Techniques for oxygen transfer measurement in bioreactors: A review

Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology

Volumn 84, Issue 8, 2009, Pages 1091-1103

  Suresh, S ^a   Srivastava, V C ^a   Mishra, I M ^a  

^a INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY ROORKEE   (India)

Author keywords

OTR; Oxygen electrode; Oxygen measurement; Oxygen transfer rate; Sensor; Shake flasks

Indexed keywords

OTR; OXYGEN ELECTRODE; OXYGEN MEASUREMENT; OXYGEN TRANSFER RATE; SHAKE FLASKS;

BIOCONVERSION; BIOREACTORS; BOTTLES; CELL CULTURE; CELL MEMBRANES; ELECTRODES; INDUSTRIAL CHEMICALS; MASS TRANSFER; MEASUREMENTS; OPTICAL SENSORS; OXYGEN PERMEABLE MEMBRANES; OXYGEN SENSORS; PLANT CELL CULTURE; ZIRCONIA;

OXYGEN;

SULFITE; ZIRCONIUM OXIDE;

BIOPROCESS; BIOREACTOR; CONTROLLED STUDY; ELECTROCHEMICAL ANALYSIS; ELECTRODE; INFRARED RADIATION; LIQUID CULTURE; MEASUREMENT; MICROBIAL GROWTH; NONHUMAN; ONLINE SYSTEM; OPTICAL BIOSENSOR; OXIDATION; OXYGEN CONCENTRATION; OXYGEN TRANSFER; PLANT CELL CULTURE; REVIEW; ULTRASOUND;

EID: 67650898837     PISSN: 02682575     EISSN: 10974660     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/jctb.2154     Document Type: Review

References (160)

