Big-fish-little-pond social comparison and local dominance effects: Integrating new statistical models, methodology, design, theory and substantive implications

Learning and Instruction

Volumn 33, Issue , 2014, Pages 50-66

  Marsh, Herbert W ^a,b,c   Kuyper, Hans ^d   Morin, Alexandre J S ^a   Parker, Philip D ^a   Seaton, Marjorie ^a  

^a AUSTRALIAN CATHOLIC UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

^b UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD   (United Kingdom)

^c KING SAUD UNIVERSITY   (Saudi Arabia)

^d UNIVERSITY OF GRONINGEN   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Academic self concept; Big fish little pond effect (BFLPE); Local dominance effect; Multilevel structural equation models; Social comparison processes

Indexed keywords

EID: 84899805059     PISSN: 09594752     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.learninstruc.2014.04.002     Document Type: Article

References (64)

1. Alicke M.D., Zell E., Bloom D.L. Mere categorization and the frog-pond effect. Psychological Science 2010, 21:174-177. 10.1177/0956797609357718.
2. Asparouhov T., Muthen B. Bayesian analysis of latent variable models using Mplus 2010, http://www.statmodel.com/download/Bayes3.pdf.
3. Beauducel A., Herzberg P. On the performance of maximum likelihood versus means and variance adjusted weighted least squares estimation in CFA. Structural Equation Modeling 2006, 13:186-203. 10.1207/s15328007sem1302_2.
4. Blanton H., Buunk B.P., Gibbons F.X., Kuyper H. When better-than -others compare upward: choice of comparison and comparative evaluation as independent predictors of academic performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1999, 76:420-430. 10.1037/0022-3514.76.3.420.
5. Chen S., Yeh Y., Hwang F., Lin S.S.J. The relationship between academic self-concept and achievement: a multicohort-multioccasion study. Learning and Individual Differences 2013, 23:172-178. 10.1016/j.lindif.2012.07.021.
6. Cialdini R.B., Borden R.J., Thorne A., Walker M.R., Freeman S., Sloan L.R. Basking in reflected glory: three (football) field studies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1976, 34:366-375. 10.1037/0022-3514.34.3.366.
7. Cialdini R.B., Richardson K.D. Two indirect tactics of image management: basking and blasting. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1980, 39:406-415. 10.1037/0022-3514.39.3.406.
8. Coleman J.M., Fults B.A. Special class placement, level of intelligence, and the self-concepts of gifted children: a social comparison perspective. Remedial and Special Education 1985, 6:7-11. 10.1177/074193258500600103.
9. Dai D.Y. How universal is the big-fish-little-pond effect?. American Psychologist 2004, 59:267-268. 10.1037/0003-066X.59.4.267.
10. Dai D.Y., Rinn A.N. The big-fish-little-pond effect: what do we know and where do we go from here?. Educational Psychological Review 2008, 20:283-317. 10.1007/s10648-008-9071-x.
11. Davis J.A. The campus as a frog pond: an application of theory of relative deprivation to career decisions for college men. American Journal of Sociology 1966, 72:17-31. 10.1086/224257.
12. DiStefano C. The impact of categorization with confirmatory factor analysis. Structural Equation Modeling 2002, 9:327-346. 10.1207/S15328007SEM0903_2.
13. Dolan C.V. Factor analysis of variables with 2, 3, 5 and 7 response categories: a comparison of categorical variable estimators using simulated data. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology 1994, 47:309-326. 10.1111/j.2044-8317.1994.tb01039.x.
14. Festinger L. Atheory of social comparison processes. Human Relations 1954, 7:117-140. 10.1177/001872675400700202.
15. Gladwell M. David and goliath: Underdogs, misfits, and the Art of Battling giants 2013, Little, Brown & Company, Boston MA.
16. Guay F., Larose S., Boivin M. Academic self-concept and educational attainment level: a ten-year longitudinal study. Self and Identity 2004, 3:1-16. 10.1080/13576500342000040.
17. Hambleton R.K., Swaminathan H., Rogers H.J. Fundamentals of item response theory 1991, Sage Publications, London.
18. Hattie J.A.C. Classroom composition and peer effects. International Journal of Educational Research 2002, 37:449-481. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0883-0355(03)00015-6.
19. Hattie J.A.C. Visible learning. A synthesis of over 800 meta-analyses relating to achievement 2009, Routledge, London.
20. Helson H. Adaptation-level theory 1964, Harper & Row, New York.
21. Huguet P., Dumas F., Marsh H.W., Regner I., Wheeler L., Suls J., et al. Clarifying the role of social comparison in the Big-Fish-Little-Pond Effect (BFLPE): an integrative study. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2009, 97:671-710. 10.1037/a0015558.
