'Family' ownership, tunnelling and earnings management: A review of the literature

Journal of Economic Surveys

Volumn 24, Issue 4, 2010, Pages 705-730

  Bhaumik, Sumon Kumar ^a   Gregoriou, Andros ^b  

^a ASTON UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF EAST ANGLIA   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Agency problem; Earnings management; Family control; Group affiliation; Tunnelling

Indexed keywords

FIRM OWNERSHIP; INCOME; STAKEHOLDER;

EID: 77955760048     PISSN: 09500804     EISSN: 14676419     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-6419.2009.00608.x     Document Type: Review

References (135)

1. Aharony J, Wang J, Yuan H. Related party transactions: the 'real' means of earnings management during the IPO process in China. 2005, Mimeo, Singapore National University
2. Akerlof GA. Labor contracts as a partial gift exchange. Quarterly Journal of Economics 1982, 97(4):543-569.
3. Ali A, Chen T-Y, Radhakrishnan S. Corporate disclosures by family firms. Journal of Accounting and Economics 2007, 44:238-286.
4. Almeida HV, Wolfenzon D. A theory of pyramidal ownership and family business groups. Journal of Finance 2006, 61:2637-2680.
5. Anderson RC, Deeb DM. Founding family ownership and firm performance: evidence from S&P500. Journal of Finance 2003, 58:1301-1328.
6. Anderson RC, Mansi SA, Reeb DM. Founding family ownership and the agency cost of debt. Journal of Financial Economics 2003, 68:263-285.
7. Andres C. Large shareholders and firm performance - an empirical examination of founding family ownership. Journal of Corporate Finance 2008, 14:431-445.
8. Aoki M. Risk sharing in the corporate group. The Economic Analysis of the Japanese Firm 1984, Aoki M. In, ed., New York, North-Holland
9. Aoki M. Information, Incentives and Bargaining in the Japanese Economy 1988, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press
10. Arregle J-L, Hitt MA, Sirmon DG, Very P. The development of organizational social capital: attributes of family firms. Journal of Management Studies 2007, 44:73-95.
11. Astrachan JH, Shanker MC. Family businesses' contribution to the U.S. economy: a closer look. Family Business Review 2003, 16(3):211-219.
12. Atanasov V. How much value can blockholders tunnel? Evidence from the Bulgarian mass privatization auctions. Journal of Financial Economics 2005, 76:191-234.
13. Atanasov V, Black B, Ciccotello CS, Gyoshev S. The anatomy of financial tunnelling in an emerging market. 2006, Finance Working Paper No. 123, /2006, European Corporate Governance Institute
14. Atanasov V, Black B, Ciccotello CS. Unbundling and measuring tunnelling. 2008, Law and Economics Working Paper No. 117, School of Law, University of Texas and Austin
15. Bae K-H, Kang J-K, Kim J-M. Tunnelling or value added? Evidence from mergers by Korean business groups. Journal of Finance 2002, 57:2695-2740.
16. Baek J-S, Kang J-K, Lee I. Business groups and tunnelling: evidence from private securities offerings by Korean chaebols. Journal of Finance 2006, 61:2415-2449.
17. Barnay JB. Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management 1991, 17(3):99-120.
18. Bebchuk LA, Kraakman R, Triantis G. Stock pyramids, cross-ownership and dual class equity: the mechanisms and agency costs of separating control from cash-flow rights. Concentrated Corporate Ownership 2000, 445-460. Morck R, In, ed., pp, Chicago, IL, University of Chicago Press
19. Bennedsen M. Inside the family firm: the role of families in succession decisions and performance. Quarterly Journal of Economics 2007, 122(2):647-691. Nielsen, K., Peréz-Gonzaléz, F., and, Wolfenzon, D.
20. Berger P, Ofek E. Diversification's effect on firm value. Journal of Financial Economics 1995, 37:39-65.
21. Bergstrom C, Rydqvist K. Ownership of equity in dual-class firms. Journal of Banking and Finance 1990, 14:255-269.
22. Bertrand M, Mehta P, Mullainathan S. Ferreting out tunnelling: an application to Indian business groups. Quarterly Journal of Economics 2002, 117:121-148.
23. Bertrand M. Mixing family with business: a study of Thai business groups and the families behind them. Journal of Financial Economics 2008, 88:466-498. Johnson, S., Samphantharak, K., and, Schoar, A.