1. Gupta A and Rao GA, Study of oxygen transfer in shake flasks using a non-invasive oxygen sensor. BiotechnolBioeng 84:351-358 (2003).
2. Gogate PR and Pandit AB, Survey of measurement technique for gas-liquid mass transfer coefficeient in biorectors. Biochem Eng J 4:7-15 (1999).
3. Clark GJ, Langley D and Bushell ME, Oxygen limitation can induce microbial secondary metabolite formation: investigations with miniature electrodes in shaker and bioreactor culture. Microbiol 141:663-669 (1995).
4. Garcia-Ochoa F and Gomez E, Mass transfer coefficient in stirred tank reactors for xanthan gum solutions. Biochem Eng J 1:1-10 (1998).
5. La in yeast broths. Process Biochem 34:549-555 (1999).
6. Ozbek B and Gayik S, The studies on the oxygen mass transfer coefficient in a bioreactor. Process Biochem 36:729-741 (2001).
7. Cascaval D, Oniscu C and Galaction AI, Biochemical Engineering and Biotechnology: Bioreactors. Inter Global, Iasi, pp 73 (2002).
8. Cascaval D, Galaction AI, Folescu E and Turnea M, Comparative study on the effects of n-dodecane addition on oxygen transfer in stirred bioreactors for simulated, bacterial and yeasts broths. BiochemEng J 31:56-66 (2006).
9. Vardar F and Lilly MD, Effect of cycling dissolved oxygen concentrations on product formation in penicillin fermentations. Eur J Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 14:203-211 (1982).
10. Morimoto T, Itoh H and Chibata I, Shaking method for tube cultures of microorganisms. Agr Biol Chem 43:15-18 (1979).
11. Maier U and Buchs J, Characterization of gas-liquid mass transfer in shaking bioreactors. Biochem Eng J 7:99-106 (2001).
12. Maier U, Losen M and Buchs J, Advances in understanding and modeling the gas-liquid mass transfer in shake flasks. Biochem Eng J 17:155-167 (2004).
13. Belo I, Pinheiro R and Mota M, Fed-batch cultivation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae in a hyperbaric bioreactor. Biotechnol Prog 19:665-671 (2003).
14. Knoll A, Maier B, Tscherrig H and Buchs J, The oxygen mass transfer, carbon dioxide inhibition, heat removal and energy and cost efficiencies of high pressure fermentation. Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol 92:77-99 (2005).
15. Sonnleitner B and Hahnemann U, Dynamics of the respiratory bottleneck of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. J Biotechnol 38:63-79 (1994).
16. van Ede CJ, van HR and Beenackers AACM, Enhancement of gas to water mass transfer rates by dispersed organic phase. Chem Eng Sci 50:2911-2922 (1995).
17. Galaction AI, Cascaval D, Oniscu C and Turne M, Prediction of oxygen mass transfer coefficients in stirred bioreactors for bacteria, yeasts and fungus broths. Biochem Eng J 20:85-94 (2004).
18. Lee JM, Biochemical engineering. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. pp. 240 (1992).
19. MacLean GT, Oxygen diffusion rates in organic fermentation broths. Process Biochem 12:22-28 (1977).
20. Hassan ITM and Robinson CW, Oxygen transfer in mechanically agitated aqueous systems containing dispersed hydrocarbon. Biotechnol Bioeng 19:661-682 (1977).
21. Ho CS, Ju LK and Baddour RF, Enhancing penicillin fermentations by increased oxygen solubility through the addition of n-hexadecane. Biotechnol Bioeng 36:1110-1118 (1990).
22. Ju LK and Ho CS, Oxygen diffusion coefficient and solubility an n-hexadecane. Biotechnol Bioeng 34:1221-1224 (1989).
23. Zhao S, Kuttuva SG and Ju LK, Oxygen transfer characteristics of multiple-phase dispersions simulating water-in-oil xanthan fermentations. Bioprocess Eng 20:313-323 (1999).
24. Giridhar Rand Srivastava AK, Productivity enhancement in l-sorbose fermentation using oxygen vector. Enzyme Microb Technol 27:537-541 (2000).
