Effectiveness of stereoscopic displays in medicine: A review

3D Research

Volumn 3, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 1-13

  van Beurden, M H P H ^a   IJsselsteijn, W A ^a   Juola, J F ^a,b  

^a EINDHOVEN UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY   (Netherlands)

^b UNIVERSITY OF KANSAS   (United States)

Author keywords

Diagnosis; Medicine Pre operative planning; Minimally Invasive Surgery; Perception; Performance; Stereoscopic Displays; Teaching; Training

Indexed keywords

COMPUTERIZED TOMOGRAPHY; DATA VISUALIZATION; DIAGNOSIS; DISPLAY DEVICES; MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; MEDICAL EDUCATION; MEDICAL IMAGING; PERSONNEL TRAINING; SENSORY PERCEPTION; STEREO IMAGE PROCESSING; TEACHING; TRANSPLANTATION (SURGICAL); ULTRASONIC APPLICATIONS;

INTERNAL STRUCTURE; MINIMALLY INVASIVE SURGERY; PERFORMANCE; POTENTIAL BENEFITS; PRE-OPERATIVE PLANNING; STEREOSCOPIC DISPLAY; STEREOSCOPIC VIEWING; SURGICAL PROCEDURES;

THREE DIMENSIONAL COMPUTER GRAPHICS;

EID: 84872058796     PISSN: None     EISSN: 20926731     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/3DRes.01(2012)3     Document Type: Review

References (95)

