The use of safety-seeking behavior in exposure-based treatments for fear and anxiety: Benefit or burden? A meta-analytic review

Clinical Psychology Review

Volumn 45, Issue , 2016, Pages 144-156

  Meulders, Ann ^a   Van Daele, Tom ^a,b   Volders, Stéphanie ^a   Vlaeyen, Johan W S ^a,c  

^a UNIVERSITY OF LEUVEN   (Belgium)

^b Thomas More University College   (Belgium)

^c MAASTRICHT UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Anxiety; Exposure; Fear; Meta analysis; Review; Safety seeking behavior

Indexed keywords

ANXIETY; BEHAVIOR; EFFECT SIZE; EXPOSURE; FEAR; FILTRATION; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; SAFETY; ANXIETY DISORDERS; COGNITIVE THERAPY; PROCEDURES; PSYCHOLOGY;

ANXIETY DISORDERS; COGNITIVE THERAPY; FEAR; HUMANS;

EID: 84969438815     PISSN: 02727358     EISSN: 18737811     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpr.2016.02.002     Document Type: Review

References (67)

1. 2-enriched air in a non-clinical sample. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2007, 45:2280-2294.
2. Anderson P., Rothbaum R.O., Hodges L.F. Virtual reality exposure in the treatment of social anxiety. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice 2003, 10:240-247.
3. Back M., Cider A., Herlitz J., Lundberg M., Jansson B. The impact on kinesiophobia (fear of movement) by clinical variables for patients with coronary artery disease. International Journal of Cardiology 2013, 167:391-397.
4. Barlow D.H. Anxiety and its disorders. the nature and treatment of anxiety and panic 2002, The Guilford Press, New York.
5. Barlow D.H. Clinical handbook of psychological disorders: A step-by-step treatment manual 2008, Vol. 4. Oxford University Press, London.
6. Barlow D.H., Raffa S.D., Cohen E.M. Psychosocial treatments for panic disorder, phobias, and generalized anxiety disorder. A guide to treatments that work 2002, 301-336. Oxford University Press, Oxford. P.E. Nathan, J.M. Gorman (Eds.).
7. Baxter A.J., Scott K.M., Vos T., Whiteford H.A. Global prevalence of anxiety disorders: A systematic review and meta-regression. Psychological Medicine 2013, 43:897-910.
8. Bouton M.E. Learning and behavior: A contemporary synthesis 2006, Sinauer Associates, Inc. Publishers, Sunderland, Massachusetts.
9. Bouton M.E., Mineka S., Barlow D.H. A modern learning theory perspective on the etiology of panic disorder. Psychological Review 2001, 108:4-32.
10. Bradley M.M., Silakowski T., Lang P.J. Fear of pain and defensive activation. Pain 2008, 137:156-163.
11. Bulté I., Onghena P. An R package for single-case randomization tests. Behavior Research Methods 2008, 40:467-478.
12. Cima R.F.F., Maes I.H., Joore M.A., Scheyen D.J.W.M., El Refaie A., Baguley D.M., Vlaeyen J.W.S. Specialised treatment based on cognitive behaviour therapy versus usual care for tinnitus: A randomised controlled trial. The Lancet 2012, 379:1951-1959.
13. Cohen J.A. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences 1988, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ. 2nd ed.
14. Craske M.G., Kircanski K., Zelikowsky M., Mystkowski J., Chowdhury N., Baker A. Optimizing inhibitory learning during exposure therapy. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2008, 46:5-27.
15. Deacon B.J., Maack D.J. The effects of safety behaviors on the fear of contamination: An experimental investigation. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2008, 46:537-547.
16. Deacon B.J., Sy J.T., Lickel J.J., Nelson E.A. Does the judicious use of safety behaviors improve the efficacy and acceptability of exposure therapy for claustrophobic fear?. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 2010, 41:71-80.
17. Garcia-Palacios A., Botella C. The effects of dropping in-situation safety behaviors in the treatment of social phobia. Behavioral Interventions 2003, 18:23-33.
18. Goetz A.R., Lee H.J. The effects of preventive and restorative safety behaviors on a single-session of exposure therapy for contamination fear. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 2015, 46:151-157.
19. Grillon C., Davis M. Fear-potentiated startle conditioning in humans: Explicit and contextual cue conditioning following paired versus unpaired training 1997, Vol. 34:451-458. Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
20. Gustavsson A., Svensson M., Jacobi F., Allgulander C., Alonso J., Beghi E., Olesen J. Cost of disorders of the brain in Europe 2010. [Research support, non-U.S. gov't]. European Neuropsychopharmacology 2011, 21:718-779.
