Correlation of clinical performance with 'in vitro tests' of restorative dental materials that use polymer-based matrices

Dental Materials

Volumn 28, Issue 1, 2012, Pages 52-71

  Bayne, Stephen C ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN   (United States)

Author keywords

Clinical properties; Clinical trials; Correlation; Laboratory properties

Indexed keywords

BIOLOGICAL PROPERTIES; CLINICAL OBSERVATION; CLINICAL OUTCOME; CLINICAL PERFORMANCE; CLINICAL PROPERTIES; CLINICAL RESEARCH; CLINICAL TRIAL; COLOR MATCH; CRITICAL REVIEW; IN-VITRO; IN-VITRO TESTS; IN-VIVO; LABORATORY TEST; MARGINAL INTEGRITY; MATERIALS RESEARCH; META ANALYSIS; NEW STUDY; RISK FACTORS; SURFACE TEXTURES; TEST PRODUCTS;

DENTAL MATERIALS; EXPERIMENTS; LABORATORIES; MATERIALS; MECHANICAL PROPERTIES; OPTICAL CORRELATION; RESTORATION;

TESTING;

BIOMEDICAL AND DENTAL MATERIALS; POLYMER;

CHEMISTRY; CLINICAL TRIAL (TOPIC); DENTAL BONDING; DENTAL PROCEDURE; DENTAL RESEARCH; DENTAL SURGERY; EVIDENCE BASED DENTISTRY; HUMAN; LITERATURE; MATERIALS TESTING; MECHANICS; META ANALYSIS (TOPIC); METHODOLOGY; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; REVIEW; STANDARD; STRUCTURE ACTIVITY RELATION; TOOTH DISEASE;

CLINICAL TRIALS AS TOPIC; DENTAL BONDING; DENTAL LEAKAGE; DENTAL MATERIALS; DENTAL RESEARCH; DENTAL RESTORATION FAILURE; DENTAL RESTORATION WEAR; DENTAL RESTORATION, PERMANENT; DENTAL STRESS ANALYSIS; EVIDENCE-BASED DENTISTRY; HUMANS; MATERIALS TESTING; MECHANICAL PROCESSES; META-ANALYSIS AS TOPIC; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT (HEALTH CARE); POLYMERS; RESEARCH DESIGN; REVIEW LITERATURE AS TOPIC; STRUCTURE-ACTIVITY RELATIONSHIP;

EID: 84255197883     PISSN: 01095641     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.dental.2011.08.594     Document Type: Review

References (99)

