liberalism (New York: Columbia University Press, 1993) at 214.
384. C. Nino, The Constitution of Deliberative Democracy (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1996) at 219.
385. M. van Hoecke, ‘Judicial Review and Deliberative Democracy: a Circular Model of Law Creation and Legitimation’ (2001) 14 Ratio Juris, 415 at 420.
386. C. Peters, ‘Assessing the new Judicial Minimism’ (2000) 100 Columbia Law Review, 1454 at 1498.
387. C. Schroeder, ‘Deliberative Democracy’s Attempt to Turn Politics into Law’ (2002) 65 Law and Contemporary Problems, 95 at 98.
388. D. Dickson (ed.), The Supreme Court in Conference (1940–1985): the Private Discussions behind nearly 300 Supreme Court Decisions (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001).
389. N. Daniels, ‘Accountability for Reasonableness’ (2000) 321 British Medical Journal, 1300 at 1301;
390. C. Ham and G. Robert (eds.), Reasonable Rationing (Buckingham: Open University Press, 2003)
391. K. Syrett, ‘Deconstructing Deliberation in the Appraisal of Medical Technologies: NICEly does it?’ (2006) 69 Modern Law Review, 869.
392. J. Montgomery, Health Care Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2nd edn, 2003) at 67, 74.
393. L. Sweatman and D. Woolard, ‘Resource Allocation Decisions in Canada’s Health Care System: Can these Decisions Be Challenged in a Court of Law?’ (2002) 62 Health Policy, 275 at 289.
394. D. Greschner, How Will the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and Evolving Jurisprudence Affect Health Care Costs? Discussion Paper No. 20 (Ottawa: Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada, 2002) at 5.
395. C. Ngwena and R. Cook, ‘Rights Concerning Health’, Chapter 4 in D. Brand and C. Heyns (eds.), Socio-Economic Rights in South Africa (Pretoria: Pretoria University Press, 2005) at 133.
396. R. Lie, ‘Health, Human Rights and Mobilisation of Resources for Health’ (2004) 4 BMC International Health and Human Rights, available at www.biomedcentral.com/1472-698X/4/4 (accessed 8 January 2007).
397. A. Kaczorowska, ‘A Review of the Creation by the European Court of Justice of the Right to Effective and Speedy Medical Treatment and its Outcomes’ (2006) 12 European Law Journal, 345.
398. D. O’Sullivan, ‘The allocation of scarce resources and the right to life under the European Convention on Human Rights’ [1998] Public Law, 389
399. E. Haggett, The Human Rights Act 1998 and Access to NHS Treatments and Services: a Practical Guide (London: Constitution Unit, University College, 2001)
400. C. Newdick, Who Should We Treat? (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2nd edn, 2004) at 119–20.
401. P. Craig, Administrative Law (London: Sweet and Maxwell, 5th edn, 2003)
402. P. Leyland and G. Anthony, Textbook on Administrative Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 5th edn) at 4–9
403. M. Fordham, ‘What is “anxious scrutiny”?’ (1996) 1 Judicial Review, 81.
404. J. Laws, ‘Is the High Court the Guardian of Fundamental Constitutional Rights?’ [1993] Public Law, 59 at 69.
405. C. Burgoyne, ‘Distributive Justice and Rationing in the NHS: Framing Effects in Press Coverage of a Controversial Decision’ (1997) Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology, 119 at 129
406. V. Entwistle, I. Watt, R. Bradbury and L. Pehl, ‘Media Coverage of the Child B case’ (1996) 312 British Medical Journal, 1587.
407. R. James and D. Longley, ‘Judicial Review and Tragic Choices: ex parte B’ [1995] Public Law, 367 at 373.
408. A. Grubb and M. Jones, ‘Institutional Liability’ in A. Grubb (ed.), Principles of Medical Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2nd edn, 2004)
409. K. Syrett (2000) 22 Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law, 200.
410. K. Syrett, ‘Impotence or Importance? Judicial Review in an Era of Explicit NHS Rationing’ (2004) 67 Modern Law Review, 289.
