The effects of safety behaviors during exposure therapy for anxiety: Critical analysis from an inhibitory learning perspective

Clinical Psychology Review

Volumn 49, Issue , 2016, Pages 1-15

  Blakey, Shannon M ^a   Abramowitz, Jonathan S ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA   (United States)

Author keywords

Exposure therapy; Inhibitory learning; Safety behaviors

Indexed keywords

ANXIETY DISORDER; DISTRESS SYNDROME; EXPECTANCY; EXPOSURE THERAPY; HEALTH BEHAVIOR; HUMAN; INFORMATION PROCESSING; LEARNING; LEARNING THEORY; LIFE THREAT; MEDLINE; PATIENT SAFETY; PERCEPTION; PRIMARY PREVENTION; PSYCHOTHERAPY; PSYCINFO; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; SAFETY BEHAVIOR; SEARCH ENGINE; SELF CONCEPT; SELF CONTROL; SOCIAL ACCEPTANCE; IMPLOSIVE THERAPY; PATHOPHYSIOLOGY; PROCEDURES; STANDARDS;

ANXIETY DISORDERS; HUMANS; IMPLOSIVE THERAPY;

EID: 84979670956     PISSN: 02727358     EISSN: 18737811     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpr.2016.07.002     Document Type: Review

References (106)