1. S.C. Bayne Dental restorations for oral rehabilitation - testing of laboratory properties versus clinical performance for clinical decision making J Oral Rehabil 34 2007 921 932
2. S.D. Heintze Systematic reviews: I. The correlation between laboratory tests on marginal quality and bond strength. II. The correlation between marginal quality and clinical outcome J Adhes Dent 9 Suppl. 2007 77 106
3. D.F. Taylor, S.C. Bayne, K.F. Leinfelder, S. Davis, and G.G. Koch Pooling of long term clinical wear data for posterior composites Am J Dent 7 6 1994 167 174
4. S.C. Bayne, and S.J. Marshall 20-Year analysis of basic vs applied DMG-IADR research abstracts J Dent Res 78 1999 130 [Abstract No. 196]
5. S.C. Bayne, and S.K. Grayden DMG-IADR abstract research patterns by type, focus, and funding J Dent Res 87 Special Issue A 2008 1093 [Abstract No. 1093]
6. S.C. Bayne 1990-2000 Clinical research citations/abstracts in dentistry and dental materials J Dent Res 81 2002 A-138,0952 [Abstract No. 0952]
7. J.F. Cvar, and G. Ryge Clinical evaluation of dental restorative materials 1971 USDHEW, USPHS, NIH San Francisco
8. X. Hu, A.C. Shortall, and P.M. Marquis Wear of three dental composites under different testing conditions J Oral Rehabil 29 2002 756 764 (Pubitemid 41697872)
9. L. Papagiannoulis, A. Kakaboura, and G. Eliades In vivo and in vitro anticariogenic behavior of glass-ionomer and resin composite restorative materials Dent Mater 18 2002 561 569 (Pubitemid 40072225)
10. R. Hickel, J. Manhart, and F. Garcia-Godoy Clinical results and new developments of direct posterior restorations Am J Dent 13 2000 41D 54D
11. G. Ryge Clinical research protocols - what should and should not be included H.O. Wyckoff, D.G. Weigl, Clinical evaluation of dental materials (1978 Conference Proceedings) 1980 USDHHS, NIH Publication No. 80-1147 30 37
12. J.F. Cvar, and G. Ryge Reprint of criteria for the clinical evaluation of dental restorative materials Clin Oral Investig 9 2005 215 232
13. G. Ryge Clinical criteria Int Dent J 30 1980 347 358
14. S.C. Bayne, and G. Schmalz Reprinting the classic article on USPHS evaluation methods for measuring the clinical research performance of restorative materials Clin Oral Investig 9 2005 209 214
15. S.C. Bayne, A.D. Wilder Jr., H.O. Heymann, J.R. Sturdevant, and E.J. Swift Jr. Sources of variation in indirect wear evaluations of clinical results J Dent Res 90 2011 0147 [Abstract No. 0147]
16. S.C. Bayne, H.O. Heymann, J.R. Sturdevant, A.D. Wilder, and T.B. Sluder Contributing co-variables in clinical trials Am J Dent 4 5 1991 247 250
17. R.B. Price, M.E. McLeod, and C.M. Felix Quantifying light energy delivered to a class I restoration J Can Dent Assoc 76 2 2010 1 8
18. O. El-Mowafy, W. El-Badrawy, D.W. Lewis, B. Shokati, J. Kermalli, and O. Soliman Intensity of quartz-tungsten-halogen light-curing units used in private practice in Toronto J Am Dent Assoc 136 2005 766 773 (Pubitemid 40847609)
19. P.F. Abate, V.N. Zahra, and R.L. Macchi Effect of photopolymerization variables on composite hardness J Prosthet Dent 86 2001 632 635 (Pubitemid 33608815)
20. P.L. Fan, R.M. Schumacher, K. Azzolin, R. Geary, and F.C. Eichmiller Curing-light intensity and depth of cure of resin-based composites tested according to international standards J Am Dent Assoc 133 2002 429 434
21. J.D. Bader, and D.A. Shugars Variation in dentists' clinical decisions J Public Health Dent 55 1995 181 188
22. W.D. Brunson, S.C. Bayne, J.R. Sturdevant, T.M. Roberson, A.D. Wilder, and D.F. Taylor Three year clinical evaluation of a self-cured posterior composite resin Dent Mater 5 1989 127 132
23. A.D. Wilder, K.N. May, S.C. Bayne, D.F. Taylor, and K.F. Leinfelder Seventeen-year clinical study of ultraviolet-cured posterior composite Class I and II restorations J Esthet Dent 11 1999 135 142
24. E.J. Swift, J. Perdigão, H.O. Heymann, A.D. Wilder, S.C. Bayne, and K.N. May Clinical evaluation of a filled and unfilled dentin adhesive J Dent 29 2001 1 6 (Pubitemid 33660534)
