The power of focal points is limited: Even minute payoff asymmetry may yield large coordination failures

American Economic Review

Volumn 98, Issue 4, 2008, Pages 1443-1458

  Crawford, Vincent P ^a   Gneezy, Uri ^b   Rottenstreich, Yuval ^c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^c NEW YORK UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 53349097369     PISSN: 00028282     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1257/aer.98.4.1443     Document Type: Article

References (54)

1. Bacharach, Michael. 1993. "Variable Universe Games." In Frontiers of Game Theory, ed. Kenneth Binmore, Alan Kirman, and Piero Tani, 255-75. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
2. Bacharach, Michael, and Michele Bernasconi. 1997. "The Variable Frame Theory of Focal Points: An Experimental Study." Games and Economic Behavior, 19(1): 1-45.
3. Bacharach, Michael, and Dale O. Stahl. 2000. "Variable-Frame Level-n Theory." Games and Economic Behavior, 32(2): 220-46.
4. Bardsley, Nicholas, Judith Mehta, Chris Starmer, and Robert Sugden. 2006. "The Nature of Salience Revisited: Cognitive Hierarchy Theory versus Team Reasoning." Unpublished.
5. Blume, Andreas. 2000. "Coordination and Learning with a Partial Language." Journal of Economic Theory, 95(1): 1-36.
6. Blume, Andreas, and Uri Gneezy. 2000. "An Experimental Investigation of Optimal Learning in Coordination Games." Journal of Economic Theory, 90(1): 161-72.
7. Blume, Andreas, and Uri Gneezy. 2002. "Cognitive Forward Induction and Coordination without Common Knowledge: Theory and Evidence." Unpublished.
8. Brandts, Jordi, and Charles Holt. 1993. "Dominance and Forward Induction: Experimental Evidence." In Research in Experimental Economics, Vol. 5, ed. R. Mark Isaac, 119-36. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
9. Brandts, Jordi, and W. Bentley MacLeod. 1995. "Equilibrium Selection in Experimental Games with Recommended Play." Games and Economic Behavior, 11(1): 36-63.
10. Cachon, Gerard P., and Colin F. Camerer. 1996. "Loss-Avoidance and Forward Induction in Experimental Coordination Games." Quarterly Journal of Economics, 111(1): 165-94.
11. Camerer, Colin F. 2003. Behavioral Game Theory: Experiments in Strategic Interaction. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
12. Camerer, Colin F., and Teck-Hua Ho. 1998. "Experience- weighted Attraction Learning in Coordination Games: Probability Rules, Heterogeneity, and Time Variation." Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 42(2-3): 305-26.
13. Camerer, Colin F., Teck-Hua Ho, and Juin-Kuan Chong. 2004. "A Cognitive Hierarchy Model of Games." Quarterly Journal of Economics, 119(3): 861-98.
14. Cooper, Russell W., Douglas V. DeJong, Robert Forsythe, and Thomas W. Ross. 1989. "Communication in the Battle of the Sexes Game: Some Experimental Results." RAND Journal of Economics, 20(4): 568-87.
15. Cooper, Russell W., Douglas V. DeJong, Robert Forsythe, and Thomas W. Ross. 1990. "Selection Criteria in Coordination Games: Some Experimental Results." American Economic Review, 80(1): 218-33.
16. Cooper, Russell W., Douglas V. DeJong, Robert Forsythe, and Thomas W. Ross. 1992a. "Communication in Coordination Games." Quarterly Journal of Economics, 107(2): 739-71.
17. Cooper, Russell W., Douglas V. DeJong, Robert Forsythe, and Thomas W. Ross. 1992b. "Forward Induction in Coordination Games." Economics Letters, 40(2): 167-72.
18. Cooper, Russell W., Douglas V. DeJong, Robert Forsythe, and Thomas W. Ross. 1993. "Forward Induction in the Battle-of-the-Sexes Games." American Economic Review, 83(5): 1303-16.
19. Costa-Gomes, Miguel A., Vincent P. Crawford, and Bruno Broseta. 2001. "Cognition and Behavior in Normal-Form Games: An Experimental Study." Econometrica, 69(5): 1193-1235.
20. Costa-Gomes, Miguel A., and Vincent P. Crawford. 2006. "Cognition and Behavior in Two-Person Guessing Games: An Experimental Study." American Economic Review, 96(5): 1737-68.
21. Crawford, Vincent P. 1995. "Adaptive Dynamics in Coordination Games." Econometrica, 63(1): 103-43.
22. Crawford, Vincent P. 1997. "Theory and Experiment in the Analysis of Strategic Interaction." In Advances in Economics and Econometrics: Theory and Applications, Seventh World Congress, Vol. 1, ed. David Kreps and Ken Wallis, 206-42. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
23. Crawford, Vincent P. 1998. "A Survey of Experiments on Communication Via Cheap Talk." Journal of Economic Theory, 78(2): 286-98.
24. Crawford, Vincent P., and Bruno Broseta. 1998. "What Price Coordination? The Efficiency-Enhancing Effect of Auctioning the Right to Play." American Economic Review, 88(1): 198-225.
25. Crawford, Vincent P., and Hans Haller. 1990. "Learning How to Cooperate: Optimal Play in Repeated Coordination Games." Econometrica, 58(3): 571-95.
26. Crawford, Vincent P., and Nagore Iriberri. 2007a. "Fatal Attraction: Salience, Naivete, and Sophistication in Experimental 'Hide-and-Seek' Games." American Economic Review, 97(5): 1731-50.