24. Bhaumik SK, Driffield N, Pal S. Does ownership structure of emerging market firms affect their outward FDI? A case of Indian automotive and pharmaceutical sectors. Journal of International Business Studies 2010, forthcoming
25. Black B, Kraakman R, Tarassove A. Russian privatization and corporate governance: what went wrong?. Stanford Law Review 2000, 52:1731-1808.
26. Burkart M, Panunzi F, Shleifer A. Family firms. Journal of Finance 2003, 58:2167-2202.
27. Chacar A, Vissa B. Are emerging economies less efficient? Performance persistence and the impact of business group affiliation. Strategic Management Journal 2005, 26:933-946.
28. Chang SJ, Hong J. Economic performance of group affiliated companies in Korea: intragroup resource sharing and internal business transactions. Academy of Management Journal 2000, 43(3):429-448.
29. Chang SJ, Shin HH. Family ownership and performance in Korean conglomerates. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal 2007, 15:329-352.
30. Chen D, Jian M, Xu M. Dividends for tunneling in a regulated economy: the case of China. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal 2009, 17:209-223.
31. Cheung Y-L, Rau PR, Stouraitis A. Tunnelling, propping and expropriation: evidence from connected party transactions in Hong Kong. Journal of Financial Economics 2006, 82:343-386.
32. Claessens S. Corporate diversification in East Asia: the role of ultimate ownership and group affiliations. 1998, Fan, J.P.H., Djankov, S., and, Lang, L.H.P., Mimeo, The World Bank, Washington,DC
33. Claessens S, Djankov S, Lang LHP. The separation of ownership and control in East Asian corporations. Journal of Financial Economics 2000, 58:81-112.
34. Claessens S, Djankov S, Fan JPH, Lang LHP. Disentangling the incentive and entrenchment effects of large shareholders. Journal of Finance 2002, 57:2741-2771.
35. Daily CM, Dollinger MJ. An empirical examination of the ownership structure in family and professionally managed firms. Family Business Review 1992, 5(2):117-136.
36. DeAngelo H, DeAngelo L. Managerial ownership of voting rights: a study of public corporations with dual class of common stock. Journal of Financial Economics 1985, 14:33-69.
37. Dechow P, Sloan R, Sweeney A. Detecting earnings management. Accounting Review 1995, 170:193-225.
38. Degeorge F, Patel J, Zeckhauser R. Earnings management to exceed thresholds. Journal of Business 1999, 72:1-33.
39. Ding Y, Zhang H, Zhang J. Private versus state ownership and earnings management: evidence from Chinese listed companies. Corporate Governance: An International Review 2007, 15:223-238.
40. Dyck A, Zingales L. Private benefits of control: an international comparison. Journal of Finance 2004, 59:537-600.
41. Dye RA, Verrecchia RE. Discretion vs. uniformity: choices under GAAP. The Accounting Review 1995, 70:389-415.
42. Eaton C, Yuan L, Wu Z. Reciprocal altruism and the theory of the family firm. 2002, Philadelphia, PA
43. Ehrhardt O, Nowak E. Private benefits and minority shareholder expropriation - empirical evidence from IPOs of German family-owned firms. 2001, Working Paper No. 2001/10, Centre for Financial Studies, Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Universitat, Frankfurt am Main
44. Elliot J, Shaw W. Write-offs as accounting procedures to manage perceptions. Journal of Accounting Research 1988, 26:91-119.
45. Enriques L, Volpin P. Corporate governance reforms in Continental Europe. Journal of Economic Perspectives 2007, 21:117-140.
46. Estrin S, Poukliakova S, Shapiro D. The performance effects of business groups in Russia. Journal of Management Studies 2009, 46(3):393-420.
47. Evans J, Sridhar S. Multiple control systems, accrual accounting, and earnings management. Journal of Accounting Research 1996, 34:45-65.
48. Faccio M, Lang LHP, Young L. Dividends and expropriation. American Economic Review 2001, 91:54-78.
49. Fan JPH, Wong TJ. Corporate ownership structure and the informativeness of accounting earnings in East Asia. Journal of Accounting and Economics 2002, 33:401-425.