1. Abramowitz, J.S., Arch, J.J., Strategies for improving long-term outcomes in cognitive-behavioral therapy for obsessive-compulsive disorder: Insights from learning theory. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice 21 (2014), 20–31.
2. Abramowitz, J.S., Deacon, B.J., Whiteside, S.P., Exposure therapy for anxiety: Principles and practice. 2011, Guilford Press, New York.
3. Abramowitz, J.S., Fabricant, L.E., Taylor, S., Deacon, B.J., McKay, D., Storch, E.A., The relevance of analogue studies for understanding obsessions and compulsions. Clinical Psychology Review 34 (2014), 206–217.
4. Albarracín, D., Editorial. Psychological Bulletin 141 (2015), 1–5.
5. American Psychiatric Association [APA], Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 5th ed., 2013, Author, Washington, DD.
6. Arch, J.J., Craske, M.G., Addressing relapse in cognitive behavioral therapy for panic disorder: Methods for optimizing long-term treatment outcomes. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice 18 (2011), 306–315.
7. Arntz, A., Lavy, E., van den Berg, G., van Rijsoort, S., Negative beliefs of spider phobics: A psychometric evaluation of the spider phobia beliefs questionnaire. Advances in Behaviour Research and Therapy, 15, 1993, 257-227.
8. Arntz, A., Rauner, M., van den Hout, M., “If I feel anxious, there must be danger”: Ex-consequentia reasoning in inferring danger in anxiety disorders. Behaviour Research and Therapy 33 (1995), 917–925.
9. Baker, A., Mystkowski, J., Culver, N., Yi, R., Mortazavi, A., Craske, M.G., Does habituation matter? Emotional processing theory and exposure therapy for acrophobia. Behaviour Research and Therapy 48 (2010), 1139–1143.
10. Bandura, A., Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review 84 (1977), 191–215.
11. Bandura, A., Social foundations of thought and action: A social cognitive. 1986, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
12. Bandura, A., Jeffrey, R.W., Wright, C.L., Efficacy of participant modeling as a function of response induction aids. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 83 (1974), 56–64.
13. Barlow, D.H., Craske, M.G., Mastery of your anxiety and panic (4th Ed.): Workbook. 2007, Oxford University Press, New York.
14. Barlow, D.H., Farchione, T.J., Fairholme, C.P., Ellard, K.K., Boisseau, C.L., Allen, L.B., Ehrenreich-May, J., The unified protocol for transdiagnostic treatment of emotional disorders: Therapist guide. 2011, Oxford University Press, New York, 2011.
15. Beck, T.W., The importance of a priori sample size estimation in strength and conditioning research. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research 27 (2013), 2323–2337.
16. Beesdo-Baum, K., Jenjahn, E., Höfler, M., Lueken, U., Becker, E.S., Hoyer, J., Avoidance, safety behavior, and reassurance seeking in generalized anxiety disorder. Depression and Anxiety 29 (2012), 948–957.
17. Biondi, M., Picardi, A., Attribution of improvement to medication and increased risk of relapse of panic disorder with agoraphobia. Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics 72 (2003), 110–111 (author reply, p. 111).
18. Blakey, S.M., Deacon, B.J., “If a safety aid is present, there must be danger”: The paradoxical effects of hand sanitizer during a contamination exposure task. Journal of Experimental Psychopathology 6 (2015), 264–277.
19. Bouton, M.E., Context, ambiguity, and unlearning: Sources of relapse after behavioral extinction. Biological Psychiatry 52 (2002), 976–986.
20. Bouton, M.E., Context and behavioral processes in extinction. Learning & Memory 11 (2004), 485–494.
21. Burns, D.D., The feeling good handbook: Using the new mood therapy in everyday life. 1989, W. Morrow, New York, NY.
22. Chu, B.C., Colognori, D.B., Yang, G., Xie, M., Bergman, R.L., Piacentini, J., Mediators of exposure therapy for youth obsessive-compulsive disorder: Specificity and temporal sequence of client and treatment factors. Behavior Therapy 46 (2015), 395–408.
23. Clapp, J.D., Olsen, S.A., Beck, J.G., Palyo, S.A., Grant, D.M., Gudmundsdottir, B., Marques, L., The Driving Behavior Survey: Scale construction and validation. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 25 (2011), 96–105.
