Communicating Numerical Risk: Human Factors That Aid Understanding in Health Care

Reviews of Human Factors and Ergonomics

Volumn 8, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 235-276

  Brust Renck, Priscila G ^a   Royer, Caisa E ^a   Reyna, Valerie F ^a  

^a Department of Obstetrics Gynecology   (United States)

Author keywords

categorical risk; class inclusion; decision making; graphs; human factors; numeracy; presentation format; risk communication; visual information

Indexed keywords

EID: 84884613162     PISSN: 1557234X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book Series    
DOI: 10.1177/1557234X13492980     Document Type: Review

References (120)

1. Adam M. B.,Reyna V. F.Coherence and correspondence criteria for rationality: Experts' estimation of risks of sexually transmitted infections.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. 2005;18:169-186.
2. Ancker J. S.,Senathirajah Y.,Kukafka R.,Starren J. B.Design features of graphs in health risk communication: A systematic review.Journal of the American Medical Information Association. 2006;13:608-618.
3. Betsch C.,Brewer N. T.,Brocard P.,Davies P.,Gaissmaier W.,Haase N., Stryk M.Opportunities and challenges of web 2.0 for vaccination decisions.Vaccine. 2012;30:372-3733.
4. Boase S.,Mason D.,Sutton S.,Cohn S.Tinkering and tailoring individual consultations: How practice nurses try to make cardiovascular risk communication meaningful.Journal of Clinical Nursing. 2012;21:2590-2598.
5. Brainerd C. J.,Reyna V. F.Inclusion illusions: Fuzzy-trace theory and perceptual salience effects in cognitive development.Developmental Review. 1990;10:365-403.
6. BrewerN. T. (2011). Goals. In FischhoffB.BrewerN. T.DownsJ. S. (Eds.), Communicating risks and benefits: An evidence-based user's guide (pp. 3-10). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Food and Drug Administration. Retrieved from http://www.fda.gov/ScienceResearch/SpecialTopics/RiskCommunication/default.htm.
7. Brewer N. T.,Chapman G. B.,Gibbons F. X.,Gerrard M.,McCaul K. D.,Weinstein N. D.Meta-analysis of the relationship between risk perception and health behavior: The example of vaccination.Health Psychology. 2007;26:136-145.
8. Brewer N. T.,Fazekas K. I.Predictors of HPV vaccine acceptability: A theory-informed, systematic review.Preventive Medicine. 2007;34:107-114.
9. Brewer N. T.,Richman A. R.,DeFrank J. T.,Reyna V. F.,Carey L. A.Improving communication of breast cancer recurrence risk.Breast Cancer Research and Treatment. 2012;133:553-561.
10. Brewer N. T.,Tzeng J. P.,Lillie S. E.,Edwards A. S.,Peppercorn J. M.,Rimer B. K.Health literacy and cancer risk perception: Implications for genomic risk communication.Medical Decision Making. 2009;29:157-166.
11. Bruine de Bruin W.,Downs J. S.,Fischhoff B.,Palmgren C.Development and evaluation of an HIV/AIDS knowledge measure for adolescents focusing on misconceptions.Journal of HIV/AIDS Prevention in Children and Youth. 2007;8:35-57.
12. Brust-Renck P. G.,Royer C. E.,Reyna V. F.,Corbin J. C.The Sage handbook of risk communication. Cho H.Reimer T.McComas K., ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; in press:.
13. Cavanaugh K.,Huizinga M. M.,Wallston K. A.,Gebretsadik T.,Shintani A.,Davis D., Rothman R. L.Association of numeracy and diabetes control.Annals of Internal Medicine. 2008;148:737-746.
14. Cuite C. L.,Weinstein N. D.,Emmons K.,Colditz G.A test of numeric formats for communicating risk probabilities.Medical Decision Making. 2008;28:377-384.
15. Davids S. L.,Schapira M. M.,McAuliffe T. L.,Nattinger A. B.Predictors of pessimistic breast cancer risk perceptions in a primary care population.Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2004;19:310-315.
