Reliability and Cost of GMO Detection

Genetically Modified and Non-Genetically Modified Food Supply Chains: Co-Existence and Traceability

Volumn , Issue , 2012, Pages 307-332

  Gruden, K ^b   Allnutt, T R ^c   Ayadi, M ^a   Baeumler, S ^a   Bahrdt, C ^d   Berben, G ^e   Berdal, K G ^f   Bertheau, Y ^a   Boydler Andersen C ^f   Brodmann, P ^g   Buh Gasparic M ^b   Burns, M J ^h   Burrel, A M ^h   Cankar, K ^b   Esteve, T ^i,j   Holst Jensen, A ^f   Kristoffersen, A B ^f   La Paz, J ^f   Lee, D ^k   Lovseth A ^f   Macarthur, R ^c   Morisset, D ^b   Pla, M ^i,l   Rud, R B ^f   Skjoeret C ^f   Tengs, T ^f   Valdivia, H ^h   Wulff, D ^d   Zhang, D ^m   Zel J ^b   more..

^a CEMAGREF   (France)

^b NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF BIOLOGY   (Slovenia)

^c FOOD AND ENVIRONMENT RESEARCH AGENCY   (United Kingdom)

^d Eurofins Medinet Inc   (Germany)

^e WALLOON AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH CENTRE   (Belgium)

^f NORWEGIAN VETERINARY INSTITUTE   (Norway)

^g Biolytix   (Switzerland)

^h LGC   (United Kingdom)

ⁱ CENTRE FOR RESEARCH IN AGRICULTURAL GENOMICS CRAG   (Spain)

^j INSTITUT DE BIOLOGIA MOLECULAR DE BARCELONA   (Spain)

^k NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF AGRICULTURAL BOTANY   (United Kingdom)

^l UNIVERSITY OF GIRONA   (Spain)

^m Laboratoire BIOGEVES   (China)

more..

Author keywords

Alternative chemistries; Automation; Bias; Cost effectiveness; Detection; Digital PCR; Nanofluidic; Processed matrix; Quantification; Reliability; Robustness; Sensitivity

Indexed keywords

EID: 84887241398     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book    
DOI: 10.1002/9781118373781.ch18     Document Type: Chapter

References (89)