25. Nielsen DR, Daugulis AJ and McLellan PJ, A novel method of simulating oxygen mass transfer in two-phase partitioning bioreactors. Biotechnol Bioeng 83:735-742 (2003).
26. McMillan JD and Wang DIC, Enhanced oxygen transfer using oil-in-water dispersions. Biochemical engineering V. Ann NY Acad Sci 506:569-582 (1987).
27. McMillan JD and Wang DIC, Mechanisms of oxygen transfer enhancement during submerged cultivation in perfluorochemical-in-water dispersions. Biochemical engineering VI. Ann NY Acad Sci 589:283-300 (1990).
28. Linek V and Benes P, Analysis of gas absorption in emulsions of n-alkanes in water. Chem Eng Sci 31:1037-1043 (1976).
29. Battino R, Rettich TR and Tominaga T, The solubility of oxygen and ozone in liquids. J Phys Chem Ref Data 12:163-169 (1983).
30. Battino R, Johnson SA and Clever HL, The solubility of nitrogen and air in liquids. Solubility Data Ser 7:414-420 (1986).
31. Wilhelm E and Battino R, The solubility of gases in liquids. 17. The solubility of gases in carbon tetrachloride. Chem Rev 73:214-220 (1986).
32. Oniscu C and Cascaval D, Biochemical engineering and biotechnology.1. Biochemical process. in Biochemical Engineering, ed. by Lee JM. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, pp. 240 (1992).
33. Beenackers AACM and van Swaaij WPM, Mass transfer in gas-liquid slurry reactors. Chem Eng Sci 48:3109-3139 (1993).
34. Kim SD and Kang Y, Heat and mass transfer in three-phase fluidized-bed reactors/an overview. Chem Eng Sci 52:3639-3660 (1997).
35. Dumont E and Delmas H, Mass transfer enhancement of gas absorption in oil-in-water systems: a review. Chem Eng Process 42:419-438 (2003).
36. Yoshida F, Yamane T and Miyamoto M, The increase oxygen diffusion rates in broths adding organic substrates. Ind Eng Chem Proc Des Dev 9:570-577 (1970).
37. Rols JL and Goma G, Enhancement of oxygen transfer rates in fermentation using oxygen-vectors. Biotechnol Adv 7:1-8 (1989).
38. Rols JL, Condoret JS, Fonade C and Goma G, Mechanism of enhanced oxygen transfer in fermentation using emulsified oxygen-vectors. Biotechnol Bioeng 35:427-435 (1990).
39. Riesenberg D and Guthke R, High-cell-density cultivation of microorganisms. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 51:422-430 (1999).
40. Chung JD, Chang CC and Groves JA, High cell density induces spontaneous bifurcations of dissolved oxygen controllers during CHO cell fermentations. Biotechnol Bioeng 84:224-232 (2003).
41. Anderlei T and Buchs J, Device for sterile measurement of the oxygen transfer rate in shaking flasks. Biochem Eng J 7:157-163 (2001).
42. Cooper EB, Fernstrom GA and Miller SA, Performance of agitated gas-liquid contactors. Ind Eng Chem 36:504-509 (1944).
43. Bartholomew WH, Karow E, Staf MR and Wilhelm RH, Oxygen transfer and agitation in submerged fermentations. Ind Eng Chem 42:1801-1809 (1950).
44. Auro MA, Hodge HM and Koth G, Oxygen absorption rates in shaken flasks. Ind Eng Chem 49:1237-1238 (1957).
45. Linek V, Bestimmung der Phasen-Grenzflache in einem mit mechanischem Ruhrwerk versehenen Reaktor bei Gasdurchgang. Chem Eng Sci 21:777-790 (1966).
46. Bandyopadhyay B, Humphrey AE and Taguchi H, Dynamic measurement of the volumetric oxygen transfer coefficient in fermentation systems. Biotechnol Bioeng 9:533-544 (1967).
47. Kouda T, Yano H and Yoshinaga F, Effect of agitator configuration on bacterial cellulose productivity in aerated and agitated culture. J Ferment Bioeng 83:371-376 (1997).
48. Henzler HJ and Schedel M, Suitability of shaking flask for oxygen supply to microbial cultures. Bioprocess Eng 7:123-131 (1991).