1. R. T. Held, T. T. Hui (2011) A guide to stereoscopic 3D displays in medicine. Academic Radiology. 8(8): 1035-1048.
2. W. A. IJsselsteijn, P. J. H. Seuntiëns, L. M. J. Meesters (2005) Human factors of 3D displays. In: Schreer O, Kauff P, Sikora T, (eds.), 3D Videocommunication - Algorithms, concepts and real-time systems in human-centred communication. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., 219-234.
3. M. Lambooij, W. A. IJsselsteijn, M. Fortuin, I. Heynderickx (2009) Visual discomfort in stereoscopic displays: A review. Journal of Imaging Science and Technology. 53(3): 1-14.
4. R. Patterson (2009) Human Factors of stereo displays: An update. Journal of society for Information Display. 17(12): 987-996.
5. I. P. Howard, B. J. Rogers (2002) Seeing in Depth: Depth Perception Vol 1. Porteous Publishing, Toronto.
6. N. S. Holliman, N. A. Dodgson, G. E. Favalora, L. Pockett (2011) Three-dimensional displays: A review and application analysis. IEEE Transactions on Broadcasting. 57(2): 362-371.
7. T. Okoshi (1980) Three dimensional displays. Proceedings of the IEEE. 68: 548-564.
8. S. Pastoor (1997) 3-D displays: A review of current technologies, Displays. 17(2): 100-110.
9. H. Urey, K. V. Chelleppan, E. Erden, P. Surman (2011) State of the Art in Stereoscopic and Autostereoscopic Displays. Proceedings of the IEEE. 99(4): 540-555.
10. M. H. P. H. van Beurden, A. Kuijsters, W. A. IJsselsteijn (2010) Performance of a path tracing task using stereo and motion based depth cues, Quality of Multimedia Experience (QoMEX), 2010 Second International Workshop. 176-181.
11. J. Cutting, P. Vishton (1995) Perceiving layout and knowing distances: The integration, relative potency, and contextual use of different information about depth. In: Epstein W and Rogers S (ed) Perception of Space and Motion, Academic Press, San Diego, CA: 69-117.
12. B. Rogers, M. Graham (1982) Similarities between motion parallax and stereopsis in human depth perception. Vision Research. 22(2): 261-270.
13. M. Hershenson (1999) Visual Space Perception. The MIT Press, Cambridge.
14. H. A. Sedgwick (2001) Visual space perception. Blackwell Handbook of Perception, Blackwell Publishers Ltd., Oxford, 128-167.
15. W. A. IJsselsteijn, H. de Ridder, R. Hamberg, D. Bouwhuis, J. Freeman (1998) Perceived depth and the feeling of presence in 3DTV. Displays. 18(4): 207-214.
16. P. Seuntiëns, I. Heynderickx, W. A. IJsselsteijn (2008) Capturing the added value of 3D-TV: Viewing experience and naturalness of stereoscopic images. Journal of Imaging Science and Technology. 52(2): 1-5.
17. J. O. Merritt (1991) Evaluation of stereoscopic display benefits. In: Introduction to Stereoscopic Displays and Applications, Short Course Notes, Hodges L, McAllister D, Merritt J, (ed), SPIE The International Society for Optical Engineering, Washington.
18. N. Holliman (2005) 3D display systems. Technical Report, Department of Computer Science, Univ. Durham.
19. S. Pastoor (2006) Human factors of 3D displays in advanced image communications. Displays. 14: 150-157.
20. B. S. Kuszyk, D. G. Heath, D. F. Bliss, E. K. Fishman (1996) Skeletal 3-D CT: Advantages of volume rendering over surface rendering. Skeletal Radiology. 25(3): 207-214.
21. J. Faubert (2001) Motion parallax, stereoscopy, and the perception of depth: practical and theoretical issues. Bahram J (Ed), Proceedings of SPIE CR76: 168-191.
22. R. L. Sollenberger, P. Milgram (1993) Effects of stereoscopic and rotational displays in a three-dimensional path-tracing task. Human Factors. 35(3): 483-499.
23. C. Ware, P. Mitchell (2005) Reevaluating stereo and motion cues for visualizing graphs in three dimensions. Proceedings of the 2nd symposium on Applied perception in graphics and visualization: 51-58.
24. M. H. P. H. van Beurden, W. A. IJsselsteijn, Y. A. W. Kort de (2011) Evaluating stereoscopic displays: Both efficiency measures and perceived workload sensitive to manipulations in binocular disparity. Proceeding of SPIE-IS& T Electronic imaging. 7863: 786316 1-786316 7.
25. D. R. Melmoth, S. Grant (2006) Advantages of binocular vision for control of reaching and grasping. Experimental Brain Research. 171(3): 371-388.
26. P. Servos, M. A. Goodale, L. S. Jakobson (1992) The role of binocular vision in prehension: A kinematic analysis. Vision Research. 32(8): 1513-1521.
27. S. McWhorter, L. Hodges, W. Roderiguez (1991) Evaluation of display parameters affecting user performance of an interactive task in a virtual environment. Rep. No. GIT-GVU-91-31, Graphics, Visualization & Usability Center, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta.
