Does College Teach Critical Thinking? A Meta-Analysis

Review of Educational Research

Volumn 86, Issue 2, 2016, Pages 431-468

  Huber, Christopher R ^a   Kuncel, Nathan R ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA   (United States)

Author keywords

changes in critical thinking; college students; critical thinking

Indexed keywords

EID: 84967221920     PISSN: 00346543     EISSN: 19351046     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3102/0034654315605917     Document Type: Article

References (109)

1. P.C.AbramiR.M.BernardE.BorokhovskiA.WadeM.A.SurkesR.TamimD.Zhang (2008). Instructional interventions affecting critical thinking skills and dispositions: A stage 1 meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 78, 1102–1134. doi:10.3102/0034654308326084
2. M.H.*AdamsL.M.StoverJ.F.Whitlow (1999). A longitudinal evaluation of baccalaureate nursing students’ critical thinking abilities. Journal of Nursing Education, 38, 139–141.
3. M.H.AdamsJ.F.WhitlowL.M.StoverK.W.Johnson (1996). Critical thinking as an educational outcome: An evaluation of current tools of measurement. Nurse Educator, 21(3), 23–32. doi:10.1097/00006223-199605000-00009
4. T.*ArburnL.Bethel (1999, March). Assisting at risk community college students’ acquisition of CT learning strategies. Paper presented at the National Association for Research in Science Teaching conference, Boston, MA.
5. R.ArumJ.Roksa (2011). Academically adrift: Limited learning on college campuses. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
6. D.J.*BartlettP.D.Cox (2002). Measuring change in students’ critical thinking ability: Implications for health care education. Journal of Allied Health, 31, 64–69.
7. T.M.*BeckieL.W.LowryS.Barnett (2001). Assessing critical thinking in baccalaureate nursing students: A longitudinal study. Holistic Nursing Practice, 15(3), 18–26. doi:10.1097/00004650-200104000-00006
8. M.C.*Berger (1984). Critical thinking ability and nursing students. Journal of Nursing Education, 23, 306–308.
9. C.*BlaichK.Wise (2008). Overview of findings from the first year of the Wabash National Study of Liberal Arts Education. Crawfordsville, IN: Center of Inquiry in the Liberal Arts at Wabash College.
10. C.*BlaichK.Wise (2011). How do students change over four years of college?Crawfordsville, IN: Center of Inquiry in the Liberal Arts at Wabash College.
11. P.BobkoP.L.RothC.Bobko (2001). Correcting the effect size of d for range restriction and unreliability. Organizational Research Methods, 4, 46–61. doi:10.1177/109442810141003
12. C.F.*Brigham (1989). Critical thinking skills in nursing students progressing through a nursing curriculum (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 8918496)
13. J.A.M.*Burgess (2003). The impact of the school of nursing curriculum on generic baccalaureate nursing students’ ability to think critically at Austin Peay State University (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 3094628)
14. J.P.CampbellN.R.Kuncel (2001). Individual and team training. In (Eds.), Handbook of industrial, work & organizational psychology: Vol. 1. Personnel psychology (pp. 278–312). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
15. K.R.*Colbert (1987). The effects of CEDA and NDT debate training on critical thinking ability (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 8626790)
16. M.L.*Colucciello (1997). Critical thinking skills and dispositions of baccalaureate nursing students—a conceptual model for evaluation. Journal of Professional Nursing, 13, 236–245. doi:10.1016/S8755-7223(97)80094-4
17. L.A.*Criner (1992). Teaching thinking and reasoning: A study of critical thinking in adults (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9237328)
18. P.M.*DaleD.BallottiS.HandaT.Zych (1997). An approach to teaching problem solving in the classroom. College Student Journal, 31, 76–79.
19. W.M.*Daly (2001). The development of an alternative method in the assessment of critical thinking as an outcome of nursing education. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 36, 120–130. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2648.2001.01949.x
20. L.DeAngeloS.HurtadoJ.H.PryorK.R.KellyJ.L.SantosW.S.Korn (2009). The American college teacher: National norms for the 2007-2008 HERI faculty survey. Los Angeles, CA: Higher Education Research Institute.