49. Hirose Y, Kinoshita K and Okada H, Studies on oxygen transfer in submerged fermentations part IV: Determination of oxygen transfer rate and respiration rate in shaken cultures using oxygen analyzers. Agric Biol Chem 30:49-58 (1966).
50. Hospodka J, Oxygen absorption rate controlled feeding of substrate into aerobic microbial cultures. Biotechnol Bioeng 8:117-134 (1966).
51. McDaniel LE and Bailey EG, Effect of shaking speed and type of closure on shake flask cultures. Appl Microbiol 17:286-290 (1969).
52. Sobotka M, Prokop A, Dunn IJ and Einsele A, Review of methods for the measurement of oxygen transfer in microbial systems. Ann Rep Ferment Proc 5:127-211 (1982).
53. Tolosa L, Kostov Y, Harms P and Rao G, Non-invasive measurement of dissolved oxygen in shake flask. Biotechnol Bioeng 80:594-597 (2002).
54. 2 in shake-flasks. Biotechnol Lett 25:377-380 (2003).
55. Lotter S and Buchs J, Utilization of specific power input measurements for optimization of culture conditions in shaking flasks. Biochem Eng J 17:195-203 (2004).
56. Silberbach M, Maier B, Zimmermann M and Buchs J, Glucose oxidation by Gluconobacter oxydans: characterization in shaking-flasks, scale-up and optimization of the pH profile. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 62:92-98 (2003).
57. Anderlei T, Zang W, Papaspyrou M and Buchs J, Online respiration activity measurement (OTR, CTR, RQ) in shake flasks Biochem Eng J 17:187-194 (2004).
58. Van't Riet K, Review of measuring methods and results in non-viscous gas-liquid mass transfer in stirred vessels. Ind Eng Chem Proc Des Dev 18:357-364 (1979).
59. Rainer BW, Determination of the volumetric oxygen transfer coefficient in bioreactors. Chem Biochem Eng Q 4:185-196 (1990).
60. Fraden J, Handbook of Modern Sensors: Physic Designs and Applications. Springer-Verlag, New York (1996).
61. Jalukse L, Leito I, Mashirin A and Tenno T, Estimation of uncertainty in electrochemical amperometric measurement of dissolved oxygen concentration. Accts Qual Assur 9:340-348 (2004).
62. Hrgeti M, Krois I and Cifrek M, Accuracy analysis of dissolved oxygen measurement system realized with cypress PSoC configurable mixed signal array. IEEE 20-23:1105-1110 (2005).
63. Chang SC, Stetter JR and Cha CS, Amperometric gas sensors. Talanta 40:461-477 (1993).
64. DeltaFApplicationNoteNo.108-UHPOlefins,file:\Jordan\web test\AppNotes\ apnote8.htm.
65. www.Habmigern2003.info/suggestions/problems/oxygen/oxygensensors.html.
66. Wecker A and Onken U, Influence of dissolved-oxygen concentration and shear rate on the production of pullulan by aureobasidium-pullulans. Biotechnol Lett 13:155-160 (1991).
67. Rosenzweig Z and Kopelman R, Development of a submicrometer optical fiber oxygen sensor. Anal Chem 67:2650-2654 (1995).
68. Mills A and Thomas M, Fluorescence-based thin plastic film ion-pair sensors for oxygen. Analyst 122:63-68 (1997).
69. McNamara KP, Li X, Stull AD and Rosenzweig Z, Fiber-optic oxygen sensor based on the fluorescence quenching of tris (5-acrylamido, 1, 10 phenanthroline) ruthenium chloride. Anal Chim Acta 361:73-78 (1998).
70. Choi MMF and Xiao D, Linear calibration function of luminescence quenching-based optical sensor for trace oxygen analysis. Analyst 124:695-698 (1999).
71. Zhao Y, Richman A, Storey C, Radford NB and Pantano P, In situ fiber-optic oxygen consumption measurements from a working mouse heart Anal Chem 71:3887-3893 (1999).
72. Choi MMF and Xiao D, Single standard calibration for an optical oxygen sensor based on luminescence quenching of a ruthenium complex. Anal Chim Acta 403:57-65 (2000).
73. Riordan TC, Buckley D, Ogurtsov V, Connor RO and Papkovsky DB, A cell viability assay based on monitoring respiration by optical oxygen sensing. Anal Biochem 278:221-227 (2000).