22. Huguet P., Dumas F., Monteil J.M., Genestoux N. Social comparison choices in the classroom: further evidence for students' upward comparison tendency and its beneficial impact on performance. European Journal of Social Psychology 2001, 31:557-578. 10.1002/ejsp.81.
23. James W. The principles of psychology 1890/1963, Holt, Rinehart & Winston, New York.
24. Jöreskog K.G. Statistical estimation of structural models in longitudinal investigations. Longitudinal research in the study of behavior and development 1979, 303-351. Academic Press, New York. J.R. Nesselroade, B. Baltes (Eds.).
25. Kuyper H., Dijkstra P., Buunk A.P., Van der Werf M.P.C. Social comparisons in the classroom: an investigation of the better than average effect among secondary school children. Journal of School Psychology 2011, 49:25-53. 10.1016/j.jsp.2010.10.002.
26. Liem G.A.D., Marsh H.W., Martin A.J., McInerney D.M., Yeung A.S. The big-fish-little-pond effect and a national policy of within-school ability streaming: alternative frames of reference. American Educational Research Journal 2013, 50(2):326-370. 10.3102/0002831212464511.
27. Lüdtke O., Marsh H.W., Robitzsch A., Trautwein U. A2× 2 taxonomy of multilevel latent contextual models: accuracy-bias trade-offs in full and partial error-correction models. Psychological Methods 2011, 16:444-467. 10.1037/a0024376.
28. Lüdtke O., Marsh H.W., Robitzsch A., Trautwein U., Asparouhov T., Muthén B. The multilevel latent covariate model: a new, more reliable approach to group-level effects in contextual studies. Psychological Methods 2008, 13:203-229. 10.1037/a0012869.
29. Lynch S.M. Introduction to applied Bayesian statistics and estimation for social scientists 2007, Springer, New York.
30. Marsh H.W. Self-concept: the application of a frame of reference model to explain paradoxical results. Australian Journal of Education 1984, 28:165-181.
31. Marsh H.W. The big-fish-little-pond effect on academic self-concept. Journal of Educational Psychology 1987, 79(3):280-295. 10.1037/0022-0663.79.3.280.
32. Marsh H.W. Failure of high ability schools to deliver academic benefits commensurate with their students' ability levels. American Educational Research Journal 1991, 28:445-480. 10.2307/1162948.
33. Marsh H.W. Self-concept theory, measurement and research into practice: The role of self-concept in educational psychology 2007, British Psychological Society, Leicester.
34. Marsh H.W., Abduljabbar A.S., Abu-Hilal M.M., Morin A.J.S., Abdelfattah F., Leung K.C., Parker P. Factorial, convergent, and discriminant validity of TIMSS math and science motivation measures: a comparison of Arab and Anglo-Saxon countries. Journal of Educational Psychology 2013, 105(1):108-128. 10.1037/a0029907.
35. Marsh H.W., Chessor D., Craven R., Roche L. The effect of gifted and talented programs on academic self-concept: the big fish strikes again. American Educational Research Journal 1995, 32(2):285-319. 10.2307/1163433.
36. Marsh H.W., Hau K.-T. Assessing goodness of fit: is parsimony always desirable?. Journal of Experimental Education 1996, 64:364-390.
37. Marsh H.W., Hau K.T. Big fish little pond effect on academic self-concept: a crosscultural (26 country) test of the negative effects of academically selective schools. American Psychologist 2003, 58:364-376. 10.1037/0003-066X.58.5.364.
38. Marsh H.W., Hau K.T. Explaining paradoxical relations between academic self-concepts and achievements: cross-cultural generalizability of the internal-external frame of reference predictions across 26 countries. Journal of Educational Psychology 2004, 96:56-67. 10.1037/0022-0663.96.1.56.
39. Marsh H.W., Hau K.-T. Applications of latent-variable models in educational psychology: the need for methodological-substantive synergies. Contemporary Educational Psychology 2007, 32:151-171. 10.1016/j.cedpsych.2006.10.008.
40. Marsh H.W., Hau K.-T., Craven R. The big-fish-little-pond effect stands up to scrutiny. American Psychologist 2004, 59(4):269-271. 10.1037/0003-066X.59.4.269.
41. Marsh H.W., Kong C.-K., Hau K.-T. Longitudinal multilevel models of the big-fish-little-pond effect on academic self-concept: counterbalancing contrast and reflected-glory effects in Hong Kong schools. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2000, 78(2):337-349. 10.1037/0022-3514.78.2.337.
42. Marsh H.W., Lüdtke O., Nagengast B., Trautwein U., Morin A.J.S., Abduljabbar A.S., et al. Classroom climate and contextual effects: conceptual and methodological issues in the evaluation of group-level effects. Educational Psychologist 2012, 47:106-124. 10.1080/00461520.2012.670488.
43. Marsh H.W., Lütdke O., Robitzsch A., Trautwein U., Asparouhov T., Muthén B., et al. Doubly-latent models of school contextual effects: integrating multilevel and structural equation approaches to control measurement and sampling error. Multivariate Behavioral Research 2009, 44:764-802. 10.1080/00273170903333665.