21. L.E.Drouin (1992). An investigation of the critical thinking ability of engineering students seeking a bachelor of science degree. Dissertation Abstracts International, 53, 1070A.
22. R.L.*Erickson (1999). The effects of database training and use on the development of critical-thinking skills (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9955755)
23. L.L.*Ewen (2001). A longitudinal study of nursing students’ self-esteem, locus of control, anxiety, critical thinking and academic achievement (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 3041104)
24. N.C.*FacioneP.A.Facione (1997). Critical thinking assessment in nursing education programs: An aggregate data analysis. Millbrae: California Academic Press.
25. N.C.FacioneP.A.FacioneC.A.Sanchez (1994). Critical thinking disposition as a measure of competent clinical judgment: The development of the California Critical Thinking Disposition Inventory. Journal of Nursing Education, 33, 345–350.
26. P.A.Facione (2011). Critical thinking: What it is and why it counts. Millbrae: California Academic Press.
27. R.L.*Fleeger (1986). Critical thinking and moral reasoning behavior of baccalaureate nursing students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 8616530)
28. C.A.*Forbes (1997). Analyzing the growth of the critical thinking skills of college calculus students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9737709)
29. S.H.*Frost (1991). Fostering the critical thinking of college women through academic advising and faculty contact. Journal of College Student Development, 32, 359–366.
30. P.Galagan (2010). Bridging the skills gap. Alexandria, VA: American Society for Training and Development.
31. C.A.*GiancarloP.A.Facione (2001). A look across four years at the disposition toward critical thinking among undergraduate students. Journal of General Education, 50, 29–55. doi:10.1353/jge.2001.0004
32. L.J.GleserI.Olkin (2009). Stochastically dependent effect sizes. In (Eds.), The handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis (2nd ed., pp. 357–376). New York, NY: Russell Sage Foundation.
33. H.I.J.*Goodin (2005). The use of deliberative discussion as a teaching strategy to enhance the critical thinking abilities of freshman nursing students (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from https://etd.ohiolink.edu/ap/10?214682536937066::NO:10:P10_ETD_SUBID:63853
34. Y.*GrossE.TakazawaC.Rose (1987). Critical thinking and nursing education. Journal of Nursing Education, 26, 317–323.
35. L.S.*HagedornE.T.PascarellaM.EdisonJ.BraxtonA.NoraP.T.Terenzini (1999). Institutional context and the development of critical thinking: A research note. Review of Higher Education, 22, 265–286. doi:10.1353/rhe.1999.0010
36. D.F.Halpern (2001). Assessing the effectiveness of critical thinking instruction. Journal of General Education, 50, 270–286. doi:10.1353/jge.2001.0024
37. B.W.*Hancock (1981). The effect of guided design on the critical thinking ability of college level administrative science students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 8206458)
38. J.A.Hattie (1987). Identifying the salient facets of a model of student learning: A synthesis of meta-analyses. International Journal of Educational Research, 11, 187–212.
39. J.A.Hattie (1992). Measuring the effects of schooling. Australian Journal of Education, 36, 5–13.
40. K.E.Hill (1995). Critical thinking and its relation to academic, personal, and moral development in the college years. Dissertation Abstracts International, 56, 4603B.
41. J.E.HunterF.L.Schmidt (2004). Methods of meta-analysis: Correcting error and bias in research findings. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
42. L.G.*Isaacs (1990). A study of the effect of teaching critical thinking in an introductory nursing course (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9104407)
43. S.S.Jacobs (1995). Technical characteristics and some correlates of the California Critical Thinking Skills Test, Forms A and B. Research in Higher Education, 36, 89–108. doi:10.1007/BF02207768
44. F.E.*Johnson (2002). Critical thinking skills of baccalaureate nursing students in a collaborative nursing program. (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 3041691)