28. D. C. Smith, R. E. Cole, J. O. Merritt, R. L. Pepper (1979) Remote operator performance comparing mono and stereo TV displays: The effects of visibility, learning and task factors. Technical report Naval Ocean Systems Center. San Diego.
29. B. G. Blundell, A. J. Schwarz (2006) Creative 3-D displays and Interaction Interfaces. Wiley-Interscience, New Jersey.
30. J. T. Case (1912) The Importance of Stereoradiography, especially of the Alimentary Tract, with Demonstration of Plates. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine. 5: 73-86.
31. J. M. Davidson (1918) Stereoscopic Radiography. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 12: 1-8.
32. A. B. Johnson (1901) Stereoscopic radiography. Annals of Surgery. 35: 455-466.
33. J. K. Udupa, G. T. Herman (2000) 3D imaging in medicine, CRC Press LLC, Boca Raton.
34. Zonneveld FW, Fukuta K (1994) A decade of clinical three-dimensional imaging: a review. Part II: Clinical applications. Investigative Radiology 29(5): 574-589.
35. F. W. Zonneveld (1994) A decade of clinical three-dimensional imaging: a review. Part III. Image analysis and interaction, display options, and physical models. Investigative Radiology. 29(5): 716-725.
36. M. Tory, M. S. Akins, A. E. Kirkpatrick, M. Nicolaou, G. Z. Yang (2005) Eyegaze analysis of displays with combined 2D and 3D views. IEEE Visualization. 2005: 519-526.
37. M. S. Atkins, A. Moise, R. Rohling (2006) An application of eye-gaze tracking for designing radiologists workstation: Insights for comparative visual search task. ACM Transaction on Applied Perception. 3(2): 136-151.
38. A. E. Krupinski (2010) Perceptual factors in reading medical images. In Samei, E, and Krupinski E (ed) The handbook of medical image perception and techniques. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 81-90.
39. M. F. Verde, N. A. Macmillan, C. M. Rotello (2006) Measures of sensitivity based on a single hit rate and false alarm rate: The accuracy, precision, and robustness of d', Az, and A'. Perception and Psychophysics. 68(4): 643-654.
40. H. L. Kundel (1990) Visual cues in the interpretation of medical imaging. Journal of Clinical Neurophysiology. 7(4): 472-483.
41. R. Kickuth, G. Hartung, U. Laufer, C. Gruening, C. Stueckle, D. Liermann (2002) Stereoscopic 3D CT vs. standard 3D CT in the classification of acetabular fractures: An experimental study. British Journal of Radiology. 75(893): 422-427.
42. A. E. Rosenbaum, W. Huda, K. A. Lieberman, R. D. Caruso (2000) Binocular three-dimensional perception through stereoscopic generation from rotating images. Academic Radiology. 7(1): 21-26.
43. M. A. Kersten, A. J. Stewart, N. Troje, R. Ellis (2006) Enhancing depth perception in translucent volumes. IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics. 12: 1117-1123.
44. X. H. Wang, J. E. Durick, D. L. Herbert, S. K. Lu A Golla, D. D. Shinde, S. Piracha, K. Foley, C. R. Fuhrman, B. E. Shindel, J. K. Leader, W. F. Good (2010) Compare display schemes for lung nodule CT screening. Journal of Digital imaging. 24(3): 478-484.
45. C. A. Mistretta (1993) Relative characteristics of MR angiography and competing vascular imaging modalities Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging. 3(5): 685-698.
46. K. Doi, E. E. Duda (1983) Detectability of depth information by use of magnification stereoscopic technique in cerebral angiography. Radiology. 146: 91-95.
47. T. H. Moll, F. Turjman, C. Picard, J. P. Bres, M. Amiel (1997) Depth separation in ten observers with a new stereoscopic X-ray acquisition system. European Radiology7(8): 1343-1347.
48. M. Takahashi, H. Bussaka, M. Miyawaki (1986) Stereoscopic DSA of the central nervous system. Neuroradiology. 28(2): 105-108.
49. K. U. Wentz, H. P. Mattle, R. R. Edelman, J. Kleefield, G. V. O'Reilly, C. Liu (1991) Stereoscopic display of MR angiograms. Neuroradiology. 33(2): 123-125.
50. A. Abildgaard, A. K. Witwit, J. S. Karlsen, E. A. Jacopsen, B. Tennoe, G. Ringstad, P. Due-Tonnessen (2010) An autostereoscopic 3D display can improve visualization of 3D models from intracranial MR angiography. International Journal of computer Assisted Radiology and Surgery. 5: 549-554.
51. A. Hernandez, O. Basset, A. Bremond, I. E. Magnin (1998) Stereoscopic visualization of three-dimensional ultrasonic data applied to breast tumours. European Journal of Ultrasound8(1): 51-65.
