Communicating likelihoods and probabilities in forecasts of volcanic eruptions

Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research

Volumn 272, Issue , 2014, Pages 1-15

  Doyle, Emma E H ^a   McClure, John ^b   Johnston, David M ^a,c   Paton, Douglas ^d  

^a MASSEY UNIVERSITY   (New Zealand)

^b VICTORIA UNIVERSITY OF WELLINGTON   (New Zealand)

^c GNS SCIENCE   (New Zealand)

^d UNIVERSITY OF TASMANIA   (Australia)

Author keywords

Communicating probabilities; Forecasts; Perception; Volcanology; Warnings

Indexed keywords

DECISION MAKING PROCESS; EARTHQUAKE AFTERSHOCKS; EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT; EMERGENCY WARNINGS; PUBLIC INFORMATION; VOLCANIC ERUPTIONS; VOLCANOLOGY; WARNINGS;

BEHAVIORAL RESEARCH; DECISION MAKING; EARTHQUAKES; RISK MANAGEMENT; SENSORY PERCEPTION; VEHICLE ROUTING; VOLCANOES;

FORECASTING;

AFTERSHOCK; DECISION MAKING; EARLY WARNING SYSTEM; FORECASTING METHOD; PERCEPTION; PROBABILITY; VOLCANIC EARTHQUAKE; VOLCANIC ERUPTION; VOLCANOLOGY;

EID: 84892630090     PISSN: 03770273     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jvolgeores.2013.12.006     Document Type: Article

References (92)