74. Ishiji T and Kaneko M, Photoluminescence of pyrenebutyric acid incorporated into silicone film as a technique in luminescence oxygen sensing. Analyst 120:1633-1638 (1995).
75. Potyrailo RA and Hieftje GM, Oxygen detection by fluorescence quenching of tetraphenylporphyrin immobilized in the original cladding of an optical fiber. Anal Chim Acta 370:1-8 (1998).
76. Lee SK and Okura I, Optical sensor for oxygen using a porphyrindoped sol-gel glass. Analyst 122:81-84 (1997).
77. Xiao D and Choi MMF, Aspartame optical biosensor with bienzyme-immobilized eggshell membrane and oxygen-sensitive optical membrane. Anal Chem 74:863-870 (2002).
78. Chu L and Robinson DK, Industrial choices for protein production by large-scale cell culture. Curr Opinion Biotechnol 12:180-187 (2001).
79. Xiao D,Mo Y and Choi MMF, A hand-held optical sensor for dissolved oxygen measurement. Meas Sci Technol 14:862-867 (2003).
80. Bacon JR and Demas JN, Determination of oxygen concentrations by luminescence quenching of a polymer immobilized transition metal complex. Anal Chem 59:2780-2785 (1987).
81. Klimant I and Wolfbeis OS, Oxygen-sensitive luminescent materials based on silicone-soluble ruthenium diimine complexes. Anal Chem 67:3160-3166 (1995).
82. John GT, Klimant I, Wittmann C and Heinzle E, Integrated optical sensing of dissolved oxygen in microtiter plates: a novel tool for microbial Cultivation Biotechnol Bioeng 81:829-836 (2003).
83. Bambot SB, Holavanahali R, Lakowicz JR, Carter GM and Rao G, Phase fluorometric sterilizable optical oxygen sensor. Biotechnol Bioeng 43:1139-1145 (1994).
84. Huber C, Klimant I, Krause C,Werner T,Mayr T and Wolfbeis OS, Dual lifetime referenced (DLR) optode for salinity. Fresenius J Anal Chem 368:196-202 (2000).
85. Hanson MA, Ge X, Kostov Y, Brorson KA, Moreira AR and Rao G, Comparisons of optical pH and dissolved oxygen sensors with traditional electrochemical probes during mammalian cell culture. Biotechnol Bioeng 97:833-841 (2007).
86. Chojnacki P, Mistlberger G and Klimant I, Separable magnetic sensors for the optical determination of oxygen. Angew Chem Int Ed 46:8850-8853 (2007).
87. Mahony FCO, Donovan CO, Hynes J, Moore T, Davenport J and Papkovsky DB, Rapid high throughput assessment of animal model studies and toxicity screening. Environ Sci Technol 39:5010-5014 (2005).
88. Buck SM, Koo YL, Park E, Xu H, Philbert MA, Brasuel MA, et al., Optochemical nanosensor PEBBLEs: photonic explorers for bioanalysis with biologically localized embedding. Curr Opin Chem Biol 8:540-546 (2004).
89. Schmalzlin E, van Dongen JT, Klimant I, Marmodee B, Steup M, Fisahn J, et al., An optical multifrequency phase-modulation method using microbeads for measuring intracellular oxygen concentrations in plants. Biophys J 89:1339-1345 (2005).
90. Corman J, Tsuchiya HM, Kosepsell HJ, Benedict RG, Kelley SE, Feger VH, et al., Oxygen absorption rates in laboratory and pilot plant equipment. Appl Microbiol 5:313-318 (1957).
91. Ecker RE and Lockhart WR, Calibration of laboratory aeration apparatus. Appl Microbiol 7:102-105 (1959).
92. Ecker RE and Lockhart WR, Theoretical basis for laboratory aeration. Appl Microbiol 9:25-31 (1961).
93. Van't Riet K, Turbine agitator hydrodynamics and dispersion performance, Thesis, University of Technology, Delft (1975).
94. Suijdam V, Kossen NWF and Joha AC, Model for oxygen transfer in a shake flask. Biotechnol Bioeng 20:1695-1709 (1978).
95. Linek V and Vacek V, Chemical engineering use of catalyzed sulfite oxidation kinetics for the determination of mass transfer characteristics of gas-liquid contactors. Chem Eng Sci 36:1747-1768 (1981).
