Rebuttal of "Flawed experimental design reveals the need for guidelines requiring appropriate positive controls in endocrine disruption research" by vom Saal

Toxicological Sciences

Volumn 115, Issue 2, 2010, Pages 614-620

  Gray Jr , Leon E ^a   Ryan, Bryce ^b   Hotchkiss, Andrew K ^a   Crofton, Kevin M ^a  

^a U S ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF REDLANDS   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

4,4' ISOPROPYLIDENEDIPHENOL; DRINKING WATER; ENDOCRINE DISRUPTOR; ETHINYLESTRADIOL; POLYCARBONATE;

ADVERSE OUTCOME; ANIMAL HOUSING; CHEMOSENSITIVITY; ECOTOXICOLOGY; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; ESTROGEN ACTIVITY; EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN; GOVERNMENT REGULATION; HUMAN; INFERTILITY; LETTER; LONG EVANS RAT; MOLECULAR BIOLOGY; NONHUMAN; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; PUBLIC HEALTH; RAT STRAIN; REPRODUCTIVE TOXICITY; RISK ASSESSMENT; SEX DIFFERENTIATION; SPRAGUE DAWLEY RAT; STRAIN DIFFERENCE; TOXICOKINETICS; WATER CONTAMINATION;

EID: 77954154253     PISSN: 10966080     EISSN: 10960929     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/toxsci/kfq073     Document Type: Letter

References (81)

1. Akingbemi, B. T., Sottas, C. M., Koulova, A. I., Klinefelter, G. R., and Hardy, M. P. (2004). Inhibition of testicular steroidogenesis by the xenoestrogen bisphenol A is associated with reduced pituitary luteinizing hormone secretion and decreased steroidogenic enzyme gene expression in rat Leydig cells. Endocrinology 145, 592-603.
2. Ashby, J., Tinwell, H., and Haseman, J. (1999). Lack of effects for low dose levels of bisphenol A and diethylstilbestrol on the prostate gland of CF1 mice exposed in utero. Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 30, 156-166.
3. Barraclough, C. A., and Gorski, R. A. (1962). Studies on mating behavior in the androgen-sterilized female rat in relation to the hypothalamic regulation of sexual behaviour. J. Endocrinol. 25, 175-182.
4. Biegel, L. B., Flaws, J. A., Hirshfield, A. N., O'Connor, J. C., Elliott, G. S., Ladics, G. S., Silbergeld, E. K., Van Pelt, C. S., Hurtt, M. E., Cook, J. C., et al. (1998). 90-Day feeding and one-generation reproduction study in Crl:CD BR rats with 17 beta-estradiol. Toxicol. Sci. 44, 116-142.
5. Blye, R. P. (1973). The use of estrogens as postcoital contraceptive agents. Clinical effectiveness and potential mode of action. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 116, 1044-1050.
6. Cagen, S. Z., Waechter, J. M., Jr, Dimond, S. S., Breslin, W. J., Butala, J. H., Jekat, F. W., Joiner, R. L., Shiotsuka, R. N., Veenstra, G. E., and Harris, L. R. (1999a). Normal reproductive organ development in CF-1 mice following prenatal exposure to bisphenol A. Toxicol. Sci. 50, 36-44.
7. Cagen, S. Z., Waechter, J. M., Jr, Dimond, S. S., Breslin, W. J., Butala, J. H., Jekat, F. W., Joiner, R. L., Shiotsuka, R. N., Veenstra, G. E., and Harris, L. R. (1999b). Normal reproductive organ development in Wistar rats exposed to bisphenol A in the drinking water. Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 30, 130-139.
8. Casanova, M., You, L., Gaido, K. W., Archibeque-Engle, S., Janszen, D. B., and Heck, H. A. (1999). Developmental effects of dietary phytoestrogens in Sprague-Dawley rats and interactions of genistein and daidzein with rat estrogen receptors alpha and beta in vitro. Toxicol. Sci. 51, 236-244.
