Benchmarking B-cell epitope prediction for the design of peptide-based vaccines: Problems and prospects

Journal of Biomedicine and Biotechnology

Volumn 2010, Issue , 2010, Pages

  Caoili, Salvador Eugenio C ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF THE PHILIPPINES MANILA   (Philippines)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

CROSS REACTING ANTIBODY; EPITOPE; PEPTIDE VACCINE; SUBUNIT VACCINE;

AMINO ACID SEQUENCE; B LYMPHOCYTE; CROSS REACTION; ELECTRICITY; IMMUNIZATION; IMMUNOASSAY; PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY; PREDICTION; QUALITY CONTROL; REVIEW; SEQUENCE ALIGNMENT; ANIMAL; BIOLOGICAL MODEL; DRUG DESIGN; HUMAN; IMMUNOLOGY; STATISTICAL MODEL;

ANIMALS; DRUG DESIGN; EPITOPES, B-LYMPHOCYTE; HUMANS; MODELS, IMMUNOLOGICAL; MODELS, STATISTICAL; VACCINES, SUBUNIT;

EID: 77951682769     PISSN: 11107243     EISSN: 11107251     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1155/2010/910524     Document Type: Review

References (115)

1. Marshall S. J., Developing countries face double burden of disease Bulletin of the World Health Organization 2004 82 7 556
2. De Groot A. S., Rappuoli R., Genome-derived vaccines Expert Review of Vaccines 2004 3 1 59 76 (Pubitemid 38202173)
3. Korber B., LaBute M., Yusim K., Immunoinformatics comes of age PLoS Computational Biology 2006 2 6, article e71
4. Fauci A. S., Emerging and re-emerging infectious diseases: influenza as a prototype of the host-pathogen balancing act Cell 2006 124 4 665 670
5. Belpomme D., Irigaray P., Sasco A. J., The growing incidence of cancer: role of lifestyle and screening detection (Review) International Journal of Oncology 2007 30 5 1037 1049
6. Purcell A. W., McCluskey J., Rossjohn J., More than one reason to rethink the use of peptides in vaccine design Nature Reviews Drug Discovery 2007 6 5 404 414 (Pubitemid 46696551)
7. Gay C. G., Zuerner R., Bannantine J. P., Genomics and vaccine development Revue Scientifique et Technique 2007 26 1 49 67 (Pubitemid 47148812)
8. Greenbaum J. A., Andersen P. H., Blythe M., Towards a consensus on datasets and evaluation metrics for developing B-cell epitope prediction tools Journal of Molecular Recognition 2007 20 2 75 82 (Pubitemid 46761248)
9. Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Reineke U., Schutkowski M., What is a B cell epitope? Epitope Mapping Protocols 2009 2nd New York, NY, USA Humana Press 3 20
10. Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Immunoinformatics may lead to a reappraisal of the nature of B cell epitopes and of the feasibility of synthetic peptide vaccines Journal of Molecular Recognition 2006 19 3 183 187
11. Pellequer J. L., Westhof E., Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Predicting location of continuous epitopes in proteins from their primary structures Methods in Enzymology 1991 203 176 201
12. Blythe M. J., Flower D. R., Benchmarking B cell epitope prediction: underperformance of existing methods Protein Science 2005 14 1 246 248
13. Larsen J. E., Lund O., Nielsen M., Improved method for predicting linear B-cell epitopes Immunome Research 2006 2, article 2
14. Caoili S. E. C., A structural-energetic basis for B-cell epitope prediction Protein and Peptide Letters 2006 13 7 743 751
15. Caoili S. E. C., Immunization with peptide-protein conjugates: impact on benchmarking B-cell epitope prediction for vaccine design Protein and Peptide Letters 2010 17 3 386 398
16. Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Pellequer J. L., Predicting antigenic determinants in proteins: looking for unidimensional solutions to a three-dimensional problem? Peptide Research 1994 7 4 224 228
17. Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Molecular recognition in the post-reductionist era Journal of Molecular Recognition 1999 12 1 1 2
18. Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Pitfalls of reductionism in the design of peptide-based vaccines Vaccine 2001 19 1719 2369 2374
19. Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Reductionism and the search for structure-function relationships in antibody molecules Journal of Molecular Recognition 2002 15 5 240 247
20. Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Biological complexity emerges from the ashes of genetic reductionism Journal of Molecular Recognition 2004 17 3 145 148
21. Huang J., Honda W., Kanehisa M., Predicting B cell epitope residues with network topology based amino acid indices Genome Informatics 2007 19 40 49
22. Swets J. A., Measuring the accuracy of diagnostic systems Science 1988 240 4857 1285 1293
23. Lund O., Nielsen M., Lundegaard C., Kesmir C., Brunak S., Immunological Bioinformatics 2005 1st Cambridge, Mass, USA MIT Press
24. Craig L., Sanschagrin P. C., Rozek A., Lackie S., Kuhn L. A., Scott J. K., The role of structure in antibody cross-reactivity between peptides and folded proteins Journal of Molecular Biology 1998 281 1 183 201 (Pubitemid 28360680)
25. Green N., Alexander H., Olson A., Immunogenic structure of the influenza virus hemagglutinin Cell 1982 28 3 477 487
26. Atassi M. Z., Young C. R., Discovery and implications of the immunogenicity of free small synthetic peptides: powerful tools for manipulating the immune system and for production of antibodies and T cells of preselected submolecular specificities Critical Reviews in Immunology 1985 5 4 387 409
27. Barnett P. V., Rowlands D. J., Parry N. R., Characterization of monoclonal antibodies raised against a synthetic peptide capable of inducing a neutralizing response to human rhinovirus type 2 Journal of General Virology 1993 74 7 1295 1302
28. Laver W. G., Air G. M., Webster R. G., Smith-Gill S. J., Epitopes on protein antigens: misconceptions and realities Cell 1990 61 4 553 556 (Pubitemid 20169012)
29. Schwab C., Bosshard H. R., Caveats for the use of surface-adsorbed protein antigen to test the specificity of antibodies Journal of Immunological Methods 1992 147 1 125 134
30. Leder L., Wendt H., Schwab C., Genuine and apparent cross-reaction of polyclonal antibodies to proteins and peptides European Journal of Biochemistry 1994 219 1-2 73 81 (Pubitemid 24053619)
31. Williams R. M., Obradovi Z., Mathura V., The protein non-folding problemml: amino acid determinants of intrinsic order and disorder Proceedings of the Pacific Symposium on Biocomputing. Pacific Symposium on Biocomputing 2001 89 100
32. Uversky V. N., Protein folding revisited. A polypeptide chain at the folding-misfolding-nonfolding cross-roads: which way to go? Cellular and Molecular Life Sciences 2003 60 9 1852 1871
33. Fink A. L., Natively unfolded proteins Current Opinion in Structural Biology 2005 15 1 35 41
34. Dunker A. K., Oldfield C. J., Meng J., The unfoldomics decade: an update on intrinsically disordered proteins BMC Genomics 2008 9 supplement 2 S1
35. Dunker A. K., Lawson J. D., Brown C. J., Intrinsically disordered protein Journal of Molecular Graphics and Modelling 2001 19 1 26 59
36. Vucetic S., Brown C. J., Dunker A. K., Obradovic Z., Flavors of protein disorder Proteins 2003 52 4 573 584 (Pubitemid 37034155)
37. Radivojac P., Iakoucheva L. M., Oldfield C. J., Obradovic Z., Uversky V. N., Dunker A. K., Intrinsic disorder and functional proteomics Biophysical Journal 2007 92 5 1439 1456 (Pubitemid 46393458)
38. Szilagyi A., Gyorffy D., Zavodszky P., The twilight zone between protein order and disorder Biophysical Journal 2008 95 4 1612 1626
39. Espinoza-Fonseca L. M., Reconciling binding mechanisms of intrinsically disordered proteins Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications 2009 382 3 479 482
40. Dyson H. J., Wright P. E., Coupling of folding and binding for unstructured proteins Current Opinion in Structural Biology 2002 12 1 54 60
41. Sigalov A. B., Zhuravleva A. V., Orekhov V. Y., Binding of intrinsically disordered proteins is not necessarily accompanied by a structural transition to a folded form Biochimie 2007 89 3 419 421
42. Wright P. E., Dyson H. J., Linking folding and binding Current Opinion in Structural Biology 2009 19 1 31 38
43. Hazy E., Tompa P., Limitations of induced folding in molecular recognition by intrinsically disordered proteins ChemPhysChem 2009 10 9-10 1415 1419
44. Tang Y. M., Chen G.-F., Thompson P. A., Development of an antipeptide antibody that binds to the C-terminal region of human CYP1B1 Drug Metabolism and Disposition 1999 27 2 274 280
