The effect of fish meal replacement by soyabean products on fish growth: A meta-analysis

British Journal of Nutrition

Volumn 102, Issue 12, 2009, Pages 1709-1722

  Sales, James ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH BOHEMIA   (Czech Republic)

Author keywords

Fish diets; Fish meal; Growth; Meta analysis; Soyabean products

Indexed keywords

METHIONINE; SOYBEAN PROTEIN; AMINO ACID;

ANIMAL FOOD; ARTICLE; BODY GROWTH; CONTROLLED STUDY; DIET SUPPLEMENTATION; EFFECT SIZE; FOOD COMPOSITION; FOOD INTAKE; GROWTH RATE; NONHUMAN; PISCICULTURE; PROTEIN CONTENT; SOYBEAN; ANIMAL; AQUACULTURE; CHEMISTRY; DIET; FAT INTAKE; FISH; GROWTH, DEVELOPMENT AND AGING; META ANALYSIS; METHODOLOGY; PLANT SEED; REVIEW; SEA FOOD; SPECIES DIFFERENCE; WEIGHT GAIN;

AMINO ACIDS; ANIMALS; AQUACULTURE; DIET; DIETARY FATS; DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS; FISH PRODUCTS; FISHES; METHIONINE; SEEDS; SOYBEAN PROTEINS; SOYBEANS; SPECIES SPECIFICITY; WEIGHT GAIN;

EID: 74949097236     PISSN: 00071145     EISSN: 14752662     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1017/S0007114509991279     Document Type: Article

References (90)