24. Clark, D.M., Wells, A., A cognitive model of social phobia. Heimberg, R.G., Liebowitz, M.R., Hope, D.A., Schneier, F.R., Heimberg, R.G., Liebowitz, M.R., Schneier, F.R., (eds.) Social phobia: Diagnosis, assessment, and treatment, 1995, Guilford Press, New York, NY, US, 69–93.
25. Coles, M.E., Heimberg, R.G., Memory biases in the anxiety disorders: Current status. Clinical Psychology Review 22 (2002), 587–627.
26. Craske, M.G., Kircanski, K., Zeilkowsky, M., Mystkowski, J., Chowdhury, N., Baker, A., Optimizing inhibitory learning during exposure therapy. Behaviour Research and Therapy 46 (2008), 5–27.
27. Craske, M.G., Treanor, M., Conway, C.C., Zbozinek, T., Vervliet, B., Maximizing exposure therapy: An inhibitory learning approach. Behaviour Research and Therapy 58 (2014), 10–23.
28. de Silva, P., Rachman, S., Does escape behaviour strengthen agoraphobic avoidance—A preliminary study. Behaviour Research and Therapy 22 (1984), 87–91.
29. Deacon, B.J., Maack, D.J., The effects of safety behaviors on the fear of contamination: An experimental investigation. Behaviour Research and Therapy 46 (2008), 537–547.
30. Deacon, B.J., Kemp, J., Dixon, L.J., Sy, J.T., Farrell, N.R., Zhang, A., Maximizing the efficacy of IE by optimizing inhibitory learning: A randomized controlled trial. Behaviour Research and Therapy 51 (2013), 588–596.
31. Deacon, B.J., Lickel, J.J., Possis, E.A., Abramowitz, J.S., Mahaffey, B., Wolitzky-Taylor, K., Do cognitive reappraisal and diaphragmatic breathing augment IE for anxiety sensitivity?. Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy 26 (2012), 257–269.
32. Deacon, B.J., Sy, J.T., Lickel, J.J., Nelson, E.A., Does the judicious use of safety behaviors improve the efficacy and acceptability of exposure therapy for claustrophobic fear?. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 41 (2010), 71–80.
33. Engelhard, I.M., van Uijen, S.L., van Seters, N., Velu, N., The effects of safety behavior directed towards a safety cue on perceptions of threat. Behavior Therapy, 2015.
34. Faul, F., Erdfelder, E., Lang, A.-G., Buchner, A., G*Power 3: A flexible statistical power analysis program for the social, behavioral, and biomedical sciences. Behavior Research Methods 39 (2007), 175–191.
35. Foa, E.B., Kozak, M.J., Emotional processing of fear: Exposure to corrective information. Psychological Bulletin 99 (1986), 20–35.
36. Foa, E.B., McNally, R.J., Mechanisms of change in exposure therapy. Rapee, M., (eds.) Current controversies in the anxiety disorders, 1996, The Guilford Press, New York, 329–343.
37. Foa, E.B., Huppert, J.D., Cahill, S.P., Emotional processing theory: An update. Rothbaum, B.O., (eds.) Pathological anxiety: Emotional processing in etiology and treatment, 2006, Guilford Press, New York, NY, US, 3–24.
38. Gangemi, A., Mancini, F., van den Hout, M., Behavior as information: “If I avoid, then there must be danger. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 43 (2012), 1032–1038.
39. Garcia-Palacios, A., Botella, C., The effects of dropping in-situation safety behaviors in the treatment of social phobia. Behavioral Interventions 18 (2003), 23–33.
40. Garg, A.X., Hackam, D., Tonelli, M., Systematic review and meta-analysis: When one study is just not enough. Clinical Journal of the American Society of Nephrology 3 (2008), 253–260.
41. Goetz, A.R., Lee, H., The effects of preventive and restorative safety behaviors on a single-session of exposure therapy for contamination fear. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 46 (2015), 151–157.
42. Hayes, S.C., Wilson, K.G., Gifford, E.V., Follette, V.M., Strosahl, K., Experiential avoidance and behavioural disorders: A functional dimensional approach to diagnosis and treatment. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 64 (1996), 1152–1168.
43. Hedtke, K.A., Kendall, P.C., Tiwari, S., Safety-seeking and coping behavior during exposure tasks with anxious youth. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology 38 (2009), 1–15.
44. Helbig-Lang, S., Petermann, F., Tolerate or eliminate? A systematic review on the effects of safety behavior across anxiety disorders. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 17 (2010), 218–233.
