Aerodynamic shape optimization using first and second Order adjoint and direct approaches

Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering

Volumn 15, Issue 4, 2008, Pages 447-488

  Papadimitriou, Dimitrios I ^a   Giannakoglou, Kyriakos C ^a  

^a NATIONAL TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY OF ATHENS   (Greece)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ADJOINT; ADJOINT APPROACHES; ADJOINT FORMULATIONS; ADJOINT METHODS; AERODYNAMIC SHAPE OPTIMIZATIONS; CASCADE FLOWS; DESIGN VARIABLES; DIRECT APPROACHES; DIRECT DIFFERENTIATION METHODS; DIRECT DIFFERENTIATIONS; ENTROPY GENERATIONS; FIELD INTEGRALS; HESSIAN MATRICES; INVERSE DESIGNS; OBJECTIVE FUNCTIONS; OPTIMIZATION SCHEMES; QUASI NEWTONS; SECOND ORDERS; SECOND-ORDER SENSITIVITIES; SENSITIVITY EXPRESSIONS; SOLID WALLS; TOTAL PRESSURES; VISCOUS LOSS;

AERODYNAMICS; DISTRIBUTION FUNCTIONS; FUNCTIONS; INVERSE PROBLEMS;

SHAPE OPTIMIZATION;

EID: 67349240444     PISSN: 11343060     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s11831-008-9025-y     Document Type: Article

References (128)