9. Chapin, R. E., Adams, J., Boekelheide, K., Gray, L. E., Jr, Hayward, S. W., Lees, P. S., McIntyre, B. S., Portier, K. M., Schnorr, T. M., Selevan, S. G., et al. (2008). NTP-CERHR expert panel report on the reproductive and developmental toxicity of bisphenol A. Birth Defects Res. B Dev. Reprod. Toxicol. 83, 157-395.
10. Chapin, R. E., Delaney, J., Wang, Y., Lanning, L., Davis, B., Collins, B., Mintz, N., and Wolfe, G. (1999). The effects of 4-nonylphenol in rats: a multigeneration reproduction study. Toxicol. Sci. 52, 80-91.
11. Cowin, P. A., Foster, P., Pedersen, J., Hedwards, S., McPherson, S. J., and Risbridger, G. P. (2008). Early-onset endocrine disruptor-induced prostatitis in the rat. Environ. Health Perspect. 116, 923-929.
12. Diel, P. (2002). Tissue-specific estrogenic response and molecular mechanisms. Toxicol. Lett. 127, 217-224.
13. Ema, M., Fujii, S., Furukawa, M., Kiguchi, M., Ikka, T., and Harazono, A. (2001). Rat two-generation reproductive toxicity study of bisphenol A. Reprod. Toxicol. 15, 505-523.
14. Environment Canada (Canadian Government). (2008). Screening assessment for the challenge: bisphenol A. Available at: http://www.ec.gc.ca/substances/ese/eng/challenge/batch2/batch2_80-05-7.c fm. Accessed March 24, 2010.
15. European Union (EU). (2010). European Union Risk Assessment Report: Bisphenol A, Vol. 201-245-8, pp. 1-695.
16. Goldman, J. M., Cooper, R. L., Rehnberg, G. L., Hein, J. F., McElroy, W. K., and Gray, L. E., Jr. (1986). Effects of low subchronic doses of methoxychlor on the rat hypothalamic-pituitary reproductive axis. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 86, 474-483.
17. Gorski, J., Wendell, D., Gregg, D., and Chun, T. Y. (1997). Estrogens and the genetic control of tumor growth. Prog. Clin. Biol. Res. 396, 233-243.
18. Gould, K. A., Pandey, J., Lachel, C. M., Murrin, C. R., Flood, L. A., Pennington, K. L., Schaffer, B. S., Tochacek, M., McComb, R. D., Meza, J. L., et al. (2005). Genetic mapping of Eutr1, a locus controlling E2-induced pyometritis in the Brown Norway rat, to RNO5. Mamm. Genome 16, 854-864.
19. Gould, K. A., Shull, J. D., and Gorski, J. (2000). DES action in the thymus: inhibition of cell proliferation and genetic variation. Mol. Cell. Endocrinol. 170, 31-39.
20. Gould, K. A., Strecker, T. E., Hansen, K. K., Bynote, K. K., Peterson, K. A., and Shull, J. D. (2006). Genetic mapping of loci controlling diethylstilbestrol-induced thymic atrophy in the Brown Norway rat. Mamm. Genome 17, 451-464.
21. Gould, K. A., Tochacek, M., Schaffer, B. S., Reindl, T. M., Murrin, C. R., Lachel, C. M., VanderWoude, E. A., Pennington, K. L., Flood, L. A., Bynote, K. K., et al. (2004). Genetic determination of susceptibility to estrogen-induced mammary cancer in the ACI rat: mapping of Emca1 and Emca2 to chromosomes 5 and 18. Genetics 168, 2113-2125.
22. Gray, L. E., Jr, Ferrell, J. M., and Ostby, J. S. (1985). Alteration of behavioral sex differentiation by exposure to estrogenic compounds during a critical neonatal period: effects of zearalenone, methoxychlor, and estradiol in hamsters. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 80, 127-136.
23. Gray, L. E., Jr, Ostby, J., Cooper, R. L., and Kelce, W. R. (1999a). The estrogenic and antiandrogenic pesticide methoxychlor alters the reproductive tract and behavior without affecting pituitary size or LH and prolactin secretion in male rats. Toxicol. Ind. Health 15, 37-47.