411. T. Hervey and J. MacHale, Health Law and the European Union (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004).
412. K. Syrett, ‘Opening Eyes to the Reality of Scarce Resources? [2006] Public Law, 664.
413. D. Greschner, How Will the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and Evolving Jurisprudence Affect Health Care Costs? Discussion Paper No. 20 (Ottawa: Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada, 2002)
414. M. Jackman, ‘Giving Real Effect to Equality: Eldridge v. British Columbia and Vriend v. Alberta’ (1998) 4 Review of Constitutional Studies, 352.
415. K. Syrett, ‘Priority-Setting and Public Law: Potential Realised or Unfulfilled?’ (2006) 7 Medical Law International, 265.
416. C. Flood, K. Roach and L. Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice: the Legal Debate over Private Health Insurance in Canada (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2005)
417. J. King, ‘Constitutional Rights and Social Welfare: a Comment on the Canadian Chaoulli Health Care Decision’ (2006) 69 Modern Law Review, 631.
418. B. Sheldrick, ‘Judicial Review and the Allocation of Health Resources in Canada and the United Kingdom’ (2003) 5 Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis, 149 at 157.
419. S. Hannett, ‘Third Party Intervention in the Public Interest’ [2003] Public Law, 128 at 134.
420. P. Bryden, ‘Public Interest Intervention in the Courts’ (1987) 66 Canadian Bar Review, 490 at 509.
421. P. Craig, Administrative Law (London: Sweet & Maxwell, 5th edn, 2003) at 622.
422. C. Manfredi and A. Maioni, ‘Courts and Health Policy: Judicial Policy-Making and Publicly Funded Health Care in Canada’ (2002) 27 Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 213 at 229.
423. D. Greschner and S. Lewis, ‘Auton and Evidence-Based Decision-Making: Medicare in the Courts’ (2003) 82 Canadian Bar Review, 501 at 532.
424. C. Wright, ‘Different Interpretations of “Evidence” and Implications for the Canadian Healthcare System’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 223.
425. H. Stewart, ‘Implications of Chaoulli for Fact-Finding in Constitutional Cases’, in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 213.
426. C. Flood, M. Stabile and S. Kontic, ‘Finding Health Policy “Arbitrary”: the Evidence on Waiting, Dying and Two-Tier Systems’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 297.
427. J. Hagan, ‘Social Science Evidence in Constitutional Litigation’ in R. Sharpe (ed.) Charter Litigation (Toronto: Butterworths, 1987) at 215
428. K. Davis, ‘An Approach to Problems of Evidence in the Administrative Process’ (1942) 55 Harvard Law Review, 364 at 402–3.
429. S. Choudry, ‘Worse than Lochner?’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 95.
430. A. Hutchinson, ‘“Condition Critical”: the Constitution and Health Care’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 111.
431. B. Dickens, ‘The Chaoulli Judgment: Less than Meets the Eye – Or More?’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 19.
432. A. Maynard, ‘How to Defend a Public Health Care System: Lessons from Abroad’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 237.
433. R. Romanow, ‘In Search of a Mandate?’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 528.
434. M. Kirby, quoted in D. Low, L. Wakulowsky, G. Moysa, ‘Failing on the Fundamentals: the Chaoulli Decision’, Law and Governance (June 2005), available at www.longwoods.com/product.php?productid=17188&page=3. (accessed 8 January 2006).
435. S. Lewis, ‘Physicians, It’s in your Court now’ (2005) 173 Canadian Medical Association Journal, 275 at 276
436. T. Lemmens and T. Archibald, ‘The CMA’s Chaoulli Motion and the Myth of Promoting Fair Access to Health Care’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 323.
437. ‘CMA proposes options for private-public split’ (2006) 175 Canadian Medical Association Journal, 18.
438. Government of Québec, Guaranteeing Access (Montreal: Government of Québec, 2006) at 3.
439. T. Caulfield and N. Ries, ‘Politics and Paradoxes: Chaoulli and the Alberta Reaction’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 414.