1. Aspinall W., Cooke R. Expert judgement and the Montserrat Volcano eruption. Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Probabilistic Safety Assessment and Management PSAM4, September 13th-18th. New York, USA 1998, 2113-2118. A. Mosleh, R.A. Bari (Eds.).
2. Aspinall W., Loughlin S.C., Michael F.V., Miller A.D., Norton G.E., Rowley K.C., Sparks R.S.J., Young S.R. The Montserrat Volcano Observatory; its evolution, organization, role and activities. The Eruption of Soufriere Hills Volcano, Montserrat From 1995 to 1999 2002, 71-91. The Geological Society of London, London, UK. T.H. Druit, B.P. Kokelaar (Eds.).
3. Atman C.J., Bostrom A., Fischhoff B., Morgan M.G. Designing risk communications: completing and correcting mental models of hazardous processes, part I. Risk Anal. 1994, 14(5):779-788.
4. Baxter P.J., Aspinall W.P., Neri A., Zuccaro G., Spence R.J.S., Cioni R., Woo G. Emergency planning and mitigation at Vesuvius: a new evidence-based approach. J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 2008, 178:454-473.
5. Bebbington M.S., Lai C.D. Statistical analysis of New Zealand volcanic occurrence data. J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 1996, 74:101-110.
6. Bordens K.S., Abbot B.B. Research Design and Methods: A Process Approach 1999, 526. Mayfield Publishing Company, Mountain View, California. 4th ed.
7. Borodzicz E., van Haperen K. Individual and group learning in crisis simulations. J. Conting. Crisis Manag. 2002, 10(3):139-147.
8. Bostrom A. Putting seismic risk and uncertainty on the map, a response to Pang's paper "Visualising uncertainty in natural hazards". Volume 14 of Risk, Governance and Society 2008, 14:306-310. Springer Verlag, Berlin. A. Bostrom, S. French, S. Gottlieb (Eds.).
9. Bostrom A., Fischhoff B., Granger Morgan M. Characterizing mental models of hazardous processes: a methodology and an application to radon. J. Soc. Issues 1992, 48(4):85-100.
10. Bruine De Bruin W.B., Fischhoff B., Millstein S.G., Halpern-Felsher B.L. Verbal and numerical expressions of probability: "It's a fifty-fifty chance.". Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process. 2000, 81(1):115-131.
11. Brun W., Teigen K.H. Verbal probabilities: ambiguous, context-dependent, or both?. Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process. 1988, 41:390-404.
12. Budescu D.V., Karelitz T.M., Wallsten T.S. Predicting the directionality of probability words from their membership functions. J. Behav. Decis. Mak. 2003, 16(3):159-180.
13. Budescu D.V., Broomell S., Por H.-H. Improving communication of uncertainty in the reports of the intergovernmental panel on climate change. Psychol. Sci. 2009, 20(3):299-308.
14. Cannon-Bowers J.A., Bell H.E. Training decision makers for complex environments: implications of the naturalistic decision making perspective. Naturalistic Decision Making 1997, 99-110. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. C.E. Zsambok, G. Klein (Eds.).
15. Connor C.B., McBirney A.R., Furlan C. What is the probability of explosive eruption at a long-dormant volcano?. Special Publications of IAVCEI 2006, 1:39-46. Geological Society, London. H.M. Mader, S.G. Coles, C.B. Connor, L.J. Connor (Eds.).
16. Cosmides L., Tooby J. Are humans good intuitive statisticians after all? Rethinking some conclusions from the literature on judgment under uncertainty. Cognition 1996, 58(1):1-73.
17. Crego J., Spinks T. Critical incident management simulation. Decision Making Under Stress: Emerging Themes and Applications 1997, 85-94. Ashgate Publishing Limited, Aldershot, England. R. Flin (Ed.).
18. Crichton M., Flin R. Command decision making. Incident Command: Tales from the Hot Seat 2002, 201-238. Ashgate Publishing Limited, Aldershot, England. R. Flin, K. Arbuthnot (Eds.).
19. Cronin S.J. The Auckland Volcano Scientific Advisory Group during Exercise Ruaumoko: observations and recommendations. Civil Defence Emergency Management: Exercise Ruaumoko 2008, Auckland Regional Council, Auckland.
20. Dhami M.K., Wallsten T.S. Interpersonal comparison of subjective probabilities: toward translating linguistic probabilities. Mem. Cogn. 2005, 33(6):1057-1068.
21. Dieckmann N.F., Mauro R., Slovic P. The effects of presenting imprecise probabilities in intelligence forecasts. Risk Anal. 2010, 30(6):987-1001.
