When overconfidence is revealed to others: Testing the status-enhancement theory of overconfidence

Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes

Volumn 122, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 266-279

  Kennedy, Jessica A ^a   Anderson, Cameron ^b   Moore, Don A ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

Author keywords

Better than average; Overconfidence; Self enhancement; Self perception; Status

Indexed keywords

EID: 84884752230     PISSN: 07495978     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.obhdp.2013.08.005     Document Type: Article

References (144)

1. Alexander R.D. The biology of moral systems 1987, Aldine de Gruyter, Hawthorne, NY.
2. Alicke M.D. Global self-evaluation as determined by the desirability and controllability of trait adjectives. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1985, 49:1621-1630.
3. Alicke M.D., Govorun O. The better-than-average effect. The self in social judgment 2005, 85-106. Psychology Press, New York, NY. M.D. Alicke, D. Dunning, J. Krueger (Eds.).
4. Anderson C., Ames D.R., Gosling S.D. Punishing hubris: The perils of overestimating one's status in a group. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2008, 34:90-101.
5. Anderson C., Brion S., Moore D.A., Kennedy J.A. A status-enhancement account of overconfidence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2012, 103:718-735.
6. Anderson C.A., John O.P., Keltner D., Kring A.M. Who attains social status? Effects of personality and physical attractiveness in social groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2001, 81:116-132.
7. Anderson C., Kilduff G.J. Why do dominant personalities attain influence in face-to-face groups? The competence-signaling effects of trait dominance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2009, 96:491-503.
8. Anderson C., Srivastava S., Beer J., Spataro S.E., Chatman J.A. Knowing your place: Self-perceptions of status in social groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2006, 91:1094-1110.
9. Armor D.A., Massey C., Sackett A.M. Prescribed optimism: Is it right to be wrong about the future?. Psychological Science 2008, 19:329-331.
10. Bales R.F., Strodtbeck F.L., Mills T.M., Roseborough M.E. Channels of communication in small groups. American Sociological Review 1951, 16:461-468.
11. Barber B.M., Odean T. Trading is hazardous to your wealth: The common stock investment performance of individual investors. Journal of Finance 2000, 55:773-806.
12. Barkow J.H. Prestige and culture: A biosocial interpretation. Current Anthropology 1975, 16:553-572.
13. Bass, B. M. (with Bass, R.) (2008). The Bass handbook of leadership (4th ed.). New York, NY: Free Press.
14. Benassi M.A. Effects of order of presentation, primacy, and physical attractiveness on attributions of ability. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1982, 43:48-58.
15. Berger J., Cohen B.P., Zelditch M. Status characteristics and social interaction. American Sociological Review 1972, 37:241-255.
16. Berger J., Webster M., Ridgeway C., Rosenholtz S.J. Status cues, expectations, and behaviors. Advances in group processes 1986, Vol. 3:1-22. JAI, Greenwich, CT.
17. Blau P.M. Exchange and power in social life 1964, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
18. Bonner B.L., Sillito S.D., Baumann M.R. Collective estimation: Accuracy, expertise, and extroversion as sources of intra-group influence. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2007, 103:121-133.
19. Breland H.M., Jones R.J. Perceptions of writing skills. Written Communication 1984, 1:101-119.
20. Brinol P., Petty R.E. Overt head movements and persuasion: A self-validation analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2003, 84:1123-1139.
21. Brooks A.W., Schweitzer M.E. Can Nervous Nelly negotiate? How anxiety causes negotiators to make low first offers, exit early, and earn less profit. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2001, 115:43-54.
22. Buhrmester M., Kwang T., Gosling S.D. Amazon's Mechanical Turk: A new source of inexpensive, yet high-quality, data?. Perspectives on Psychological Science 2011, 6:3-5.
23. Camerer C.F., Lovallo D. Overconfidence and excess entry: An experimental approach. American Economic Review 1999, 89:306-318.
24. Campbell W.K., Goodie A.S., Foster J.D. Narcissism, confidence, and risk attitude. Journal of Behavioral Decision-Making 2004, 17:297-311.
25. Carli L.L., LaFleur S.J., Loeber C.C. Nonverbal behavior, gender, and influence. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1995, 68:1030-1041.
26. Cohen J., Cohen P., West S.G., Aiken L.S. Applied multiple regression/correlation analysis for the behavioral sciences 2003, Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. 3rd ed.
