Analysis methods in neutron and X-ray reflectometry

Current Opinion in Colloid and Interface Science

Volumn 4, Issue 3, 1999, Pages 197-204

  Lovell, M R ^a   Richardson, R M ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Anomalous reflection; Bayes' theorem; Genetic algorithm; Magnetic reference layer; Neutron reflection; X ray reflection

Indexed keywords

ALGORITHM; BAYES THEOREM; MATHEMATICAL MODEL; NEUTRON SCATTERING; REFLECTOMETRY; REVIEW; ROENTGEN SPECTROSCOPY;

EID: 0032826757     PISSN: 13590294     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/S1359-0294(99)00039-4     Document Type: Article

References (49)

1. Pershan P.S. X-ray or neutron reflectivity: Limitations in the determination of interfacial profiles. Phys Rev E. 50:1994;2369-2372.
2. Zhou X.-L., Chen S.-H. Model-independent method for reconstruction of scattering-density profiles using neutron or X-ray reflectivity data. Phys Rev E. 47:1993;3174-3190.
3. Zhou X.-L., Chen S.-H. Theoretical foundation of X-ray and neutron reflectometry. Phys Rep. 257:1995;223-348.
4. Lee E.M., Milnes J.E., Wong I.C. The simultaneous analysis of multi-contrast neutron and X-ray grazing incidence reflection data from amphiphilic layers. Physica B. 221:1996;159-167.
5. Lu J.R., Li Z.X., Smallwood J., Thomas R.K. Detailed structure of the hydrocarbon chain in a surfactant monolayer at the air-water interface: neutron reflection from hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide. J Phys Chem. 99:1995;8233-8243.
6. Li Z.X., Lu J.R., Styrkas D.A., Thomas R.K. The structure of the surface of ethanol-water mixtures. Mol Phys. 80:1993;925-939.
7. Regan M.J., Magnussen O.M., Kawamoto E.H. et al. X-ray studies of atomic layering at liquid metal surfaces. J Non-Cryst Solids. 205-207:1996;762-766.
8. Sferrazza M., Xiao C., Jones R.A.L., Bucknall D.G., Webster J., Penfold J. Evidence for capillary waves at immiscible polymer/polymer interfaces. Phys Rev Lett. 78:1997;3693-3696.
9. Voorma HJ, Louis E, Koster NB, Bijkerk F, Spiller E. •Characterisation of multilayers by Fourier analysis of X-ray reflectivity. J Appl Phys 1997;81:6112-6119.The BMFT analysis allows accurate determination of multilayer parameters such as d-spacing, layer densities, interfacial roughness and layer thickness errors. It does not require the additional soft X-ray measurements otherwise needed in the classical method and yet yields nearly identical results. It is an extremely useful method as it has a good accuracy and is fast.
10. Chou C.-H. A necessary modification for groove tracking method. Physica B. 233:1997;130-133.
11. Chou C.-H., Regan M.J., Pershan P.S., Zhou X.-L. Model-independent reconstruction of smooth electron density profiles from reflectivity data of liquid surfaces. Phys Rev E. 55:1997;7212-7216.
12. Chou C.-H. Improved smoothing procedures for a smoothed groove tracking method. Physica B. 253:1998;320-324.
13. Pedersen J.S. Model-independent determination of the surface scattering-length density profile from specular reflectivity data. J Appl Cryst. 25:1992;129-145.
14. Pedersen J.S., Hamley I.W. Analysis of neutron and X-ray reflectivity data by constrained least-squares methods. Physica B. 198:1994;16-23.
15. Pedersen J.S., Hamley I.W. Analysis of neutron and X-ray reflectivity data. II. Constrained least-squares methods. J Appl Cryst. 27:1994;36-49.
16. Singh N., Tirrell M., Bates F.S. Applications of Fourier-synthesis to the analysis of specular reflectivity. J Appl Cryst. 26:1993;650-659.
17. Gerstenberg M.C., Pedersen J.S., Smith G.S. Surface induced ordering of micelles at the solid-liquid interface. Phys Rev E. 58:1998;8028-8031.
18. Dewhurst P.F., Lovell M.R., Jones J.L., Richards R.W., Webster J.R.P. Organisation of dispersions of a linear diblock copolymer of polystyrene and poly(ethylene oxide) at the air-water interface. Macromolecules. 31:1998;7851-7864.
19. Asmussen A., Riegler H. Numerical analysis of X-ray reflectivity data from organic thin films at interfaces. J Chem Phys. 104:1996;8159-8164.
20. Sanyal M.K., Basu J.K., Datta A., Banerjee S. Determination of small fluctuations in electron density profiles of thin films: layer formation in a polystyrene film. Europhys Lett. 36:1996;265270.
21. 0 but recent results have indicated that it is actually the scattering from the fluctuation that needs to be small with respect to the scattering from the strongest scattering interface, which is usually the air-film or film-substrate interface.
22. -9 are possible.
23. Karim A., Felcher G.P., Russell T.P. Interdiffusion of polymers at short times. Macromolecules. 27:1994;6973-6979.
24. Lee D.R., Park Y.J., Kim D., Jeong Y.H., Lee K.-B. Non-specular X-ray reflectivity study of partially correlated interface roughness of a Mo/Si multilayer. Phys Rev B. 57:1998;8786-8789.
25. Richardson R.M., Webster J.R.P. Zarbakhsh: study of off-specular neutron reflectivity using a model system. J Appl Cryst. 30:1997;943-947.
26. Holý V., Giannini C., Tapfer L., Marschner T., Stolz W. Diffuse X-ray reflection from multilayers with stepped interfaces. Phys Rev B. 55:1997;9960-9968.