22. Donovan A., Oppenheimer C., Bravo M. The use of belief-based probabilistic methods in volcanology: scientists' views and implications for risk assessments. J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 2012, 247-248:168-180.
23. Doyle E.E., Johnston D.M. Science advice for critical decision-making. Working in High Risk Environments: Developing Sustained Resilience 2011, 69-92. Charles C Thomas, Springfield, Illinois, USA. D. Paton, J. Violanti (Eds.).
24. Doyle E.E.H., Johnston D.M., McClure J., Paton M. The communication of uncertain scientific advice during natural hazard events. N. Z. J. Psychol. 2011, 40(4):39-50.
25. Eiser J.R., Bostrom A., Burton I., Johnston D.M., McClure J., Paton D., van der Pligt J., White M.P. Risk interpretation and action: a conceptual framework for responses to natural hazards. Int. J. Disaster Risk Reduct. 2012, 1:5-16.
26. Endsley M.R. The role of situation awareness in naturalistic decision making. Naturalistic Decision Making 1997, 269-284. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. C.E. Zsambok, G. Klein (Eds.).
27. Fischhoff B., Slovic P., Lichtenstein S. Lay foibles and expert fables in judgements about risk. Am. Stat. 1982, 36(3):240-255.
28. Gigerenzer G., Edwards A. Simple tools for understanding risks: from innumeracy to insight. Br. Med. J. 2003, 327(7417):741.
29. Gigerenzer G., Hoffrage U. How to improve Bayesian reasoning without instruction: frequency formats. Psychol. Rev. 1995, 102(4):684-704.
30. Gigerenzer G., Hoffrage U. Overcoming difficulties in Bayesian reasoning: a reply to Lewis and Keren (1999) and Mellers and McGraw (1999). Psychol. Rev. 1999, 106(2):425-430.
31. Gigerenzer G., Hertwig R., van den Broek E., Fasolo B., Katsikopoulos K.V. "A 30 % chance of rain tomorrow": how does the public understand probabilistic weather forecasts?. Risk Anal. 2005, 25(3).
32. Gill J., et al. Guidelines on Communicating Forecast Uncertainty 2008, World Meteorological Organization, (WMO/TD No. 4122).
33. Haynes K., Barclay J., Pidgeon N. Whose reality counts? Factors affecting the perception of volcanic risk. J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 2008, 172(3-4):259-272.
34. Heath R., Lee J., Ni L. Crisis and risk approaches to emergency management planning and communication: the role of similarity and sensitivity. J. Public Relat. Res. 2009, 21(2):123-141.
35. Honda H., Yamagishi K. Directional verbal probabilities. Exp. Psychol. 2006, 53(3):161-170.
36. Houghton J.T., Ding Y., Griggs D.J., Noguer M., van Der Linden P.J., Dai X., Maskell K., Johnson C.A. Climate Change 2001: The Scientific Basis - Cambridge University Press 2002, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.
37. IAVCEI Subcomittee for Crisis Protocols Professional conduct of scientists during volcanic crises. Bull. Volcanol. 1999, 60:323-334.
38. Iversen G., Brown S., Melamed L., Cobb G., Fisher R. Random assignment. The SAGE Encyclopedia of Social Science Research Methods 2004, 908-909. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA. M.S. Lewis-Beck, A. Bryman, T. Futing Liao (Eds.).
39. Johnson-Laird P.N. Mental Models: Towards a Cognitive Science of Language, Inference and Consciousness 1983, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA. 5th ed.
40. Joslyn S.L., Nichols R.M. Probability or frequency? Expressing forecast uncertainty in public weather forecasts. Meteorol. Appl. 2009, 16(3):309-314.
41. Joslyn S.L., Nadav-Greenberg L., Taing M.U., Nichols R.M. The effects of wording on the understanding and use of uncertainty information in a threshold forecasting decision. Appl. Cogn. Psychol. 2009, 23(1):55-72.
42. Karelitz T.M., Budescu D.V. You say "probable" and I say "likely": improving interpersonal communication with verbal probability phrases. J. Exp. Psychol. Appl. 2004, 10(1):25-41.
43. Kuhberger A. The influence of framing on risky decisions: a meta-analysis. Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process. 1998, 75(1):23-55.
44. Levin I.P., Schneider S.L., Gaeth G.J. All frames are not created equal: a typology and critical analysis of framing effects. Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process. 1998, 76(2):149-188.
45. Lindsay J., Marzocchi W., Jolly G., Constantinescu R., Selva J., Sandri L. Towards real-time eruption forecasting in the Auckland Volcanic Field: application of BET_EF during the New Zealand National Disaster Exercise "Ruaumoko.". Bull. Volcanol. 2009, 72(2):185-204.
