Uncertainty in integrative structural modeling

Current Opinion in Structural Biology

Volumn 28, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 96-104

  Schneidman Duhovny, Dina ^a   Pellarin, Riccardo ^a   Sali, Andrej ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ACCURACY; ANALYTICAL ERROR; BAYES THEOREM; DATA ANALYSIS; DATA EXTRACTION; DATA SYNTHESIS; EXPERIMENTAL STUDY; INFORMATION MODEL; INFORMATION RETRIEVAL; INTEGRATIVE STRUCTURAL MODELING; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROCESS OPTIMIZATION; REVIEW; SAMPLING; SCORING SYSTEM; SIMULATION; CLUSTER ANALYSIS; DATA COLLECTION METHOD; INFORMATION SYSTEM; MEASUREMENT ACCURACY; MEASUREMENT PRECISION; NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE SPECTROSCOPY; STANDARDIZATION; SYSTEMATIC ERROR; VALIDATION PROCESS; X RAY CRYSTALLOGRAPHY; CHEMICAL STRUCTURE; THEORETICAL MODEL;

MODELS, MOLECULAR; MODELS, THEORETICAL; MOLECULAR STRUCTURE;

EID: 84908116377     PISSN: 0959440X     EISSN: 1879033X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.sbi.2014.08.001     Document Type: Review

References (66)