52. T. R. Nelson, E. K. Ji, J. H. Lee, M. J. Bailey, D. H. Pretorius (2008) Stereoscopic evaluation of fetal bony structures. Journal of Ultrasound in Medicine. 27(1): 15-24.
53. A. H. J. Koning (2011) How 3D immersive visualization is changing medical diagnostics. Proceedings of SPIE-IS& T Electronic imaging. 7865: 786503 1-786503 7.
54. G. Bol Raap, A. H. J. Koning, T. V. Scohy, A. D. Ten Harkel, F. J. Meijboom, A. P. Kappetein, P. J. Spek van der, A. J. J. C. Bogers (2007) Virtual reality 3D echocardiography in the assessment of tricuspid valve function aftersurgical closure of ventricular septum defect. Cardiovascular Ultrasound. 5(8).
55. C. M. Verwoerd-Dikkeboom, A. H. J. Koning, P. J. Spek van der, N. Exalto, E. A. P. Steegers (2008) Embryonic staging using a 3D virtual reality system. Human Reproduction. 23(7): 1479-1484.
56. A. N. Cherniy, B. M. Kanter, E. V. Serova, G. V. Ratobylski (2007) Use of stereoscopic vision for analysis of digital X-ray images of lungs. Biomedical Engineering. 41(5): 214-217.
57. D. J. Getty, P. J. Green (2007) Clinical applications for stereoscopic 3-D displays. Journal of the Society for Information Display. 15(6): 377-384.
58. J. Hsu, C. F. Babbs, D. M. Chelberg, Z. Pizlo (1993) Study of the effectiveness of stereo imaging with applications in mammography. Proceedings of SPIE. 1913: 154-165.
59. A. Smith (2005) Full field breast tomosynthesis. Radiological Management. 27(5): 25-31.
60. L. J. Webb, E. Samei, J. Y. Lo, J. A. Baker, S. V. Ghate, C. Kim, M. S. Soo, R. Walsh (2011) Comparaive performance of multiview stereoscopic mammographic display modalities for breast lesion detection. Med. Phys. 38(4): 1972-1980.
61. T. M. Satava, S. B. Jones (2002) Medical applications of virtual environments. In: Stanney, KM (ed) Handbook of Virtual Environments: Design, Implementation, and Applications, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, New Jersey 937-957.
62. T. J. White, G. R. Avery, N. Kennan, A. M. Syed, J. E. Hartley, J. R. T. Monson (2009) Virtual colonoscopy versus conventional colonoscopy in patients at high risk of colorectal cancer - a prospective trial of 150 patients. Colorectal Disease. 11(2): 138-145.
63. P. Sharma, P. A. Sample, L. M. Zangwill, J. S. Schuman (2008) Diagnostic tools for glaucoma detection and management. Survey of Opthalmology. 53(1): s17-s32.
64. P. Seuntiëns, L. M. J. Meesters, W. A. IJsselsteijn (2005) Perceptual attributes of crosstalk in 3D images. Displays. 26(4): 177-183.
65. B. Reitinger, A. Bornik, R. Beichel, D. Schmalstieg (2006) Liver surgery planning using virtual reality. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications. 26(6): 36-47.
66. R. Shahidi, R. Tombropoulos, P. Grzeszczuk (1998) Clinical applications of three-dimensional rendering of medical data sets. Proceedings of the IEEE. 86(3): 555-568.
67. B. Reggiani, L. Cristofolini, E. Varini, M. Viceconti (2007) Predicting the subject-specific primary stability of cementless implants during pre-operative planning: Preliminary validation of subject-specific finite-element models. Journal of Biomechanics. 40(11): 2552-2558.
68. R. J. Hubbold, D. J. Hancock, C. J. Moore (1999) Autostereoscopic display for radiotherapy planning. Proceedings SPIE. 3012: 16-27.
69. M. Hegarty, M. Keehner, C. Cohen, D. R Montello, Y. Lippa (2007) The role of spatial cognition in medicine: Applications for selecting and training professionals. In Allen, G. L. (ed) Applied spatial cognition, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey, 285-315.
70. A. Cuschieri (1995) Visual displays and visual perception in minimal access surgery. Seminars in Laparoscopic Surgery. 2(3): 209-214.
71. J. Hofmeister, T. G. Frank, A. Cuschieri, N. J. Wade (2001) Perceptual aspects of two-dimensional and stereoscopic display techniques in endoscopic surgery: review and current problems. Seminars of Laparoscopic Surgery. 8(1): 12-24.
72. Hanna GB, Cuschieri A (2000) Influence of two-dimensional and three-dimensional imaging on endoscopic bowel suturing. World Journal of Surgery 24(4): 444-449.
73. S. H. Kong, B. M. Oh, H. Yoon, H. S. Ahn, H. J. Lee, S. G. Chung, N. Shiraishi, S. Kitano, H. K. Yang (2010) Comparison of two and three dimensional camera systems in laparoscopic performance: A novel 3D system with one camera. Surgical endoscopy. 24(5): 1132-1143.
74. U. D. Mueller-Richter, A. Limberger, P. Weber, W. Spitzer, M. Schilling (2003) Comparison between three-dimensional presentation of endoscopic procedures with polarization glasses and an autostereoscopic display. Surgical Endoscopy. 17(3): 502-504s.
