Accuracy comparison of guided surgery for dental implants according to the tissue of support: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Clinical Oral Implants Research

Volumn 28, Issue 5, 2017, Pages 602-612

  Raico Gallardo, Yolanda Natali ^a   da Silva Olivio, Isabela Rodrigues Teixeira ^a   Mukai, Eduardo ^b   Morimoto, Susana ^c   Sesma, Newton ^a   Cordaro, Luca ^d  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SÃO PAULO   (Brazil)

^b APCD   (Brazil)

^c IBIRAPUERA UNIVERSITY   (Brazil)

^d George Eastman Odontoiatric Hospital   (Italy)

Author keywords

computer aided design; computer aided manufacturing; computer aided surgery; dental implants; systematic review

Indexed keywords

COMPUTER ASSISTED SURGERY; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; TOOTH IMPLANT; TOOTH IMPLANTATION; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

DENTAL IMPLANTATION; DENTAL IMPLANTATION, ENDOSSEOUS; DENTAL IMPLANTS; HUMANS; SURGERY, COMPUTER-ASSISTED; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84963745124     PISSN: 09057161     EISSN: 16000501     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/clr.12841     Document Type: Review

References (61)

1. Abboud, M., Wahl, G., Guirado, J.L. & Orentlicher, G. (2012) Application and success of two stereolithographic surgical guide systems for implant placement with immediate loading. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 27: 634–643.
2. Al-Harbi, S.A. & Sun, A.Y. (2009) Implant placement accuracy when using stereolithographic template as a surgical guide: preliminary results. Implant Dentistry 18: 46–56.
3. Arisan, V., Karabuda, C.Z. & Ozdemir, T. (2010a) Implant surgery using bone- and mucosa-supported stereolithographic guides in totally edentulous jaws: surgical and post-operative outcomes of computer-aided vs. standard techniques. Clinical Oral Implants Research 21: 980–988.
4. Arisan, V., Karabuda, C.Z. & Ozdemir, T. (2010b) Accuracy of two stereolithographic guide systems for computer aided implant placement: a computed tomography based clinical comparative study. Journal of Periodontology 81: 43–51.
5. Arisan, V., Karabuda, Z.C., Pişkin, B. & Özdemir, T. (2013) Conventional multi-slice computed tomography (CT) and cone-beam CT (CBCT) for computer-aided implant placement. Part II: reliability of mucosa-supported stereolithographic guides. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 15: 907–917.
6. Azari, A. & Nikzad, S. (2008) Flapless implant surgery: review of the literature and report of 2 cases with computer-guided surgical approach. Journal of Oral Maxillofacial Surgery 66: 1015–1021.
7. Behneke, A., Burwinkel, M. & Behneke, N. (2012a) Factors influencing transfer accuracy of cone beam CT-derived template-based implant placement. Clinical Oral Implants Research 23: 416–423.
8. Behneke, A., Burwinkel, M., Knierim, K. & Behneke, N. (2012b) Accuracy assessment of cone beam computed tomography-derived laboratory-based surgical templates on partially edentulous patients. Clinical Oral Implants Research 23: 137–143.
9. Campelo, L.D. & Camara, J.R. (2002) Flapless implant surgery: a 10-year clinical retrospective analysis. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 17: 271–275.
10. Cassetta, M., Di Mambro, A., Di Giorgio, G., Stefanelli, L.V. & Barbato, E. (2013e) The influence of the tolerance between mechanical components on the accuracy of implants inserted with a stereolithographic surgical guide: a retrospective clinical study. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 17: 580–588.
11. Cassetta, M., Di Mambro, A., Giansanti, M., Stefanelli, L.V. & Barbato, E. (2013a) Is it possible to improve the accuracy of implants inserted with a stereolithographic surgical guide by reducing the tolerance between mechanical components? International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 42: 887–890.