1. Naylor RL, Goldburg RJ, Primavera JH, et al. (2000) Effect of aquaculture on world fish supplies. Nature 405, 1017-1024.
2. Hardy RW (1996) Alternate protein sources for salmon and trout diets. Anim Feed Sci Tech 59, 71-80.
3. El-Sayed AFM (1999) Alternate dietary protein sources for farmed tilapia, Oreochromis spp. Aquaculture 179, 149-168.
4. Watanabe T (2002) Strategies for further development of aquatic feeds. Fisheries Sci 68, 242-252.
5. Drew MD, Borgeson TL & Thiessen DL (2007) A review of processing of feed ingredients to enhance diet digestibility in finfish. Anim Feed Sci Tech 138, 118-136.
6. Gatlin DM, Barrows FT, Brown P, et al. (2007) Expanding the utilization of sustainable plant products in aquafeeds: a review. Aquac Res 38, 551-579.
7. Glencross BD, Booth M & Allan GL (2007) A feed is only as good as its ingredients-a review of ingredient evaluation strategies for aquaculture feeds. Aquac Nutr 13, 17-34.
8. Drakeford B & Pascoe S (2008) The substitutability of fishmeal and fish oil in diets for salmon and trout: a meta-analysis. Aquac Econ Manage 12, 155-175.
9. Lim CE, Webster CD & Lee CS (2008) Alternative Protein Sources in Aquaculture Diets. New York, NY: Haworth Press.
10. Francis G, Makkar HPS & Becker K (2001) Antinutrional factors present in plant-derived alternate fish feed ingredients and their effects in fish. Aquaculture 199, 197-227.
11. Chou RL, Her BY, Su MS, et al. (2004) Substituting fish meal with soybean meal in diets of juvenile cobia Rachycentron canadum. Aquaculture 229, 325-333.
12. Lim SR, Choi SM, Wang XJ, et al. (2004) Effects of dehulled soybean meal as a fish meal replacer in diets for fingerling and growing Korean rockfish Sebastes schlegeli. Aquaculture 231, 457-468.
13. Barrows FT, Stone DAJ & Hardy RW (2007) The effects of extrusion conditions on the nutritional value of soybean meal for rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Aquaculture 265, 244-252.
14. Heikkinen J, Vielma J, Kemiläinen O, et al. (2006) Effects of soybean meal based diet on growth performance, gut histo-pathology and intestinal microbiota of juvenile rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Aquaculture 261, 259-268.
15. Kikuchi K (1999) Use of defatted soybean meal as a substitute for fish meal in diets of Japanese flounder (Paralichthys oliva-ceus). Aquaculture 179, 3-11.
16. Elangovan A & Shim KF (2000) The influence of replacing fish meal partially in the diet with soybean meal on growth and body composition of juvenile tin foil barb (Barbodes altus). Aquacul-ture 189, 133-144.
17. Romarheim OH, Skrede A, Gao Y, et al. (2006) Comparison of white flakes and toasted soybean meal partly replacing fish meal as protein source in extruded feed for rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Aquaculture 256, 354-364.
18. Fernandez-Duque E (1997) Comparing and combining data across studies: alternatives to significance testing. Oikos 79, 616-618.
19. Cook DJ, Guyatt GH, Ryan G, et al. (1993) Should unpublished data be included in meta-analyses? Current convictions and controversies. J Am Med Assoc 269, 2749-2753.
20. Davey Smith G & Egger M (1998) Meta-analysis. Unresolved issues and future developments. Br Med J 316, 221-225.
21. Wee KL & Shu S-W (1989) The nutritive value of boiled full-fat soybean in pelleted feed for Nile tilapia. Aquaculture 81, 303-314.
22. Shiau S-Y, Lin S-F, Yu S-L, et al. (1990) Defatted and full-fat soybean meal as partial replacements for fish meal in tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus x O. aureus) diets at low protein level. Aquaculture 86, 401-407.
23. Olivia-Teles A, Gouveia AJ, Gomes E, et al. (1994) The effect of different processing treatments on soybean meal utilization by rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss. Aquaculture 124, 343-349.
24. Rumsey GL, Siwicki AK, Anderson DP, et al. (1994) Effect of soybean protein on serological response, non-specific defense mechanisms, growth, and protein utilization in rainbow trout. Vet Immunol Immunopathol 41, 323-339.
25. Nengas I, Alexis MN & Davies SJ (1996) Partial substitution of fish meal with soybean meal products and derivatives in diets for the gilthead sea bream Sparus aurata (L.). Aquac Res 27, 147-156.
26. Brown PB, Twibell R, Jonker Y, et al. (1997) Evaluation of three soybean products in diets fed to juvenile hybrid striped bass Morone saxatilis x M. chrysops. J World Aquac Soc 28, 215-223.
27. Boonyaratpalin M, Suraneiranat P & Tunpibal T (1998) Replacement of fish meal with various types of soybean products in diets for the Asian seabass, Lates calcarifer. Aquaculture 161, 67-78.
28. Hemre G-I, Sanden M, Bakke-McKellep AM, et al. (2005) Growth, feed utilization and health of Atlantic salmon Salmo salar L. fed genetically modified compared to non-modified commercial hybrid soybeans. Aquac Nutr 11, 157-167.
29. Shiau S-Y, Chuang J-L & Sun C-L (1987) Inclusion of soybean meal in tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus x O. aureus) diets at two protein levels. Aquaculture 65, 251-261.
30. Shiau S-Y, Kwok C-C, Hwang J-Y, et al. (1989) Replacement of fish meal with soybean meal in male tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus x O. aureus) fingerling diets at suboptimal protein level. J World Aquac Soc 20, 230-235.
31. Kaushik S, Cravedi JP, Lalles JP, et al. (1995) Partial or total replacement of fish meal by soybean protein on growth, protein utilization, potential estrogenic or antigenic effects, cholestero-lemia and flesh quality in rainbow trout, Oncothynchus mykiss. Aquaculture 133, 257-274.
