Comparison of four species-delimitation methods applied to a DNA barcode data set of insect larvae for use in routine bioassessment

Freshwater Science

Volumn 33, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 338-348

  White, Bryan P ^a   Pilgrim, Erik M ^b   Boykin, Laura M ^c   Stein, Eric D ^a   Mazor, Raphael D ^a  

^a SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA COASTAL WATER RESEARCH PROJECT   (United States)

^b U S ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA   (Australia)

Author keywords

benthic macroinvertebrates; bioassessment; biomonitoring; coalescent theory; COI; cytochrome oxidase I; DNA barcoding; GMYC; species delimitation

Indexed keywords

ABUNDANCE; BENTHOS; BIOMONITORING; BOOTSTRAPPING; COALESCENCE; COMPARATIVE STUDY; DATA SET; ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT; GENE EXPRESSION; GENETIC MARKER; GENOTYPE; LARVA; MACROINVERTEBRATE; MAXIMUM LIKELIHOOD ANALYSIS; MAYFLY; PARTHENOGENESIS; SPECIES RICHNESS; STREAMWATER; TAXONOMY;

EID: 84896322579     PISSN: 21619549     EISSN: 21619565     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1086/674982     Document Type: Article

References (67)

1. Ball, S. L., P. D. N. Hebert, S. K. Burian, and J. M. Webb. 2005. Biological identifications of mayflies (Ephemeroptera) using DNA barcodes. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 24:508-524. (Pubitemid 41346061)
2. Bergman, E. A., and W. L. Hilsenhoff. 1978. Parthenogenesis in the mayfly genus Baetis (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Annals of the Entomological Society of America71:167-168.
3. Bergsten, J., D. T. Bilton, T. Fujisawa, M. Elliott, M. T. Monaghan, M. Balke, and A. P. Vogler. 2012. The effect of geographical scale of sampling on DNA barcoding. Systematic Biology 61: 851-869.
4. Bertolazzi, P., G. Felici, and E. Weitschek. 2009. Learning to classify species with barcodes. BMC Bioinformatics10:S7.
5. Bickford, D., D. J. Lohman, N. S. Sodhi, P. K. Ng, R. Meier, K. Winker, K. K. Ingram, and I. Das. 2007. Cryptic species as a window on diversity and conservation. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 22:148-155. (Pubitemid 46273824)
6. Boykin, L. M., K. F. Armstrong, L. Kubatko, and P. D. Barro. 2012. Species delimitation and global biosecurity. Evolutionary Bioinformatics 8:1-37.
7. Brown, W. M., M. George, and A. C. Wilson. 1979. Rapid evolution of animal mitochondrial DNA. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the Unites States of America 76:1967-1971. (Pubitemid 9207037)
8. Buckley, T. R., D. Attanayake, D. Park, S. Ravindran, T. R. Jewell, and B. B. Normark. 2008. Investigating hybridization in the parthenogenetic New Zealand stick insect Acanthoxyla (Phasmatodea) using single-copy nuclear loci. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 48:335-349.
9. Carew, M. E., V. J. Pettigrove, L. Metzeling, and A. A. Hoffmann. 2013. Environmental monitoring using next generation sequencing: rapid identification of macroinvertebrate bioindicator species. Frontiers in Zoology 10:1-15.
10. Christodoulou, M., A. Antoniou, A. Magoulas, and A. Koukouras. 2012. Revision of the freshwater genus Atyaephyra (Crustacea, Decapoda, Atyidae) based on morphological and molecular data. ZooKeys 229:53-110.
11. Collins, R. A., L. M. Boykin, R. H. Cruickshank, and K. F. Armstrong. 2012. Barcoding's next top model: an evaluation of nucleotide substitution models for specimen identification. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 3:457-465.
12. Cummings, M. P., M. C. Neel, and K. L. Shaw. 2008. A genealogical approach to quantifying lineage divergence. Evolution 62:2411-2422.
13. Dawnay, N., R. Ogden, R. McEwing, G. R. Carvalho, and R. S. Thorpe. 2007. Validation of the barcoding gene COI for use in forensic genetic species identification. Forensic Science International 173:1-6. (Pubitemid 47418547)