1. Brünger A.T. Free R value: a novel statistical quantity for assessing the accuracy of crystal structures. Nature 1992, 355:472-475.
2. Read R.J., Adams P.D., Arendall W.B., Brunger A.T., Emsley P., Joosten R.P., Kleywegt G.J., Krissinel E.B., Lütteke T., Otwinowski Z., et al. A new generation of crystallographic validation tools for the protein data bank. Structure 2011, 19:1395-1412.
3. Montelione G.T., Nilges M., Bax A., Güntert P., Herrmann T., Richardson J.S., Schwieters C.D., Vranken W.F., Vuister G.W., Wishart D.S., et al. Recommendations of the wwPDB NMR Validation Task Force. Structure 2013, 21:1563-1570.
4. Henderson R., Sali A., Baker M.L., Carragher B., Devkota B., Downing K.H., Egelman E.H., Feng Z., Frank J., Grigorieff N., et al. Outcome of the first electron microscopy validation task force meeting. Structure 2012, 205-214.
5. Jacques D.A., Guss J.M., Svergun D.I., Trewhella J. Publication guidelines for structural modelling of small-angle scattering data from biomolecules in solution. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr 2012, 68:620-626.
6. Trewhella J., Hendrickson W.A., Kleywegt G.J., Sali A., Sato M., Schwede T., Svergun D.I., Tainer J.A., Westbrook J., Berman H.M. Report of the wwPDB Small-Angle Scattering Task Force: data requirements for biomolecular modeling and the PDB. Structure 2013, 21:875-881.
7. Schwede T., Sali A., Honig B., Levitt M., Berman H.M., Jones D., Brenner S.E., Burley S.K., Das R., Dokholyan N.V., et al. Outcome of a workshop on applications of protein models in biomedical research. Structure 2009, 151-159.
8. Berman H.M., Westbrook J., Feng Z., Gilliland G., Bhat T.N., Weissig H., Shindyalov I.N., Bourne P.E. The Protein Data Bank. Nucl Acids Res 2000, 28:235-242.
9. Saxton W.O., Baumeister W. The correlation averaging of a regularly arranged bacterial cell envelope protein. J Microsc 1982, 127:127-138.
10. Harauz G., van Heel M. Exact filters for general geometry three dimensional reconstruction. Proc IEEE Computer Vision Pattern Recogn 1986, 78:146-156.
11. Henderson R., Chen S., Chen J.Z., Grigorieff N., Passmore L.A., Ciccarelli L., Rubinstein J.L., Crowther R.A., Stewart P.L., Rosenthal P.B. Tilt-pair analysis of images from a range of different specimens in single-particle electron cryomicroscopy. J Mol Biol 2011, 413:1028-1046.
12. Scheres S.H.W., Chen S. Prevention of overfitting in cryo-EM structure determination. Nat Methods 2012, 9:853-854.
13. Chen S., McMullan G., Faruqi A.R., Murshudov G.N., Short J.M., Scheres S.H.W., Henderson R. High-resolution noise substitution to measure overfitting and validate resolution in 3D structure determination by single particle electron cryomicroscopy. Ultramicroscopy 2013, 135:24-35.
14. Stagg S.M., Noble A.J., Spilman M., Chapman M.S. ResLog plots as an empirical metric of the quality of cryo-EM reconstructions. J Struct Biol 2014, 185:418-426.
15. Rambo R.P., Tainer J.A. Accurate assessment of mass, models and resolution by small-angle scattering. Nature 2013, 496:477-481.
16. Rambo R.P., Tainer J.A. Characterizing flexible and intrinsically unstructured biological macromolecules by SAS using the Porod-Debye law. Biopolymers 2011, 95:559-571.
17. Haas J., Roth S., Arnold K., Kiefer F., Schmidt T., Bordoli L., Schwede T. The Protein Model Portal-a comprehensive resource for protein structure and model information. Database (Oxford) 2013, 2013. bat031.
18. Kryshtafovych A., Barbato A., Fidelis K., Monastyrskyy B., Schwede T., Tramontano A. Assessment of the assessment: evaluation of the model quality estimates in CASP10. Proteins 2014, 82(Suppl 2):112-126.
19. Sali A., Glaeser R., Earnest T., Baumeister W. From words to literature in structural proteomics. Nature 2003, 422:216-225.
20. Alber F., Dokudovskaya S., Veenhoff L.M., Zhang W., Kipper J., Devos D., Suprapto A., Karni-Schmidt O., Williams R., Chait B.T., et al. Determining the architectures of macromolecular assemblies. Nature 2007, 450:683-694.
21. Russel D., Lasker K., Webb B., Velázquez-Muriel J., Tjioe E., Schneidman-Duhovny D., Peterson B., Sali A. Putting the pieces together: integrative modeling platform software for structure determination of macromolecular assemblies. PLoS Biol 2012, 10:e1001244.
