Whom do children copy? Model-based biases in social learning

Developmental Review

Volumn 33, Issue 4, 2013, Pages 341-356

  Wood, Lara A ^a   Kendal, Rachel L ^a   Flynn, Emma G ^b  

^a DURHAM UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^b DURHAM UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Cultural transmission; Model based biases; Social cognition; Social learning; Trust

Indexed keywords

EID: 84887607472     PISSN: 02732297     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.dr.2013.08.002     Document Type: Review

References (121)

1. Abramovitch R., Corter C., Pepler D.J. Observations of mixed-sex sibling dyads. Child Development 1980, 51(4):1268-1271.
2. Amlacher J., Dugatkin L.A. Preference for older over younger models during mate-choice copying in young guppies. Ethology Ecology & Evolution 2005, 17:161-169.
3. Behne T., Carpenter M., Tomasello M. One-year-olds comprehend the communicative intentions behind gestures in a hiding game. Developmental Science 2005, 8(6):492-499.
4. Bekkering H., Wohlschläger A., Gattis M. Imitation of gestures in children is goal-directed. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 2000, 53:153-164.
5. Benskin C.M.H., Mann N.I., Lachlan R.F., Slater P.J.B. Social learning directs feeding preferences in the zebra finch (Taeniopygia guttata). Animal Behaviour 2002, 64(5):823-828.
6. Birch S.A.J., Vauthier S.A., Bloom P. Three- and four-year-olds spontaneously use others' past performance to guide their learning. Cognition 2008, 107(3):1018-1034.
7. Biro D., Inoue-Nakamura N., Tonooka R., Yamakoshi G., Sousa C., Matsuzawa T. Cultural innovation and transmission of tool use in wild chimpanzees: Evidence from field experiments. Animal Cognition 2003, 6(4):213-223.
8. Bonawitz E., Shafto P., Gweon H., Goodman N.D., Spelke E., Schulz L. The double-edged sword of pedagogy: Instruction limits spontaneous exploration and discovery. Cognition 2011, 120(3):322-330.
9. Bonnie K.E., Horner V., Whiten A., de Waal F.B.M. Spread of arbitrary conventions among chimpanzees: A controlled experiment. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2007, 274(1608):367-372.
10. Boyd R., Richerson P. Culture and the evolutionary process 1985, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
11. Boyd R., Richerson P.J., Henrich J. The cultural niche: Why social learning is essential for human adaptation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2011, 108(2):10918-10925.
12. Brody G.H., Stoneman Z. Selective imitation of same-age, older, and younger peer models. Child Development 1981, 52(2):717-720.
13. Brody G.H., Stoneman Z. Peer imitation: An examination of status and competence hypotheses. The Journal of Genetic Psychology 1985, 146(2):161-170.
14. Brosseau-Liard P.E., Birch S.A. 'I bet you know more and are nicer too!': What children infer from others' accuracy. Developmental Science 2010, 13(5):772-778.
15. Brosseau-Liard P.E., Birch S.A. Epistemic states and traits: Preschoolers appreciate the differential informativeness of situation-specific and person-specific cues to knowledge. Child Development 2011, 82(6):1788-1796.
16. Brugger A., Lariviere L.A., Mumme D.L., Bushnell E.W. Doing the right thing: Infants' selection of actions to imitate from observed event sequences. Child Development 2007, 78(3):806-824.
17. Buttelmann D., Carpenter M., Call J., Tomasello M. Enculturated chimpanzees imitate rationally. Developmental Science 2007, 10(4):F31-F38.
18. Buttelmann D., Zmyj N., Daum M.M., Carpenter M. Selective imitation of in-group over out-group members in 14-month-old infants. Child Development 2012, 84(2):422-428.
19. Cadieu N., Fruchard S., Cadieu J.-C. Innovative individuals are not always the best demonstrators: Feeding innovation and social transmission in Serinus canaria. PLoS One 2010, 5(1):e8841.
20. Call J., Tomasello M. Distinguishing intentional from accidental actions in orangutans (Pongo pygmaeus), chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) and human children (Homo sapiens). Journal of Comparative Psychology 1999, 112(2):192-206.
21. Carpenter M., Akhtar N., Tomasello M. Fourteen- through 18-month-old infants differentially imitate intentional and accidental actions. Infant Behavior and Development 1998, 21(2):315-330.