1. Lighthill MJ (1945) A new method of two-dimensional aerodynamic design. Aeronautical Research Council
2. McFadden GB (1979) An artificial viscosity method for the design of supercritical airfoils. New York University Report C00-3077-158
3. Davis L (1991) Handbook of genetic algorithms. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York
4. Michalewicz Z (1994) Genetic algorithms + data structures = evolution programs, 2nd edn. Springer, Berlin
5. Bäck T (1996) Evolutionary algorithms in theory and practice. Evolution strategies, evolutionary programming, genetic algorithms. Oxford University Press, Oxford
6. Bäck T (1996) Evolutionary algorithms in theory and practice. Oxford University Press, Oxford
7. Bertsekas DP (1996) Constrained optimization and Lagrange multiplier methods, 1st edn. Athena Scientific, Nashua
8. Bertsekas DP (1999) Nonlinear programming, 2nd edn. Athena Scientific, Nashua
9. Gill PE, Murray W, Wright MH (1981) Practical optimization. Academic, New York
10. Luenberger DG (2003) Linear and nonlinear programming, 2nd edn. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht
11. Fletcher R (1988) Practical methods of optimization, 2nd edn. Wiley, New York
12. Y Jin 2003 A comprehensive survey of fitness approximation in evolutionary computation Soft Comput 9 3 12
13. GG Wang S Shan 2006 Review of metamodelling techniques in support of engineering design optimization Trans ASME, J Mech Des 129 4 370 380
14. El-Beltagy MA, Nair PB, Keane AJ (1999) Metamodeling techniques for evolutionary optimization of computationally expensive problems: Promises and limitations. In: GECCO99, genetic and evolutionary computation conference, Orlando, July 1999
15. K Giannakoglou 2002 Design of optimal aerodynamic shapes using stochastic optimization methods and computational intelligence Int Rev J Prog Aerosp Sci 38 43 76 (Pubitemid 34201146)
16. Lions JL (1971) Optimal control of systems governed by partial differential equations. Springer, New York
17. O Pironneau 1974 On optimum design in fluid mechanics J Fluid Mech 64 97 110
18. Pironneau O (1984) Optimal shape design for elliptic systems. Springer, New York
19. A Jameson 1988 Aerodynamic design via control theory J Sci Comput 3 233 260
20. Jameson A, Reuther J (1994) Control theory based airfoil design using the Euler equations. AIAA Paper 94-4272
21. Jameson A (1995) Optimum aerodynamic design using CFD and control theory. AIAA Paper 95-1729
22. A Jameson N Pierce L Martinelli 1998 Optimum aerodynamic design using the Navier-Stokes equations Theor Comput Fluid Dyn 10 213 237 (Pubitemid 128368364)
23. WK Anderson E Nielsen 2001 Sensitivity analysis for Navier-Stokes equations on unstructured grids using complex variables AIAA J 39 31 56 63
24. Lyness JN, Moler CB (1967) Numerical differentiation of analytic functions. In: ACM 22nd national conference
25. Martins R, Kroo IM, Alonso J (2000) An automated method for sensitivity analysis using complex variables. AIAA Paper 2000-0689
26. W Squire G Trapp 1998 Using complex variables to estimate derivatives of real functions SIAM Rev 10 1 110 112 (Pubitemid 128628446)
27. Newman JC, Anderson WK, Whitfield DL (1998) Multidisciplinary sensitivity derivatives using complex variables. Tech Rep MSSU-COE-ERC-98-08
28. Nielsen EJ, Kleb WL (2005) Efficient construction of discrete adjoint operators on unstructured grids by using complex variables. AIAA Paper 2005-0324
29. F Courty A Dervieux B Koobus L Hascoët 2003 Reverse automatic differentiation for optimum design: from adjoint state assembly to gradient computation Optim Methods Softw 18 5 615 627
30. Griewank A (1989) On automatic differentiation. In: Mathematical programming: recent developments and applications. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht
31. Hovland P, Mohammadi B, Bischof C (1997) Automatic differentiation of Navier-Stokes computations. Technical Report MCS-P687-0997, Argonne National Laboratory
32. Juedes D (1991) A taxonomy of automatic differentiation tools. In: Automatic differentiation of algorithms: theory, implementation, and application. SIAM, Philadelphia, pp 315-329
33. Bischof C, Carle A, Corliss G, Griewank A, Hovland P (1991) ADIFOR Generating derivative codes from Fortran programs. Report CRPC-TR91185-S, Center for Research and Parallel Computation, Rice University
34. R Giering T Kaminski 1998 Recipes for adjoint code construction ACM Trans Math Softw 24 437 474 (Pubitemid 128447709)
35. Berz M (1990) The DA precompiler DAFOR. Technical Report, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA
