Stepping off the pendulum: Why only an action-based approach can transcend the nativist-empiricist debate

Cognitive Development

Volumn 28, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 96-133

  Allen, Jedediah W P ^a   Bickhard, Mark H ^b  

^a ROBERT WOOD JOHNSON MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^b LEHIGH UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Action; Anticipation; Emergence; Empiricism; Infancy; Nativism; Representation

Indexed keywords

EID: 84878108359     PISSN: 08852014     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cogdev.2013.01.002     Document Type: Article

References (147)

1. Allen J.W.P., Bickhard M.H. Emergent constructivism. Child Development Perspectives 2011, 5:164-165.
2. Allen J.W.P., Bickhard M.H. You can't get there from here: Foundationalism and development. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2011, 34:124-125.
3. Allen J.W.P., Bickhard M.H. Normativity: A crucial kind of emergence. Human Development 2011, 54:106-112.
4. Anisfeld M. No compelling evidence to dispute Piaget's timetable of the development of representational imitation in infancy. Perspectives on imitation: From neuroscience to social science 2005, vol. 2:107-131. MIT Press.
5. Aslin R.N. Why take the cog out of infant cognition?. Infancy 2000, 1:463-470.
6. Aslin R.N., Fiser J. Methodological challenges for understanding cognitive development in infants. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2005, 9:92-98.
7. Baillargeon R. Representing the existence and the location of hidden objects: Object permanence in 6- and 8-month old infants. Cognition 1986, 23:21-41.
8. Baillargeon R. Object permanence in 3.5 and 4.5-month-old infants. Developmental Psychology 1987, 23:655-664.
9. Baillargeon R. Young infants' reasoning about the physical and spatial properties of a hidden object. Cognitive Development 1987, 2:179-200.
10. Baillargeon R. Reasoning about the height and location of a hidden object in 4.5- and 6.5-month-old infants. Cognition 1991, 38:13-42.
11. Baillargeon R. Reply to Bogartz, Shinskey and Schilling; Schilling; and Cashon and Cohen. Infancy 2000, 1:447-462.
12. Baillargeon R. Innate ideas revisited: For a principle of persistence in infants' physical reasoning. Psychological Science 2008, 3:2-13.
13. Baillargeon R., Graber M. Where's the rabbit? 5.5-month-old infants' representation of the height of a hidden object. Cognitive Development 1987, 2:375-392.
14. Baillargeon R., Li J., Luo Y., Wang S. Under what conditions do infants detect continuity violations?. Processes of change in brain and cognitive development: Attention and performance 2006, XXI:163-188. Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
15. Baillargeon R., Li J., Ng W., Yuan S. An account of infants' physical reasoning. Learning and the infant mind 2009, 66-116. Oxford University Press, New York, NY. A. Woodward, A. Needham (Eds.).
16. Baillargeon R., Spelke E.S., Wassermann S. Object permanence in five-month-old infants'. Cognition 1985, 20:191-208.
17. Baird J.A., Baldwin D.A. Making sense of human behavior: Action parsing and intentional inference. Intentions and intentionality: Foundations of social cognition 2001, 193-206. MIT-Press, Cambridge: MA. B.F. Malle, L.J. Moses, D.A. Baldwin (Eds.).
18. Baron-Cohen S. Mindblindness: An essay on autism and theory of mind 1997, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
19. Bickhard M.H. The import of Fodor's anti-constructivist argument. Epistemological foundations of mathematical experience 1991, 14-25. Springer-Verlag, New York. L.P. Steffe (Ed.).
20. Bickhard M.H. Why children don't have to solve the frame problems: Cognitive representations are not encodings. Developmental Review 2001, 21:224-262.
21. Bickhard M.H. Interactivism: A manifesto. New Ideas in Psychology 2009, 27:85-95.
22. Bickhard M.H. The interactivist model. Synthese 2009, 166:547-591.
23. Bickhard, M. H. The whole person: Toward a naturalism of persons - contributions to an ontological psychology; in preparation.
24. Bickhard M.H., Richie D.M. On the nature of representation: A case study of James Gibson's theory of perception 1983, Praeger Publishers, New York, NY.
25. Bickhard M.H., Terveen L. Foundational issues in artificial intelligence and cognitive science: Impasse and solution 1995, Elsevier Scientific.
26. Blumberg M.S. Basic instinct: The genesis of behavior 2005, Thunder's Mouth Press, New York.
27. Bogartz R.S., Shinskey J.L., Speaker C.J. Interpreting infant looking: The event set x event set design. Developmental Psychology 1997, 33:408-422.
