Identifying Viable "Need-Solution Pairs": Problem Solving Without Problem Formulation

Organization Science

Volumn 27, Issue 1, 2016, Pages 207-221

  von Hippel, Eric ^a   von Krogh, Georg ^b  

^a MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (United States)

^b ETH ZURICH   (Switzerland)

Author keywords

Decision making and theory of the firm; Economics and organization; Information transfer costs; Innovation; Knowledge production; Managerial and organizational cognition; Organization and management theory; Organizational economics

Indexed keywords

EID: 84982811723     PISSN: 10477039     EISSN: 15265455     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1287/orsc.2015.1023     Document Type: Article

References (116)

1. Abbott J (2005) Understanding and managing the unknown: The nature of uncertainty in planning. J. Planning Ed. Res. 24(3): 237-251.
2. Adamson RE (1952) Functional fixedness as related to problem solving: A repetition of three experiments. J. Experiment. Psych. 44(4):288-291.
3. Adler PS, Obstfeld D (2007) The role of affect in creative projects and exploratory search. Indust. Corporate Change 16(1):19-50.
4. Allen TJ (1966) Studies of the problem-solving process in engineering design. IIEE Trans. Engrg. Management 13(2):72-83.
5. Allen TJ, Marquis DG (1964) Positive and negative biasing sets: The effects of prior experience on research performance. IEEE Trans. Engrg. Management 11(4):158-161.
6. Altshuller G (1998) 40 Principles: TRIZ Keys to Technical Innovation (Technical Innovation Center, Worcester, MA).
7. Amabile T, Pillmer J (2012) Perspectives on the social psychology of creativity. J. Creative Behav. 46(1):3-15.
8. Amabile T, Barsade SG, Mueller JS, Staw B (2005) Affect and creativity at work. Admin. Sci. Quart. 50(3):367-403.
9. Baer M, Dirks KT, Nickerson JA (2013) Microfoundations of strategic problem formulation. Strategic Management J. 34(2):197-214.
10. Baldwin CY, Clark KB (2000) Design Rules: The Power of Modularity (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
11. Banerjee J (2014) Sir William Henry Perkin and the Coal-Tar Colours. The Victorian Web (August 28), http://www.victorianweb.org/ science/perkin.html.
12. Barrick MR, Mount MK (1991) The big five personality dimensions and job performance: A meta-analysis. Personnel Psych. 44(1):1-26.
13. Bathelt H, Malmberg A, Maskell P (2004) Clusters and knowledge: Local buzz, global pipelines, and the process of knowledge creation. Progress Human Geography 28(1):31-56.
14. Beale R (2007) Supporting serendipity: Using ambient intelligence to augment user exploration for data mining and web browsing. Internat. J. Human-Comput. Stud. 65(5):421-433.
15. Ben-Menahem S, von Krogh G, Erden Z, Schneider A (2015) Coordinating knowledge creation in multidisciplinary teams: Evidence from early-stage drug discovery. Acad. Management J., ePub ahead of print June 16, http://dx.doi.org/10.5465/amj.2013.1214.
16. Birch HG, Rabinowitz HS (1951) The negative effect of previous experience on productive thinking. J. Experiment. Psych. 41(2):121-125.
17. Bourgeois LJ (1979) Toward a method of middle-range theorizing. Acad. Management Rev. 4(3):443-447.
18. Bradley EH, Byam P, Alpern R, Thompson JW, Zerihun A, Abeb Y, Curry LA (2012) A systems approach to improving rural care in Ethiopia. PloS One 7(4):e3402.
19. Brooks PF (1979) The Mythical Man-Month: Essays on Software Engineering (Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA).
20. Campbell DT (1960) Blind variation and selective retentions in creative thought as in other knowledge processes. Psych. Rev. 67(6):380-400.
21. Carruthers JD, Carruthers JA (1992) Treatment of glabellar frown lines with C. botulinum-A exotoxin. J. Dermatologic Surgery Oncology 18(11):17-21.
22. Churchill J, von Hippel E, Sonnack M (2009) Lead user project handbook: A practical guide for lead user project teams. (October 1), http://web.mit.edu/evhippel/www/Lead%20User %20Project%20Handbook%20%28Full%20Version%29.pdf.
23. Cohen MD, March JG, Olsen JP (1972) A garbage can model of organizational choice. Admin. Sci. Quart. 17(1):1-25.
24. Cohendet P, Simon L (2007) Playing across the playground: Paradoxes of knowledge creation in the video game firm. J. Organ. Behav. 28(5):587-605.
