Eight-year clinical evaluation of a 2-step self-etch adhesive with and without selective enamel etching

Dental Materials

Volumn 26, Issue 12, 2010, Pages 1176-1184

  Peumans, M ^a   De Munck, J ^a   Van Landuyt, K L ^a   Poitevin, A ^a   Lambrechts, P ^a   Van Meerbeek, B ^a  

^a DEPARTMENT OF IMAGING AND PATHOLOGY   (Belgium)

Author keywords

Adhesive; Class V; Composite restoration; Randomized clinical trial; Self etch

Indexed keywords

ACID-ETCHING; CLASS-V; CLINICAL EFFECTIVENESS; CLINICAL EVALUATION; CLINICAL PERFORMANCE; CLINICAL SERVICES; CLINICAL TRIAL; COMPOSITE RESTORATIONS; CONTROL GROUPS; EXPERIMENTAL GROUPS; KURARAY; MARGINAL INTEGRITY; MCNEMAR; POSITIVE EFFECTS; RANDOMIZED CLINICAL TRIALS; RECALL RATE; RETENTION RATE; SELF-ETCH; SELF-ETCH ADHESIVES;

DENTAL COMPOSITES; ENAMELS; ETCHING; EXPERIMENTS; PHOSPHORIC ACID; RESTORATION;

DISCOLORATION;

CLEARFIL SE BOND; PHOSPHORIC ACID; RESIN; RESIN CEMENT;

ARTICLE; CLINICAL TRIAL; CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIAL; CONTROLLED STUDY; DENTAL ACID ETCHING; DENTAL SURGERY; DENTIN SENSITIVITY; ENAMEL; ENDODONTICS; FEMALE; FOLLOW UP; HUMAN; MALE; METHODOLOGY; MIDDLE AGED; NONPARAMETRIC TEST; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL; TOOTH CERVIX; TOOTH DISCOLORATION; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

ACID ETCHING, DENTAL; COMPOSITE RESINS; DENTAL ENAMEL; DENTAL MARGINAL ADAPTATION; DENTAL RESTORATION FAILURE; DENTAL RESTORATION, PERMANENT; DENTIN SENSITIVITY; FEMALE; FOLLOW-UP STUDIES; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; PHOSPHORIC ACIDS; RESIN CEMENTS; STATISTICS, NONPARAMETRIC; TOOTH CERVIX; TOOTH DISCOLORATION; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 78049332506     PISSN: 01095641     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.dental.2010.08.190     Document Type: Article

References (73)