22. Chen M.L., Waxman S.R. "Shall we "blick?": Novel words highlight actors' underlying intentions for 14-month-old infants. Developmental Psychology 2013, 49(3):426-431.
23. Choleris E., Guo C., Liu H., Mainardi M., Valsecchi P. The effect of demonstrator age and number on duration of socially-induced food preferences in house mouse (Mus domesticus). Behavioural Processes 1997, 41(1):69-77.
24. Chudek M., Heller S., Birch S., Henrich J. Prestige-biased cultural learning: Bystander's differential attention to potential models influences children's learning. Evolution and Human Behavior 2012, 33(1):46-56.
25. Clément F., Koenig M.A., Harris P.L. The Ontogenesis of trust. Mind & Language 2004, 19(4):360-379.
26. Corriveau K., Harris P.L. Preschoolers continue to trust a more accurate informant 1week after exposure to accuracy information. Developmental Science 2009, 12(1):188-193.
27. Corriveau K., Harris P.L. Choosing your informant: Weighing familiarity and recent accuracy. Developmental Science 2009, 12(3):426-437.
28. Corriveau K., Harris P.L., Meins E., Fernyhough C., Arnott B., Elliott L., et al. Young children's trust in their mother's claims: Longitudinal links with attachment security in infancy. Child Development 2009, 80(3):750-761.
29. Csibra G., Gergely G. Natural pedagogy. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2009, 13(4):148-153.
30. Dawkins R. The selfish gene 1989, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
31. Dean L.G., Kendal R.L., Schapiro S.J., Thierrey B., Laland K.N. Identification of the social-cognitive capabilities underlying human cumulative culture. Science 2012, 335(6072):1114-1118.
32. Dindo M., Thierry B., Whiten A. Social diffusion of novel foraging methods in brown capuchin monkeys (Cebus apella). Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2008, 275(1631):187-193.
33. DiYanni C., Kelemen D. Using a bad tool with good intention: Young children's imitation of adults' questionable choices. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 2008, 101(4):241-261.
34. Duffy G.A., Pike T.W., Laland K.N. Size-dependent directed social learning in nine-spined sticklebacks. Animal Behaviour 2009, 78(2):371-375.
35. Elekes, F., & Kiraly, I. (2012). Selective imitation in relation to the demonstrator's inferred knowledgeability in 18- to 24-month-old infants. Poster presented at the Budapest CEU conference on cognitive development. Budapest, Hungary.
36. Flynn E. Investigating children as cultural magnets: Do young children transmit redundant information along diffusion chains?. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B - Biological Sciences 2008, 363(1509):3541-3551.
37. Flynn E., Whiten A. Imitation of hierarchical structure versus component details of complex actions by 3-and 5-year-olds. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 2008, 101(4):228-240.
38. Flynn E., Whiten A. Experimental "microcultures" in young children: Identifying biographic, cognitive, and social predictors of information transmission. Child Development 2012, 83(3):911-925.
39. Frazier B.N., Gelman S.A., Kaciroti N., Russell J.W., Lumeng J.C. I'll have what she's having: The impact of model characteristics on children's food choices. Developmental Science 2011, 15(1):87-98.
40. Fusaro M., Harris P.L. Children assess informant reliability using bystanders' non-verbal cues. Developmental Science 2008, 11(5):771-777.
41. Gardiner A.K., Greif M.L., Bjorklund D.F. Guided by intention: Preschooler's imitation reflects inferences of causation. Journal of Cognition and Development 2011, 12(3):355-373.
42. Grusec J.E., Abramovitch R. Imitation of peers and adults in a natural setting: A functional analysis. Child Development 1982, 53:636-642.
43. Grusec J.E., Lytton H. Social development 1988, Springer, New York.
44. Harris P.L. Trust. Developmental Science 2007, 10(1):135-138.
45. Henrich J., Gil-White F.J. The evolution of prestige: Freely conferred deference as a mechanism for enhancing the benefits of cultural transmission. Evolution and Human Behavior 2001, 22(3):165-196.
46. Henrich J., McElreath R. The evolution of cultural evolution. Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews 2003, 12(3):123-135.
47. Horner V., Proctor D., Bonnie K.E., Whiten A., de Waal F.B.M. Prestige affects cultural learning in chimpanzees. PLoS One 2010, 5(5):e10625.