28. Bogartz R.S., Shinskey J.L., Schilling T.H. Object permanence in five-and-a-half-month-old infants?. Infancy 2000, 1:403-428.
29. Bogartz R.S., Cashon C.H., Cohen L.B., Schilling T.H., Shinskey J.L. Reply to Baillargeon, Aslin, and Munakata. Infancy 2000, 1:479-490.
30. Borke H. Piaget's mountains revisited: Changes in the egocentric landscape. Developmental Psychology 1975, 11:240-243.
31. Braine M.D.S. The ontogeny of certain logical operations: Piaget's formulation examined by non-verbal methods. Psychological Monographs: General and Applied 1959, 73:1-43. (5, Whole No. 475).
32. Bremner G. Cognitive development: Knowledge of the physical world. Blackwell handbook of infant development 2001, 99-138. Blackwell Publishing, Malden. G. Bremner, A. Fogel (Eds.).
33. Brooks R.A. Intelligence without representation. Artificial Intelligence Journal 1991, 47:139-159.
34. Bryant P.E., Trabasso T. Transitive inferences and memory in young children. Nature 1971, 232:456-458.
35. Campbell R.L., Bickhard M.H. Knowing levels and developmental stages: Contributions to human development 1986, Karger, Basel, Switzerland.
36. Campbell R.L., Bickhard M.H. Interactivism and genetic epistemology. Archives de Psychologie 1989, 57:99-121.
37. Carey S. The origin of concepts 2009, Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
38. Cashon C.H., Cohen L.B. Eight-month-old-infants' perception of possible and impossible events. Infancy 2000, 1:429-446.
39. Chandler M. Alternative readings of the competence performance relation. Criteria for competence: Controversies in the conceptualization and assessment of children's abilities 1991, 5-18. Laurence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ. M. Chandler, M. Chapman (Eds.).
40. Chapman M. Constructive evolution: Origins and development of Piaget's thought 1988, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.
41. Chomsky N. A review of skinner's verbal behavior. Language 1959, 35:26-58.
42. Chomsky N. Aspects of the theory of syntax 1965, M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, MA.
43. Chomsky N., Fodor J. The inductivist fallacy. Language and learning: The debate between Jean Piaget and Noam Chomsky 1980, 255-275. Harvard University Press, Cambridge. M. Piattelli-Palmarini (Ed.).
44. Clark A. Mindware: An introduction to the philosophy of cognitive science 2001, Oxford University Press.
45. Clark A., Toribio J. Doing without Representing?. Synthese 1994, 101:401-431.
46. Clearfield M.W. Infants' enumeration of dynamic displays. Cognitive Development 2004, 19:309-324.
47. Clearfield M.W., Mix K.S. Number versus contour length in infant discrimination of small visual sets. Psychological Science 1999, 10:408-411.
48. Clearfield M.W., Mix K.S. Infants use continuous quantity-not number-to discriminate small visual sets. Journal of Cognition and Development 2001, 2:243-260.
49. Clearfield M.W., Westfahl S. Familiarization in infants' perception of addition problems. Journal of Cognition and Development 2006, 7:27-43.
50. Cohen L.B. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary controls. Developmental Science 2002, 5:210-212.
51. Cohen L.B., Marks S.M. How infants process addition and subtraction events. Developmental Science 2002, 5:186-212.
52. Cowie F. What's within? Nativism reconsidered 1999, Oxford Press, NY, NY.
53. Elman J.L. Connectionist models of cognitive development: Where next?. Trends in Cognitive Science 2005, 9:112-117.
54. Elman J.L., Bates E.A., Johnson M.H., Karmiloff-Smith A., Parisi D., Plunkett K. Rethinking innateness 1996, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
55. Fantz R.L. Visual experience in infants: Decreased attention to familiar patterns relative to novel ones. Science 1964, 146:668-670.
56. Fantz R.L., Fagan J.F. Visual attention to size and number of pattern details by term and preterm infants during the first six months. Child Development 1975, 46:3-18.
57. Feigenson L., Carey S., Spelke E. Infants' discrimination of number vs. continuous extent. Cognitive Psychology 2002, 44:33-66.
58. Fischer K., Bidell W.S. Constraining nativist inferences about cognitive capacities. Epigenesis of mind: Studies in biology and cognition 1991, 133-170. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. S. Carey, R. Gelman (Eds.).