440. Government of Alberta, Getting on with Better Health Care (Calgary: Government of Alberta, 2006).
441. ‘Chaoulli Decision Resonates One Year Later’ (2006) 175 Canadian Medical Association Journal, 17, 18.
442. N. Lawson, The View From Number 11 (London: Bantam, 1992) at 613
443. Commission on the Future of Health Care in Canada, Building on Values: The Future of Health Care in Canada, Final Report (Ottawa: National Library of Canada, 2002) at xviii:
444. R. Romanow, ‘Preface’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at ix
445. P. Hogg and A. Bushell, ‘The Charter Dialogue between Courts and Legislatures (or Perhaps the Charter isn’t Such a Bad Thing After All)’ (1997) 35 Osgoode Hall Law Journal, 75.
446. K. Roach, The Supreme Court on Trial: Judicial Activism or Democratic Dialogue (Toronto: Irwin Law, 2001).
447. R. Clayton, ‘Judicial Deference and “Democratic Dialogue”: the Legitimacy of Judicial Intervention under the Human Rights Act 1998’ [2004] Public Law, 33.
448. K. Roach, ‘Dialogic Judicial Review and its Critics’ (2004) 23 Supreme Court Law Review (2d), 49 at 55.
449. K. Roach, ‘The Courts and Medicare: Too Much or Too Little Judicial Activism?’ in Flood, Roach and Sossin (eds.), Access to Care, Access to Justice at 198.
450. K. Klare, ‘Legal Culture and Transformative Constitutionalism’ (1998) 14 South African Journal on Human Rights, 146 at 150.
451. C. Ngwena, ‘Substantive Equality in South African Health Care: the Limits of Law’ (2000) 4 Medical Law International, 111.
452. M. Pieterse, ‘Possibilities and Pitfalls in the Domestic Enforcement of Social Rights: Contemplating the South African Experience’ (2004) 26 Human Rights Quarterly, 882 at 885.
453. C. Ngwena and R. Cook, ‘Rights Concerning Health’ in D. Brand and C. Heyns (eds.), Socio-Economic Rights in South Africa (Pretoria: Pretoria University Press, 2005) at 137–8.
454. M. Pieterse, ‘Coming to Terms with Judicial Enforcement of Socio-Economic Rights’ (2004) South Africa Journal of Human Rights, 383 at 402
455. ‘Possibilities and Pitfalls’ (2004) 26 Human Rights Quarterly, 882 at 89
456. D. Moellendorf, ‘Reasoning about Resources: Soobramoney and the Future of Socio-Economic Rights Claims’ (1998) 14 South African Journal on Human Rights, 327
457. C. Scott and P. Alston, ‘Adjudicating Constitutional Priorities in a Transnational Context: a Comment on Soobramoney’s Legacy and Grootboom’s Promise’ (2000) 16 South African Journal on Human Rights, 206 at 243.
458. P. de Vos, ‘Grootboom, the Right of Access to Housing and Substantive Equality as Fairness’ (2001) 17 South African Journal on Human Rights, 259.
459. N. Nattrass, The Moral Economy of AIDS in South Africa (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004) at 47.
460. J. Klaaren, ‘A Remedial Interpretation of the Treatment Action Campaign decision’ (2003) 19 South African Journal on Human Rights, 455 at 461.
461. T. Roux, ‘Legitimating Transformation: Political Resource Allocation in the South African Constitutional Court’ (2003) 10 Democratization, 92 at 96.
462. D. Bilchitz, ‘Towards a Reasonable Approach to the Minimum Core: Laying the Foundations for Future Socio-Economic Rights Jurisprudence’ (2003) 19 South African Journal on Human Rights, 1 at 10.
463. ‘Reasoning about Resources’ (1998) 14 South African Journal on Human Rights, 327.
464. C. Sunstein, Designing Democracy (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001) at 236.
465. E. Mureinik, ‘A Bridge to Where? Introducing the Interim Bill of Rights’ (1994) 10 South African Journal on Human Rights, 31 at 32.