1. Andersen C.B., Holst-Jensen A., Berdal K.G., Thorstensen T. and Tengs T. 2006. Equal performance of TaqMan, MGB, molecular beacon, and SYBR green-based detection assays in detection and quantification of roundup ready soybean. J. Agric. Food Chem., 54: 9658-9663.
2. Anklam E., Gadani F., Heinze P., Pijnenburg H. and Van den Eede G. 2002. Analytical methods for detection and determination of genetically modified organisms in agricultural crops and plant-derived food products. Eur. Food Res. Technol., 214: 3-26.
3. Bauer T., Weller P., Hammes W.P. and Hertel C. 2003. The effect of processing parameters on DNA degradation in food. Eur. Food. Res. Technol., 217: 338-343.
4. Berdal K.G., Boydler C., Tengs T. and Holst-Jensen A. 2008. A statistical approach for evaluation of PCR results to improve the practical limit of quantification (LOQ) of GMO analyses (SIMQUANT). Eur. Food Res. Technol., 227 (4): 1149-1157.
5. Berdal K.G. and Holst-Jensen A. 2001. Roundup Ready soybean event-specific real-time quantitative PCR assay and estimation of the practical detection and quantification limits in GMO analyses. Eur. Food Res. Technol., 213: 432-438.
6. Bhat S., Herrmann J., Armishaw P., Corbisier P. and Emslie K.R. 2009. Single molecule detection in nanofluidic digital array enables accurate measurement of DNA copy number. Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 394: 457-467.
7. Brodmann P., Lee D. and Gruden K. 2009. Report on development of DNA extraction methods of selected highly refined materials. Deliverable 5.7 of Co-Extra project.
8. Brodmann P.D., Ilg E.C., Berthoud H. and Herrmann A. 2002. Real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction methods for four genetically modified maize varieties and maize DNA content in food. J. AOAC Intl., 85: 646-653.
9. Broothaerts W., Corbisier P., Schimmel H., Trapmann S., Vincent S. and Emons H. 2008. A Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP839) in the adh1 Reference Gene Affects the Quantitation of Genetically Modified Maize (Zea mays L.). J. Agric. Food Chem., 56: 8825-8831.
10. Buh Gasparic M., Cankar K., Zel J. and Gruden K. 2008. Comparison of different real-time PCR chemistries and their suitability for detection and quantification of genetically modified organisms. BMC Biotechnol., 8: 26 Meeting Abstract: 8 (March) 12pp. Available at: http://www. biomedcentral.com/content/pdf/1472-6750-8-26.pdf [accessed 1 May 2012].
11. Buh Gasparic M., Tengs T., La Paz J., Holst-Jensen A., Pla M., Esteve T., Zel J. and Gruden K. 2010. Comparison of nine different real-time PCR chemistries for qualitative and quantitative applications in GMO detection. Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 396: 2023-2029.
12. Burns M. and Valdivia H. 2008. Modelling the limit of detection in real-time quantitative PCR. Eur. Food Res. Technol., 226: 1513-1524.
13. Burns M.J., Burrell A.M. and Foy C. 2010. The applica-bility of digital PCR for the assessment of detection limits in GMO analysis. Eur. Food Res. Technol., 231: 353-362.
14. Burns M., Nixon G., Foy C. and Harris N. 2005. Standardisation of data from real-time quantitative PCR methods-evaluation of outliers and comparison of calibration curves. BMC Biotechnol., 5: 31 Available at: http://www. biomedcentral.com/content/pdf/1472-6750-5-31.pdf [accessed 1 May 2012].
15. Busconi M., Foroni C., Corradi M., Bongiorni C., Cattapan F. and Fogher C. 2003. DNA extraction from olive oil and its use in the identification of the production cultivar. Food Chem., 83: 127-134.
16. Cankar K., Stebih D., Dreo T., Zel J. and Gruden K. 2006. Critical points of DNA quantification by real-time PCR-effects of DNA extraction method and sample matrix on quantification of genetically modified organisms. BMC Biotechnol., 6: 37.