50. Filatotchev I, Lien Y-C, Piesse J. Corporate governance and performance in publicly listed, family-controlled firms: evidence from Taiwan. Asia-Pacific Journal of Management 2005, 22:257-283.
51. Franks J, Mayer C. Ownership and control of German corporations. Review of Financial Studies 2001, 14:943-977.
52. Franks J, Mayer C, Rossi S. Spending less time with the family: the decline of family ownership in the United Kingdom. A History of Corporate Governance Around the World 2005, 581-607. Morck R, In, ed., pp, Chicago, IL, University of Chicago Press
53. Friedman E, Johnson S, Mitton T. Propping and tunnelling. Journal of Comparative Economics 2003, 31:732-750.
54. Gao L, Kling G. Corporate governance and tunnelling: empirical evidence from China. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal 2008, 16:591-605.
55. Gaver J, Gaver K. The election between nonrecurring accounting transactions and CEO cash compensation. Accounting Review 1998, 73:235-253.
56. Ghatak M, Kali R. Financially interlined business groups. Journal of Economics and Management Strategy 2001, 10:591-619.
57. Ghemawat P, Khanna T. The nature of diversified business groups: a research design and two case studies. Journal of Industrial Economics 1998, 46:35-61.
58. Goffee R, Scasse R. Proprietorial control in family firms: some functions of 'quasi-organic' management systems. Journal of Management Studies 1985, 22(1):53-68.
59. Gompers PA, Ishii JL, Metrick A. Incentives versus control: an analysis of US dual class companies. 2004, Working Paper No. 10240, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA
60. Gopalan R, Nanda V, Seru A. Affiliated firms and financial support: evidence from Indian business groups. Journal of Financial Economics 2007, 86:759-795.
61. Gordon EA, Henry E. Related party transactions and earnings management. 2005, http://ssrn.com/abstract=612234, Available at, SSRN
62. Goto A. Business groups in a market economy. European Economic Review 1982, 19:53-70.
63. Graham JR, Lemmon ML, Wolf JG. Does corporate diversification destroy value?. Journal of Finance 2002, 57:695-720.
64. Grant RM. The resource-based theory of competitive advantage: implications for strategy formulation. California Management Review 1991, 33(3):114-135.
65. Guidry FA, Leone J, Rock S. Earnings-based bonus plans and earnings management by business-unit managers. Journal of Accounting and Economics 1999, 26:113-142.
66. Guillen MF. Business groups in emerging economies: a resource-based view. Academy of Management Journal 2000, 43:362-380.
67. Habberson TJ, Williams ML. A resource-based framework for assessing the strategic advantages of family firms. Family Business Review 1999, 12(1):1-22.
68. Healy P. The impact of bonus schemes on the selection of accounting principles. Journal of Accounting and Economics 1985, 7:85-107.
69. Healy PM, Palepu KG. The fall of Enron. Journal of Economic Perspectives 2003, 17:3-26.
70. Healy PM, Wahlen JM. A review of the earnings management literature and its implications for standard setting. Accounting Horizons 1999, 13:265-383.
71. Holmen M, Hogfeldt P. Pyramidal discounts: tunnelling or agency costs?. 2005, Finance Working Paper No. 73/2005, European Corporate Governance Institute
72. Hutton AP. A discussion of 'corporate disclosures by family firms'. Journal of Accounting and Economics 2007, 44:287-297.
73. Jensen M. Agency costs of free cash flow, corporate finance, and takeovers. American Economic Review 1986, 76:323-329.
74. Jensen MC, Meckling W. Theory of the firm: managerial behaviour, agency costs and ownership structure. Journal of Financial Economics 1976, 3:305-360.
75. Johanson J, Vahlne JE. The internationalisation process of the firm: a model of knowledge development and increasing market commitments. Journal of International Business Studies 1977, 8:23-32.
76. Johnson S, La Porta R, Lopez-da-Silanes F, Shleifer A. Tunneling. 2000, 90:22-27.
77. Jones J. Earnings management during import relief investigations. Journal of Accounting Research 1991, 29:193-228.
78. Jung K, Kwon SY. Ownership structure and earnings informativeness: evidence from Korea. International Journal of Accounting 2002, 37:301-325.
