Regulating health and environmental risks under WTO law: A critical analysis of the sps agreement

Regulating Health and Environmental Risks under WTO Law: A Critical Analysis of the SPS Agreement

Volumn , Issue , 2010, Pages 1-336

  Gruszczynski, Lukasz ^a  

^a Institute of Legal Studies Polish Academy of Science   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Environment risk; Health risk; International trade; Non tariff barriers; Risk analysis; Risk regulation; Sps agreement; Trade and regulation; WTO law

Indexed keywords

EID: 84921549569     PISSN: None     EISSN: None     Source Type: Book    
DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199578924.001.0001     Document Type: Book

References (121)

1. Alemanno, Alberto, Trade in Foods. Regulatory and Judicial Approaches in the EC and the WTO (Cameron May, London: 2007)
2. Applegate, John S, 'The Taming of the Precautionary Principle' (2002-2003) 27(13) William and Mary Environmental Law & Policy Review 12
3. Arcuri, Alessandra and Dari-Mattiacci, Giuseppe, 'Centralization versus Decentralization as a Risk-Return Trade-off', Amsterdam Center for Law & Economics Working Paper No 2007-06
4. Arnoldi, Jakob, Risk: An Introduction (Polity Press, Cambridge: 2009)
5. Atik, Jeffery, 'The Weakest Link: Demonstrating the Inconsistency of "Appropriate Levels of Protection" in Australia - Salmon' (2004) 24(2) Risk Analysis 483
6. Arnoldi, Jakob, 'Science and International Regulatory Convergence' (1996-97) 17 Northwestern Journal of International Law & Business 736
7. Baldwin, Robert, Hutter, and Rothstein, Henry, 'Risk Regulation, Management and Compliance, A Report to the BRI Inquiry', available at
8. Barceló III, John J, 'Burden of Proof, Prima Facie Case and Presumption in WTO Dispute Settlement' (2009) 42(1) Cornell International Law Journal 23
9. Barceló III, John J, 'Product Standards to Protect the Local Environment-the GATT and the Uruguay Round Sanitary and Phytosanitary Agreement' (1994) 27 Cornell International Law Journal 755
10. Bechtel, William, 'Scientific Evidence: Creating and Evaluating Experimental Instruments and Research Techniques', PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, Vol 1 (1990)
11. Beck, Ulrich, Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity (Sage, Newbury Park, CA: 1992)
12. Bergkamp, Lucas, European Community Law for the New Economy (Intersentia, Antwerp, New York: 2003)
13. Bhuiyan, Sharif, National Law in WTO Law. Effectiveness and Good Governance in the World Trading System (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge: 2007)
14. Birnie, Patricia W and Boyle, Alan E, International Law and the Environment (Oxford University Press, London: 2002)
15. Bloche, M Gregg, 'WTO Deference to National Health Policy: Toward an Interpretative Principle' (2002) 5(4) Journal of International Economic Law 825
16. Blomkvist, Anna-Christina, 'Psychological Aspects of Values and Risks', in Lennart Sjöberg (ed), Risk and society (Allen & Unwin, London, Boston: 1987)
17. Boehmer-Christiansen, Sonja, 'The Precautionary Principle in Germany- Enabling Government' in Timothy O'Riordan and James Cameron (eds), Interpreting the Precautionary Principle (Cameron May, London: 1994)
18. Bohanes, Jan, 'Risk Regulation in WTO Law: A Procedure-Based Approach to the Precautionary Principle' (2002) 40 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 323
19. Bossche, Peter van den, The Law and Policy of the World Trade Organization: Text, Cases, and Materials (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge: 2005)
20. Boudia, Sonya and Nathalie Jas, 'Introduction: Risk and Risk Society in Historical Perspective' (2007) 23(4) History and Technology 317
21. Bradbury, Judith A, 'The Policy Implications of Differing Concepts of Risk' (1989) 14(4) Science, Technology & Human Values 380
22. Broude, Tomer, 'Genetically Modified Rules: The Awkward Rule-Exception-Right Distinction in EC-Biotech' (2007) 6(2) World Trade Review 215
23. Button, Catherine, The Power to Protect. Trade, Health and Uncertainty in the WTO (Hart Publishing, Oxford, Portland: 2004)
24. Byrd, Daniel M III and C Richard Cothern, C Richard, Introduction to Risk Analysis: A Systematic Approach to Science-Based Decision Making (Government Institutes, Rockville, MD: 2000)