16. Downs J. S.,Bruine de Bruin W.,Fischhoff B.Parents' vaccination comprehension and decisions.Vaccine. 2008;26:1595-1607.
17. Epstein S.Integration of the cognitive and the psychodynamic unconscious.American Psychologist. 1994;49:709-724.
18. Eraker S. A.,Sox H. C.Assessment of patients' preferences for therapeutic outcomes.Medical Decision Making. 1981;1:29-39.
19. Evans J. St. B. T.Dual-process theories of reasoning: Contemporary issues and developmental applications.Developmental Review. 2011;31:86-102.
20. FagerlinA.PetersE. (2011) Quantitative information. In FischhoffB.BrewerN. T.DownsJ. S. (Eds.), Communicating risks and benefits: An evidence-based user's guide (pp. 53-64). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Food and Drug Administration. Retrieved from http://www.fda.gov/ScienceResearch/SpecialTopics/RiskCommunication/default.htm.
21. Fagerlin A.,Zikmund-Fisher B. J.,Ubel P. A.Helping patients decide: Ten steps to better risk communication.Journal of the National Cancer Institute. 2011;103:1436-1443.
22. Feldman-Stewart D.,Brundage M. D.,Zotov V.Further insight into the perception of quantitative information for treatment decisions.Medical Decision Making. 2007;27:34-43.
23. Fischhoff B.Decision research strategies.Health Psychology. 2005;21 (4): S9-S16.
24. Fischhoff B.Oxford textbook of public health. 2009). Risk perception and communication. In DetelsR.BeagleholeR.LansangM. A.GuillifordM. (Eds.), Oxford textbook of public health (5th ed., pp. 940-952). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.Detels R.Beaglehole R.Lansang M. A.Guilliford M., ed. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 2009:940-952.
25. Fischhoff B.Judgment and decision making.Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Cognitive Science. 2010;1:724-735.
26. FischhoffB. (2011). Duty to inform. In FischhoffB.BrewerN. T.DownsJ. S. (Eds.), Communicating risks and benefits: An evidence-based user's guide (pp. 19-29). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Food and Drug Administration. Retrieved from http://www.fda.gov/ScienceResearch/SpecialTopics/RiskCommunication/default.htm.
27. FischhoffB.BrewerN. T.DownsJ. S. (Eds.) (2011). Communicating risks and benefits: An evidence-based user's guide. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Food and Drug Administration. Retrieved from http://www.fda.gov/ScienceResearch/SpecialTopics/RiskCommunication/default.htm.
28. Fischhoff B.,Kadvany J.Risk: A very short introduction. New York, NY: Oxford University Press; 2011:.
29. Fraenkel L.,Peters E.,Charpentier P.,Olson B.,Errante L.,Schoen R.,Reyna V.A decision tool to improve the quality of care in rheumatoid arthritis.Arthritis Care & Research. 2012;64:977-985.
30. Gaissmaier W.,Wegwarth O.,Skopec D.,Müller A.,Broschinski S.,Politi M. C.Numbers can be worth a thousand pictures: Individual differences in understanding graphical and numerical representations of health-related information.Health Psychology. 2012;31:286-296.
31. Galesic M.,Garcia-Retamero R.Graph literacy: A cross-cultural comparison.Medical Decision Making. 2011;31:444-457.
32. Garcia-Retamero R.,Cokely E. T.Effective communication of risks to young adults: Using message framing and visual aids to increase condom use and STD screening.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied. 2011;17:270-287.
33. Garcia-Retamero R.,Galesic M.Who profits from visual aids: Overcoming challenges in people's understanding of risks.Social Science & Medicine. 2010;70:1019-1025.
34. Gardner P. H.,McMillan B.,Raynor D. K.,Woolf E.,Knapp P.The effect of numeracy on the comprehension of information about medicines in users of a patient information website.Patient Education and Counseling. 2011;83:398-403.
