Rethinking inhibition theory: On the problematic status of the inhibition theory for forgetting

Journal of Memory and Language

Volumn 68, Issue 2, 2013, Pages 98-122

  Raaijmakers, Jeroen G W ^a   Jakab, Emoke ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF AMSTERDAM   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Forgetting; Inhibition; Interference

Indexed keywords

EID: 84871929512     PISSN: 0749596X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jml.2012.10.002     Document Type: Article

References (137)

1. Allen M.M. Cueing and retrieval in free recall. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1969, 81:29-35.
2. Anderson J.R. Interference. The relationship between response latency and response accuracy. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 1981, 7:326-343.
3. Anderson J.R. A spreading activation theory of memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1983, 22:261-295.
4. Anderson M.C. Active forgetting: Evidence for functional inhibition as a source of memory failure. Journal of Aggression Maltreatment, and Trauma 2001, 4:185-210.
5. Anderson M.C. Rethinking interference theory: Executive control and the mechanisms of forgetting. Journal of Memory and Language 2003, 49:415-445.
6. Anderson M.C., Bell T. Forgetting our facts: The role of inhibitory processes in the loss of propositional knowledge. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 2001, 130:544-570.
7. Anderson M.C., Bjork R.A., Bjork E.L. Remembering can cause forgetting: Retrieval dynamics in long-term memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 1994, 20:1063-1087.
8. Anderson M.C., Bjork E.L., Bjork R.A. Retrieval-induced forgetting: Evidence for a recall-specific mechanism. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 2000, 7:522-530.
9. Anderson M.C., Green C. Suppressing unwanted memories by executive control. Nature 2001, 410:366-369.
10. Anderson M.C., Green C., McCulloch K.C. Similarity and inhibition in long-term memory: Evidence for a two-factor model. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition 2000, 26:1141-1159.
11. Anderson M.C., Huddleston E. Towards a cognitive and neurobiological model of motivated forgetting. True and false recovered memories: Toward a reconciliation of the debate 2011, Vol. 58:53-120. Springer, New York, NY. R.F. Belli (Ed.).
12. Anderson M.C., Levy B.J. On the relation between inhibition and interference in cognition. Successful remembering and successful forgetting: A Festschrift in honor of Robert A. Bjork 2010, 107-132. Psychology Press, London. A. Benjamin (Ed.).
13. Anderson M.C., McCulloch K.C. Integration as a general boundary condition on retrieval-induced forgetting. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 1999, 25:608-629.
14. Anderson M.C., Neely J.H. Interference and inhibition in memory retrieval. Memory 1996, 237-313. Academic Press, San Diego, CA. E.L. Bjork, R.A. Bjork (Eds.).
15. Anderson M.C., Ochsner K., Kuhl B., Cooper J., Robertson E., Gabrieli S.W., et al. Neural systems underlying the suppression of unwanted memories. Science 2004, 303:232-235.
16. Anderson M.C., Reinholz J., Kuhl B.A., Mayr U. Intentional suppression of unwanted memories grows more difficult as we age. Psychology and Aging 2011, 26:397-405.
17. Anderson M.C., Spellman B.A. On the status of inhibitory mechanisms in cognition: Memory retrieval as a model case. Psychological Review 1995, 102:68-100.
18. Aron A.R. The neural basis of inhibition in cognitive control. The Neuroscientist 2007, 13:214-228.
19. Aslan A., Bäuml K.-H., Grundgeiger T. The role of inhibitory processes in part-list cuing. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2007, 33:335-341.
20. Aslan A., Bäuml K.-H., Pastotter B. No inhibitory deficit in older adultsr episodic memory. Psychological Science 2007, 18:72-78.
21. Barnes J.M., Underwood B.J. " Fate" of first-list associations in transfer theory. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1959, 58:97-105.
22. Basden D.R. Cued and uncued free recall of unrelated words following interpolated learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1973, 98:429-431.
23. Basden B.H., Basden D.R. Directed forgetting: A contrast of methods and interpretations. Intentional forgetting: Interdisciplinary approaches 1998, 139-172. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. J.M. Golding, C.M. MacLeod (Eds.).
24. Basden D.R., Basden B.H., Galloway B.C. Inhibition with part-list cuing: Some tests of the item strength hypothesis. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 1977, 3:100-108.
25. Bäuml K.-H. Revisiting an old issue: Retroactive interference as a function of the degree of original and interpolated learning. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 1996, 3:380-384.
26. Bäuml K.-H. The list-strength effect: Strength-dependent competition or suppression. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 1997, 4:260-264.