27. College Board (1976-1977). Student descriptive questionnaire. Princeton, NJ: Educational Testing Service.
28. Cronbach L.J., Furby L. How should we measure "change": Or should we?. Psychological Bulletin 1970, 74:68-80.
29. Cross P. Not can but will college teaching be improved?. New Directions for Higher Education 1977, 17:1-15.
30. De Cremer D., van Knippenberg D. Leader self-sacrifice and leadership effectiveness: The moderating role of leader self-confidence. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2004, 95:140-155.
31. DePaulo B.M., Lindsay J.J., Malone B.E., Muhlenbruch L., Charlton K., Cooper H. Cues to deception. Psychological Bulletin 2003, 129:74-118.
32. Driskell J.E., Mullen B. Status, expectations, and behavior: A meta-analytic review and test of the theory. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 1990, 16:541-553.
33. Dunning D., Heath C., Suls J.M. Flawed self-assessment: Implications for health, education, and the workplace. Psychological Science in the Public Interest 2004, 5:69-106.
34. Dunning D., Leuenberger A., Sherman D.A. A new look at motivated inference: Are self-serving theories of success a product of motivational forces?. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1995, 69:58-68.
35. Dunning D., Meyerowitz J.A., Holzberg A.D. Ambiguity and self-evaluation: The role of idiosyncratic trait definitions in self-serving assessments of ability. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1989, 57:1082-1090.
36. Edwards J.R. Regression analysis as an alternative to difference scores. Journal of Management 1994, 20:683-689.
37. Edwards J.R. The study of congruence in organizational behavior research: Critique and a proposed alternative. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 1994, 58:51-100.
38. Edwards J.R., Parry M.E. On the use of polynomial regression equations as an alternative to difference scores in organizational research. Academy of Management Journal 1993, 36:1577-1613.
39. Ehrlinger J., Dunning D. How chronic self-views influence (and potentially mislead) estimates of performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2003, 84:5-17.
40. Ehrlinger J., Johnson K., Banner M., Dunning D., Kruger J. Why the unskilled are unaware: Further explorations of (absent) self-insight among the incompetent. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2008, 105:98-121.
41. Eibl-Eibesfeldt I. Human ethology 1989, Aldine de Gruyter Press, New York, NY.
42. Emerson R.M. Power dependence relations. American Sociological Review 1962, 27:31-41.
43. Flynn F.J., Reagans R.E., Amanatullah E.T., Ames D.R. Helping one's way to the top: Self-monitors achieve status by helping others and knowing who helps whom. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2006, 91:1123-1137.
44. Fragale A. The power of powerless speech: The effects of speech style and task interdependence on status conferral. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2006, 101:243-261.
45. Gigerenzer G., Hoffrage U., Kleinbölting H. Probabilistic mental models: A Brunswikian theory of confidence. Psychological Review 1991, 98:506-528.
46. Glass C.R., Merluzzi T.V., Biever J.L., Larsen K.H. Cognitive assessment of social anxiety: Development and validation of a self-statement questionnaire. Cognitive Therapy and Research 1982, 6:37-55.
47. Goldhamer H., Shils E.A. Types of power and status. American Journal of Sociology 1939, 45:171-182.
48. Gray-Little B., Burks N. Power and satisfaction in marriage: A review and critique. Psychological Bulletin 1983, 93:513-538.
49. Hall J.A. Gender, gender roles, and nonverbal communication skills. Skill in nonverbal communication 1979, 32-67. Oelgeschlager, Gunn, & Hain, Cambridge, MA. R. Rosenthal (Ed.).
50. Harrison D.A., Price K.H., Gavin J.H., Florey A.T. Time, teams, and task performance: Changing effects of surface- and deep-level diversity on group functioning. Academy of Management Review 2002, 45:1029-1045.
51. Haun D.E., Zeringue A., Leach A., Foley A. Assessing the competence of specimen-processing personnel. Laboratory Medicine 2000, 31:633-637.
52. Hayward M.L.A., Hambrick D.C. Explaining the premiums paid for large acquisitions: Evidence of CEO hubris. Administrative Science Quarterly 1997, 42:103-127.
53. Hoelzl E., Rustichini A. Overconfident: Do you put your money on it?. Economic Journal 2005, 115:305-318.
54. Johnson D.D.P. Overconfidence and war: The havoc and glory of positive illusions 2004, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
55. Johnson D.D.P., Fowler J.H. The evolution of overconfidence. Nature 2011, 477(7364):317-320.
56. Jones E.E., Rock L., Shaver K.G., Goethals G.R., Ward L.M. Pattern of performance and ability attribution: An unexpected primacy effect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1968, 10:317-340.
