Acceptability of financial incentives for encouraging uptake of healthy behaviours: A critical review using systematic methods

Preventive Medicine

Volumn 73, Issue , 2015, Pages 145-158

  Giles, Emma L ^a   Robalino, Shannon ^a   Sniehotta, Falko F ^a   Adams, Jean ^a   McColl, Elaine ^b  

^a NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

^b NEWCASTLE UNIVERSITY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Behaviour change; Critical review; Financial incentives; Healthy behaviours; Systematic review

Indexed keywords

BEHAVIOR CHANGE; CONSENSUS; COST EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS; FINANCIAL INCENTIVES; FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT; HEALTH BEHAVIOR; HEALTH CARE POLICY; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS (TOPIC); PRIORITY JOURNAL; PROGRAM ACCEPTABILITY; REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; THEMATIC ANALYSIS; COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS; HEALTH PROMOTION; MOTIVATION; PROCEDURES; REWARD;

COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; HEALTH BEHAVIOR; HEALTH PROMOTION; HUMANS; MOTIVATION; REWARD;

EID: 84923544654     PISSN: 00917435     EISSN: 10960260     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ypmed.2014.12.029     Document Type: Review

References (118)

1. Adams J., Giles E.L., McColl E., Sniehotta F.F. Carrots, sticks and health behaviours: a framework for documenting the complexity of financial incentive interventions to change health behaviours. Health Psychol. Rev. 2013, 8(3):286-295.
2. Allan C., Radley A., Williams B. Paying the price for an incentive: an exploratory study of smokers' reasons for failing to complete an incentive based smoking cessation scheme. J. Health Serv. Res. Policy 2012, 17:212-218.
3. Arterburn D., Westbrook E.O., Wiese C.J., Ludman E.J., Grossman D.C., Fishman P.A., Finkelstein E.A., Jeffery R.W., Drewnowski A. Insurance coverage and incentives for weight loss among adults with metabolic syndrome. Obes 2008, 16:70-76.
4. Ashcroft R.E. Personal financial incentives in health promotion: where do they fit in an ethic of autonomy. Health Expect. 2011, 14:191-200.
5. Ashcroft R.E., Marteau T.M., Oliver A. Payment to look after health: incentive mechanisms require deeper understanding. BMJ 2008, 337:a1135.
6. Aveyard P., Bauld L. Incentives for promoting smoking cessation: what we still do not know. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. (Online) 2011, ED000027.
7. Axtell-Thompson L. Nudge ethics for health plans. Am. J. Bioeth. 2012, 12:24-25.
8. Barnard K., Thomas S., Royle P., Noyes K., Waugh N. Fear of hypoglycaemia in parents of young children with type 1 diabetes: a systematic review. BMC Pediatr. 2010, 10:1-8.
9. Barnett-Page E., Thomas J. Methods for the synthesis of qualitative research: a critical review. BMC Med. Res. Methodol. 2009, 9:1-11.
10. Blacksher E. Carrots and sticks to promote healthy behaviors: a policy update. Hastings Cent. Rep. 2008, 38:13-16.
11. Blumenthal-Barby J.S., Burroughs H. Seeking better health care outcomes: the ethics of using the "nudge". Am. J. Bioeth. 2012, 12:1-10.
12. Bonevski B., Bryant J., Paul C. Encouraging smoking cessation among disadvantaged groups: a qualitative study of the financial aspects of cessation. Drug Alcohol Rev. 2011, 30:411-418.
13. Bonevski B., Bryant J., Lynagh M., Paul C. Money as motivation to quit: a survey of a non-random Australian sample of socially disadvantaged smokers' views of the acceptability of cash incentives. Prev. Med. 2012, 55:122-126.
14. Botelho R. Motivating Healthy Behavior 2012, 301-307. O.J.Z. Sahler (Ed.).
15. Braun V., Clarke V. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qual. Res. Psychol. 2006, 3:77-101.
16. Britten N., Campbell R., Pope C., Donovan J., Morgan M., Pill R. Using meta ethnography to synthesise qualitative research: a worked example. J. Health Serv. Res. Policy 2002, 7:209.
17. Bryman A. Social Research Methods 2004, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
18. Burry J.N. Mutual obligation and Indigenous health: thinking through incentives and obligations. Med. J. Aust. 2006, 185:181-182.