24. Gray, L. E., Jr, Ostby, J., Ferrell, J., Rehnberg, G., Linder, R., Cooper, R., Goldman, J., Slott, V., and Laskey, J. (1989). A dose-response analysis of methoxychlor-induced alterations of reproductive development and function in the rat. Fundam. Appl. Toxicol. 12, 92-108.
25. Gray, L. E., Jr, Ostby, J. S., Ferrell, J. M., Sigmon, E. R., and Goldman, J. M. (1988). Methoxychlor induces estrogen-like alterations of behavior and the reproductive tract in the female rat and hamster: effects on sex behavior, running wheel activity, and uterine morphology. Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol. 96, 525-540.
26. Gray, L. E., Jr, Wolf, C., Lambright, C., Mann, P., Price, M., Cooper, R. L., and Ostby, J. (1999b). Administration of potentially antiandrogenic pesticides (procymidone, linuron, iprodione, chlozolinate, p,p'-DDE, and ketoconazole) and toxic substances (dibutyl-and diethylhexyl phthalate, PCB 169, and ethane dimethane sulphonate) during sexual differentiation produces diverse profiles of reproductive malformations in the male rat. Toxicol. Ind. Health 15, 94-118.
27. Hall, J. M., and Korach, K. S. (2002). Analysis of the molecular mechanisms of human estrogen receptors alpha and beta reveals differential specificity in target promoter regulation by xenoestrogens. J. Biol. Chem. 277, 44455-44461.
28. Haspels, A. A. (1972). The after-pill. Experiences of 1000 women with postcoital administration of high estrogen doses. Fortschr. Med. 90, 595-596. passim.
29. Howdeshell, K. L., Furr, J., Lambright, C. R., Wilson, V. S., Ryan, B. C., and Gray, L. E., Jr. (2008). Gestational and lactational exposure to ethinyl estradiol, but not bisphenol A, decreases androgen-dependent reproductive organ weights and epididymal sperm abundance in the male long evans hooded rat. Toxicol. Sci. 102, 371-382.
30. Howdeshell, K. L., Peterman, P. H., Judy, B. M., Taylor, J. A., Orazio, C. E., Ruhlen, R. L., vom Saal, F. S., and Welshons, W. V. (2003). Bisphenol A is released from used polycarbonate animal cages into water at room temperature. Environ. Health Perspect. 111, 1180-1187.
31. Hunt, P. A., Koehler, K. E., Susiarjo, M., Hodges, C. A., Ilagan, A., Voigt, R. C., Thomas, S., Thomas, B. F., and Hassold, T. J. (2003). Bisphenol a exposure causes meiotic aneuploidy in the female mouse. Curr. Biol. 13, 546-553.
32. Jobling, S., Nolan, M., Tyler, C. R., Brighty, G., and Sumpter, J. P. (1998). Widespread sexual disruption in wild fish. Environ. Sci. Technol. 32, 2498-2506.
33. Jobling, S., Williams, R., Johnson, A., Taylor, A., Gross-Sorokin, M., Nolan, M., Tyler, C. R., van Aerle, R., Santos, E., and Brighty, G. (2006). Predicted exposures to steroid estrogens in U.K. rivers correlate with widespread sexual disruption in wild fish populations. Environ. Health Perspect. 114(Suppl. 1), 32-39.
34. Katzenellenbogen, B. S., Choi, I., Delage-Mourroux, R., Ediger, T. R., Martini, P. G., Montano, M., Sun, J., Weis, K., and Katzenellenbogen, J. A. (2000). Molecular mechanisms of estrogen action: selective ligands and receptor pharmacology. J. Steroid Biochem. Mol. Biol. 74, 279-285.
35. Kidd, K. A., Blanchfield, P. J., Mills, K. H., Palace, V. P., Evans, R. E., Lazorchak, J. M., and Flick, R. W. (2007). Collapse of a fish population after exposure to a synthetic estrogen. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 104, 8897-8901.
36. Kirigaya, A., Hayashi, S., Iguchi, T., and Sato, T. (2006). Developmental effects of ethinylestradiol on reproductive organs of female mice. In Vivo 20, 867-873.