57. Jost J.T., Banaji M.R. The role of stereotyping in system-justification and the production of false consciousness. British Journal of Social Psychology 1994, 33:1-27.
58. Kaiser R.B., Hogan R., Craig S.B. Leadership and the fate of organizations. American Psychologist 2008, 63:96-110.
59. Kenny D.A. A general model of consensus and accuracy in interpersonal perception. Psychological Review 1991, 98:155-163.
60. Kenny D.A. SOREMO: A FORTRAN program for round robin data structures 1998, Author, Storrs, CT.
61. Kenny D.A., La Voie L. The social relations model. Advances in experimental social psychology 1984, Vol. 18:142-182. Academic, Orlando.
62. Klein W.M., Kunda Z. Exaggerated self-assessments and the preference for controllable risks. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 1994, 59:410-427.
63. Krebs D.L., Denton K. Social illusions and self-deception: The evolution of biases in person perception. Evolutionary social psychology 1997, Lawrence Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. J.A. Simpson, D.T. Kenrick (Eds.).
64. Krueger J.I., Mueller R.A. Unskilled, unaware, or both? The better-than-average heuristic and statistical regression predict errors in estimates of own performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2002, 82:180-188.
65. Kruger J. Lake Wobegon be gone! The "below-average effect" and the egocentric nature of comparative ability judgments. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1999, 77:221-232.
66. Kruger J., Dunning D. Unskilled and unaware of it: How difficulties in recognizing one's own incompetence lead to inflated self-assessments. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1999, 77:1121-1134.
67. Kunda Z. Motivated inference: Self-serving generation and evaluation of causal theories. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1987, 53:636-647.
68. Larrick R.P., Burson K.A., Soll J.B. Social comparison and confidence: When thinking you're better than average predicts overconfidence (and when it does not). Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2007, 102:76-94.
69. Laughlin P.R., Ellis A.L. Demonstrability and social combination processes on mathematical intellective tasks. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 1986, 22:177-189.
70. Laughlin P.R. Social combination processes of cooperative problem-solving groups on verbal intellective tasks. Progress in social psychology 1980, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. M. Fishbein (Ed.).
71. Leary M.R. Motivational and emotional aspects of the self. Annual Review of Psychology 2007, 58:317-344.
72. Lee M.T., Ofshe R. The impact of behavioral style and status characteristics on social influence: A test of two competing theories. Social Psychology Quarterly 1981, 44:73-82.
73. Lewinsohn P.M., Mischel W., Chaplin W., Barton R. Social competence and depression: The role of illusory self-perceptions. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 1980, 89:203-212.
74. Littlepage G.E., Morris L.W., Poole J.R. Components of state anxiety as mediators of social interference in a coaction situation. Journal of Social Behavior and Personality 1991, 6:377-386.
75. Littlepage G.E., Mueller A.L. Recognition and utilization of expertise in problem-solving groups: Expert characteristics and behavior. Group Dynamics: Theory, Research, and Practice 1997, 1:324-328.
76. Littlepage G., Robison W., Reddington K. Effects of task experience and group experience on group performance, member ability, and recognition of expertise. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 1997, 69:133-147.
77. Littlepage G.E., Schmidt G.W., Whisler E.W., Frost A.G. An input-process-output analysis of influence and performance in problem-solving groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1995, 69:877-889.
78. Lord R.G. Social information processing and behavioral measurement: Application to leadership measurement. Research in Organizational Behavior 1985, Vol. 7:87-128. JAI Press, Greenwich, CT.
79. Lord R.G., de Vader C.L., Alliger G.M. A meta-analysis of the relation between personality traits and leadership perceptions: An application of validity generalization procedures. Journal of Applied Psychology 1986, 71:402-410.
80. Malmendier U., Tate G. CEO overconfidence and corporate investment. Journal of Finance 2005, 60:2661-2700.
81. Mann R.D. A review of the relationships between personality and performance in small groups. Psychological Bulletin 1959, 56:241-270.
82. Marshall M.A., Brown J.D. On the psychological benefits of self-enhancement. Self-criticism and self-enhancement: Theory, research, and clinical implications 2008, 19-35. American Psychological Association, Washington, DC.
