Judicial Control in the European Union: Reforming Jurisdiction in the Intergovernmental Pillars

Judicial Control in the European Union: Reforming Jurisdiction in the Intergovernmental Pillars

Volumn , Issue , 2010, Pages 1-232

  Hinarejos, Alicia ^a,b,c  

^a BRASENOSE COLLEGE   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD   (United Kingdom)

^c MCGILL UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

Constitutional balance; Constitutional change; Constitutional treaty; Court of justice; European union; Intergovernmental pillars; Judicial control; Jurisdiction; Need for reform; Treaty of lisbon

Indexed keywords

EID: 84921605935     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book    
DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199569960.001.0001     Document Type: Book

References (225)

1. Albors-Llorens, A, Private Parties in European Community Law: Challenging Community measures (Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1996)
2. Albors-Llorens, A, 'Changes in the Jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice under the Treaty of Amsterdam' (1998) 35 CML Rev 1273
3. Albors-Llorens, A, 'The Standing of Private Parties to Challenge Community Measures: Has the European Court Missed the Boat?' (2003) 62 CML Rev 72
4. Allan, T, Law, Liberty and Justice: The Legal Foundations of British Constitutionalism (Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1993)
5. Arden, LJ, 'Jurisdiction of the New United Kingdom Supreme Court' [2004] Winter PL 699
6. Arnull, A, 'Does the Court of Justice Have Inherent Jurisdiction?' (1991) 28 CML Rev 669
7. Arnull, A, 'The European Court of Justice and Judicial Objectivity: A Reply to Professor Hartley' (1996) 112 LQR 95
8. Arnull, A, The European Union and its Court of Justice (Oxford EC Law Library, OUP: Oxford, 1999)
9. Arnull, A, 'The Rule of Law in the European Union' in A Arnull and D Wincott (eds), Accountability and Legitimacy in the European Union (OUP: Oxford, 2003)
10. Arnull, A, 'From Bit Part to Starring Role? The Court of Justice and Europe's Constitutional Treaty' (2005) 24 YEL 1
11. Arnull, A, The European Union and its Court of Justice (2nd edn, OUP: Oxford, 2006)
12. Bartelt, S, and H Zeitler, '"Intelligente Sanktionen" zur Terrorismusbekämpfung in der EU' (2003) 23 Europäische Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsrecht 712
13. Beaud, O, 'Reframing a Debate among Americans: Contextualizing a Moral Philosophy of Law' (2009) 7 I-CON 53
14. Bell, J, S Boyron, and S Whittaker, Principles of French Law (OUP: Oxford, 1998)
15. Bell, J, S and L Brown, French Administrative Law (Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1998)
16. Bering Liisberg, J, 'The EU Constitutional Treaty and its Distinction between Legislative and Non-legislative Acts: Oranges into Apples?' Jean Monnet Working Paper 01/06 http://www.jeanmonnetprogram.org/papers/06/060101.html (accessed January 2009)
17. Besselink, L, 'Curing a "Childhood Sickness"? On Direct Effect, Internal Effect, Primacy and Derogation from Civil Rights. The Netherlands Council of State Judgment in the Metten Case' (1996) 3 Maastricht J of Eur and Comparative L 165
18. Bickel, A, The Least Dangerous Branch (Yale University Press: New Haven, 1962)
19. Boer, D, 'Justice and Home Affairs Co-operation in the Treaty on European Union: More Complexity Despite Communautarization' (1997) 4 Maastricht J 310
20. Borgers, MJ, 'Implementing Framework Decisions' (2007) 44 CML Rev 1361
21. Buergenthal, T, 'Self-executing and Non Self-executing Treaties in National and International Law' 235 1992-IV Hague Recueil des Cours 303
22. Búrca, G de, 'The European Court of Justice and the International Legal Order after Kadi' Jean Monnet Working Paper 01/09 (accessed March 2009)
23. Burley, A, and W Mattley, 'Europe before the Court: A Political Theory of Legal Integration' (1993) 47 International Organizations 41