35. Grime J.,Blenkinsopp A.,Raynor D. K.,Pollock K.,Knapp P.The role and values of written information for patients about individual medicines: A systematic review.Health Expectations. 2007;10:286-298.
36. Hawley S. T.,Zikmund-Fisher B.,Ubel P.,Jancovic A.,Lucas T.,Fagerlin A.The impact of the format of graphical presentation on health-related knowledge and treatment choices.Patient Education and Counseling. 2008;73:448-455.
37. HessR.VisschersV. H. M.SiegristM. (2011). Risk communication with pictographs: The role of numeracy and graph processing. Judgment and Decision Making, 6, 263-274. Retrieved from http://journal.sjdm.org/11/10630/jdm10630.html.
38. Kahneman D.A perspective on judgment and choice: Mapping bounded rationality.American Psychologist. 2003;58:697-720.
39. Kahneman D.Thinking fast and slow. New York, NY: Farrar, Strauss, Giroux; 2011:.
40. KahnemanD.TverskyA. (1979). Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica, 47, 263-292. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/1914185.
41. Kühberger A.,Tanner C.Risky choice framing: Task versions and a comparison of prospect theory and fuzzy-trace theory.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. 2010;23:314-329.
42. Liberali J. M.,Reyna V. F.,Furlan S.,Stein L. M.,Pardo S. T.Individual differences in numeracy and implications for biases and fallacies in probability judgment.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. 2011;25:361-381.
43. Lipkus I. M.,Hollands J. G.The visual communication of risk.Journal of the National Cancer Institution Monograph. 1999;25:149-163.
44. Lipkus I. M.,Peters E.Understanding the role of numeracy in health: Proposed theoretical framework and practical insights.Health Education and Behavior. 2009;36:1065-1081.
45. Lloyd F. J.,Reyna V. F.A web exercise in evidence-based medicine using cognitive theory.Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2001;16:94-99.
46. Lloyd F. J.,Reyna V. F.Clinical gist and medical education: Connecting the dots.Journal of the American Medical Association. 2009;302:1332-1333.
47. Lloyd F.,Reyna V. F.,Whalen P.Accuracy and ambiguity in counseling patients about genetic risk.Archives of Internal Medicine. 2001;161:2411-2413.
48. Mather M.,Mazar N.,Gorlick M. A.,Lighthall N. R.,Burgeno J.,Schoeke A.,Ariely D.Risk preferences and aging: The "certainty effect" in older adults' decision making.Psychology and Aging. in press;27:801-816.
49. McCaffery K. J.,Dixon A.,Hayen A.,Jansen J.,Smith S.,Simpson J. M.The influence of graphic display format on the interpretations of quantitative risk information among adults with lower education and literacy: A randomized experimental study.Medical Decision Making. 2012;32:532-544.
50. Mills B.,Reyna V. F.,Estrada S.Explaining contradictory relations between risk perception and risk taking.Psychological Science. 2008;19:429-433.
51. Miron-Shatz T.,Hanoch Y.,Graef D.,Sagi M.Presentation format affects comprehension and risk assessment: The case of prenatal screening.Journal of Health Communication. 2009;14:439-450.
52. Mitzner T.,McBride S.,Barg-Walkow L.,Rogers W.Reviews of human factors and ergonomics. Morrow D. G., ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage; in press:.
53. Morrow D. G.,Weiner M.,Young J.,Steinley D.,Deer M.,Murray M. D.Improving medication knowledge among older adults with heart failure: A patient-centered approach to instruction design.Gerontologist. 2005;45:545-552.
54. National Cancer Institute. (2011). Breast Cancer Risk Assessment Tool: An interactive tool to help estimate a woman's risk of developing breast cancer. Retrieved from http://www.cancer.gov/bcrisktool.
55. Nelson W.,Reyna V. F.,Fagerlin A.,Lipkus I.,Peters E.Clinical implications of numeracy: Theory and practice.Annals of Behavioral Medicine. 2008;35:261-274.
