Titanium versus zirconia implants supporting maxillary overdentures: Three-dimensional finite element analysis

International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Implants

Volumn 28, Issue 5, 2013, Pages e198-e208

  Osman, Reham B ^a,b   Elkhadem, Amr H ^b   Ma, Sunyoung ^a   Swain, Michael V ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF OTAGO   (New Zealand)

^b CAIRO UNIVERSITY   (Egypt)

Author keywords

Finite element analysis; Implant materials; Implant overdentures; Maxilla; Titanium; Zirconia

Indexed keywords

TITANIUM; ZIRCONIUM; ZIRCONIUM OXIDE; TOOTH IMPLANT;

ARTICLE; DENTAL PROCEDURE; MAXILLA; MECHANICAL STRESS; METHODOLOGY; OVERLAY DENTURE; PROSPECTIVE STUDY; TOOTH IMPLANT; TOOTH PROSTHESIS; PROCEDURES;

DENTAL IMPLANTS; DENTAL PROSTHESIS, IMPLANT-SUPPORTED; DENTAL STRESS ANALYSIS; DENTURE, OVERLAY; MAXILLA; PROSPECTIVE STUDIES; STRESS, MECHANICAL; TITANIUM; ZIRCONIUM;

EID: 84899468972     PISSN: 08822786     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.11607/jomi.3019     Document Type: Article

References (68)