24. Cameron, I, 'European Union Anti-Terrorist Blacklisting' (2004) 4 HRLRev 225
25. Canor, I, 'Primus Inter Pares: Who is the Ultimate Guardian of Fundamental Rights in Europe' (2000) 25 ELR 3
26. Cappelletti, M, The Judicial Process in Comparative Perspective (Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1989)
27. Cassesse, A, 'Modern Constitutions and International Law' 192 1985-III Hague Recueil des Cours 331
28. Chalmers, D, 'The Court of Justice and the Third Pillar' (2005) 30 ELR 773
29. Chalmers, D, 'The Secret Delivery of Justice' (2008) 33 ELR 773
30. Claes, M, The National Courts' Mandate in the European Constitution (Hart: Oxford, 2006)
31. Conant, L, Justice Contained (Cornell University Press: Ithaca, 2002)
32. Constantinesco, V, 'The ECJ as a Law-Maker: Praeter aut Contra Legem?' in D O'Keeffe (ed), Judicial Review in European Union Law: Liber Amicorum in Honour of Lord Slynn of Hadley (Kluwer: London, 2000)
33. Costello, C, 'The Bosphorus Ruling of the ECHR: Fundamental Rights and Blurry Boundaries in Europe' (2006) 6 EHRLRev 87
34. Craig, P, 'Legality, Standing and Substantive Review in Community Law' (1994) 14 OJLS 507
35. Craig, P, 'Formal and Substantive Conceptions of the Rule of Law: An Analytical Framework' [1997] PL 467
36. Craig, P, EU Administrative Law (OUP: Oxford, 2006)
37. Craig, P, and G de Búrca, EU Law: Text, Cases and Materials (4th edn, OUP: Oxford, 2003)
38. Cremona, M, 'A Constitutional Basis for Effective External Action? An Assessment of the Provisions on EU External Action in the Constitutional Treaty' (2006) 30 EUI Working Paper http://cadmus.eui.eu/dspace/handle/1814/6293 (accessed March 2009)
39. Cremona, M, 'Case C-403/05, European Parliament v Commission (Philippines Border Management Project), Judgment of the Grand Chamber of 23 October 2007 [2007] ECR I-9045' (2008) 45 CML Rev 1727
40. Cremona, M, 'Coherence through Law: What difference will the Treaty of Lisbon make?' (2008) 3 Hamburg Rev of Social Sciences 11
41. Cremona, M, F Francioni, and S Poli, 'Challenging EU Counter-Terrorism Measures through the Courts' EUI Working Paper (forthcoming)
42. Cullen, H, and A Charlesworth, 'Diplomacy by other Means: The Use of Legal Basis Litigation as a Political Strategy by the European Parliament and Member States' (1999) 36 CML Rev 1234
43. Dashwood, A, 'The Law and Practice of CFSP Joint Actions' in M Cremona and B de Witte (eds), EU Foreign Relations Law: Constitutional Fundamentals (Hart: Oxford, 2008)
44. Dashwood, A, and C Hillion (eds), The General Law of EC External Relations (Sweet & Maxwell: Oxford, 2000)
45. Dashwood, A, and A Johnston, 'Synthesis of the Debate' in A Dashwood and A Johnston (eds), The Future of the Judicial System of the European Union (Hart: Oxford, 2001)
46. Dawes, A, and O Lynskey, 'The Ever-longer Arm of EC Law: The Extension of Community Competence into the Field of Criminal Law' (2008) 45 CML Rev 131
47. De Hert, P, C Riehle, and V Papakonstantinou, 'Data Protection in the Third Pillar: Cautious Pessimism' in M Martin Crime (ed), Rights and the EU: The Future of Police and Judicial Cooperation (Justice: London, 2008)
48. Denza, E, The Intergovernmental Pillars of the European Union (OUP: Oxford, 2002)
49. Denza, E, 'Common Foreign Policy and Single Foreign Policy' in T Tridimas and P Nebbia (eds), European Union Law for the Twenty-First Century: Rethinking the New Legal Order (Hart: Oxford, 2004)
50. De Witte, B, 'Direct Effect, Supremacy and the Nature of the Legal Order' in P Craig and G De Búrca (eds), The Evolution of EU Law (OUP: Oxford, 1999)
51. Dicey, A, The Law of the Constitution (10th edn, Macmillan: London, 1959)
52. Dickson, B, Introduction to French Law (Pitman Publishing: London, 1994)
53. Dougan, M, 'When Worlds Collide: Relationship between Direct Effect and Supremacy' (2007) 44 CML Rev 931
54. Dougan, M, 'The Treaty of Lisbon 2007: Winning Minds, Not Hearts' (2008) 45 CML Rev 617