21. Hedges L.V. Nonparametric estimators of effect size in meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin 1984, 96.
22. Helbig-Lang S., Petermann F. Tolerate or eliminate? A systematic review on the effects of safety behavior across anxiety disorders. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice 2010, 17:218-233.
23. Hermans D., Craske M.G., Mineka S., Lovibond P.F. Extinction in human fear conditioning. Biological Psychiatry 2006, 60:361-368.
24. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions 2008, Wiley. J.P.T. Higgins, S. Green (Eds.).
25. Higgins J.P.T., Thompson S.G., Deeks J.J., Altman D.G. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analysis. British Medical Journal 2003, 327:557-560.
26. Hood H.K., Antony M.M., Koerner N., Monson C.M. Effects of safety behaviors on fear reduction during exposure. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2010, 48:1161-1169.
27. van den Hout M.A., Engelhard I.M., Toffolo M.B.J., van Uijen S.L. Exposure plus response prevention versus exposure plus safety behaviours in reducing feelings of contamination, fear, danger and disgust. An extended replication of Rachman, Shafran, Radomsky & Zysk. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 2011, 42:364-370.
28. Janssens T., De Peuter S., Stans L., Verleden G., Troosters T., Decramer M., Van den Bergh O. Dyspnea perception in COPD association between anxiety, dyspnea-related fear, and dyspnea in a pulmonary rehabilitation program. Chest 2011, 140:618-625.
29. Kessler R.C., Chiu W.T., Demler O., Walters E.E. Prevalence, severity, and comorbidity of 12-month DSM-IV disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Archives of General Psychiatry 2005, 62:617-627.
30. Kim E.-J. The effect of the decreased safety behaviors on anxiety and negative thoughts in social phobics. Journal of Anxiety Disorders 2005, 19:69-86.
31. Langer J., Rodebaugh T. Social anxiety and gaze avoidance: Averting gaze but not anxiety. Cognitive Therapy and Research 2013, 37:1110-1120.
32. Lissek S., Powers A.S., McClure E.B., Phelps E.A., Woldehawariat G., Grillon C., Pine D.S. Classical fear conditioning in the anxiety disorders: A meta-analysis. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2005, 43:1391-1424.
33. Lovibond P.F., Davis N.R., O'Flaherty A.S. Protection from extinction in human fear conditioning. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2000, 38:967-983.
34. Lovibond P.F., Mitchell C.J., Minard E., Brady A., Menzies R.G. Safety behaviours preserve threat beliefs: Protection from extinction of human fear conditioning by an avoidance response. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2009, 47:716-720.
35. Mattick R.P., Clarke J.C. Development and validation of measures of social phobia scrutiny fear and social interaction anxiety 1. Behaviour Research and Therapy 1998, 36:455-470.
36. McManus F., Sacadura C., Clark D.M. Why social anxiety persists: An experimental investigation of the role of safety behaviours as a maintaining factor. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 2008, 39:147-161.
37. McMillan D., Lee R. A systematic review of behavioral experiments vs. exposure alone in the treatment of anxiety disorders: A case of exposure while wearing the emperor's new clothes?. Clinical Psychology Review 2010, 30:467-478.
38. Meulders A., Vlaeyen J.W.S. Reduction of fear of movement-related pain and pain-related anxiety: An associative learning approach using a voluntary movement paradigm. Pain 2012, 153:1504-1513.
39. Meulders A., Vansteenwegen D., Vlaeyen J.W.S. The acquisition of fear of movement-related pain and associative learning: A novel pain-relevant human fear conditioning paradigm. Pain 2011, 152:2460-2469.
40. Milosevic I., Radomsky A.S. Safety behaviour does not necessarily interfere with exposure therapy. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2008, 46:1111-1118.
41. Milosevic I., Radomsky A.S. Keep your eye on the target: Safety behavior reduces targeted threat beliefs following a behavioral experiment. Cognitive Therapy and Research 2013, 37:557-571.
42. Morgan H., Raffle C. Does reducing safety behaviours improve treatment response in patients with social phobia?. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 1999, Vol. 33:503-510. Sage Publications, Ltd.
43. Onghena P., Edgington E.S. Customization of pain treatments: Single-case design and analysis. The Clinical Journal of Pain 2005, 21:56-68.