25. E.J. Swift, J. Perdigão, H.O. Heymann, A.D. Wilder, K.N. May, and T.M. Roberson Clinical evaluation of two "one-bottle" dentin adhesives at three years J Am Dent Assoc 132 2001 1117 1123 (Pubitemid 33609936)
26. S.C. Bayne Biomaterials: where are we and where are we going Proceedings of distinguished professors symposium J Dent Educ 69 2005 571 585
27. D.F. Taylor, S.C. Bayne, J.R. Sturdevant, and A.D. Wilder Comparison of direct and indirect methods for analyzing wear of posterior composite restorations Dent Mater 5 1989 157 160
28. D.F. Taylor, S.C. Bayne, J.R. Sturdevant, and A.D. Wilder Correlation of M-L, Leinfelder, and USPHS clinical evaluation techniques for wear Dent Mater 6 1990 151 153
29. S.C. Bayne, D.F. Taylor, E.D. Rekow, A.D. Wilder, and H.O. Heymann Confirmation of Leinfelder clinical wear standards Dent Mater 10 1994 11 18
30. K.F. Leinfelder, D.F. Taylor, W.W. Brkmeier, and A.J. Goldberg Quantitative wear measurement of posterior composite resins Dent Mater 2 1986 198 201
31. A.J. Goldberg, E. Rydinge, E.A. Santucci, and W.B. Racz Clinical evaluation methods for posterior composite restorations J Dent Res 63 1984 1387 1391
32. E. Asmussen Clinical relevance of physical, chemical, and bonding properties of composite resins Oper Dent 10 1985 61 73
33. S.C. Bayne Biopsy and analysis of 5 to 10 year old composites 1987-1991 NIH-NIDCR Grant 1-RO1-DEO8005
34. M.J. Metz, M.A. Cochran, B.A. Matix, C. Gonzalez, J.A. Platt, and M.R. Pund Clinical evaluation of 15% carbamide peroxide on the surface microhardness and shear bond strength of human enamel Oper Dent 32 2007 427 436
35. J.C. Mitchem, and D.G. Gronas Clinical evaluation of cement solubility J Prosthet Dent 40 1978 453 456
36. J.L. Ferracane, J.C. Mitchem, J.R. Condon, and R. Todd Wear and marginal breakdown of composites with various degrees of cure J Dent Res 76 1997 1508 1516 (Pubitemid 127732704)
37. R.P. Kusy, and K.L. Leinfelder In situ replica techniques. I. Preliminary screening and the negative replica technique J Dent Res 56 1977 925 932 (Pubitemid 8236049)
38. R.P. Kusy, and K.L. Leinfelder Pattern of wear in posterior composite restorations J Dent Res 56 1977 544 (Pubitemid 8140950)
39. G.W. Marshall, V.A. Marker, and S.C. Bayne Replication technique for monitoring intra-oral processes with the SEM Quintessence Int 9 Report 1669 1978 1 3
40. V. Qvist Marginal adaptation of composite restorations performed in vivo with different acid-etch restorative procedures Scand J Dent Res 93 1985 68 75
41. L.N. Baratieri, and A.V. Ritter Critical appraisal: to bevel or not in anterior composites J Esthet Dent 17 2005 264 269 (Pubitemid 44502296)
42. L.N. Baratieri, S. Canabarro, G.C. Lopes, and A.V. Ritter Effect of resin viscosity and enamel beveling on the clinical performance of Class V composite restorations: three-year results Oper Dent 28 2003 482 487 (Pubitemid 37229776)
43. F.H. Coelho-de-Souza, C.A. Klein-Junior, J.C. Camargo, T. Beskow, M.D. Balestrin, and F.F. Demarco Double-blind randomized clinical trial of posterior composite restorations with or without bevel: 6-month follow-up J Contemp Dent Pract 11 2 2010 1 8
44. J.L. Ferracane, and J.C. Mitchem Properties of posterior composite: results of round robin testing for a specification Dent Mater 10 1994 92 99
45. I.A. Mjor Frequency of secondary caries at various anatomical locations Oper Dent 10 1985 88 92
46. I.A. Mjor, and V. Qvist Marginal failure of amalgam and composite restorations J Dent 25 1997 25 30 (Pubitemid 127412645)
47. A. Brunthaler, F. Konig, T. Lucas, and W. Sperr Longevity of direct resin composite restorations in posterior teeth Clin Oral Investig 7 2003 63 70
48. S.C. Bayne 10-Year clinical wear-factor analysis for conventional versus packable molar composites J Dent Res 89 Special Issue 2010 3569 [Abstract No. 3569]
49. S.L. Wendt, T.L. Ziemiecki, and K.F. Leinfelder Proximal wear rates by tooth position of resin composite restorations J Dent 24 1996 33 39 (Pubitemid 126348343)