14. de Queiroz, K. 2007. Species concepts and species delimitation. Systematic Biology 56:879-886. (Pubitemid 350129638)
15. Drummond, A. J., and A. Rambaut. 2007. BEAST: Bayesian evolutionary analysis by sampling trees. BMC Evolutionary Biology 7:214.
16. Drummond, A. J., M. A. Suchard, D. Xie, and A. Rambaut. 2012. Bayesian phylogenetics with BEAUti and the BEAST 1.7. Molecular Biology and Evolution 29:1969-1973.
17. Edgar, R. C. 2004. MUSCLE: multiple sequence alignment with high accuracy and high throughput. Nucleic Acids Research 32:1792-1797. (Pubitemid 38832724)
18. Felsenstein, J. 1985. Confidence limits on phylogenies: an approach using the bootstrap. Evolution 39:783-791.
19. Fontaneto, D., E. A. Herniou, C. Boschetti, M. Caprioli, G. Melone, C. Ricci, and T. G. Barraclough. 2007. Independently evolving species in asexual bdelloid rotifers. PloS Biology 5:e87.
20. Fujita, M. K., A. D. Leache, F. T. Burbrink, J. A. McGuire, and C. Moritz. 2012. Coalescent-based species delimitation in an integrative taxonomy. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 27: 480-488.
21. Funk, D. H., J. K. Jackson, and B. W. Sweeney. 2006. Taxonomy and genetics of the parthenogenetic mayfly Centroptilum triangulifer and its sexual sister Centroptilum alamance (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Journal of the North American Benthological Society 25:417-429. (Pubitemid 43837007)
22. Funk, D. H., J. K. Jackson, and B. W. Sweeney. 2008. A new parthenogenetic mayfly (Ephemeroptera: Ephemerellidae: Eurylophella Tiensuu) oviposits by abdominal bursting in the subimago. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 27:269-279. (Pubitemid 351967291)
23. Funk, D. H., B. W. Sweeney, and J. K. Jackson. 2010. Why stream mayflies can reproduce without males but remain bisexual: a case of lost genetic variation. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 29:1258-1266.
24. Hajibabaei, M., D. H. Janzen, J. M. Burns, W. Hallwachs, and P. D. N. Hebert. 2006. DNA barcodes distinguish species of tropical Lepidoptera. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 103:968-971. (Pubitemid 43212205)
25. Hebert, P. D. N., A. Cywinska, S. L. Ball, J. R. deWaard. 2003. Biological identifications through DNA barcodes. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B: Biological Sciences 270:313-321. (Pubitemid 36228536)
26. Hebert, P. D. N., M. Y. Stoeckle, T. S. Zemlak, and C. M. Francis. 2004. Identification of birds through DNA barcodes. PLoS Biology 2:e312.
27. Heled, J., and A. J. Drummond. 2010. Bayesian inference of species trees from multilocus data. Molecular Biology and Evolution 27:570-580.
28. Janzen, D. H., W. Hallwachs, P. Blandin, J. M. Burns, J. Cadiou, I. Chacon, T. Dapkey, A. R. Deans, M. E. Epstein, B. Espinoza, J. G. Franclemont, W. A. Haber, M. Hajibabaei, J. P. W. Hall, P. D. N. Hebert, I. D. Gauld, D. J. Harvey, A. Hausmann, I. J. Kitching, D. Lafontaine, J.-F. Landry, C. Lemaire, J. Y. Miller, J. S. Miller, L. Miller, S. E. Miller, J. Montero, E. Munroe, S. R. Green, S. Ratnasingham, J. E. Rawlins, R. K. Robbins, J. J. Rodriguez, R. Rougerie, M. J. Sharkey, M. A. Smith, M. A. Solis, J. B. Sullivan, P. Thiaucourt, D. B. Wahl, S. J. Weller, J. B. Whitfield, K. R. Willmott, D. M. Wood, N. E. Woodley, and J. J. Wilson. 2009. Integration of DNA barcoding into an ongoing inventory of complex tropical biodiversity. Molecular Ecology Resources 9:1-26.
29. Ji, Y., L. Ashton, S. M. Pedley, D. P. Edwards, Y. Tang, A. Nakamura, R. Kitching, P. M. Dolman, P.Woodcock, F. A. Edwards, T. H. Larsen,W.W. Hsu, S. Benedick, K. C.Hamer,D. S. Wilcove, C. Bruce, X. Wang, T. Levi,M. Lott, B. C. Emerson, and D. W. Yu. 2013. Reliable, verifiable and efficient monitoring of biodiversity via metabarcoding. Ecology Letters 16:1245-1257.
30. Jones, F. C. 2008. Taxonomic sufficiency: The influence of taxonomic resolution on freshwater bioassessments using benthic macroinvertebrates. Environmental Reviews 16:45-69.
