The weak relationship between anatomy competence and clinical skills in junior medical students

Anatomical Sciences Education

Volumn 5, Issue 4, 2012, Pages 217-224

  Schoeman, Scarpa ^a   Chandratilake, Madawa ^b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF THE FREE STATE   (South Africa)

^b UNIVERSITY OF DUNDEE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Assessment of competence; Basic sciences; Clinical anatomy; Clinical correlation; Clinical skills; Gross anatomy education; OSCE; Physical examination; Undergraduate medical education

Indexed keywords

ANATOMY; ARTICLE; ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; CLINICAL COMPETENCE; COHORT ANALYSIS; CURRICULUM; EDUCATION; EDUCATIONAL STATUS; HUMAN; MEDICAL EDUCATION; MEDICAL STUDENT; RETROSPECTIVE STUDY;

ANATOMY; CLINICAL COMPETENCE; COHORT STUDIES; CURRICULUM; EDUCATION, MEDICAL, UNDERGRADUATE; EDUCATIONAL MEASUREMENT; EDUCATIONAL STATUS; HEALTH KNOWLEDGE, ATTITUDES, PRACTICE; HUMANS; RETROSPECTIVE STUDIES; STUDENTS, MEDICAL;

EID: 84863329846     PISSN: 19359772     EISSN: 19359780     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/ase.1272     Document Type: Article

References (39)