25. Conboy K (2009) Agility from first principles: Reconstructing the concept of agility in information systems development. Inform. Systems Res. 20(3):329-354.
26. Connell JL, Shafer LB (1989) Structured Rapid Prototyping (Prentice- Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ).
27. Coondoo A, Sengupta S (2015) Serendipity and its role in dermatology. Indian J. Dermatology 60(2):130-135.
28. Corneil DG (2004) Lexicographic breadth first search-A survey. Hromkovic J, Nagl M, eds. Graph-Theoretical Concepts in Computer Science (Springer, Berlin), 1-19.
29. Cutrell E, Guan Z (2007) What are you looking for? An eye-tracking study of information usage in web search. Proc. SIGCHI Human Factors Comput. Systems (ACM, New York), 407-416.
30. Dane E, Baer M, Pratt MG, Oldham GR (2011) Rational versus intuitive problem solving: How thinking "off the beaten path" can stimulate creativity. Psych. Aesthetics Creativity Arts 5(1):3-12.
31. de Rond M (2014) The structure of serendipity. Culture Organ. 20(5):342-358.
32. de Rond M, Thietart RA (2007) Choice, chance, and inevitability in strategy. Strategic Management J. 28(5):535-551.
33. Denrell J, Fang C, Winter S (2003) The economics of strategic opportunity. Strategic Management J. 24(10):977-990.
34. Duncker K (1945) On problem-solving, trans. Lees LS. Psych. Monographs 58(5):i-113.
35. Emirbayer M, Mische A (1998) What is agency? Amer. J. Sociol. 103(4):962-1023.
36. Felin T, Zenger TR (2012) Open or closed innovation? Problem solving and governance choice. Res. Policy 43(5):914-925.
37. Ferre X, Juristo N, Windl H, Constantine L (2001) Usability basics for software developers. IEEE Software 18(1):22-29.
38. Fioratou E, Cowley SJ (2009) Insightful thinking: Cognitive dynamics and material artifacts. Pragmatics Cognition 17(3):549-572.
39. Fioretti G, Lomi A (2010) Passing the buck in the garbage can model of organizational choice. Comput. Math. Organ. Theory 16(2): 113-143.
40. Fleming L, Sorenson O (2004) Science as a map in technological search. Strategic Management J. 25(8-9):909-928.
41. Foster A, Ford N (2003) Serendipity and information seeking: An empirical study. J. Documentation 59(3):321-340.
42. Garriga H, von Krogh G, Spaeth S (2013) How constraints and knowledge impact open innovation. Strategic Management J. 34(9): 1134-1144.
43. George JM, Zhou J (2001) When openness to experience and conscientiousness are related to creative behavior: An interactional approach. J. Appl. Psych. 86(3):513-524.
44. Ghemawat P, Levinthal D (2008) Choice interactions and business strategy. Management Sci. 54(9):1638-1651.
45. Glaser BG, Strauss AL (1967) The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research (Aldine Publishing, Chicago).
46. Greiner R (1996) PALO: A probabilistic hill-climbing algorithm. Artificial Intelligence 84(1-2):177-208.
47. Greiner R, Hayward R, Jankowska M, Molloy M (2006) Finding optimal satisficing strategies for and-or trees. Artificial Intelligence 170(1):19-58.
48. Gronbaek K (1989) Rapid prototyping with fourth generation systems: An empirical study. Office: Tech. People 5(2):105-125.
49. Hamilton LA (2003) The Political Philosophy of Needs (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK).
50. Hatchuel A, Weil B (2002) C-K Theory: Notions and applications of a unified design theory. Proc. Herbert Simon Internat. Conf. Design Sci., Lyon, 15-16 March.
51. Hsieh C, Nickerson JA, Zenger TR (2007) Opportunity discovery, problem solving and a theory of the entrepreneurial firm. J. Management Stud. 44(7):1255-1277.
52. Hui SK, Fader PS, Bradlow ET (2009) Path data in marketing: An integrative framework and prospectus for model building. Marketing Sci. 28(2):320-335.
53. International Electrotechnical Commission (2006) Fault Tree Analysis (FTA), International Standard IEC 61025, 2nd ed. (IEC, Geneva).
54. Ishikawa K (1968) Guide to Quality Control (JUSE, Tokyo).
55. Ishikawa K (1976) Guide to Quality Control (Asian Productivity Organization, Tokyo).
56. Jeppesen LB, Lakhani KR (2010) Marginality and problem-solving effectiveness in broadcast search. Organ. Sci. 21(5):1016-1033.