55. Douglas-Scott, S, 'The Rule of Law in the European Union: Putting the Security into the EU's Area of Freedom Security and Justice' (2004) 29 ELR 219
56. Douglas-Scott, S, 'A Tale of Two Courts: Luxembourg, Strasbourg and the Growing European Human Rights Acquis' (2006) 43 CML Rev 619
57. Douglas-Scott, S, 'Bosphorus Hava Youllari Turizm Ve Ticaret Anonim Sirketi v Ireland' (2006) 43 CML Rev 243
58. Dworkin, R, Taking Rights Seriously (Harvard University Press: Boston, 1977)
59. Dworkin, R, A Matter of Principle (Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1986)
60. Eckes, C, 'Annotation to Case T-228/02, Organisation des Modjahedines du Peuple d'Iran v. Council and UK (OMPI), Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber) of 12 December 2006' (2007) 44 CML Rev 1117
61. Eckes, C, 'Sanctions against Individuals: Fighting Terrorism within the European Legal Order' (2008) 4 EuConst 205
62. Editorial, 'The CFSP under the EU Constitutional Treaty: Issues of Depillarization' (2005) 42 CML Rev 325
63. Editorial, 'The Rule of Law as the Backbone of the EU' (2007) 44 CML Rev 875
64. Editorial, (2008) 45 CML Rev 1571
65. Eeckhout, P, 'The European Court of Justice and the "Area of Freedom, Security and Justice": Challenges and Problems' in D O'Keeffe (ed), Judicial Review in European Union Law: Liber Amicorum in Honour of Lord Slynn of Hadley (Kluwer: London, 2000)
66. Eeckhout, P, External Relations of the European Union: Legal and Constitutional Foundations (OUP: Oxford, 2004)
67. Eeckhout, P, 'Community Terrorism Listings, Fundamental Rights, and UN Security Council Resolutions: In Search of the Right Fit' (2007) 3 EuConst 183
68. Eleftheriadis, P, 'The Direct Effect of Community Law: Conceptual Issues' (1996) 16 YEL 205
69. Ely, JH, Democracy and Distrust: A Theory of Judicial Review (Harvard University Press: Cambridge, 1981)
70. Evans, A, 'The Enforcement Procedure of Article 169 EEC: Commission's Discretion' (1979) 4 ELR 442
71. Everling, U, 'On the Judge-Made Law of the European Community's Courts' in D O'Keeffe (ed), Judicial Review in European Union Law: Liber Amicorum in Honour of Lord Slynn of Hadley (Kluwer: London, 2000)
72. Fallon, R, 'The Core of an Uneasy Case for Judicial Review' (2008) 121 Harvard LR 1693
73. Favoreu, L, 'Le Droit Constitutionnel, Droit de la Constitution et Constitution du Droit' (1990) 1 Revue Française de Droit Constitutionnel 71
74. Fennelly, N, 'The "Area of Freedom, Security and Justice" and the European Court of Justice: A Personal View' (2000) 49 ICLQ 1
75. Ferejohn, J, and P Pasquino, 'Constitutional Adjudication: Lessons from Europe' (2004) 82 Texas L Rev 1671
76. Ferreres Comella, V, 'The Consequences of Centralizing Constitutional Review in a Special Court: Some Thoughts on Judicial Activism' (2004) 82 Texas L Rev 1705
77. Ferreres Comella, V, 'The European Model of Constitutional Review of Legislation: Toward Decentralization?' (2004) 2 I-CON 461
78. Figueroa Regueiro, P, 'Invocability of Substitution and Invocability of Exclusion: Bringing Legal Realism to the Current Development of the Case-Law of Horizontal Direct Effect of Directives' (2002) Jean Monnet Working Paper 7/02 www.jeanmonnetprogram.org/papers/02/020701.pdf (accessed Jan 2007)
79. Fijnaut, C, 'Police Co-operation and the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice' in N Walker (ed), Europe's Area of Freedom, Security and Justice (OUP: Oxford, 2004)
80. Fiss, O, 'The Perils of Minimalism' (2008) 9 Theoretical Inquiries 643
81. Fletcher, M, 'Extending "Indirect Effect" to the Third Pillar: The Significance of Pupino' (2005) 30 ELR 862
82. Franck, T, Political Questions/Judicial Answers: Should the Rule of Law Apply to Foreign Affairs? (Princeton University Press: Princeton, 1992)
83. Fröwein, J, 'Solange II' (1988) 25 CML Rev 201
84. Gaja, G, 'Constitutional Court (Italy) Decision No. 170 of 8 June 1984, S.p.a. granital v Amministrazione delle Finanze dello Stato' (1984) 21 CML Rev 756