19. Cahill K., Perera R. Quit and win contests for smoking cessation. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2008, 3:CD004986.
20. Cahill K., Perera R. Competitions and incentives for smoking cessation. Cochrane Database Syst. Rev. 2011, 4. CD004307.
21. Cameron J., Ritter A. Contingency management: perspectives of Australian service providers. Drug Alcohol Rev. 2007, 26:183-189.
22. Capewell S., Graham H. Will cardiovascular disease prevention widen health inequalities?. PLoS Med. 2010, 7(8):e1000320. 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000320.
23. Cawley J. The Affordable Care Act permits greater financial rewards for weight loss: a good idea in principle, but many practical concerns remain. J. Policy Anal. Manag. 2014, 33:810-820.
24. Cookson R. Should disadvantaged people be paid to take care of their health? Yes. BMJ 2008, 337:141.
25. Craig P., Dieppe P., Macintyre S., Michie S., Nazareth I., Petticrew M. Developing and evaluating complex interventions: the new Medical Research Council guidance. BMJ 2008, 337:a1655.
26. Department, Of Health Our Healthier Nation: A Contract for Health 1998, Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London.
27. Department, Of Health Choosing Health: Making Healthier Choices Easier 2004, Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London.
28. Department, Of Health Healthy Lives, Healthy People: Our Strategy for Public Health in England 2010, Her Majesty's Stationery Office, London.
29. Donatelle R.J., Hudson D., Dobie S., Goodall A., Hunsberger M., Oswald K. Incentives in smoking cessation: status of the field and implications for research and practice with pregnant smokers. Nicotine Tob. Res. 2004, 6:S163-S179.
30. Dreger M. Guidance for a reasonably designed, employer-sponsored wellness program using outcomes-based incentives. J. Occup. Environ. Med. 2012, 54:889-896.
31. Ducharme L.J., Knudsen H.K., Abraham A.J., Roman P.M. Counselor attitudes toward the use of motivational incentives in addiction treatment. Am. J. Addict. 2010, 19:496-503.
32. Effective Public Health Practice Project Quality Assessment Tool for Quantitative Studies [Online] Available. http://www.ephpp.ca/PDF/Quality%20Assessment%20Tool_2010_2.pdf.
33. Giles E.L., Robalino S., McColl E., Sniehotta F.F., Adams J. A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of effectiveness of financial incentives and penalties for encouraging healthy behaviours. PLoS One 2014, 9:1-16.
34. Goel V. Nudging for health: do we need financial incentives?. Healthc. Pap. 2012, 12:23-26. (discussion 64-66).
35. Grant R.W. The ethics of incentives: historical origins and contemporary understandings. Econ. Philos. 2002, 111-139.
36. Grant R.W. Ethics and incentives: a political approach. Am. Polit. Sci. Rev. 2006, 100:29-39.
37. Halpern S.D., Madison K., Volpp K.G. Patients as mercenaries?: the ethics of using financial incentives in the war on unhealthy behaviors. Circ. Cardiovasc. Qual. Outcomes 2009, 2:514-516.
38. Haveman R.H. Principles to guide the development of population health incentives. Prev. Chron. Dis. 2010, 7:A94.
39. Higgins J.W., Cookson S., Hastings-James C., Frazer A. Redeeming behaviours: a push, not a shove. Healthc. Pap. 2012, 12:42-47. (discussion 64-66).
40. Hoddinott P., Morgan H., Maclennan G., Sewel K., Thomson G., Bauld L., Yi D., Ludbrook A., Campbell M.K. Public acceptability of financial incentives for smoking cessation in pregnancy and breast feeding: a survey of the British public. BMJ Open 2014, 4:9.
41. Horwitz J.R., Kelly B.D., Dinardo J.E. Wellness incentives in the workplace: cost savings through cost shifting to unhealthy workers. Health Aff. 2013, 32:468-476.
42. Johnston M., Sniehotta F.F. Financial incentives to change behaviour. J. Health Serv. Res. Policy 2010, 15:131.
43. Kane R., Johnson P., Town R., Butler M. A structured review of the effect of economic incentives on consumers' preventive behavior. Am. J. Prev. Med. 2004, 27:327-352.