56. Nisbett R. E.,Ross L.Human inference: Strategies and shortcomings of social judgment. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall; 1980:.
57. O'Keefe D. J.,Jensen J. D.The relative persuasiveness of gain-framed loss-framed messages for encouraging disease prevention behaviors: A meta-analytic review.Journal of Health Communication: International Perspectives. 2007;12:623-644.
58. Peters E.Numeracy and the perception and communication of risk.Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. 2008;1128:1-7.
59. Peters E.,Dieckmann N. F.,Västfjäll D.,Mertz C. K.,Slovic P.,Hibbard J. H.Bringing meaning to numbers: The impact of evaluative categories on decisions.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied. 2009;15:213-227.
60. Peters E.,Kunreuther H.,Sagaara N.,Slovic P.,Schley D. R.Protective measures, personal experience, and the affective psychology of time.Risk Analysis. in press;:.
61. PetersE.SlovicP.VästfjällD.MertzC. K. (2008). Intuitive numbers guide decisions. Judgment and Decision Making, 3, 619-635. Retrieved from journal.sjdm.org/8827/jdm8827.html.
62. Peters E.,Västfjäll D.,Slovic P.,Mertz C. K.,Mazzocco K.,Dickert S.Numeracy and decision making.Psychological Science. 2006;17:407-413.
63. Petty R. E.,Cacioppo J. T.The elaboration likelihood model of persuasion.Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. 1986;19:123-205.
64. Porcelli A. J.,Delgado M. R.Acute stress modulates risk taking in financial decision making.Psychological Science. 2009;20:278-283.
65. Reyna V. F.Class inclusion, the conjunction fallacy, and other cognitive illusions.Developmental Review. 1991;11:317-336.
66. Reyna V. F.How people make decisions that involve risk: A dual process approach.Current Directions in Psychological Science. 2004;13:60-66.
67. Reyna V. F.A theory of medical decision making and health: Fuzzy-trace theory.Medical Decision Making. 2008;28:850-865.
68. ReynaV. F. (2011). Across the lifespan. In FischhoffB.BrewerN. T.DownsJ. S. (Eds.), Communicating risks and benefits: An evidence-based user's guide (pp. 111-119). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Food and Drug Administration. Retrieved from http://www.fda.gov/ScienceResearch/SpecialTopics/RiskCommunication/default.htm.
69. ReynaV. F. (2012a). A new intuitionism: Meaning, memory, and development in fuzzy-trace theory. Judgment and Decision Making, 7, 332-359. Retrieved from http://journal.sjdm.org/11/111031/jdm111031.html.
70. Reyna V. F.Risk perception and communication in vaccination decisions: A fuzzy-trace theory approach.Vaccine. 2012b;30:3790-3797.
71. Reyna V. F.The development of thinking and reasoning. Barrouillet P.Gauffroy C., ed. Hove, UK: Psychology Press; in press:.
72. Reyna V. F.,Adam M. B.Fuzzy-trace theory, risk communication, and product labeling in sexually transmitted diseases.Risk Analysis. 2003;23:325-342.
73. Reyna V. F.,Adam M. B.,Poirier K.,LeCroy C. W.,Brainerd C. J.The development of children's and adolescents' judgment and decision-making. Jacobs J.Klaczynski P., ed. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 2005:77-106.
74. Reyna V. F.,Brainerd C. J.Fuzzy processing in transitivity development.Annals of Operations Research. 1990;23:37-63.
75. Reyna V. F.,Brainerd C.J.Fuzzy-trace theory and framing effects in choice: Gist extraction, truncation, and conversion.Journal of Behavior and Decision Making. 1991;4:249-262.
76. Reyna V. F.,Brainerd C. J.From learning processes to cognitive processes: Essays in honor of William K. Estes. Healy A.Kosslyn S.Shiffrin R., ed. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 1992:235-259.