25. Cameron, James and Abouchar, Juli, 'The Status of the Precautionary Principle in International Law' in David Freestone and Ellen Hey (eds), The Precautionary Principle in International Law (Kluwer Law International, The Hague: 1996)
26. Carmody, Chios, 'WTO Obligations as Collective' (2006) 17(2) European Journal of International Law 419
27. Chang, Howard F, 'Risk Regulation, Endogenous Public Concerns, and the Hormones Dispute: Nothing to Fear but Fear Itself' (2004) 77(1) Southern California Law Review 743
28. Charnovitz, Steve, 'The Supervision of Health and Biosafety Regulation by World Trade Rules' (2000) 13(1) Tulane Environmental Law Journal 271
29. Cole, Stephen, Making Science: Between Nature and Society (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass: 1992)
30. Conrad, Christiane R, 'The EC-Biotech Dispute and Applicability of the SPS Agreement: Are the Panel's Findings Built on Shaky Ground?' (2007) 6 World Trade Review 23
31. Covelli, Nick and Hohots Viktor, 'The Health Regulation of Biotech Foods under the WTO Agreement' (2003) 6(4) Journal of International Economic Law 773
32. Covello, Vincent T and Merkhofer, Miley W, Risk Assessment Methods: Approaches for Assessing Health and Environmental Risk (Plenum Press, New York: 1993)
33. Covello, Vincent T and Merkhofer, Miley W, and Mumpower, Jeryl, 'Risk Analysis and Risk Management: An Historical Perspective' (1985) 5(2) Risk Analysis 103
34. Covello, Vincent T and Merkhofer, Miley W, and Detlof von Winterfeldt, Vincent T and Slovic, Paul, 'Communicating Scientific Information about Health and Environmental Risks: Problems and Opportunities from a Social and Behavioral Perspective' in Vincent T Covello, Lester B Lave, Alan Moghissi, and VR Uppuluri (eds), Uncertainty in Risk Assessment, Risk Management and Decision Making (Plenum Press, New York: 1984)
35. Cranor, Carl F, 'Science Courts, Evidentiary Procedures, and Mixed Science Policy Decisions' (1993) 4(2) Risk: Issue in Health and Safety 113
36. Cranor, Carl F, Crawford-Brown, Douglas, Pauwelyn, Joost, and Smith, Kelly, 'Environmental Risk, Precaution and Scientific Rationality in the Context of WTO/NAFTA Trade Rules' (2004) 24(2) Risk Analysis 461
37. Douglas, Mary, 'Risk as a Forensic Resource' (1990) 119(4) Daedalus 1
38. Douglas, Mary, and Aaron Wildavsky, Risk and Culture: An Essay on the Selection of Technical and Environmental Dangers (University of California Press, Berkeley: 1982)
39. Echols, Marsha A, Food Safety and the WTO. The Interplay of Culture, Science and Technology (Kluwer Law International; The Hague: 2001)
40. (p.285) Editors of The American Heritage Dictionaries (ed), The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, 4th edn (Houghton Mifflin, Boston: 2000)
41. Ehlermann, Claus-Dieter and Lockhart, Nicolas, 'Six Years on the Bench of the "World Trade Court". Some Personal Experience as Member of the Appellate Body of the World Trade Organization' (2002) 36(4) Journal of World Trade 605
42. Echols, Marsha A, Food Safety and the WTO. The Interplay of Culture, Science and Technology (Kluwer Law International; The Hague: 2001)
43. Epps, Tracey, International Trade and Health Protection. A Critical Assessment of the WTO's SPS Agreement (Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham: 2008)
44. European Commission, Health & Consumers Protection Directorate-General, First Report on the Harmonisation of Risk Assessment Procedures, Part 1: The Report of the Scientific Steering Committee's Working Group on Harmonisation of Risk Assessment Procedures in the Scientific Committees Advising the European Commission in the Area of Human and Environmental Health (2000)
45. Food and Agriculture Organization and World Health Organization, Report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Consultation, Application of Risk Analysis to Food Standard Issues, WHO/FNU/FOS/95.3 (WHO, Geneva: 1995)
46. Food and Agriculture Organization and World Health Organization, Understanding the Codex Alimentarius, 3rd edn (Rome: 2005)
47. Food and Agriculture Organization and World Health Organization, Expert Consultation on Food Safety, Science and Ethics (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome: 2003)
48. Food and Agriculture Organization and World Health Organization, Report of the Evaluation of the Codex Alimentarius and Other FAO and WHO Food Standards Work (Rome: 2002)