45. J.H.*JonesL.V.Morris (2007). Evaluation of critical thinking skills in an associate degree nursing program. Teaching and Learning in Nursing, 2, 109–115. doi:10.1016/j.teln.2007.07.006
46. R.*Keller (1993). Effects of an instructional program on critical thinking and clinical decision-making skills of associate degree nursing students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9404905)
47. J.*Kintgen-Andrews (1988). Development of critical thinking: Career ladder PN and AD nursing students, pre-health science freshmen, generic baccalaureate sophomore nursing students. Minneapolis: The University of Minnesota. Retrieved from ERIC database. (ED297153)
48. S.KleinR.BenjaminR.ShavelsonR.Bolus (2007). The collegiate learning assessment: Facts and fantasies. Evaluation Review, 31, 415–439. doi:10.1177/0193841X07303318
49. J.KoenigJ.HermanG.DuncanD.KnappP.KyllnonenP.SackettK.. Iverson (2011). Assessing 21st century skills: Summary of a workshop. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
50. M.A.*Kokinda (1989). The measurement of critical thinking skills in a selected baccalaureate nursing program (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9004798)
51. N.R.Kuncel (2011). Measurement and meaning of critical thinking (Research report for the NRC 21st Century Skills Workshop). Washington, DC: National Research Council.
52. I.J.*Lehmann (1963). Changes in critical thinking, attitudes, and values from freshman to senior years. Journal of Educational Psychology, 54, 305–315. doi:10.1037/h0045302
53. C.J.*Leppa (1997). Standardized measures of critical thinking: Experience with the California critical thinking tests. Nurse Educator, 22, 29–33. doi:10.1097/00006223-199709000-00012
54. D.R.*LewisT.Dahl (1972). Critical thinking skills in the principles course: An experiment. In (Ed.), Research papers in economic education (pp. 50–68). New York, NY: Joint Council on Economic Education.
55. E.M.*Lyons (2008). Examining the effects of problem-based learning and NCLEX-RN scores on the critical thinking skills of associate degree nursing students in a southeastern community college. International Journal of Nursing Education Scholarship, 5, 1–17. doi:10.2202/1548-923X.1524
56. P.*McCarthyP.SchusterP.ZehrD.McDougal (1999). Evaluation of critical thinking in a baccalaureate nursing program. Journal of Nursing Education, 38, 142–144.
57. M.F.*Mcdonough (1997). An assessment of critical thinking at the community college level (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9738997)
58. M.L.*McKee (2006). Overcoming obstacles in teaching college students how to think critically: The effects of an instructional intervention (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 3222188)
59. J.H.McMillan (1987). Enhancing college students’ critical thinking: A review of studies. Research in Higher Education, 26, 3–29. doi:10.1007/BF00991931
60. J.E.McPeck (1984). Stalking beasts, but swatting flies: The teaching of critical thinking. Canadian Journal of Education, 9, 28–44. doi:10.2307/1494448
61. J.E.McPeck (1990). Critical thinking and subject specificity: A reply to Ennis. Educational Researcher, 19(4), 10–12. doi:10.3102/0013189X019004010
62. G.T.*MeissG.W.Bates (1984, May). Cognitive and attitudinal effects of reasoning message strategies. Paper presented at the annual conference of the International Communication Association, San Francisco, CA.
63. T.M.*Melvin (1996). Evaluation of curriculum effectiveness in developing critical thinking skills at Wentworth Institute of Technology (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9720530)
64. M.MentkowskiG.Rogers (1985, October). Longitudinal assessment of critical thinking in college: What measures assess curricular impact?Paper presented at the annual meeting of The Mid-Western Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL.
65. M.H.*Miller (1987). Impact of a baccalaureate registered nurse program on the critical thinking skills of students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 8808292)
66. R.A.*MinesP.M.KingA.B.HoodP.K.Wood (1990). Stages of intellectual development and associated critical thinking skills in college students. Journal of College Student Development, 31, 538–547.