50. S.C. Bayne, E.J. Swift Jr., A.D. Wilder Jr., H.O. Heymann, and J.R. Sturdevant Cluster analysis of long-term USPHS-category changes for posterior composites Trans Acad Dent Mater 2009 [Poster-0006, Abstract No. 6]
51. S.C. Bayne, A.D. Wilder, H.O. Heymann, J.R. Sturdevant, and E.J. Swift Cluster analysis of short-term USPHS-category changes for class-V composites J Dent Res 89 2010 0027 [Abstract No. 27]
52. N.K. Sarkar, J.W. Osborne, and K.F. Leinfelder In vitro corrosion and in vivo marginal fracture of dental amalgam J Dent Res 61 1982 126201268
53. K.J.M. Soderholm Correlation of in vivo and in vitro performance of adhesive restorative materials: a report of the ASC MD156 task group on test methods for the adhesion of restorative materials Dent Mater 7 1991 74 83
54. D.C. Sarrett Prediction of clinical outcomes of a restoration based on in vivo marginal quality evaluation J Adhes Dent Suppl. 1 2007 117 120
55. E. Swenson, and B. Hennessy Detection of occlusal carious lesions: an in vitro comparison of clinicians' diagnostic abilities at varying levels of experience Gen Dent 57 2009 60 66
56. A.I. Ismail, W. Sohn, M. Tellez, A. Amaya, A. Sen, and H. Hasson The international caries detection and assessment system (ICDAS): an integrated system for measuring dental caries Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 35 2007 170 178
57. I.A. Mjor Glass-ionomer cement restorations and secondary caries: a preliminary report Quintessence Int 27 1996 171 174 (Pubitemid 126699250)
58. V. Qvist, A. Poulsen, P.T. Teglers, and I.A. Mjor The longevity of different restorations in primary teeth Int J Paediatr Dent 20 2010 1 7
59. V. Qvist, A. Poulsen, P.T. Teglers, and I.A. Mjor Fluorides leaching from restorative materials the effect on adjacent teeth Int Dent J 60 2010 156 160
60. J. De Munck, K. Van Landuyt, M. Peumans, A. Poitevin, P. Lambrechts, and M. Braem A critical review of the durability of adhesion to tooth tissue: methods and results J Dent Res 84 2005 118 132 (Pubitemid 43822043)
61. S.C. Paffenbarger, W.T. Sweeney, and A. Issacs Zinc phosphate cements: physical properties and specification J Dent Res 21 1934 1907 1911
62. American Dental Association Revised national standards/American Dental Association specification no. 8 for zinc phosphate cement 1977 ADA Council on Scientific Affairs p. 1-6
63. D. Orstavik Weight loss of endodontic sealers, cements, and pastes in water Scand J Dent Res 91 1983 316 319
64. A.D. Wilson Specification test for the solubility and disintegration of dental cements: a critical evaluation of its meaning J Dent Res 55 1976 721 729
65. A.U.J. Yap, L.F.K.L. Ong, S.H. Teoh, and G.W. Hastings Comparative wear ranking of dental restoratives with the BIOMAT wear simulator J Oral Rehabil 26 1999 228 235
66. S.C. Bayne, D.F. Taylor, and H.O. Heymann Protection hypothesis for composite wear Dent Mater 8 1992 305 309
67. A.D. Wilder, S.C. Bayne, J. Perdigao, H.O. Heymann, and E.J. Swift 10-Year clinical performance of packable posterior composite J Dent Res 87 Spec Iss B 2008 0125 [Abstract No. 0125]
68. K.J. Soderholm, M. Zigan, M. Ragan, W. Fischlschweiger, and M. Bergman Hydrolytic degradation of dental composites J Dent Res 63 1984 1248 1254
69. K.J.M. Soderholm Leaking of fillers in dental composites J Dent Res 62 1983 126 130 (Pubitemid 13081991)
70. J.E. McKinney, and W. Wu Relationship between subsurface damage and wear in dental restorative composites J Dent Res 61 1982 1083 1088
71. J.E. McKinney, and W. Wu Chemical softening and wear of dental composites J Dent Res 64 1985 1326 1331 (Pubitemid 16227212)
72. E.C. Kao Influence of food-stimulating solvents on resin composites and glass-ionomer restorative cement Dent Mater 5 1989 201 208
73. N.K. Sarkar Internal corrosion in dental composite wear: its significance and simulation J Biomed Mater Res 53 2000 271 280
74. K.F. Leinfelder Composite resins in posterior teeth Symposium on composite resins in dentistry Dent Clin North Am 25 2 1981 357 364