46. Lipkus I.M. Numeric, verbal, and visual formats of conveying health risks: suggested best practices and future recommendations. Med. Decis. Making 2010, 27(5):696-713.
47. Lipshitz R., Klein G., Orasanu J., Salas E. Focus article: taking stock of naturalistic decision making. J. Behav. Decis. Mak. 2001, 14(5):331-352.
48. Statistics in Volcanology. Special Publications of the International Association of Volcanology and Chemistry of the Earth's Interior 2006, 1. The Geological Society, London, England, (285 pp.). H.M. Mader, S.G. Coles, C.B. Connor, L.J. Connor (Eds.).
49. Martin L., Flin R., Skriver J. Emergency decision making - a wider decision framework?. Decision Making Under Stress: Emerging Themes and Applications 1997, 280-290. Ashgate Publishing Limited, Aldershot, England. R. Flin (Ed.).
50. Marzocchi W., Woo G. Probabilistic eruption forecasting and the call for an evacuation. Geophys. Res. Lett. 2007, 34(22):1-4.
51. Marzocchi W., Woo G. Principles of volcanic risk metrics: theory and the case study of Mt. Vesuvius and Campi Flegrei (Italy). J. Geophys. Res. 2009, 114(B03213). 10.1029/2008JB005908.
52. Marzocchi W., Sandri L., Gasparinii P., Newhall C., Boschi E. Quantifying probabilities of volcanic events: the example of volcanic hazard at Mount Vesuvius. J. Geophys. Res. 2004, 109(B11201). 10.1029/2004JB003155.
53. Marzocchi W., Sandri L., Furlan C. A quantitative model for volcanic hazard assessment. Special Publications of IAVCEI 2006, 1:31-38. Geological Society, London. H.M. Mader, S.G. Coles, C.B. Connor, L.J. Connor (Eds.).
54. Marzocchi W., Newhall C., Woo G. The scientific management of volcanic crises. J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 2012, 247-248:181-189.
55. McClure J., Sibley C.G. Framing effects on disaster preparation: is negative framing more effective?. Aust. J. Disaster Trauma Stud. 2011, 2011-1. (http://www.massey.ac.nz/trauma/issues/2011-1/mcclure.htm). 1174-4707.
56. McClure J., Sutton R.M., Sibley C.G. Listening to reporters or engineers: how different messages about building design affect earthquake fatalism. J. Appl. Psychol. 2007, 37:1956-1973.
57. McClure J., White J., Sibley C.G. Framing effects on preparation intentions: distinguishing actions and outcomes. Disaster Prev. Manage. 2009, 18:187-199.
58. MCDEM Exercise Ruaumoko '08 Final Exercise Report 2008, Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management, The Department of Internal Affairs, NZ, Wellington, NZ, (Accessed from http://www.civildefence.govt.nz/memwebsite.nsf/Files/National%20Exercise%20Programme/$file/ExRuaumoko-FINAL-REPORT-Aug08.pdf).
59. McGuire W.J., Solana M.C., Kilburn C.R.J., Sanderson D. Improving communication during volcanic crises on small, vulnerable islands. J. Volcanol. Geotherm. Res. 2009, 183(1-2):63-75.
60. Morgan M.G., Fischhoff B., Bostrom A., Atman C.J. Risk Communication: A Mental Models Approach 2002, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, (351 pp.).
61. Morss R.E., Demuth J.L., Lazo J.K. Communicating uncertainty in weather forecasts: a survey of the U.S. public. Weather Forecast. 2008, 23(5):974.
62. Moss R.H., Schneider S.H. Uncertainties in the IPCC TAR: recommendations to lead authors for more consistent assessment and reporting. IPCC Supporting Material, Guidance Papers on the Cross Cutting Issues of the Third Assessment Report of the IPCC 2000, 33-51. R. Pachauri, T. Taniguchi, K. Tanaka (Eds.).
63. MVO Montserrat Volcano Observatory Scientific Advisory Committee Reports (last accessed 25th August 2010). http://www.mvo.ms/.
64. Neace W.P., Michaud S., Bolling L., Deer K., Zecevic L. Frequency formats, probability formats, or problem structure? A test of the nested-sets hypothesis in an extensional reasoning task. Judgm. Decis. Making 2008, 3(2):140-152.
65. Newhall C.G., Hoblitt R.P. Constructing event trees for volcanic crises. Bull. Volcanol. 2002, 64:3-20. 10.1007/s004450100173.
66. Paton D., Jackson D. Developing disaster management capability: an assessment centre approach. Disaster Prev. Manage. 2002, 11(2):115-122.
67. Paton D., McClure J. Preparing for Disaster: Building Household and Community Capacity 2013, Charles C Thomas Pub Ltd, (246 pp.).
68. Paton D., Smith L., Violanti J. Disaster response: risk, vulnerability and resilience. Disaster Prev. Manage. 2000, 9(3):173-180.