27. Crawford, Vincent P., and Nagore Iriberri. 2007b. "Level-k Auctions: Can a Nonequilibrium Model of Strategic Thinking Explain the Winner's Curse and Overbidding in Private-Value Auctions?" Econometrica, 75(6): 1721-70.
28. Gneezy, Uri. 2005. "Step-Level Reasoning and Bidding in Auctions." Management Science, 51(11): 1633-42.
29. Gneezy, Uri, and Yuval Rottenstreich. 2005. "The Power of Focal Points is Limited: Even Minute Payoff Asymmetry Yields Massive Coordination Failures." Unpublished.
30. Harsanyi, John C., and Reinhard Selten. 1988. A General Theory of Equilibrium Selection in Games. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
31. Haruvy, Ernan, and Dale O. Stahl, II. 2004. "Deductive versus Inductive Equilibrium Selection: Experimental Results." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 53(3): 319-31.
32. Heath, Chip. 1999. "On the Social Psychology of Agency Relationships: Lay Theories of Motivation Overemphasize Extrinsic Incentives." Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 78(1): 25-62.
33. Heath, Chip, and Nancy Staudenmeyer. 2000. "Coordination Neglect: How Lay Theories of Organizing Complicate Coordination in Organizations." In Research in Organizational Behavior, Vol. 22, ed. Barry Staw and Nancy Staudenmayer, 153-91. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
34. Ho, Teck-Hua, Colin Camerer, and Keith Weigelt. 1998. "Iterated Dominance and Iterated Best Response in Experimental 'p-Beauty Contests.' " American Economic Review, 88(4): 947-69.
35. Mehta, Judith, Chris Starmer, and Robert Sugden. 1994a. "Focal Points in Pure Coordination Games: An Experimental Investigation." Theory and Decision, 36(2): 163-85.
36. Mehta, Judith, Chris Starmer, and Robert Sugden. 1994b. "The Nature of Salience: An Experimental Investigation of Pure Coordination Games." American Economic Review, 84(3): 658-73.
37. Nagel, Rosemarie. 1995. "Unraveling in Guessing Games: An Experimental Study." American Economic Review, 85(5): 1313-26.
38. O'Neill, Barry. 1987. "Nonmetric Test of the Minimax Theory of Two-Person Zerosum Games." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 84(7): 2106-09.
39. Rapoport, Amnon, and Richard B. Boebel. 1992. "Mixed Strategies in Strictly Competitive Games: A Further Test of the Minimax Hypothesis." Games and Economic Behavior, 4(2): 261-83.
40. Ratner, Rebecca, and Dale Miller. 2001. "The Norm of Self-interest and Its Effects on Social Action." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 81(1): 5-16.
41. Rubinstein, Ariel. 1999. "Experience from a Course in Game Theory: Pre- and Post-Class Problem Sets as a Didactic Device." Games and Economic Behavior, 28(1): 155-70.
42. Rubinstein, Ariel, and Amos Tversky. 1993. "Naïve Strategies in Zero-Sum Games." Tel Aviv University Sackler Institute of Economic Studies Working Paper 17-93.
43. Rubinstein, Ariel, Amos Tversky, and Dana Heller. 1996. "Naive Strategies in Competitive Games." In Understanding Strategic Interaction-Essays in Honor of Reinhard Selten, ed. Wulf Albers, Werner Güth, Peter Hammerstein, Bemmy Moldovanu, and Eric van Damme, 394-402. Berlin: Springer-Verlag.
44. Schelling, Thomas. 1960. The Strategy of Conflict. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
45. Stahl, Dale O., II, and Paul W. Wilson. 1994. "Experimental Evidence on Players' Models of Other Players." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 25(3): 309-27.
46. Stahl, Dale O., II, and Paul W. Wilson. 1995. "On Players' Models of Other Players: Theory and Experimental Evidence." Games and Economic Behavior, 10(1): 218-54.
47. Straub, Paul G. 1995. "Risk Dominance and Coordination Failures in Static Games." Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 35(4): 339-63.
48. Sugden, Robert. 1995. "A Theory of Focal Points." Economic Journal, 105(430): 533-50.
49. Van Huyck, John B., Raymond C. Battalio, and Richard O. Beil. 1990. "Tacit Coordination Games, Strategic Uncertainty, and Coordination Failure." American Economic Review, 80(1): 234-48.
50. Van Huyck, John B., Raymond C. Battalio, and Richard O. Beil. 1991. "Strategic Uncertainty, Equilibrium Selection, and Coordination Failure in Average Opinion Games." Quarterly Journal of Economics, 106(3): 885-910.
51. Van Huyck, John B., Raymond C. Battalio, and Richard O. Beil. 1993. "Asset Markets as an Equilibrium Selection Mechanism: Coordination Failure, Game Form Auctions, and Tacit Communication." Games and Economic Behavior, 5(3): 485-504.
52. Van Huyck, John B., Raymond C. Battalio, and Frederick W. Rankin. 1997. "On the Origin of Convention: Evidence from Coordination Games." Economic Journal, 107(442): 576-96.
53. Van Huyck, John B., Joseph P. Cook, and Raymond C. Battalio. 1997. "Adaptive Behavior and Coordination Failure." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 32(4): 483-503.
54. Van Huyck, John B., Ann B. Gillette, and Raymond C. Battalio. 1992. "Credible Assignments in Coordination Games." Games and Economic Behavior, 4(4): 606-26.