59. Fodor J.A. The appeal to tacit knowledge in psychological explanation. The Journal of Philosophy 1968, 65:627-640.
60. Fodor J.A. The language of thought 1975, Thomas Y. Crowell, NY.
61. Fodor J.A. On the impossibility of acquiring " more powerful" structures. Language and learning: The debate between Jean Piaget and Noam Chomsky 1980, 142-162. Harvard University Press, Cambridge. M. Piattelli-Palmarini (Ed.).
62. Fodor J.A. The present status of the innateness controversy. RePresentations 1981, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 257-316.
63. Fodor J.A. In critical condition: Polemical essays on cognitive science and the philosophy of mind 1998, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 143-152.
64. Gallistel C.R., Gelman R. Preverbal and verbal counting and computation. Cognition 1992, 44:43-74.
65. Gelman R. Conservation acquisition: A problem of learning to attend to relevant attributes. Experimental Child Psychology 1969, 7:167-187.
66. Gelman R., Baillargeon R. A review of some Piagetian concepts. Carmichael's manual of child psychology 1983, 3:167-230. Wiley, NY.
67. Gelman S.A., Kalish C.W. Conceptual development. Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 2, cognition, perception, and language 2006, 687-733. John Wiley & Sons Inc, Hoboken, NJ. 6th ed.
68. Gelman R., Williams E. Enabling constraints for cognitive development and learning: Domain specificity and epigenesis. Cognition, perception and language. Vol. 2. Handbook of child psychology 1998, 575-630. John Wiley and Sons, New York, W. Damon, Editor-in-Chief. 5th ed.
69. Gopnik A. The theory theory as an alternative to the innateness hypothesis. Chomsky and his critics 2003, 238-254. Basil Blackwell, New York. L. Antony, N. Hornstein (Eds.).
70. Haith M.M. Who put the cog in infant cognition? Is a rich interpretation too costly?. Infant Behavior & Development 1998, 21:167-179.
71. Haith M.M., Benson J.B. Infant cognition. Handbook of child psychology: Vol. 2. Cognition, perception, and language development 1998, 199-254. Wiley, New York. 5th ed.
72. Haith M.M., Hazan C., Goodman G.S. Expectation and anticipation of dynamic visual events by 3.5-month-old babies. Child Development 1988, 59:467-479.
73. Hunter M.A., Ames E.W. A multifactor model of infant preferences for novel and familiar stimuli. Advances in infancy research 1988, 5:69-95. Ablex, Norwood, NJ.
74. Hunter M.A., Ames E.W., Koopman R. Effects of stimulus complexity and familiarization time on infant preferences for novel and familiar stimuli. Developmental Psychology 1983, 19:338-352.
75. Jackson I., Sirois S. Infant cognition: Going full factorial with pupil dilation. Developmental Science 2009, 12:670-679.
76. Johnston T.D. Toward a systems view of development: An appraisal of Lehrman's critique of Lorenz. Cycles of contingency 2001, 15-24. MIT Press. S. Oyama, P.E. Griffiths, R.D. Gray (Eds.).
77. Kagan J. Attention and psychological change in the young child: Analysis of early determinants of attention provides insights into the nature of psychological growth. Science 1970, 170:826-832.
78. Kagan J. Surprise, uncertainty, and mental structures 2002, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
79. Kagan J. In defense of qualitative changes in development. Child Development 2008, 79:1606-1624.
80. Karmiloff-Smith A. Beyond modularity: A developmental perspective on cognitive science 1992, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
81. Keil F.C. Constraints on knowledge and cognitive development. Psychological Review 1981, 88:197-227.
82. Keil F.C. Cognitive science and the origins of thought and knowledge. Handbook of child psychology, 1: theoretical models of human development 1998, 341-413. John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ, US. 5th ed. D. William, R.M. Lerner (Eds.).
83. Kellman P.J., Spelke E.S. Perception of partially occluded objects in infants. Cognitive Psychology 1983, 15:483-524.
84. Lefebvre-Pinard M.L., Pinard A. Taking charge of one's cognitive activity: A moderator of competence. Moderators of competence 1985, 191-211. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. E.D. Neimark, R. DeLisi, J.L. Newman (Eds.).
85. Leslie A.M. Pretense and representation: The origins of 'theory of mind'. Psychological Review 1987, 94:412-426.
86. Lourenco O., Machado A. In defense of Piaget's theory: A reply to 10 common criticisms. Psychological Review 1996, 103:143-164.