12. Cassetta, M., Di Mambro, A., Giansanti, M., Stefanelli, L.V. & Cavallini, C. (2013d) The intrinsic error of a stereolithographic surgical template in implant guided surgery. International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 42: 264–275.
13. Cassetta, M., Giansanti, M., Di Mambro, A., Calasso, S. & Barbato, E. (2013c) Accuracy of two stereolithographic surgical templates: a retrospective study. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 15: 448–459.
14. Cassetta, M., Pompa, G., Di Carlo, S., Piccoli, L., Pacifici, A. & Pacifici, L. (2012b) The influence of smoking and surgical technique on the accuracy of mucosa-supported stereolithographic surgical guide in complete edentulous upper jaws. European Review for Medical and Pharmacological Sciences 16: 1546–1553.
15. Cassetta, M., Stefanelli, L.V., Giansanti, M. & Calasso, S. (2012a) Accuracy of implant placement with a stereolithographic surgical template. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 27: 655–663.
16. Cassetta, M., Stefanelli, L.V., Giansanti, M., Di Mambro, A. & Calasso, S. (2011) Depth deviation and occurrence of early surgical complications or unexpected events using a single stereolithographic surgi-guide. International Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 40: 1377–1387.
17. Cassetta, M., Stefanelli, L.V., Giansanti, M., Di Mambro, A. & Calasso, S. (2013b) Accuracy of a computer-aided implant surgical technique. The International Journal of Periodontics & Restorative Dentistry 33: 317–325.
18. Chambrone, L., Chambrone, D., Lima, L.A. & Chambrone, L.A. (2010) Predictors of tooth loss during long-term periodontal maintenance: a systematic review of observational studies. Journal of Clinical Periodontology 37: 675–684.
19. Chambrone, L., Shibli, J.A., Mercúrio, C.E., Cardoso, B. & Preshaw, P.M. (2015) Efficacy of standard (SLA) and modified sandblasted and acid-etched (SLActive) dental implants in promoting immediate and/or early occlusal loading protocols: a systematic review of prospective studies. Clinical Oral Implants Research 26: 359–370.
20. D'haese, J., Van De Velde, T., Elaut, L. & De Bruyn, H. (2012) A prospective study on the accuracy of mucosally supported stereolithographic surgical guides in fully edentulous maxillae. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 14: 293–303.
21. Di Giacomo, G.A., Cury, P.R., De Araujo, N.S., Sendyk, W.R. & Sendyk, C.L. (2005) Clinical application of stereolithographic surgical guides for implant placement: preliminary results. Journal of Periodontology 76: 503–507.
22. Di Giacomo, G., Da Silva, J.V., Da Silva, A.M., Paschoal, G.H., Cury, P.R. & Szarf, G. (2012) Accuracy and complications of computer designed selective laser sintering surgical guides for flapless dental implant placement and immediate definitive prosthesis installation. Journal of Periodontology 83: 410–419.
23. Ersoy, A.E., Turkyilmaz, I., Ozan, O. & McGlumphy, E.A. (2008) Reliability of implant placement with stereolithographic surgical guides generated from computed tomography: clinical data from 94 implants. Journal of Periodontology 79: 1339–1345.
24. Flanagan, D. (2007) Flapless dental implant placement. Journal of Oral Implantology 33: 75–83.
25. Fortin, T., Bosson, J.L., Isidori, M. & Blanchet, E. (2006) Effect of flapless surgery on pain experienced in implant placement using an image-guided system. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 21: 298–304.
26. Ganz, S.D. (2015) Three-dimensional imaging and guided surgery for dental implants. Dental Clinics of North America 59: 265–290.
27. Higgins, J.P.T. & Green, S. (2011) Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions [serial on the Internet]. Available at: www.cochrane-handbook.org.
28. Jung, R.E., Schneider, D., Ganeles, J., Wismeijer, D., Zwahlen, M., Hammerle, C., Tahmaseb, A. (2009) Computer technology applications in surgical implant dentistry: a systematic review. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 24: 92–109.