83. Maslow A.H. A theory of human motivation. Psychological Review 1943, 50:370-396.
84. Mazur A. A biosocial model of status in face-to-face primate groups. Social Forces 1985, 64:377-402.
85. McAndrew F.T. Pattern of performance and attributions of ability and gender. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 1981, 7:583-587.
86. McGraw A.P., Mellers B.A., Ritov I. The affective costs of overconfidence. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 2004, 17:281-295.
87. McNulty S.E., Swann W.B. Identity negotiation in roommate relationships: The self as architect and consequence of social reality. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1994, 67:1012-1023.
88. Merton R.K. The Matthew effect in science. Science 1968, 159:56-63.
89. Metcalfe J. Cognitive optimism: Self-deception or memory-based processing heuristics?. Personality and Social Psychology Review 1998, 2:100-110.
90. Moore D.A. Not so above average after all: When people believe they are worse than average and its implications for theories of bias in social comparison. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2007, 102:42-58.
91. Moore D.A., Healy P.J. The trouble with overconfidence. Psychological Review 2008, 115:502-517.
92. Mullen B., Salas E., Driskell J.E. Salience, motivation, and artifact as contributions to the relation between participation rate and leadership. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 1989, 25:545-559.
93. Mussweiler T. Comparison processes in social judgment: Mechanisms and consequences. Psychological Review 2003, 110:472-489.
94. Neale M.A., Bazerman M.H. The effects of framing and negotiator overconfidence on bargaining behaviors and outcomes. Academy of Management Journal 1985, 28:34-49.
95. Odean T. Volume, volatility, price, and profit when all traders are above average. Journal of Finance 1998, 53:1887-1934.
96. Osborne J.W. Testing stereotype threat: Does anxiety explain ethnicity and sex differences in achievement?. Contemporary Educational Psychology 2001, 26:291-310.
97. Paese P.W., Kinnaly M. Peer input and revised judgment: Exploring the effects of unbiased confidence. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 1993, 23:1989-2011.
98. Pajares F. Self-efficacy beliefs in academic settings. Review of Educational Research 1996, 66:543-578.
99. Paulhus D.L. Interpersonal and intrapsychic adaptiveness of trait self-enhancement: A mixed blessing?. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1998, 74:1197-1208.
100. Paulhus D.L., Bruce M.N. The effect of acquaintanceship on the validity of personality impressions: A longitudinal study. Personality Processes and Individual Differences 1992, 63:816-824.
101. Peltokorpi V. Transactive memory systems. Review of General Psychology 2008, 12:378-394.
102. Plaks J.E., Stecher K. Unexpected improvement, decline, and stasis: A prediction confidence perspective on achievement success and failure. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2007, 93:667-684.
103. Preacher K.J., Hayes A.F. Asymptotic and resampling strategies for assessing and comparing indirect effects in multiple mediator models. Behavior Research Methods 2008, 40:879-891.
104. Radzevick J.R., Moore D.A. Competing to be certain (but wrong): Social pressure and overprecision in judgment. Management Science 2011, 57(1):93-106.
105. Ridgeway C.L. Conformity, group-oriented motivation, and status attainment in small groups. Social Psychology 1978, 41:175-188.
106. Ridgeway C.L. Nonconformity, competence, and influence in groups: A test of two theories. American Sociological Review 1981, 46:333-347.
107. Ridgeway C.L. Nonverbal behavior, dominance, and the basis of status in task groups. American Sociological Review 1987, 52:683-694.
108. Ridgeway C.L., Diekema D. Dominance and collective hierarchy formation in male and female task groups. American Sociological Review 1989, 54:79-93.
109. Riggio R.E. Assessment of basic social skills. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1986, 51:649-660.
110. Rudman L.A., Fairchild K. Reactions to counterstereotypic behavior: The role of backlash in cultural stereotype maintenance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2004, 87:157-176.
111. Rudman L.A., Glick P. Feminized management and backlash toward agentic women: The hidden costs to women of a kinder, gentler image of middle managers. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1999, 77:1004-1010.
112. Sah S., Moore D.A., MacCoun R.J. Cheap talk and credibility: The consequences of confidence and accuracy on advisor credibility and persuasiveness. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2013, 121:246-255.
113. Scherer K.R., London H., Wolf J.J. The voice of confidence: Paralinguistic cues and audience evaluation. Journal of Research in Personality 1973, 7:31-44.