48. Horner V., Whiten A. Causal knowledge and imitation/emulation switching in chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) and children (Homo sapiens). Animal Cognition 2005, 8(3):164-181.
49. Jaswal V.K., Malone L.S. Turning believers into skeptics: 3-year-olds' sensitivity to cues to speaker credibility. Journal of Cognition and Development 2007, 8(3):263-283.
50. Jaswal V.K., McKercher D.A., VanderBorght M. Limitations on reliability: Regularity rules in the English plural and past tense. Child Development 2008, 79(3):750-760.
51. Jaswal V.K., Neely L.A. Adults don't always know best. Psychological Science 2006, 17(9):757-758.
52. Katz M., Lachlan R.F. Social learning of food types in zebra finches (Taenopygia guttata) is directed by demonstrator sex and feeding activity. Animal Cognition 2003, 6(1):11-16.
53. Kendal R.L., Coolen I., Laland K.N. The role of conformity in foraging when personal and social information conflict. Behavioral Ecology 2004, 15(2):269-277.
54. Kendal R., Custance D., Kendal J., Vale G., Stoinski T., Rakotomalala N., et al. Evidence for social learning in wild lemurs (Lemur catta). Learning & Behavior 2010, 38(3):220-234.
55. Kendal, R. L., Hopper, L. M., Laland, K. N., Whiten, A., Brosnan, S. F., Lambeth, S. P., et al. (submitted for publication). Chimpanzees copy dominant and knowledgeable individuals.
56. Kinzler K.D., Corriveau K.H., Harris P.L. Children's selective trust in native-accented speakers. Developmental Science 2011, 14(1):106-111.
57. Kinzler K.D., Dupoux E., Spelke E.S. The native language of social cognition. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2007, 104(30):12577-12580.
58. Koenig M.A., Clément F., Harris P.L. Trust in testimony: Children's use of true and false statements. Psychological Science 2004, 15(10):694-698.
59. Koenig M.A., Echols C.H. Infants' understanding of false labeling events: The referential roles of words and the speakers who use them. Cognition 2003, 87(3):179-208.
60. Koenig M.A., Harris P.L. The role of social cognition in early trust. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2005, 9(10):457-459.
61. Koenig M.A., Harris P.L. Preschoolers mistrust ignorant and inaccurate speakers. Child Development 2005, 76(6):1261-1277.
62. Koenig M.A., Jaswal V.K. Characterizing children's expectations about expertise and incompetence: Halo or pitchfork effects?. Child Development 2011, 82(5):1634-1647.
63. Kuczynski L., Zahn-Waxler C., Radke-Yarrow M. Development and content of imitation in the second and third years of life: A socialization perspective. Developmental Psychology 1987, 23(2):276-282.
64. Laland K.N. Social learning strategies. Learning & Behavior 2004, 32(1):4-14.
65. Lane J.D., Wellman H.M., Gelman S.A. Informants' traits weigh heavily in young children's trust in testimony and in their epistemic inferences. Child Development 2012, 84(4):1258-1268.
66. Learmonth A.E., Lamberth R., Rovee-Collier C. The social context of imitation in infancy. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 2005, 91(4):297-314.
67. Liszkowski U., Carpenter M., Tomasello M. Twelve-month-olds communicate helpfully and appropriately for knowledgeable and ignorant partners. Cognition 2008, 108(3):732-739.
68. Lucas A.J., Lewis C., Pala F.C., Wong K., Berridge D. Social-cognitive processes in preschoolers' selective trust: Three cultures compared. Developmental Psychology 2013, 49(3):579-590.
69. Ma L., Ganea P.A. Dealing with conflicting information: Young children's reliance on what they see versus what they are told. Developmental Science 2010, 13(1):151-160.
70. McGuigan N. The influence of model status on the tendency of young children to over-imitate. Journal of Experimental Psychology 2013.
71. McGuigan N., Makinson J., Whiten A. From over-imitation to super-copying: Adults imitate causally irrelevant aspects of tool use with higher fidelity than young children. British Journal of Psychology 2011, 102(1):1-18.
72. Mesoudi A., O'Brien M.J. The cultural transmission of great basin projectile-point technology II: An agent-based computer simulation. American Antiquity 2008, 73(4):627-644.