77. Reyna V. F.,Brainerd C. J.Subjective probability. Wright G.Ayton P., ed. New York, NY: Wiley; 1994:239-272.
78. Reyna V. F.,Brainerd C. J.Fuzzy-trace theory: An interim synthesis.Learning and Individual Differences. 1995;7:1-75.
79. Reyna V. F.,Brainerd C. J.The importance of mathematics in health and human judgment: Numeracy, risk communication, and medical decision making.Learning and Individual Differences. 2007;17:147-159.
80. Reyna V. F.,Brainerd C. J.Numeracy, ratio bias, and denominator neglect in judgments of risk and probability.Learning and Individual Differences. 2008;18:89-107.
81. Reyna V. F.,Brainerd C. J.Dual processes in decision making and developmental neuroscience: A fuzzy-trace model.Developmental Review. 2011;31:180-206.
82. Reyna V. F.,Estrada S. M.,DeMarinis J. A.,Myers R. M.,Stanisz J. M.,Mills B. A.Neurobiological and memory models of risky decision making in adolescents versus young adults.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition. 2011;37:1125-1142.
83. Reyna V. F.,Farley F.Risk and rationality in adolescent decision making: Implications for theory, practice and public policy.Psychological Science in the Public Interest. 2006;7:1-44.
84. Reyna V. F.,Hamilton A. J.The importance of memory in informed consent for surgical risk.Medical Decision Making. 2001;21:152-155.
85. Reyna V. F.,Lloyd F. J.Physician decision making and cardiac risk: Effects of knowledge, risk perception, risk tolerance, and fuzzy processing.Journal of Experimental Psychology. 2006;12:179-195.
86. Reyna V. F.,Lloyd F. J.,Brainerd C. J.Emerging perspectives on judgment and decision research. Schneider S.Shanteau J., ed. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press; 2003:201-245.
87. Reyna V. F.,Lloyd F.,Whalen P.Genetic testing and medical decision making.Archives of Internal Medicine. 2001;161:2406-2408.
88. Reyna V. F.,Mills B. A.Converging evidence supports fuzzy-trace theory's nested sets hypothesis (but not the frequency hypothesis).Behavioral and Brain Sciences. 2007;30:278-280.
89. Reyna V. F.,Mills B. A.,Estrada S. M. Paper presented at the 30th annual meeting of the Society of Medical Decision Making; 2008Philadelphia, PA; 2008.
90. Reyna V. F.,Nelson W.,Han P.,Dieckmann N. F.How numeracy influences risk comprehension and medical decision making.Psychological Bulletin. 2009;135:943-973.
91. Reyna V. F.,Nelson W.,Han P.,Pignone M. P.Decision making and cancer. 2012;:.
92. Reyna V. F.,Rivers S. E.Current theories of risk and rational decision making.Developmental Review. 2008;28:1-11.
93. Rivers S. E.,Reyna V. F.,Mills B. A.Risk taking under the influence: A fuzzy-trace theory of emotion in adolescence.Developmental Review. 2008;28:107-144.
94. Robertson G.,Czerwinski M.,Fisher D.,Lee B.Reviews of human factors and ergonomics. Durso F. T., ed. Santa Monica, CA: Human Factors and Ergonomics Society; 2009:41-81.
95. Rolison J. J.,Hanoch Y.,Miron-Shatz T.What do men understand about lifetime risk following genetic testing? The effect of context and numeracy.Health Psychology. 2012;31:530-533.
96. Salz T.,Richman A. R.,Brewer N. T.Meta-analyses of the effect of false-positive mammograms on generic and specific psychosocial outcomes.Psycho-Oncology. 2010;19:1026-1034.
97. Schapira M. M.,Davids S. L.,McAuliffe T. L.,Nattinger A. B.Agreement between scales in the measurement of breast cancer risk perceptions.Risk Analysis. 2004;24:665-673.
98. Severtson D. J.,Henriques J. B.The effect of graphics on environmental health risk beliefs, emotions, behavioral intentions, and recall.Risk Analysis. 2009;29:1549-1565.