96. Hermann R, Walther N, Maier U and Buchs J, Optical method for the determination of the oxygen-transfer capacity of small bioreactors based on sulfite oxidation. Biotechnol Bioeng 74:355-363 (2001).
97. Sharma MM and Danckwerts PV, Chemical methods of measuring interfacial area and mass transfer coefficients in two-fluid systems. Br Chem Engng 15:522-528 (1970).
98. Robinson CW and Wilke CR, Simultaneous measurement of interfacial area and mass transfer coefficients for well-mixed gas dispersion in aqueous electrolyte solutions. AIChE J 20:285-293 (1974).
99. Westerterp KR, Van Dierendonck LL and De Kraa JA, Interfacial areas in agitated gas-liquid contactors. Chem Eng Sci 18:157-68 (1963).
100. de Waal KJA and Okeson JC, The oxidation of aqueous sulfite solutions. Chem Eng Sci 21:559-572 (1966).
101. Astarita G, Mass Transfer with Chemical Reaction. Elsevier (1967).
102. Linek V, Mayrhoferova J and Mosnerova J, The influence of diffusivity on liquid-phase mass transfer in solutions of electrolytes. Chem Eng Sci 25:1033-1045 (1970).
103. Gmelin L, Handbuch der anorganischen Chemie Bd. S [B].Verlag Chemie, Weinheim Bergstrabe (1963).
104. Linek V and Tvrdik J, A generalization of kinetic data on sulfite oxidation systems. Biotechnol Bioeng 13:353-369 (1971).
105. Reith T and Beek WJ, The oxidation of aqueous sodium sulphite solutions. Chem Eng Sci 28:1331-1339 (1973).
106. La) with the sulfite oxidation method. Chem Eng J 30:29-389 (1985).
107. de Waal KJA and van Mameren AC, AIChE.-International Chemical Engineering Symposium. Ser. No. 6. Institution of Chemical Engineers, London (1965).
108. Harris IJ and Roper GH, Absorption of oxygen by sodium sulfite on sieve plate. Canad J Chem Eng 42:34-37 (1964).
109. Kilian SG, Prior BA, Pretorius IS, du Preez JC, Venter JJ and Potgieter HJ, Nutritional, temperature, ph, and oxygen requirements of Candida wickerhamii. Eur J Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 17:334-338 (1983).
110. Ducros E, Ferrari M, Pellegrino M, Raspanti C and Bogni C, Effect of aeration and agitation on the protease production by Staphylococcus aureus mutant RC128 in a stirred tank bioreactor. Bioprocess Biosyst Eng 32:143-148 (2009).
111. Amanullah A, Tuttiett B and Nienow AW, Agitator speed and dissolved oxygen effects in xanthan fermentations. Biotechnol Bioeng 57:198-210 (1998).
112. La measurement in viscous gas-liquid systems. Biotechnol Bioeng 22:1945-1956 (1980).
113. La. Biotechnol Bioeng 23:277-290 (1981).
114. Kato Y, Tada Y, Iwanagai E, Nagatsu Y, Iwata SS, Lee YS, et al., KOH Effects of liquid film formed on flask surface on oxygen transfer rate in shaking flask and development of baffled shaking vessel by optical method based on sulfite oxidation. J Chem Eng Japan 38:873-877 (2005).
115. Veglio F, Ubaldini S, Abbruzzese C and Toro G, Oxygen mass transfer scale-up in the bioleaching of manganiferrous minerals by heterotrophic microorganisms. in Mineral Bioprocessing 11, ed. by Holmes DS and Smith RW. TMS, Warrendale PA (1995).
116. Veglio F, Beolchini F and Ubaldini S, Empirical models for oxygen mass transfer: a comparison between shake flask and lab-scale fermentor and application to manganiferous ore bioleaching. Process Biochem 33:367-376 (1998).
117. Puthli MS, Rathod VK and Pandit AB, Gas-liquid mass transfer studies with triple impeller system on a laboratory scale bioreactor. Biochem Eng J 23:25-30 (2005).
118. Pirt SJ, Principles of Microbe and Cell Cultivation. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford (1985).