1. Steinemann SG. Titanium-the material of choice? Periodontology 2000 1998; 17: 7-21.
2. Özkurt Z, Kazazoğlu E. Zirconia dental implants: A literature review. J Oral Implantol 2011; 37: 367-376.
3. Sicilia A, Cuesta S, Coma G, et al. Titanium allergy in dental implant patients: A clinical study on 1,500 consecutive patients. Clin Oral Implants Res 2008; 19: 823-835.
4. Vagkopoulou T, Koutayas SO, Koidis P, Strub JR. Zirconia in dentistry: Part 1: Discovering the nature of an upcoming ceramic. Eur J Esthet Dent 2009; 4: 130-151.
5. Javed F, Al-Hezaimi K, Almas K, Romanos GE. Is titanium sensitivity associated with allergic reactions in patients with dental implants? A systematic review. Clin Implant Dent Relat Res 2013; 15: 47-52.
6. Siddiqi A, Payne AGT, De Silva RK, Duncan WJ. Titanium allergy: Could it affect dental implant integration? Clin Oral Implants Res 2011; 22: 673-680.
7. Flatebø RS, Johannessen AC, Grønningsæter AG, et al. Host response to titanium dental implant placement evaluated in a human oral model. J Periodontol 2006; 77: 1201-1210.
8. Chaturvedi TP. An overview of the corrosion aspect of dental implants (titanium and its alloys). Indian J Dent Res 2009; 20: 91-98.
9. Du Preez L, Bütow KW, Swart TJP. Implant failure due to titanium hypersensitivity/ allergy?-Report of a case. S Af Dent J 2007; 62: 22-25.
10. Egusa H, Ko N, Shimazu T, Yatani H. Suspected association of an allergic reaction with titanium dental implants: A clinical report. J Prosthet Dent 2008; 100: 344-347.
11. Kawahara H, Hirabayashi M. Single crystal alumina for implants and bone screws. J Biomed Mater Res 1980; 14: 597-605.
12. Koth DL, McKinney RV, Steflik DE, Davis QB. Clinical and statistical analyses of human clinical trials with the single crystal aluminium oxide endosteal dental implant: Five-year results. J Prosthet Dent 1988; 60: 226- 234.
13. Sclaroff A, El-Mofty S, Guyer SE. Clinical evaluation of a single crystal sapphire tooth implant in human beings. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 1990; 70: 141-146.
14. Fartash B, Eliasson S, Arvidson K. Mandibular single crystal sapphire implants: Changes in crestal bone levels over three years. Clin Oral Implants Res 1995; 6: 181-188.
15. Fartash B, Tangerud T, Silness J, Arvidson K. Rehabilitation of mandibular edentulism by single crystal sapphire implants and overdentures: 3-12 year results in 86 patients. Clin Oral Implants Res 1996; 7: 220-229.
16. Steflik DE, Koth DL, Robinson FG, et al. Prospective investigation of the single-crystal sapphire endosteal dental implant in humans: Ten-year results. J Oral Implantol 1995; 11: 8-18.
17. Ichikawa Y, Akagawa Y, Nikai H, Tsuru H. Tissue compatibility and stability of a new zirconia ceramic in vivo. J Prosthet Dent 1992; 68: 322-326.
18. Berge TI, Grønningsæter AG. Survival of single crystal sapphire implants supporting mandibular overdentures. Clin Oral Implants Res 2000; 11: 154-162.
19. Koutayas SO, Vagkopoulou T, Pelekanos S, Koidis P, Strub JR. Zirconia in dentistry: Part 2. Evidence-based clinical breakthrough. Eur J Esthet Dent 2009; 4: 348-380.
20. Denry I, Kelly JR. State of the art of zirconia for dental applications. Dent Mater 2008; 24: 299-307.
21. Hisbergues M, Vendeville S, Vendeville P. Zirconia: Established facts and perspectives for a biomaterial in dental implantology. J Biomed Mater Res Part B Appl Biomater 2009; 88B: 519-529.
22. Garvie RC, Hannink RHJ, Pascoe RT. Ceramic steel? Nature 1975; 258: 703-704.
23. Piconi C, Maccauro G. Zirconia as a ceramic biomaterial. Biomaterials 1999; 20: 1-25.
24. Akagwa Y, Ichikawa Y, Nikai H, Tsuru H. Interface histology of unloaded and early loaded partially stabilized zirconia endosseous implant in initial bone healing. J Prosthet Dent 1993; 69: 599-604.
25. Akagwa Y, Hosokawa R, Sato Y, Kamayama K. Comparison between freestanding and tooth partially stabilized zirconia implants after two years function in monkeys: A clinical and histologic study. J Prosthet Dent 1998; 80: 551-558.
26. Scarano A, Di Carlo F, Quaranta M, Piattelli A. Bone response to zirconia ceramic implants: An experiment study in rabbits. J Oral Implantol 2003; 29: 8-12.
27. Kohal RJ, Weng D, Bächle M, Strub JR. Loaded custom-made zirconia and titanium implants show similar osseointegration: An animal experiment. J Periodontol 2004; 75: 1262-1268.
28. Sennerby L, Dasmah A, Larsson B, Iverhed M. Bone tissue responses to surface modified zirconia implants: A histomorphometric and removal torque study in the rabbit. Clin Implant Dent Relat Res 2005; 7(suppl I): 13-20.
29. Hoffmann O, Angelov N, Gallez F, Jung RE, Weber FE. The zirconia bone-implant interface: A preliminary histologic evaluation in rabbit. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2008; 23: 691-695.
30. Josset Y, Oum’Hamed Z, Zarrinpour A, Lorenzato M, Adnet JJ, Laurent-Maquin D. In vitro reactions of human osteoblasts in culture with zirconia and alumina ceramics. J Biomed Mater Res 1999; 47: 481-493.
31. Bächle M, Butz F, Hubner U, Bakalinis E, Kohal RJ. Behaviour of CAL 72 osteoblast-like cells cultured on zirconia ceramics with different surface topographies. Clin Oral Implants Res 2007; 18: 53-59.
32. Depprich R, Zipprich H, Ommerborn M, et al. Osseointegration of zirconia implants: An SEM observation of the bone-implant interface. Head Face Med 2008; 4: 25-31.
33. Gahlert M, Röhling S, Wieland M, Sprecher CM, Kniha H, Milz S. Osseointegration of zirconia and titanium dental implants: A histological and histomorphometrical study in the maxilla of pigs. Clin Oral Implants Res 2009; 20: 1247-1253.
34. Rimondini L, Cerroni L, Carrassi A, Torricelli P. Bacterial colonization of zirconia ceramic surface: An in vitro and in vivo study. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2002; 17: 793-798.
35. Scarano A, Piattelli M, Caputi S, Favero GA, Piattelli A. Bacterial adhesion on commercially pure titanium and zirconium oxide disks: An in vivo human study. J Periodontol 2004; 75: 292-296.
36. Degidi M, Artese L, Scarano A, Perrotti V, Gehrke P, Piattelli A. Inflammatory infiltrate, microvessel density, nitric oxide synthase expression, vascular endothelial growth factor expression, and proliferative activity in peri-implant soft tissues around titanium and zirconium oxide healing caps. J Periodontol 2006; 77: 73-80.