87. Mandler J. Perceptual and conceptual processes in infancy. Journal of Cognition and Development 2000, 1:3-36.
88. Mandler J. The foundations of mind: Origins of conceptual thought 2004, Oxford University Press, New York, NY.
89. Meltzoff A.N., Moore M.K. Object representation, identity, and the paradox of early permanence: Steps toward a new framework. Infant Behavior & Development 1998, 21:201-235.
90. Mix K.S., Huttenlocher J., Levine S.C. Multiple cues for quantification in infancy: Is number one of them?. Psychological Bulletin 2002, 128:205-206.
91. Müller U., Carpendale J.I.M., Smith L. Introduction part I: The context of Piaget's theory. The Cambridge companion to piaget 2009, 1-44. Cambridge University Press, New York, NY. U. Müller, J.I.M. Carpendale, L. Smith (Eds.).
92. Munakata Y. Challenges to the violation-of-expectation paradigm: Throwing the conceptual baby out with the perceptual processing bathwater?. Infancy 2000, 1:471-477.
93. Munakata Y. Graded representations in behavioral dissociations. Trends in Cognitive Science 2001, 5:309-315.
94. Munakata Y., McClelland J.L., Johnson M.H., Siegler R.S. Rethinking infant knowledge: Toward an adaptive process account of successes and failure in object permanence tasks. Psychological Review 1997, 104:686-713.
95. Newcombe N.S., Learmonth A. Change and continuity in early spatial development: Claiming the " radical middle". Infant Behavior & Development 1999, 22:457-474.
96. Onishi K.H., Baillargeon R. Do 15-month-old infants understand false beliefs?. Science 2005, 308:255-258.
97. Papert S. Artificial intelligence and general developmental mechanisms. Language and learning: The debate between Jean Piaget and Noam Chomsky 1980, 89-106. Harvard University Press, Cambridge. M. Piattelli-Palmarini (Ed.).
98. Piaget J. The construction of reality in the child 1954, Basic, New York.
99. Piattelli-Palmarini M. How hard is the " hard core" of a scientific program?. Language and learning: The debate between Jean Piaget and Noam Chomsky 1980, 6-20. Harvard University Press, Cambridge. M. Piattelli-Palmarini (Ed.).
100. Plaut D.C., McClelland J.L., Seidenberg M.S., Patterson K. Understanding normal and impaired word reading: Computational principles in quasi-regular domains. Psychological Review 1996, 103:56-115.
101. Port R., van Gelder T. Mind as motion: Exploration in the dynamics of cognition 1995, MIT, Bradford.
102. Quine W.V.O. Word and object 1960, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
103. Quinn P.C., Eimas P.D. The emergence of category representations during infancy: Are separate and conceptual processes required?. Journal of Cognition and Development 2000, 1:55-61.
104. Ratcliffe M.J. From folk psychology to commonsense. Folk psychology re-assessed 2007, 223-243. Springer, Dordrecht, Holland. D.D. Hutto, M.J. Ratcliffe (Eds.).
105. Reznick J.S. Interpreting infant conceptual categorization. Cognition and Development 2000, 1:63-66.
106. Rivera S.M., Wakeley A., Langer J. The drawbridge phenomena: representational reasoning or perceptual preference?. Developmental Psychology 1999, 35:427-435.
107. Roder B.J., Bushnell E.W., Sasseville A.M. Infants' preferences for familiarity and novelty during the course of visual processing. Infancy 2000, 1:491-507.
108. Rumelhart D.E., Mclelland J.L. On learning the past tenses of English verbs. Parallel distributed processing: Explorations in the microstructure of cognition, vol. 1: Foundations 1986, 318-362. the PDP Research Group, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA. D.E. Rumelhart, J.L. McClelland (Eds.).
109. Samuels R. Nativism in cognitive science. Mind and Language 2002, 17:233-265.
110. Schilling T.H. Infants' looking at possible and impossible screen rotations: The role of familiarization. Infancy 2000, 1:389-402.
111. Schöner G., Thelen E. Using dynamic field theory to rethink infant habituation (pp. 81-115). Psychological Review 2006, 113:273-299.
112. Seidenberg M.S., McClelland J.L. A distributed, developmental model of word recognition and naming. Psychological Review 1989, 96:523-568.
113. Simon T.J. Reconceptualizing the origins of number knowledge: a 'non-numeric' account. Cognitive Development 1997, 12:349-372.
114. Simpson T. Towards a reasonable nativism. The innate mind: Structure and contents 2005, 122-138. Oxford University Press, New York, NY. P. Carruthers, S. Laurence, S. Stich (Eds.).
115. Sirois S., Jackson L. Social cognition in infancy: A critical review of research on higher order abilities. European Journal of Developmental Psychology 2007, 4:46-64.