17. Charels D., Broeders S., Corbisier P., Trapmann S., Schimmel H., Linsinger T. and Emons H. 2007. Toward Metrological Traceability for DNA Fragment Ratios in GM Quantification. 2. Systematic Study of Parameters Influencing the Quantitative Determination of MON 810 Corn by Real-Time PCR. J. Agric. Food Chem., 55: 3258-3267.
18. CODEX. 2001. Ad Hoc Intergovernmental Task Force on Foods Derived from Biotechnology. 2001. Annex 1: List of methods validated by interlaboratory studies.
19. Corbisier P., Broothaerts W., Gioria S., Schimmel H., Burns M., Baoutina A., Emslie K.R., Furui S., Kurosawa Y., Holden M.J., Kim H.H., Lee Y., Kawaharasaki M., Sin D. and Wang J. 2007. Toward Metrological Traceability for DNA Fragment Ratios in GM Quantification. 1. Effect of DNA Extraction Methods on the Quantitative Determination of Bt176 Corn by Real-Time PCR. J. Agric. Food Chem., 55: 3249-3257.
20. Corbisier P., Trapmann S., Gancberg D., Hannes L., Van Iwaarden P., Berben G., Schimmel H. and Emons H. 2005. Quantitative determination of Roundup Ready soybean (Glycine max) extracted from highly processed flour. Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 383: 282-290.
21. Corbisier P., Bhat S., Partis, L., Rui Dan Xie V. and Emslie K. 2010. Absolute quantification of genetically modified MON810 maize (Zea mays L.) by digital polymerase chain reaction. Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 396: 2143-2150.
22. Costa J.M., Ernault P., Olivi M., Gaillon T. and Arar K. 2004. Chimeric LNA/DNA probes as a detection system for real-time PCR. Clin. Biochem., 37: 930-932.
23. CRL-GMFF. 2008. Definition of minimum Performance requirements for analytical methods of GMO testing. Available at: http://gmo-crl.jrc.ec.europa.eu/doc/Min_Perf_ Requirements_Analytical_methods.pdf [accessed 1 May 2012].
24. CRL-GMFF. 2010. Status of dossiers. Available at: http://gmo-crl.jrc.ec.europa.eu/statusofdoss.htm [accessed 1 May 2012].
25. Davison J. and Bertheau Y. 2007. EU regulations on the traceability and detection of GMOs: difficulties in interpretation, implementation and compliance. CAB Reviews: Perspectives in Agriculture, Veterinary Science, Nutrition and Natural Resources. 77. pp. 14.
26. Debode F., Janssen E. and Berben G. 2007. Physical degradation of genomic DNA of soybean flours does not impair relative quantification of its transgenic content. Eur. Food Res. Technol., 226: 273-280.
27. Dong W., Yang L., Shen K., Kim B., Kleter G.A., Marvin H.J., Guo R., Liang W. and Zhang D. 2008. GMDD: a database of GMO detection methods. BMC Bioinformatics, 9: 260.
28. Draft International Harmonisation of Pharmacopoeias. 1993. Text in validation of analytical procedure. Pharmeuropa. 5: 341.
29. Duck P., Varado-Urbina G., Burdick B. and Collier B. 1990. Probe amplifier system based on chimeric cycling oligonucleotides. Biotechniques, 9: 142-148.
30. Engel K.H., Moreano F., Ehlert A. and Busch U. 2006. Quantification of DNA from genetically modified organisms in composite and processed foods. Trends Food Sci. Tech., 17: 490-497.
31. European Commission. 2003a. Regulation (EC) No 1829/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22 September 2003 on genetically modified food and feed. Official Journal of the European Union, L 268: 1-23.
32. European Commission. 2003b. Regulation (EC) No 1830/2003 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 22 September 2003 concerning the traceability and labelling of genetically modified organisms and the traceability of food and feed products produced from genetically modified organisms and amending Directive 2001/18/EC. Official Journal of the European Union, L 268: 24-28.
33. Fluidigm Corporation. 2010a. BioMark Digital PCR Analysis Software User Guide. Available at: http://www.fluidigm.com [accessed 1 May 2012].
34. Fluidigm Corporation. 2010b. BioMark Advanced Development Protocol 10. Absolute quantification using Digital Array. Available at: http://www.fluidigm.com [accessed 1 May 2012].