44. Kavanagh J., Stansfield C., Thomas J. Incentives to Improve Smoking, Physical Activity, Dietary and Weight Management Behaviours: A Scoping Review of the Research Evidence 2009, Institute of Education, London.
45. Kennedy M. To nudge or not to nudge - that is not the question. Healthc. Pap. 2012, 12:48-52. (discussion 64-66).
46. Kim A., Kamyab K., Zhu J., Volpp K. Why are financial incentives not effective at influencing some smokers to quit? Results of a process evaluation of a worksite trial assessing the efficacy of financial incentives for smoking cessation. J. Occup. Environ. Med. 2011, 53:62-67.
47. Klein E. Redefining the clinical relationship in the era of incentives. Am. J. Bioeth. 2012, 12(2):26-27.
48. Klein E., Karlawish J. Challenges and opportunities for developing and implementing incentives to improve health-related behaviors in older adults. J. Am. Geriatr. Soc. 2010, 58:1758-1763.
49. Kowal E. Mutual obligation and Indigenous health: thinking through incentives and obligations. Med. J. Aust. 2006, 184:292-293.
50. Lagarde M., Haines A., Palmer N. Conditional cash transfers for improving uptake of health interventions in low- and middle-income countries: a systematic review. JAMA 2007, 298:1900-1910.
51. Lawson J., Howard B. Why UFI nudges will get stuck in the policy process. Healthc. Pap. 2012, 12:53-57. (discussion 64-66).
52. Lesser L.L., Puhl R.M. Alternatives to monetary incentives for employee weight loss. Am. J. Prev. Med. 2014, 46:429-431.
53. Lewis M.W. Application of contingency management-prize reinforcement to community practice with alcohol and drug problems: a critical examination. Behav. Soc. Issues 2008, 17:119-138.
54. Loeppke R. Guidance for a reasonably designed, employer-sponsored wellness program using outcomes-based incentives. J. Occup. Environ. Med. 2012, 54:889-896.
55. London A.J., Borasky D.A., Bhan A., Ethics Working Group Of The H.I.V.Prevention Trials Network Improving ethical review of research involving incentives for health promotion. PLoS Med. Public Libr. Sci. 2012, 9:e1001193.
56. Long J.A., Helweg-Larsen M., Volpp K.G. Patient opinions regarding 'pay for performance for patients'. J. Gen. Intern. Med. 2008, 23:1647-1652.
57. Lunze K., Paasche-Orlow M.K. Financial incentives for healthy behavior: ethical safeguards for behavioral economics. Am. J. Prev. Med. 2013, 44:659-665.
58. Luyten J., Vandevelde A., Van Damme P., Beutels P. Vaccination policy and ethical challenges posed by herd immunity, suboptimal uptake and subgroup targeting. Public Health Ethics 2011, 4:280-291.
59. Luyten J., Dorgali V., Hens N., Beutels P. Public preferences over efficiency, equity and autonomy in vaccination policy: an empirical study. Soc. Sci. Med. 2013, 77:84-89.
60. Lynagh M., Bonevski B., Symonds I., Sanson-Fisher R.W. Paying women to quit smoking during pregnancy? Acceptability among pregnant women. Nicot. Tob. Res. 2011, 13:102-1036.
61. Lynagh M., Sanson-Fisher R., Bonevski B. What's good for the goose is good for the gander. Guiding principles for the use of financial incentives in health behaviour change. International Journal of Behavioural Medicine 2013, 20:114-120.
62. Madison K.M., Volpp K., Halpern S.D. The law, policy, and ethics of employers' use of financial incentives to improve health. J. Law Med. Ethics 2011, 39:450-468.
63. Malone S.W., Jason L. Using incentives, lotteries, and competitions in work-site smoking cessation interventions. Drug Alcohol Prev. 1990, 313-337.
64. Mantzari E., Vogt F., Marteau T.M. The effectiveness of financial incentives for smoking cessation during pregnancy: is it from being paid or from the extra aid?. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2012, 12:24.
65. Marteau T.M., Oliver A., Ashcroft R.E. Changing behaviour through state intervention. BMJ 2008, 337.
66. Marteau T., Ashcroft R., Oliver A. Using financial incentives to achieve healthy behaviour. BMJ 2009, 338:983-985.
67. McCormack R. Provider disclosure of financial incentives in managed care: pros and cons. Bioeth. Forum Spr. 1996, 12:21-24.
68. Meads D.M., Mccabe C., Camidge D.C., Hill K.M., House A.O., Hulme C.T. A contingent valuation survey of user financial incentives for health behaviour change. Value Health 2013, 16(3):A11.