79. Kasznik R. On the association between voluntary disclosure and earnings management. Journal of Accounting Research 1999, 37:57-81.
80. Keister LA. Engineering growth: business group structure and firm performance in China's transition economy. American Journal of Sociology 1998, 104:404-440.
81. Khanna T. Business groups and social welfare in emerging markets: existing evidence and unanswered questions. European Economic Review 2000, 44:748-761.
82. Khanna T, Palepu K. Why focussed strategies might be wrong for emerging markets. Harvard Business Review 1997, 74:41-50.
83. Khanna T, Palepu K. Is group membership profitable in emerging markets? An analysis of diversified Indian business groups. Journal of Finance 1999, 55:867-891.
84. Khanna T, Palepu K. Emerging market business groups, foreign investors and corporate governance. Concentrated Corporate Ownership 2000, 265-294. Morck R, In, ed., pp, Chicago, IL, University of Chicago Press
85. Khanna T, Rivkin JW. Estimating the performance effects of business groups in emerging markets. Strategic Management Journal 1999, 22:45-74.
86. Khanna T, Yafeh Y. Business groups and risk sharing around the world. Journal of Business 2005, 78(1):301-340.
87. King MR, Santor E. Family values: ownership structure, performance and capital structure of Canadian firms. Journal of Banking and Finance 2008, 32:2423-2432.
88. Kothari SP, Leone AJ, Wasley CE. Performance matched discretionary accrual measures. Journal of Accounting and Economics 2005, 39:163-197.
89. Lang L, Stulz R. Tobin's q, corporate diversification, and firm performance. Journal of Political Economy 1994, 102:142-174.
90. La Porta R, Lopez-de-Silanes F, Shleifer A. Corporate ownership around the world. Journal of Finance 1999, 54:471-517.
91. Lemmon ML, Lins KV. Ownership structure, corporate governance, and firm value: evidence from the East Asian financial crisis. Journal of Finance 2003, 53:1445-1468.
92. Lesnik R, Van Der Molen R, Gangopadhyay S. Business groups, financing constraints and investment: the case of India. Journal of Development Studies 2003, 40:93-119.
93. Leuz C, Nanda D, Wysocki PD. Earnings management and investor protection: an international comparison. Journal of Financial Economics 2003, 69:505-527.
94. Liu C, Ryan S. The effect of loan portfolio composition on the market reaction to and anticipation of loan loss provisions. Journal of Accounting Research 1995, 33:77-94.
95. Liu C, Ryan S, Wahlen J. Differential valuation implications of loan loss provisions across banks and fiscal quarters. Accounting Review 1997, 72:133-146.
96. Liu Q, Lu Z. Corporate governance and earnings management in Chinese listed companies: a tunnelling perspective. Journal of Corporate Finance 2007, 13:881-906.
97. Maury B. Family ownership and performance: empirical evidence from Western European corporations. Journal of Corporate Finance 2006, 12:321-341.
98. Morck R, Yeung B. Agency problems in large family business groups. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 2003, 27(4):367-382.
99. Morck R, Shleifer A, Vishny R. Management ownership and market valuation: an empirical analysis. Journal of Financial Economics 1988, 20:293-315.
100. Morck R, Stangeland DA, Yeung B. Inherited wealth, corporate control and economic growth: the Canadian disease. 1998, Working Paper No. 6814, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA
101. Nenova T. The value of corporate voting rights and control: a cross-country analysis. Journal of Financial Economics 2003, 68:325-381.
102. Penalva F. Loss reserves and accounting discretion in the property-causality insurance industry. 1998, Working Paper, University of California
103. Peng MW, Delios A. What determines the scope of the firm over time and around the world? An Asia Pacific perspective. Asia Pacific Journal of Management 2006, 23:385-406.
104. Peng MW, Heath P. The growth of the firm in planned economies in transition: institutions, organizations, and strategic choice. Academy of Management Review 1996, 21:492-528.
105. Peng MW, Jiang Y. Family ownership and control in large firms: the good, the bad and the irrelevant - and why. 2006, Working Paper No. 840, William Davidson Institute, University, of Michigan, Ann Arbor