49. Food and Agriculture Organization and World Health Organization, Report of a Joint FAO/WHO Consultation on Risk Management and Food Safety (Rome: 1997)
50. Fisher, Elizabeth, Jones, Judith, and von Schomber Rene (eds), Implementing the Precautionary Principle: Perspectives and Prospects (Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham: 2006)
51. Fisher, Elizabeth, Jones, Judith, and von Schomber Rene (eds)'Beyond the Science/Democracy Dichotomy: The World Trade Organisation Sanitary and Phytosanitary Agreement and Administrative Constitutionalism' in Christian Joerges and Ersnt-Ulrich Petersmann (eds), Constitutionalism, Multi-level Trade Governance and Social Regulation (Hart Publishing, Oxford, Portland: 2006)
52. Fraiberg, Jeremy and Trebilcock, Michael J, 'Risk Regulation: Technocratic and Democratic Tools for Regulatory Reform' (1998) 43 McGill Law Journal 835
53. Freestone David and Hey, Ellen (eds), The Precautionary Principle in International Law (Kluwer, Hague: 1996)
54. Freestone David and Hey, Ellen (eds), 'The Road to Rio: International Environmental Law After the Earth Summit' (1994) 6 Journal of Environmental Law 193
55. Gardiner, Richard K, Treaty Interpretation (Oxford University Press, Oxford: 2008)
56. Gascoine, Digby, 'Harmonization, Mutual Recognition and Equivalence-How and What Is Attainable?', Paper presented at the Conference on International Food Trade Beyond 2000: Science-Based Decisions, Harmonization, Equivalence and Mutual Recognition, Melbourne Australia, 11-15 October 1999
57. Giddens, Anthony, Modernity and Self Identity: Self and the Society in the Late Modern Age (Politi Press, Cambridge: 1991)
58. Godard, Olivier, 'The Precautionary Principle, the Environment and International Trade: Sovereignty and Collective Preferences in Question', Ecole Polytechnique, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Cahier No 2006-05
59. Graham, John D, Chang, Bei-Hung, and Rhomberg, Lorenz, 'Challenges in Risk Assessment and Risk Management' (1996) 545 Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 15 (p.286)
60. Graubard, Stephen R, 'Preface to the Issue "Risk"' (1990) 119(4) Daedalus i
61. Guruswamy, Lakshman D, 'Sustainable Agriculture: Do GMOs Imperil Biosafety' (2002-03) 9(1) Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 461
62. Gutteling, Jan and Kuttschreuter, Margot, 'The Role of Expertise in Risk Communication: Laypeople's and Expert's Perception of the Millennium Bug Risk in the Netherlands' (2002) 5(1) Journal of Risk Research 35
63. Guzman, Andrew T, 'Dispute Resolution in SPS Cases' in Dan Horovitz, Daniel Moulis and Debra Steger (eds), Ten Years of WTO Dispute Settlement (International Bar Association, London: 2007)
64. Hathcock, John N, 'The Precautionary Principle-An Impossible Burden of Proof for New Products' (2000) 3(4) AgBioForum 255
65. Hohmann, Harald, Precautionary Legal Duties and Principles of Modern International Environmental Law (Graham & Trotman, London: 1994)
66. Hood, Christopher, Rothstein, Henry, and Baldwin, Robert, The Government of Risk: Understanding Risk Regulation Regimes (Oxford University Press, Oxford: 2004)
67. Horn, Henrik and Weiler, Joseph HH, 'European Communities-Trade Description of Sardines: Textualism and its Discontent' in Henrik Horn and Petros C Mavroidis (eds), The WTO Case Law of 2002 (New York: Cabridge University Press, 2005)
68. Howse, Robert, 'The Use and Abuse of Other "Relevant Rules of International Law" in Treaty Interpretation: Insight from WTO Trade/Environment Litigations', IILJ Working Paper 2007/1
69. Howse, Robert, 'Democracy, Science and Free Trade-Risk Regulation on Trial at the WTO' (1999-2000) 98 Michigan Law Review 2343
70. Hudec, Robert E, 'Science and Post-discriminatory WTO Law' (2003) 26 Boston College International and Comparative Law Review 185
71. Hudec, Robert E, ' "Like Product": The Differences in Meaning in GATT Articles I and III', in Thomas Cottier and Petros Mavroidis (eds), Regulatory Barriers and the Principle of Non-Discrimination in World Trade Law (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor: 2000)
72. Hudec, Robert E, Kennedy, Daniel LM, and Sgarbossa, Mark, 'A Statistical Overview of GATT Dispute Settlement Cases: 1948-1989' (1993) 2 Minnesota Journal of Global Trade 1