1. Adibi I, Hasani N, Ashoorioun V, Sadrearhami S, Monajemi AR. 2007. Integrating physical examination and trunk anatomy; A new course for second year medical students. Med Teach 29: 975-977.
2. Altman DG. 1991. Practical Statistics for Medical Research. 1st Ed. London, UK: Chapman and Hall. 611 p.
3. Balla JI, Biggs JB, Gibson M, Chang AM. 1990. The application of basic science concepts to clinical problem-solving. Med Educ 24: 137-147.
4. Boon JM, Meiring JH, Richards PA. 2002. Clinical anatomy as the basis for clinical examination: Development and evaluation of an Introduction to Clinical Examination in a problem-oriented medical curriculum. Clin Anat 15: 45-50.
5. Carney PA, Ogrinc G, Harwood BG, Schiffman JS, Cochran N. 2005. The influence of teaching setting on medical students' clinical skills development: Is the academic medical center the "gold standard"? Acad Med 80: 1153-1158.
6. Collins JP. 2008. Modern approaches to teaching and learning anatomy. BMJ 337: a1310.
7. Dangerfield P, Bradley P, Gibbs T. 2000. Learning gross anatomy in a clinical skills course. Clin Anat 13: 444-447.
8. Dusseau J, Knutson D, Way D. 2008. Anatomy correlations: Introducing clinical skills to improve performance in anatomy. Fam Med 40: 633-637.
9. st Ed. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. 352p.
10. Escobar-Poni B, Poni ES. 2006. The role of gross anatomy in promoting professionalism: A neglected opportunity! Clin Anat 19: 461-467.
11. Eva KW, Neville AJ, Norman GR. 1998. Exploring the etiology of content specificity: Factors influencing analogic transfer and problem solving. Acad Med 73: S1-S5.
12. Fowell SL, Southgate LJ, Bligh JG. 1999. Evaluating assessment: The missing link? Med Educ 33: 276-281.
13. st Ed. London, UK: General Medical Council. 28 p. URL: [accessed 22 November 2011].
14. nd Ed. London, UK: General Medical Council. 40 p. URL: [accessed 22 November 2011].
15. rd Ed. London, UK: General Medical Council. 104p. URL: [accessed 22 November 2011].
16. Gregory JK, Lachman N, Camp CL, Chen LP, Pawlina W. 2009. Restructuring a basic science course for core competencies: An example from anatomy teaching. Med Teach 31: 855-861.
17. Hamann C, Volkan K, Fishman MB, Silvestri RC, Simon SR, Fletcher SW. 2002. How well do second-year students learn physical diagnosis? Observational study of an Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE). BMC Med Educ 2: 1.
18. Klement BJ, Paulsen DF, Wineski LE. 2011. Anatomy as the backbone of an integrated first year medical curriculum: Design and implementation. Anat Sci Educ 4: 157-169.
19. Lam TP, Irwin M, Chow LW, Chan P. 2002. Early introduction of clinical skills teaching in a medical curriculum-factors affecting students' learning. Med Educ 36: 233-240.
20. Lempp HK. 2005. Perceptions of dissection by students in one medical school: Beyond learning about anatomy. A qualitative study. Med Educ 39: 318-325.
21. Leonard RJ, Acland RD, Agur A, Blevins CE, Cahill DR, Collins JD, Dalley AFII, Dolph J, Hagedoorn JP, Hoos PC, Jones DG, Mathers LH, McFee R, Mennin SP, Negulesco JA, Nelson ML, Olson TR, Page DW, Pawlina W, Petterborg LJ, Price JM, Spielman JE, Younoszai R. 1996. A clinical anatomy curriculum for the medical student of the 21st century: Gross anatomy. Clin Anat 9: 71-99.
22. Leonard RJ, Blevins CE, Cahill DR, Hoos PC, Lozanoff S, Marks SCJr, Mathers LH, Page DW, Pawlina W, Petterborg LJ. 2001. Clinical anatomy and the physical examination part I: Thorax, abdomen, perineum, and pelvis. Clin Anat 14: 332-348.
23. Louw G, Eizenberg N, Carmichael SW. 2009. The place of anatomy in medical education: AMEE Guide no 41. Med Teach 31: 373-386.
24. Manuel RS, Borges NJ, Gerzina HA. 2005. Personality and clinical skills: Any correlation? Acad Med 80: S30-S33.
25. Marks SCJr. 1996. Information technology, medical education, and anatomy for the twenty-first century. Clin Anat 9: 343-348.
26. Marks SCJr. 2000. The role of three-dimensional information in health care and medical education: The implications for anatomy and dissection. Clin Anat 13: 448-452.
27. Mavis BE. 2000. Does studying for an objective structured clinical examination make a difference? Med Educ 34: 808-812.
28. McKeown PP, Heylings DJ, Stevenson M, McKelvey KJ, Nixon JR, McCluskey DR. 2003. The impact of curricular change on medical students' knowledge of anatomy. Med Educ 37: 954-961.
29. Monkhouse WS. 1993. Teaching and examining clinical skills in anatomy. Clin Anat 6: 185-187.
30. Moxham BJ, Plaisant O. 2007. Perception of medical students towards the clinical relevance of anatomy. Clin Anat 20: 560-564.
31. Norman G, Bordage G, Page G, Keane D. 2006. How specific is case specificity? Med Educ 40: 618-623.
32. Older J. 2004. Anatomy: A must for teaching the next generation. Surgeon 2: 79-90.
33. Peterson CA, Tucker RP. 2005a. Undergraduate coursework in anatomy as a predictor of performance: Comparison between students taking a medical gross anatomy course of average length and a course shortened by curriculum reform. Clin Anat 18: 540-547.
34. Peterson CA, Tucker RP. 2005b. Medical gross anatomy as a predictor of performance on the USMLE Step 1. Anat Rec 283B: 5-8.
35. Schoeman S, Chandratilake M. 2012. The Anatomy Competence Score - a new marker for anatomical ability. Anat Sci Educ 5: 33-40.
36. Sugand K, Abrahams P, Khurana A. 2010. The anatomy of anatomy: A review for its modernization. Anat Sci Educ 3: 83-93.
37. Tucker RP. 2008. Performance in a prematriculation gross anatomy course as a predictor of performance in medical school. Anat Sci Educ 1: 224-227.
38. Vasan NS, Holland BK. 2003. Increased clinical correlation in anatomy teaching enhances students' performance in the course and National Board subject examination. Med Sci Monit 9: SR23-SR28.
39. White CB, Ross PT, Haftel HM. 2008. Assessing the assessment: Are senior summative OSCEs measuring advanced knowledge, skills, and attitudes? Acad Med 83: 1191-1195.