35. Fluidigm Corporation. 2010c. BioMark Advanced Development Protocol 9. Calculating Copy Number Using a 12.765 Digital Array. Available at: http://www.fluidigm.com [accessed 1 May 2012].
36. Giglio S., Monis P.T. and Saint C.P. 2003. Demonstration of preferential binding of SYBR Green I to specific DNA fragments in real-time multiplex PCR. Nucleic Acids Res., 31: e136.
37. Greenspoon S.A., Sykes K.L.V., Ban J.D., Pollard A., Baisden M., Farr M., Graham N., Collins B.L., Green M.M. and Christenson C.C. 2006. Automated PCR setup for forensic casework samples using the Normalization Wizard and PCR Setup robotic methods. Forensic Sci. Int., 164: 240-248.
38. Gruden K., Buh G.M., Boydler C., Holst-Jensen A., Tengs T., Ayadi M., Kobilinsky A., Bertheau Y., Laval V., Allnutt T.R., Pla M., La Paz J.L., Esteve T., Brodmann P., Lee D., Janssen E., Debode F. and Berben G. 2009a. Evaluation of different chemistries and apparatus of real-time quantitative PCR in view of different applications. Deliverable 5.9 of Co-Extra project.
39. Gruden K., Stebih D., Demsar T., Zel J., Wulff D. and Baeumler S. 2009b. Automatisation in GMO detection. Deliverable 5.12 of Co-Extra project.
40. Gruere G.P. and Rao S.R. 2007. A review of international labeling policies of genetically modified food to evaluate India's proposed rule. AgBioForum, 10: 51-64.
41. Hernandez M., Esteve T., Prat S. and Pla M. 2004. Development of real-time PCR systems based on SYBR Green I, Amplifluor and TaqMan technologies for specific quantitative detection of the transgenic maize event GA21. J. Cereal Sci., 39: 99-107.
42. Hernandez M., Pla M., Esteve T., Prat S., Puigdomenech P. and Ferrando A. 2003. A specific real-time quantitative PCR detection system for event MON810 in maize YieldGard based on the 3'-transgene integration sequence. Transgenic Res., 12: 179-189.
43. Higuchi R., Fockler C., Dollinger G. and Watson R. 1993. Kinetic PCR Analysis: Real-time Monitoring of DNA Amplification Reactions. Nat Biotech., 11: 1026-1030.
44. Holland P.M., Abramson R.D., Watson R. and Gelfand D.H. 1991. Detection of specific polymerase chain reaction product by utilizing the 5'-3' exonuclease activity of Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 88: 7276-7280.
45. Holst-Jensen A. and Berdal K.G. 2004. The modular analytical procedure and validation approach and the units of measurement for genetically modified materials in foods and feeds. J. AOAC Intl., 87: 927-936.
46. Holst-Jensen A., Ronning S.B., Lovseth A. and Berdal K.G. 2003. PCR technology for screening and quantification of genetically modified organisms (GMOs). Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 375: 985-993.
47. International Organization for Standardization. 2006. ISO 24276: 2006. Foodstuffs-Methods of analysis for the detection of genetically modified organisms and derived products -General requirements and definitions. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland.
48. James C. 2008. Global status of commercialized biotech/GM crops 2008. ISAAA brief 39.
49. Karsai A., Muller S., Platz S. and Hauser M.T. 2002. Evaluation of a homemade SYBR Green I reaction mixture for real-time PCR quantification of gene expression. Biotechniques, 32: 790-796.
50. Koshkin A.A., Singh S.K., Nielsen P., Rajwanshi V.K., Kumar R., Meldgaard M., Olsen C.E. and Wengel J. 1998. LNA (Locked Nucleic Acids): Synthesis of the adenine, cytosine, guanine, 5-methylcytosine, thymine and uracil bicyclonucleoside monomers, oligomerisation, and un precedented nucleic acid recognition. Tetrahedron., 54: 3607-3630.
51. Kutyavin I.V., Afonina I.A., Mills A., Gorn V.V., Lukhtanov E.A., Belousov E.S., Singer M.J., Walburger D.K., Lokhov S.G., Gall A.A., Dempcy R., Reed M.W., Meyer R.B. and Hedgpeth J. 2000. 3'-minor groove binder-DNA probes increase sequence specificity at PCR extension temperatures. Nucleic Acids Res., 28: 655-661.