22. Ward A.B., Sali A., Wilson I.A. Biochemistry integrative structural biology. Science 2013, 339:913-915.
23. Habeck M. Statistical mechanics analysis of sparse data. J Struct Biol 2011, 173:541-548.
24. Borek D., Otwinowski Z. Everything happens at once-deconvolving systematic effects in X-ray data processing. Adv Methods Biomol Crystallogr 2013, 105-112.
25. Guentert P., Braun W., Billeter M. Automated stereospecific proton NMR assignments and their impact on the precision of protein structure determinations in solution. J Am Chem Soc 1989, 111:3997-4004.
26. Duhovny D., Nussinov R., Wolfson H.J. Efficient unbound docking of rigid molecules. Proceedings of the 2'nd Workshop on Algorithms in Bioinformatics (WABI) 2002, 185-200.
27. Murtola T., Bunker A., Vattulainen I., Deserno M., Karttunen M. Multiscale modeling of emergent materials: biological and soft matter. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2009, 11:1869-1892.
28. Kahraman A., Malmström L., Aebersold R. Xwalk: computing and visualizing distances in cross-linking experiments. Bioinformatics 2011, 27:2163-2164.
29. Burnley B.T., Afonine P.V., Adams P.D., Gros P. Modelling dynamics in protein crystal structures by ensemble refinement. Elife 2012, 1:e00311.
30. Lindorff-Larsen K., Best R.B., Depristo M.A., Dobson C.M., Vendruscolo M. Simultaneous determination of protein structure and dynamics. Nature 2005, 433:128-132.
31. Bernado P., Mylonas E., Petoukhov M.V., Blackledge M., Svergun D.I. Structural characterization of flexible proteins using small-angle X-ray scattering. J Am Chem Soc 2007, 129:5656-5664.
32. Pelikan M., Hura G.L., Hammel M. Structure and flexibility within proteins as identified through small angle X-ray scattering. Gen Physiol Biophys 2009, 28:174-189.
33. Rózycki B., Kim Y.C., Hummer G. SAXS ensemble refinement of ESCRT-III CHMP3 conformational transitions. Struct/Folding Design 2011, 19:109-116.
34. Berlin K., Castañeda C.A., Schneidman-Duhovny D., Sali A., Nava-Tudela A., Fushman D. Recovering a representative conformational ensemble from underdetermined macromolecular structural data. J Am Chem Soc 2013, 135:16595-16609.
35. Shatsky M., Hall R.J., Nogales E., Malik J., Brenner S.E. Automated multi-model reconstruction from single-particle electron microscopy data. J Struct Biol 2010, 170:98-108.
36. Rieping W., Habeck M., Nilges M. Inferential structure determination. Science 2005, 309:303-306.
37. Nilges M., Bernard A., Bardiaux B., Malliavin T., Habeck M., Rieping W. Accurate NMR structures through minimization of an extended hybrid energy. Struct/Folding Design 2008, 16:1305-1312.
38. Scheres S.H.W. RELION: implementation of a Bayesian approach to cryo-EM structure determination. J Struct Biol 2012, 180:519-530.
39. Scheres S.H.W. A Bayesian view on cryo-EM structure determination. J Mol Biol 2012, 415:406-418.
40. Rieping W., Nilges M., Habeck M. ISD: a software package for Bayesian NMR structure calculation. Bioinformatics 2008, 24:1104-1105.
41. Fernández I.S., Bai X-C., Hussain T., Kelley A.C., Lorsch J.R., Ramakrishnan V., Scheres S.H.W. Molecular architecture of a eukaryotic translational initiation complex. Science 2013, 342:1240585.
42. Bai X-C., Fernández I.S., McMullan G., Scheres S.H. Ribosome structures to near-atomic resolution from thirty thousand cryo-EM particles. Elife 2013, 2:e00461.
43. Sauerwald A., Sandin S., Cristofari G., Scheres S.H.W., Lingner J., Rhodes D. Structure of active dimeric human telomerase. Nat Struct Mol Biol 2013, 20:454-460.
44. Cossio P., Hummer G. Bayesian analysis of individual electron microscopy images: towards structures of dynamic and heterogeneous biomolecular assemblies. J Struct Biol 2013, 184:427-437.
45. Molnar K.S., Bonomi M., Pellarin R., Clinthorne G.D., Gonzalez G., Goldberg S.D., Sali A., DeGrado W.F. Cys-scanning Disulfide crosslinking and Bayesian modeling suggest scissoring motions in the histidine kinase, PhoQ. Structure 2014, 22. (in press), pii:S0969-2126(14)00204-4.
46. Street T.O., Zeng X., Pellarin R., Bonomi M., Sali A., Kelly M.J.S., Chu F., Agard D.A. Elucidating the mechanism of substrate recognition by the bacterial Hsp90 molecular chaperone. J Mol Biol 2014, 426:2393-2404.
47. Bonomi M, Muller EGD, Pellarin R, Kim SJ, Russel D, Ramsden R, Sundin BA, Davis TN, Sali A. Protein complex structures from Bayesian modeling of in vivo FRET data. Mol Cell Proteomics.