67. S.B.MorrisR.P.DeShon (2002). Combining effect size estimates in meta-analysis with repeated measures and independent-groups designs. Psychological Methods, 7, 105–125. doi:10.1037//1082-989X.7.1.105
68. Y.H.*Nathan (1997). Critical thinking: Impact on two classes of nursing students in an academic year (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9734083)
69. B.R.*Norwood (1998). Critical thinking in nursing students: A comparison of designs. (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9903935)
70. M.A.*Notarianni (1991). An investigation of the critical thinking ability of associate and baccalaureate degree nursing students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9129260)
71. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. (2010). PISA 2009 results: Executive summary. Retrieved from www.oecd.org/pisa/pisaproducts/46619703.pdf
72. C.M.A.Ortiz (2007). Does philosophy improve critical thinking skills? (Unpublished master’s thesis). The University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
73. E.T.*Pascarella (1989). The development of critical thinking: Does college make a difference?Journal of College Student Development, 30, 19–26.
74. E.T.PascarellaP.T.Terenzini (1991). How college affects students: Findings and insights from twenty years of research. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
75. E.T.PascarellaP.T.Terenzini (2005). How college affects students: A third decade of research. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
76. N.G.PetersonM.MumfordW.BormanP.JeanneretE.FleishmanK.Levin (1997). O*NET final technical report. Salt Lake City: Utah Department of Workforce Services.
77. T.*Pierce (1994). Institutional effectiveness assessment process, 1993-94. Executive summary. Seattle, WA: South Seattle Community College. Retrieved from ERIC database. (ED381223)
78. T.*Pierce (2011). Introductory computer programming courses used as a catalyst to critical thinking development (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from http://cardinalscholar.bsu.edu/handle/123456789/195140
79. M.PumaS.BellR.CookC.HeidP.BroeneF.JenkinsJ.. Downer (2012). Third grade follow-up to the Head Start impact study. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Retrieved from www.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/opre/head_start_report.pdf
80. S.W.RaudenbushA.S.Bryk (2002). Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
81. R.D.RenaudH.G.Murray (2008). A comparison of a subject-specific and a general measure of critical thinking. Thinking Skills and Creativity, 3, 85–93. doi:10.1016/j.tsc.2008.03.005
82. M.A.*Richards (1977). One integrated curriculum: An empirical evaluation. Nursing Research, 26, 90–95. doi:10.1097/00006199-197703000-00003
83. M.M.*Rose (1997). Critical thinking skills instruction for postsecondary students with and without learning disabilities: The effectiveness of icons as part of a literature curriculum (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9806188)
84. G.*RossG.Semb (1981). Philosophy can teach critical thinking skills. Teaching Philosophy, 4, 111–122. doi:10.5840/teachphil19814233
85. L.G.*Ruff (2005). The development of critical thinking skills and dispositions in first-year college students: Infusing critical thinking instruction into a first-year transitions course (Doctoral dissertation). University of Maryland, College Park. Retrieved from http://drum.lib.umd.edu/handle/1903/3155
86. R.A.SchmidtR.A.Bjork (1992). New conceptualizations of practice: Common principles in three paradigms suggest new concepts for training. Psychological Science, 3, 207–217. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9280.1992.tb00029.x
87. T.A.*SeifertE.T.PascarellaN.ColangeloS.G.Assouline (2007). The effects of honors program participation on experiences of good practices and learning outcomes. Journal of College Student Development, 48, 57–74. doi:10.1353/csd.2007.0007
88. K.R.*ShinJ.H.LeeJ.Y.HaK.H.Kim (2006). Critical thinking dispositions in baccalaureate nursing students. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 56, 182–189. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2648.2006.03995.x