29. Lal, K., White, G.S., Morea, D.N. & Wright, R.F. (2006) Use of stereolithographic templates for surgical and prosthodontic implant planning and placement. Part I. The concept. Journal of Prosthodontics 15: 51–58.
30. Lee, J.H., Park, J.M., Kim, S.M., Kim, M.J., Lee, J.H. & Kim, M.J. (2013) An assessment of template-guided implant surgery in terms of accuracy and related factors. The Journal of Advanced Prosthodontics 5: 440–447.
31. Liberati, A., Altman, D.G., Tetzlaff, J., Mulrow, C., Gøtzsche, P.C., Ioannidis, J.P., Clarke, M., Devereaux, P.J., Kleijnen, J. & Moher, D. (2009) The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 62: 1–34.
32. Naitoh, M., Ariji, E., Okumura, S., Ohsaki, C., Kurita, K. & Ishigami, T. (2000) Can implants be correctly angulated based on surgical templates used for osseointegrated dental implants? Clinical Oral Implants Research 11: 409–414.
33. Nickenig, H.J. & Eitner, S. (2010a) An alternative method to match planned and achieved positions of implants, after virtual planning using cone-beam CT data and surgical guide templates–a method reducing patient radiation exposure (part I). Journal of Cranio-Maxillofacial Surgery 38: 436–440.
34. Nickenig, H.J., Wichmann, M., Hamel, J., Schlegel, K.A. & Eitner, S. (2010b) Evaluation of the difference in accuracy between implant placement by virtual planning data and surgical guide templates versus the conventional free-hand method - a combined in vivo - in vitro technique using cone-beam CT (Part II). Journal of Cranio-Maxillofacial Surgery 38: 488–493.
35. Ochi, M., Kanazawa, M., Sato, D., Kasugai, S., Hirano, S. & Minakuchi, S. (2013) Factors affecting accuracy of implant placement with mucosa-supported stereolithographic surgical guides in edentulous mandibles. Computers in Biology and Medicine 43: 1653–1660.
36. Ozan, O., Orhan, K. & Turkyilmaz, I. (2011) Correlation between bone density and angular deviation of implants placed using CT-generated surgical guides. The Journal of Craniofacial Surgery 22: 1755–1761.
37. Ozan, O., Turkyilmaz, I., Ersoy, A.E., McGlumphy, E.A. & Rosenstiel, S.F. (2009) Clinical accuracy of 3 different types of computed tomography-derived stereolithographic surgical guides in implant placement. Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery 67: 394–401.
38. Pettersson, A., Komiyama, A., Hultin, M., Näsström, K. & Klinge, B. (2012) Accuracy of virtually planned and template guided implant surgery on edentate patients. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 14: 527–537.
39. Platzer, S., Bertha, G., Heschl, A., Wegscheider, W.A. & Lorenzoni, M. (2013) Three-dimensional accuracy of guided implant placement: indirect assessment of clinical outcomes. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 15: 724–734.
40. Rosenfeld, A.L., Mandelaris, G.A. & Tardieu, P.B. (2006) Prosthetically directed implant placement using computer software to ensure precise placement and predictable prosthetic outcomes. Part 2: rapid-prototype medical modeling and stereolithographic drilling guides requiring bone exposure. The International Journal of Periodontics & Restorative Dentistry 26: 347–353.
41. Rousseau, P. (2010) Flapless and traditional dental implant surgery: an open, retrospective comparative study. Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 68: 2299–2306.
42. Schneider, D., Marquardt, P., Zwahlen, M. & Jung, R.E. (2009) A systematic review on the accuracy and the clinical outcome of computer-guided template-based implant dentistry. Clinical Oral Implants Research 20: 73–86.
43. Sun, Y., Luebbers, H.T., Agbaje, J.O., Schepers, S., Politis, C., Van Slycke, S. & Vrielinck, L. (2013) Accuracy of dental implant placement using CBCT-derived mucosa-supported stereolithographic template. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 17: 862–870.
44. Tahmaseb, A., Wismeijer, D., Coucke, W. & Derksen, W. (2014) Computer technology applications in surgical implant dentistry: a systematic review. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 29: 25–42.