45. Helbig-Lang, S., Richter, J., Lang, T., Gerlach, A.L., Fehm, L., Alpers, G.W.,.. Wittchen, H.U., The role of safety behaviors in exposure-based treatment for panic disorder and agoraphobia: Associations to symptom severity, treatment course, and outcome. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 28 (2014), 836–844.
46. Hood, H.K., Antony, M.M., Koerner, N., Monson, C.M., Effects of safety behaviours on fear reduction during exposure. Behaviour Research and Therapy 48 (2010), 1161–1169.
47. Horsley, T., Dingwall, O., Sampson, M., Checking reference lists to find additional studies for systematic reviews. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 10, 2011, 10.1002/14651858.MR000026.pub2 (Art. No. MR000026).
48. Kamphuis, J.H., Telch, M.J., Effects of distraction and guided threat appraisal on fear reduction during exposure-based treatments for specific fears. Behaviour Research and Therapy 38 (2000), 1163–1181.
49. Kessler, R.C., Berglund, P., Demler, O., Jin, R., Merikangas, K.R., Walters, E.E., Lifetime prevalence and age-of-onset distributions of DSM-IV disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Archives of General Psychiatry 62 (2005), 593–602.
50. Kim, E.J., The effect of the decreased safety behaviours on anxiety and negative thoughts in social phobics. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 19 (2005), 69–86.
51. Laborda, M.A., Miller, R.R., Reactivated memories compete for expression after Pavlovian extinction. Behavioural Processes 90 (2012), 20–27.
52. Lavy, E.H., van den Hout, M.A., Cognitive avoidance and attentional bias: Causal relationships. Cognitive Therapy and Research 18 (1994), 179–191.
53. Levy, H., Radomsky, A.S., Safety behaviour enhances the acceptability of exposure. Cognitive Behaviour Therapy 43 (2014), 83–92.
54. Levy, H.C., Senn, J.M., Radomsky, A.S., Further support for the acceptability-enhancing roles of safety behavior and a cognitive rationale in cognitive behavioral therapy for anxiety disorders. Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy 28 (2014), 303–316.
55. Lovibond, P.F., Mitchell, C.J., Minard, E., Brady, A., Menzies, R.G., Safety behaviours preserve threat beliefs: Protection from extinction of human fear conditioning by an avoidance response. Behaviour Research and Therapy 47 (2009), 16–20.
56. McManus, F., Sacadura, C., Clark, D.M., Why social anxiety persists: An experimental investigation of the role of safety behaviours as a maintaining factor. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 39 (2008), 147–161.
57. Maruish, M.E., The use of psychological testing for treatment planning and outcomes assessment. Maruish, M.E., (eds.), 1, 2004, Routledge, Mahwah, NJ, 197–250.
58. Merikangas, K.R., He, J., Burstein, M., Swanson, S.A., Avenevoli, S., Cui, L.,.. Swendsen, J., Lifetime prevalence of mental disorders in US adolescents: Results from the National Comorbidity Study-Adolescent Supplement (NCS-A). Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 49 (2010), 980–989.
59. Meulders, A., van Daele, T., Volders, S., Vlaeyen, J.W.S., The use of safety-seeking behavior in exposure-based treatments for fear and anxiety: Benefit or burden? A meta-analytic review. Clinical Psychology Review 45 (2016), 144–156.
60. Milosevic, I., Radomsky, A.S., Safety behaviour does not necessarily interfere with exposure therapy. Behaviour Research and Therapy 46 (2008), 1111–1118.
61. Milosevic, I., Radomsky, A.S., Keep your eye on the target: Safety behavior reduces targeted threat beliefs following a behavioral experiment. Cognitive Therapy and Research 37 (2013), 557–571.
62. Milosevic, I., Radomsky, A.S., Incorporating the judicious use of safety behavior into exposure-based treatments for anxiety disorders: A study of treatment acceptability. Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy: An International Quarterly 27 (2013), 155–174.
63. Morgan, H., Raffle, C., Does reducing safety behaviors improve treatment response in patients with social phobia?. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 33 (1999), 503–510.
64. Moscovitch, D.A., Antony, M.M., Swinson, R.P., Exposure-based treatments for anxiety disorders: Theory and process. Antony, M.M., Stein, M.B., Antony, M.M., Stein, M.B., (eds.) Oxford handbook of anxiety and related disorders, 2009, Oxford University Press, New York, NY, US, 461–475.