37. Latendresse, J. R., Bucci, T. J., Olson, G., Mellick, P., Weis, C. C., Thorn, B., Newbold, R. R., and Delclos, K. B. (2009). Genistein and ethinyl estradiol dietary exposure in multigenerational and chronic studies induce similar proliferative lesions in mammary gland of male Sprague-Dawley rats. Reprod. Toxicol. 28, 342-353.
38. Laws, S. C., Carey, S. A., Ferrell, J. M., Bodman, G. J., and Cooper, R. L. (2000). Estrogenic activity of octylphenol, nonylphenol, bisphenol A and methoxychlor in rats. Toxicol. Sci. 54, 154-167.
39. Lawson, D. M., Sensui, N., and Gala, R. R. (1984). Ovariectomized Sprague-Dawley and Long-Evans rats release prolactin differently in response to estrogen. Life Sci. 34, 455-459.
40. Levine, S., and Mullins, R., Jr. (1964). Estrogen administered neonatally affects adult sexual behavior in male and female rats. Science 144, 185-187.
41. Markey, C. M., Luque, E. H., Munoz De Toro, M., Sonnenschein, C., and Soto, A. M. (2001). In utero exposure to bisphenol A alters the development and tissue organization of the mouse mammary gland. Biol. Reprod. 65, 1215-1223.
42. McCarthy, M. M. (2008). Estradiol and the developing brain. Physiol. Rev. 88, 91-124.
43. Naciff, J. M., Jump, M. L., Torontali, S. M., Carr, G. J., Tiesman, J. P., Overmann, G. J., and Daston, G. P. (2002). Gene expression profile induced by 17alpha-ethynyl estradiol, bisphenol A, and genistein in the developing female reproductive system of the rat. Toxicol. Sci. 68, 184-199.
44. Nagel, S. C., vom Saal, F. S., Thayer, K. A., Dhar, M. G., Boechler, M., and Welshons, W. V. (1997). Relative binding affinity-serum modified access (RBA-SMA) assay predicts the relative in vivo bioactivity of the xenoestrogens bisphenol A and octylphenol. Environ. Health Perspect. 105, 70-76.
45. Nakanishi, J., Miyamoto, K., and Kawasaki, H. (2007). Bisphenol A Risk Assessment Document. In AIST Risk Assessment Document Series (J.N.I. o. A.I.S. a. T.R.A. Document., Eds.), No. 4. pp. 1-389.
46. National Toxicology Program, (NTP). (2001). National Toxicology Program Report of the Endocrine Disruptors Low-Dose Peer Review. NTP Office of Liaison and Scientific review, Research Triangle Park, NC. pp. 1-487.
47. National Toxicology Program (NTP). (2007). NTP-Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human Reproduction (CERHR) Expert Panel Evaluation of Bisphenol A. Vol. 2007. Department of Health and Human Services, National Institutes of Health, National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, National Toxicology Program, Research Triangle Park, NC.
48. National Toxicology Program (NTP). (2008). NTP-CERHR monograph on the potential human reproductive and developmental effects of bisphenol A. NTP-CERHR MON, pp. 1-321.
49. Ostby, J., Kelce, W. R., Lambright, C., Wolf, C. J., Mann, P., and Gray, L. E., Jr. (1999). The fungicide procymidone alters sexual differentiation in the male rat by acting as an androgen-receptor antagonist in vivo and in vitro. Toxicol. Ind. Health 15, 80-93.
50. Padilla-Banks, E., Jefferson, W. N., and Newbold, R. R. (2001). The immature mouse is a suitable model for detection of estrogenicity in the uterotropic bioassay. Environ Health Perspect 109, 821-826.
51. Pandey, J., Gould, K. A., McComb, R. D., Shull, J. D., and Wendell, D. L. (2005). Localization of Eutr2, a locus controlling susceptibility to DES-induced uterine inflammation and pyometritis, to RNO5 using a congenic rat strain. Mamm. Genome 16, 865-872.