37. Größ ner-Schreiber B, Herzog M, Hedderich J, Dück A, Hannig M, Griepentrog M. Focal adhesion contact formation by fibroblasts cultured on surface-modified dental implants: An in vitro study. Clin Oral Implants Res 2006; 17: 736-745.
38. Oliva J, Oliva X, Oliva JD. One year-follow-up of first consecutive 100 zirconia dental implants in humans: A comparison of 2 different rough surfaces. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2007; 23: 430-435.
39. Kohal RJ, Klaus G. A zirconia implant-crown system: A case report. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2004; 24: 147-153.
40. Oliva J, Oliva X, Oliva JD. Ovoid zirconia implants: Anatomic design for premolar replacement. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent 2008; 28: 609-615.
41. Payer M, Arnetzl V, Kirmeier R, Koller M, Arnetzl G, Jakse N. Immediate provisional restoration of single-piece zirconia implants: A prospective case series-Results after 24 months of clinical function. Clin Oral Implants Res 2013; 24: 569-575.
42. Kohal RJ, Papavasiliou G, Kamposiora P, Tripodakis A, Strub JR. Three-dimensional computerized stress analysis of commercially pure titanium and yttrium-partially stabilized zirconia implants. Int J Prosthodont 2002; 15: 189-194.
43. Cağlar A, Bal BT, Karakoca S, Aydin C, Yilmaz H, Sarisoy Ş. Three-dimensional finite element analysis of titanium and yttrium-stabilized zirconium dioxide abutments and implants. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2011; 26: 961-969.
44. Choi AH, Matinlinna JP, Ben-Nissan B. Finite element stress analysis of Ti-6Al-4V and partially stabilized zirconia dental implant during clenching. Acta Odontologica Scandinavica 2012 Sep; 70: 353-361.
45. Clelland NL, Lee JK, Bimbenet OC, Gilat A. use of an axisymmetric finite element method to compare maxillary bone variables for a loaded implant. J Prosthodont 1993; 2: 183-189.
46. Meyer U, Vollmer D, Runte C, Bourauel C, Joos U. Bone loading pattern around implants in average and atrophic edentulous maxillae: A finite element analysis. J Cranio Maxillofac Surg 2001; 29: 100-105.
47. Saab EX, Griggs AJ, Powers MJ, Engelmier RL. Effect of abutment angulation on the strain on the bone around an implant in the anterior maxilla: A finite element study. J Prosthet Dent 2007; 97: 85-92.
48. Cheng YY, Cheung WL, Chow TW. Strain analysis of maxillary complete denture with three dimensional finite element method. J Prosthet Dent 2010; 103: 309-318.
49. Kohal RJ, Finke HC, Klaus G. Stability of prototype two-piece zirconia and titanium implants after artificial aging: An in vitro pilot study. Clin Implant Dent Relat Res 2009; 11: 323-329.
50. Geng JP, Tan KBC, Liu GR. Application of finite element analysis in implant dentistry: A review of literature. J Prosthet Dent 2001; 85: 585-598.
51. Chun HJ, Park DN, Han CH, Heo SJ, Heo MS, Koak YJ. Stress distribution in maxillary bone surrounding overdenture implants with different overdenture attachments. J Oral Rehabil 2005; 32: 193-205.
52. Shinya A, Ballo AM, Lassila LVJ, Shinya A, Närhi TO, Vallittu PK. Stress and strain analysis of the bone-implant interface: A comparison of fiber reinforced composite and titanium implants utilizing 3-dimensional finite element study. J Oral Implantol 2011; 37: 133-140.
53. Van Steenberghe D, Quirynen M, Naert I, Maffei G, Jacobs R. Marginal bone loss around implants retaining hinging overdentures at 4-, 8- and 12-years follow-up. J Clin Periodontol 2001; 28: 628-633.
54. Närhi TO, Hevinga M, Voorsmit RA, Kalk W. Maxillary overdentures retained by splinted and unsplinted implants: A retrospective study. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2001; 16: 259-266.
55. González JEG, Mirza-Rosca JC. Study behavior of titanium and some of its alloys for biomedical and dental implant applications. J Electroanal Chem 1999; 471: 109-115.
56. Black J, Hastings G. Handbook of Biomaterial Properties,1 ed 1. Oxide Bioceramics: Inert Ceramic Materials In Medicine And Dentistry. Thomson Science, London: Chapman & Hall, 1998: 340.
57. Cağlar A, Bal BT, Aydin C, Yilmaz H, Özkan S. Evaluation of stresses occurring on three different zirconia dental implants: Three dimensional finite element analysis. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2010; 25: 95-103.
58. Osman RB, Elkhadem AH, Ma S, Swain MV. A finite element analysis of a novel implant distribution supporting maxillary overdentures. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 2013; 28: e1-e10.
59. Okumura N, Stegaroiu R, Kitamura E, Kurokawa K, Nomura S. Influence of maxillary cortical bone thickness, implant design and implant diameter on stress around implants: A three-dimensional finite element analysis. J Prosthodont Res 2010; 54: 133-142.
60. Gross MD, Nissa J, Samuel R. Stress distribution around maxillary implants in anatomic photoelastic models of varying geometry. Part I. J Prosthet Dent 2001; 85: 442-449.
61. Koca OL, Eskitascioglu G, Usumez A. Three-dimensional finite element analysis of functional stresses in different bone locations produced by implants placed in the maxillary posterior region of the sinus floor. J Prosthet Dent 2005; 93: 38-44.
62. Kamposiora P, Papavasilious G, PBayne SC, Felton DA. Finite element analysis estimates of cement microfracture under complete veneer crowns. J Prosthet Dent 1994; 71: 435-441.
63. Frost HM. From Wolff’s law to the Utah paradigm: Insights about bone physiology and its clinical applications. Anat Rec 2001; 262: 398-419.
64. Frost HM. Perspectives: Bone’s mechanical usage window. Bone Miner 1992; 19: 257-271.
65. Frost HM. A 2003 update of bone physiology and Wolff’s law for clinicians. Angle Orthod 2004; 74: 3-15.
66. Jemt T, Book K, Linden B, Urde G. Failures and complications in 92 consecutively inserted overdentures supported by Brå nemark implants in severely resorbed edentulous maxillae: A study from prosthetic treatment to first annual check-up. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 1992; 7: 162-167.
67. Johns RB, Jemt T, Heath MR, et al I. A multicenter study of overdentures supported by Brå nemark implants. Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants 1992; 7: 513-522.
68. Payne AGT, Solomons YF, Tawse-Smith A, Lownie JF. Inter-abutment and peri-abutment mucosal enlargements with mandibular implant overdentures. Clin Oral Implants Res 2001; 12: 179-187.