27. Bäuml K.-H. Strong items get suppressed, weak items do not: The role of item strength in output interference. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 1998, 5:459-463.
28. Bäuml K.-H. Making memories unavailable: The inhibitory power of retrieval. Zeitschrift fur Psychologie 2007, 215:4-11.
29. Bäuml K.-H. Inhibitory processes. Learning and memory: A comprehensive reference 2008, Vol. 2:195-220. Elsevier, Oxford, 4 vols, (J.Byrne Editor). H.L. Roediger (Ed.).
30. Bäuml K.-H., Aslan A. Part-list cuing as instructed retrieval inhibition. Memory and Cognition 2004, 32:610-617.
31. Bäuml K.-H., Aslan A. Part-list cuing can be transient and lasting: The role of encoding. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2006, 32:33-43.
32. Bäuml K.-H., Kuhbandner C. Retrieval-induced forgetting and part-list cuing in associatively structured lists. Memory and Cognition 2003, 31:1188-1197.
33. Bereiter C. Some persisting dilemmas in measurement of change. Problems in measuring change 1963, 3-20. University of Wisconsin Press, Madison. C.W. Harris (Ed.).
34. Bergstrom Z.M., De Fockert J.W., Richardson-Klavehn A. ERP and behavioural evidence for direct suppression of unwanted memories. Neuroimage 2009, 48:726-737.
35. Bergstrom Z.M., Velmans M., De Fockert J., Richardson-Klavehn A. ERP evidence for successful voluntary avoidance of conscious recollection. Brain Research 2007, 1151:119-133.
36. Bjork R.A. Retrieval inhibition as an adaptive mechanism in human memory. Varieties of memory and consciousness: Essays in honour of Endel Tulving 1989, 309-330. Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. H.L. Roediger, F.I.M. Craik (Eds.).
37. Blais C., Robidoux S., Risko E.F., Besner D. Item-specific adaptation and the conflict-monitoring hypothesis: A computational model. Psychological Review 2007, 114:1076-1086.
38. Blake M., Okada R. Intralist cuing following retroactive inhibition of well-learned items. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1973, 101:386-388.
39. Botvinick M.M., Cohen J.D., Carter C.S. Conflict monitoring and anterior cingulate cortex: An update. Trends in Cognitive Sciences 2004, 8:539-546.
40. Bowers J.S., Davis C.J., Hanley D.A. Interfering neighbours: The impact of novel word learning on the identification of visually similar words. Cognition 2005, 97:B45-B54.
41. Brewin C.R., Andrews B. Psychological defense mechanisms: The example of repression. The Psychologist 2000, 13:615-617.
42. Bulevich J.B., Roediger H.L., Balota D.A., Butler A.C. Failures to find suppression of episodic memories in the think/no-think paradigm. Memory & Cognition 2006, 34:1569-1577.
43. Burt J.S. Identifiable orthographically similar word primes interfere in visual word identification. Journal of Memory and Language 2009, 61:259-284.
44. Camp G., Pecher D., Schmidt H.G. Retrieval-induced forgetting in implicit memory tests: The role of test awareness. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review 2005, 12:490-494.
45. Camp G., Pecher D., Schmidt H.G. No retrieval-induced forgetting using item-specific independent cues: Evidence against a general inhibitory account. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2007, 33:950-958.
46. Camp G., Pecher D., Schmidt H.G., Zeelenberg R. Are independent probes truly independent?. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2009, 35:934-942.
47. Chandler C.C. Specific retroactive interference in modified recognition tests: Evidence for an unknown cause of interference. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 1989, 15:256-265.
48. Cho K., Neely J.H. Nonepisodic retrieval practice (ELE_A___cuing ELEVATOR) facilitates episodic recall of ELEPHANT (cued by E__PH_NT or GIRAFFE). Abstracts of the Psychonomic Society 2010, 15:44-45.
49. Ciranni M.A., Shimamura A.P. Retrieval-induced forgetting in episodic memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 1999, 25:1403-1414.
50. Criss A.H., Malmberg K.J., Shiffrin R.M. Output interference in recognition memory. Journal of Memory and Language 2011, 64:316-326.
51. Delprato D.J. Retroactive interference as a function of degree of interpolated study without overt retrieval practice. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 2005, 12:345-349.
52. Depue B.E., Banich M.T., Curran T. Suppression of emotional and nonemotional content in memory: Effects of repetition on cognitive control. Psychological Science 2006, 17:441-447.