114. Sedikides C., Gregg A.P. Self-enhancement: Food for thought. Perspectives on Psychological Science 2008, 3:102-116.
115. Shreve E.G., Harrigan J.A., Kues J.R., Kagas D.K. Nonverbal expressions of anxiety in physician-patient interactions. Psychiatry 1988, 51:378-384.
116. Sniezek J.A., Van Swol L.M. Trust, confidence, and expertise in a judge-advisor system. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 2001, 84:288-307.
117. Sorrentino R.M., Boutillier R.G. The effect of quantity and quality of verbal interaction on ratings of leadership ability. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 1975, 11:405-411.
118. Sorrentino R.M., Field N. Emergent leadership over time: The functional value of positive motivation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1986, 50:1091-1099.
119. Stasser G., Dietz-Uhler B. Collective choice, judgment, and problem-solving. Blackwell handbook of social psychology 2001, Vol. 4:31-55. Blackwell, Oxford, England.
120. Steele C.M. A threat in the air. How stereotypes shape intellectual identity and performance. American Psychologist 1997, 52:613-629.
121. Steiner D.D., Rain J.S. Immediate and delayed primacy and recency effects in performance evaluation. Journal of Applied Psychology 1989, 74:136-142.
122. Stogdill R.M. Personal factors associated with leadership: A survey of the literature. Journal of Psychology 1948, 25:35-71.
123. Svenson O. Are we all less risky and more skillful than our fellow drivers?. Acta Psychologica 1981, 47:143-148.
124. Swann W.B. The self and identity negotiation. Interaction Studies 2005, 6:69-83.
125. Swann W.B., Gill M.J. Confidence and accuracy in person perception: Do we know what we think we know about our relationship partners?. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1997, 73:747-757.
126. Tay L., Diener E. Needs and subjective well-being around the world. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2011, 101:354-365.
127. Taylor S.E., Brown J.D. Illusion and well-being: A social psychological perspective on mental health. Psychological Bulletin 1988, 103:193-210.
128. Tenney E.R., MacCoun R.J., Spellman B.A., Hastie R. Calibration trumps confidence as a basis for witness credibility. Psychological Science 2007, 18:46-50.
129. Tenney E.R., Spellman B.A. Complex social consequences of self-knowledge. Social Psychological and Personality Science 2010, 2:343-350.
130. Tenney E.R., Spellman B.A., MacCoun R.J. The benefits of knowing what you know (and what you don't): How calibration affects credibility. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2008, 44:1368-1375.
131. Tetlock P.E. Close-call counterfactuals and belief-system defenses: I was not almost wrong but I was almost right. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1998, 75:639-652.
132. Tetlock P.E. Expert political judgment: How good is it? How can we know? 2005, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
133. Tracy J.L., Robins R.W. Show your pride: Evidence for a discrete emotion expression. Psychological Science 2004, 15:194-197.
134. Trivers R. Social evolution 1985, Benjamin/Cummins, Menlo Park, CA.
135. Van Vugt M. Evolutionary origins of leadership and followership. Personality and Social Psychology Review 2006, 10:354-371.
136. Vancouver J.B., Thompson C.M., Tischner E.C., Putka D.J. Two studies examining the negative effect of self-efficacy on performance. Journal of Applied Psychology 2002, 87:506-516.
137. Von Hippel W., Trivers R. The evolution and psychology of self-deception. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2011, 34:1-16.
138. Waldman M. Systematic errors and the theory of natural selection. The American Economic Review 1994, 84:482-497.
139. Willer R. Groups reward individual sacrifice: The status solution to the collective action problem. American Sociological Review 2009, 74:23-43.
140. Williams E.F., Gilovich T. Do people really believe they are above average?. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2008, 44:1121-1128.
141. Wrzesniewski A., McCauley C., Rozin P., Schwartz B. Jobs, careers, and callings: People's relations to their work. Journal of Research in Personality 1997, 31:21-33.
142. Zarnoth P., Sniezek J.A. The social influence of confidence in group decision making. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 1997, 33:345-366.
143. Zenger T.R. Why do employers only reward extreme performance? Examining the relationships among performance, pay, and turnover. Administrative Science Quarterly 1992, 37:198-219.
144. Zenker S., Leslie R.C., Port E., Kosloff J. The sequence of outcomes and ESP: More evidence for a primacy effect. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 1982, 8:233-238.