89. M.L.*Smith (1995). A quantitative analysis of critical thinking abilities, learning and study strategies, and academic achievement in associate degree nursing students (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9602082)
90. T.*Solon (2001). Improving critical thinking in an introductory psychology course. Michigan Community College Journal: Research & Practice, 7, 73–80.
91. T.*Solon (2003). Teaching critical thinking: The more, the better. The Community College Enterprise, 9, 25–38.
92. T.*Solon (2007). Generic critical thinking infusion and course content learning in introductory psychology. Journal of Instructional Psychology, 34, 95–109.
93. S.C.*SpauldingK.A.Kleiner (1992). The relationship of college and critical thinking: Are critical thinkers attracted or created by college disciplines?College Student Journal, 26, 162–166.
94. P.*Sukspringarm (1976). An experimental study comparing the effects of BSCS and traditional biology on achievement, understanding of science, critical thinking ability, and attitude toward science of the first year students at the Sakon Nakorn Teachers’ College, Thailand (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 7624805)
95. E.J.*Sullivan (1987). Critical thinking, creativity, clinical performance, and achievement in RN students. Nurse Educator, 12, 12–16. doi:10.1097/00006223-198703000-00008
96. P.T.TerenziniL.SpringerE.T.PascarellaA.Nora (1995). Influences affecting the development of students’ critical thinking skills. Research in Higher Education, 36, 23–39. doi:10.1007/BF02207765
97. C.*ThompsonL.M.Rebeschi (1999). Critical thinking skills of baccalaureate nursing students at program entry and exit. Nursing and Health Care Perspectives, 20, 248–252.
98. C.*Tomlinson-KeaseyD.Eisert (1978). Second year evaluation of the ADAPT program (Essays from and about the ADAPT Program). Retrieved from http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1030&context=adaptessays
99. L.Tsui (1998). Fostering critical thinking in college students: A mixed-methods study of influences inside and outside of the classroom (Doctoral dissertation). Available from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses database. (UMI No. 9917229)
100. P.*Turner (2000). Critical thinking and intellectual development: Changes associated with baccalaureate nursing education. Korean Journal of Thinking & Problem Solving, 10, 41–48.
101. W.Viechtbauer (2014). Metafor: Meta-analysis package for R (Version 1.9-5) [Computer software]. Retrieved from https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/metafor/index.html
102. Y.WangH.C.Liao (2012). The promotion of critical thinking in baccalaureate nursing English programs. African Journal of Business Management, 6, 3188–3196.
103. G.*WatsonE.M.Glaser (1980). Watson-Glaser critical thinking appraisal. San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation.
104. L.A.*WheelerS.K.R.Collins (2003). The influence of concept mapping on critical thinking in baccalaureate nursing students. Journal of Professional Nursing, 19, 339–346. doi:10.1016/S8755-7223(03)00134-0
105. E.*Whitmire (2001). The relationship between undergraduates’ background characteristics and college experiences and their academic library use. College & Research Libraries, 62, 528–540.
106. R.L.*Williams (2003). Critical thinking as a predictor and outcome measure in a large undergraduate educational psychology course. Knoxville: The University of Tennessee. Retrieved from ERIC database. (ED 478075)
107. R.L.*WilliamsR.OliverS.L.Stockdale (2004). Psychological versus generic critical thinking as predictors and outcome measures in a large undergraduate human development course. Journal of General Education, 53, 37–58. doi:10.1353/jge.2004.0022
108. D.G.*WinterD.C.McClelland (1978). Thematic analysis: An empirically derived measure of the effects of liberal arts education. Journal of Educational Psychology, 70, 8–16. doi:10.1037//0022-0663.70.1.8
109. H.*YuanW.KunaviktikulA.KlunklinB.A.Williams (2008). Improvement of nursing students’ critical thinking skills through problem-based learning in the people’s republic of china: A quasi-experimental study. Nursing & Health Sciences, 10, 70–76. doi:10.1111/j.1442-2018.2007.00373.x