85. Garbagnati-Ketvel, MG, 'The Jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice in Respect of the Common Foreign and Security Policy' (2006) 55 ICLQ 77
86. Garlicki, L, 'Cooperation of Courts: The Role of Supranational Jurisdictions in Europe' (2008) 6 I-CON 509
87. Gattini, A, 'Annotation: Joined Cases C-402/05 P & 415/05 P, Yassin Abdullah Kadi, Al Barakaat International Foundation v Council and Commission, judgment of the Grand Chamber 2008, nyr' (2009) 46 CML Rev 213
88. Grief, N, 'EU Law and Security' (2007) 32 ELR 752
89. Griller, S, 'International Law, Human Rights and the European Community's Autonomous Legal Order: Notes on the European Court of Justice Decision in Kadi' (2008) 4 Groenendijk, K, 'Reinstatement of Controls at Internal Borders: Why and against Whom?' (2004) 10 ELJ 150
90. Guild, E, 'The Constitutional Consequences of Lawmaking in the Third Pillar of the European Union' in P Craig and C Harlow (eds), Lawmaking in the European Union (Kluwer: London, 1998)
91. Guild, E, and S Peers, 'Deference or Defiance? The Court of Justice's Jurisdiction over Immigration and Asylum' in E Guild and C Harlow (eds), Implementing Amsterdam (Hart: Oxford, 2001)
92. Habermas, J, Faktizität und Geltung: Beiträge zur Diskurstheorie des Rechts und des demokratischen Rechtsstaates (Suhrkamp: Frankfurt am Main, 1992)
93. Hailbronner, K, 'European Immigration and Asylum Law under the Amsterdam Treaty' (1998) 35 CML Rev 1047
94. Halberstam, D, 'Comparative Federalism and the Role of the Judiciary' in KE Wittington, RD Kelemen, and GA Caldeira (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Law and Politics (OUP: Oxford, 2008)
95. Halberstam, D, and E Stein, 'The United Nations, the European Union, and the King of Sweden: Economic Sanctions and Individual Rights in a Plural World Order' (2009) 46 CML Rev 13
96. Harpaz, G, 'The European Court of Justice and its Relations with the European Court of Human Rights: The Quest for Enhanced Reliance, Coherence and Legitimacy' (2009) 46 CML Rev 105
97. Hartley, T, 'The European Court, Judicial Objectivity and the Constitution of the European Union' (1996) 112 LQR 95
98. Hayes, B, 'The Future of Europol: More Powers, Less Regulation, Precious Little Debate' (Statewatch Analysis 2006) (accessed Nov 2006)
99. Hedemann-Robinson, M, 'Article 173 EC, General Community Measures and Locus Standi for Private Persons: Still a Cause for Individual Concern?' (1996) 2 Eur PL 127
100. Heliskoski, J, 'Small Arms and Light Weapons within the Union's Pillar Structure: An Analysis of Article 47 of the EU Treaty' (2008) 33 ELR 898
101. Henkin, L, 'Is there a "Political Question" Doctrine?' (1976) 85 Yale LJ 597
102. Henkin, L, Foreign Affairs and the United States Constitution (Clarendon: Oxford, 1996)
103. Herlin-Karnell, E, 'Commission v Council: Some Reflections on Criminal Law in the First Pillar' (2007) 13 Eur PL 69
104. Hermann, C, 'The Unity of the Legal Order Revisited' in M Cremona and B de Witte (eds), EU Foreign Relations Law: Constitutional Fundamentals (Hart: Oxford, 2008)
105. Herzog, R, and L Gerken, 'Stop the European Court of Justice' (accessed Jan 2009)
106. Hillion, C, and R Wessel, 'Restraining External Competences of EU Member States under CFSP' in M Cremona and B de Witte (eds), EU Foreign Relations Law: Constitutional Fundamentals (Hart: Oxford, 2008)
107. Hillion, C, and T Downes, 'Making Sense of Rights: Community Rights in EC Law' (2009) 24 ELR 121
108. Hinarejos, A (2006) 43 CML Rev 583
109. Hinarejos, A 'Bosphorus v Ireland and the Protection of Fundamental Rights in Europe' (2006) 31 ELR 251
110. Hinarejos, A 'Judicial Control of CFSP in the Constitution: A Cherry Worth Picking?' (2006) 25 YEL 363
111. Hinarejos, A 'Recent Human Rights Developments in the EU Courts: The Charter of Fundamental Rights, the European Arrest Warrant and Terror Lists' (2007) 7 HRLRev 793