119. Kato Y, Hiraoka S, Tada Y, Sato K and Ohishi T, Measurment of mass transfer rate from free surface in shaking vessel type bioreactor. J Chem Eng Japan 30:362-365 (1997).
120. La) using the dynamic gas out gas in method: analysis of errors caused by dissolved oxygen probes. Biotechnol Bioeng 46:388-392 (1995).
121. Stanbury PF, Whitaker A and Hall SJ, Principles of Fermentation Technology. Elsevier Science Ltd, Oxford, pp. 243-253 (1995).
122. Hilton MD, Small-scale liquid fermentations. in Manual of Industrial Microbiology and Biotechnology, American Society of Microbiology, ed. by Demain AL and Davies JE. ASM press, Washington, DC, pp. 49-60 (1999).
123. Payne GF, Davison SF and Tate JT, Experimental constraints to studying the effects of dissolved oxygen and dissolved carbon dioxide on plant cell growth. Dev Ind Microbiol 31:293-301 (1990).
124. Seletzky JM, Noack U, Hahn S, Knoll A, Amoabediny G and Buchs J, An experimental comparison of respiration measuring techniques in fermenters and shake flasks: exhaust gas analyzer vs. RAMOS device vs. respirometer. J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol 34:123-130 (2007).
125. Mrotzek Ch, Anderlei T, Henzler HJ and Büchs J, Mass transfer resistance of sterile plugs in shaking bioreactors. Biochem Eng J 7:99-106 (2001).
126. Betts JI and Baganz F, Miniature bioreactors: current practices and future opportunities. Microbial Cell Fact 5:1-14 (2006).
127. Duetz WA, Microtiter plates as mini-bioreactors: miniaturization of fermentation methods. Trends Microbiol 15:469-475 (2007).
128. Ortiz-Ochoa K, Doig SD, Ward JM and Baganz F, A novel method for the measurement of oxygen mass transfer rates in small-scale vessels. Biochem Eng J 25:63-68 (2005).
129. Duetz WA and Witholt B, Oxygen transfer by orbiting shaking of square wells and deepwell microtitre plates of various dimensions. Biochem Eng J 17:181-185 (2004).
130. Akesson M, Hagander P and Axelsson JP, Avoiding acetate accumulation in Escherichia coli cultures using feedback control of glucose feeding. Biotechnol Bioeng 73:223-230 (2001).
131. Calik P, Calik G and Ozdamar TH, Oxygen transfer effects in serine alkaline protease fermentation by Bacillus licheniformis: use of citric acid as the carbon source. Enzyme Microbial Technol 23:451-461 (1998).
132. Royce PN, Effect of changes in the pH and carbon dioxide evolution rate on the measured respiratory quotient of fermentations. Biotechnol Bioeng 40:1129-1138 (1992).
133. Calik P, Calik G, Takac S and Ozdamar TH, Metabolic flux analysis for serine alkaline protease fermentation by Bacillus licheniformis in a defined medium: Effects of the oxygen transfer rate. Biotechnol Bioeng 64:151-167 (1999).
134. Schmid A, Kollmer A, Mathys RG and Witholt B, Developments toward large-scale bacterial bioprocesses in the presence of bulk amounts of organic solvents. Extremophiles 2:249-256 (1998).
135. Calik P, Calik G and Ozdamar TH, Oxygen-transfer strategy and its regulation effects inserine alkaline protease production by Bacillus licheniformis. Biotechnol Bioeng 69:301-311 (2000).
136. Yang JD and Wang NS, Oxygen mass-transfer enhancement via fermenter headspace pressurization. Biotechnol Prog 8:244-251 (1992).
137. Schultz JS, Cotton closure as an aeration barrier in shaken flask fermentations. Appl Microbiol 12:305-310 (1964).
138. Rhodes RP and Gaden EL, Characterization of agitation effects in shaken flasks Ind Eng Chem 49:1233-1236 (1957).
139. Smith CG, Marvin J and Johnson MJ, Aeration requirements for the growth of aerobic microorganisms. J Bacteriol 68:346-350 (1954).
140. Finn RK, Agitation-aeration in the laboratory and in industry. Bacteriol Rev 18:254-274 (1954).