73. Moore C., Bryant D., Furrow D. Mental terms and the development of certainty. Child Development 1989, 60(1):167-171.
74. Nicol C.J., Pope S.J. Social learning in small flocks of laying hens. Animal Behaviour 1994, 47(6):1289-1296.
75. Nicol C.J., Pope S.J. The effects of demonstrator social status and prior foraging success on social learning in laying hens. Animal Behaviour 1999, 57(1):163-171.
76. Nielsen M. Copying actions and copying outcomes: Social learning through the second year. Developmental Psychology 2006, 42(3):555-565.
77. Nielsen M. The imitative behaviour of children and chimpanzees: A window on the transmission of cultural traditions. Revue de primatologie 2009, 1.
78. Nielsen M., Blank C. Imitation in young children: When who gets copied is more important than what gets copied. Developmental Psychology 2011, 47(4):1050-1053.
79. Nielsen M., Cucchiaro J., Mohamedally When the transmission of culture is child's play. PLoS One 2012, 7:e34066.
80. Nielsen M., Simcock G., Jenkins L. The effect of social engagement on 24-month-olds' imitation from live and televised models. Developmental Science 2008, 11(5):722-731.
81. Ottoni E., de Resende B., Izar P. Watching the best nutcrackers: What capuchin monkeys (Cebus apella) know about others' tool-using skills. Animal Cognition 2005, 8(4):215-219.
82. Over H., Carpenter M. Eighteen-month-old infants show increased helping following priming with affiliation. Psychological Science 2009, 20(10):1189-1193.
83. Over H., Carpenter M. Putting the social into social learning: Explaining both selectivity and fidelity in children's copying behavior. Journal of Comparative Psychology 2012, 126(2):182-192.
84. Palmquist C.M., Burns H.E., Jaswal V.K. Pointing disrupts preschoolers' ability to discriminate between knowledgeable and ignorant informants. Cognitive Development 2012, 27(1):54-63.
85. Pasquini E.S., Corriveau K.H., Koenig M.A., Harris P.L. Preschoolers monitor the relative accuracy of informants. Developmental Psychology 2007, 43(5):1216-1226.
86. Pellegrini A.D., Roseth C.J., Mliner S., Bohn C.M., Van Ryzin M., Vance N., et al. Social dominance in preschool classrooms. Journal of Comparative Psychology 2007, 121(1):54-64.
87. Pepler D.J., Abramovitch R., Corter C. Sibling interaction in the home: A longitudinal study. Child Development 1981, 52(4):1344-1347.
88. Rakoczy H., Hamann K., Warneken F., Tomasello M. Bigger knows better: Young children selectively learn rule games from adults rather than from peers. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 2010, 28(4):785-798.
89. Range F., Viranyi Z., Huber L. Selective imitation in domestic dogs. Current Biology 2007, 17(10):868-872.
90. Rendell L., Fogarty L., Hoppitt W.J.E., Morgan T.J.H., Webster M.M., Laland K.N. Cognitive culture: Theoretical and empirical insights into social learning strategies. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2011, 15(2):68-76.
91. Repacholi B.M. Linking actions and emotions: Evidence from 15- and 18-month-old infants. British Journal of Developmental Psychology 2009, 27(3):649-667.
92. Repacholi B.M., Meltzoff A.N. Emotional eavesdropping: Infants selectively respond to indirect emotional signals. Child Development 2007, 78(2):503-521.
93. Ryalls B.O., Gul R.E., Ryalls K.R. Infant imitation of peer and adult models: Evidence for a peer model advantage. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly 2000, 46(1):188-202.
94. Sabbagh M.A., Baldwin D.A. Learning words from knowledgeable versus ignorant speakers: Links between preschoolers' theory of mind and semantic development. Child Development 2001, 72(4):1054-1070.
95. Sabbagh M.A., Wdowiak S.D., Ottaway J.M. Do word learners ignore ignorant speakers?. Journal of Child Language 2003, 30(4):905-924.
96. Saggerson A.L., Honey R.C. Observational learning of instrumental discriminations in the rat: The role of demonstrator type. The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 2006, 59(11):1909-1920.
97. Sanvito S., Galimberti F., Miller E.H. Observational evidences of vocal learning in southern elephant seals: A longitudinal study. Ethology 2007, 113(2):137-146.