112. Hinarejos, A 'On the Legal Effects of Third Pillar Measures: Directly Applicable, Directly Effective, Self-Executing, Supreme?' (2008) 14 ELJ 620
113. Hinarejos, A 'The Lisbon Treaty versus Standing Still: A View from the Third Pillar' (2009) 5 EuConst 99
114. Hirschl, R, Towards Juristocracy: The Origins and Consequences of the New Constitutionalism (Harvard University Press: Cambridge, 2004)
115. House of Lords, EU Committee, 'The Future Role of the European Court of Justice: Report with Evidence' (6th Report of Session 2003-4, HL Paper 47)
116. House of Lords, EU Committee, 'Judicial Co-operation in the European Union: The Role of Eurojust. Report with Evidence' (23rd Report of Session 2003-4, HL Paper 138)
117. House of Lords, EU Committee, 'The Constitutional Treaty: Role of the ECJ: Primacy of Union Law-Government Response and Correspondence' (3rd Report of Session 2005-6, HL Paper 15)
118. House of Lords, EU Committee, 'The Criminal Law Competence of the European Community: Report with Evidence' (42nd Report of Session 2005-6, HL Paper 227)
119. Jacobs, F, 'Is the Court of Justice of the European Communities a Constitutional Court?' in D Curtin and D O'Keeffe (eds), Constitutional Adjudication in European Community and National Law (Butterworths: Dublin, 1992)
120. Jacobs, F, 'Human Rights in the European Union: The Role of the Court of Justice' (2001) 26 ELR 331
121. Jacobs, F, and S Roberts (eds), The Effects of Treaties in Domestic Law (Sweet and Maxwell: London, 1987)
122. Kelemen, RD, The Rules of Federalism: Institutions and Regulatory Politics in the EU and Beyond (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 2004)
123. Kelsen, H, 'Judicial Review of Legislation: A Comparative Study of the Austrian and American Constitution' (1942) 4 The Journal of Politics 183
124. Kelsen, H, 'La Garantie juridictionnelle de la Constitution' (1928) 44 Revue du Droit Public 197
125. Komárek, J, 'European Constitutionalism and the European Arrest Warrant: In Search of the Limits of "Contrapunctual Principles"' (2007) 44 CML Rev 9
126. Koskenniemi, M, 'International Law Aspects of the Common Foreign and Security Policy' in M Koskenniemi (ed), International Law Aspects of the European Union (Kluber Law International: The Hague, 1998)
127. Koutrakos, P, 'How Far is Far Enough? EC Law and the Organisation of the Armed Forces after Dory' (2003) 66 MLR 759
128. Koutrakos, P, EU International Relations Law (Hart: Oxford, 2006)
129. Koutrakos, P, 'Development and Foreign Policy: Where to Draw the Line between the Pillars?' (2008) 33 ELR 289
130. Koutrakos, P, 'Speeding up the Preliminary Reference Procedure: Fast but not too Fast' (2008) 33 ELR 617
131. Koutrakos, P, 'Legal Basis and Delimitation of Competences' in M Cremona and B de Witte (eds), EU Foreign Relations Law: Constitutional Fundamentals (Hart: Oxford, 2008)
132. Kuijper, P, 'The Evolution of the Third Pillar from Maastricht to the European Constitution: Institutional Aspects' (2004) 41 CML Rev 609
133. Kumm, M, 'Why Europeans Will Not Embrace Constitutional Patriotism' (2008) 6 I-CON 117
134. Kunoy, B, and A Dawes, 'Plate Tectonics in Luxembourg: The Ménage à Trois between EC Law, International Law and the European Convention on Human Rights Following the UN Sanctions Cases' (2009) 46 CML Rev 73
135. Laws, J, 'Law and Democracy' [1995] PL 72
136. Lazowski, A, 'Constitutional Tribunal on the Surrender of Polish Citizens under the European Arrest Warrant: Decision of 27 April 2005' (2005) 1 EuConst 569
137. Lazowski, A, 'From EU with Trust: The Potential and Limits of the Mutual Recognition in the Third Pillar from the Polish Perspective' in G Vernimmen-Van Tiggelen L Surano, and A Weyembergh (eds), The Future of Mutual Recognition in Criminal Matters in the European Union/L'Avenir de la reconnaissance mutuelle en matière pénale dans l'Union Européenne (Éditions de l'Université de Bruxelles: Brussels, 2009)