45. Schmidt M. A., Raupach B., Szulczynski M., Marzillier J., Identification of linear B-cell determinants of pertussis toxin associated with the receptor recognition site of the S3 subunit Infection and Immunity 1991 59 4 1402 1408
46. Gechtman Z., Belleli A., Lechpammer S., Shaltiel S., The cluster of basic amino acids in vitronectin contributes to its binding of plasminogen activator inhibitor-1: evidence from thrombin-, elastase- and plasmin-cleaved vitronectins and anti-peptide antibodies Biochemical Journal 1997 325 2 339 349 (Pubitemid 27338712)
47. Simon P. L., Kumar V., Lillquist J. S., Mapping of neutralizing epitopes and the receptor binding site of human interleukin 1 beta The Journal of Biological Chemistry 1993 268 13 9771 9779 (Pubitemid 23146039)
48. Reitmaier R., Review of immunoinformatic approaches to in-silico B-cell epitope prediction Nature Precedings 2007
49. Reimer U., Prediction of linear B-cell epitopes Methods in Molecular Biology 2009 524 335 344
50. Kulkarni-Kale U., Bhosle S., Kolaskar A. S., CEP: a conformational epitope prediction server Nucleic Acids Research 2005 33 supplement 2 W168 W171
51. Batori V., Friis E. P., Nielsen H., Roggen E. L., An in silico method using an epitope motif database for predicting the location of antigenic determinants on proteins in a structural context Journal of Molecular Recognition 2006 19 1 21 29 (Pubitemid 43129783)
52. Getzoff E. D., Geysen H. M., Rodda S. J., Mechanisms of antibody binding to a protein Science 1987 235 4793 1191 1196
53. Deroo S., Muller C. P., Antigenic and immunogenic phage displayed mimotopes as substitute antigens: applications and limitations Combinatorial Chemistry and High Throughput Screening 2001 4 1 75 110 (Pubitemid 32405670)
54. Chen S.-W. W., Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Pellequer J.-L., Structure-activity relationships in peptide-antibody complexes: Implications for epitope prediction and development of synthetic peptide vaccines Current Medicinal Chemistry 2009 16 8 953 964
55. Kondo A., Takamatsu H., Katoh S., Sada E., Adsorption equilibrium in immunoaffinity chromatography with antibodies to synthetic peptides Biotechnology and Bioengineering 1990 35 2 146 151 (Pubitemid 20119260)
56. Sancho J., Serrano L., Fersht A. R., Histidine residues at the N- and C-termini of alpha-helices: perturbed pKas and protein stability Biochemistry 1992 31 8 2253 2258
57. Loewenthal R., Sancho J., Fersht A. R., Histidine-aromatic interactions in barnase: elevation of histidine pKa and contribution to protein stability Journal of Molecular Biology 1992 224 3 759 770
58. Edgcomb S. P., Murphy K. P., Variability in the pKa of histidine side-chains correlates with burial within proteins Proteins 2002 49 1 1 6
59. Nakra P., Manivel V., Vishwakarma R. A., Rao K. V. S., B cell responses to a peptide epitope. X. Epitope selection in a primary response is thermodynamically regulated Journal of Immunology 2000 164 11 5615 5625 (Pubitemid 30389801)
60. Motte P., Alberici G., Ait-Abdellah M., Bellet D., Monoclonal antibodies distinguish synthetic peptides that differ in one chemical group Journal of Immunology 1987 138 10 3332 3338 (Pubitemid 17071914)
61. Liang T. C., Luo W., Hsieh J.-T., Lin S.-H., Antibody binding to a peptide but not the whole protein by recognition of the C-terminal carboxy group Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics 1996 329 2 208 214
62. Zhang T., Bertelsen E., Alber T., Entropic effects of disulphide bonds on protein stability Nature Structural Biology 1994 1 7 434 438
63. Novotny J., Handschumacher M., Haber E., Antigenic determinants in proteins coincide with surface regions accessible to large probes (antibody domains) Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 1986 83 2 226 230
64. Hancock D. C., OReilly N. J., Evan G. I., Synthesis of peptides for use as immunogens Methods in Molecular Biology 1998 80 69 79
65. Briand J. P., Muller S., Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Synthetic peptides as antigens: pitfalls of conjugation methods Journal of Immunological Methods 1985 78 1 59 69
66. Adrian T. E., Production of antisera using peptide conjugates Methods in Molecular Biology 1997 73 239 249