57. Koestler A (1964) The Act of Creation (Macmillan, New York).
58. Krumholz HM, Curry LA, Bradley EH (2011) Survival after acute myocardial infarction (SAMI) study: The design and implementation of a positive deviance study. Amer. Heart J. 162(6): 981-987.
59. Kurup U, Bignoli PG, Scally JR, Cassimatis NL (2011) An architectural framework for complex cognition. Cognitive Systems Res. 12(3-4):281-292.
60. Lakhani KR, Lifshitz-Assaz H, Tushman ML (2013) Open innovation and organizational boundaries: The impact of task decomposition and knowledge distribution on the locus of innovation. Grandori A, ed. Handbook of Economic Organization: Integrating Economic and Organization Theory (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, UK), 355-382.
61. Laursen K, Salter A (2006) Open for innovation: The role of openness in explaining innovation performance among U.K. manufacturing firms. Strategic Management J. 27(2):131-150.
62. Le Masson P, Weil B, Hatchuel A (2010) Strategic Management of Innovation and Design (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK).
63. Levinthal D, Posen HE (2007) Myopia of selection: Does organizational adaptation limit the efficacy of population selection? Admin. Sci. Quart. 52(4):586-620.
64. Liang RH (2012) Designing for unexpected encounters with digital products: Case studies of serendipity as felt experience. Internat. J. Design 6(1):41-58.
65. Lilien GL, Morrison PD, Searls K, Sonnack M, von Hippel E (2002) Performance assessment of the lead user idea generation process. Management Sci. 48(8):1042-1059.
66. Luchins AS (1942) Mechanization in problem solving: The effect of Einstellung. Psych. Monographs 54(6):i-95.
67. Lyles MA, Mitroff II (1980) Organizational problem formulation: An empirical study. Admin. Sci. Quart. 25(1):102-119.
68. MacDuffie JP (1997) The road to "root cause": Shop-floor problemsolving at three auto assembly plants. Management Sci. 43(4): 479-502.
69. Makri S, Blandford A, Woods M, Sharples S, Maxwell D (2014) "Making my own luck": Serendipity strategies and how to support them in digital information environments. J. Assoc. Inform. Sci. Tech. 65(11):2179-2194.
70. March JG, Simon HA (1958) Organizations (Wiley, New York).
71. Marengo L, Dosi G, Legrenzi P, Pasquali C (2000) The structure of problem-solving knowledge and the structure of organizations. Indust. Corporate Change 9(4):757-788.
72. Marples DL (1961) The decisions of engineering design. IRE Trans. Engrg. Management 8(2):55-71.
73. Martinsen O (2011) The creative personality: A synthesis and development of the creative person profile. Creativity Res. J. 23(3): 185-202.
74. McCrae RR, Costa PT (1985) Comparison of EPI and psychoticism scales with measures of the five-factor model of personality. Personality Individual Differences 6(5):587-597.
75. Merton RK (1968) Social Theory and Social Structure (Free Press, New York).
76. Merton RK, Barber E (2004) The Travels and Adventures of Serendipity: A Study in Sociological Semantics and the Sociology of Science (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
77. Mintzberg H, Raisinghani D, Theoret A (1976) The structure of "unstructured" decision processes. Admin. Sci. Quart. 21(2): 246-275.
78. Nelson RR (2008) Bounded rationality, cognitive maps, and trial and error learning. J. Econom. Behav. Organ. 67(1):78-89.
79. Novick LR, Sherman SJ (2003) On the nature of insight solutions: Evidence from skill differences in anagram solution. Quart. J. Experiment. Psych. A 56(2):351-382.
80. Ohlsson S (1984) Restructuring revisited. Scandinavian J. Psych. 25(2):65-78.
81. Padgett JF (1980) Managing garbage can hierarchies. Admin. Sci. Quart. 25(4):583-604.
82. Penin J, Burger-Helmchen T (2012) Crowdsourcing d'activités inventives et frontières des organisations. Management Internat. 16:101-112.
83. Pich M, Loch C, De Meyer A (2002) On uncertainty, ambiguity, and complexity in project management. Management Sci. 48(8):1008-1023.
84. Raymond ES (1999) The Cathedral and the Bazaar: Musings on Linux and Open Source by an Accidental Revolutionary (O'Reilly Media Inc., Sebastopol, CA).
85. Rittel HWJ, Webber MM (1973) Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sci. 4(2):155-169.