36. Horwedel J (1991) GRESS a preprocessor for sensitivity studies of Fortran programs. AIAA Paper 91-005
37. C Faure 2005 An automatic differentiation platform: Odyssée Future Gener Comput Syst 21 8 1391 1400
38. Stephens B (1991) Automatic differentiation as a general-purpose numerical tool. PhD thesis, School of Mathematics, University of Bristol, UK
39. Shiriaev D, Griewank A, Utke J (1996) A user guide to ADOL-F: automatic differentiation of Fortran codes. IOKOMO-04-1995
40. A Rhodin 1997 IMAS-integrated modeling and analysis system for the solution of optimal control problems Comput Phys Commun 107 21 38 (Pubitemid 127381500)
41. B Christianson 1992 Automatic Hessians by reverse accumulation J Numer Anal 12 135 150
42. Bischof C, Roh L, Mauer-Oats A (1997) ADIC An extensible automatic differentiation tool for ANSI-C. Preprint ANL/MCS-P626-1196, Argonne National Laboratory
43. A Griewank D Juedes H Mitev J Utke O Vogel A Walther 1996 ADOL-C: a package for the automatic differentiation of algorithms written in C/C++ ACM Trans Math Softw 22 2 131 167 (Pubitemid 126418651)
44. NA Pierce MB Giles 2000 An introduction to the adjoint approach to design Flow Turbul Combust 65 3-4 393 415
45. Nadarajah S, Jameson A (2000) A comparison of the continuous and discrete adjoint approach to automatic aerodynamic optimization. AIAA Paper 2000-0667
46. Nadarajah S, Jameson A (2001) Studies of the continuous and discrete adjoint approaches to viscous automatic aerodynamic shape optimization. AIAA Paper 2001-2530
47. Spalart PR, Allmaras SR (1994) A one-equation turbulence model for aerodynamic flows. Rech Aerosp (1):5-21
48. P Roe 1981 Approximate Riemann solvers, parameter vectors, and difference schemes J Comput Phys 43 357 371
49. DI Papadimitriou KC Giannakoglou 2007 A continuous adjoint method with objective function derivatives based on boundary integrals for inviscid and viscous flows J Comput Fluids 36 325 341 (Pubitemid 44689205)
50. Anderson WK, Venkatakrishnan V (1997) Aerodynamic design optimization on unstructured grids with a continuous adjoint formulation. AIAA Paper 97-0643
51. WK Anderson V Venkatakrishnan 1997 Aerodynamic design optimization on unstructured grids with a continuous adjoint formulation Comput Fluids 28 443 480
52. VG Asouti AS Zymaris DI Papadimitriou KC Giannakoglou 2008 Continuous and discrete adjoint approaches for aerodynamic shape optimization with low Mach number preconditioning Int J Numer Methods Fluids 57 1485 1504
53. Arian E, Salas MD (1997) Admitting the inadmissible: adjoint formulation for incomplete cost functionals in aerodynamic optimization. NASA/CR-97-206269, ICASE Report No 97-69
54. Baysal O, Ghayour K (2001) Continuous adjoint sensitivities for optimization with general cost functionals on unstructured meshes. AIAA J 39(1)
55. Jameson A, Kim S (2003) Reduction of the adjoint gradient formula in the continous limit. AIAA Paper 2003-0040
56. Denton JD (1993) Loss mechanisms in turbomachines. ASME Paper 93-GT-435
57. Davies MRD, O'Donnell FK, Niven AJ (2000) Turbine blade entropy generation rate, part I: the boundary layer defined. ASME Paper 2000-GT-265
58. O'Donnell FK, Davies MRD (2000) Turbine blade entropy generation rate, part II: the measured loss. ASME Paper 2000-GT-266
59. Papadimitriou DI, Giannakoglou KC (2006) Compressor blade optimization using a continuous adjoint formulation. ASME TURBO EXPO, GT2006/90466, Barcelona
60. DI Papadimitriou KC Giannakoglou 2007 Total pressure losses minimization in turbomachinery cascades, using a new continuous adjoint formulation Proc Inst Mech Eng, Part A: J Power Energy 222 6 865 872 (Pubitemid 47603761)
61. Papadimitriou DI, Zymaris AS, Giannakoglou KC (2005) Discrete and continuous adjoint formulations for turbomachinery applications. In: UROGEN 2005, international conference proceedings, Munich, September 2005
62. Papadimitriou DI, Giannakoglou KC (2006) A continuous adjoint method for the minimization of losses in cascade viscous flows. AIAA Paper 2006-0049
63. Kim SK, Alonso JJ, Jameson A (2000) Two-dimensional high-lift aerodynamic optimization using the continuous adjoint method. AIAA Paper 2000-4741
64. Kim SK, Alonso JJ, Jameson A (2002) Design optimization of high-lift configurations using a viscous continuous adjoint method. AIAA Paper 2002-0844
65. Leoviriyakit K, Jameson A (2003) Aerodynamic shape optimization of wings including planform variations. AIAA Paper 2003-0210