32. Davies SJ & Morris PC (1997) Influence of multiple amino acid supplementation on the performance of rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss (Walbaum), fed soya based diets. Aquac Res 28, 65-74.
33. Keembiyehetty CH & Gatlin DM (1997) Performance of sunshine bass fed soybean-meal-based diets supplemented with different methionine compounds. Prog Fish-Cult 59, 25-30.
34. Médale F, Boujard T, Vallée F, et al. (1998) Voluntary feed intake, nitrogen and phosphorus losses in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) fed increasing dietary levels of soy protein concentrate. Aquat Living Resour 11, 239-246.
35. Mambrini M, Roem AJ, Carvèdi JP, et al. (1999) Effects of replacing fish meal with soy protein concentrate and of dl-methionine supplementation in high-energy extruded diets on the growth and nutrient utilization of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). J Anim Sci 77, 2990-2999.
36. Day O & Plascencia González H (2000) Soybean protein concentrate as a protein source for turbot Scophthalmus maximus L. Aquac Nutr 6, 221-228.
37. Khan MA, Jafri AK, Chadra NK, et al. (2003) Growth and body composition of rohu (Labeo rohita) fed diets containing oilseed meals: partial or total replacement of fish meal with soybean meal. Aquac Nutr 9, 391-396.
38. Choi S-M, Wang X, Park G-J, et al. (2004) Dietary dehulled soybean meal as a replacement for fish meal in fingerling and growing olive flounder Paralichthys olivaceus (Temminck et Schlegel). Aquac Res 35, 410-418.
39. Ai Q & Xie X (2005) Effects of replacement of fish meal by soybean meal and supplementation of methionine in fish/ soybean meal-based diets on growth performance of the Southern catfish Silurus meridionalis. J World Aquac Soc 36, 498-507.
40. Deng J, Mai K, Ai Q, et al. (2006) Effects of replacing fish meal with soy protein concentrate on feed intake and growth of juvenile Japanese flounder, Paralichthys olivaceus. Aquaculture 258, 503-513.
41. Tibaldi E, Hakim Y, Uni Z, et al. (2006) Effects of the partial substitution of dietary fish meal by differently processed soybean meals on growth performance, nutrient digestibility and activity of intestinal brush border enzymes in the European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax). Aquaculture 261, 182-193.
42. Shiau S-Y, Pan BS, Chen S, et al. (1988) Successful use of soybean meal with a methionine supplement in diets for milk-fish Chanos chanos Forskal. J World Aquac Soc 19, 14-19.
43. Refstie S, Korsoen OJ, Storebakken T, et al. (2000) Differing nutritional responses to dietary soybean meal in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Aquaculture 190, 49-63.
44. Gallagher ML (1994) The use of soybean meal as a replacement for fish meal in diets for hybrid striped bass (Morone saxatilis £ M. chrysops). Aquaculture 126, 119-127.
45. McGoogan BB & Gatlin DM (1997) Effects of replacing fish meal with soybean meal in diets for red drum Sciaenops ocella-tus and potential for palatability enhancement. J World Aquac Soc 28, 374-385.
46. Hernández MD, Mart́inez FJ, Jover M, et al. (2007) Effects of partial replacement of fish meal by soybean meal in sharpsn-out seabream (Diplodus puntazzo) diet. Aquaculture 263, 159-167.
47. Hedges LV & Olkin I (1985) Statistical Methods for Meta-analysis. San Diego, CA: Academic Press.
48. Gurevitch J, Morrow LL, Wallace A, et al. (1992) A meta-analysis of competition in field experiments. Am Nat 140, 539-572.
49. Hedges LV (1981) Distributional theory for Glass's estimator of effect size and related estimators. J Educ Stat 6, 107-128.
50. Hedges LV & Vevea JL (1998) Fixed and random effects models in meta analysis. Psychol Methods 3, 486-504.
51. Orwin RG (1983) A fail-safe N for effect size in meta-analysis. J Educ Stat 8, 157-159.
52. Robaina L, Izquierdo MS, Moyano FJ, et al. (1995) Soybean and lupin seed meals as protein sources in diets for gilthead seabream (Sparus aurata): nutritional and histological implications. Aquaculture 130, 219-233.
53. Jackson AJ, Capper BS & Matty AJ (1982) Evaluation of some plant proteins in complete diet for the tilapia Sarotherodon mossambicus. Aquaculture 27, 97-109.
54. Abery NW, Gunasekera RM & de Silva SS (2002) Growth and nutrient utilization of Murray cod Maccullochella peelii peelii (Mitchell) fingerlings fed diets with varying levels of soybean meal and blood meal. Aquac Res 33, 279-289.
55. Sanz A, Morales AE, de la Higuera M, et al. (1994) Sunflower meal compared with soybean meal as partial substitutes for fish meal in in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) diets: protein and energy utilization. Aquaculture 128, 287-300.
56. Reigh RC & Ellis SC (1992) Effects of dietary soybean and fish-protein ratios on growth and body composition of red drum (Sciaenops ocellatus) fed isonitrogenous diets. Aquaculture 104, 279-292.
57. Biswas AK, Kaku H, Ji SC, et al. (2007) Use of soybean meal and phytase for partial replacement of fish meal in the diet of red sea bream, Pagrus major. Aquaculture 267, 284-291.
58. Catacutan MR & Pagador GE (2004) Partial replacement of fish meal with defatted soybean meal in formulated diets for the mangrove red snapper, Lutjanus argentimaculatus (Forsskal 1775). Aquac Res 35, 299-306.
59. Viola S & Ariela Y (1983) Nutrition studies with tilapia (Sarotherodon). 1. Replacement of fish meal by soybean meal in feeds for intensive tilapia culture. Bamidgeh 35, 9-17.
60. Viola S, Ariela Y & Zohar G (1988) Animal-protein-free feeds for hybrid tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus x O. aureus) in intensive culture. Aquaculture 75, 115-125.