1. B. Van Meerbeek, J. De Munck, Y. Yoshida, S. Inoue, M. Vargas, and P. Vijay Buonocore memorial lecture: adhesion to enamel and dentin: current status and future challenges Oper Dent 28 2003 215 235
2. R. Frankenberger, D.H. Pashley, S.M. Reich, U. Lohbauer, A. Petschelt, and F. Tay Characterisation of resin-dentine interfaces by compressive cyclic loading Biomaterials 26 2005 2043 2052
3. J. De Munck, K. Van Landuyt, M. Peumans, A. Poitevin, P. Lambrechts, and M. Braem A critical review of the durability of adhesion to tooth tissue: methods and results J Dent Res 84 2005 118 132
4. U. Blunck, and Zaslansky Effectiveness of all-in-one adhesive systems tested by thermo-cycling following short and long-term water storage J Adhes Dent 9 2007 231 240
5. K.L. Van Landuyt, A. Mine, J. De Munck, S. Jaecques, M. Peumans, and P. Lambrechts Are one-step adhesives easier to use and better performing? Multifactorial assessment of contemporary one-step self-etching adhesives J Adhes Dent 11 2009 175 190
6. M. Hashimoto A review - micromorphological evidence of degradation in resin-dentin bonds and potential preventional solutions J Biomed Mater Res Part B: Appl Biomater 92B 2010 268 280
7. B. Van Meerbeek, M. Peumans, A. Poitevin, A. Mine, A. Van Ende, and J. De Munck Relationship between bond strength tests and clinical outcomes Dent Mater 26 2010 100 121
8. K. Van Landuyt, P. Kanumilli, J. De Munck, M. Peumans, P. Lambrechts, and B. Van Meerbeek Bond strength of a mild self-etch adhesive with and without prior acid-etching J Dent 34 2006 77 85
9. W.W. Brackett, F.R. Tay, S.W. Looney, S. Ito, L.D. Haisch, and D.H. Pashley Microtensile dentin and enamel bond strengths of recent self-etching resins Oper Dent 33 2008 89 95
10. M.F. Burrow, Y. Kitasako, C.D. Thomas, and J. Tagami Comparison of enamel and dentin microshear bond strengths of a two-step self-etching priming system with five all-in-one systems Oper Dent 33 2008 456 460
11. A. Mine, J. De Munck, M.V. Cardoso, K.L. Van Landuyt, A. Poitevin, and T. Kuboki Bonding effectiveness of two contemporary self-etch adhesives to enamel and dentin J Dent 37 2009 872 883
12. J. Perdigão, M.M. Lopes, and G. Gomes In vitro bonding performance of self-etch adhesives. II. Ultramorphological evaluation Oper Dent 33 2008 534 549
13. Van Landuyt KL, De Munck J, Mine A, Cardoso MV, Peumans M, Van Meerbeek B. Self-etch bonding jeopardized by smear and filler debonding. J Dent Res (2010) in press.
14. S.L. Türkun Clinical evaluation of a self-etching and a one-step bottle adhesive system at two years J Dent 31 2003 527 534
15. J. Perdigão, A.R.P. Carmo, C. Anauate-Netto, R. Amore, H.R. Lewgoy, and H.J. Cordeiro Clinical performance of a self-etching adhesive at 18 months Am J Dent 18 2005 135 140
16. M. Peumans, J. De Munck, K. Van Landuyt, P. Lambrechts, and B. Van Meerbeek Three-year clinical effectiveness of a two-step self-etch adhesive in cervical lesions Eur J Oral Sci 113 2005 1 7
17. M. Peumans, J. De Munck, K.L. Van Landuyt, P. Kanumilli, Y. Yoshida, and S. Inoue Restoring cervical lesions with flexible composites Dent Mater 23 2007 749 754
18. A.D. Loguercio, E. Lorini, R.V. Weiss, A.P. Tori, C.C. Picinatto, and N.R. Ribeiro A 12-month clinical evaluation of composite resins in Class III restorations J Adhes Dent 9 2007 57 64
19. M. Peumans, J. De Munck, K. Van Landuyt, P. Lambrechts, and B. Van Meerbeek Five-year clinical effectiveness of a two-step self-etching adhesive J Adhes Dent 9 2007 7 10
20. R.B. Ermis, O. Kam, E.U. Celik, and U.B. Temel Clinical evaluation of a two-step etch & rinse and a two-step self-etch adhesive system in Class II restorations: two-year results Oper Dent 34 2009 656 663
21. Y. Yoshida, K. Nagakane, R. Fukuda, Y. Nakayami, M. Okazaki, and H. Shintani Comparative study on adhesive performance of functional monomers J Dent Res 83 2004 454 458
22. S. Inoue, K. Koshiro, Y. Yoshida, J. De Munck, K. Nagakane, and K. Suzuki Hydrolytic stability of self-etch adhesives bonded to dentin J Dent Res 84 2005 1160 1164
23. R. Frankenberger, and F. Tay Self-etch vs etch-and-rinse adhesives: effect of thermo-mechanical fatigue loading on marginal quality of bonded resin composite restorations Dent Mater 21 2005 397 412
24. J.I. Rosales-Leal Microleakage of Class V composite restorations placed with etch-and-rinse and self-etching adhesives before and after thermocycling J Adhes Dent 9 2007 255 259
25. A.I. Abdalla, and A.J. Feilzer Four-year water degradation of a total-etch and two self-etching adhesives bonded to dentin J Dent 36 2008 611 617