48. Dong G.Q., Fan H., Schneidman-Duhovny D., Webb B., Sali A. Optimized atomic statistical potentials: assessment of protein interfaces and loops. Bioinformatics 2013, 29:3158-3166.
49. Alber F., Dokudovskaya S., Veenhoff L.M., Zhang W., Kipper J., Devos D., Suprapto A., Karni-Schmidt O., Williams R., Chait B.T., et al. The molecular architecture of the nuclear pore complex. Nature 2007, 450:695-701.
50. Efron B, Efron B. The jackknife, the bootstrap and other resampling plans. 1982. http://epubs.siam.org/doi/abs/10.1137/1.9781611970319.fm.
51. Tjong H., Gong K., Chen L., Alber F. Physical tethering and volume exclusion determine higher-order genome organization in budding yeast. Genome Res 2012, 22:1295-1305.
52. Lasker K., Förster F., Bohn S., Walzthoeni T., Villa E., Unverdorben P., Beck F., Aebersold R., Sali A., Baumeister W. Molecular architecture of the 26S proteasome holocomplex determined by an integrative approach. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2012, 109:1380-1387.
53. Loquet A., Sgourakis N.G., Gupta R., Giller K., Riedel D., Goosmann C., Griesinger C., Kolbe M., Baker D., Becker S., et al. Atomic model of the type III secretion system needle. Nature 2012, 486:276-279.
54. Murakami K., Elmlund H., Kalisman N., Bushnell D.A., Adams C.M., Azubel M., Elmlund D., Levi-Kalisman Y., Liu X., Gibbons B.J., et al. Architecture of an RNA polymerase II transcription pre-initiation complex. Science 2013, 342:1238724.
55. Kalisman N., Adams C.M., Levitt M. Subunit order of eukaryotic TRiC/CCT chaperonin by cross-linking, mass spectrometry, and combinatorial homology modeling. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2012, 109:2884-2889.
56. Tosi A., Haas C., Herzog F., Gilmozzi A., Berninghausen O., Ungewickell C., Gerhold C.B., Lakomek K., Aebersold R., Beckmann R., et al. Structure and subunit topology of the INO80 chromatin remodeler and its nucleosome complex. Cell 2013, 154:1207-1219.
57. Ciferri C., Lander G.C., Maiolica A., Herzog F., Aebersold R., Nogales E. Molecular architecture of human polycomb repressive complex 2. Elife 2012, 1:e00005.
58. Greber B.J., Boehringer D., Leitner A., Bieri P., Voigts-Hoffmann F., Erzberger J.P., Leibundgut M., Aebersold R., Ban N. Architecture of the large subunit of the mammalian mitochondrial ribosome. Nature 2014, 505:515-519.
59. Erzberger JP, Stengel F, Pellarin R, Zhang S, Schaefer T, Ayelett CH, Cimermančič P, Boehringer D, Sali A, Aebersold R, et al.: Molecular architecture of the 40S•eIF1•eIF3 translation initiation complex. Cell, 158 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2014.07.044 (in press).
60. Politis A., Stengel F., Hall Z., Hernández H., Leitner A., Walzthoeni T., Robinson C.V., Aebersold R. A mass spectrometry-based hybrid method for structural modeling of protein complexes. Nat Methods 2014, 10.1038/nmeth.2841.
61. Boura E., Rózycki B., Herrick D.Z., Chung H.S., Vecer J., Eaton W.A., Cafiso D.S., Hummer G., Hurley J.H. Solution structure of the ESCRT-I complex by small-angle X-ray scattering, EPR, and FRET spectroscopy. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2011, 108:9437-9442.
62. Huang J-R., Warner L.R., Sanchez C., Gabel F., Madl T., Mackereth C.D., Sattler M., Blackledge M. Transient electrostatic interactions dominate the conformational equilibrium sampled by multi-domain splicing factor U2AF65: a combined NMR and SAXS study. J Am Chem Soc 2014, 10.1021/ja502030n.
63. Deshmukh L., Schwieters C.D., Grishaev A., Ghirlando R., Baber J.L., Clore G.M. Structure and dynamics of full-length HIV-1 capsid protein in solution. J Am Chem Soc 2013, 135:16133-16147.
64. Baù D., Sanyal A., Lajoie B.R., Capriotti E., Byron M., Lawrence J.B., Dekker J., Marti-Renom M.A. The three-dimensional folding of the α-globin gene domain reveals formation of chromatin globules. Nat Struct Mol Biol 2011, 18:107-114.
65. Baù D., Marti-Renom M.A. Structure determination of genomic domains by satisfaction of spatial restraints. Chromosome Res 2011, 19:25-35.
66. Kalhor R., Tjong H., Jayathilaka N., Alber F., Chen L. Genome architectures revealed by tethered chromosome conformation capture and population-based modeling. Nat Biotechnol 2012, 30:90-98.