75. K.D. Jorgensen Occlusal abrasion of a composite resin with ultra-fine filler - an initial study Quintessence Int 6 1978 73 78
76. K.D. Jorgensen Restorative resins: abrasion vs mechanical properties Scand J Dent Res 88 1980 557 568 (Pubitemid 11190868)
77. K.D. Jorgensen In vitro wear tests on macro-filled composite restorative materials Aust Dent J 27 1982 153 158
78. K.D. Jorgenson, P. Horsted, O. Janum, J. Krogh, and J. Schulz Abrasion of class I restorative resins Scand J Dent Res 87 1979 140 145
79. K.R. Leinfelder, and S. Suzuki In vitro wear device for determining posterior composite wear J Am Dent Assoc 130 1999 1347 1353
80. G. Leloup, W. D'Hoore, D. Bouter, M. Degrange, and J. Vreven Meta-analytical review of factors involved in dentin adherence J Dent Res 80 2001 1605 1614 (Pubitemid 33001854)
81. S.D. Heintze, C. Thunpithayakul, S.R. Armstrong, and V. Rousson Correlation between microtensile bond strength data and clinical outcome of class V restorations Dent Mater 27 2011 114 125
82. S.D. Heintze, and V. Rousson Pooling of dentin microtensile bond strength data improves clinical correlation J Adhes Dent 13 2011 107 110
83. S.D. Heintze, U. Blunck, T.N. Gohring, and V. Rousson Marginal adaptation in vitro and clinical outcome of class V restorations Dent Mater 25 2009 605 620
84. F. Garcia-Godoy, N. Kramer, A.J. Feilzer, and R. Frankenberger Long-term degradation of enamel and dentin bonds: 6-year results in vitro vs. in vivo Dent Mater 26 2010 1113 1118
85. A.I. Abdalla, and C.L. Davidson Comparison of the marginal and axial wall integrity of in vivo and in vitro made adhesive class V restorations J Oral Rehabil 20 1993 257 269
86. ClinicalTrials.gov National registry of clinical trials and results 22 August 2011 NIH-NLM-HHS http://www.clinicaltrials.gov
87. CONSORT Consort statement website 22 August 2011 http://www.consort- statement.org/now-published-consort-2010-statement/
88. PRISMA Rules for preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses 22 August 2011 http://prisma-statement.org/
89. B.L. Philstrom Reporting clinical trial results J Am Dent Assoc 140 2009 12 15
90. V. Yengopal, S.Y. Harnekar, N. Patel, and N. Siegfried Dental fillings for the treatment of caries in the primary dentition Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2 2009 10.1002/14651858.CD004483.pub2 [Article No.: CD004483]
91. R. Hickel, J.F. Roulet, S.C. Bayne, S.D. Heintze, I.A. Mjor, and M. Peters Recommendations for controlled clinical trials of restorative materials. Part 2: criteria for evaluation J Adhes Dent 9 2007 121 147
92. R. Hickel, A. Peschke, M. Tyas, I. Mjor, S. Bayne, and M. Peters FDI world dental federation - clinical criteria for the evaluation of direct and indirect restorations. Update and clinical examples J Adhes Dent 12 2010 259 272
93. American Dental Association American dental association acceptance program guidelines for composite resins for posterior restorations November 1989 ADA Council on Scientific Affairs p. 1-13
94. American Dental Association American Dental Association acceptance program guidelines: restorative materials March 1996 ADA Council on Scientific Affairs p. 1-10
95. American Dental Association American dental association acceptance program guidelines for resin based composites for posterior restorations May 2001 ADA Council on Scientific Affairs p. 1-12
96. American Dental Association Revised American Dental Association acceptance program guidelines for dentin and enamel adhesive materials May 2001 ADA Council on Scientific Affairs p. 1-9
97. American Dental Association American Dental Association acceptance program guidelines: products for the treatment of dentinal hypersensitivity May 1998 ADA Council on Scientific Affairs p. 1-9
98. American Dental Association American Dental Association acceptance program guidelines: home-use tooth whitening products May 1998 ADA Council on Scientific Affairs p. 1-9
99. A. Jokstad, S. Bayne, U. Blunck, M. Tyas, and N.H. Wilson Quality of dental restorations - FDI Commission Project 2-95 Int Dent J 53 2001 117 158