98. Seehagen S., Herbert J.S. Infant imitation from televised peer and adult models. Infancy 2011, 16(2):113-136.
99. Seehagen S., Herbert J.S. Selective imitation in 6-month-olds: The role of the social and physical context. Infant Behavior and Development 2012, 35:509-512.
100. Serbin L.A., Poulin-Dubois D., Colburne K.A., Sen M.G., Eichstedt J.A. Gender stereotyping in infancy: Visual preferences for and knowledge of gender-stereotyped toys in the second year. International Journal of Behavioral Development 2001, 25(1):7-15.
101. Shutts K., Banaji M.R., Spelke E.S. Social categories guide young children's preferences for novel objects. Developmental Science 2010, 13(4):599-610.
102. Shutts K., Kinzler K.D., McKee C.B., Spelke E.S. Social information guides infants' selection of foods. Journal of Cognition and Development 2009, 10(1-2):1-17.
103. Southgate V., Chevallier C., Csibra G. Sensitivity to communicative relevance tells young children what to imitate. Developmental Science 2009, 12(6):1013-1019.
104. Swaney W., Kendal J., Capon H., Brown C., Laland K.N. Familiarity facilitates social learning of foraging behaviour in the guppy. Animal Behaviour 2001, 62(3):591-598.
105. Taylor M.G. Gender influences on children's selective trust of adult testimony. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 2013, 115(4):672-690.
106. Tenney E.R., MacCoun R.J., Spellman B.A., Hastie R. Calibration trumps confidence as a basis for witness credibility. Psychological Science 2007, 18(1):46-50.
107. Tenney E.R., Small J.E., Kondrad R.L., Jaswal V.K., Spellman B.A. Accuracy, confidence, and calibration: How young children and adults assess credibility. Developmental Psychology 2011, 47(4):1065-1077.
108. Tenney E.R., Spellman B.A., MacCoun R.J. The benefits of knowing what you know (and what you don't): How calibration affects credibility. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 2008, 44(5):1368-1375.
109. Užgiris I.C. Two functions of imitation during infancy. International Journal of Behavioral Development 1981, 4(1):1-12.
110. van de Waal E., Renevey N., Favre C.M., Bshary R. Selective attention to philopatric models causes directed social learning in wild vervet monkeys. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2010, 277(1691):2105-2111.
111. VanderBorght M., Jaswal V.K. Who knows best? Preschoolers sometimes prefer child informants over adult informants. Infant and Child Development 2009, 18(1):61-71.
112. Vázquez M.D., Delisle S.S., Saylor M.M. Four- and six-year-olds use pragmatic competence to guide word learning. Journal of Child Language 2012, 40(2):291-306.
113. Whiten A., Erdal D. The human socio-cognitive niche and its evolutionary origins. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2012, 367(2):2119-2129.
114. Whiten A., Hinde R.A., Laland K.N., Stringer C.B. Culture evolves. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2011, 366(1567):938-948.
115. Williamson R.A., Meltzoff A.N., Markman E.M. Prior experiences and perceived efficacy influence 3-year-olds' imitation. Developmental Psychology 2008, 44(1):275-285.
116. Wood, L. A., Kendal, R. L., & Flynn, E. G. (in preparation). Familiar peers' past-proficiency and children's solution choice.
117. Wood L.A., Kendal R.L., Flynn E.G. Context-dependent model-based biases in cultural transmission: Children's imitation is affected by model age over model knowledge state. Evolution and Human Behavior 2012, 33(4):387-394.
118. Wood L.A., Kendal R.L., Flynn E.G. Copy me or copy you? The effect of prior experience on social learning. Cognition 2013, 127:203-213.
119. Zmyj N., Aschersleben G., Prinz W., Daum M.M. The peer model advantage in infants' imitation of familiar gestures performed but differently aged models. Fourteen-month-olds' imitation of differently aged models. Frontiers in, Developmental Psychology 2012, 3:252.
120. Zmyj N., Buttelmann D., Carpenter M., Daum M.M. The reliability of a model influences 14-month-olds' imitation. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 2010, 106(4):208-220.
121. Zmyj N., Daum M.M., Prinz W., Nielsen M., Aschersleben G. Fourteen-month-olds' imitation of differently aged models. Infant and Child Development 2011, 21(3):250-266.