67. Gullick W. J., Production of antisera to synthetic peptides Methods in Molecular Biology 1994 32 389 399
68. Liang F. T., Nowling J. M., Philipp M. T., Cryptic and exposed invariable regions of VlsE, the variable surface antigen of Borrelia burgdorferi sl Journal of Bacteriology 2000 182 12 3597 3601
69. Ferreon A. C. M., Gambin Y., Lemke E. A., Deniz A. A., Interplay of alpha-synuclein binding and conformational switching probed by single-molecule fluorescence Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2009 106 14 5645 5650
70. Haspel H. C., Rosenfeld M. G., Rosen O. M., Characterization of antisera to a synthetic carboxyl-terminal peptide of the glucose transporter protein The Journal of Biological Chemistry 1988 263 1 398 403
71. Wang H.-Y., Lipfert L., Malbon C. C., Bahouth S., Site-directed anti-peptide antibodies define the topography of the beta-adrenergic receptor The Journal of Biological Chemistry 1989 264 24 14424 14431
72. Dinauer M. C., Pierce E. A., Erickson R. W., Point mutation in the cytoplasmic domain of the neutrophil p22-phox cytochrome b subunit is associated with a nonfunctional NADPH oxidase and chronic granulomatous disease Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 1991 88 24 11231 11235
73. Bruss M., Hammermann R., Brimijoin S., Bonisch H., Antipeptide antibodies confirm the topology of the human norepinephrine transporter The Journal of Biological Chemistry 1995 270 16 9197 9201
74. Baude A., Nusser Z., Molnar E., McIlhinney R. A. J., Somogyi P., High-resolution immunogold localization of AMPA type glutamate receptor subunits at synaptic and non-synaptic sites in rat hippocampus Neuroscience 1995 69 4 1031 1055
75. Kuroda R., Kinoshita J.-Y., Honsho M., Mitoma J.-Y., Ito A., In situ topology of cytochrome b5 in the endoplasmic reticulum membrane Journal of Biochemistry 1996 120 4 828 833
76. Dewji N. N., Singer S. J., Cell surface expression of the Alzheimer disease-related presenilin proteins Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 1997 94 18 9926 9931
77. Yu J., Wessling-Resnick M., Structural and functional analysis of SFT, a stimulator of Fe transport The Journal of Biological Chemistry 1998 273 33 21380 21385
78. Lambert G., Traebert M., Hernando N., Biber J., Murer H., Studies on the topology of the renal type II NaPi-cotransporter Pflugers Archiv European Journal of Physiology 1999 437 6 972 978
79. Taylor P. D., Day T., Nagy D., Wild G., Andre J.-B., Gardner A., The evolutionary consequences of plasticity in host-pathogen interactions Theoretical Population Biology 2006 69 3 323 331
80. Wilson J. N., Nokes D. J., Dimmock N. J., Analysis of the relationship between immunogenicity and immunity for viral subunit vaccines Journal of Medical Virology 2001 64 4 560 568
81. Klasse P. J., Sattentau Q. J., Occupancy and mechanism in antibody-mediated neutralization of animal viruses Journal of General Virology 2002 83 9 2091 2108
82. Burton D. R., Saphire E. O., Parren P. W. H. I., A model for neutralization of viruses based on antibody coating of the virion surface Current Topics in Microbiology and Immunology 2001 260 109 143
83. Parren P. W. H. I., Burton D. R., The antiviral activity of antibodies in vitro and in vivo Advances in Immunology 2001 77 195 262
84. Reading S. A., Dimmock N. J., Neutralization of animal virus infectivity by antibody Archives of Virology 2007 152 6 1047 1059
85. Zwick M. B., Burton D. R., HIV-1 neutralization: mechanisms and relevance to vaccine design Current HIV Research 2007 5 6 608 624
86. Briand J.-P., Barin C., Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Muller S., Application and limitations of the multiple antigen peptide (MAP) system in the production and evaluation of anti-peptide and anti-protein antibodies Journal of Immunological Methods 1992 156 2 255 265
87. Debeljak N., Feldman L., Davis K. L., Komel R., Sytkowski A. J., Variability in the immunodetection of His-tagged recombinant proteins Analytical Biochemistry 2006 359 2 216 223
88. Leonetti M., Pillet L., Maillere B., Immunization with a peptide having both T cell and conformationally restricted B cell epitopes elicits neutralizing antisera against a snake neurotoxin Journal of Immunology 1990 145 12 4214 4221