52. Rooman, R. P., De Beeck, L. O., Martin, M., van Doorn, J., Mohan, S., and Du Caju, M. V. (2005). Ethinylestradiol and testosterone have divergent effects on circulating IGF system components in adolescents with constitutional tall stature. Eur. J. Endocrinol. 152, 597-604.
53. Ryan, B. C., Hotchkiss, A. K., Crofton, K. M., and Gray, L. E., Jr. (2010). In utero and lactational exposure to bisphenol a, in contrast to ethinyl estradiol, does not alter sexually dimorphic behavior, puberty, fertility, and anatomy of female le rats. Toxicol. Sci. 114, 133-148.
54. Sanchez, R., Nguyen, D., Rocha, W., White, J. H., and Mader, S. (2002). Diversity in the mechanisms of gene regulation by estrogen receptors. Bioessays 24, 244-254.
55. Schmitt, K., Schilling, R., Frisch, H., Schober, E., Weninger, M., Tulzer, G., and Waldhauser, F. (1992). Reduction of body height in tall girls by estrogen treatment. Klin. Padiatr. 204, 405-410.
56. Schonfelder, G., Flick, B., Mayr, E., Talsness, C., Paul, M., and Chahoud, I. (2002). In utero exposure to low doses of bisphenol A lead to long-term deleterious effects in the vagina. Neoplasia 4, 98-102.
57. Scientific Panel on Food Additives, Flavourings Processing Aids and Materials in Contact with Food. (2006). Opinion of the scientific panel on food additives, flavourings, processing aids and materials in contact with food (AFC) related to 2,2-BIS(4-HYDROXYPHENYL)PROPANE. EFSA J. 428, 1-6.
58. Svan, H., Ritzen, E. M., Hall, K., and Johansson, L. (1991). Estrogen treatment of tall girls: dose dependency of effects on subsequent growth and IGF-I levels in blood. Acta Paediatr. Scand. 80, 328-332.
59. Thayer, K. A., Ruhlen, R. L., Howdeshell, K. L., Buchanan, D. L., Cooke, P. S., Preziosi, D., Welshons, W. V., Haseman, J., and vom Saal, F. S. (2001). Altered prostate growth and daily sperm production in male mice exposed prenatally to subclinical doses of 17alpha-ethinyl oestradiol. Hum Reprod 16, 988-996.
60. Thomas, T., Gallo, M. A., and Thomas, T. J. (2004). Estrogen receptors as targets for drug development for breast cancer, osteoporosis and cardiovas-cular diseases. Curr. Cancer Drug Targets 4, 483-499.
61. Tinwell, H., Haseman, J., Lefevre, P. A., Wallis, N., and Ashby, J. (2002). Normal sexual development of two strains of rat exposed in utero to low doses of bisphenol A. Toxicol. Sci. 68, 339-348.
62. Tinwell, H., Joiner, R., Pate, I., Soames, A., Foster, J., and Ashby, J. (2000). Uterotrophic activity of bisphenol A in the immature mouse. Regul. Toxicol. Pharmacol. 32, 118-126.
63. Tyl, R. W. (2003). Bisphenol A: findings of a multigenerational rat study. Environ. Health Perspect. 111, A632.
64. Tyl, R. W., Myers, C. B., Marr, M. C., Sloan, C. S., Castillo, N. P., Veselica, M. M., Seely, J. C., Dimond, S. S., Van Miller, J. P., Shiotsuka, R. N., et al. (2008a). Two-generation reproductive toxicity study of dietary bisphenol A in CD-1 (Swiss) mice. Toxicol. Sci. 104, 362-384.
65. Tyl, R. W., Myers, C. B., Marr, M. C., Sloan, C. S., Castillo, N. P., Veselica, M. M., Seely, J. C., Dimond, S. S., Van Miller, J. P., Shiotsuka, R. S., et al. (2008b). Two-generation reproductive toxicity evaluation of dietary 17beta-estradiol (E2; CAS No. 50-28-2) in CD-1 (Swiss) mice. Toxicol. Sci. 102, 392-412.