65. NICE, Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD): The management of PTSD in adults and children in primary and secondary care. Clinical guideline 26, 2005, National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, London Available at www.nice.org.uk.
66. Olatunji, B.O., Etzel, E.N., Tomarken, A.J., Ciesielski, B.G., Deacon, B.J., The effects of safety behaviors on health anxiety: An experimental investigation. Behaviour Research and Therapy 49 (2011), 719–728.
67. Parrish, C.L., Radomsky, A.S., Dugas, M.J., Anxiety-control strategies: Is there room for neutralization in successful exposure treatment?. Clinical Psychology Review 28 (2008), 1400–1412.
68. Plasencia, M.L., Alden, L.E., Taylor, C.T., Differential effects of safety behavior subtypes in social anxiety disorder. Behaviour Research and Therapy 49 (2011), 665–675.
69. Podină, I.R., Koster, E.W., Philippot, P., Dethier, V., David, D.O., Optimal attentional focus during exposure in specific phobia: A meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review 33 (2013), 1172–1183.
70. Posner, M.I., Attention in a social world. 2012, Oxford University Press, New York.
71. Powers, M.B., Smits, J.A., Telch, M.J., Disentangling the effects of safety-behavior utilization and safety-behavior availability during exposure-based treatment: A placebo-controlled trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 72 (2004), 448–454.
72. Powers, M.B., Smits, J.A., Whitley, D., Bystritsky, A., Telch, M.J., The effect of attributional processes concerning medication taking on return of fear. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 76 (2008), 478–490.
73. Rachman, S., Emotional processing. Behaviour Research and Therapy 18 (1980), 51–60.
74. Rachman, S., Craske, M.G., Tallman, K., Solyon, C., Does escape behavior strengthen agoraphobic avoidance?. Behavior Therapy 17 (1986), 366–384.
75. Rachman, S., Radomsky, A.S., Shafran, R., Safety behaviour: A reconsideration. Behaviour Research and Therapy 46 (2008), 163–173.
76. Rachman, S., Shafran, R., Radomsky, A.S., Zysk, E., Reducing contamination by exposure plus safety behaviour. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 42 (2011), 397–404.
77. Rentz, T.O., Powers, M.B., Smits, J.J., Cougle, J.R., Telch, M.J., Active-imaginal exposure: Examination of a new behavioral treatment for cynophobia (dog phobia). Behaviour Research and Therapy 41 (2003), 1337–1353.
78. Rescorla, R.A., Wagner, A.R., A theory of Pavlovian conditioning: Variations in the effectiveness of reinforcement and non-reinforcement. Prokasy, A.H., (eds.) Classical conditioning II: Current research and theory, 1972, Appleton-Century-Croft, New York, 64–99.
79. Richards, H.J., Benson, V., Donnelly, N., Hadwin, J.A., Exploring the function of selective attention and hypervigilance for threat in anxiety. Clinical Psychology Review 34 (2014), 1–13.
80. Salkovskis, P.M., The importance of behaviour in the maintenance of anxiety and panic: A cognitive account. Behavioural Psychotherapy 19 (1991), 6–19.
81. Salkovskis, P.M., Clark, D.M., Hackmann, A., Wells, A., Gelder, M., An experimental investigation of the role of safety behaviours in the maintenance of panic disorder with agoraphobia. Behaviour Research and Therapy 37 (1999), 559–574.
82. Salkovskis, P.M., Hackmann, A., Wells, A., Gelder, M.G., Clark, D.M., Belief disconfirmation versus habituation approaches to situational exposure in panic disorder with agoraphobia: A pilot study. Behaviour Research and Therapy 45 (2006), 877–885.
83. Sartory, G., Master, D., Rachman, S.J., Safety-signal therapy in agoraphobics: A preliminary test. Behaviour Research and Therapy 27 (1989), 205–209.
84. Saunders, J., Selective memory bias for self-threatening memories in trait anxiety. Cognition and Emotion 27 (2013), 21–36.
85. Schmidt, N.B., Lerew, D.R., Trakowski, J.H., Body vigilance in panic disorder: Evaluating attention to bodily perturbations. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 65 (1997), 214–220.
86. Simons, J.S., Gaher, R.M., The Distress Tolerance Scale: Development and validation of a self-report measure. Motivation and Emotion 29 (2005), 83–102.
87. Sloan, T., Telch, M.J., The effects of safety-seeking behavior and guided threat reappraisal on fear reduction during exposure: An experimental investigation. Behaviour Research and Therapy 40 (2002), 235–251.