75. A. Tabaee, V. K. Anand, J. F. Fraser, S. M. Brown, A. Singh, T. H. Schwartz (2009) Three dimensional endoscopic pituitary surgery. Operative neurosurgery. 64(5): 288-295.
76. M. N. Thomsen, D. Robert, M. D. Lang (2004) An experimental comparison of 3-dimensional and 2-dimensional endoscopic systems in a model. The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery. 20(4): 419-423.
77. M. Wentink, J. J. Jakimowicz, L. M. Vos, D. W. Meijer, P. A. Wieringa (2002) Quantitative evaluation of three advanced laparoscopic viewing technologies: a stereo endoscope, an image projection display, and a TFT display. Surgical Endoscopy. 16(8): 1237-1241.
78. A. Pietrabissa, E. Scarcello, A. Carobbi, F. Mosca (1994) Three-dimensional versus two-dimensional video system for the trained endoscopic surgeon and the beginner. Endoscopic Surgery and allied technologies. 2(6): 315-317.
79. V. Falk, D. Mintz, J. Grunenfelder, J. I. Fann, T. A. Burdon (2001) Influence of three-dimensional vision on surgical telemanipulator performance. Surgical Endoscopy. 15(11): 1282-1288.
80. C. A. Lagrange, C. J. Clark, E. W. Gerber, S. E. Strup (2008) Evaluation of three laparoscopic modalities: Robotics versus three-dimensional vision laparoscopy versus standard laparoscopy. Journal of Endourology. 22(3): 511-516.
81. A. Blavier, Q. Gaudissart, G. B. Cadiere, A. S. Nyssen (2007) Perceptual and instrumental impacts of robotic laparoscopy on surgical performance. Surgical Endoscopy. 21(10): 1875-1882.
82. G. Hubens, H. Coveliers, L. Balliu, M. Ruppert, W. Vaneerdeweg (2003) A performance study comparing manual and robotically assisted laparoscopic surgery using the da Vinci system. Surgical Endoscopy. 17(10): 1595-1599.
83. J. W. Huber, N. Taffinder, R. C. G. Russell, A. Darzi (2003) The effects of different viewing conditions on performance in simulated minimal access surgery. Ergonomics. 46(10): 999-1016.
84. J. C. Byrn, S. Schluender, C. M. Divino, J. Conrad, B. Gurland, E. Shlasko (2007) Three-dimensional imaging improves surgical performance for both novice and experienced operators using the da Vinci Robot System. The American Journal of Surgery. 193(4): 519-522.
85. I. C. Jourdan, E. Dutson, A. Garcia, T. Vleugels, J. Leroy, D. Mutter (2004) Stereoscopic vision provides a significant advantage for precision robotic laparoscopy. British Journal of Surgery. 91(7): 879-885.
86. Y. Munz, K. Moorthy, A. Dosis, D. Hernandez (2004) The benefits of stereoscopic vision in robotic-assisted performance on bench models. Surgical Endoscopy. 18(4): 611-616.
87. J. F. Fraser, B. Allen, V. K. Anand, T. H. Schwartz (2009) Three dimensional neurostereoendoscopy: Subjective and objective comparison to 2D. Minimal invasive neurosurgery52(1): 25-31.
88. N. V. Vasilyev, P. M. Novotny, J. F. Martinez, H. Loyola, I. S. Salgo, R. D. Howe, P. J. del Nido (2008) Stereoscopic vision displays technology in real-time three-dimensional echocardiography-guided intracardiac beating-heart surgery. The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery. 135: 1334-1341.
89. J. M. Luursema, P. A. M. Kommers, W. B. Verweij (2004) Stereopsis in medical virtual learning environments. Studies in Health Technology and Informatics. 103: 262-269.
90. C. E. Lathan, M. R. Tracey, M. M. Sebrechts, D. M. Clawson, G. A. Higgens (2002) Using virtual environments as training simulators: Measuring transfer. In: Stanney, KM (ed), Handbook of Virtual Environments: Design, Implementation, and Applications, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, New Jersey, 403-414.
91. J. Owczarczyk, B. Owczarczyk (1990) Evaluation of true 3D display systems for visualizing medical volume data, The Visual Computer. 6(4): 219-226.
92. J. M. Luursema, W. B. Verweij, P. A. M. Kommers, J. H. Annema (2008) The role of stereopsis in virtual anatomical learning. Interacting with Computers. 20(4-5): 455-460.
93. J. Ilgner, J. Jae-Hyun park, D. Labbé (2007) Using a high-definition stereoscopic video system to teach microscopic surgery. Proceedings of the SPIE. 6490: 1-7.
94. R. Aggarwal K. Moorthy, A. Darz (2004) Laparoscopic skills training and assessment. British Journal of Surgery91(12): 1549-1558.
95. K. Votanopoulos, F. C. Brunicardi, J. Thornby, C. F. Bellows (2008) Impact of three-dimensional vision in laparoscopic training. World Journal of Surgery. 32(1): 110-118.