53. Dieler A.C., Plichta M.M., Dresler T., Fallgatter A.J. Suppression of emotional words in the Think/No-Think paradigm investigated with functional near-infrared spectroscopy. International Journal of Psychophysiology 2010, 78:129-135.
54. Gelfand, H., & Bjork, R. A. (1985). On the locus of retrieval inhibition in directed forgetting. Paper presented at the 26th annual meeting of the Psychonomic Society, Boston, MA.
55. Grainger J. Word frequency and neighborhood frequency effects in lexical decision and naming. Journal of Memory and Language 1990, 29:228-244.
56. Greeno J.G., James C.T., DaPolito F.J. A cognitive interpretation of negative transfer and forgetting of paired associates. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1971, 10:331-345.
57. Greeno J.G., James C.T., DaPolito F.J., Polson P.G. Associative learning: A cognitive analysis 1978, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
58. Hanslmayr S., Leipold P., Bäuml K.-H. Anticipation boosts forgetting of voluntarily suppressed memories. Memory 2010, 18:252-257.
59. Hanslmayr S., Staudigl T., Aslan A., Bäuml K.H. Theta oscillations predict the detrimental effects of memory retrieval. Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience 2010, 10:329-338.
60. Healey M.K., Campbell K.L., Hasher L., Ossher L. Direct evidence for the role of inhibition in resolving interference in memory. Psychological Science 2010, 21:1464-1470.
61. Hertel P.T., Calcaterra G. Intentional forgetting benefits from thought substitution. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 2005, 12:484-489.
62. Hertel P.T., Gerstle M. Depressive deficits in forgetting. Psychological Science 2003, 14:573-578.
63. Hertel P.T., McDaniel L. The suppressive power of positive thinking: Aiding suppression-induced forgetting in repressive coping. Cognition and Emotion 2010, 24:1239-1249.
64. Hintzman D.L. On testing the independence of associations. Psychological Review 1972, 79:261-264.
65. Huddleston E., Anderson M.C. Reassessing critiques of the independent probe method for studying inhibition. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2012, 38:1408-1418.
66. Hulbert J.C., Shivde G., Anderson M.C. Evidence against associative blocking as a cause of cue-independent retrieval-induced forgetting. Experimental Psychology 2012, 59:11-21.
67. Jakab E., Raaijmakers J.G.W. The role of item strength in retrieval induced forgetting. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2009, 35:607-617.
68. Johansson M., Aslan A., Bäuml K.H., Gäbel A., Mecklinger A. When remembering causes forgetting: Electrophysiological correlates of retrieval-induced forgetting. Cerebral Cortex 2007, 17:1335-1341.
69. Johnson S.K., Anderson M.C. The role of inhibitory control in forgetting semantic knowledge. Psychological Science 2004, 15:448-453.
70. Jonker, T. R., Seli, P., & MacLeod, C. M. (2012). Less we forget: Retrieval cues and release from retrieval-induced forgetting. Memory and Cognition. 26.06.12.
71. Jonker T.R., MacLeod C.M. Retrieval-induced forgetting: Testing the competition assumption of inhibition theory. Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology 2012, 66:204-211.
72. Karpicke J.D., Roediger H.L. The critical importance of retrieval for learning. Science 2008, 319:966-968.
73. Koessler S., Engler H., Riether C., Kissler J. No retrieval-induced forgetting under stress. Psychological Science 2009, 20:1356-1363.
74. Koppenaal R.J. Time changes in strength of A-B, A-C lists: Spontaneous recovery?. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1963, 2:310-319.
75. Kornell N., Bjork R.A., Garcia M.A. Why tests appear to prevent forgetting: A distribution-based bifurcation model. Journal of Memory and Language 2011, 65:85-97.
76. Lambert A.J., Good K.S., Kirk I.J. Testing the repression hypothesis: Effects of emotional valence on memory suppression in the think - No think task. Consciousness and Cognition 2010, 19:281-291.
77. Lee Y., Lee H., Tsai S. Effects of post-cue interval on intentional forgetting. British Journal of Psychology 2007, 98:257-272.
78. Lehman M., Malmberg K.J. A global theory of remembering and forgetting from multiple lists. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2009, 35:970-988.
79. Lehman M., Malmberg K.J. Overcoming the effects of intentional forgetting. Memory and Cognition 2011, 39:335-347.
80. Lemoult J., Hertel P.T., Joormann J. Training the forgetting of negative words: The role of direct suppression and the relation to stress reactivity. Applied Cognitive Psychology 2010, 24:365-375.