466. D. Dyzenhaus, ‘Law as Justification: Etienne Mureinik’s Conception of Legal Culture’ (1998) 14 South African Journal on Human Rights, 11
467. J. van der Walt and H. Botha, ‘Democracy and Rights in South Africa: Beyond a Constitutional Culture of Justification’ (2000) 7 Constellations, 341.
468. ‘A Bridge to Where?’ 10 South African Journal on Human Rights, 31 at 33.
469. J. Fitzpatrick and R. Slye, ‘Republic of South Africa v. Grootboom and Minister of Health v. Treatment Action Campaign’ (2003) 97 American Journal of International Law, 669 at 680
470. M. Heywood, ‘Preventing Mother-to-Child HIV Transmission in South Africa: Background, Strategies and Outcomes of the Treatment Action Campaign Case against the Minister of Health’ (2003) 19 South African Journal on Human Rights, 278 at 304.
471. M. Heywood, ‘Contempt or Compliance? The TAC Case after the Constitutional Court Judgment’ (2003) 4 ESR Review, 7 at 9.
472. H. Schneider, ‘On the Fault-line: the Politics of AIDS Policy in Contemporary South Africa’ (2002) 61 African Studies, 145
473. L. Fuller: ‘The Forms and Limits of Adjudication’ (1978) 92 Harvard Law Review, 353 at 368–9.
474. W. Hutton, New Life for Health (London: Vintage, 2000) at 31, 60–62.
475. M. Hall, Making Medical Spending Decisions (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997) at 73.
476. T. Roux, ‘Legitimating Transformation: Political Resource Allocation in the South African Constitutional Court’ (2003) 10 Democratization, 92 at 107
477. M. Pieterse, ‘Coming to Terms with Judicial Enforcement of Socio-Economic Rights’ (2004) South African Journal on Human Rights, 383 at 404.
478. B. Sheldrick, ‘Judicial Review and the Allocation of Health Resources in Canada and the United Kingdom’ (2003) 5 Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis, 149 at 157
479. J. Jowell, ‘Of Vires and Vacuums: The Constitutional Context of Judicial Review’ [1999] Public Law, 448 at 453.
480. R. James and D. Longley, ‘Judicial Review and Tragic Choices’: ex parte B [1995] Public Law, 367 at 373.
481. United Nations Economic and Social Council, Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. The Right of Everyone to the Enjoyment of the Highest Attainable Standard of Physical and Mental Health: Report of the Special Rapporteur (New York, United Nations, 2003)
482. T. Evans, ‘A Human Right to Health?’ (2002) 23 Third World Quarterly, 197 at 200
483. C. Newdick, Who ShouldWe Treat? (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2nd edn, 2004) at 10
484. N. Daniels, Just Health Care (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985) at 43
485. R. Dworkin, Taking Rights Seriously (London: Duckworth, 1978) at xi.
486. D. Feldman, Civil Liberties and Human Rights in England and Wales (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2nd edn, 2002) at 6.
487. J. van der Walt and H. Botha, ‘Democracy and Rights in South Africa: Beyond a Constitutional Culture of Justification’ (2000) 7 Constellations, 341 at 343–4.
488. E. Mureinik, ‘A Bridge to Where? Introducing the Interim Bill of Rights’ (1994) 10 South African Journal of Human Rights, 11.
489. T. Prosser, ‘Towards a Critical Public Law’ (1982) 9 Journal of Law and Society, 1 at 11.
490. M. Dowdle (ed.), Public Accountability: Designs, Dilemmas and Experiences (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2006) at 1.
491. P. Craig, Administrative Law (London: Sweet & Maxwell, 5th edn, 2003) at 630–2.
492. P. Cane, Administrative Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 4th edn., 2003) at 258.
493. R. Smith ‘Rationing: the Debate We Have to Have’ (1995) 310 British Medical Journal, 686.
494. A. Parkin, ‘Allocating Healthcare Resources in an Imperfect World’ (1995) 58 Modern Law Review, 867 at 876.