141. Heinemann B, Howard AJ and Palocz HJ, Influence of dissolved oxygen levels on production of L-Asparaginase and prodigiosin by Serratia marcescens. Appl Microbiol 5:800-804 (1970).
142. McDaniel LE, Zimmerli A and Bailey EG, Effect of oxygen supply rates on growth of Escherichia coli. I. Studies in baffled and unbaffled shake flasks. Appl Microbiol 13:109-114 (1965a).
143. McDaniel LE, Zimmerli A and Bailey EG, Effect of oxygen-supply rates on growth of Escherichia coli. II. Comparison of results in shake flasks and 50-liter fermentor. Appl Microbiol 13:115-119 (1965b).
144. Kanokwaree K and Doran PM, The extent to which external oxygen transfer limits growth in shake flask culture of hairy roots. Biotechnol Bioeng 55:520-526 (1997).
145. Roseiro JC, Peito MA, Girio FM and Amaral-Collaco MT, The effects of the oxygen-transfer coefficient and substrate concentration on the xylose fermentation by Debaryomyces-hansenii. Archives Microbiol 156:484-490 (1991).
146. Pena C, Campos N and Galindo E, Changes in alginate molecular mass distribution, broth viscosity and morphology of Azotobacter vinelandii cultured in shake flasks. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 48:510-515 (1997).
147. Reyes C, Pena C and Galindo E, Reproducing shake flasks performance in stirred fermentors: production of alginates by Azotobacter vinelandii. J Biotechnol 105:189-198 (2003).
148. Seletzky JM, Noack U, Fricke J, Hahn S and Buchs J, Metabolic activity of Corynebacterium glutamicum grown on L-lactic acid under stress. Appl Biotechnol Bioeng 72:1297-1307 (2006).
149. Olson BH and Johnson MJ, Factors producing high yeast yields in synthetic media. J Bacteriol 57:235-246 (1949).
150. Doig SD, Pickering SCR, Lye GJ and Baganz F, Modelling surface aeration rates in shaken microtitre plates using dimensionless groups. Chem Eng Sci 60:2741-2750 (2005).
151. Stockmann C, Maier U, Anderlei T, Knocke C, Gellissen G and Buchs J, The oxygen transfer rate as key parameter for the characterization of Hansenula polymorpha screening cultures J Ind Microbiol Biotechnol 30:613-622 (2003).
152. Freyer SA, Konig M and Künkel A, Validating shaking flasks as representative screening systems. Biochem Eng J 17:169-173 (2004).
153. Baumchen C, Knol A, Husemann B, Seletzky J, Maier B, Dietrich CC, et al., Effect of elevated dissolved carbon dioxide concentrations on growth of Corynebacterium glutamicum on d-glucose and l-lactate. J Biotechnol 128:868-874 (2007).
154. Pena C, Peter CP, Buchs J and Galindo E, Evolution of the specific power consumption and oxygen transfer rate in alginate-producing cultures of Azotobacter vinelandii conducted in shake flasks. Biochem Eng J 36:73-80 (2007).
155. Nikakhtari H and Hill GA, Closure effects on oxygen transfer and aerobic growth in shake flasks. Biotechnol Bioeng 95:15-21 (2006).
156. Akgun A, Muller C, Engmann R and Buchs J, Application of an improved continuous parallel shaken bioreactor system for three microbial model systems. Bioprocess Biosyst Eng 31:193-205 (2008).
157. Honda H, Hattori T, Uozumi N, Kobayashi T, Kato Y and Hiraoka S, Production of regenerated plantlet using a shaking vessel-type bioreactor. J Chem Eng Japan 30:179-182 (1997).
158. Lamping SR, Zhang H and Shamlou AP, Design of a prototype microlitre bioreactor for high throughput automated bioprocessing. Chem Eng Sci 58:747-758 (2003).
159. Zhang H, Dalson WW, Moore EK and Shamlou PA, CFD analysis of mixing and gas-liquid mass transfer in shake flasks. Biotechnol Appl Biochem 41:1-8 (2005).
160. Zhang H, Lamping SR, Pickering SCR, Lye GJ and Shamlou PA, Engineering characterization of a single well from 24-well and 96-well microtitre plates. Biochem Eng J 40:38-149 (2008).