52. Lalam N., Jacob C. and Jagers P. 2005. Estimation of the PCR efficiency based on a size-dependent modelling of the amplification process. Comptes Rendus Mathematiques, 341: 631-634.
53. Lalam N. 2007. Statistical inference for quantitative polymerase chain reaction using a hidden Markov model: a Bayesian approach. Stat. Appl. Genet. Mol. B., 6: Article 10.
54. La Paz J.L., Esteve, T. and Pla M. 2007. Comparison of real-time PCR detection chemistries and cycling modes using Mon810 event-specific assays as model. J. Agric. Food Chem., 55: 4312-4318.
55. Lee D., La Mura M., Greenland A. and Mackay I. 2010. Quantitation using informative zeros (QUIZ): application for GMO detection and quantification without recourse to certified reference material. Food Chem., 118: 974-978.
56. Macarthur R., Feinberg M. and Bertheau Y. 2010. Construction of measurement uncertainty profiles for quantitative analysis of genetically modified organisms based on interlaboratory validation data. J. AOAC Intl., 93 (3): 1046-1056.
57. Mitchell D.L., Jen J. and Cleaver J.E. 1992. Sequence specificity of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers in DNA treated with solar (ultraviolet B) radiation. Nucleic Acids Res., 20: 225-229.
58. Moreano F., Busch U. and Engel K.H. 2005. Distortion of genetically modified organism quantification in processed foods: influence of particle size compositions and heat-induced DNA degradation. J. Agric. Food Chem., 53: 9971-9979.
59. Morisset D., Demsar T., Gruden K., Vojvoda J., Stebih D. and Zel J. 2009. Detection of genetically modified organisms-closing the gaps. Nat. Biotechnol., 27: 700-701.
60. Mulhardt C. 2002. Der Experimentator: Molekularbiologie/Genomics. Spektrum, Akademischer Verlag, Heidelberg.
61. Nazarenko I., Pires R., Lowe B., Obaidy M. and Rashtchian A. 2002. Effect of primary and secondary structure of oligodeoxyribonucleotides on the fluorescent properties of conjugated dyes. Nucleic Acids Res., 30: 2089-2195.
62. Nazarenko I.A., Bhatnagar S.K. and Hohman R.J. 1997. A closed tube format for amplification and detection of DNA based on energy transfer. Nucleic Acids Res., 25: 2516-2521.
63. Oblinger J.L. and Koburger J.A. 1975. Understanding and teaching Most Probable Number technique. J. Milk Food Technol., 38: 540-545.
64. Peano C., Samson M.C., Palmieri L., Gulli M. and Marmiroli N. 2004. Qualitative and quantitative evaluation of the genomic DNA extracted from GMO and non-GMO foodstuffs with four different extraction methods. J. Agric. Food Chem., 52: 6962-6968.
65. Peccoud J. and Jacob C. 1996. Theoretical uncertainty of measurements using quantitative polymerase chain reaction. Biophys. J., 71: 101-108.
66. PfafflM.W. 2010. Gene-Quantification-The reference in QRT-PCR-Academic & Industrial Information Platform. Available at: http://gene-quantification.info [accessed 1 May 2012].
67. Ririe K.M., Rasmussen R.P. and Wittwer C.T. 1997. Product differentiation by analysis of DNA melting curves during the polymerase chain reaction. Anal. Biochem., 245: 154-160.
68. Santangelo P., Nitin N. and Bao G. 2006. Nanostructured probes for RNA detection in living cells. Ann. Biomed. Eng., 34: 39-50.
69. Saunders G.C. and Parkers H.C. 1999 Analytical Molecular Biology-Quality and Validation. The Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK.
70. Schneeberger C., Speiser P., Kury F. and Zeillinger R. 1995. Quantitative detection of reverse Transcriptase-PCR products by means of a novel and sensitive DNA stain. PCR Meth. Appl., 4: 234-238.
71. Schwenzer R., Schöneberg A. and Pflug W. 2008. Implementation of a robotized real-time PCR setup for the use of the Quantifiler Human DNA quantification kit. Forensic Sci. Int.-Gen. Supplement Series, 1: 68-70.