26. R. Frankenberger, U. Lohbauer, M.J. Roggendorf, M. Naumann, and M. Taschner Selective enamel etching reconsidered: better than etch-and-rinse and self-etch? J Adhes Dent 10 2008 339 344
27. F. Monticelli, M. Toledano, A. Simoes Silva, E. Osorio, and R. Osorio Sealing effectiveness of etch-and-rinse vs self-etching adhesives after water aging: influence of acid etching and NaOCl dentin pretreatment J Adhes Dent 10 2008 183 188
28. J. Zhou, J. Tan, L. Chen, D. Li, and Y. Tan The incorporation of chlorhexidine in a two-step self-etching adhesive preserves dentin bond in vitro J Dent 37 2009 807 812
29. M. Ülker, M. Özcan, A. Sengün, F. Özer, and S. Belli Effect of artificial aging regimens on the performance of self-etching adhesives J Biomed Mater Res B: Appl Biomater 93 2010 175 184
30. A.I. Abdalla, M. El Eraki, and A.J. Feilzer The effect of direct and indirect water storage on the microtensile dentin bond strength of a total-etch and two self-etching adhesives Am J Dent 20 2007 370 374
31. A.I. Abdalla, A.A. El Zohairy, M.M.N. Aboushelib, and A.J. Feilzer Influence of thermal and mechanical load cycling on the microtensile bond strength of self-etching adhesives Am J Dent 20 2007 250 254
32. T. Bortolotto, W. Doudou, M. Stavridakis, M. Ferrari, and I. Krejci Marginal adaptation after aging of a self-etching adhesive containing an antibacterial monomer J Adhes Dent 9 2007 311 317
33. H.D. Arisu, M.B. Ütasli, E. Eligüzeloglu, S. Özcan, and H. Ömürlü The effect of occlusal loading on the microleakage of class V restorations Oper Dent 33 2008 135 141
34. R. Osorio, J. Pisani-Proenca, M. Carolina, G. Erhardt, Z. Osorio, and F.S. Aguillera Resistance of ten contemporary adhesives to resin-dentine bond degradation J Dent 36 2008 163 169
35. M. Rotta, P. Bresciani, S.K. Moura, R.H.M. Grande, L.A. Hilgert, and L.N. Baratieri Effects of phosphoric acid pretreatment and substitution of bonding resin on bonding effectiveness of self-etch systems to enamel J Adhes Dent 9 2007 537 546
36. R.S. Alexandre, R.H. Sundfeld, M. Giannini, and J.R. Lovadino The influence of temperature on three adhesives systems on bonding to ground enamel Oper Dent 33 2008 272 281
37. R.L. Erickson, W.W. Barkmeier, and M.A. Latta The role of etching in bonding to enamel: a comparison of self-etching and etch-and-rinse adhesive systems Dent Mater 25 2009 1459 1467
38. R.L. Erickson, W.W. Barkmeier, and N.S. Kimmes Bond strength of self-etch adhesives to pre-etched enamel Dent Mater 25 2009 1187 1194
39. W.W. Barkmeier, R.L. Erickson, N.S. Kimmes, M.A. Latta, and T.M. Wilwerding Effect of enamel etching time on roughness and bond strength Oper Dent 34 2009 217 222
40. R.L. Erickson, W.W. Barkmeier, and N.S. Kimmes Fatigue of enamel bonds with self-etch adhesives Dent Mater 25 2009 716 720
41. A.D. Loguercio, S.K. Moura, A. Pellizzaro, K. Dal-Bianco, R.T. Patzlaff, and R.H.M. Grande Durability of enamel bonding using two-step self-etch systems on ground and unground enamel Oper Dent 33 2008 79 88
42. A. Reis, S.K. Moura, A. Pellizzaro, K. Dal-Bianco, A.M. Andrade, and R.H.M. Grande Durability of enamel bonding using one-step self-etch systems on ground and unground enamel Oper Dent 34 2009 181 191
43. A.I. Abdalla, and A.J. Feilzer Two-year water degradation of self-etching adhesives bonded to bur ground enamel Oper Dent 34 2009 732 740
44. R. Frankenberger, N. Krämer, U. Lohbauer, S.A. Nikolaendo, and S.M. Reich Marginal integrity: is the clinical performance of bonded restorations predictable in vitro? J Adhes Dent 9 2007 107 116
45. J. Perdigão, P. Monteiro, and G. Gomes In vitro enamel sealing of self-etch adhesives Quintessence Int 40 2009 225 233
46. A.K. Lührs, S. Guhre, R. Schilke, L. Borchers, W. Geurtsen, and H. Günay Shear bond strength of self-etch adhesives to enamel with additional phosphoric acid etching Oper Dent 33 2008 155 162
47. B. Van Meerbeek, P.V. Kanumilli, J. De Munck, K. Van Landuyt, P. Lambrechts, and M. Peumans A randomized controlled trial evaluating the three-year clinical effectiveness of two etch-and-rinse adhesives in cervical lesions Oper Dent 29 2004 376 385
48. G. Vanherle, M. Verschueren, P. Lambrechts, and M. Braem Clinical investigation of dental adhesive systems. Part I. An in vivo study J Prosthet Dent 55 1986 157 163
49. N. Akimoto, M. Takamizu, and Y. Momoi 10-year clinical evaluation of a self-etching adhesive system Oper Dent 32 2007 3 10
50. A.A. Boghosian, J.L. Drummond, and E. Lautenschlager Clinical evaluation of a dentin adhesive system: 13 year results J Dent Res 86 Spec. Issue A 2007 [Abstr. No. 228]