86. Sadow BD (1972) Rolling luggage. U.S. Patent 3,653,474, filed February 16, 1970, and issued April 4, 1972.
87. Schon DA (1983) The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action (Basic Books, New York).
88. Schwenk C, Thomas H (1983) Formulating the mess: The role of decision aids in problem formulation. Omega 11(3):239-252.
89. Sharkey J (2010) Reinventing the suitcase by adding the wheel. Bus. Day: New York Times (October 4), http://www.nytimes.com/ 2010/10/05/business/05road.html.
90. Sieg JH (2012) Problems on the Boundary: Involving External Service Providers in Organizational Problem Formulation. Ph.D. dissertation, ETH No. 20285, ETH, Zurich.
91. Simon HA (1973) The structure of ill-structured problems. Artificial Intelligence 4(3-4):181-201.
92. Simon HA (1977) Models of Discovery and Other Topics in the Methods of Science, Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science (D. Reidel, Dordrecht, Netherlands).
93. Simon HA (1978) On how to decide what to do. Bell J. Econom. 9(2):494-507.
94. Simon HA (1979) Models of Thought (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT).
95. Simon HA, Simon PA (1962) Trial and error search in solving difficult problems: Evidence from the game of chess. Behav. Sci. 7(4):425-429.
96. Smith RP, Eppinger SD (1997) Identifying controlling features of engineering design iteration. Management Sci. 43(3):276-293.
97. Spradlin W (2012) Are you solving the right problem? Harvard Bus. Rev. 90(9):85-93.
98. Szulanski G (1996) Exploring internal stickiness: Impediments to the transfer of best practice within the firm. Strategic Management J. 17(S2):27-43.
99. ter Hark M (2010) Psychology of thinking before the cognitive revolution: Otto Seltz on problems, schemas, and creativity. History Psychology 13(1):2-24.
100. Terwiesch C, Loch CH, De Meyer A (2002) Exchanging preliminary information in concurrent engineering: Alternative coordination strategies. Organ. Sci. 13(4):402-419.
101. Thomke SH (1998) Managing experimentation in the design of new products. Management Sci. 44(6):743-762.
102. Thomke SH (2003) Experimentation Matters: Unlocking the Potential of New Technologies for Innovation (Harvard Business School Press, Boston).
103. Thomke SH, Fujimoto T (2000) The effect of "front-loading" problem-solving on product development performance. J. Product Innovation Management 17(2):128-142.
104. Tyre MJ, von Hippel E (1997) The situated nature of adaptive learning in organizations. Organ. Sci. 8(1):71-83.
105. Van Andel P (1994) Anatomy of the unsought finding. Serendipity: Origin, history, domains, traditions, appearances, patterns and programmability. British J. Philos. Sci. 45(2):631-648.
106. Volkema RJ (1983) Problem formulation in planning and design. Management Sci. 29(6):639-652.
107. von Hippel E (1986) Lead users: A source of novel product concepts. Management Sci. 32(7):791-805.
108. von Hippel E (1994) "Sticky information" and the locus of problem solving: Implications for innovation. Management Sci. 40(4):429-439.
109. von Hippel E (2005) Democratizing Innovation (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
110. von Hippel E, Tyre MJ (1996a) The mechanics of learning by doing: Problem discovery during process machine use. Technology and Culture 37(2):312-329.
111. von Hippel E, Tyre MJ (1996b) How learning by doing is done: Problem identification in novel process equipment. Res. Policy 24(1):1-12.
112. von Krogh G, Haefliger S, Spaeth S, Wallin M (2012) Carrots and rainbows: Motivations and social practice in open source software development. MIS Quart. 36(2):649-676.
113. Wallin MW, von Krogh G, Sieg JH (2013) A "problem in the making": How firms formulate problems for innovation contests. Working paper, ETH Zurich, Zurich.
114. Walpole H (1960) To Mann, Monday 28 January 1754. Lewis WS, ed. The Yale Editions of Horace Walpole's Correspondence, With Sir Horace Mann, IV, Vol. 20 (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT), 407-411.
115. Wertheimer M (1959) Productive Thinking (Harper, New York).
116. Zhao H, Seibert SE (2006) The big five personality dimensions and entrepreneurial status: A meta-analytical review. J. Appl. Psych. 91(2):259-271.