69. Meredith S.E., Grabinski M.J., Dallery J. Internet-based group contingency management to promote abstinence from cigarette smoking: a feasibility study. Drug Alcohol Depend. 2011, 118:23-30.
70. Meredith S.E., Jarvis B.P., Raiff B.R., Rojewski A.M., Kurti A., Cassidy R.N., Erb P., Sy J.R., Dallery J. The ABCs of incentive-based treatment in health care: a behavior analytic framework to inform research and practice. Psychol. Res. Behav. Manag. 2014, 7:103-114.
71. Moher D., Liberati A., Tetzlaff J., Altman D.G. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Med. 2009, 6.
72. Ni Mhurchu C., Eyles H., Dixon R., Matoe L., Teevale T., Meagher-Lundberg P. Economic incentives to promote healthier food purchases: exploring acceptability and key factors for success. Health Promot. Int. 2011, 27:331-341.
73. Ni Mhurchu C., Eyles H., Dixon E., Matoe L., Teevale T., Meagher-Lundberg P. Economic incentives to promote healthier food purchases: exploring acceptability and key factors for success. Health Promot. Int. 2012, 27(3):331-341.
74. Noblit G.W., Hare R.D., Van Maanen J. Meta-Ethnography: Synthesizing Qualitative Studies (Qualitative Research Methods) 1988, SAGE Publications Ltd, London.
75. O'Donnell M.P. Financial incentives for workplace health promotion: what is equitable, what is sustainable, and what drives healthy behaviors?. Am. J. Health Promot. 2012, 26:iv-vii.
76. Oliver A. Can financial incentives improve health equity?. BMJ 2009, 339:b3847.
77. Oliver A. A nudge too far? A nudge at all? On paying people to be healthy. Healthc. Pap. 2012, 12:8-16.
78. Oliver A., Brown L.D. A consideration of user financial incentives to address health inequalities. J. Health Polit. Policy Law 2012, 37:201-226.
79. Park J.D., Mitra N., Asch D.A. Public opinion about financial incentives for smoking cessation. Prev. Med. 2012, 55(Suppl.):S41-S45.
80. Parke H., Ashcroft R., Brown R., Marteau T.M., Seale C. Financial incentives to encourage healthy behaviour: an analysis of UK media coverage. Health Expect. 2013, 16:292-304.
81. Paul-Ebhohimhen V., Avenell A. Systematic review of the use of financial incentives in treatments for obesity and overweight. Obes. Rev. 2008, 9:355-367.
82. Pearson S.D., Lieber S. Financial penalties for the unhealthy? Ethical guidelines for holding employees responsible for their health. Health Aff. 2009, 28:845-852.
83. Petry N.M. Contingency management treatments: controversies and challenges. Addict 2010, 105:1507-1509.
84. Petticrew M., Roberts H. Systematic Reviews in the Social Sciences A Practical Guide 2005, Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Oxford.
85. Popay J. Should disadvantaged people be paid to take care of their health? No. BMJ 2008, 337:141.
86. Promberger M., Brown R., Ashcroft R.E., Marteau T.M. Acceptability of financial incentives to improve health outcomes in UK and US samples. J. Med. Ethics 2011, 37:682-687.
87. Promberger M., Dolan P., Marteau T.M. "Pay them if it works": discrete choice experiments on the acceptability of financial incentives to change health related behaviour. Soc. Sci. Med. 2012, 75:2509-2514.
88. Raiff B.R., Jarvis B.P., Turturici M., Dallery J. Acceptability of an internet-based contingency management intervention for smoking cessation: views of smokers, nonsmokers, and healthcare professionals. Exp. Clin. Psychopharmacol. 2013, 21:204-213.
89. Ritter A., Cameron J. Australian clinician attitudes towards contingency management: comparing down under with America. Drug Alcohol Depend. 2007, 87:312-315.
90. Robison J.I. To reward? . . . or not to reward?: questioning the wisdom of using external reinforcement in health promotion programs. Am. J. Health Promot. 1998, 13:1-3.
91. Roozen H.G. Legitimizing the Medical Prescription of Money. Addict 2009, 104:1539-1540. [Commentary].
92. Schmidt H. Bonuses as incentives and rewards for health responsibility: a good thing?. J. Med. Philos. 2008, 33:198-220.
93. Schmidt H. Wellness incentives, equity, and the 5 groups problem. Am. J. Public Health 2012, 102:49-54.