73. Hunter, Paul R and Fewtrell, Lorna, 'Acceptable Risk' in Lorna Fewtrell and Jamie Bartram (eds), Water Quality: Guidelines, Standards and Health (IWA Publishing, London: 2001)
74. Hurst, David R, 'Hormones: European Communities-Measures Affecting Meat and Meat Products' (1998) 1(9) European Journal of International Law
75. International Association for Impact Assessment & Institute for Environmental Assessment, Principles of Environmental Impact Assessment Best Practice (Fargo, Lincoln: 1990)
76. International Law Commission, Fragmentation of International Law: Difficulties Arising from the Diversification and Expansion of International Law, Report of the Study Group of the International Law Commission, A/CN.4/ L.682 (2006)
77. Jaeger, Carlo, Webber, Thomas, Rose, Eugene A, and Renn, Ortwin, Risk, Uncertainty, and Rational Action (Earthscan Publications, Sterling: 2001)
78. Jasanoff, Sheila, 'The Songlines of Risk' 8(2) Environmental Values, Special Issue: Risk 135
79. Johnson, Renée, Potential Farm Sector Effects of 2009 H1N1 'Swine Flu': Questions and Answers, CRS Report for Congress (Congressional Research Service, Washington, D.C: 2009) (p.287)
80. Kastner, Justin and Powell, Douglas, 'The SPS Agreement: Addressing Historical Factors in Trade Dispute Resolution' (2002) 19 Agriculture and Human Values 283
81. Klinke, Andreas and Renn, Ortwin, A New Approach to Risk Evaluation and Management, Risk-Based, Precaution Based, and Discourse-Based Strategies (2002) 22(6) Risk Analysis 1071
82. Kremlis, Georges, Balias, Yiorgos and Sifakis, Antonis (eds), The Precautionary Principle (Sakkoulas, Athens: 2004)
83. Kuhn, Thomas S, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, London: 1996)
84. Lagadec, Patrick, Major Technological Risk: An Assessment of Industrial Disasters (Oxford [Oxfordshire], New York: Pergamon Press, 1982)
85. Lang, Andrew, 'Provisional Measures under Article 5.7 of the WTO's Agreement on Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures: Some Criticism of the Jurisprudence So Far' (2008) 42(6) Journal of World Trade 1085
86. Lave, Lester B, Quantitative Risk Assessment in Regulation (Brookings Institution, Washington, D.C: 1982)
87. Leebron, David W, 'Lying Down with Procrustes: An Analysis of Harmonization Claims' in Jagdish Bhagwati and Robert Hudec (eds), Fair Trade and Harmonization: Prerequisites for Free Trade? Vol. 1: Economic Analysis (MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts: 1996)
88. Leiss, William, 'Three Phases in the Evolution of Risk Communication Practice' (1996) 545 Annals 85
89. Lennard, Michael, 'Navigating by the Stars: Interpreting the WTO Agreement' (2002) 5(1) Journal of International Economic Law 17
90. Lowrance, William W, Of Acceptable Risk: Science and the Determination of Safety (W Kaufmann, Los Altos, California: 1976)
91. Lupton, Deborah, Risk (Routledge, London, New York: 1999)
92. MacGarvin, Malcolm, 'Precaution, Science and the Sin of Hubris' in: Timothy O'Riordan and James Cameron (eds), Interpreting the Precautionary Principle (Cameron May, London: 1994)
93. McLachlan, Campbell, 'The Principle of Systemic Integration in Treaty Interpretation and Article 31(3)(c) of the Vienna Convention', (2005) 54 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 279, 315
94. McMahon, Joe and Margaret A Young, 'The WTO's Use of Relevant Rules of International Law: An Analysis of the Biotech Case', (2007) 56(4) International and Comparative Law Quarterly 907
95. Majone, Giandomenico, 'What Price Safety? The Precautionary Principle and Its Political Implications' (2002) 40(1) Journal of Common Market Studies 89
96. Marceau, Gabrielle and Trachtman, Joel P, 'The Technical Barriers to Trade Agreement, the Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures Agreement, and the General Agreement on Tariff and Trade' (2002) 36 Journal of World Trade 811
97. Margolis, Howard, Dealing with Risk: Why the Public and the Experts Disagree on Environmental Issues (University of Chicago Press, Chicago: 1996)
98. Maruyama, Warren H, 'A New Pillar of the WTO: Sound Science' (1998) 32(1) International Lawyer 651
99. Mayeda, Graham, 'Developing Disharmony? The SPS and TBT Agreements and the Impact of Harmonization on Developing Countries' (2004) 7(4) Journal of International Economic Law 737