69. Patt A., Dessai S. Communicating uncertainty: lessons learned and suggestions for climate change assessment. C. R. Geosci. 2005, 337(4):425-441.
70. Patt A., Schrag D.P. Using specific language to describe risk and probability. Clim. Chang. 2003, 61:17-30.
71. Pliske R.M., McCloskey M.J., Klein G. Decision skills training: facilitating learning from experience. Linking Expertise and Naturalistic Decision Making 2001, 37-53. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. E. Salas, G. Klein (Eds.).
72. Risbey J.S., Kandlikar M. Expressions of likelihood and confidence in the IPCC uncertainty assessment process. Clim. Chang. 2007, 85(1-2):19-31.
73. Russo J.E., Schoemaker P.J.H. Decision traps 1989, Simon & Schuster, New York.
74. Salas E., Stout R.J., Cannon-Bowers J.A. The role of shared mental models in developing shared situational awareness. Situational Awareness in Complex Systems: Proceedings of a Cahfa Conference 1994, 298-304. Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University Press, Daytona Beach, FL. R.D. Gilson, D.J. Garland, J.M. Koonce (Eds.).
75. Siegrist M. Communicating low risk magnitudes: incidence rates expressed as frequency versus rates expressed as probability. Risk Anal. 1997, 17(4):8-11.
76. Smith R. Research, science and emergency management: partnering for resilience. Tephra, Community Resilience: Research, Planning and Civil Defence Emergency Management 2009, 71-78. Ministry of Civil Defence & Emergency Management, Wellington, New Zealand.
77. Sobradelo R., Marti J. Bayesian event tree for long-term volcanic hazard assessment: application to Teide-Pico Viejo stratovolcanoes, Tenerife, Canary Islands. J. Geophys. Res. 2010, 115(B05206). 10.1029/2009JB006566.
78. Sparks R.S.J. Forecasting volcanic eruptions. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 2003, 210(1-2):1-15.
79. Swanson D.A., Casadevall T.J., Dzurisin D., Malone S.D., Newhall C.G., Weaver C.S. Predicting eruptions at Mount St. Helens, June 1980 through December 1982. Science 1983, 221(4618):1369.
80. Teigen K.H., Brun W. The directionality of verbal probability expressions: effects on decisions, predictions, and probabilistic reasoning. Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process. 1999, 80(2):155-190.
81. Turner M., Cronin S.J., Bebbington M., Platz T. Developing a probabilistic eruption forecast for dormant volcanoes; a case study from Mt Taranaki, New Zealand. Bull. Volcanol. 2008, 70:507-515.
82. Upton G., Cook I. A Dictionary of Statistics (2 rev) 2008, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, (ISBN: 9780191726866).
83. Van Asselt M.B.A. Perspectives on Uncertainty and Risk: the PRIMA Approach to Decision Support 2000, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.
84. Velluppillai M.J. A Tale of Two Cities: Judgements About Earthquake Probabilities in Time Windows 2013, (M.Sci Thesis), Victoria University of Wellington, New Zealand.
85. Visschers V.H.M., Meertens R.M., Passchier W.W.F., de Vries N.N.K. Probability information in risk communication: a review of the research literature. Risk Anal. 2009, 29(2):267-287.
86. Vogt W.P. Dictionary of Statistics & Methodology 2005, Sage Publications, Inc. 3rd edition, 10.4135/9781412983907.
87. Wallsten T.S., Fillenbaum S., Cox J.A. Base rate effects on the interpretations frequency expressions of probability. J. Mem. Lang. 1986, 25:571-587.
88. Werner F., Scholz R.W. Ambiguities in decision-oriented life cycle inventories: the role of mental models. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2002, 7(6):330-338.
89. Wiedemann P., Borner F., Schultz H. Lessons learned: recommendations for communicating conflicting evidence for risk characterization. The Role of Evidence in Risk Characterisation: Making Sense of Conflicting Data 2008, 205-213. Weinheim, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA. P.M. Wiedemann, H. Schultz (Eds.).
90. Windschitl P.D., Weber E.U. The interpretation of "likely" depends on the context, but "70%" is 70% - right? The influence of associative processes on perceived certainty. J. Exp. Psychol. Learn. Mem. Cogn. 1999, 25(6):1514-1533.
91. Woo G. Probabilistic criteria for volcano evacuation decisions. Nat. Hazards 2008, 45(1):87-97.
92. Zaksek M., Arvai J.L. Toward improved communication about wildfire: mental models research to identify information needs for natural resource management. Risk Anal. 2004, 24(6):1503-1514.