138. Leczykiewicz, D, (2006) 43 CML Rev 1181
139. Leczykiewicz, D, 'Constitutional Conflicts and the Third Pillar' 33 (2008) ELR 230.
140. Lenaerts, K, 'The Rule of Law and the Coherence of the Judicial System of the European Union' (2007) 44 CML Rev 1625
141. Lenaerts, K, and T Corthaut, 'Of Birds and Hedges: The Role of Primacy in Invoking Norms of EU Law' (2006) 31 ELR 287
142. Lenaerts, K, and P Van Nuffel, Constitutional Law of the European Union (2nd edn, Sweet & Maxwell: London, 2005)
143. Lenz, M, D Sif Tynes, and L Young, 'Horizontal What? Back to Basics' (2000) 25 ELR 509
144. Mitsilegas, V, 'Border Security in the European Union: Towards Centralized Controls and Maximum Surveillance' in E Guild and F Geyer (eds), Security versus Justice? Police and Judicial Cooperation in the European Union (Ashgate: Aldershot, 2008)
145. Monar, J, 'Justice and Home Affairs in the Treaty of Amsterdam: Reform at the Price of Fragmentation' (1998) 23 ELR 320
146. Monar, J, 'Alternatives to the Community Method in EU Justice and Home Affairs' (CONNEX 2007) http://www.portedeurope.org/IMG/doc/Jorg_Monar.doc (accessed March 2009).
147. Mueller, JW, Constitutional Patriotism (Princeton University Press: Princeton, 2008)
148. Neill, P, The European Court of Justice: A Case Study in Judicial Activism (European Policy Forum: London, 1995)
149. Nettesheim, M, 'UN Sanctions against Individuals: A Challenge to the Architecture of European Union Governance' (2007) 44 CML Rev 567
150. Nihoul, P, 'La Recevabilité des recours en annulation introduits par un particulier à l'encontre d'un acte communautaire de portée générale' (1994) 30 Revue Trimestrielle de Droit Européen 171
151. O'Keeffe, D, 'Recasting the Third Pillar' (1995) 32 CML Rev 893
152. Oliveira, A, 'Annotation to Case C170/96, Commission of the European Communities v Council of the European Union, judgment of 12 May 1998, [1998] ECR I-2763' (1999) 99 CML Rev 149
153. Orakeshevili, A, Peremptory Norms in International Law (OUP: Oxford, 2006)
154. Peers, S, 'National Security and European Law' (1996) 16 YEL 363
155. Peers, S, 'Who's Judging the Watchmen: The Judicial System of the "Area of Freedom, Security and Justice"' (1998) 17 YEL 337
156. Peers, S, EU Justice and Home Affairs Law (OUP: Oxford, 2006)
157. Peers, S, 'Transferring the Third Pillar' (Statewatch Analysis 2006) http://www.statewatch.org/news/2006/may/analysis-3rd-pill-transfer-may-2006.pdf (accessed August 2006)
158. Peers, S, 'Salvation outside the Church: Judicial Protection in the Third Pillar after the Pupino and Segi Judgments' (2007) 44 CML Rev 885
159. Peers, S, 'The Jurisdiction of the Court of Justice over EC Immigration and Asylum Law: Time for a Change?' in H Toner, E Guild, and A Baldaccini (eds), Whose Freedom, Security and Justice? EU Immigration and Asylum Law and Policy (Hart: Oxford, 2007)
160. Peers, S, 'The European Community's Criminal Law Competence: The Plot Thickens' (2008) 33 ELR 399
161. Pernice, I, 'Die Dritte Gewalt im europäischen Verfassungsverbund' (1996) 31 Europarecht 27
162. Peters, A, 'The Bananas Decision 2000 of the German Federal Constitutional Court: Towards Reconciliation with the ECJ as regards Fundamental Rights Protection in Europe' (2000) 43 German Yearbook of International Law 276
163. Petersmann, E, 'Act of State Doctrine, Political Question Doctrine und gerichtliche Kontrolle der auswärtigen Gewalt' (1976) 25 Jahrbuch des öffentlichen Rechts der Gegenwart NF 587
164. Poiares Maduro, M, 'Europe and the Constitution: What if this is as Good as it Gets?' Constitutionalism Web-Papers, University of Bath: www.bath.ac.uk/esml/conWEB/Conweb%20papers-filestore/conweb5-2000.pdf (accessed August 2009).