72. Sherrill C.B., Marshall D.J., Moser M.J., Larsen C.A., Daude-Snow L., Jurczyk S., Shapiro G. and Prudent J.R. 2004. Nucleic acid analysis using an expanded genetic alphabet to quench fluorescence. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 126: 4550-4556.
73. Skjaeret C., Holst-Jensen A. and Berdal K.G. 2009. Multiplexing of SIMQUANT. Available at: http://www.coextra.eu/conference/files/CoExtra_programme_abstracts.pdf [accessed 1 May 2012].
74. Smith K., Diggle M.A. and Clarke S.C. 2004. Automation of a fluorescence-based multiplex PCR for the laboratory confirmation of common bacterial pathogens. J. Med. Microbiol., 53: 115-117.
75. Spurgeon S.L., Jones R.C. and Ramakrishnan R. 2008. High throughput gene expression measurement with real time PCR in a microfluidic dynamic array. PLoS ONE, 3: e1662.
76. Swiss Food Manual. 2001. Eidgenössische Drucksachen-und Materialzentrale. Bern, Switzerland.
77. Terry C.F., Shanahan D.J., Ballam L.D., Harris N., McDowell D.G. and Parkes H.C. 2002. Real-time detection of genetically modified soya using Lightcycler and ABI 7700 platforms with TaqMan, Scorpion, and SYBR® Green I chemistries. J. AOAC Intl., 85: 938-944.
78. Trapmann S., Schimmel H., Kramer G.N., van den Eede G. and Pauwels J. 2002. Production of certified reference materials for the detection of genetically modified organisms. J. AOAC Intl., 85: 775-779.
79. Tyagi S. and Kramer F.R. 1996. Molecular beacons: probes that fluoresce upon hybridization. Nat. Biotechnol., 14: 303-308.
80. United States Department of Agriculture. 2008. Audit report -United States Department of Agriculture controls over importation of transgenic plants and animals. 50601-17-Te.
81. Van den Eede G., Kay S., Anklam E. and Schimmel H. 2002. Analytical challenges: bridging the gap from regulation to enforcement. J. AOAC Intl., 85: 757-761.
82. Van P.J. and Wakelyn P.J. 1997. Technology and Solvents for Extracting Oilseeds and Nonpetroleum Oils. The American Oil Chemists Society, Urbana, IL.
83. Waiblinger H.U., Grohmann L., Mankertz J., Engelbert D. and Pietsch K. 2009. A practical approach to screen for authorised and unauthorised genetically modified plants. Anal. Bioanal. Chem., 396: 2065-2072.
84. Wang X.P. and Ginocchio C.C. 2009. Automation of the BD GeneOhm methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus assay for high-throughput screening of nasal swab specimens. J. Clin. Microbiol., 47: 1546-1548.
85. Yoshimura T., Kuribara H., Matsuoka T., Kodama T., Iida M., Watanabe T., Akiyama H., Maitani T., Furui S. and Hino A. 2005a. Applicability of the quantification of genetically modified organisms to foods processed from maize and soy. J. Agric. Food Chem., 53: 2052-2059.
86. Yoshimura T., Kuribara H., Kodama T., Yamata S., Futo S., Watanabe S., Aoki N., Iizuka T., Akiyama H., Maitani T., Naito S. and Hino A. 2005b. Comparative Studies of the Quantification of Genetically Modified Organisms in Foods Processed from Maize and Soy Using Trial Producing. J. Agric. Food Chem., 53: 2060-2069.
87. Žel J., Gruden K., Cankar K., Stebih D. and Blejec A. 2007. Calculation of measurement uncertainty in quantitative analysis of genetically modified organisms using intermediate precision-a practical approach. J. AOAC Intl., 90: 582-586.
88. Zhang D., Corlet A., Fouilloux S., Bertheau Y., Laval V., Couture C., Kobilinsky A., Ancel V., Baeumler S., Cankar K. and Gruden K. 2008. Practical ways to increase accuracy of quantitative PCR methods including the system for evaluation of DNA quality in terms of PCR amplificability for quantitative purposes from different matrixes. Deliverable 5.3 of Co-Extra project.
89. Zipper H., Brunner H., Bernhagen J. and Vitzthum, F. 2004. Investigations on DNA intercalation and surface binding by SYBR Green I, its structure determination and methodological implications. Nucleic Acids Res., 32: e103.