100. McGinnis, John O, 'The Appropriate Hierarchy of Global Multilateralism and Customary International Law: The Example of the WTO' (2003-04) 44 Virginia Journal of International Law 229
101. McGrady, Benn, 'Fragmentation of International Law or Systemic Integration of Treaty Regimes: EC-Biotech Products and the Proper Interpretation of Article 31(3)(c) of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties' (2008) 42(4) Journal of World Trade 589 (p.288)
102. McIntyre, Owen and Mosedale, Thomas 'The Precautionary Principle As a Norm of Customary International Law' (1997) 9(1) Journal of Environmental Law 221
103. McLachlan, Campbell, 'The Principle of Systemic Integration in Treaty Interpretation and Article 31(3)(c) of the Vienna Convention' (2005) 54(2) International and Comparative Law Quarterly 279
104. McMahon, Joe and Young, Margaret A, 'The WTO's Use of Relevant Rules of International Law: An Analysis of the Biotech Case' (2007) 56(4) International and Comparative Law Quarterly 907
105. McNelis Natalie, 'The Role of the Judge in the EU and WTO: Lessons from the BSE and Hormones Cases' (2001) 4(1) Journal of International Economic Law 189
106. McNiel, Dale E, 'The First Case Under the WTO's Sanitary and Phytosanitary Agreement: The European Union's Hormone Ban' (1998) 39 Virginia Journal of International Law 89
107. Merkhofer, Miley W, Decision Science and Social Risk Management: A Comparative Evaluation of Cost-Benefit Analysis, Decision Analysis, and Other Formal Decision-Aiding Approaches (Kluwer Academic Publisher, Dordrecht, Netherlands: 1987)
108. Molak, Vlasta, Vlasta Fundamentals of Risk Analysis and Risk Management (Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton: 1997)
109. Motaal, Doaa A, 'The "Multilateral Scientific Consensus" and the World Trade Organization' (2004) 38(5) Journal of World Trade 855
110. National Research Council, Committee on the Institutional Means for Assessment of Risks to Public Health, Risk Assessment in the Federal Government: Managing the Process (National Academy Press, Washington, DC: 1983)
111. National Research Council, Committee on Risk Assessment of Hazardous Air Pollutants, Commission on Life Sciences, Science and Judgment in Risk Assessment (National Academy Press, Washington, DC: 1994)
112. Neugebauer, Regine, 'Fine-Tuning WTO Jurisprudence and the SPS Agreement: Lessons from the Beef Hormone Case' (2000) 31 Law and Policy in International Business 1255
113. OECD Joint Working Party on Trade and Environment, Uncertainty and Precaution: Implications for Trade and Environment, COM/ENV/TD(2000)114/ FINAL Oesch, Matthias, Standards of Review in WTO Dispute Resolution (Oxford University Press, Oxford, New York: 2003)
114. Ore, Oystein, 'Pascal and the Invention of Probability Theory' (1960) 67(5) The American Mathematical Monthly 409
115. O'Riordan, Timothy and Cameron James (eds), Interpreting the Precautionary Principle (Cameron May, London: 1994)
116. Ortino, Federico, 'Treaty Interpretation and the WTO Appellate Body Report in US-Gambling: A Critique', (2006) 9(1) Journal of International Economic Law 117
117. Palmeter, David and Mavroidis, Petros C Dispute Settlement in the World Trade Organization: Practice and Procedure (Cambridge University Press, New York: 2004)
118. Pauwelyn, Joost, 'Expert Advice in WTO Dispute Settlement' in George A Bermann and Petros C Mavroidis (eds), Trade and Human Health and Safety (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, New York: 2006)
119. Pauwelyn, Joost, 'Non-Traditional Patterns of Global Regulation: Is the WTO "Missing the Boat"' in Christian Joerges and Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann (eds), Constitutionalism, Multilevel Trade Governance and Social Regulation (Hart Publishing, Oxford, Portland: 2006) (p.289)
120. Pauwelyn, Joost, Conflict of Norms in Public International Law: How WTO Law Relates to Other Rules of International Law (Cambridge University Press, New York: 2003)
121. Pauwelyn, Joost, 'Does the WTO Stand for "Deference to" or "Interference with" National Health Authorities When Applying the Agreement on Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures (SPS Agreement)' in Thomas Cottier and Petros C Mavroidis (eds) The Role of the Judge in International Trade Regulation: Experience and Lessons for the WTO 175 (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor: 2003)