165. Prechal, S, 'Does Direct Effect Still Matter?' (2000) 37 CML Rev 1047
166. Prechal, S, Directives in EC Law (2nd edn, OUP: Oxford, 2005)
167. Prechal, S, 'Direct Effect, Indirect Effect, Supremacy and the Evolving Constitution of the European Union' in C Barnard (ed), The Fundamentals of EU Law Revisited (OUP: Oxford, 2007)
168. Puntscher Riekmann, S, 'Security, Freedom and Accountability: Europol & Frontex' in E Guild and F Geyer (eds), Security versus Justice? Police and Judicial Cooperation in the European Union (Ashgate: Aldershot, 2008)
169. Ragolle, F, 'Access to Justice for Private Applicants in the Community Legal Order: Recent (R)evolutions' (2003) 28 ELR 90
170. Rasmussen, H, On Law and Policy in the European Court of Justice (Martinus Nijhoff: Dordrecht, 1986)
171. Rasmussen, H, The European Court of Justice (GadJura: Copenhagen, 1993)
172. Raz, J, 'The Rule of Law and its Virtue' (1977) 93 LQR 195
173. Rosenfeld, M, 'Constitutional Adjudication in Europe and the United States: Paradoxes and Contrasts' (2004) 2 I-CON 633
174. Rosenfeld, M, 'Comparing Constitutional Review by the European Court of Justice and the US Supreme Court' (2006) 4 I-CON 618
175. Ross, M, 'Effectiveness in the European Legal Order(s): Beyond Supremacy to Constitutional Proportionality' (2006) 31 ELR 476
176. Sadurski, W, Rights before Courts: A Study of Constitutional Courts in Postcommunist Countries in Central and Eastern Europe (Springer: Dordrecht, 2005)
177. Schermers, H, and C Swaak, 'Official Acts of Community Servants and Article 215(4) EC' in T Heukels and A McDonnell (eds), The Action for Damages in Community Law (Kluwer: The Hague, 1997)
178. Schwarze, J (ed), The Birth of a European Constitutional Order: The Interaction of National and European Constitutional Law (Nomos: Baden-Baden, 2000)
179. Schweitzer, M, Staatsrecht III (8th edn, CF Müller Verlag: Heidelberg, 2004)
180. Shapiro, M, Courts: A Comparative and Political Analysis (University of Chicago Press: Chicago, 1981)
181. Shapiro, M, 'The European Court of Justice' in P Craig and G De Búrca (eds), The Evolution of EU Law (OUP: Oxford, 1999)
182. Shapiro, M, and A Stone, 'Introduction: The New Constitutional Politics' (1994) 26 Comparative Political Studies 397
183. Simpson, G, 'Asylum and Immigration in the European Union after the Treaty of Amsterdam' (1999) 5 Eur PL 91
184. Skouris, V, 'The Position of the European Court of Justice in the EU Legal Order and its Relationship with National Constitutional Courts' (2005) 60 Zeitschrift für Öffentliches Recht 323
185. Slaughter, A-M, AS Sweet, and JHH Weiler (eds), The European Courts and National Courts: Doctrine and Jurisprudence (Hart: Oxford, 1998)
186. Spaventa, E, 'Remembrance of Principles Lost: On Fundamental Rights, the Third Pillar and the Scope of Union Law' (2006) 25 YEL 153
187. Spaventa, E, 'Opening Pandora's Box: Some Reflections on the Constitutional Effects of the Decision in Pupino' (2007) 3 EuConst 5
188. Spaventa, E, 'Fundamental What? The Difficult Relationship between Foreign Policy and Fundamental Rights' in M Cremona and B de Witte (eds), EU Foreign Relations Law: Constitutional Fundamentals (Hart: Oxford, 2008)
189. Spencer, J, 'The European Arrest Warrant' (2004) 6 Cambridge Ybk of European Legal Studies 201
190. Spencer, J, 'Child Witnesses and the European Union' (2005) 64 CLJ 569
191. Spencer, M, States of Injustice: A Guide to Human Rights and Civil Liberties in the European Union (Pluto: London, 1995)
192. Sternberger, D, Verfassungspatriotismus (Insel: Frankfurt am Main, 1990)
193. Stone, A, 'Judicial Review without Rights: Some Problems for the Democratic Legitimacy of Structural Judicial Review' (2008) 28 OJLS 1
194. Stone-Sweet, A, Governing with Judges (OUP: Oxford, 2000)
195. Sunstein, C, 'Incompletely Theorized Agreements' (1995) 108 Harvard LR 1733
196. Sunstein, C, One Case at a Time: Judicial Minimalism on the Supreme Court (Harvard University Press: Cambridge, 1999)