51. J.W.V. van Dijken, Sunnegrdh-Grönberg, and A. Lindberg Clinical long-term retention of etch-and-rinse and self-etch adhesive systems in non-carious cervical lesions. A 13 years evaluation Dent Mater 23 2007 1101 1107
52. J.W.V. van Dijken, and U. Pallesen Long-term dentin retention of etch-and-rinse and self-etch adhesives and a resin-modified glass ionomer cement in non-carious cervical lesions Dent Mater 24 2008 915 922
53. R. Hickel, J.F. Roulet, S. Bayne, S.D. Heintze, I.A. Mjör, and M. Peters Recommendations for conducting controlled clinical studies of dental restorative materials. Science Committee Project 2/98 - FDI World Dental Federation. Study design (Part I) and criteria for evaluation (Part II) of direct and indirect restorations including onlays and partial crowns J Adhes Dent 9 2007 121 147
54. A.V. Ritter, E.J. Swift, H.O. Heymann, J.R. Sturdevant, and A.D. Wilder An eight-year clinical evaluation of filled and unfilled one-bottle dental adhesives J Am Dent Assoc 140 2009 28 37
55. A.D. Wilder, E.J. Swift, H.O. Heymann, A.V. Ritter, J.R. Sturdevant, and S.C. Bayne A 12-year clinical evaluation of a three-step dentin adhesive in noncarious cervical lesions J Am Dent Assoc 140 2009 526 535
56. A. Takahashi, Y. Sato, S. Uno, P.N. Pereira, and H. Sano Effects of mechanical properties of adhesive resins on bond strength to dentin Dent Mater 18 2002 263 268
57. T. Ikeda, J. De Munck, K. Shirai, K. Hikita, S. Inoue, and H. Sano Effect of fracture strength of primer-adhesive mixture on bonding effectiveness Dent Mater 21 2005 413 420
58. T. Ikeda, J. De Munck, K. Shirai, K. Hikita, S. Inoue, and H. Sano Effect of air-drying and solvent evaporation on the strength of HEMA-rich versus HEMA-free one-step adhesives Dent Mater 24 2008 978 985
59. F.T. Sadek, F.C. Calheiros, P.E.C. Cardoso, Y. Kawano, and F. Tay Early and 24-hour bond strength and degree of conversion of etch-and-rinse and self-etch adhesives Am J Dent 21 2008 30 34
60. C.O. Navarra, M. Cadenaro, S.R. Armstrong, J. Jessop, F. Antoniolli, and V. Sergo Degree of conversion of Filtek Silorane Adhesive System and Clearfil SE Bond within the hybrid layer and adhesive layer: an in situ Raman analysis Dent Mater 25 2009 1178 1185
61. M. Toledano, R. Osorio, E. Osorio, F.S. Aguilera, M. Yamauti, and D.H. Pashley Durability of resin-dentin bonds: effects of direct/indirect exposure and storage media Dent Mater 23 2007 885 892
62. J. De Munck, K. Shirai, Y. Yoshida, S. Inoue, K. Van Landuyt, and P. Lambrechts Effect of water storage on the bonding effectiveness of 6 adhesives to Class I cavity dentin Oper Dent 31 2006 456 465
63. J. De Munck, P.E. Van den Steen, A. Mine, K.L. Van Landuyt, A. Poitevin, and G. Opdenakker Inhibition of enzymatic degradation of adhesive-dentin interfaces J Dent Res 12 2009 1101 1106
64. L.S. Türkün, and E.U. elik Noncarious Class V lesions restored with a polyacid modified resin composite and a nanocomposite: a two-year clinical trial J Adhes Dent 10 2008 339 405
65. M. Peumans, P. Kanumilli, J. De Munck, K. Van Landuyt, P. Lambrechts, and B. Van Meerbeek Clinical effectiveness of contemporary adhesives: a systematic review of current clinical trials Dent Mater 21 2005 864 881
66. K.L. Van Landuyt, M. Peumans, S. Fieuws, J. De Munck, M.V. Cardoso, and R.B. Ermis A randomized controlled clinical trial of a HEMA-free all-in-one adhesive in non-carious cervical lesions at 1 year J Dent 36 2008 847 855
67. S. Kubo, H. Yokota, H. Yokota, and Y. Hayashi Three-year clinical evaluation of a flowable and a hybrid resin composite in non-carious cervical lesions J Dent 38 2010 191 200
68. D.C. Sarret Prediction of clinical outcomes of a restoration based on in vivo marginal quality evaluation J Adhes Dent 9 2007 117 120
69. S.D. Heintze, U. Blunck, T.N. Göhring, and V. Rousson Marginal adaptation in vitro and clinical outcome of class V restorations Dent Mater 25 2009 605 620
70. T. Bortolotto, I. Onisor, and I. Krejci Proximal direct composite restorations and chairside CAD/CAM inlays: marginal adaptation of a two-step self-etch adhesive with and without selective enamel conditioning Clin Oral Invest 11 2007 35 43
71. J. Perdigão New developments in dental adhesion Dent Clin North Am 51 2007 333 357
72. I.A. Mjör, J.E. Moorhead, and J.E. Dahl Reasons for replacement of restorations in permanent teeth in general dental practice Int Dent J 50 2000 361 366
73. I.A. Mjör The reasons for replacement and the age of failed restorations in general dental practice Acta Odontol Scand 55 1997 58 63