88. Spurr, J.M., Stopa, L., Self-focused attention in social phobia and social anxiety. Clinical Psychology Review 22 (2002), 947–975.
89. Stewart, S.H., Westra, H.A., Thompson, C.E., Conrad, B.E., Effects of naturalistic benzodiazepine use on selective attention to threat cues among anxiety disorder patients. Cognitive Therapy and Research 24 (2000), 67–85.
90. Sy, J.T., Dixon, L.J., Lickel, J.J., Nelson, E.A., Deacon, B.J., Failure to replicate the deleterious effects of safety behaviors in exposure therapy. Behaviour Research and Therapy 49 (2011), 305–314.
91. Taylor, C.T., Alden, L.E., Safety behaviors and judgmental biases in social anxiety disorder. Behaviour Research and Therapy 48 (2010), 226–237.
92. Taylor, C.T., Alden, L.E., To see ourselves as others see us: An experimental integration of the intra and interpersonal consequences of self-protection in social anxiety disorder. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 720 (2011), 129–141.
93. Telch, M.J., Lancaster, C.L., Is there room for safety behaviors in exposure therapy for anxiety disorders?. Neudeck, P., Wittchen, H., (eds.) Exposure therapy: Rethinking the model – Refining the method, 2012, Springer Science + Business Media, New York, NY, US, 313–334.
94. Telch, M.J., Plasencia, L., When are safety behaviors contraindicated in the treatment of anxiety disorders? A test of the threat disconfirmation model. Talk presented at the world congress of behavioral and cognitive therapies, 2010 Boston, MA, June 4th 2010.
95. Thorpe, S.J., Salkovskis, P.M., Selective attention to real phobic and safety stimuli. Behaviour Research and Therapy 36 (1998), 471–481.
96. Thwaites, R., Freeston, M.H., Safety-seeking behaviours: Fact or function? How can we clinically differentiate between safety behaviors and adaptive coping strategies across anxiety disorders?. Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy 33 (2005), 177–188.
97. van den Hout, M., Engelhard, I.M., Toffolo, M.B.J., van Uijen, S.L., Exposure plus response prevention versus exposure plus safety behaviours in reducing feelings of contamination, fear, danger, and disgust. An extended replication of Rachman, Shafran, Radomsky & Zysk (2011). Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 42 (2011), 364–370.
98. van den Hout, M., Gangemi, A., Mancini, F., Engelhard, I.M., Rijkeboer, M.M., van Dams, M., Klugkist, I., Behavior as information about threat in anxiety disorders: A comparison of patients with anxiety disorders and non-anxious controls. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 45 (2014), 489–495.
99. van den Hout, M.A., Reininghaus, J.K., van der Stap, D., Engelhard, I.M., Why safety behaviour may not be that bad in the treatment of anxiety disorders: The commitment to future exposures. Psicoterapia Cognitiva e Comportamentale, monograph supplement, 2012, 111–126.
100. van Uijen, S.L., Toffolo, M.J., Safety behavior increases obsession-related cognitions about the severity of threat. Behavior Therapy 46 (2015), 521–531.
101. Waters, A.M., Kershaw, R., Direction of attention bias to threat relates to differences in fear acquisition and extinction in anxious children. Behaviour Research and Therapy 64 (2015), 56–65.
102. Wells, A., Papageorgiou, C., Social phobia: Effects of external attention on anxiety, negative beliefs, and perspective taking. Behavior Therapy 29 (1998), 357–370.
103. Wells, A., Clark, D.M., Salkovskis, P., Ludgate, J., Hackmann, A., Gelder, M., Social phobia: The role of in-situation safety behaviors in maintaining anxiety and negative beliefs. Behavior Therapy 26 (1995), 153–161.
104. Westra, H.A., Stewart, S.H., Cognitive behavioral therapy and pharmacotherapy: Complimentary or contradictory approaches to the treatment of anxiety disorders?. Clinical Psychology Review 18 (1998), 307–340.
105. Wolitzky, K.B., Telch, M.J., Augmenting in vivo exposure with fear antagonistic actions: A preliminary test. Behavior Therapy 40 (2009), 57–71.
106. Wu, C., Wang, C., Katz, A., Farley, J., National trends of psychotropic medication use among patients diagnosed with anxiety disorders: Results from Medical Expenditure Panel Survey 2004–2009. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 27 (2013), 163–170.