66. Leoviriyakit K, Kim S, Jameson A (2003) Viscous aerodynamic shape optimization of wings including planform variations. AIAA Paper 2003-3498
67. Leoviriyakit K, Kim S, Jameson A (2004) Aero-structural wing planform optimization using the Navier-Stokes equations. AIAA Paper 2004-4479
68. Leoviriyakit K, Jameson A (2005) Multi-point wing planform optimization via control theory. AIAA Paper 2005-0450
69. Giles MB, Pierce NA (1997) Adjoint equations in CFD: duality, boundary conditions and solution behaviour. AIAA Paper 97-1850
70. Giles MB, Pierce NA (1998) On the properties of solutions of the adjoint Euler equations. In: 6th ICFD conference on numerical methods for fluid dynamics, Oxford, UK, 1998
71. Harbeck M, Jameson A (2005) Exploring the limits of transonic shock-free airfoil design. AIAA Paper 2005-1041
72. J Reuther JJ Alonso MJ Rimlinger A Jameson 1999 Aerodynamic shape optimization of supersonic aircraft configurations via an adjoint formulation on distributed memory parallel computers Comput Fluids 28 675 700 (Pubitemid 29346203)
73. Nadarajah S, Kim SK, Jameson A, Alonso JJ (2002) Sonic boom reduction using an adjoint method for supersonic transport aircraft configuration. In: Symposium transsonicum IV, international union of theoretical and applied mechanics, September 2-6, 2002, DLR Gottingen, Germany
74. Nadarajah S, Jameson A, Alonso JJ (2002) Sonic boom reduction using an adjoint method for wing-body configurations in supersonic flow. AIAA Paper 2002-5547
75. Alonso JJ, Kroo IM, Jameson A (2002) Advanced algorithms for design and optimization of quiet supersonic platform. AIAA Paper 2002-0144
76. Nadarajah S, Jameson A, Alonso JJ (2002) An adjoint method for the calculation of remote sensitivities in supersonic flow. AIAA Paper 2002-0261
77. Taasan S, Kuruvila G, Salas MD (1992) Aerodynamic design and optimization in one-shot. AIAA Paper 91-005
78. Kuruvila G, Taasan S, Salas MD (1995) Airfoil design and optimization by the one-shot method. AIAA Paper 95-0478
79. Hazra SB (2004) An efficient method for aerodynamic shape optimization. AIAA Paper 2004-4628
80. S Hazra V Schulz J Brezillon N Gauger 2005 Aerodynamic shape optimization using simultaneous pseudo-timestepping J Comput Phys 204 1 46 64 (Pubitemid 40305777)
81. SB Hazra V Schulz 2006 Simultaneous pseudo-timestepping for aerodynamic shape optimization problems with state constraints SIAM J Sci Comput 28 3 1078 1099 (Pubitemid 46785416)
82. C Held A Dervieux 2002 One-shot airfoil optimisation without adjoint Comput Fluids 31 1015 1049
83. A Dadone B Grossman 2000 Progressive optimization of inverse fluid dynamic design problems Comput Fluids 29 1 32
84. A Dadone B Grossman 2003 Fast convergence of inviscid fluid dynamic design problems Comput Fluids 32 607 627 (Pubitemid 36175088)
85. Soto O, Lohner R (2004) On the computation of flow sensitivities from boundary integrals. AIAA Paper 04-0112
86. Jameson A, Shankaran S, Martinelli L (2003) A continuous adjoint method for unstructured grids. AIAA Paper 2003-3955
87. Kim S, Leoviriyakit K, Jameson A (2003) Aerodynamic shape and planform optimization of wings using a viscous reduced adjoint gradient formula. In: 2nd MIT conference on computational fluid and solid mechanics, Cambridge, MA, June 17-20, 2003
88. Othmer C, de Villiers E, Weller HG (2007) Implementation of a continuous adjoint for topology optimization of ducted flows. AIAA Paper 2007-3947
89. Mohammadi B, Pironneau O (2001) Applied shape optimization for fluids. Clarendon, Oxford
90. B Mohammadi O Pironneau 2004 Shape optimization in fluid mechanics Annu Rev Fluid Mech 36 255 279 (Pubitemid 38381912)
91. O Soto R Lohner 2001 CFD shape optimization using an incomplete-gradient adjoint formulation Int J Numer Methods Fluids 51 735 753 (Pubitemid 32575756)
92. Soto O, Lohner R (2000) CFD optimization using an incomplete-gradient adjoint approach. AIAA Paper 00-0666
93. Soto O, Lohner R (2000) CFD shape optimization using an incomplete-gradient adjoint approach. In: ECCOMAS, Barcelona, September 2000
94. Soto O, Lohner R (2001) General methodologies for incompressible flow design problems. AIAA Paper 01-1061
95. Soto O, Lohner R (2002) A mixed adjoint formulation for incompressible rans problems. AIAA Paper 02-0451
96. Kim HJ, Sasaki D, Obayashi S, Nakahashi K (2001) Aerodynamic optimization of supersonic transport wing using unstructured adjoint method. AIAA J 39(6)
97. Nielsen EJ, Park MA (2005) Using an adjoint approach to eliminate mesh sensitivities in computational design. AIAA Paper 2005-0491