94. Schmidt H., Gerber A., Stock S. What can we learn from German health incentive schemes?. BMJ 2009, 339:b3504.
95. Schmidt H., Voigt K., Wikler D. Carrots, sticks and health care reform - problems with wellness incentives. N. Engl. J. Med. 2009.
96. Schmidt H., Asch A., Halpern S.D. Fairness and wellness incentives: what is the relevance of the process-outcome distinction?. Prev. Med. 2012, 55:S118-S123.
97. Serxner S.A. A different approach to population health and behavior change: moving from incentives to a motivation-based approach. Am. J. Health Promot. AJHP 2013, 27:TAHP4-TAHP7.
98. Sindelar J.L. Paying for performance: the power of incentives over habits. Health Econ. 2008, 17:449.
99. Stephens C. Paying the piper: additional considerations of the theoretical, ethical and moral basis of financial incentives for health behaviour change. Int. J. Behav. Med. 2014, 21:202-205.
100. Strauss A.L. Qualitative Analysis for Social Scientists 2003, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
101. Swann C., Carmona C., Ryan M., Raynor M., Baris E., Dunsdon S., Huntley J., Kelly M.P. Health Systems and Health-Related Behaviour Change: A Review of Primary and Secondary Evidence 2010, National Institute for Clinical Excellence, Copenhagen.
102. ten Have M., van der Heide A., Mackenbach J.P., de Beaufort I.D. An ethical framework for the prevention of overweight and obesity: a tool for thinking through a programme's ethical aspects. Eur. J. Public Health 2012, 23(2):299-305.
103. ten Have M., van der Heide A., Mackenbach J.P., De Beaufort I.D. An ethical framework for the prevention of overweight and obesity: a tool for thinking through a programme's ethical aspects. Eur. J. Public Health 2013, 23:299-305.
104. Terry P.E. The use of incentives for "nondiscriminatory" wellness programs: three questions answered and three questions still wanting. Am. J. Health Promot. 2013, 27:taph10-taph12.
105. Terry P.E., Anderson D. Finding common ground in the use of financial incentives for employee health management: a call for a progress-based approach. Am. J. Health Promot. 2011, 26:ev-evii.
106. Thaler R.H., Sunstein C.R. Nudge: improving decisions about health, wealth, and happiness 2008, Yale University Press.
107. The Cochrance Collaboration Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions [Online] Available. http://handbook.cochrane.org/.
108. Thomson G., Dykes F., Hurley M., Hoddinott P. Incentives as connectors: insights into a breastfeeding incentive intervention in a disadvantaged area of North-West England. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2012, 12:22.
109. Thomson G., Morgan H., Crossland N., Bauld L., Dykes F., Hoddinott P., On behalf of the BIBS Team Unintended consequences of incentive provision for behaviour change and maintenance around childbirth. PLoS One 2014, 9:e111322.
110. Tuten L., Jones H.E., Schaeffer C.M., Stitzer M.L. Contingency Management to Improve Treatment Outcomes 2012, 109-120. Tuten, L Michelle.
111. Voigt K. Incentives, health promotion and equality. Health Econ. Policy Law 2012, 7:263-283.
112. Volpp K.G., Galvin R. Reward-based incentives for smoking cessation: how a carrot became a stick. JAMA 2014, 311:909-910.
113. Volpp K.G., Pauly M.V., Loewenstein G., Bangsberg D. P4P4P: an agenda for research on pay-for-performance for patients. Health Aff. 2009, 28:206-214.
114. Volpp K.G., Asch D.A., Galvin R., Loewenstein G. Redesigning employee health incentives: lessons from behavioral economics. N. Engl. J. Med. 2011, 365:388-390.
115. Wall J., Ni Mhurchu C., Blakely T., Rodgers A., Wilton J. Effectiveness of monetary incentives in modifying dietary behavior: a review of randomized, controlled trials. Nutr. Rev. 2006, 64:518-531.
116. Wharf Higgins J., Cookson S., Hastings-James C., Frazer A. Redeeming behaviours: a push not a shove. Healthc. Pap. 2012, 12(4):42-47.
117. White M., Adams J., Heywood P. How and why do interventions that increase health overall widen inequalities within populations?. Soc. Inequal. Public Health 2009, 65-82.
118. Wu J. Rewarding healthy behaviors - pay patients for performance. Ann. Fam. Med. 2012, 10:261-263.