27. Kepa H., Kleinwaks L.J., Berk N.F., Majkrzak C.F., Berzina T.S., Troitsky V.I., Antolini R., Feigin L.A. Neutron and X-ray reflectometry studies of rough interfaces in a Langmuit-Blodgett film. Physica B. 241:1998;1048-1054.
28. Tang C.C., Telling N.D., Langridge S. Synchrotron X-ray reflectivity study of Co/Cu multilayer structure. Physica B. 248:1998;395-398.
29. Samoilenko I.I., Shchedrin B.M., Feigin L.A. Global minimisation in reconstruction of the scattering-length density profile by X-ray reflectivity data. Physica B. 221:1996;542-546.
30. Geoghegan M., Jones R.A.L., Sivia D.S., Penfold J., Clough A.S. Experimental study of surface aggregation and wetting in films of a partially miscible polymer blend. Phys Rev E. 53:1996;825-837.
31. Bucknall D.G., Butler S.A., Hermes H.E., Higgins J.S. Neutron reflectivity investigations of semi-crystalline polymer interfaces. Physica B. 241-243:1998;1071-1073.
32. Sivia D.S., David W.I.F., Knight K.S. An introduction to Bayesian model selection. Physica D. 66:1993;234-242.
33. 2 minimisation, and can improve matters significantly when such procedures fail. Moreover it can help in designing the optimum experiment to perform and this is demonstrated in terms of PSF analysis. This is a powerful method that can be used to address many aspects of reflectometry at both practical and theoretical levels.
34. Sivia D.S., Hamilton W.A., Smith G.S. Analysis of neutron reflectivity data: maximum entropy, Bayesian spectral analysis and speckle holography. Physica B. 173:1991;121-138.
35. Kunz K., Reiter J., Götzelmann A., Stamm M. Model-free analysis of neutron reflectivity data from polymer thin films with the simulated annealing technique. Macromolecules. 26:1993;4316-4323.
36. de Hann V.-O. Drijkoningen: genetic algorithms used in model finding and fitting for neutron reflection experiments. Physica B. 198:1994;24-26.
37. Dane AD, Veldhuis A, de Boer DKG, Leenaers AJG, Buydens LMC. ••Application of genetic algorithms for characterisation of thin layered materials by glancing incidence X-ray reflectometry. Physica B 1998;253:254-268.The genetic algorithm was used to obtain thicknesses and roughness for several thin film materials and was able to find an exact answer in 61% of simulated experiments in a single run. The method is capable of reducing human effort and experience and lessens the chance of missing feasible solutions. Results for experimental data were encouraging but highlighted the need for external knowledge about the system under study in order to reduce the unknown parameter ranges and hence provide more accurate solutions. This method provides a useful alternative to analytical free-form methods.
38. Li Z.X., Thirtle P.N., Weller A., Thomas R.K., Penfold J., Webster J.R.P., Rennie A.R. Some improvements and extensions of the application of specular neutron reflection to the study of interfaces. Physica B. 248:1998;171-183.
39. Penfold J., Staples E.J., Tucker I., Thompson L.J., Thomas R.K. The structure and composition of mixed cationic and non-ionic surfactant layers adsorbed at the hydrophilic silicon surface. Physica B. 248:1998;223-228.
40. Sanyal M.K., Sinha S.K., Gibaud A. et al. Fourier reconstruction of density profiles of thin films using anomalous X-ray reflectivity. Europhys Lett. 21:1993;691-696.
41. 3, Fe K and 6.95 keV, the latter being far away from Gd and Fe edges. This strategy enabled element-specific atomic density profiles of Gd and Fe to be obtained unambiguously. Furthermore, X-ray resonant magnetic scattering measurements showed that Gd was magnetised at room temperature. This work is an elegant demonstration of the anomalous scattering technique and shows the breadth of information that can be gained from x-ray reflectivity experiments.
42. Penfold J., Webster J.R.P., Bucknall D.G., Siva D.S. Unique density profile determination in thin films. Colloids Surfaces A: Physicochem Eng Aspects. 86:1994;165-170.
43. Majkrzak C.F., Berk N.F. Exact determination of the phase in neutron reflectometry. Phys Rev B. 52:1995;10827-10830.
44. de Haan V.-O., van Well A.A., Adenwalla S., Felcher G.P. Retrieval of phase information in neutron reflectometry. Phys Rev B. 52:1995;10831-10833.
45. de Haan V.-O., van Well A.A., Sacks P.E., Adenwalla S., Felcher G.P. Toward the solution of the inverse problem in neutron reflectometry. Physica B. 221:1996;524-532.
46. Majkrzak C.F., Berk N.F. Exact determination of the neutron reflection amplitude or phase. Physica B. 221:1996;520-523.
47. Majkrzak C.F., Berk N.F., Dura J. et al. Direct inversion of specular reflectometry. Physica B. 241-243:1998;1101-1103.
48. Majkrzak CF, Berk NF, Dura JA, et al. •Phase determination and inversion in specular neutron reflectometry. Physica B 1998;248:338-342.The experimental feasibility of the direct inversion method is tested with two examples, a deuterated polystyrene (dPS) film using Cu, Ni and Mo magnetic reference layers and a symmetric film consisting of a dPS film between non-magnetic media of equal scattering length density. The paper demonstrates the direct inversion method to be practical with existing instrumentation for types of systems not far removed from those currently studied.
49. Lipperheide R., Kasper J., Leeb H., Reiss G. The phase problem in neutron reflection. Physica B. 234-236:1997;1117-1119.