98. Mavriplis DJ (2005) Formulation and multigrid solution of the discrete adjoint for optimization problems on unstructured meshes. AIAA Paper
99. Mavriplis DJ (2006) A discrete adjoint-based approach for optimization problems on three-dimensional unstructured meshes. AIAA Paper
100. EJ Nielsen WK Anderson 2002 Recent improvements in aerodynamic design optimization on unstructured meshes AIAA J 40 6 1155 1163 (Pubitemid 34648448)
101. Nielsen EJ, Anderson WK (2001) Recent improvements in aerodynamic design optimization on unstructured meshes. AIAA Paper 2001-0596
102. Elliot J, Peraire J (1996) Aerodynamic design using unstructured meshes. AIAA Paper 96-1941
103. Elliot J, Peraire J (1997) Aerodynamic optimization using unstructured meshes with viscous effects. AIAA Paper 97-1849
104. J Elliot J Peraire 1997 Practical 3d aerodynamic design and optimization using unstructured meshes AIAA J 35 9 1479 1485 (Pubitemid 127543086)
105. Pulliam TH, Nemec M, Holst TL, Zingg DW (2003) Comparison of genetic and adjoint methods for multi-objective viscous airfoil optimizations. AIAA Paper 2003-0298
106. J Elliot J Peraire 1998 Constrained, multipoint shape optimisation for complex 3d configurations Aeronaut J 102 1017 365 376 (Pubitemid 128548434)
107. JRRA Martins JJ Alonso JJ Reuther 2005 A coupled-adjoint sensitivity analysis method for high-fidelity aero-structural design Optim Eng 6 1 33 62
108. Leoviriyakit K, Jameson A (2004) Case studies in aero-structural wing planform and section optimization. AIAA Paper 2004-5372
109. Leoviriyakit K, Jameson A (2004) Aero-structural wing planform optimization. AIAA Paper 2004-0029
110. Nadarajah S, Jameson A (2002) Optimal control of unsteady flows using a time accurate method. AIAA Paper 2002-5436
111. Nadarajah S, McMullen M, Jameson A (2002) Non-linear frequency domain based optimum shape design for unsteady three-dimensional flow. AIAA Paper 2002-2838
112. Nadarajah S, Jameson A (2002) Optimum shape design for unsteady three-dimensional viscous flows using a non-linear frequency domain method. AIAA Paper 2002-2838
113. Campobasso MS, Duta MC, Giles MB (2001) Adjoint methods for turbomachinery design. In: ISOABE conference, 2001
114. MC Duta MB Giles MS Campobasso 2002 The harmonic adjoint approach to unsteady turbomachinery design Int J Numer Meth Fluids 40 3-4 323 332
115. Campobasso MS, Duta MC, Giles MB (2003) Adjoint calculation of sensitivities of turbomachinery objective functions. AIAA J Propuls Power 19(4)
116. Giannakoglou KC, Papadimitriou DI (2006) Formulation and application of the continuous adjoint method in aerodynamics and turbomachinery. Von-Karman institute lecture series
117. Anderson WK, Bonhaus DL (1997) Aerodynamic design on unstructured grids for turbulent flows. NASA Technical Memorandum
118. WK Anderson DL Bonhaus 1999 Airfoil design on unstructured grids for turbulent flows AIAA J 37 2 185 191
119. EJ Nielsen J Lu MA Park DL Darmofal 2004 An implicit exact dual adjoint solution method for turbulent flows on unstructured grids Comput Fluids 33 1131 1155 (Pubitemid 38653508)
120. LL Sherman AC Taylor III LL Green PA Newman GW Hou VM Korivi 1996 First- and second-order aerodynamic sensitivity derivatives via automatic differentiation with incremental iterative methods J Comput Phys 129 307 331 (Pubitemid 126164762)
121. DI Papadimitriou KC Giannakoglou 2007 Direct, adjoint and mixed approaches for the computation of Hessian in airfoil design problems Int J Numer Methods Fluids 56 1929 1943
122. DI Papadimitriou KC Giannakoglou 2007 Computation of the Hessian matrix in aerodynamic inverse design using continuous adjoint formulations Comput Fluids 37 1029 1039
123. D Tortorelli P Michaleris 1994 Design sensitivity analysis: overview and review Inverse Probl Eng 1 1 71 105
124. GW Hou J Sheen 1993 Numerical methods for second-order shape sensitivity analysis with applications to heat conduction problems Int J Numer Methods Eng 36 417 435 (Pubitemid 23657785)
125. FX Le Dimet IM Navon DN Daescu 2002 Second-order information in data assimilation Mon Weather Rev 130 3 629 648
126. F Veerse D Auroux M Fisher 2000 Limited-memory BFGS diagonal preconditioners for a data assimilation problem in meteorology Optim Eng 1 323 339
127. DN Daescu IM Navon 2003 An analysis of a hybrid optimization method for variational data assimilation Int J Comput Fluid Dyn 17 4 299 306 (Pubitemid 36973347)
128. E Arian S Taasan 1999 Analysis of the Hessian for aerodynamic optimization: inviscid flow Comput Fluids 28 7 853 877 (Pubitemid 29396060)