66. Tyl, R. W., Myers, C. B., Marr, M. C., Thomas, B. F., Keimowitz, A. R., Brine, D. R., Veselica, M. M., Fail, P. A., Chang, T. Y., Seely, J. C., et al. (2002). Three-generation reproductive toxicity study of dietary bisphenol A in CD Sprague-Dawley rats. Toxicol. Sci. 68, 121-146.
67. Valenstein, E. S., Kakolewski, J. W., and Cox, V. C. (1967). Sex differences in taste preference for glucose and saccharin solutions. Science 156, 942-943.
68. vom Saal, F. S., Akingbemi, B. T., Belcher, S. M., Crain, D. A., Crews, D., Guidice, L. C., Hunt, P. A., Leranth, C., Myers, J. P., Nadal, A., et al. (2010). Flawed experimental design reveals the need for guidelines requiring appropriate positive controls in endocrine disruption research. Toxicol. Sci. Advance Access published on February 17, 2010; doi: 10.1093/toxsci/kfq048.
69. vom Saal, F. S., Cooke, P. S., Buchanan, D. L., Palanza, P., Thayer, K. A., Nagel, S. C., Parmigiani, S., and Welshons, W. V. (1998). A physiologically based approach to the study of bisphenol A and other estrogenic chemicals on the size of reproductive organs, daily sperm production, and behavior. Toxicol. Ind. Health 14, 239-260.
70. Wendell, D. L., and Gorski, J. (1997). Quantitative trait loci for estrogen-dependent pituitary tumor growth in the rat. Mamm. Genome 8, 823-829.
71. Wiklund, J. A., and Gorski, J. (1982). Genetic differences in estrogen-induced deoxyribonucleic acid synthesis in the rat pituitary: correlations with pituitary tumor susceptibility. Endocrinology 111, 1140-1149.
72. Yasuda, Y., Kihara, T., and Nishimura, H. (1977). Effect of prenatal treatment with ethinyl estradiol on the mouse uterus and ovary. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol. 127, 832-836.
73. Yasuda, Y., Kihara, T., and Nishimura, H. (1981). Effect of ethinyl estradiol on development of mouse fetuses. Teratology 23, 233-239.
74. Yasuda, Y., Kihara, T., and Tanimura, T. (1985a). Effect of ethinyl estradiol on the differentiation of mouse fetal testis. Teratology 32, 113-118.
75. Yasuda, Y., Kihara, T., Tanimura, T., and Nishimura, H. (1985b). Gonadal dysgenesis induced by prenatal exposure to ethinyl estradiol in mice. Teratology 32, 219-227.
76. Yasuda, Y., Konish, H., and Tanimura, T. (1987). Ovarian follicular cell hyperplasia in fetal mice treated transplacentally with ethinyl estradiol. Teratology 36, 35-43.
77. Yasuda, Y., Konishi, H., Matuso, T., and Tanimura, T. (1986a). Accelerated differentiation in seminiferous tubules of fetal mice prenatally exposed to ethinyl estradiol. Anat. Embryol. 174, 289-299.
78. Yasuda, Y., Konishi, H., and Tanimura, T. (1986b). Leydig cell hyperplasia in fetal mice treated transplacentally with ethinyl estradiol. Teratology 33, 281-288.
79. Yoshino, H., Ichihara, T., Kawabe, M., Imai, N., Hagiwara, A., Asamoto, M., and Shirai, T. (2002). Lack of significant alteration in the prostate or testis of F344 rat offspring after transplacental and lactational exposure to bisphenol A. J. Toxicol. Sci. 27, 433-439.
80. Zoeller, R. T., Bansal, R., and Parris, C. (2005). Bisphenol-A, an environmental contaminant that acts as a thyroid hormone receptor antagonist in vitro, increases serum thyroxine, and alters RC3/neurogranin expression in the developing rat brain. Endocrinology 146, 607-612.
81. Zsarnovszky, A., Le, H. H., Wang, H. S., and Belcher, S. M. (2005). Ontogeny of rapid estrogen-mediated extracellular signal-regulated kinase signaling in the rat cerebellar cortex: potent nongenomic agonist and endocrine disrupting activity of the xenoestrogen bisphenol A. Endocrinology 146, 5388-5396.