106. Peréz-Gonzaléz F. Inherited control and firm performance. American Economic Review 2006, 96(5):1559-1588.
107. Perotti EC, Gelfer S. Red barons or robber barons? Governance and financing in Russian financial-industrial groups. European Economic Review 2001, 45:1601-1617.
108. Perry SE, Williams TH. Earnings management preceding management buyout offers. Journal of Accounting and Economics 1994, 18:157-179.
109. Petroni KR. Optimistic reporting in the property causality insurance industry. Journal of Accounting and Economics 1992, 15:485-508.
110. Piramal G. Business Maharajahs 1996, New Delhi, Penguin Books
111. Poza EJ, Alfred T, Maheshwari A. Stakeholder perceptions of culture and management practices in family and family firms: a preliminary report. Family Business Review 1997, 10(2):135-155.
112. Redding SG. The Spirit of Chinese Capitalism 1990, Berlin, Walter de Gruyter
113. Riyanto YE, Toolsema LA. Tunnelling and propping: a justification for pyramidal ownership. Journal of Banking and Finance 2008, 32:2178-2187.
114. Rizov M, Croucher R. Human resource management and performance in European firms. Cambridge Journal of Economics 2009, 33:253-272.
115. Schipper K. Implications and requirements to discuss quality (not just acceptability) of reporting on accounting research and decision making of standard setter, regulators, management, audit committees, and auditors. 1999
116. Shin H-H, Park YS. Financing constraints and internal capital markets: evidence from Korean 'chaebols'. Journal of Corporate Finance 1999, 5(2):169-191.
117. Shin H-H, Stulz RM. Are internal capital markets efficient?. Quarterly Journal of Economics 1998, 113(2):531-552.
118. Shleifer A, Vishny RW. A survey of corporate governance. Journal of Finance 1997, 52:737-783.
119. Smith BF, Amoako-Adu B. Management succession and financial performance of family controlled firms. Journal of Corporate Finance 1999, 5(4):341-368.
120. Sraer D, Thesmar D. Performance and behaviour of family firms: evidence from the French stock market. Journal of European Economic Association 2007, 5(4):709-751.
121. Strong J, Meyer J. Asset write-downs: managerial incentives and security returns. Journal of Finance 1987, 42:643-661.
122. Teoh SH, Welch I, Wong TJ. Earnings management and the long term market performance of initial public offerings. Journal of Finance 1998, 53:1935-1974.
123. Thomsen S, Pedersen T. Ownership structure and economic performance in the largest European companies. Strategic Management Journal 2000, 21:689-705.
124. Tsang EWK. Internationalising the family firm: a case study of Chinese family business. Journal of Small Business Management 2001, 39:88-94.
125. Villalonga B, Amit R. How do family ownership, control and management affect firm value?. Journal of Financial Economics 2006, 80:385-417.
126. Villalonga B, Amit R. How are US family firms controlled?. Review of Financial Studies 2008, 22:3047-3091.
127. Wang D. Founding family ownership and earnings management. Journal of Accounting Research 2006, 44:619-656.
128. Warfield TD, Wild JJ, Wild KL. Managerial ownership, accounting choices, and informativeness of earnings. Journal of Accounting and Economics 1995, 20:61-91.
129. Watts RL, Zimmerman JL. Positive Accounting Theory 1986, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice Hall
130. Watts RL, Zimmerman JL. Positive accounting theory: a ten year perspective. Accounting Review 1990, 65:131-156.
131. Weidenbaum M. The Chinese family business enterprise. California Management Review 1996, 38:141-156.
132. Weinstein DE, Yafeh Y. On the costs of the bank-centred financial system: evidence from the changing main bank relations in Japan. Journal of Finance 1998, 53:635-672.
133. Yeung H. Change and continuity in Southeast Asian Chinese business. Asia Pacific Journal of Management 2006, 23:229-254.
134. Zahra SA. Entrepreneurial risk taking in family firms. Family Business Review 2003, 18:23-40.
135. Zhang J, Ma H. Adoption of professional management in Chinese family business: a multilevel analysis of impetuses and impediments. Asia Pacific Journal of Management 2009, 26(1):119-139.