31. Kimura, M. 1980. A simple method for estimating evolutionary rate of base substitutions through comparative studies of nucleotide sequences. Journal of Molecular Evolution 16:111-120. (Pubitemid 11166431)
32. Knowles, L. L., and B. C. Carstens. 2007. Delimiting species without monophyletic gene trees. Systematic Biology 56:887-895. (Pubitemid 350129639)
33. Lakra, W. S., M. S. Verma, M. Goswami, K. K. Lal, V. Mohindra, P. Punia, A. Gopalakrishnan, K. V. Singh, R. D. Ward, and P. Hebert. 2011. DNA barcoding Indian marine fishes. Molecular Ecology Resources 11:60-71.
34. Liu, L., and D. K. Pearl. 2007. Species trees from gene trees: reconstructing Bayesian posterior distributions of a species phylogeny using estimated gene tree distributions. Systematic Biology 56:504-514.
35. Maralit, B. A., R. D. Aguila, M. F. H. Ventolero, S. K. L. Perez, and M. D. Santos. 2013. Detection of mislabeled commercial fishery by-products in the Philippines using DNA barcodes and its implications to food traceability and safety. Food Control (in press).
36. Masters, B. C., V. Fan, and H. A. Ross. 2011. Species delimitation-A Geneious plugin for the exploration of species boundaries. Molecular Ecology Resources 11:154-157.
37. McCafferty, W. P., and D. K. Morihara. 1979. The male of Baetis macdunnoughi Ide and notes on parthenogenetic pop-ulations within Baetis (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae). Entomological News 90:26-28.
38. Mecklenburg, C. W., P. R. Møller, and D. Steinke. 2011. Biodiversity of arctic marine fishes: taxonomy and zoogeography. Marine Biodiversity 41:109-140.
39. Meyer, C. P., and G. Paulay. 2005. DNA barcoding: error rates based on comprehensive sampling. PLoS Biology 3:e422.
40. Monaghan, M. T., R.Wild, M. Elliot, T. Fujisawa, M. Balke, D. J. Inward, D. C. Lees, R. Ranaivosolo, P. Eggleton, T. G. Barraclough, and A. P. Vogler. 2009. Accelerated species inventory on Madagascar using coalescent-based models of species delineation. Systematic Biology 58:298-311.
41. Nuñez, J. J., A. Vejar-Pardo, B. E. Guzmán, E. H. Barriga, and C. S. Gallardo. 2012. Phylogenetic and mixed Yule-coalescent analyses reveal cryptic lineages within two South American marine snails of the genus Crepipatella (Gastropoda: Calyptraeidae). Invertebrate Biology 131:301-311.
42. Oceguera-Figueroa, A., V. León-Règagnon, and M. E. Siddall. 2010. DNA barcoding reveals Mexican diversity within the freshwater leech genus Helobdella (Annelida: Glossiphoniidae). Mitochondrial DNA 21:24-29.
43. O'Meara, B. C. 2010. New heuristic methods for joint species delimitation and species tree inference. Systematic Biology 59:59-73.
44. Pilgrim, E. M., S. A. Jackson, S. Swenson, I. Turcsanyi, E. Friedman, L. Weigt, and M. J. Bagley. 2011. Incorporation of DNA barcoding into a large-scale biomonitoring program: opportunities and pitfalls. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 30:217-231.
45. Pons, J., T. G. Barraclough, J. Gomez-Zurita, A. Cardoso, D. P. Duran, S. Hazell, and A. P. Vogler. 2006. Sequence-based species delimitation for the DNA taxonomy of undescribed insects. Systematic Biology 55:595-609.
46. Posada, D. 2008. jModelTest: phylogenetic model averaging. Molecular Biology and Evolution 25:1253-1256. (Pubitemid 351882013)
47. Ratnasingham, S., and P. D. Hebert. 2007. BOLD: The Barcode of Life Data System (http://www.barcodinglife.org). Molecular Ecology Notes 7:355-364. (Pubitemid 46714172)
48. Rivera, J., and D. C. Currie. 2009. Identification of Nearctic black flies using DNA barcodes (Diptera: Simuliidae). Molecular Ecology Resources 9:224-236.
49. Rodrigo, A., F. Bertels, J. Heled, R. Noder, H. Shearman, and P. Tsai. 2008. The perils of plenty: what are we going to do with all these genes Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B: Biological Sciences 363:3893-3902.