45. Tapie, L., Lebon, N., Mawussi, B., Fron, Chabouis.H., Duret, F. & Attal, J.P. (2015) Understanding dental CAD/CAM for restorations–the digital workflow from a mechanical engineering viewpoint. International Journal of Computerized Dentistry 18: 21–44.
46. Valente, F., Schiroli, G. & Sbrenna, A. (2009) Accuracy of computer aided oral implant surgery: a clinical and radiographic study. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 24: 234–242.
47. Van Assche, N., Van Steenberghe, D., Quirynen, M. & Jacobs, R. (2010) Accuracy assessment of computer-assisted flapless implant placement in partial edentulism. Journal of Clinical Periodontology 37: 398–403.
48. Van Assche, N., Vercruyssen, M., Coucke, W., Teughels, W., Jacobs, R. & Quirynen, M. (2012) Accuracy of computer-aided implant placement. Clinical Oral Implants Research 23: 112–123.
49. Van de Wiele, G., Teughels, W., Vercruyssen, M., Coucke, W., Temmerman, A. & Quirynen, M. (2014) The accuracy of guided surgery via mucosa-supported stereolithographic surgical templates in the hands of surgeons with little experience. Clinical Oral Implants Research 26: 1–6.
50. ™)-guided implant positions: a prospective radiological study. Clinical Oral Implants Research 22: 1157–1163.
51. Vercruyssen, M., Cox, C., Coucke, W., Naert, I., Jacobs, R. & Quirynen, M. (2014) A randomized clinical trial comparing guided implant surgery (bone or mucosa supported) with mental navigation or the use of a pilot-drill template. Journal of Clinical Periodontology 41: 717–723.
52. Vercruyssen, M., Jacobs, R., Van Assche, N. & Van Steenberghe, D. (2008) The use of CT scan based planning for oral rehabilitation by means of implants and its transfer to the surgical field: a critical review on accuracy. Journal of Oral Rehabilitation 35: 454–474.
53. Verhamme, L.M., Meijer, G.J., Bergé, S.J., Soehardi, R.A., Xi, T., De Haan, A.F., Schutyser, F. & Maal, T.J. (2014) An accuracy study of computer-planned implant placement in the augmented maxilla using mucosa-supported surgical templates. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 2: 1–10.
54. Verhamme, L.M., Meijer, G.J., Boumans, T., De Haan, A.F., Bergé, S.J. & Maal, T.J. (2013) A clinically relevant accuracy study of computer-planned implant placement in the edentulous maxilla using mucosa-supported surgical templates. Clinical Implant Dentistry & Related Research 17: 343–352.
55. Vieira, D.M., Sotto-Maior, B.S., Barros, C.A., Reis, E.S. & Francischone, C.E. (2013) Clinical accuracy of flapless computer-guided surgery for implant placement in edentulous arches. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 28: 1347–1351.
56. Wagner, A., Wanschitz, F., Birkfellner, W., Zauza, K., Klug, C., Schicho, K., Kainberger, F., Czerny, C., Bergmann, H. & Ewers, R. (2003) Computer-aided placement of endosseous oral implants in patients after ablative tumour surgery: assessment of accuracy. Clinical Oral Implants Research 14: 340–348.
57. Web, P.A. (2000) A review of rapid prototyping (RP) techniques in the medical and biomedical sector. Journal of Medical Engineering & Technology 24: 149–153.
58. Widman, G. & Bale, J.B. (2006) Accuracy in computer-aided implant surgery-a review. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 21: 305–313.
59. Wittwer, G., Adeyemo, W.L., Schicho, K., Birkfellner, W. & Enislidis, G. (2007b) Prospective randomized clinical comparison of 2 dental implant navigation systems. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 22: 785–790.
60. Wittwer, G., Adeyemo, W.L., Schicho, K., Figl, M. & Enislidis, G. (2007a) Navigated flapless transmucosal implant placement in the mandible: a pilot study in 20 patients. The International Journal of Oral & Maxillofacial Implants 22: 801–807.
61. Wittwer, G., Adeyemo, W.L., Schicho, K., Gigovic, N., Turhani, D. & Enislidis, G. (2006) Computer-guided flapless transmucosal implant placement in the mandible: a new combination of two innovative techniques. Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology 101: 718–723.