99. Severtson D. J.,Vatovec C.The theory-based influence of map features on risk beliefs: Self-reports of what is seen and understood for maps depicting an environmental health hazard.Journal of Health Communication: International Perspectives. 2012;17:836-856.
100. Shiloh S.,Salton E.,Sharabi D.Individual differences in rational and intuitive thinking styles as predictors of heuristic responses and framing effects.Personality and Individual Differences. 2002;32:415-429.
101. SleathB.GoldsteinM. (2011). Health care professionals. In FischhoffB.BrewerN. T.DownsJ. S. (Eds.), Communicating risks and benefits: An evidence-based user's guide (pp. 121-128). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Food and Drug Administration. Retrieved from http://www.fda.gov/ScienceResearch/SpecialTopics/RiskCommunication/default.htm.
102. Sleath B.,Roter D.,Chewning B.,Svarstad B.Asking questions about medication: Analysis of physician-patient interactions and physician perceptions.Medical Care. 1999;37:1169-1173.
103. Sleath B.,Tulsky J. A.,Peck B. M.,Thorpe J.Provider-patient communication about antidepressants among veterans with mental health conditions.American Journal of Geriatric Pharmacotharapy. 2007;5:9-17.
104. Sloman S. A.The empirical case for two systems of reasoning.Psychological Bulletin. 1996;119:3-22.
105. Slovic P.,Finucane M.,Peters E.,MacGregor D. G.Risk as analysis and risk as feelings: Some thoughts about affect, reason, risk, and rationality.Risk Analysis. 2004;24 (2): 1-12.
106. Slovic P.,Fischhoff B.,Lichtenstein S.Rating the risks.Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development. 1979;21 (3): 14-39.
107. Stanovich K. E.Who is rational? Studies of individual differences in reasoning. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum; 1999:.
108. Stanovich K. E.,West R. F.,Toplak M. E.The complexity of developmental predictions from dual process models.Developmental Review. 2011;31:103-118.
109. Stone E. R,Sieck W. R.,Bull B. E.,Yates J. F.,Parks S. C.,Rush C. J.Foreground-background salience: Explaining the effects of graphical displays on risk avoidance.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. 2003;90:19-36.
110. Stone E. R.,Yates J. F.,Parker A. M.Risk communication: Absolute versus relative expressions of low-probability risks.Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. 1994;60:387-408.
111. Stone E. R.,Yates J. F.,Parker A. M.Effects of numerical and graphical displays on professed risk-taking behavior.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied. 1997;3:243-256.
112. StreetR. L.GordonH. S.WardM. M.KrupatE.KravitzR. L. (2005). Patient participation in medical consultations: Why some patients are more involved than others. Medical Care, 43, 960-969. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/4640903.
113. Wilhelms E. A.,Reyna V. F.Fuzzy trace theory and medical decisions by minors: Differences in reasoning between adolescents and adults.Journal of Medicine and Philosophy. 2013;38:.
114. Wolf M. S.,King J.,Wilson E. A.,Curtis L. M.,Bailey S. C.,Duhig J., Lambert B.Usability of FDA-approved medication guides.Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2012;27:1714-1720.
115. Wolfe C. R.Information seeking on Bayesian conditional probability problems: A fuzzy-trace theory account.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. 1995;8:85-108.
116. Wolfe C. R.,Fisher C. R.,Reyna V. R.Semantic coherence and inconsistency in estimating conditional probabilities.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. in press;:.
117. Wolfe C. R.,Reyna V. F.Assessing semantic coherence and logical fallacies in joint probability estimates.Behavior Research Methods. 2010a;42:366-372.
118. Wolfe C. R.,Reyna V. F.Semantic coherence and fallacies in estimating joint probabilities.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making. 2010b;23:203-223.
119. Wood S. W.,Bechara A.The neuroscience of risking decision making. Reyna V.Zayas V., ed. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association; in press:.
120. Young H. N.,Bell R. A.,Epstein R. M.,Feldman M. D.,Kravitz R. L.Types of information physicians provide when prescribing antidepressants.Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2006;21:1172-1177.