50. Rosenberg, N. A. 2007. Statistical tests for taxonomic distinctiveness from observations of monophyly. Evolution 61:317-323. (Pubitemid 46411604)
51. Saitou, N., and Nei M. 1987. The neighbor-joining method: a new method for reconstructing phylogenetic trees. Molecular Biology and Evolution 4:406-425.
52. Shendure, J., and H. Ji. 2008. Next-generation DNA sequencing. Nature Biotechnology 26:1135-1145.
53. Srivathsan, A., and R. Meier. 2011. On the inappropriate use of Kimura-2-parameter (K2P) divergences in the DNA-barcoding literature. Cladistics 28:190-194.
54. Stein, E. D., B. P. White, R. D. Mazor, J. K. Jackson, J. M. Battle, P. E. Miller, E. M. Pilgrim, and B. W. Sweeney. 2014. Does DNA barcoding improve performance of traditional stream bioassessment metrics Freshwater Science 33:302-311.
55. Stein, E. D., B. P. White, R. D. Mazor, P. E. Miller, and E. M. Pilgrim. 2013. Evaluating ethanol-based sample preservation to facilitate use of DNA barcoding in routine freshwater biomonitoring programs using benthic macroinvertebrates. PloS ONE 8:e51273.
56. Sweeney, B. W., J. M. Battle, J. K. Jackson, and T. Dapkey. 2011. Can DNA barcodes of stream macroinvertebrates improve descriptions of community structure and water quality Journal of the North American Benthological Society 30: 195-216.
57. Tamura, K., D. Peterson, N. Peterson, G. Stecher, M. Nei, and S. Kumar. 2011. MEGA5: Molecular Evolutionary Genetics Analysis using maximum likelihood, evolutionary distance, and maximum parsimony methods. Molecular Biology and Evolution 28:2731-2739.
58. Valentini, A., F. Pompanon, and P. Taberlet. 2009. DNA barcoding for ecologists. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 24: 110-117.
59. Vanoverbeke, J., and L. De Meester. 1997. Among-populational genetic differentiation in the cyclical parthenogen Daphnia magna (Crustacea, Anomopoda) and its relation to geographic distance and clonal diversity. Hydrobiologia 360: 135-142.
60. Verberk, W. C. E. P., C. G. E. van Noordwijk, and A. G. Hildrew. 2013. Delivering on a promise: integrating species traits to transform descriptive community ecology into a predictive science. Freshwater Science 32:531-547.
61. Vuataz, L., M. Sartori, J. L. Gattolliat, and M. T. Monaghan. 2012. Endemism and diversification in freshwater insects of Madagascar revealed by coalescent and phylogenetic analysis of museum and field collections. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 66:979-991.
62. Weitschek, E., R. Velzen, G. Felici, and P. Bertolazzi. 2013. BLOG 2.0: a software system for character-based species classification with DNA Barcode sequences. What it does, how to use it. Molecular Ecology Resources. doi:10.1111/1755-0998.12073
63. Yang, Z., and B. Rannala. 2010. Bayesian species delimitation using multilocus sequence data. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 107: 9264-9269.
64. Zaldívar-Riverón, A., J. J. Martínez, F. S. Ceccarelli, V. S. De Jesús-Bonilla, A. C. Rodríguez-Pérez, A. Reséndiz-Flores, and M. A. Smith. 2010. DNA barcoding a highly diverse group of parasitoid wasps (Braconidae: Doryctinae) from a Mexican nature reserve. Mitochondrial DNA 21:18-23.
65. Zhang, C., D. X. Zhang, T. Zhu, and Z. Yang. 2011. Evaluation of a Bayesian coalescent method of species delimitation. Systematic Biology 60:747-761.
66. Zhou, X., S. J. Adamowicz, L. M. Jacobus, E. DeWalt, and P. D. N. Hebert. 2009. Toward a comprehensive barcode library for Arctic life-Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera, and Trichoptera of Churchill, Manitoba, Canada. Frontiers in Zoology 6:30.
67. Zhou, X., J. L. Robinson, C. J. Geraci, C. R. Parker, O. S. Flint, D. Etnier, D. Ruiter, R. E. DeWalt, L. M. Jacobus, and P. D. N. Hebert. 2011. Accelerated construction of a regional DNA barcode reference library: caddisflies (Trichoptera) in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Journal of the North American Benthological Society 30:131-162.