61. Akiyama T, Unuma T, Yamamoto T, et al. (1995) Combinational use of malt protein flour and soybean meal as alternative protein sources of fish meal in fingerling rainbow trout diets. Fisheries Sci 61, 828-832.
62. DeCoster J (2004) Meta-analysis notes. http://www.stat-help.com/notes. html (accessed March 2008).
63. Krogdahl A, Bakke-McKellep AM & Baeverfjord G (2003) Effects of graded levels of standard soybean meal on intestinal structure, mucosal enzyme activities, and pancreatic response in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.). Aquac Nutr 9, 361-371.
64. Borenstein M, Hedges L & Rothstein H (2007) Meta-analysis. Fixed effect vs. random effects. http://www.Meta-Analysis.com (accessed September 2008).
65. Lipsey MW & Wilson DB (2000) Practical Meta-Analysis, 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
66. Cohen J (1988) Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences, 2nd ed. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
67. Nakagawa S & Cuthill IC (2007) Effect size, confidence interval and statistical significance: a practical guide for biologists. Biol Rev 82, 591-605.
68. Steidl RJ & Thomas L (2001) Power analysis and experimental design. In Design and Analysis of Ecological Experiments, pp. 14-36 [SM Scheiner and J Gurevitch, editors]. New York: Oxford University Press.
69. Rosenthal R (1979) The "file drawer problem" and tolerance for null results. Psychol Bull 86, 638-641.
70. Rosenberg MS (2005) The file-drawer problem revisited: a general weighted method for calculating fail-safe numbers in meta-analysis. Evolution 59, 464-468.
71. Rosenthal R (1991) Meta-analytic Procedures for Social Research. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
72. Refstie S, Førde-Skjærvik O, Rosenlund G, et al. (2006) Feed intake, growth, and utilisation of macronutrients and amino acids by 1-and 2-year old Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) fed standard or bioprocessed soybean meal. Aquaculture 255, 279-291.
73. Carter CG & Hauler RC (2000) Fish meal replacement by plant meals in extruded feeds for Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L. Aquaculture 185, 299-311.
74. Olli JJ, Krogdahl A & Vabenø A (1995) Dehulled solvent-extracted soybean meal as a protein source in diets for Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L. Aquac Res 26, 167-174.
75. Viola S, Ariela J, Rappaport U, et al. (1981) Experiments in the nutrition of carp. Replacement of fish meal by soybean meal. Bamidgeh 33, 35-49.
76. El-Sayed AFM (1994) Evaluation of soybean meal, spirulina meal and chicken offal meal as protein sources for silver seab-ream (Rhabdosargus sarba) fingerlings. Aquaculture 127, 169-176.
77. Refstie S, Sahlström S, Bra°then E, et al. (2005) Lactic acid fermentation eliminates indigestible carbohydrates and antinutritional factors in soybean meal for Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Aquaculture 246, 331-345.
78. Storebakken T, Kvien IS, Shearer KD, et al. (1998) The apparent digestibility of diets containing fish meal, soybean meal or bacterial meal fed to Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar): evaluation of different faecal collection methods. Aquaculture 169, 195-210.
79. Refstie S, Helland SJ & Storebakken T (1997) Adaptation to soybean meal in diets for rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss. Aquaculture 153, 263-272.
80. Refstie S, Storebakken T & Roem AJ (1998) Feed consumption and conversion in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) fed diets with fish meal, extracted soybean meal or soybean meal with reduced content of oligosaccharides, trypsin inhibitors, lectins and soya antigens. Aquaculture 162, 301-312.
81. Venou B, Alexis MN, Fountoulaki E, et al. (2006) Effect of extrusion and inclusion of soybean meal on diet digestibility, performance and nutrient utilization of gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata). Aquaculture 261, 343-356.
82. 14C) amino acids by rainbow trout, Salmo gairdneri Richardson. J Fish Biol 33, 293-305.
83. Zarate DD & Lovell RT (1997) Bioavailability of free vs. protein-bound lysine in practical diets for young channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus). Aquaculture 159, 87-100.
84. Lusas EW & Riaz MN (1995) Soy protein products: processing and use. J Nutr 125, 573S-580S.
85. Kissil GWM, Lupatsch I, Higgs DA, et al. (2000) Dietary substitution of soy and rapeseed protein concentrate for fish meal, and their effects on growth and nutrient utilization in gilthead seabream Sparus aurata L. Aquac Res 31, 595-601.
86. Stuart JS & Hung SSO (1989) Growth of juvenile white sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus) fed different proteins. Aquaculture 76, 303-316.
87. Berge GM, Grisdale-Helland B & Helland SJ (1999) Soy protein concentrate in diets for Atlantic halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus). Aquaculture 178, 139-148.
88. Storebakken T, Shearer KD & Roem AJ (2000) Growth, uptake and retention of nitrogen and phosphorus, and absorption of other minerals in Atlantic salmon Salmo salar fed diets with fish meal and soy-protein concentrate as the main sources of protein. Aquac Nutr 6, 103-108.
89. Stickney RR, Hardy RW, Koch K, et al. (1996) The effects of substituting selected oilseed protein concentrates for fish meal in rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss diets. J World Aquac Soc 27, 57-63.
90. Storebakken T, Shearer KD & Roem AJ (1998) Availability of protein, phosphorus and other elements in fish meal, soy protein concentrate and phytase treated soy-protein-concentrate-based diets to Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar. Aquaculture 161, 365-379.