81. MacLeod C.M. Directed forgetting. Intentional forgetting: Interdisciplinary approaches 1998, 1-57. Erlbaum, Mahwah, NJ. J.M. Golding, C.M. MacLeod (Eds.).
82. Malmberg K.J., Shiffrin R.M. The " One-Shot" hypothesis for context storage. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory and Cognition 2005, 31:322-336.
83. McGeoch J.A. Forgetting and the law of disuse. Psychological Review 1932, 39:352-370.
84. McGeoch J.A. The psychology of human learning 1942, Longmans, Green, New York.
85. Mecklinger A., Parra M., Waldhauser G.T. ERP correlates of intentional forgetting. Brain Research 2009, 1255:132-147.
86. Meier B., Konig A., Parak S., Henke K. Suppressed, but not forgotten. Swiss Journal of Psychology 2011, 70:5-11.
87. Melton A.W., Irwin J.Mc.Q. The influence of degree of interpolated learning on retroactive inhibition and the overt transfer of specific responses. The American Journal of Psychology. 1940, 53:173-203.
88. Mensink G.J.M., Raaijmakers J.G.W. A model for interference and forgetting. Psychological Review 1988, 95:434-455.
89. Mulji R., Bodner G.E. Wiping out memories: New support for a mental context change account of directed forgetting. Memory 2010, 18:763-773.
90. Norman K.A., Newman E.L., Detre G. A neural network model of retrieval-induced forgetting. Psychological Review 2007, 114:887-953.
91. Otani H., Whiteman H.L. Hypermnesia is not an artifact of response bias. The American Journal of Psychology 1994, 107:401-421.
92. Pastotter B., Bäuml K.-H. Amount of postcue encoding predicts amount of directed forgetting. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2010, 36:54-65.
93. Perfect T.J., Stark L., Tree J.J., Moulin C.J.A., Ahmed L., Hutter R. Transfer appropriate forgetting: The cue-dependent nature of retrieval-induced forgetting. Journal of Memory and Language 2004, 51:399-417.
94. Postman L. Verbal learning and memory. Annual Review of Psychology 1975, 26:291-335.
95. Postman L. The present status of interference theory. Verbal learning and verbal behavior 1961, 152-179. McGraw-Hill, New York. C.N. Cofer (Ed.).
96. Postman L., Stark K., Fraser J. Temporal changes in interference. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1968, 7:672-694.
97. Raaijmakers J.G.W. Mathematical models of human memory. Learning and memory: A Comprehensive Reference 2008, Vol. 2:445-466. Elsevier, Oxford, 4 vols, (J.Byrne Editor). H.L. Roediger (Ed.).
98. Raaijmakers, J. G. W & Jakab, E. (2006, July). A non-inhibitory explanation of retrieval inhibition. Paper presented at the fifth annual summer interdisciplinary conference, Åndalsnes, Norway.
99. Raaijmakers J.G.W., Jakab E. Retrieval-induced forgetting without competition: Testing the retrieval specificity assumption of the inhibition theory. Memory and Cognition 2012, 40:19-27.
100. Raaijmakers J.G.W., Phaf R.H. Part-list cuing revisited: A test of the SAM explanation. progress and reflection on the 30th anniversary of the Atkinson-Shiffrin model 1999, 87-104. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ. C. Izawa (Ed.).
101. Raaijmakers J.G.W., Shiffrin R.M. SAM: A theory of probabilistic search of associative memory. The psychology of learning and motivation: Adv an ce s in research and theory 1980, Vol. 14:207-262. Academic Press, New York.
102. Raaijmakers J.G.W., Shiffrin R.M. Search of associative memory. Psychological Review 1981, 88:93-134.
103. Ratcliff R., Clark S., Shiffrin R.M. The list-strength effect: I. Data and discussion. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 1990, 16:163-178.
104. Roediger H.L. Inhibition in recall from cueing with recall targets. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1973, 12:644-657.
105. Roediger H.L. Inhibiting effects of recall. Memory and Cognition 1974, 2:261-296.
106. Roediger H.L. Recall as a self-limiting process. Memory and Cognition 1978, 6:54-63.
107. Roediger H.L., Schmidt S.R. Output interference in the recall of categorized and paired-associate lists. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 1980, 6:91-105.
108. Román P., Soriano M.F., Gómez-Ariza C.J., Bajo M.T. Retrieval-induced forgetting and executive control. Psychological Science 2009, 20:1053-1058.
109. Rundus D. Negative effects of using list items as recall cues. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 1973, 12:43-50.