44. Parrish C.L., Radomsky A.S., Dugas M.J. Anxiety-control strategies: Is there room for neutralization in successful exposure treatment?. Clinical Psychology Review 2008, 28:1400-1412.
45. Powers M.B., Smits J.A., Telch M.J. Disentangling the effects of safety-behavior utilization and safety-behavior availability during exposure-based treatment: A placebo-controlled trial. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2004, 72:448-454.
46. Rachman S. Health anxiety disorders: A cognitive construal. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2012, 50:502-512.
47. Rachman S., Hodgson R. Obsessions and compulsions 1980, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
48. Rachman S., Radomsky A.S., Shafran R. Safety behaviour: A reconsideration. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2008, 46:163-173.
49. Rachman S., Shafran R., Radomsky A.S., Zysk E. Reducing contamination by exposure plus safety behaviour. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry 2011, 42:397-404.
50. Rescorla R.A. Protection from extinction. Learning & Behavior 2003, 31:124-132.
51. Salkovskis P.M. The importance of behaviour in the maintenance of anxiety and panic: A cognitive account. Behavioural Psychotherapy 1991, 19:6-19.
52. Salkovskis P.M. The cognitive approach to anxiety: Threat beliefs, safety-seeking behavior and the special case of health anxiety and obsessions. Frontiers of cognitive therapy 1996, The Guilford Press, New York. P.M. Salkovskis (Ed.).
53. Salkovskis P.M., Clark D.M., Gelder M.G. Cognition-behaviour links in the persistence of panic. Behaviour Research and Therapy 1996, 34:453-458.
54. Salkovskis P.M., Clark D.M., Hackmann A., Wells A., Gelder M.G. An experimental investigation of the role of safety-seeking behaviours in the maintenance of panic disorder with agoraphobia. Behaviour Research and Therapy 1999, 37:559-574.
55. Salkovskis P.M., Hackmann A., Wells A., Gelder M.G., Clark D.M. Belief disconfirmation versus habituation approaches to situational exposure in panic disorder with agoraphobia: A pilot study. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2006, 45:877-885.
56. Schmidt N.B., Buckner J.D., Pusser A., Woolaway-Bickel K., Preston J.L., Norr A. Randomized controlled trial of false safety behavior elimination therapy: A unified cognitive behavioral treatment for anxiety psychopathology. Behavior Therapy 2012, 43:518-532.
57. Sloan T., Telch M.J. The effects of safety-seeking behavior and guided threat reappraisal on fear reduction during exposure: an experimental investigation. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2002, 40:235-251.
58. Sy J.T., Dixon L.J., Lickel J.J., Nelson E.A., Deacon B.J. Failure to replicate the deleterious effects of safety behaviors in exposure therapy. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2011, 49:305-314.
59. Tang N.K.Y., Salkovskis P.M., Poplavskaya E., Wright K.J., Hanna M., Hester J. Increased use of safety-seeking behaviors in chronic back pain patients with high health anxiety. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2007, 45:2821-2835.
60. Taylor C.T., Alden L.E. Safety behaviors and judgmental biases in social anxiety disorder. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2010, 48:226-237.
61. Vlaeyen J.W.S., Linton S.J. Fear-avoidance and its consequences in chronic musculoskeletal pain: a state of the art. Pain 2000, 85:317-332.
62. Vlaeyen J.W.S., Linton S.J. Fear-avoidance model of chronic musculoskeletal pain: 12 years on. Pain 2012, 153:1144-1147.
63. Vlaeyen J.W.S., de Jong J., Geilen M., Heuts P.H.T.G., van Breukelen G. The treatment of fear of movement/(re)injury in chronic low back pain: Further evidence on the effectiveness of exposure in vivo. Clinical Journal of Pain 2002, 18:251-261.
64. Vlaeyen J.W.S., Morley S., Linton S.J., Boersma K., De Jong J.R. Pain-related fear: Exposure-based treatment for chronic pain 2012, IASP Press, Seattle.
65. Volders S., Meulders A., De Peuter S., Vervliet B., Vlaeyen J.W.S. Safety behavior can hamper the extinction of fear of movement-related pain: An experimental investigation in healthy participants. Behaviour Research and Therapy 2012, 50:735-746.
66. Volders S., Meulders A., De Peuter S., Vlaeyen J.W. The reduction of fear of movement-related pain: does motivational context matter?. The Clinical journal of pain 2015, 31(11):933-945.
67. Wells A., Clark D.M., Salkovskis P.M., Ludgate J., Hackmann A., Gelder M.G. Social phobia: The role of in-situation safety behaviors in maintaining anxiety and negative beliefs. Behavior Therapy 1995, 26:153-161.