44. Marsh H.W., O'Mara A.J. Long-term total negative effects of school-average ability on diverse educational outcomes: direct and indirect effects of the big-fish-little-pond effect. Zeitschrift für Pädagogische Psychologie/German Journal of Educational Psychology 2010, 24(1):51-72. 10.1024/1010-0652.a000004.
45. Marsh H.W., Parker J.W. Determinants of student self-concept: is it better to be a relatively large fish in a small pond even if you don't learn to swim as well?. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1984, 47(1):213-231. 10.1037/0022-3514.47.1.213.
46. Marsh H.W., Rowe K.J. The negative effects of school-average ability on academic self-concept - an application of multilevel modeling. Australian Journal of Education 1996, 40:65-87. 10.1177/000494419604000105.
47. Marsh H.W., Seaton M., Trautwein U., Lüdtke O., Hau K.T., O'Mara A.J., et al. The big-fish-little-pond-effect stands up to critical scrutiny: implications for theory, methodology, and future research. Educational Psychology Review 2008, 20(3):319-350. 10.1007/s10648-008-9075-6.
48. Meelissen M., Punter A. The Netherlands. TIMSS 2011 encyclopedia: Education policy and curriculum in mathematics and science 2012, Vol. 2:619-630. TIMSS & PIRLS International Study Center, Boston College.
49. Mehta P.D., Neale M.C. People are variables too: multilevel structural equation modeling. Psychological Methods 2005, 10:259-284. 10.1037/1082-989X.10.3.259.
50. Möller J., Pohlmann B., Köller O., Marsh H.W. Ameta-analytic path analysis of the internal/external frame of reference model of academic achievement and academic self-concept. Review of Educational Research 2009, 79:1129-1167.
51. Morin A.J.S., Marsh H.W., Nagengast B., Scalas L.F. Doubly latent multilevel analyses of classroom climate: an illustration. Journal of Experimental Education 2014, 82:143-167. 10.1080/00220973.2013.769412.
52. Muthén B., Kaplan D. Acomparison of some methodologies for the factor analysis of non-normal Likert variables. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology 1985, 38(2):171-189. 10.1111/j.2044-8317.1985.tb00832.x.
53. Muthén L.K., Muthén B.O. Mplus user's guide 2008-2013, Muthén & Muthén, Los Angeles, CA.
54. Nagengast B., Marsh H.W. Big fish in little ponds aspire more: mediation and cross-cultural generalizability of school-average ability effects on self-concept and career aspirations in science. Journal of Educational Psychology 2012, 104(4):1033-1053. 10.1037/a0027697.
55. Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development PISA 2003 technical report 2005, Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris.
56. Parker P.D., Marsh H.W., Lüdtke O., Trautwein U. Differential school contextual effects for math and English: integrating the big-fish-little-pond effect and the internal/external frame of reference. Learning and Instruction 2013, 23:78-89. 10.1016/j.learninstruc.2012.07.001.
57. Pinxten M., De Fraine B., Van Damme J., D'Haenens E. Causal ordering of academic self-concept and achievement: effects of type of achievement measure. British Journal of Educational Psychology 2010, 80:689-709. 10.1348/000709910X493071.
58. Scheerens J., Luyten H., van Ravens J. Perspectives on educational quality: Illustrative outcomes on primary and secondary schooling in the Netherlands 2011, Springer, New York.
59. Seaton M., Marsh H.W. Methodological innovation in big-fish-little-pond effect research: methodological-substantive synergy at work. International advances in self research 2013, Vol. 4:161-181. Information Age Publishing, Charlotte, NC.
60. Seaton M., Marsh H.W., Craven R.G. Earning its place as a pan-human theory: universality of the big-fish-little-pond effect across 41 culturally and economically diverse countries. Journal of Educational Psychology 2009, 101(2):403-419. 10.1037/a0013838.
61. Seaton M., Marsh H.W., Dumas F., Huguet P., Monteil J.-M., Régner I., et al. In search of the big fish: investigating the coexistence of the big-fish-little-pond effect with the positive effects of upward comparisons. British Journal of Social Psychology 2008, 47:73-103. 10.1348/014466607X202309.
62. Trautwein U., Lüdtke O., Marsh H.W., Nagy G. Within-school social comparison: how students perceive the standing of their class predicts academic self-concept. Journal of Educational Psychology 2009, 101:853-866. 10.1037/a0016306.
63. Upshaw H.S. The personal reference scale: an approach to social judgment. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 1969, 4:315-370. L. Berkowitz (Ed.).
64. Zell E., Alicke M.D. Contextual neglect, self-evaluation, and the frog-pond effect. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2009, 97(3):467-482. 10.1037/a0015453.