110. Sahakyan L., Foster N.L. Intentional forgetting of actions: Comparison of list-method and item-method directed forgetting. Journal of Memory and Language 2009, 61:134-152.
111. Sahakyan L., Goodmon L.B. Theoretical implications of extralist probes for directed forgetting. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2010, 36:920-937.
112. Sahakyan L., Kelley C. A contextual change account of the directed forgetting effect. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2002, 28:1064-1072.
113. Saunders J., MacLeod M.D. Can inhibition resolve retrieval competition through the control of spreading activation?. Memory and Cognition 2006, 34:307-322.
114. Sheard E.D., MacLeod C.M. List method directed forgetting: Return of the selective rehearsal account. Dynamic cognitive processes 2005, 219-248. Springer-Verlag, Tokyo, Japan. N. Ohta, C.M. MacLeod, B. Uttl (Eds.).
115. Shiffrin R.M., Ratcliff R., Clark S. The list-strength effect: II. Theoretical mechanisms. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 1990, 16:179-195.
116. Shiffrin R.M., Steyvers M. A model for recognition memory: REM: Retrieving effectively from memory. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 1997, 4:145-166.
117. Shivde G., Anderson M.C. The role of inhibition in meaning selection: Insights from retrieval-induced forgetting. On the consequences of meaning selection: Perspectives on resolving lexical ambiguity 2001, 175-190. American Psychological Association, Washington, DC. D.S. Gorfein (Ed.).
118. Slamecka N.J. An examination of trace storage in free recall. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1968, 76:504-513.
119. Staudigl T., Hanslmayr S., Bäuml K.-H.T. Theta oscillations reflect the dynamics of interference in episodic memory retrieval. The Journal of Neuroscience 2010, 30:11356-11362.
120. Storm B.C. Retrieval-induced forgetting and the resolution of competition. Successful remembering and successful forgetting: A Festschrift in honor of Robert A. Bjork 2010, 89-105. Psychology Press, London. A. Benjamin (Ed.).
121. Storm B.C., Bjork E.L., Bjork R.A. When intended remembering leads to unintended forgetting. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 2007, 60:909-915.
122. Storm B.C., Bjork E.L., Bjork R.A., Nestojko J.F. Is retrieval success a necessary condition for retrieval-induced forgetting?. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 2006, 13:1023-1027.
123. Storm B.C., Levy A progress report on the inhibitory account of retrieval-induced forgetting. Memory and Cognition 2012, 40:827-843.
124. Storm B.C., Nestojko J.F. Successful inhibition, unsuccessful retrieval: Manipulating time and success during retrieval practice. Memory 2010, 18:99-114.
125. Thune L.E., Underwood B.J. Retroactive inhibition as a function of degree of interpolated learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1943, 32:185-200.
126. Tulving E., Hastie R. Inhibition effects of intralist repetition in free recall. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1972, 92:297-304.
127. Underwood, B. J. (1945). The effect of successive interpolations on retroactive and proactive inhibition. Psychological Monographs, 59(3, Whole No. 273).
128. Underwood B.J. " Spontaneous recovery" of verbal associations. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1948, 38:429-439.
129. Verde M.F. The list-strength effect in recall: Relative-strength competition and retrieval inhibition may both contribute to forgetting. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 2009, 35:205-220.
130. Verde M.F. Retrieval-induced forgetting and inhibition: A critical review. Psychology of learning and motivation 2012, Vol. 56:47-80. Academic Press, USA.
131. Verde M.F., Perfect T.J. Retrieval induced forgetting in recognition is absent under time pressure. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review 2011, 18:1166-1171.
132. Waldhauser G.T., Johansson M., Bäckstrom M., Mecklinger A. Trait anxiety, working memory capacity, and the effectiveness of memory suppression. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 2011, 52:21-27.
133. Wegner D.M. Ironic processes of mental control. Psychological Review 1994, 101:34-52.
134. Wenzlaff R.M., Wegner D.M. Thought suppression. Annual Review of Psychology 2000, 51:59-91.
135. Wessel I., Wetzels S., Jelicic M., Merckelbach H. Dissociation and memory suppression: A comparison of high and low dissociative individualsr performance on the Think-No Think task. Personality and Individual Differences 2005, 39:1461-1470.
136. Williams C.C., Zacks R.T. Is retrieval-induced forgetting an inhibitory process?. American Journal of Psychology 2001, 114:329-354.
137. Wimber M., Rutschmann R.M., Greenlee M.W., Bäuml K.H. Retrieval from episodic memory: Neural mechanisms of interference resolution. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2009, 21:538-549.