197. Thym, D, 'The Schengen Law: A Challenge for Legal Accountability in the European Union' (2002) 8 ELJ 218
198. Timmermans, C, 'The Constitutionalisation of the European Union' (2002) 21 YEL 1
199. Tobler, C, 'Annotation to Case C-176/03, Commission v Council, judgment of the Grand Chamber of 13 September 2005, nyr' (2006) 43 CML Rev 835
200. Tomuschat, C, 'Annotation to Yusuf and Kadi' (2007) 43 CML Rev 537
201. Treanor, WM, 'Judicial Review before Marbury' (2005) 58 Stanford L Rev 455
202. Tridimas, T, 'The Court of Justice and Judicial Activism' (1997) 2 ELR 199
203. Tridimas, T, 'Black, White and Shades of Grey: Horizontality of Directives Revisited' (2002) 21 YEL 327
204. Tridimas, T, 'The European Court of Justice and the Draft Constitution: A Supreme Court for the Union?' in T Tridimas and P Nebbia (eds), European Union Law for the Twenty-First Century: Rethinking the New Legal Order (Hart: Oxford, 2004)
205. Tridimas, T, The General Principles of EU Law (2nd edn, OUP: Oxford, 2006)
206. Tridimas, T, and JA Gutierrez-Fons, 'EU Law, International Law, and Economic Sanctions against Terrorism: The Judiciary in Distress?' (2009) 32 Fordham Int LJ 660
207. Tushnet, M, Taking the Constitution away from the Courts (Princeton University Press: Princeton, 1999)
208. Ukrow, J, Richterliche Rechstfortbildung durch den EuGH (Nomos: Baden-Baden, 1995)
209. Unger, R, Law in Modern Society: Toward a Criticism of Social Theory (Free Press: New York, 1976)
210. Usher, JA, 'Direct and Individual Concern: An Effective Remedy or a Conventional Solution?' (2003) 28 ELR 575
211. Van den Wyngaert, C, 'Eurojust and the European Public Prosecutor' in N Walker (ed), Europe's Area of Freedom, Security and Justice (OUP: Oxford, 2004)
212. Van Ooik, R, 'Cross-Pillar Litigation before the ECJ: Demarcation of Community and Union Competences' (2008) 4 EuConst 399
213. Von Mehren, AT, and PL Murray, Law in the United States (2nd edn, Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, 2007)
214. Waldron, J, 'The Core of the Case against Judicial Review' (2006) Yale L J 1346
215. Ward, A, 'Access to Justice' in S Peers and A Ward (eds), The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (Hart: Oxford, 2004)
216. Ward, A, Judicial Review and the Rights of Private Parties in EU Law (OUP: Oxford, 2007)
217. Weatherill, S, 'Activism and Restraint in the European Court of Justice' in P Capps, M Evans, and S Konstadinidis (eds), Asserting Jurisdiction: International and European Legal Perspectives (Hart: Oxford, 2003)
218. Weatherill, S, Cases and Materials on EU Law (8th edn, OUP: Oxford, 2007)
219. Weiler, JHH, 'Fundamental Rights and Fundamental Boundaries: On Standards and Values in the Protection of Human Rights' in N Neuwahl and A Rosas (eds), The European Union and Human Rights (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers: The Hague, 1995)
220. Weiler, JHH, and UR Haltern, 'Constitutional or International? The Foundations of the Community Legal Order and the Question of Judicial Kompetenz-Kompetenz' in A-M Slaughter, A Sweet, and JHH Weiler (eds), The European Courts and National Courts: Doctrine and Jurisprudence (Hart: Oxford, 1998)
221. Winter, J, 'Direct Applicability and Direct Effect: Two Distinct and Different Concepts in Community Law' (1972) 9 CML Rev 425
222. Wolfrum, R, 'Kontrolle der auswärtigen Gewalt' (1997) 56 Veröffentlichungen der Vereinigung der Deutschen Staatsrechtslehrer 38
223. Wyatt, D, and A Dashwood (eds), European Union Law (5th edn, Sweet & Maxwell: London, 2006)
224. Zeitler, FC, 'Judicial Review und Judicial Restraint gegenüber der auswärtigen Gewalt' (1976) 25 Jahrbuch des öffentlichen Rechts der Gegenwart NF 621
225. Ziegler, K, 'Strengthening the Rule of Law, but Fragmenting International Law: The Kadi Decision of the ECJ from the Perspective of Human Rights' (2009) HRLRev 288.