116. Smith L. Necessary knowledge: Piagetian perspectives on constructivism 1993, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hove, UK.
117. Sokolov E. Perception and the conditioned reflex 1963, Pergamon, New York.
118. Sophian C. Beyond competence: The significance of performance for conceptual development. Cognitive Development 1997, 12:281-303.
119. Spelke E.S., Breinlinger K., Macomber J., Jacobson K. Origins of knowledge. Psychological Review 1992, 99:605-632.
120. Spelke E.S., Kinzler K.D. Core knowledge. Developmental Science 2007, 10:89-96.
121. Spelke E.S., Newport E.L. Nativism, empiricism, and the development of knowledge. Handbook of child psychology, 1: Theoretical models of human development 1998, 275-340. US John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ. 5th ed. W. Damon, R.M. Lerner (Eds.).
122. Spencer J.P., Blumberg M.S., McMurray B., Scott R.R., Samuelson L.K., Tomblin B.J. Short arms and talking eggs: Why we should no longer abide the nativist-empiricist debate. Child Development Perspectives 2009, 3:79-87.
123. Spencer J.P., Corbetta D., Buchanan P., Clearfield M., Ulrich B., Schöner G. Moving towards a grand theory of development: In memory of Esther Thelen. Child Development 2006, 77:1521-1538.
124. Spencer J.P., Perone S. Defending qualitative change: The view from dynamical systems theory. Child Development 2008, 79:1639-1647.
125. Spencer J.P., Schöner G. Bridging the representational gap in the dynamic systems approach to development. Developmental Science 2003, 6:392-412.
126. Starkey P., Cooper R.G. Perception of numbers by human infants. Science 1980, 210:1033-1035.
127. Starkey P., Spelke E.S., Gelman R. Numerical abstraction by human infants. Cognition 1990, 36:97-128.
128. Thelen E., Schöner G., Scheier C., Smith L.B. The dynamics of embodiment: A field theory of infant perseverative reaching. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2001, 24:1-86.
129. Thelen E., Smith L.B. A dynamic systems approach to the development of cognition and action 1994, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
130. Uller C., Carey S., Huntley-Fenner G., Klatt L. What representations might underlie infant numerical knowledge. Cognitive Development 1999, 14:1-36.
131. van Gelder, T. (1999). 'Revisiting the dynamical hypothesis'. Preprint No. 2/99, University of Melbourne, Department of Philosophy (URL:). http://www.arts.unimelb.edu.au/~tgelder/papers/Brazil.pdf.
132. Wakeley A., Rivera S., Langer J. Can young infants add and subtract?. Child Development 2000, 71:1525-1534.
133. Wang S.H., Baillargeon R., Brueckner L. Young infants' reasoning about hidden objects: Evidence from violation-of-expectation tasks with test trials only. Cognition 2004, 93:167-198.
134. Warbin, R. W. (1995). The contribution of experimenters' actions on objects to infants' knowledge of object properties. Dissertation. Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering, pp. 1471.
135. Woodward A.L. Infants selectively encode the goal object of an actor's reach. Cognition 1998, 69:1-34.
136. Woodward A.L. Infants' ability to distinguish between purposeful and non-purposeful behaviors. Infant Behavior and Development 1999, 22:145-160.
137. Wellman H.M. The child's theory of mind 1990, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
138. Witherington D.C. The dynamic systems approach as metatheory for developmental psychology. Human Development 2007, 50:127-153.
139. Witherington D.C. Taking emergence seriously: The centrality of circular causality for dynamic systems approaches to development. Human Development 2011, 54:66-92.
140. Wynn K. Addition and subtraction by human infants. Nature 1992, 358:749-750.
141. Wynn K. Origins of numerical knowledge. Mathematical Cognition 1995, 1:35-60.
142. Wynn K. Infants' individuation and enumeration of actions. Psychological Science 1996, 7:164-169.
143. Wynn K. Competence models of numerical development. Cognitive Development 1997, 12:333-339.
144. Wynn K. Psychological foundations of number: Numerical competence in human infants. Trends in Cognitive Science 1998, 2:296-303.
145. Wynn K. Do infants have numerical expectations or just perceptual preferences?. Developmental Science 2002, 5:207-209.
146. Xu F., Carey S. Infants' metaphysics: the case of numerical identity. Cognitive Psychology 1996, 30:111-153.
147. Xu F., Spelke E.S. Large number discrimination in 6-month-old infants. Cognition 2000, 74:1-11.