89. Vita R., Vaughan K., Zarebski L., Curation of complex, context-dependent immunological data BMC Bioinformatics 2006 7, article 341
90. Vita R., Peters B., Sette A., The curation guidelines of the immune epitope database and analysis resource Cytometry A 2008 73 11 1066 1070
91. Carter J. M., Epitope mapping of a protein using the Geysen (PEPSCAN) procedure Methods in Molecular Biology 1994 36 207 223
92. Carter J. M., Loomis-Price L., B cell epitope mapping using synthetic peptides Current Protocols in Immunology 2004 chapter 9, unit 9.4
93. Reineke U., Sabat R., Antibody epitope mapping using SPOT peptide arrays Methods in Molecular Biology 2009 524 145 167
94. Baxevanis A. D., Searching the NCBI databases using Entrez Current Protocols in Human Genetics 2006 chapter 6, unit 6.10
95. Bouhnik J., Galen F.-X., Menard J., Production and characterization of human renin antibodies with region-oriented synthetic peptides The Journal of Biological Chemistry 1987 262 6 2913 2918 (Pubitemid 17105669)
96. Sytkowski A. J., Donahue K. A., Immunochemical studies of human erythropoietin using site-specific anti-peptide antibodies. Identification of a functional domain The Journal of Biological Chemistry 1987 262 3 1161 1165
97. Harari I., Donohue-Rolfe A., Keusch G., Arnon R., Synthetic peptides of Shiga toxin B subunit induce antibodies which neutralize its biological activity Infection and Immunity 1988 56 6 1618 1624
98. Harshman S., Alouf J. E., Siffert O., Baleux F., Reaction of staphylococcal alpha-toxin with peptide-induced antibodies Infection and Immunity 1989 57 12 3856 3862
99. Pontzer C. H., Russell J. K., Johnson H. M., Localization of an immune functional site on staphylococcal enterotoxin A using the synthetic peptide approach Journal of Immunology 1989 143 1 280 284
100. Bavoso A., Ostuni A., De Vendel J., Aldehyde modification of peptide immunogen enhances protein-reactive antibody response to toxic shock syndrome toxin-1 Journal of Peptide Science 2006 12 12 843 849
101. Partidos C. D., Peptide mimotopes as candidate vaccines Current Opinion in Molecular Therapeutics 2000 2 1 74 79
102. Partidos C. D., Steward M. W., Mimotopes of viral antigens and biologically important molecules as candidate vaccines and potential immunotherapeutics Combinatorial Chemistry and High Throughput Screening 2002 5 1 15 27
103. Sabatino G., Papini A. M., Advances in automatic, manual and microwave-assisted solid-phase peptide synthesis Current Opinion in Drug Discovery and Development 2008 11 6 762 770
104. Lemus R., Karol M. H., Conjugation of haptens Methods in Molecular Medicine 2008 138 167 182
105. Hans D., Young P. R., Fairlie D. P., Current status of short synthetic peptides as vaccines Medicinal Chemistry 2006 2 6 627 646
106. Van Regenmortel M. H. V., Synthetic peptide vaccines and the search for neutralization B cell epitopes The Open Vaccine Journal 2009 2 33 44
107. Hopp T. P., Woods K. R., Prediction of protein antigenic determinants from amino acid sequences Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 1981 78 6 I 3824 3828
108. Fedorov V., Mannino F., Zhang R., Consequences of dichotomization Pharmaceutical Statistics 2009 8 1 50 61
109. Murphy K. P., Freire E., Thermodynamics of structural stability and cooperative folding behavior in proteins Advances in Protein Chemistry 1992 43 313 361
110. Murphy K. P., Predicting binding energetics from structure: looking beyond G Medicinal Research Reviews 1999 19 4 333 339
111. Edgcomb S. P., Murphy K. P., Structural energetics of protein folding and binding Current Opinion in Biotechnology 2000 11 1 62 66
112. Mummert M. E., Voss E. W. Jr., Transition-state theory and secondary forces in antigen-antibody complexes Biochemistry 1996 35 25 8187 8192
113. James L. C., Tawfik D. S., Structure and kinetics of a transient antibody binding intermediate reveal a kinetic discrimination mechanism in antigen recognition Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2005 102 36 12730 12735
114. Verdier F., Non-clinical vaccine safety assessment Toxicology 2002 174 1 37 43
115. Descotes J., Ravel G., Ruat C., Vaccines: predicting the risk of allergy and autoimmunity Toxicology 2002 174 1 45 51